State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
1. Mr. Damodar J. Kamat Bambolkar, vs 1. Manipal Sowbhagya Nidhi Limited, on 20 March, 2009
THE STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION THE STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION PANAJI GOA Present: Smt. Sandra Vaz e Correia .. Presiding Member
Smt. Caroline Collasso .. Member.
Execution Application No. 8 of 2004
1. Mr. Damodar J.
Kamat Bambolkar, r/o Damodar Sadan, Khorlim, Mapusa, Goa.
2. Mr. Jayavant Shriniwas Nayak, r/o Ashirwad, Near Sarswat Vidyalaya, Khorlim, Mapusa, Goa.
3. Mrs. Prema Moraskar, r/o Pequeno Ducan, Duler, Near Marathi School, Mapusa, Goa.
4. Mr. Anand Rama Amerkar, r/o H. No. 630, Ward No.10, Vidyanagar, Khorlim, Mapusa, Goa.
5. Mrs. Manik Kamat,
6. Mrs. Sima Kamat,
7. Mrs. Dulba Purshottam Kamat,
8. Mrs. Manik Dulba Kamat, All r/o Malwada Post Madkai, Via-Mardol, Goa.
9. Mr. Abhay D. Sawant
10.Miss Bhakti A. Sawant
11.Miss Anita A. Sawant, All r/o Dangui Colony, Mapusa, Goa.
12. Miss Bhakti P. Naik,
13. Miss Priyanka P. Naik, Both r/o C/o P.N. Naik, B-31, Housing Board, Mapusa, Goa.
14. Anjali Narvekar
15. Hanumanth N. Narvekar, Both r/o Ramsadan, Near Saraswat Vidyalaya, Khorlim, Mapusa, Goa.
16. Miss Smita Shankar Salkar.
17. Miss Sharmila Shankar Salkar,
18. Master Avinash Shankar Salkar,
19. Mrs. Jaywanti Shankar Salkar, All r/o Saal, Post Assanora, Goa.
20. Mr. Vinayak V. Shenvi
21. Vidya Shenvi, Both r/o Swantantrapath, Vasco Goa.
22. Mr. Vijaykumar Vasant Shenvi.
23. Smt. Rekha Vasant Shenvi, Both r/o 15/3, Pexim, Dongri, Vasco da Gama.
24. Mrs. Maria Betty Lobo e Martins,
25. Mrs. Maria Betty Lobo e Martins, Both r/o H.No. 629, Sallis Vaddo, Parra, Bardez Goa.
26. Rev. Fr. Pedro Antonio Sequeira, R/o Vanelim-Gran Colva, Salcete Goa.
27. Mr. Lahu Anand Goltekar, r/o Cobrawaddo, Calangute Beach, Bardez Goa.
28. Pratibha Lavoo Korgaonkar,
29. Smt. Asha Pooniah.
Both r/o A1, Junta Quarters, Mapusa-Gopa.
