State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
United India Ins Co Ltd vs Valjibhai J Rabari on 30 November, 2007
tum cL5212 Gtcu2I1 sfiaatrx, o_y=ar2m mru, wtaxcue wile-L rimca [zoos aiulélre : grmfés sSr£1u.L s$«22i'L2v2+ §L. C-{L I201, auéL2L1c2mL,»«.r22aLg2L<~L22 ziars 24.52 vtcL2oLg2L, 2-2=~Lucu_s..
{E23222 f'22=.&-sra* : *2. CJ.L&t°fl01.tg °?m'om1LsS 26222'! 23222/bitsuumit-1 53.262221
15. 2¢>u2"l ClL'<{, 521231, rtL.Lus,2L "$1. cL§Ls.21.
2. <alL'~'PJ. iH°s2>2{1 gmla H§«eL2S<2 2+cfl2{l:» well.
eflltctrfl 5225222, <»2"l°&1 rum, sL2<'=fl<:tLoL, c2.§.La2L.
inn : sit =s'L=l1.2»LLg°sL_, m22L.€>"£'L:»L {M2, ail t>{1.2£'taL.°&m'1, $9612 A _M «AFN 2»L.scLL.sa22 : 2»tu.c-tra :22; =2-efklsgc-su£)§:G¢J*ct' : afl c£1.ul-wauctél D.2=.E'z-s~»2 dlé = zfl 2$'tv1.23tvt.°mc2 z§&'{=--- ail '1i3.2»1.2»Lt§m, fumlsiilna SW12 14.1258 L. szflzus, 3,22 4.22:2/o2 Essa: [EL r2§Ls2t [Mat Jtlés rt3Q.L2 RQLQQL $2221 u,3o,'3/oevu 21°: £»'2'1U.L*iHl $21212 (4502 vflit gwot gswt 32:2 9.
"a2"Lzua"L21L E.Ll»l.-Gt sia &2'l22La 2~[s.L<1: H32 s2czmi am (3. 2m2Lqwu:3t cufim :zu».s,s?+L gL.<t,uo,ooo/-- (gt. am uauzt @412 322) <'ll.3{(:/O°l8n. 23»: sgaqtq cut. yen cufiais C: 23L cam: aélct, mvtfias '>li2t-tl qumzvu §5L.?_,OOO/---- (gt. cit é."A'l3. gm) aw»; 521222 1221-1L 3,231,000/--{ gt. its
-2322 3,220 gsurfl <1L2'1w4'.1 [2222 30-11 2122 gadl mtucu-{L gm §x2C{lHi am 2'9. 3222 2252241 2»L2°m2 c22[32ct canes (3u2'L3ct 23'-L, Er.-11 (314.2 Imcutu->1 <2«u°K, zvtutélet viii ED-L°o' t»t°a'<1taL'l H'-ft Hail get 23% amtqmzvil 'Md. 911w 1-!.l.C-L rflcasctuial qga fimqqt «asset: 2;:-.siL. "
tzuitart gsuaii vumr 21:5 zs2'1uLz---u gum mHLqLuLL2l1 ~éL€-Lrfl bu 2-u.flc+ ama sia gm mruqwu smvu alhlara ém ELM 6'3. nail 2u=+LctLu1L ct2'L'!s at-'i 2»n£1c+«u Lu.LqLtrLL5x gm £r2"tu.t€l «QT; :a'c»iLttcLLHi z-u<ic=L 23:.
isfle-u€L~{L "324. zitcit is 3, sflutil-tL Iucgailzrlt zwucuuu vi/1 wuzasu ¥tLH.lCl£Ull. via an éu-{mizfi mi-ta allszflsra u"Lc--fl2{1 cw/xa/cc afl um/e/zoozvu zmunuuu Hfe'. .cu-{I PM': 1i'Lruvu ufavu «LL51. cmuaa. &2'1uLL2.'1ru Htru M54'. [flan-3 §5l_.9.,"l-l.O,OOO/-- emu L.°L,uo,ooo,/---3 zilu. gen. :15; mg. ML 1i'Le:--[12{1 1'»lH<:tHi all A mun-t failattélrtl Lcgafl-"i rLL.'lO/2/O9.-it 2%' £122. (anvil ufl oacu mil-1 mi mg 2~t2tsLcu aioilz 2S°4n,2»i1 dl si. 21+.=%.°z§Lnf1rtL ~aqu»u-Lmt zuzcuz nfa c-uS mu an utams zuacuz iiutql L2uS12t.°a'l. éR44.'18C--LHL 6123 watt sisazsflait °ert2LtéLeL, uig r1.l.°cO{2/0%!-1.1 £19; *13.--3'u aafs afle-us.'lvu umcgzflg 11:3 aim. (3u1'L;:rL u'Lc--E12{1 zrtvqii uumcuum 2214. imqcu 0:321 2f1.LE3l°t§l wild-3 3é--'LiSH .=?L=i mcuui 2»tLE1e., uig cflul an-1"L:31 ma-n 25% 3531:-L -tét .9-[1 gut ,u.o,ooo,I--rfl 23% mm: wild ¥L<:1c:qLmé EL. élzn zmat s 2'1u.:z ELHC-L siefl.
