Karnataka High Court
Neelakant Rao S/O.Guddo Kulkarni, ... vs The State Of Karnataka Rept, By Its ... on 21 January, 2011
Author: S.Abdul Nazeer
Bench: S.Abdul Nazeer
EN THE; H1ii§E-E C{3UE';'T {'.')E? P{;'§§§°'=3{3f§'fXI{£'z CERCUIT §:'{£i§N<3E-{ A'? D%iARW£§D ::w:§E;} Wig THEE 21$: :3;-1'; {TE}? x.§;%I'€UAR':", BEFQERE-T;
ma H{}I\§'BLE: F¥§§{;t.EL§E3r§'EC.§: ;s:;;3;:-;2:>%§L ';~eA;r:é:'};:i§:_ mm' PETI'E'IOi\§ §\é<}.£s5?2é';;,zV2{;.1figmj" - ;BEZTWEEN:
E"~EEB§A§<;ANZ' m<3, 225:3 EEUDDO KULKEXRNI SENSE: DEAD BY HES LR:-3 T , vawgwagfi, E350 I'EEELAKANTE~Z~A<j} r<;':;:;:»§;:--:¥:1\::;. AGE 59 YEARS, ()C{3i=AGR§,s"' * " V Rg<;> §=s§..-%E.A{}U?EéD, f:i;2_,L:_ %§:.AN<£;AL§, F1.fE"§'§':. V %'~§%j;;r%'?;g;,*jvEI:' gay' SRE. I'v'£.$.}~§£aIQA\5?§, i§3:£353;¥.;f{.):C?;¢;7§f§'}~~. _ ' AND :
"ESE: gram (3? .;<_.;x;?<:>1';E;§A:~«:;:;[;~-
Ram: BY {TE-E;:+§?:2{3}?%E:'i1'%Pl?'fz"E*rj:; ' §<&s:w%:NU§; :§}'*stV§>A;RT3v;.E:\4i:f ' 'JI.}{é1fE~';3' zéégubzem, ABm%<;A:;::>§a§: 3 1;.
rm {:E~{2;Efi§E2:%x§A1'€, '§;A.?3§§;: TR::8L§':%;:a_L, Hfiszizai, *;%~A:,;*w3:A?;:a;§:s%.v§;; j£}§:T~§T. E~*Z;~'=s.'v'E«:R§' ES¥*i~z§:--E'£EzrEi.?.§*§.E%i'§§3§E;3;g széjziz '§*;=3;;":?:%::3§:.-2; E'~x§:'%'§"'E'i M/a:~».I1 . ;%<f;'§:'x€:;.3 5s:*§:a;:2'sa <;>:;:<:: §x,{}R§' ' R;'»:f> M;sm;%<}U'ND? ma E~~1§&N{},%L, Q.) h ' £:2::: *€: }~:;:e;;vE;m= V "'gT§3":<._si:§«%§ Ea-E. §rssa§s,.;-":'.,::$ 522132;. §1"€§§Z1;' {j2__,«'E§#3 *--§*%v2*1*;§::§:<%§«§4% E{.{)§,£=§§.~':,f'a.;?«35 ;»;(:{:~:3 :~"e<';>:;% 22:1 mgr: H.PE'.ET§'£€}E\iER ....§§':§fI§.§§>{'}?=€§}E§E'%'}"§% 'E€;?;j3 I%fi$&§Rmf?£Tn%0N:$EHLEQ:JxBERgu?ficLEs22eég227 <5? THE <x3N$?mifl%@m'{M?:fiEHa PRA?fi} T0 gxxy§aT?HE :3R3ERz3ATE::§9;a3;20@?PA$$Em>%¥1%fi§2w3RE$P0§{fifi§iA$ E3ET;§%3 ANXEXURE: WEI ANS EEYFC, ' " " ' ?}§$ 2¥RYF ?ETYflC%3 C0kfiN§iMCEE §é$3=fi§Efi1m:waE?' HEAR§KL?HE§B&YfNfi§CGURYMADETfiE§¥fiL§%fl§Ga_.__ 0RDER';'a' *«'. ~F in ihi$ Case {he pfi':'?§i'E,;:{}11'§:3}.'.V"§"ié1§F; Cfé':i;};..§{3ii1§'.. §f§.; <:;;;%3§sf:}%{2r2 €315 2-*ahidi?;}: GE ithé orsiez" 221*; Fusnsrxuri-:""Z;7;'%"z:>hi{«::<:i €39,-f'€}f§»;' ESQ? pa:-zsed %'::y {ha Lanai Tyibuzszii H..é:.h_ge3.§;wi}C'C.1,:p22::cy r§§._§?:z'{.s§ in mscpafié sf %;.%:<3 1;m:<:?': vbeezzjifigg'S5;:.?€<>;'«1'v{:i.§§ n'1:':;.2:s-Léringg 9 ?<l?:C,'i"€3'S£ zami 125$ <>'z1r1'i;as. 0%" 1fv'f.%2;>._E21 7%;3r:{i.x:;i'1V3.g<;: 'ff? 3;: H2122 I211 Eexiuk in favmzr Sf iha b _ _ ..;. ...%._ E 3"? reaspésrzrrkziét, V _
