Karnataka High Court
Sri Rajesh vs State Of Karnataka on 10 August, 2011
Author: N.Ananda
Bench: N.Ananda
ms mge: mg; H ::{>z3§2':' <13?' i~{£k¥'~EI'€'s1'¥'AP{§1 z%;'r- £13;-'~..rx§<;;x:;<>E.i<{_z3 :;>§;:T'E:::3 'BEES Tm: 1%? {Law {T}? AU'GUS'I' 2&1. 2 P £?..E§8I£N"i' 'E'Piii<?; L§<>:2'-'2s1.£:": E's!I§€.J{,ES3'§'I€?§%:-?'*3<*5\::*~§z'7NEi§2"*;:q ANE} I 1 1' ' "i'%~iE%: ;<»~»i'c>m3L:é: MR.J'{J$i';i<:««:«*;z'v.&§:5:~éi £;x:;%>;»gg%;.;a;r;; CR£N§ENAE.- mi>P£sA1,,_ ';*::>j9 J :!€}0I'"}{ E3 E§r§.wVS? EN 5 S1":i., E{2:1je"3:'».;1': _ S/{:2 V@':"1ii;:'t:;%sh21é;1}1 Aged 25 YGEKS V _ ' R/0 A}}_§§ag§e1'i% 'V i?Lftz{}:i"¢:5 Chez.1mapai.:':;I;""féi'i3;;}g._ ..
§;3a£."1g_;*ziL:)1"'€: I~1'Lz__1faE-if}?§;'i.z'§{,.1:;, _ V "V ' g {B}; S:*'i,'T, E"{,§'1v'§Oé'12:i1 .5-'§gcix<c;t?::"£.{:%ff..._H_ .,R zT§p;>(:sIE1g1E}E Afiéffi: . V. Siam aéf E<1_;t.r:1'saL.;a;§:<;:;V " _ «. ~ Rep, "£31;-I }?7{uéf°;-3;} E7-'r>1§.§{:?:*:,_ {fix<;t";"::€§ap;e3J€':r:z7:
E?%aI1g;a§_<>_§"€ §Zz.{:";1EV E}1'.55§i.':£°%Z{':?5.'v. t..,E{€t:~;p:>:':{iié:3?'. {E332 f:S'1f§_i. N ,. 1 Sam f§g.':...:'; ggi §°2:1";';": 3% 9: h , H C G P} 'E'7r1§A:%;.&;3§ipr:2:3 £53 §iE{~:tr:i E.,3:'1{§€§' EBsa3€:£.i<}:T: 3?L§{2} {"i§xE'.{L
2.; _én;:>fi.. %'h_£:% .§?£§ i;.§;§§:';{;?:'1£. £fz'E,i§.{',*C§ .E$%;':2'EQ38.20%9€% ;>a:§;si~:<5€§ '$33; Eizéer §;.C::9§'i"::§2".z'1§;5;"{ESE}'*>f;"T§}§ss'a.;';§{%% zmd ${'ffi§:':?:Si.{}Zf"£i~f§ a§:..z{ig§é:: §"z:1s"~;i" "§"m<T%k, €:{i§'§o.:§.'E'T'§."V_Ei§g '§;§.§i§Ei§{EE§{EE"€E §3€,'s_:§':::§ §'}i:a:§:°E<.':§,.? Efie-a;<'1;.g;a:.§<}2°:=I: in _ .§§.{§.?7E<>.?i-7% ,5' 1235525. (.?<>m='§<.:i:E2.':;-_; %.E':£:r zjzggéeiEzzim;':?:C£:u$€:{:3 {ii}? zm. v.;)E'§%;%:1<:a=% ~ ;g§:I2;3'1.i.:i-:E§z1§:§§€i Lzizcriafr ¥~:=,.:=7<*:'§§<m 382 '§§.'-'{7; 21;::.€§ :e:€::3.€.{5:1<;:i.1";g; E":,i:;"t;_ M3 "L'E.§2{§f31'§._:;€} 1mg}ri§a;<>:"s.:"":é§%:'1E: §'E;}'§' E256: :E'§§'3(.§ pa}; fE:"z<*: E}? ._ 2%-%isé'.5§{'}=C}C¥,f--' in e:iz5¢.f2§.z.:E.*i, £5} :.,2:';{,'§;:';-233:0 Em' {ms :'_y7€'é?1l° §"<f;r' 21:':
' . s:3'i"§éi*;:.::% §}'§,ZE'Z.iE:%E'E£?ib§€' L..:.:'1e:'E:_%':" .:=«:z<:=;'%§"§{';:'1 IEEIEZ» §E3'{,"i_ ~ V. 'G{}¥-E-?:'Z?fi3';§}i}§1'}ASi '§T1":§::" 'a:*:V<';;.;$§::{£ §¥{:::j:t:$§";a 32:1? e=%i5i:§r bra:}éhs::° 0?