2mucuuurCL c-tauq nllcit 23 3;, an Lsnmi a3.'lzu£l=.?L \i1¢{1:aHL $33 2'1ul'1é, \i1:~a1i'Lé>t L12 Q xi2.mL~_1 cL:3'Li Dag sic--L vtefi. 2m4.Lc1LU1t~3L 3>i.£x?.44.Ld. v.~i5L titfl wet szcuai wzle. £9 '.23 1i'Lc«[l2fl_-1'l 2L2 rELr€L Gian etch ém 2»t3wct¥i atzlél 13:3 2:219. e$Lcu-3 gzcuz mg. -1 élu v."tu.La 22 2t€1.l§4. um ifi, L. ilfmravtt cL=§1c+ aft c{l.L[l vtL9.LLcLél¥'t Me}. QU.'iL€{lU1L-it q3§1c4 all 23't~s..=lt-1.°o'L2,q€i. Liowm. 2°33 2Li4c--t swtuil cizwéi emu.
zwucuuu cflm s}uv{Lw-tizfl 'JAHC-L iiseilsra u':c{1%£l 3,L.=t,uo,ooo;---{I Hlvill :H.01l1;l*t E 5:: !:2'1tLL?l~1L Htcysfl auu. £9 Pméi fiwtilci évfl A 2451 sin? rtszr-L vwfl. Iitc-ihilvtt H?-IDLLUIL slum £sHU1lf;t-igt =33 2Li1c+ 6t 245'. w2L «mm weal '.*.L.'iO/3JO".'t'. an em wufi. u.$1°mr. 2S'<~:L2>{'v. mu uzvmtzvg, 13:3 rflwim £9 2:1-3. St tszsurt-31 swét =33 vfluéia £124 cibu éu-{I mitzil isn imqcu ml? séufn $115. mzcuai u&c4. zimetra-u Cl£at':l3fl§ saw 3 cflm éusfl-1 dL.3/ejoavu in: u§s,c=[I cum cxuat zqmi mi-:41, -vltaé-t 3; otvuctru was uélvu uzél wan szcuui 2»u?xc--[1 cleft M1 °e!ll§t zrwti 2»LlElc{1 élcu-1 awét cfivu éuvfl 2S'rc'nél51a2 qéli i'Ls1¥'t ctum 321 afsc-1 vufl Elan flute 22 ztcuél u.L>L £9. zitiiara-1L <{§IeL£fl$'i 2_r(:_oo>:-) %flt£15z'r--2ao(2S'm2{1)-tL gmzt uz zvutuz zulla £9. 91 igstét Iitcu cnflm 5-Jurfil-"1 vii =iL£1 wet szcmi zvucfl £124 2451 linanrfl wi;c{12{1Hi°xr2LLczu ?\;Jl°Jbt"°£?Lbt(1_{Hi'$£3Ld1-{L 3323;: wit ém, win: mil cflimi .<>.ul1aL rt 3231 um 2-vi he 2212'}-{L em, s2'1qw+i. ozrlauczu _garc»m'l aaslscit mm rmmui All méta aslscil £6;-t Etcu s'12~umi cflitt-.L2-'i 251+. Htrfl 943: rtél €120 Cauilsa
9.tta'Lrt-1 zvutui 211%:-Lra-it qsletaflgt 2311+ sic; '3 v{L§l afluxa £:2ClLHl mail -Sm «£1 29+ .Ufl 2&3: mil Em 2P'Li'ic-tra-it qflasilwt start ELL'-it wit iéiltd excu 'i2fl. saw #151 salute zctmi wail 4.124 613; «twat stiivi vtmen aama afiutél a=J=~LLz 12, 321 £31 rail, 23; EH1 mil ofl°!l 2.91 es'1.=scEL wet kzurl «:--L23'v'i (ma 20g zula 1r21vi'Lg3t€L wuqmi bttéta >. d.