Karnataka High Court
Neelawwa Mahadevappa Patil vs Shri Shridhar Pandappa Sori, on 11 June, 2012
Author: V.Jagannathan
Bench: V.Jagannathan
l'»€a%%;&§:§€2*a§3';:a
Fflgzg V
' ":53; E'? .z%<"§:r::;>{:§.§€z:;:
EEE' "§"§=iE HEQE £§¥§T 3%' K§iRZ¥§§:'§"&§{§§
§EES?§i'f' f3§E€€E£ EAT E}§§aRi¥'§§.§
ir§'x'§EjE'} 'TEES mg m §}5'>\f{ {>9 3£UE'\2fE£_..2_{§'?.§' j;
gayoag '
THE %I$i'<}"ELE §¥§Ré5§§S'§§§€E'.§if;;j§"§§§;%§:I€$'i?'.§i$E§2;'
EEFA Clwg RE0é?§$ i2i¢r:>*'{.:s.;9. ;
C W; EEFA §%e.2V;§;§§V§ 2339 xvii:
WW
321% 53383 :€a¢?§$.z_2{3{éA§%"'
§E?WE€§: A_ _W »
g, E€eiaw€§;a ..;p;;n;g;;*
*iC)e3._{:i"'~:é--§Q€:_:3eE:e:;2§d <2,/*a*;"'§<:,
N)
3 ?v§%;s--Z%:--a:2{E--e:+.22§3§§":é"?"é:{%E§
: '2€j'vV7:'f€.,a':7:'§; . *.f:1;%:g:':Ee:1§,
3, ;"Sa:é?:._§:::sh E3'a:§,
figs Z"'§_En>«'f':'?€§,1"Sg.V{}éiT?'€ : gtuéfifié,
'W .¢
"§'8.E'2,:§<: §%ia:r:::"E:.;:g§
i'3*£J%Za'I""§€}Z'5{§
«mcmmtg%.x
E. Shré Sizrédhgr §;'>§EfEEi§3§}€£ Sari,
éagfi : Efiajiyr, <iT}<:<:% : iiéagsimsggf
§f<:s,I'2§;a:r2?:;s"1:2 peééfs
3
EI3is£z*é=:'{ Beigazérn.
M:
The §'f§&:'§a§€53€,
Béégé; piaga Coéésge §%:;a<§? §.§?§g.§_LQE,E1. f_ V!
V*w *MR€SP8fi§€%?S
(85; 8:3 8 Ka§:a§<ma:h3
{E,E~;fixaedj ,=. A" =' "-- *
"§'%:r;sg EV§E";3:,{';:*cs':'; is-T.§éié;>%'€§'i;r:_:T§éfV.a:f§i€:" 5%} Rzzée
L153 sf SEES; agai.2::3': award dated
18j§2§2{}{}%_..p'a_f§;:.e::§L£3; §'éC,€8§f{}j§;GGé 9:: 13:6
féie af §;'§';'é:::§::.e;«*, a5':/E "1.C:i'v--§"fl Beégaum argé
E'{E~A§§E, "B_éEg:;:3':':1§ pafriizs aiiaixvézzg
{E36 tiaém g3.€§;;;: :2 ';?A;i}'if'Vv{'TG'f'§'}_:;'}€E"§'SzSf{iQ1"1 and seeking;
5 33 E: 3: :3 <1" i-':4 ':4 fléif :::: £i%*i:_i% :1} 5:3 3-; i :15: E
§§§%?§T§g.§:6§5§;@§%'
V
II'???
V.-W3}
M
W
A @
§g::f:";=.::':@.,:' r«:§':::% E.:3.w i:'%§§é<%ez:g E"; §*}<.a}f:€.§':s§
V
szizszg _< sssaé éiimgs, "éaaéfi Eézgzbié,
' ..,%??E;;1Lg%E"€'§'
Bajaj fiiianz iéezzeiai §ns':;§8;:_::«:*..€ 2:53;
J
Psi' E}:
2. §'»3€éeE21xar2é;a fifiafiaaieixagsga ?ai:%§;
;5':g€<§ aiseéaé
2; Jag2::<7iiSE: I\4§aE":a{§e:/':%g:;;3ak Eiaféi
;%§€{E aisazgé: 26 ':"€::':::*ss,
Cm
S3f}%§§":8Sh §«a'§al?:a{%e*;ag3pa
Age Eibfihii E8 '£6333, V ' '
~42 §{u.maz'§ :S5:1a:3<%a Ea/iaEé'au{i$éza;§'::3.