E?' .V E"~fig"9ZZ1':~5i:T:;?%':vE<;z%E.:::Ea%<§3E::1':2:én§:1*:zz is; €'E':<-3% m€3EE1.:5::' G? .§-'-K-'sr'92 zmzffi
-- E~E::4z{§§°é;T:§§:2T;.A .' 4§??'2-'V'. E~EE'%1é_:r:u"'z1::"3.u £329 z'3':2;2¥;i%.:"':3::; rwszajtizjé :3?
" '€§€?f{.'.'-
IN) 'E'.%31i::-:2 a;:}pe2?:..Z {ée::;.m§1":g; am far %1e21:'i:1.§;j Ehisés .{ia.3;.
[}E:, J, ci:?E.:v<;%:*:3c:§ 1'h.=:": E'¥:s11.:n.v§:':g: ' J U if} E} M 1%; N "F 'ET'h:% el§3§".3(:":lE£1§':'i.--£3,€?{'?iiE§€"{§ izzas; §§E€;{i§ §.hi:=; .';:5L;L*}';:')«:t-£5: , j1.1{i§:§II1E3t§'§{, Of r::<:}:'1\.?ic:"%,§.<.>::'1 ft}? 2-in «:>§'£€;:1§.t<:;"' T;:§i,z§:%.::3E1a_b'£'e Sr;x':i.i(31'1 302 §,1§'3.{"f, 2', $66: Elssvs hfiélfd S1'€.'E1}<Z.M_£)hv21::' 'E32215-3, Eé?'z:--IT:_1e3:§,'%;:0:..§:';§5e;%E for 21<?c:us§£t€i amzi Si'? N.S;'S:1i§:'1;i321':}g§'i :13: gzaizzh, §E'f21f'1'3=f3'{§ G0w3:nm:€:z":é:, P%€:21<:§<:--r i°<3'§' E':.:*"'i€f"€3~§.:§'£'§.€?"' 3, in §f:é'zf§e.£',."":.hé%" :ffa1$c%"'Q'§7.Vgjéi--<2:+;'t.:{3*;::§:,§.c3.;§ zmé §:":E.€::.°Se 3"$§z?Li'.§«:"2'§.1 b::*%i>s;a-'::%e;";~'E§€§::*:é3AEM i:§f€§% " pzi:s;é?'{':,1§..§€i¥:'}'"'=a;?E§.1'1&*SSc;%:=5; :11:-:3-' E3»? s::.i.:1i.€<"E ii"; :23:
§€:.,z{i:°:;%é3--E;2z. v.§'s-:;i.n:_?€r.§:3;ét-i:%éj:::£s;€:«:§} wzizs iiimé E":_:.:s§s%322:;<3{% {if §WJ(2--
21T{€£ju:«2§:'.1<§, V' -.v.:§.'3Vif':::5W§3}1§E'EiE'E"3.'§1'§;2i Elm'. 53:1}: §'}.€,':i." :3? {:i{::<;* %2"i:%::%{§ ii ; £2 5 .5 5 E :2,;=;€<;§ §«2;z,.:'{*§:*%=%.f§*1:;*:. (§;axV,,'~u{f:g..2w-~4"«E5°§~x_ 9" '* i&'f32£§?{};E€'3( 33-3EEi?i,§1.€E§'=,?;.}'1E §:'V*-T§:::':'§.<;3;'~;=:» §"<}u:'1<:§ {ten Ehéé £§§"fE?%';'fZZ£E53f3{i z>».zs:'::% {"'E2.'{IiS%'»(':'{i §i3}r a;,. §€.>:'1§g; §YéE3J"k{%<;".§ gag gsész' '%§<}b i. mi} 33:63 griézaeruzesswzcé E2':