30. Miss Vaibhavi P.S. Navelkar, r/o Assolna, Salcete Goa.
31. Mrs. Maria Aida Dias R. Silva, r/o Gomesvaddo, Majorda, Salcete Goa.
32. Milagrina Fernandes.
33. Mr. Joseph Sebastiao Fernandes, Both r/o Vandana Apartments, E-4, Khadapband, Ponda Goa.
34. Mr. Manikrao Narayan Patil, R/o Geetanjali Apartments, Block No.2, Pontimol, Curchorem, Goa.
35. Mr. Naik Vinayak Vasudev, r/o Near Petroleum Pump, Bicholim Bus Stand, Bhaili Peth, Bicholim Goa.
36. Smt. Jayashree K. Shirodkar,
37. Mrs. Shreya B. Serdesai,
38. Shri Balvath Rao Serdesai, All r/o H. No.8, Ward No.8, Atin Peth, Bicholim Goa.
39. Shri Charles M de Souza, r/o F-8, St. Britto Appts, Altinho, Mapusa, Goa.
40. Shri Rosario Milagres Caldeira, r/o Flat No.A-1, Sea Gull Apts., Near Municipal Market, Panaji-Goa.
41. Master Chris Allan Menezes, r/o 477, Bamon Vaddo, Assonora, Bardez Goa.
42. Shri Vasant Vishnu Gharse
43. Smt. Vinda V. Gharse
44. Shri Vishnudas M. Kamat, All r/o H.No.781, Agacaim, Goa.
45. Smt. Smita M. Chonkar r/o H.No.673, Bodiem Tivim, Bardez Goa.
46. Shri Manohar Chonkar, r/o H.No. 673, Bodiem Tivim, Bardez Goa.
47. Smt. Lalita Mohanrao Kadekodi, r/o Agnelo Colony, A-Wing, Kerant, Caranzalem, Goa.
48. Smt. Vidya Manoj Patil.
49. Miss Sonia Manoj Patil, Both r/o flat No/104, 1st Floor,.
A-Wing, Agnelo Colony, Kerant, Caranzalem, Goa.
50. Shri O.A. Fernandes, r/o H.No.E-236, Cortin, Panaji-Goa.
51. Smt. W. Fernandes, R/o S-6, Block 3, Madhu Vihar Complex, P.O. Caranzalem, St. Inez, Panaji-Goa.
52. Miss Sharlene Fernandes, r/o Asha Building, S-2, Mala Fountainhas, Panaji-Goa.
53. Shri Shaikh Riyaz, r/o Ramnagar, Betim, Goa.
54. Smt. Sabina Riyaz, r/o Municipal Market, Panaji, Goa.
55. Shri Vassudeva Sinai Borcar,
56. Smt. Madhura Vassudeva Borcar, Both r/o 65, Sindur, 2nd Floor, Opp. Passport Office, S.V. Road, Panaji-Goa.
57. Smt. Radhabai J. Vaze, r/o H.No.82/C, Behind Govt. Primary School, Bordem, Hodapan, Bicholim, Goa.
58. Shri Dileep Dasharath Dicholkar, R/o H. No. 322, C/o Narayan Arolkar, At: Maina Pilerne, Post: Reis-Magose, Bardez Goa.