§(3'U.2id tau: 23 etitc-1 g.sL€L 'flan szlutélvfl ésaimi 22121 azlcet 91211 szflzusil nxugtru ~.d.l is 3lH.L=.'L assuafl rflm $u~{1~1 «swat sszcfl °£L2S2IL wxi; =.»uu2"L 2«LHi'.t-'|.L ézmi gag mvttzrfl tileflaél 2»£5L Em-it ctmit 3: r»i'L°2_rL-'1'. MGR ém «£1 0: é'ta»i'L cflm s§urL'I~'1' mug: si. mu z£<-i'LaE'mi =amLi 52'huL€l aim °z:t2Lw.rtL £114 3; wilcilzfl 2»151 Fwéi '54; A «ma MHZ V-L iLcu-1 smét assuzfl cflm éurfléi 'W91 ail aéa mil éizfl «M1 °a'U9L arzqmi azlutélvfl iam2'lL siscw-L Em umcuni wax zruczg '-L93. £128 (sumn aisqmi muéla gsxaxui rméic-1 Etbttldail vifiietra-11321;': .s}'Ls§ Citfii uc{L--12{L ¢1"tqLa'1r{'1'$2+ 2ltci1€9 3: H31-ill am (ztmfl nil =mL '~LL%lLHi oinflz $Sw»i'L Etcuii mi: «mo/2./oqvu in: gvail aziteu. wueuul 2'§'zL:»['L uilcfl A 2451-{1 32141 [EL .=é'L=.H mat vg szcuui 2-Lxéia imga 2»i'Ls£1a2, umail Cm élrazvuaii. =u.=1o{2/oaru aw téi[$'$e «mm :9 L9. Hzvm-'i Hnzuni %S°.n2»i1 uzla ecfl 225% mg; tag c-iwfl qél atilet gr; min £'12mi12+.°x'L élzxflacmi 2132 azcuui amen St vhcu Hlfltwfl mui zvucu usnél zfiomil tin-Ltg qrtauctcuui mag »$Lu cit it mmmii srztit nL2u:Hi. 1'§°m»£'L 2u1c--u-3 WLLLL :59 2'~L3l {I3 512? mm é.uS 2L3 vtél éiefl °é'L 2¢éiE?:§a=+L am uufl ua oacurfl éslsdl ét'bl.d.LH.i '4; mail elm eiL um Htzzmé ztiicfl <S=erI.m$t mil {H miéi citét Ctsfl DB1:-L eg A 2Léi(?:3..2 anti mail éezz iirazru i'+£1s«..c-L milalzti utfic-L éla. all 91 £x9.'1u.L~2.'1vu 3:21-1 zmairt mil 8: 's, an Sérwit ufl °mLefl wit-£1 am zitilaravu cL:§1asfl~;_ saw 1!} mil rxcuefl 2S°¢rt>.»{'L uitefl éla an L Rug c2?LzS23i PL 32¢-1 mi wil and %ldl «all 231 gzflscz Q 3;, 2»u gm =§t¢.2.~mS.2»4.L2. ELMGL szctmi 2»u€tc~L -tail 3: ullzetilén zcuui 1»{L€l<~l -tail Emil aiuletra-it ctélc-ufl-3 2115;: 52m 63: 3, nits.»-u29.2-uz. :4-3; u"L2a~.I'L£H fig szqmi *1 muéi cit \i1c{1%flrfl anew om mil £84 aflaus. 22 atcu um 2} 2:61 .'tc{12{1r{1 uzcil -it 2191 c-u31c{1 ém A-3 uziuad 32:41:; 2~L-1 '%;'L€LI.-g °s3,_2'1 M41 £9 Em °E'néL .t:<:E(e)§1flH élé-aux ouzafl -1'lé1aL§tM'1vu Eami suqqmi améia 9'9. 25! éslsrt 25 3, fteilzflai asvettéla aucil °&'Lq1rfl éiu 25 MA E1 anvil-_1, zwziua-1 Gt 21:1 9: slang elm $3. uilsct [Swain ::+'51¢-4.329 'il%i'i,1-Lig. 2%; Eswu =3'ts.=>LuS.::u2. M31 ifnzeulén slcttg gm lg'. °2:3;z'1 wan. '1(2oc>o) «'e{1Lfl58--W1c, uiuuiat 3[°\i9.L~t, '1 (2ooo)2{1L€153~ua mzuiar. sfiw-1, *1(2_oou) :.«€1uI1%--u23 Czdzim mm, 2(2oo2) zfltiléir-'tau mgg. 'trsL31:aI{12 slfiatrvtt 'semi, (auitad aim-{'L d2$?fl aztqcmi 2>tl5{C~t £9 3; =$i£=.:»u2S.2»uz. uhaulén -{'La *1 £121 all e.ss'Is<{L3L zautui °6-'1 usaaanit anlal 133, 21,3 étu ci1cf1tu_sIuvL'1 'cLLt»4.2;L:=. 235.