".:in§%i;:9i':i1222é.é.<.}§': 2=3:;;':z'f§ %:a=":s::§é;-,%:'1a"a': (3? E1*'&?':«s;« E. 2a;:§:'i 37%. é.'é.§.}§;i£"§' §é"{:z::1 :.§'2.:3. fa:
<ii:»;;')z,1£{:£i éfijg ihéf ;:s.<:<;'u:<::=<~?<'L "i'§'1<;* r:%§22£.i:}:":é:.--s11.§.g} bf3'{'fff;*fE;?E"£ '§.h£%
2.:<*:.<%u;s.~;<3:§ a:':<i c.§<':?<:r€;'r21s=,;€s<i 2.1:'":{i s:3{':m,;1s:> £3? ifité p:"<>:est:é<;.éz:ti<§;z '$.31.-*}:1.'£'.'z{Tf-.'rE§§:*.'sfii':'Et': 21:52: s~3'£.21i5.t%{'§ .<.-;::.:;,>2":13,. E12-$3 EEITJI §:}<:<%1:1. <.iispz:'ie£'E.. '§."E.'1e:'j"'£--T.r:;<':-1E'4 f.§'§£1'§' éiézfméz-z:~;<=:<§ E'{u:"§":°<%s:«."§":211 £i1?::*s';.§ E'1{>':'3'}i<':§.s:§2~::E 5:i:3;;1§.I?': 21:. am ':95 .1€3.iZ{3{}4 m'.*m" 531.,g\;-wjss s"sg»t1.<3<:E E35 ;'%,§3f§";;r:g?{s;.s:'§;;'.};?jEi.2::V§§.VV :'§{}'é. %3s:<::": ejjiés-;§31.xE:<;%{"i. E?-.'.v<'::'1 {N§':<;%;°w§:s:;§:%'.""%"§'f;{?. g§;iar§%:T1 by E"s3e-2EE":;--E3:',M2:12?a.»*:2gg<>w{i221 v;I;%z:i--:4_1'1*<;7'v':%;:.§ '~fl'h,.;;:*£'f' .j£',i.16.-': ' <ié?<é€:a:+;e=:i E25253 :~:r;u§'£.':e'r:;%::i 2'2 z'§'1;?;-_;':jg5 as:a" E':-';z:ri.ses;§ :Z':1§u::"§.e&-;; <3? {%§§'f€z'£;%%:'z£. :21ease:::"=:%:::'1&1'1.1.s«; :i3.::2_€:-i?;22:;§._;;.g1:"£'S§;V E2315; <>§.}i.ne<:§ Ehzaéi: i;.§:€=. {Eek T}: :2; . '"Wt.<§ 4' .%5_E'}€.§{%'E§;---VV"2;:::d he%mm°r°%1a_g;;<é <7::w:::~;-;t;%qu<:%':'"z?;. ':3; i:':}_:§g;.f'i<Es; is) ;ri'E'éa;E §)é2.:*-:'.:'s $;§{TE1 25:5; 'i'Z{3.'{?E~i. §?"~J'2.i §1f;2§f=3"'§}*'"}I§fi'.:€?{'§ '~,il*i£1E.' 2.31:2 §:*;m'§§::~is Ekmizd mi: %_.§;<3~. <:a:.:se:§?{§ xx»-'§.§.h 2:: s:sh.213f;;} %:%€§g,§e<:E e;"§<,+c<ia1$z*<§ {i%;::sj1,.fit:%_ h7g:_fg.re;§'. E}.