59. Smt. Laxmibai P. Joshi.
60. Shri Pradeep Vasant Joshi.
61. Master Prashant Pradeep Joshi, All r/o Khorlim, Mapusa, Goa.
62. Smt. Naik Rukmini Vinayak, R/o Rukmini Niwas, Bhaili Peth, Bicholim, Goa.
63. Liberata Socorro Vaz, R/o Bairo de St. Jose Building, 1st Floor, Flat No.4, Altinho, Mapusa Goa.
64. Smt. Socorro Liberata Vaz, r/o Povoacao, Moira, Bardez Goa.
65. Mr. Edward Peter Martins, r/o H.No. 629, Sallis Vaddo, Parra, Bardez, Goa.
66. Shri P.N. Palang, r/o Laxmi, 1st Floor, Behind Mapusa Clinic, Mapusa, Goa.
67. Shri Shriram Laxman Prabhu Moye
68. Smt. Godavari L.P. Moye, Both r/o H.No.112/C-3, Govind Nagar, Karaswada, Mapusa, Goa.
69. Mr. Vbasundhara H. Naik, r/o Madlawada, Savoiverem, Ponda Goa.
70. Mrs. Shalini Dinanath Naik, r/o Kurtarkar Nagar, Beyond Forest Dept., Shantinager, Ponda Goa.
71. Mr. Dilip Kumar Shirodkar, r/o Gomantak Sivarnakar Sangha, Feira Baixa, Mapusa Goa.
72. Mr. Anil Shantaram Naik, r/o Green Field Appts., Flat No.348 D (2) 4, Shetyewado, Duler, Mapusa Goa.
73. Mrs. Sunita Surendra Raiturcar.
74. Miss Raiturcar Sreeja S.
75. Mrs. Raiturcar Sunita R. All r/o H.No.729/D, Sonu Township St. Jose de Areal, Nessai, Salcete Goa.
76. Mrs. Sandhya Suraj Velingker.
77. Mr. Suraj Madhav Velingker, Both r/o M-79, Housing Board Colony, Alto Porvorim, Bardez Goa.
78. Master Sohan Subhash Borkar, r/o Paraag Housing Society, Behind Super Market, Ponda Goa.
79. Mrs. Shailaja Borkar.
80. Master Chetan G. Borkar.
81. Miss Arati Balakrishna Borkar, All r/o H.No. 873, Paniwada, Near Dattamandir, Borim, Ponda Goa.
82. Mrs. Lalita Dinesh Korde, r/o Devba, H.No.879, Panchme.
83. Miss Geeta R. Navelkar, r/o Near Police Station, Ribandar, Goa. 403006.
84. Mr. S.N. Kamat.
85. Mr. Sanket S. Kamat.
86. Mrs. Neeta S. Kamat.
87. Miss Swati S. Kamat.
88. Miss Archana S. Kamat, All r/o Talaulikar Building Yeshwant Nagar, Ponda Goa 403401.
89. Sinai Wagle A.V.
90. Wagle A.V.
91. Master Subash A. Wagle, All r/o Near C vine Kamala, Tiska, Usgao, Goa.
92. Mr. Shamba Krishna Naik, r/o Madla Vado, Savoi Verem, Ponda Goa.
93. Mr. D.K. Velgekar,
94. Mrs. Madhura D. Velgekar, Both r/o 10, Amrit Madhura, 5th Floor, RSC 28, Sector 3, Charkop, Kandivili (W), Mumbai 4000067.
95. Miss Nutan K. Naik.
96. Miss Susheela K. Naik, Both r/o F-11, 2nd Floor, Soares Appts., Tisk, Ponda Goa.
97. Mr. Gopal Timmappa Denageri, r/o Tisk, Usgao, Goa.
98. Miss Niliksha B. Shirodkar, r/o Warkhande, Near Maruti Temple, Ponda Goa.
99. Mr. Prabhakar P.S. Borkar.
100.Mr. Sinai Borkar Prabhakar P.
101. Mr. Pandurang P.S. Varde.
102. Mrs. Vasanti K. Khanvte,
103. Mr. Hari P. Borkar, All r/o S-4, Builidng 1-D, 2nd Floor, Kurtarkar Nagari, Santa Cruz, Ponda Goa.
104. Mr. Nilesh M. Nagarcenkar, r/o B.11, Mandar Co-op Housing Society, Super market, Ponda, Goa.
105. Mr. Rajendra S. Upasani, r/o c/o Central Mansion, Ponda Goa.
106. Mrs. Lata Gajanan Naik, r/o c/o Adv. G.V. Naik, Menino Building, Ponda Goa.
107. Mr. Parag M. Nagarcenkar, r/o B.11, Mandar Co-op Housing Society, Super Market, Ponda Goa.
108. Mrs. Vaijanyanti Shivaji Dessai, r/o Golna Pompurpa, P.O. Earona, Bardez Goa.
109. Miss Ishwariya Damodar Kakule,
110. Mr. Anirudh Damodar Kakule,
111. Mrs. Sujata Damodar Kakule, All r/o c/o A.S. Wagle, Esvonta F-2, Santa Inez, Panaji, Goa.
112. Mrs. Sandhya Shiwananda Wagle
113. Miss Shiwani Wagle.
114. Mrs. Gulab Awadhut Wagle
115. Mr. Awadhut Shripad Wagle, All r/o Esvonta F-2, Santa Inez, Panaji-Goa.
116. Miss Reshma R. Shirodkar
117. Mrs. Rohini R. Shirodkar.
Both r/o Vagon Kirlapal, Via Curchorem, Goa.
118. Master Ramdas R. Pandit.
119 Mrs. Sushma R. Pandit.
Both r/o Ganga Nagar, Curta, Ponda Goa.
