Karnataka High Court
Anil D Salvi, Area Manager, Jain ... vs Union Of India Rep By Its Secretary on 4 November, 2010
Author: B.S.Patil
Bench: B.S.Patil
W.§}'fi?'2'}§.:'2{} E ("E WE-333.{é?Z53*i7%«?.'}§?};'E (P. §N?HEaKHéC§URT0FKA%mmmxa{ma1fiT8EN¢§A§_ Dagfiwafi ;
§fiTEBE?§S?HE{Mfi%BAY{H?NGVEM8E§;2§fi§_ 3 aagagg THE§fiE¢BmaM§J§S3cE:a$?A§;V; :
%R?3%mé?2§$!2§E$@xfiE 'A ;
ui?3§g&@?295zx@?29@ 23§a{$&@4x3w@ « BET§7a.--"EEZ.N:
Mr: zigfzéi D: Saki, Age: 43 jgeamg _ ' zirea Ixfianagep, 3: h . * » .
Jain Errigaitéarz ST§;sié;«:3"zi%:$1--:_§V,{:d.,. " " Qjgsxlymzxegsgg %'L"% Rameshwari €."30§=::s:"£3:~',= V' 'f 2, % " Jamkhaméé, $5*:s::'~Ba.g2;E§<::}VtV..
' V' I " ,..P'e%:§*::££r::er .. ~ V - éfiammerzi _ {B5,-7 S§--:§x§la$a_::a§%aE3§f;_ ;_;1&3 Eéasakaréfi _:i'~:dx-a} ' A' :*,$§%§g%§a?i@é?2é:§ E3;::.:an §.:':dé;%, " Eéfififig Etg SE'€f€§af'}=°, é » €;Zv{:§€':*:s':;*r:a§":é sf imfiéafi " . i§;:§'$:§'%'m€*:EE {}§§E"1€§2€i;
_ % '"B€f§ar'ims:z°:'z :3?' §¥.;"2<:{§ :«;::2::% ifiivié f:%:2pp§é.s:§;3 T §@E%";'§' ("fin
3.
'é£'.§*.€é?2<}5f2{}i €) cfw W§)'>;. f>?Ll€?{>«2{}9.:' E G. The Siam sf Karnataiqaf Rapid' by im Secreiafy, Eapariment af Fsad 8:, Ch-»*:7.1; S'u§p}%:3:EL Z%£.SfiBuéEdir:g, Bangaierewfi E, Sri' Rangappa Krighieappa. ?a.t;i.E3. Ageé abaut 36 years, 5360: Agri£u§":ur'€$ -
R/:3 Q-am, Tq: jamkhanéiy ' Bzisiz Bagaiket EN W'?.N0.6?'29éf2§EG Unian cf Erzdiaa Reptfi, b}-:%__Vi':$;=S€'::;;it§::a;r'}{,'* Cv@<:$r:";£*::e:*1iTAs::§5.Endéég §€§8.E'E;?'ZifE€I."-ii e§VE:@.;:';éa;;~ _ ._ ~ E€par'§::":1--3:n§. <3? §?Q:a:§ ' ~:3.:"1d__ €3.§.}a.i§ S'i.,1§i}pEi€S5 Mew' §e3Eh:";~__ * V V H = "§'h.& SE-afiie Gf'E{ag:::a?:a.i<fia, R€pi::.:§ :::;;»~ itg S=€'{."I.v"E3§ 3§f";'f»,-"Ty V °§f'§;ep:a€§:*'§:'<§r:£t" {sf F035; & Qii.-ii" Szégmiées, S».&:;§:3angV,"*B_angg.2ag~e--@E n "Famm aim 3. IEE a§§<:;', Ag£_%5 }:'fE§;:"t3 ;. '@923: Agriauiizzrefi Rffa %i}a1:i, '??.:;*;: L§am':<;%:ar:&*£3
- 3.3§=Sf;: §§g§:E§<:§€ ,}P;%é::g:3'§:ééé';r:?§s *' §€$§<>:':€E€::"§8 @5232:
EN [Wt EN W. 1;
Vvi E*.6'?295:'2(} 1 (3 :::"w Vz:fI}S.{373?}{3~3'}9fi {L ',,..,f PgN0,§?2§?" -ZZQEG Unien cf Enfiia, Repté. by K5 S€C§'€TZ3'£°:€'., GGver'n.m.er:§ 0? Efiéiéi, Departmani Sf India 3€*pa§'?::'f1€?Z'1;?: sf Faad and Cizgfi Sup;:'§.i»@g, Nsw Beihi.