{stats "E 2-?;."af,«:%':; ' :1: $~ié_ E7 3 zuaf; *:.'E':ct- jag d §;:;':'":e3; 1': in .335}. atijsuki be :~;:':-:;:>.:.'"a i°z'<>:'":z "§;:}'w {."£}§":'€_é:E'§'3E.S:% mi" E'E2':'::,a£. 's 5- a&;é%:+1»4%4w;/ww--5%:
""é,--fr3a:%:':"':L.. "ws;;i';<e;% '"§€§§'E'v'§{3E,€§:§m'(HE E319 E32.:s~;i:';~.: <3? s's.:»zme €i'§:'§€§£?E1{2€f. "Efi'§i:';:f§%:iE;::':%';'1:5 5;:L:§fn'1':'§:sss%<>':': of k?2::':";<7:s:'§ :.:'t{m.z.*;:~'s:;=:%«§ £23? ;1:;:<':us;a--3{i " , Egg-_V '*§'3:::~s"§*3;.m<§ §§€<§:?s:=%a&;z%{:§} 'i%;'£1§§: §':4:z'::':§ng_,i 2-:2'; gm§1€:s:*§<:E{sa§';;5:w; '§"E.1é3 "I'hi:'°:1:zmi21§"§« él:'2g;1<§.i {,?i'":;1::<.i "EL E-<Zz1:11«:%:e;E*:.;1 am;{?§. ';'<::§:é_ié$E'1;:z. i.2'1_._i:,he Eihrch Ei;_§h'i', £.l1.e}; ws3:':;?~. 2¢m13.~:'r.(.'E w§:..E"; xw:a1§.}<:;'}&s {Kid '£'I*1.'§i"}i '"':i:_'2:*:3 Ezeitmv:5sk..c§E.§.:3;' fikzm thy? p§2'1<*,@ <13»? i:.":.:;%£=:ieI:1'{ 2~1§é'.€rr éi~::%_._a::;".2':_;{ E?"
2?m(f§ 9 E"£1E':I:'".£€.'3i 13:? a<*{t.r€rpi.€:<i. §%: i{:»:j>k;~:.% E3¥.i:.fi:?\211:z§€?_'E".§é3"i§"' '?.'V"'~'»~" '»*¢'3ii€3 Emri S§€E'i}'1 3&3:-47' {Ea-%<'<itas~.:~2€t:§ in t§'1€: :T?:):'21.;.3;-m}; {:=_:"' 4g:::'<'::.1[[:j~"=§:?<%.2312:}"<§%.%3€%%*I1j_' §}€t:'s;ofiss I"i2:'s1'":iEE§§-" E'{2'a._§e%s:sE':z;1, T?%.i1:::.:f:'}2?1iz-ah;._ 2{iF"1§;§Ei'€'§§ A A..§3§";;-::1<§3z'z1, .§f<ia_:11es:a§m and '1'<>gesaf1a nezxz" {T}*;21z2';;;1g;:;E.'i.2:.:?;2i' bazie Si.é:.%:ic::1 ai. f:..£3G p.:'n.'_ 022 "E0. .}..C3.2{§{)*5}i<';._§f:i.'éS1f §'1;';"".-ws: '§7:.>_g;.iz1'€:d_ 3.2: <3p§;':im1 ihsars, §,.hOf:3£";? p«:'tr'§§<m:%~; h;a:::EA.a}1§e30 j:;'}i.t':1€:>,€:_ ':'hc': ._z1{:_<ta,:.'?:'é'&>{§.V 'fa?'-'.:z 'J:i*'3, {?<>n":;1'3§s5s'£0m. {)5 {3fiEé::<it:%, '.£'}.13;é2"e.{%jT;;*z :1':-33:';3€;*::5§:§)E:1i'1;:gE.1it:~%é;'-E33" H26 §:1V<::sa£i§g2:{.i':1gg 0§"§Ez':€:' Em' gg'i&'_iz":g;j__ fig) §§é=£%. _2ib:{;Av;T3"' 'f."§'€?'E°S.