120. Miss Hema R. Borkar, r/o Dabal, Kirlapal, Goa.
121. Mrs. Prafull R. Chari, r/o Dabal, Kirlapal, Curchorem, Goa.
122. Mrs. Kamalavati K. Vernekar, r/o Dabal, Kirlapal, Goa.
123. Mrs. Madhavi M. Borkar.
124. Mr. Madhusudan Borkar
125. Miss Kanaka M. Borkar, All r/o Dabal, Niranchal, Ponda Goa.
126. Mrs. Yamini Vaman Mahale, r/o Goassavi wada, H. No. 253, Barazan, Usgao, Goa.
127. Miss Vaibhavi S. Barve.
128. Miss Triputi S. Barve,
129. Mr. Subhash P. Barve, All r/o Opp. Goa State Co-op. Bank Ltd., Ponda Goa.
130. Mr. Chandrakant Vaman Mahale, r/o Goassavi Wadda, H. No. 253, Barazan, Usgao, Goa.
131. Mr. Bhiku B. Shet Verekar.
132. Mr. Prashant S. Sawant, Both r/o Talaulim Ponda Goa.
133. Banti R. Chari.
134. Chari Ramdas.
135. Mr. R.G. Chari.
136. Mrs. Lata Ramdas Chari All r/o Harshavihar, Near I.D. Hospital, Tisk, Ponda Goa.
137. Mr. Ashok S. Dhabolkar.
138. Mr. Rameshwar Ashok Dhabolkar, Both r/o H.No.448, Post Vagator, Caisau, Dharalvado, Bardez Goa.
139. Mr. Mohan N. Shinde.
140. Mr. Siddharth Mohan Shinde.
141. Mr. Mohini Mohan Shinde.
142. Miss Namita Mohan Shinde, All r/o H.No. 106/10, Khorlim, Koleghati, Mapusa, Bardez, Goa.
143. Mrs. Gauri Shanker Vernekar, r/o H.No. 50, Chinchwado, Chimbel, Ribandar, Goa.
144. Mr. Balchandra P. Chodanker.
145. Mrs. Bhagyashri B. Chodankar, Both resident of H.No.188, St. Francisco Waddo, Goa Velha Goa 403108.
146. Mr. Janardan Bhikaji Joshi
147. Mrs. Sneha Janardan Joshi.
148. Miss Aditi Janardan Joshi, All r/o A1 and Post Dhargal, Vai Colvale, Dhargal, Goa 403513.
149. Mrs. Sneha Satish Bhide, W/o Mr. Satish Bhinde, r/o Patto, Ribandar Goa.
150. Mr. Uday D. Hirloskar.
151. Mrs. Rekha Uday Hirloskar.
Both resident of Uday Appts. Khorlim Mapusa Goa.
152. Pirabai D. Hirloskar, r/o H.No.48, Peacelink Co-op. HSG Society, Khorlim, Mapusa Goa.
153. Miss.
Trupti Sridhar Kamat, r/o H.No.99, Sal, Khalcha Wada, Post Assonora, Goa.
154. Mr. Ganapati Ghivaputra Ghodekar, r/o H.No. 178/73, Narayan Nagar, P.O. Pratapnagar, Sakhali, Goa.
155. Mr. Yeshwant Naik.
156. Mrs. Vijaya Yeshwant Naik.
Both r/o H.No.133, Ward No.10, Near Central Garage, St. Inez, Panaji-Goa.
157. Sunita U. Joshi, r/o Durgavady, Taleigao, Goa.
158. Mr. Augusto Negredo, r/o H.No. 56, Santana Talaulim, Velha, Ilhas Goa.
159. Mary F. Mendonsa,
160. Mr. A.S. V. de Figueiredo e Melo,
161. Ms. Olive de Figueiredo e Melo, All r/o Villamel, Solmona, Saligao, Bardez Goa.
162. Mrs. Carmen T. De Souza, r/o F-2, Indraprastha, M.B. Road, Panaji-Goa.
163. Mr. Prashant U. Gude, S/o Mr. Uttam V. Gude, r/o Chimbul Wada, Marcel, Goa.
164. Master Roystern DSouza.
165. Mrs. Mercian DSouza.
166. Mr. Patricio DSouza.
All r/o H.No.291, Bhattier, Nerul, Bardez Goa.