Cauitsrt Eitthtirt ailru, 2-mtvfl zmatrfi $21 wilcu ciliiatzii am'i'vn!§t9. u.§1 °xcuL-1 sL2éL mull aioflz 2§°m2»i'L uitefl MA 2?m.23l-'e+.<x'1. énaflac-mi 2152 sactmi MEL 31 uéw ructru [mil Aug Iirg aim Q 51 bis": dean -99. A211 3-Hill"-LL a'm{l2 29=m2»iL aziiefl «$124, tél qél 013 @124. M31 ctoflofl umtanm that «it A 2{°i1a1"mi A =»1s24¢u-£31 swét 2S°zn=»i1 etildl H Vrllvtcllfi-li M31 ® 2rL¥'L El sS°x12»i'L-3L amt Avg; 133 mg' am AH. at-iqmi bail £9 Frail at Mt um °&1 23Ls,2»mS.uL2. 3; u"Lée%{'téu. vile szcuni vl mucfl elm ch net cflmtuzsg :33 z»1e32111c14'1 312121 11211 £9 P111 °11v1c11=1i2>11€'1 £9. 2 (2001) 21f111151?--2::\1, 2:1-i%'1~11s[?1s.1v'1 11121 21151; 321611141 (9 3, 212112 2132111241 51211 1311:1211 21£1c«[1 $12.1 ,;~112c112 EJ121121 :»11c1'1 «$12.1 2141 521211 2112212 111}. 21u1c--1 2151; 113 $1212: 1S*1r1=»i'1$'1 31221 élé-121 214141 312121 2113. 21121 :11 81-1 2»1s2411r1-1 312191 21i'1c--1 é°x12»1'1-1 5121131 21% 21211-3 311211 213121 2231 2c1.'1n.1 3:11-1'1$'1 °ac11:»1a12 5213111 1'1. 21 0; 2"1€1 2r(2'ooa)2f114f152r--2e: 1111212 ~04; vilrs 5122112 sB1s.1v1-11 $21211 11121 c11111t112s 1111 0521211 51211 °1r 9111-; =33 2121211 2:1-1 £1 111% 32:11 g21<:i'1 15121 c1112 3191 §E?.rfl 21:3 -1 3-$11111 11121 2»1s2411c131 3121131 2111121 11:3 5éic111.1, 312121 3 A 3321111 r113, 512111 1-1111 211é1 c1'1é'1 1:141 *zc11-'1 5121;-"1 11:3 211:1 $1211 9151 21324114-1 312111 31:3 a1i1c11-1 9112121111 1»11E'1r.1 2:151' cII111 .éu~--1'1+'1 °xc11a1s12 s21c1c1121i 2-11E'1:~1 {:1 2291 2»11 321211 241211r1=11 gslrfl 21:3 111131 c-1b1c1111'1 =:11'r'1<:-1 £111 :11 11121 $191 2»1a2211c1?1 31291 2181a gag 01121212112 2113161. =1 (2000) 211L1f1*é<--\-1°1¢ =»1it111'2;21sE119.1v1-113s21=11x1@1 311513112211 1151 °1_rc11-'1 551291 1113 212141 112121 23'1¢.2:112S.2»112. 2151 1112111. vi'1a ~1 é'1c11e9c1'111121 3rl£2%Lcl?-H 1113 215-'1c1 1531:1151 512151 11111 s§1.1r1'1~31 =-2rc11<>12.12 .s21c1c1u1'12»11Eic1 :59, 31221 é 2:-1121 1151231 Igcg 231 $125 §--11[Ear1 512 £131 vwfl. 11 (2000) 2{It[1°3'--2=1:1 (ac11211%.a1 35121-1r11 3:21:11 2313 2o1'1~1'1 211$1 g ce.'l1:12=11 mail =xr11 2S*1c12»1'1é1 312191 gcg 21:11 2?1$.=z»112S.2~112. 21-"1 ufl.-£111. v{'1a «1 é'1c11 29c1i 11191 1132211141. 512151 11:31 2111:1131. a1121c11=1'1 2»11&c1 21-1 $1 $21211 11121 1:11:11 211-1141 %rc11t»1s.12 521c1c11111 2»1131c~1. {-1 2r 2131 '1 (2oo11)2{'11I1°?.':-«x123 'QrL2i.