§:§}}"i:"=S in 3'19 §:i:'12s.} '1*e§3G3:i, £?2':§.Ii{1{}§. be 3 T§;:5{j2.1.1z§.<§?.' i.(.3, éi'§...$<1'21r+:i-- %';§'3{:% &a!£d€:::1<:<;*r ad::§:4::':a%s:i E33;-' pr{}s:3a$§':1.1"E.i£fx:':x " ThEss_ ..§";€}éI"~::;_ '.é%3»§.f,"{.iE'i'£.i(}£'E :1:~'E'::%r::'; $€:~'€é;'z-23 ;1<:e:?ns::€é€£ :&fa:'e;% E?_T'§,f:d ;:~u"i5€§ V_:=é{;v:11{°: of *él"§€::1';: w£;*.:"£: 21oquié_.€.€r.{i; zmd s~:<}H1€ if}? %3z'":;'?;a:i}?' %;:z:%_ :-33?: -:'::
Efi;;v---§"vV2 'aim. viii? {sf {§€:<7.fi2:::'-,=;€:i,, SEE}:-3. E':z~2s«: {is:p<;as:e«;€:i maxi 5 ER? _§/:
Sfiiiiifféi fms §:siz:><:s:§ st2.zi:'1eci {?§{':'LE'1€Tt.':% {sf {E16 cgit'-*<7s;>a5:-:=:?(E. Thii? &§(,'{'.£.§S{E{i v0Ez:1'1iee;é1'e:E i:}i%3:":13z::'i,£<i>:1 in ih.<~:*. r;=:.*:"i':'e<7E i..ii221£."':;§T:"'r1§;% 2'§m?.<3z1*2p2:2t'1i&?(§ §"}.¥:" WEE} s'<~;E1<m-' 'the ;3§21<.:<% '2,vE":«:%1°~t.* Z522? E'f:_::j:%;i <:::§:5';€. Lg;-:,2€£v::--'_T ' :5: E<}:1g§_ exriii E',1".::;% .sE'1.§.:": :3?" C§=E?(,'£:'.£:1S{'Tf{i; '?§i1é.}§_ad:m:§:i§'£§j'§a:a%_";3{3fci§{;n {if " 'voE:.21'11211'§,.? .:=_j§E..i3;':'£.f;fE'1'2¥;'T'.E"3§. 4}? 'tbs e.:c<irz.::=:{<:.fi<i §1)é'3;,*5'f§'15'~ Iii:-'~1;'§ E5-'_x:.P24. {En {ha iE1>E'E<m-'it'1;.g (2213? EM: E.{_':{,'1'E<;A.'._':_j}2'-,1:e':'}C§".EK' r::Unch,1e::.i.<--:{i §%"2€§§.§E':Si. peg" E%3x.E?3V'§'E?§. Eie 2%%;+;{3_ z'»:t<:<>}':"c§e«:§ the :~i;i;2:'€:{%:21<%1'1t§; {>5 <;'.{;*.'§'€21i.i.1'1 ;:;z§if%'s<3::;'§ £i;"" " :?::'5?':f?:'i' ~€"E_1€.: cifiasi bagly £2}? p{}$":'.m:):<"£'.€:§'1 exm:1i:1aEi:}§§'; _ "§:"im.--'~ i;%_.;f%{f{§ §:>.2::;::i ?£:E":<3: i.:rwessEig§22Ei<}1'1 gaff ' M4 .z2:'1:§ p2m§:.§"; w:é':é_':: T §:é:saj£s:> i.E1ej:3w2?:r fiefld sf (3:16 §Su.:'£=,$h=i'21z":s:f'*--pi'éié%ié§;s:i 2%;-.§_T1a=:>':L1;;:;; §_'_"2":>_:T§i.§..E 2&1 ' j in «-'air 1.'i:*:E::%x §f3~:£-'i7ii}$€.§i_'~.{fffi" .::?:>:2;21é:vi_a_'m§ ii::::'2.§?7*;Ef3G .':2a;~:; c§a;%;3{3§::;.