167. Mr. Patil Maruti Narayan, r/o Ajobanagar, Harualem, Post Pratpnagar, Sanquelim, Taluka, Bicholim, Goa.
168. Mrs. Jayashree K. Shirodkar, r/o H.No.8, Ward, Atin Peth, Bicholim Goa.
169. Mr. Tanaji Yeshwant Pai, r/o H.No.62, Ward No.2, Borda, Bicholim Goa.
170. Mr. Rahul Rajaram Gawas, r/o Keri Ghoteli No.1, Post Sanquelim, Goa.
171. Miss Seema Tanaji Pal.
172. Miss Anjali Tanaji Pal r/o H.No.62, ward no.2 Borda, Bicholim, Goa.
173. Mr. Pravin A. Kalgutkar, r/o Om Chambers, 1st Floor, Opp. Laxmi Narayan Temple, Mapusa Goa.
174. Mr. Maxie Fernades, r/o H.No. 225, Bella Vista, Golvale, Bardez Goa.
175. Mr. Balvanth Rao Sardessai,
176. Mrs. Shreya B. Sardesai, Both r/o H.No. 8, Ward No.8, Atin Peth, Bicholim, Goa.
177. Master Kaushik Dhond
178. Mr. Pradeep V. Dhond, Both r/o Pradeep Medical Stores, Near S.B.I. (Bank), Ponda Goa.
179. Miss Marlyn Costa, r/o Old Market, Margao, Goa 403601.
180. Mr. Rodrigues Clemente, r/o 137, Palmar Grande, Chinchinim, Salcete Goa.
181. Mrs. Monalisa Rodrigues, r/o Opp. KTC Bus Stand, Maddel Grande, Margao, Goa.
182. Mrs. Carol Rodrigues, r/o 137, Palmar Grande, Chinchinim, Salcete Goa.
183. Mrs. Lucy Costa, r/o Madel Grande, Margao, Goa.
184. Master Sidesh Mohan Netalkar, r/o Veling, Mardol, Goa 403404.
185. Malan R. Malkarnekar, r/o H.No. 24/A. Taradatta, Arlem, Raia, Salcete Goa.
186. Mrs. Geeta G. Jotkar, r/o L.T.V. High School, Kavlem, Ponda Goa.
187. Mr. Dinanath B. Kamat, r/o H.No. 402, Fatorda, Margao Goa.
188. Master Disha Dilip Naik.
189. Anisha Dilip Naik, Both r/o F-1, Shivam Appts, Opp. Football Ground, Pantemol, Curchorem, Goa.
190. Mr. V.K. Naik, r/o H.No.440, Murida, Fatorda, Margao Goa.
191. Mrs. R.K. Naik, r/o G-4, Anita Appts, Fatorda, Margao Goa.
192. Mr. Krishnanath Pandari Naik, r/o F-2, Sneha Appts, Fatorda, Margao Goa..
193. Mrs. Olivia John Rodrigues,
194. Mr. Hayson John Rodrigues.
195. Mr. John Rodrigues All r/o H.No.70, Grande Waddo, Colva Salcete Goa.
196. Mr. Anthony Giles Coelho, r/o Madhuban Complex, C-11, Tolaband, Madhar, Benaulim, Goa.
197. Mr. Balchandra N. Pundalik, r/o Shree Krupa, E173/174, Housing Board Colony, Ghogal, Margao Goa. 4036001.
198. Miss Kane Madhura Pradeep.
199. Tanmay Pradeep Kane.
200. Pai Kane Vidya P.
201. Pradeep V. Kane, All r/o Madhupriya, H. No.547, Orel, Assolna Salcete Goa.
202. Mr. Shetti G.D. R/O Happy Homes Appts.
Near Costa Hospital, Fatorda, Margao Goa.
203. Mr. Omkar Rajendra Amonkar, r/o H.No. 207, Khornwada, Pato Ribandar Goa.
204. Miss Ligia DSilva, r/o Maddar, Benaulim, Salcete Goa.
205. Miss Mayura S.N. Kurade.
206. Mrs. Usha S.N. Kurade.
207. Mr. Shridhar D.N. Kurade, All r/o Near P.W.D. Water Tanks, Borda, Fatorda, Margao Goa.
208. Mrs. Tari Pushpa D., r/o c/o Damodar Purushottam Tari, H.No. 368, Borda Margao, Goa 403601.
209. Master Gitesh Ramesh Volvoikar.
210. Master Pritesh Ramesh Volvoikar.
Both r/o Haveli, Curti, Ponda, Goa.