2. E-..».{'.'=ar.:_':.e{§.._«:;:€:.:,i.1::駧é'i Ear {ha p6%jt.i<}::e: <:~<::=:":tf:::'1c§s; that iihfi §4§'};.E'1{§. '§'§"i'E}¥.111'é%L§'.§T;;$_$;§'pé':SE'~;€€§ {ha arciésg' xa-*§%;ha:):;z'€ zzzking %2':?;0 {'i(}f3'E§§§§.€3I€.£i{§§}§':._ffT;{j §'I18.€1f3§'"§£§§.-":§ am :":;*;:;::>:'{§; it §E,i:'f.h€I" <:<}§2t:€z:{i€::i ?;E"_£:45;'i: 'theg §;§e;;2:;3:-r;~,§';::%§ 2:%:,t.«:}§'::€é§,f Efpislziisr <3? f;§'2{f §3<:%é;.§é'.£:m5%: in <f(}§%;¥:S§{}:'}
-- Wéiiét %j'.§*z§:: "-3?'<§fe:r;_§3<::':€§é3:}i. hag {EEE-"i{§{':' s~:i:;2;,§<i*:m<::z'2%: i>€::f:.>':*c %;'%"';::"< Ls.'-ma? W,'V§':"';3§3':_3::1:~:E6'5: {}?§g'{}2,-'2i§€;%? 292.<E§n%:§§n;g *é;'hz~3 §ffi3"ié-.';Z"%€1?};'" <.:2Ei" §.§';€'3' (1 3% 5 % 'g ,
-$33 9- :3: :"<:&:§<>r:r:§¢:1:.. it is §L1:"ih::r é:U"'§g%,1€'-d ihzii 'ihff saici évidericte Q? fhéi }C2{}'JV€"31" cf ;;»1'£':'.0:°z1€j; h(}§C§.€?Z' €sh<'3L:Er:i mg: hézws bt%<3:: ::2¢:_§:s:?':3I'««.¢:§f:%f:V<3 .E}.C€3{}'L3.§1i whéic': Cisnsicierérizg ihe ezpplicaiion 3:-if 4th-:é '*--._£§"ii'§_A r€$p<:»~I:':d::=nL E1: is f3;::"3;}1er" zzrgucé {hai nggtéate {)f'E"fi:f;':"'g§i{"€}{5€:°~f3{§'i.§'1gE§ has: 110?; bags isguéii :0 {he ;:>::*'£§{i0ne3r,
3. {I321 the :>*{h<::" hzzizd, 'i~r;:z1f:r:§:C% ' C:';>Lir:
}€}VEi'T§}Z"§1€'l'1.'§ Péeazdiir ;1p'p@zmmg f{}; ?'-»,VVI"V€ii§'pC%§7'}.Ci;{':3§Ti"i'S;"Ex: 21§:;:i :2? and. Eezxned zzdvecaaie a.ppé32mi:>.g'§Qr i'€:'$pG f§*dL€EEi I'Jf'G.3 ha*é}e"$<>13;ght if} _}L:.:5--;tif}: £1128 impugned ardei". Eli: i:«;L',2:'2*§:.1é2_.~::§._ ;¥;_é_.f:<--3§" yemand (3? tbs 6213:: by Cezgfura \%i1"§'{.j_'?§2:i*::f~i3r1 N<>.§4{%E3ff.980 di-S;@iC}S€C§ if {:=1r:'TA2:§jE 1§84E»', '::<}iic_s:s have '$38631 §s:;'a.:<-xi is: 317163 gczitionezr " {:sf;' €;;';*€§,A'ViZ'%.'Vi"",.5.§.LC3*F5.3fi;»'?:.... " The Eeséarned High <3{::1;.2*i; G{3w3:'nm@m :P'§.::2%<:€:2r '£121.34 p"r'<>é:'L:::e{§ éhgr :"e€<::«rés of "F:"ibun;'~:§ £62" p@§;:}§;£{E {:15 t?:is»;V'{3{};.::"'i. '§'h<: <:as;::= Q? '€'.E'1:3 3"? ;§"€E§§€}§'§d€E1'[ is ihai; .Ef:<: ::3,:?1:;: §€;.%:ci;1%t«..§3.§"?;}:§3 iami in {§L2€S?Z'§f}1'§. 3%: had fiészti E3{>r:':e E"€<3'.*-7 g§s::.if:~:.--€}§ <2<::;"::,1§2'sm:j_.: :°§gh'€.ss in *Z"<f§§p€'€;'.'