'flee Siam af' Karnaiakaf R23§t&. by its; SeC:'<3i8;:"y,., Dsparimfini Gf Faad 85 Eiivéi S'%3{p§3Eie$; ?»;E.S.B:,:iEdi:2g5 Bar:ga1G.§";€~0§.,-'"' . Yamarzappa, SEQ 3:'v'1a§Eapp_a*;§*~ie.::;<;i,:;g Age: 64 yfiars, Qczz: Ag:%.C.:}_it;;r'5:§ "
Egg Sa_r:::é, Tq:_Ja;r::.E<:ha._§1di, X B2183: .Baga.'EEm¥*_L _ _ ?»N@'6'?2%9$ 2"'2;;GE E'-'1;;._ , EEr:ion:?efEn1G'i£s§_ _ Rep*:d. 'E3j;x' its .3£ecg;:c%;a:;r;'%'.T._*2 ' Qmie:m:<:;;e::%: 0f'.hj';:Ei.;ag_ " "
Be§8.:°§méf;i1:_Gf£m£i_£a; "
Qe§a_:=*:m€n'?ii"<;§ F':;.:33d a§'::d.'C§véE. Seupgsééaa, ?'§€'w-3§}$E§";éP 'V '".'{'§:;_e "'S:3f: é §f"~E:iarz:ataE<;8;, S€?€f'€§af§f'§ E"}€'p*_a:f€'§:3.§€--r3: =»:§§§TF"Gaé; & iii»-*§'£ ?§':},§3§§§€S, E';-»'i$"§3u%.?;d;§3i:§,.5Ba;:':gza£e::;r:~:«~QE D S%:£a$};ap§%:3.& S.'3i"3_?-'appa Hagar, Vxfiige: 6?5.j;f:>:a:"3;§ 86:3: :'%.gr£c§.fl.i:'u2*€, _ V' ifR5A;'a---fianés Tag: Ja';:r:§;§g2::1é§., j '§§$.%::_AE%:ag«;a§E§{3:, Re-Spfinfiezits.
R%'3S§=*fiEE{§€Z'§E§3 '§§§.'§'s-
EV P;{3'?2'§f¥:'2{3 E {4} :;:;"w "¢'JE}s.fa?Z§}ef§~2'%}f 1 (E, ii?" W.P.N3,6?299?2G3G Ev {NJ} UBEGH sf India, Rapid' my its Secretary", ifimsernment sf £:1d1?a, fieparzmem 0% indéa, Depazétmgni :35 Fafifi am? Cm': S%,§pp§i:{'3'S§ Néw "Ssihi.
"f'§*1e?: Siam af Kamaxtaka, ; Regtéu by its Secreta.ry_,, Bepaytmeni sf Faofi $3 Civii Ss.:pp%ie79.:, §\fi.S¢B:;zi£di:'1g, B9.nga§az"&~«G§;' _ Age: 35 }?€a3:"s§ Gaza: Ag.:'ic~uku_«§"e,_ V' R/Q Gané, 'Tag: ;§amE«:E1a?i':§£, . ' Bisit: Bagaikai. '- _ Gimappa, S/G Parighappa E'éfafi14:x}::':*;._:;*:v3;;*:.i, . " fiéspcnéanis <33; gm: ?'§--.E.§€i'L§.V{}€§2<,i§13;'£5':V§f§:l ,§"§C§_§'P"§%§§'--.§{~2 aad Sal. isaeyasgam. ';3;;::'i.ij§1.é§'--§§fE:'%3 in 31% 1:236 pfitiiieszésg 'i'.§'f:eseV.'x?€'2*§§ Paiitéarga .aré" flied '£J;.E.'1fi€? Arizicies 1226 ané 8.5 Ehifiég €j::>n$1:§'f{i;:E--§§;:: ___z3f Enfiia prajgérig if} quagéz $216 E;x*-'é¢':l:§::§<:z°:'~-1E'3":j+:fia*€é:Ei.:*:g$ in ,§}{'?6?§{}ST,3@ is «<§3;'2€§@@ {:53 {E363 §}.€'- es? I':';r:§:f 3i?§§?§C?..%:2Z7%f"€;§}'fi,_§8_ga§§{{)'{3 Vida ;%:'me:x:u§'e--G at-{:3 <.__r%'::§szE::§6 nfh€S€~'p$§i{€£vfi$1' earning; an E9: <:>:*dez°$ ibis 232.8 {E322}? ihe §<3§E@%_w%24:;;33;':' $322:
'»'v'fl§"''.¥§?Z'}5EZ{}§ {} \§"i3s3;.€}?Z?}€>«3§}{}f§ {.73.