211. Mr. Sadanand Ramchandra Mudras, r/o A-2, T-4, 3rd Floor, Kurtarkar Modern Homes, Aquem-Baiso, P.O. Navelim,.
Salcete Goa 403707.
212. Mrs. Ruasinha Almeida.
213. Mr. Alfred Almeida.
214. G.A. Almeida, All r/o Pajifond Appartments, Rua de Sauddader, Margao Goa.
215. Mrs. Shaila V. Rivankar.
216. Mr. Vithalrao A. Rivankar, Both r/o H.No.E-35, 1st Floor, Fontainhas, Mala, Panaji Goa 403001.
217. Mr. Sadanand F. Kantak, Both r/o Near Sri Kalanath Temple, Mapa, Panchwadi, Post Panchwadi, Via Curchorem Goa.
218. Mrs. Chaya Prakash Surlakar.
219. Mr. Prakash P. Surlakar.
Both r/o H.No.116, Comba Alto, Margao-Goa.
220. Mr. Diago V. Costa, r/o H.No.42, Aquem Baixo, Navelim Salcete Goa.
221. Mrs. Catarina Fernandes, r/o Opp.3 MTR Church, Aquem Baixo, Navelim, Salcete Goa.
222. Mr. Adgaonkar Ramesh P.
223. Mrs. Rekha R. Adgaonkar.
224. Mr. Hrishikesh Ramesh Adgaonkar.
225. Miss Adgaonkar Rageshree R. All r/o Padre Conceicao College of Engineering, Verna, Salcete Goa.
226. Mrs. Mirabai Kurade, r/o Near St. Joseph High School, Aquem Alto, Margao Goa.
227. Shakila Banu.
228. Mr. Nawaabjaan Khan, Both r/o Flat No.6, Shantinagar, Loresno Vaz Building, Aquem Baixo P.O. Navelim Goa.
229. Mrs. Reena Paya Naik, r/o Near Singbal Hospital, Khadpaband, Ponda Goa.
230. Mr. Mahesh Arjun Gaonkar.
231. Miss Archana Arjun Gaonkar.
232. Mrs. Gulabi Arjun Gaonkar.
233. Mr. Arjun Modsu Gaonkar, All r/o Sattari Wado, Thane, H.No.27, Sattari Goa.
234. Mr. Dattatreya Baburao Kamat, r/o H.No.402, Fatorda, Near P.W.D. Margao Goa.
235. Mrs. Maria Bernda Dias, r/o H.No. 55/1. St. Francisco Colony, P.O. Quepem, Goa.
236. Mrs. Malini C. Caculo, r/o H.No.507, Near Aquem Post, Opp.
Sanskar Society, Margao Goa.
237. Mrs. Binda Virendra Kenkre.
238. Mrs. Nirmala Suresh Kenkre.
Both r/o H.No.159(1) Vasvaddo, Benaulim, Salcete Goa.
239. Miss Sarita S. Pangam, r/o Santacruz, Bastora, Mapusa Goa.
240. Smt. Shalini R. Mudras, H.No. 44/2-G, Santacruz, Bastora, Mapusa Goa.
241. Krishnakant Pangam.
242. Mr. Anant S. Pangam, Both r/o Taliwado, Bastora, Mapusa Goa.
243. Miss Smruti Moye.
244. Mrs. Pushpa Moye, Both r/o Anjali Niwas, Khorlim, Mapusa Goa.
245. Mr. Jayant Kuvelkar, r/o Mahalsa Temple Road, Mardol Goa.
246. Master Aniket Hirachand Naik,
247. Mr. Hirachand Yeshwant Naik Both r/o Madlawada, Savoiverem, Ponda Goa.
248. Miss. Samidha S. Raikar.
c/o Suresh Raikar, Sirsat Wada, Mapusa Goa.