éI <3'? éiizg». :<;a.ic§ izznd =~.f?%2<:_.~§;ma:§.«:§ T':"§ba2.222:§ G33 <:':{§:1s;§£%,<:3"2'§i,i<;>§2 af :zr,2:i::%;"i.e2E§; am ,:e':<:;}:"z:§. ha':~:Vrig..;%:?;1§; grzgzstizd <}<?€_:L§§32.m.::§z ':*ig;E":E$¢ ~v"'""""'3» ieziars $322: by the ia.:':dI<>rd 2z.s:§<§.:1_§g; him to pzsxjgg {hes rézniss. The sgaici 1¢3i.*{§?fE§ are :3.va»1i§.zfl:31<:= in the :'&*{":{>r::%.:;' TEE'? 3"-3 r{%sp::nd:-3:2? L225 21133:} §:>:a3m§zas:%r:§. 5: %5:é':':":<?$s:; is}; Z'i€:1I3"1€i' HamL:z23a%*i.'£.i5§z%§§;f>2:
F"22.k§ra;:2p21 Fviatfaidi. in his; c§ep<2s§ii<>n., %:.1%"z.e:< w§§n:3s:§_s:' bzzgé "::t1a:%;%':i K ihat ha E«:z2s:>w::: the p'*?;é:i«:3:r:é:r as: :a"2£:"~3<>"§}"::?, 3"-'?--' I'€3i~3p'€i:."1 tI§€§"1vi§,:". has furéhér 8'iat<3'{§ Ehai the 3?" r<:$'p9r::d_éf:'i Wa':_s :3._ z'v:é:':':ééf;%;j é:7; respect sf iihéa ianai in qL2i:s;ti<>;?;._2;'é';.Ci he"v=5asVp2:}i£1ri'g: E~.b;igs; <:r<£"' pzzddy and certain quezzgzifis {;f___gz3é;vs:r:'vV_;3;ram "t:i;>__t.h:* Ia:":d§<:>:"<:,E §e:>Wards rerzzft. Thamgh E':éu::~L-'as7r:rc;?' :#w€'§<:2:V':r:i':A:-_ec§. by the Eezainésii ;%ds;<:»ca:te appearing. fer "g:e:ti.t§V{:i--::€»:, nt:3€§r:§::'g v;c}:thwh:.'E<: has; 'mist: eEi~::§ic.d E33I}:.hc§5'ifra>:;$'-fipiaminaézgi-sriD {§{)pj§,»-' czsf the p<:vwc'r of £:%i;<}z'r:€'"§;.VV is é§jvéa§§_2éE3..§<é: in thé: rec(::rd. 'F21k§r:g £2/2:0 c<3n:~;iderg:§.i{)r;._ time a's;"ifs3§é:':e«i;<>éé;.,4<}.§ the p<:»x>v<«:r Sf a1;.z<>r;r3€jy G? the pf:§i"%;§{}1"1€:',, £115; 'E':°i.b:.._:m:4.;_v§ 'E22232; grarxteti c>c<:u.pa;1::3; zigghisz in
--.§e*$p:%r~::*E'.,=:2§{has £2133ii"'i::s___:f;u=::8é;i::3;<1 in §'ava'L:2" 05 {E153 3"? z{3s';p{>nder2t, Rife::..<:s:h<§I'%fi?i§5§"~€:§3€ maiefréaég rciv21i1e:.E31<;': 33 the rsiéxérds rsztati wiih é;'.he: =.T'car«§c§~:3:§:¢:Vé §*§az1":;:mag3;3a F;':'iki}T£'§3}3§E£ Em'-izrzzdé ciezarij; €:§Eab'§.%.__s--;'f:€::; ziizgfigt é;.3r:a': 3"'? mse:p<}:z€§:--:§:?; {E19 i.<:r2.:«;:::2E sf 331%: iamii E27: c:;;,2<is§t§<3n§-- it :3 aEs;<3 <f::Es:.a3" {$3222. igim: ;";s<':€§§'.'§::>:r"::*::" 22».;a::s; :rf:{>ié'§E€{§ zafésr 3, E rememci <35 i'hi?. ('.231':'5v:'E £23}; t.?:§&':s Czyazrz. 1 dc; no: find 2-my r:r1<:%:'%f;_in this: _p:;>.'iiEic:~"§2. _2%{?<%<}§cii:2g;;§§;', if is; d.f£:=:~:mi$s3€.<i. NC: (1{3S§E:§. % % km?