wazram sf arrest The peiiiismer Eias bean eniayged cm baié, Ei: £3 at 3115.3 gtage 2&3: the petitigner has appmached thég Sour: Sseking {:2 q'L,1:a$E': the €X€C12'[i€§fZ pm<:€e&iz:gs. 7?' Bath thé parltéés basis 50%! rsached séfiiemerri 5:16 tarms aef which are stated b€§9?5~V':?:§L{~§§~..¢ei;:*iA iihéi éeained Cauxésfii far bath {he parVi.§€$:--§:1 j%?:T§ §?i5:$€7':€:'<":.§ '=«:;fA their pariiea and am mquestimg %:f:éifs__Cm;i*:,_ ii; §iS;f3$I'¥'S.'s§Cv.¢f:}{Vff' fijiesée writ §€ii¥:i01r"1$ in $316 fafimvirzg terms: '-, {i} That thfs ieakage p<:€ri':;§' Eaid in the E8;F§.dS.~{:"§*€§T%é";:f§'¢:5:ff'£if'fi1t§E*§?;;'f%'éS":3'~€33£d€E'l"{S herein slnafi be E.:<ec'u':i2:e E1%'2g1'.neer, D5p8;1*'§:é;_:':'%:: 9'§=EQ§V1';?éA@r: Eifigééiaxifi Jaméihandéy in tha prfigfiince %:>f e.:A§m§3.air:a§2ts~farmer$ and a£.S<3 §§:'%5?r€§A%"é: 361:3 "§é§i§T2-<e...z*.s-{V "é:.h5: petitiaasrs {ii} T¢I¥1:eV * " f:';§§z.@<:iéen s§":.a_'iE Eaéifi giace :>'~;»'é§h:?§:: 5&5 é:,§aj§_;=*'S §'F®ff§ §E'E:§€ ésfgzs: af Y€?3€*f.pi :3? a egg' :3? this erfier 5;; "i:§%:é,AS4s€; E§<:€m§:i:r'e §f'E§iE"i€€E'} §€§&'§'§E°§?i'<Ei'E'§'€ cf V ~.1"§..?:_23GE" EZ"'E"§§gaf,§QT:"§.§ -<§a3i:":E»<;E".:3;né.i. fiagia E}«:eC:,:.?.i'<se E:i:_.g.§:1e€:1 §€_'§é"s:§"E§'Z':§f.'i_'"§€ 0? "F2§i:":£::§" §:*:*i§g:2s:;,%{§:":, a§;'"1Iz'.§"ig§<I;§'§z;":E.E'?.4:'§il§.;§ iaézaiifi. .:"$::<§§°€§ '§?TE.€E $1» W.I'.{§?2')5f2{}E {,3 cj="w 'J~5§T3s.{>>?'2@?(>-3'.}*)f E i}._ 18 {vi} E'mm the? ciate 3? Suppéy ef the materiais and the pajjimergi Gf amauni, 21 E-3;'&fE'?'aE'§€}=' C}? 234; jgsars i§;S~ given 32$ {E26 <:0mpEai.naz'1i:S~fa.rm€r$ ané if 8;E'§}--' Eeakaga is fauzlé in {hex pip€$ at the '' qégesfian gr eat any Gthar peirzig :12: tbs then the peatiéégnez" ska}? ati:€z1fi §e§V é;Ef:<:.vSa_m*:: same manna' as &1're€t€€i af§0v:3 ".:}_'y:'i.$i-%E:f:g"':ZEfi¢~ of {£26 friize Campiainantg' 3ié?§§fi thé Asst. Exscméve Erzgimasr, Mégrzor Errigaitiisfi, J amkh '_ {vii} E: WEE} he fine' I'€SQ€3:{§Sj€.ié';~'i',§iEL§:5V "i~h'Q..i'f§s>:--$p®r1逧1§-- farmara is gsai: %t«§::é-- leakage..~;b::3'i«r2A€:s?.i_:*€:f;33;i'rs&'
8. This p?Qp:--";§é:§ V315;"zag2":=;é{:§._§a:é*:2;;re€2': the parties is just and reasenabise Ha:-i_i§i§V §ég»_;aé'.d "ét.;:%"_;':§':;@ rzaéazrs sf éérectiezz issuad '§}»:._§E':€ S.f;.:it§§:e '~»£T9§:2,1*;:§s;.31;a:2_a.:é.§ in the Eighz; 5%" Egha énabééiig?