249. Mr. Sarvesh S. Raikar, r/o Guru Sadan Vithalwadi.
250. Suresh D. Raikar, r/o D-2, Bhawani Appts., Ansabhat, Mapusa Goa.
251. Mrs. Nisha S. Raikar, R/o D-2, Bhawani Appts, Ansabhat, Mapusa Goa.
252. Mr. Shridhar Balaji Gaonkar.
253. Mr. Pankaj Ramdas Gaonkar, Both r/o 272-B/2, Shetia Wada, Opp. SFX High School, Mapusa Goa.
All 253 members represented by All Goa Manipal Finance Group of Companies Creditors Association, Office at 13/B, Garden Centre, Opp. Police Station, Mapusa, Bardez, Goa. Decree Holders.
(Original Complainants) v/s
1. Manipal Sowbhagya Nidhi Limited, Registered Office at Manipal House, Manipal 576 119, Karnataka.
2. Branch Office of Manipal Sowbhagya Nidhi Limited, Mapusa, Bardez, Goa.
Through its Officer in charge.
3. Branch Office of Manipal Sowbhagya Nidhi Limited, Panaji, Goa.
Through its Officer in charge.
4. Branch Office of Manipal Sowbhagya Nidhi Limited, Ponda, Goa.
Through its Officer in charge.
5. Branch Office of Manipal Sowbhagya Nidhi Limited, Margao, Goa.
Through its Officer in charge.
(Original Opposite Parties) Judgment Debtors For the Decree Holders Shri G. Agni, Advocate For the Judgment Debtors Shri Samant, Advocate Dated:20-03-2009 ORDER [Per Smt. Caroline Collasso, Member]
1. This order will dispose off application of Decree Holder under section 25 of the Consumer Protection Act.
2. As per order of this Commission dated 28-07-2004 the Opposite Parties were jointly and severally directed to pay to the Complainant the principal amount of the Sowbhagyalaxmi Cash Certificates, Fixed Deposits Receipts and Senior Citizens Special Deposit Scheme amounting to Rs.87,33,000/- along with interest @ specified in the terms and conditions within 30 days.
3. The Opposite Parties were jointly and severally further directed to pay to the Complainant-Association a sum of Rs.10,000/- as cost of the litigation. This order was challenged before the Honble National Commission vide order dated 09-05-2006. The Honble National Commission held that they do not find any merit in the appeal and dismissed the same. The Appellants/Judgment Debtors herein were to pay to the Respondent (Decree Holders) Rs.1000/- as cost to each of the depositors who are members of Respondent/Association.
4. The Decree Holder has submitted detailed calculations vide application dated 05-12-2008. The amount due to the creditors as on 31-11-2008 is Rs.50,37,255 (Rupees Fifty lakhs, thirty seven thousand, two hundred fifty five only).
5. It is brought to our notice that some of the Decree Holders are already paid. The District Recovery Officer, Panaji, is thus to ascertain those Decree Holders who have received the amounts due to them and obtain from them the original fixed deposit/cash certificates and hand over the same to the Judgment Debtors.
6. The Decree Holder has also submitted the list of properties belonging to Judgment Debtor. They are as follows:
(i) Manipal House at Manipal Karnataka.
(ii) Flat No.C-3, at Green Land Housing Co-operative Society at Panaji, Behind Military Hospital, Panaji-
Goa.
(iii) 1st Floor of building named Shindur, where at present office of Manipal Finance Group is functioning at A.B. Road, Opposite Gomant Maratha Samaj, Panaji.
(iv) Right side of the ground floor of Shivneri Building at Margao behind Loyala High School, Margao-Goa.
ORDER The District Recovery Officer, Panaji is hereby directed to attach the above properties to recover the decretal amount of Rs.50,37,255/-. The individual Decree Holders are to hand over the original fixed deposit/cash certificates to the District Recovery Officer at the time of receipt of individual amount. The District Recovery Officer is to hand over the same to the Judgment Debtors.
Pronounced.
[Sandra Vaz e Correia] Member [Caroline Collasso] Member