%lt3. 313121441 $21211 11121 ~11e1g=111i 1151 05:11:11 2S°af12~11 21:11 2113 21ilc;1 2131 231s.2»111S.2212. ~=1:3'12 -1"i%1c11>11 221161121 -1 érfl 11131 1911311111 151322 81 2131212115352 2-111fl?1 =1r1121 321 212 % 2S°41=»i'1-'1 312121 21:3 21€1c--1 £9 11-31 151 312151 <fl=11 _éuv1'1?i1 '9rc11612.12 a21c1c11111 :r11€'1<1 1'9. 1151 321111 11121 211 2121 c€1121%112.1:?1. {I111 v31c--[12£1~1'1 2521 2»11u.c1111'1 2»11r1c1 is 1111 2(2oo:1) 2fltfl=?.§mn =»1§1v11 31312141 .s21E'1c--1 £9. 1 (2002) °1s11,°n:_1 2314 3122112 3912151 11121 =.»1s2411c1v11 '$21211 21i'1c1 2521131 312121 2&1 21111 231 2§'1s~.2»112$;:»112. 3 1121-1121 -1 £111 3 2123121 2:111:11-11111 2112c112 cfltfl -1 £121 221%. Sn-12é13121r1 2"111'1ér1i 2»1s2H1r1$1 312121 231 eS'°x12»i'1 2113 @111 2131 21:31 21:31:11-1 11:1-32 2112-1 <-2115;
111115111191 952161212 .s21E1<-.1 132." 211 2121211 11121 cf1111 $11-1'1-'1 "5-:11<»1e12 a21c1c11=11é (3L12"1sc1 vii-3L 2»u.fl.Li 5? :z'11i"Lé vg szrmti zvuélet :59 2431 am 141911 14.51 °5qL5+; satin'. ru2Lm.f.
-£1. arm 133 W5 2:}; Elm um; 2i"L::ia-1L3 EL. slim max 51322-3: 23 szcuui mile-1 E1} ML 2»L'L:>'L2vug °m2.c-1 ustzg s), :33 um.-mi: °x'uS'€{ szcmi 3>!.l5l.C<L -1211, 'wig an I1 211 w»a;2u2--4 éfi 3.' ma (suzefl nil varuéi stztéi men-In *S°m~l1 urn c4m..s.'l qél '?a$'.CU.3fl 2&5 at}. 5~2."tu1'a1~{'t}2{ oilru ma: 'cfl=~utu2.a 2122 unit 1151 °m.L2£1 Hmmmil 343201 qél °o'd.L 23i2t.23t2m'1 émflaaui its; act: M. é:1'Z-1«[I2<:£H.i 6:153 mu uéaa "2! 133 élq :z~Lswct-EL swéi wile: $3w>EL-rL'1 ~33 w1<¢L:_'L_ :>uaLeLmi MEL Lib méi imi R1. élzug zllcu cum (ma. aaufiet 23 § 2»:s2HL-:1~"i smét :33 em: emu éuvfl Len Q Glmfl cflm éuvflall "J7: 2»1LséuS=¢ -1_L1--'ug:-. azfi 4212+ all A Smtrfl \»t--n:{1 atem Sail 'mm rtmt mil am and 2129291 612%. (zuium '+'t°¢>L~3..L\L3-1.1: wfla 22 acu mot Q24 gym gau saqmi wét $35.
§--'>_'*.
1»t1-flét 22. smmi burl $35.
waa-+.L mi 24-'?t 5&2'? gm szcuai mttcmfk -tail.
2361-::Lr"é 5: £16 2211 1-l'$[ afitzt-1 Met wt 52L€Lc--t éiu EH1 diam amzugfk ail St (mo. HUlGLL'U.-'91. czmr aélctvfl 3.s=£v{1 altitatrarzt -xmrft 2?{sL(3+e Q25 :33 zliijetraéi a:.»a mi-1'1 1°a'1:e{1'-1. gm szcuui =.»u,Et Q).
_ "' vs ' . * we: 21°: 'ii-uoa-u my 31512.': gafl mtemi-Li 'Kl-$2 safi.
( »:1.:q.z.u§m) (a{1.2l7L$¢.°.§'vaI1 ) ELQ_{LES§[:)L in:-42 5{WrL.2