pie'-gagiséii {§t1;e«g3€fé§:::i{;:f:e:° Ea s::@'§§';§§3: %;a?étE'1 the Saw; direséiam I }--fié.S?'§'a.%:g'ié«'V:;;;§?;§;:%?{%§:°§a'¥;e w éé$§8Se «sf '$522636 u-fit yeiétiefig §_;§g2;;1;::g ii} the pariésg ta aéhsye 33:: "aha <;€;:2§éi.£9ns;. '"§'%:e§: ;%:;s%':° E:x:e¢':,;:%:%v€ Engénesr, {:25 §zr'§'%':":5:2§' §:°:':%ga;:§.<;:§"::§ &a':z{:«=:'%:;::"':z<i;2i, €Z§§§"€{3§;:'"3'{§ Ea:
' §\%=-me"
n '3§5?2.2¢ $5.}-3.{}?2?}§f2(} 1 £3 s:::'w '%¥E':§.{>?2¥§€%-2{~§')f E 41}, czamgsigg' with the ciirsciiezzs :"eg3..rd%;:1g ééé'-:mi.fi{:a*{:"ez:3 0:1'-°~.___the éeakage peints enguring the <:0~0§e;"a':ii@n af ether §a§'jr:§E:?}g--.j%*:4 whage Earzds the Eeakags Qzymts ceuici be nrgiiceéa Q, Ths petiiifina" ghaié pay 8, $;'L€::fi'"'g3fI f2.£§,.Q"€}jg¥ remunéraiéen is ihfi Fsgst, Execzztéya Eng;1é_z:{€--r3r, Béggaftrfzsyi-i'cf V' Eviingz Erfégatienfi $am§<:i'.:.a.néi, far C'2zz.f§*'}?i:zg Qizfi d5§:;fe§';*L§;i:s 3S afcremémtiazzedfl 'E'%1€ _ps:'§i%'.§Qn§>':*'miSA f§::zf\§'§;§:'€ed iéyiihdyaw the amgunt 9:' Rg.2;3.<30@/A» '3:§e';§'G$§%e<--i. 2figfgééze 'Ehe Stats Qemmissien in r@s§re7cé'g.<_3_%' aaéih a3f~f:'E:e"'V§";,¥;rz%a~s%;%s.; EC. 'E'h€ : 'Ef;;i::§*in§r§§,VVV'éfiepartmem :3? Mains? Erzégaiéarz, Ja§3:isE<:Q1.;a.::d.% % C8_3"§"'}-' 92.3: the i:1s_p$<:':i0n as éirecteé h@r€V§:2*'«abva:r:¢;._ sf thig arfiefz 32.13%? $8 sen: Ea %E:f¢..g:%sst» 7E.;%§;5;::;::';a:e E%:gi§_§¢:*, Bspariyzzezzi Sf Méfiar Errégaiégn; sjaf§:.k%t2a5mji} '§~z:§1?_E<aié'--~.:é:':=;f@:"zf::a':ie:r: ami €fi§7Z'T.fi§i3f{E*Ci33. A 99:33? 8%"
: ._%:%::T3 s3%::§é;€'._§?:a§§~v.,_;:.§§{;' %€ hazzdfiéi @362" :8 '£315 S-evsarnmeni
7.P":*<:':v:£:;§€:" ésaéze 8V§';~a_§Ej'..--§@?waré fzhe Sfiflifi {5} {£16 £333?" Exscaiézfs _ E,j:':"}«::;g:"z:§e:y §:3§£;3*'i.:*::$z':?;. {sf f%;E.:§:';<::" Ezrigaaiésm g§a.mk.ha:f:::§, % : 3: , aarééfiz as: L i§:S§€"i§C§§{}§E 3, £3' "
4.»;
3..
Vi W.1}.€§?2€1'§i'2€)E {E cfw ¥%"'E:'$.€%?2§}6~Z?}'1E5I (1 Ed EL The Execzztion Pezitierz N03. 31'? 'ii; 43 are «:ii3p~z3-sad ef in {he éighi es? the ahmfe Qréer. A cap}: Gf t.E.':.i$ order 3h&EE he S€?}'€ Eta {he Eistzécz C0n.sumer Ferum; Ba_ga.iI«:ai. E2» @2533 wré'"§ p€'[§§§.€3E'1S gm accaréizxgijg §iS1;f;.s}.:$;-:aii'_ - Gsvernment Piaader is pfiymitted :0 53:3 I':/Esme §{.é_;_.3g§'s3.:éé;1'2";:;.'2..<:Tb€"' '*3-»'ét.§"::E:1 ':§.1z"€e '£21-'€3é3'}€S iii 83} $1935: {:&S€S& mks »