€:cE :.E'1a,§. bf; 1;.h{? i'L§§1VE_fif §}._<;':--E"$é1£;}§:§.'§:?§§V§13{3=!}'Ev€fE?'vé%j§.2*;'%.§-€323 <'.'i'§.§'E'1t'f E'f2.2-id bee:":. .§'&g.is:§§:3:'as=3s:§ bf,' the :a;z.:§:::§:2ss§_3«::V{é§{3';t'".:f;£',.;§{}§_§{{?e. Ewis Tt'1z':é%; <i€;~.r1i<";~:i {$2.9 sf~.su;;;;_:.>;{-=:$zi{}}'; 5&1;-1'€,:v:»'s-a::{:}§;,::s3ér3{iV §1:;:{Vi":':0':: §wi<?k<%a§ ":..t';§ EE3i'1§§: €f:'c}::"1 i%':a;=r j<3v;2~::° £:'}'.€:,\:zfin
--.E"§.€;%"....Ei§;3.S=és_"'{§{3'§)§}§S=3€3{iZ Vi'.'§*::L{*£. '§E':ai g:}§;w:*: §'m3'§': 'W-'"E.1{"'.' re §§E%;'.' ;-,2€:§:u.&:~€d s::'e:%:§1::':;s%:'§.;.i §_::v':: 'W'EE€f%§ E 2: <'ii.::eE2:.1.'1c€r 2»? E89 f:°<>:':": 'E."m{i §::Ta:~7:{'t{% 3%" z g N 3'.i'1A?::§;:iA:';%n'€,» ' ' amurgai 8.80 pm. an 1G$i§.2GQ:§. 'E'E':.e acczggeii had apgarareé befera Channapaina rural paiiae at Q,&i'§ cisthfig were Siairzeé aariih §}E€}0{§w "fine *m§u_r:§:*3;%y :<-:§;ié'a:é%.i*;.2.2é;i*;'§; given E3}? {he accusad had iad is :*e:::<:sv2:>%:"jg eff' L§';ru;.E'g1'.--VIV;!'s4;»%;'é;:;§§<,>;.:'2.V?'«:::§' u afféncsz} fmm tha jazvar fieid af 0:126 Si€_feéh,'TTx:r.1§i::i:
éisiazzce 0f 10% fig, fmm ma géialcifgef ifi.€Z1:f&€Hi. v A 33¢ Thé ESE regfigzj: wa_r;:z'V2',':'E' e:§: Qathfis 05 deceased anafi the slaffiée-fé "$50:;;é_¢fiA.';'V§.x;;:¥_:"& gtairzed wiih human 'aEv9o§§;*}V3f:'.'G'§;A_A' 'b§§*:fiV_ §«i:§us€d haé made unsuezzessfiié V T_hé'i?.{f:{1§£€«.::ir~::j;i1a;s:ari;tes have hem": estabiishefi by the prafsiagtégéiiaiz=._'§y'=. @':§_g::.;:;.i' énd canségégnf. ewléence, The :3'2?ifi§;;f:--s:e aéjézgéagi Eizy the pE"8S€(EU.§§Gfl in grass? sf . - ciféziiiiiéézzvrivtaé p-uifaévffiih by 'die pmsgrzzzriian 313 wnzpaiibie wifi': ihfi sf accused anfi ii exciufieg hm-@se'r:s3& af 329$."-<c';};::é::i§§ia'§ azay army :1': Egmidirzg {fiat g§c:,§.s€é ihaé aé:;%;';;S&é} ~;§§§%§;s§$f@r§-3 we Essie} {fiat fiiff Esamfié ma: J:/figs has