Agé abeut 2%? 'f€a:"g, V -- W
U";
'?§§;2;%wx:a; §{§r:§;::::*g_::>:L:._<§é,.;
aiéeut €38 %"§--%a:?!s3 "
535:': are €€'3.§§_l%E3i§;G§.§<:.£i§:3,1%E§;'£é.,T§i§Ei§<: Ramdurg;
Qésiri§€~.,VB§'T§;g.;3{2,::::. "
6; Sriéiyz "§¥7'»s{.;:f; 223;} VE?7>":::*%__
z i§LZE"§§
.§?'.EZ:§P§3:T?§§:'?;?€"E'S
;'i?'E.10é%}_: _ , y 3
3:25. *' ; ;.§§;3;':2§}éT%§ §3.SE3%'E5. in §'=*'E*'
5*; * éihe §:s'T§a>:::::i%$?, §":£A€'?~E
'EEE ;%s:§:§§';§}isiri€: '\§z;:;;;:;s>} g:2%;a:"<ié::z.J<>: &
_ .;f:s:,:ef::j§e::Vé2:'{é@:2 £2? P;:§';'§§§:4?£}§}C%;'» énésregz é'€?E>
Cragg gégjeséésn gzzéi apgeaé {:€3ri1i::g 8?":
far a.é:::és;s§{::*; Ems (ia}7, $313 C9225: €:'ié:=§év6:*e:§"----.%:E1e
9? 'gigs
faiiawéng:
§§§§E§§E§"E°'
E318 amssaé azrzaé CFQSS @':3'~§ec€=_:'ie:,>.::: a»:*é;~?=;éé iii?'
SE16 anaié
{E36 égamé jLé%:i§.m€r:'{v. T§i§1A:5V.:».4_.?.%!§:3~.iT;'§',
Beiggzma. E'E:€ ézzgurance cs§"::a';;,§--3;;r:§,* Ezgs 633236. in
Queaééan {he §ia'a§§i%:;/"«--.;:?:z_: 5:25;':
f «M
K ;>
$3.,
'*7
('M
£3"
{T3
('*3
W
$3
:3
S33
33'
(''''"i'
m
the crass @§:?}.3CE%Gf§,""";'~SJ'gs':J
geeking {?1'E§f'.:Véz,;f1€$;i§;€§7}v€E3':€,'G.f_V{?GEf§:'§§"?%E'f1 3.5;'?/Viara
?..§F;£' "'é?§é?;§fE35;§1'£§ éefgrs iihe
'}f:%§3z:z:§é;_E *é.2.i_a;:'»:, sf 'ihfi E8? Céaimani
:r:a:r::*:a§;.«-V' 3;/E«:%b'z:a§Ee:r3§g>§;+2" wéséée ?:i:3::eE§é:':g :33: a
an
:::>?"'
$33
13
W
£113
r°t>
€22
W M
We
<23
L5
r"""r
fifziéféiéig :::1<;E<31:*:%jgs:tEE {E35 :§§s:'E;:5>:" éjsrgizéssrzéed;
q2§,;.::é: I'é§&§':a:§€'s-';i§'§'23. was ':a§:€:3 Ea
:5@:' 'i?€a§'§'§E%3?E'§ 9%; ?€a_::23::§:.:§*g aflé': §éL:%>E§ azécé
wwg '
mm
("£31
E25 er; 5%, {E2}; haasfi, %;:3j§;::*§: €225; 2:§ff.2i}i"':5y 3%
="T:~
%E'i%8§£§§'
EEK: :{=:3€€:::'é ?:'€3'=J€8§S "£13: 3336
%,é;:3.$ §E{}"éi~~' iéfiiixézzg
'E
»C0§§;::§ai:"':€ was §s;s<;§g€<:. 153},/' ans EX/Eaéagpa as 93:
axbagé Baséizgg §--?'§§
§::§::c?za1":g>::"::a iv}
§E;:>{.P;5 Elifld éhze CE::;2:ge:% siéset E:a§.?.§, ?§§f":"€"'~§T,::§'£3:i §1FT:8';':f:'LE:?;
$e:3gs:Fh?:V 'f¥:_>:* {E36 s:€::::33€:':s;22'{é<>:::_'."T. 'Ti*ze
&§EC?V\§€3'§. ihs Ciaérn §§:<e:i%é<;'%:'«--§?;r::i axa-"§,rV§T€v%§'Q::'v$_jVu§é :32?
%33§:;;:s::}<}[:~ Wm: izzéiérssi pg'; «--Z'f§:$ }Ea%:%i%E}*
was gag am €326 é::sus:éi:_1£t': zzfhéch 3:3 331.6
3;:3p€§§az":'%; €21 ihfff appvegm-%:'a=i'§--r\€»L.
'-€é;.:§2s<:i Cmgzggsi £3: '£7343
322$ 58}: ihe
<?§3i?I3a?i.'§f*3._&i%5'3éS:fé'.._§e:%.;..s6<% E326 mgeyeig :3? €ih§S
sags,
§€5.:":':€::§ CC%E},?:S€§ 52:}? '§§§$é;§;E'§,§E,C€'
'E
rm
3?»
1:3
mm
\-
2»
we
£'a€C6««s3;$$_~;iE':<§*L*':;3$€3§ :'§<Ei:":;§; '$3225? :32<:2:@:"::2;€
BMW"
W"
F"
(T31
$13
6"}
("D
$33
£23
flu
W4"
$123"
("Z3
M
Y""*'§*'*g
CE
W
(""0
SK)
gm
$3»?
31??
(X2
<"'""I*
CW0»
'E
MW
.23
Ca'?
'€ "Z
M a
919
L33
-1
5123
«Wk
23::
£2'
iii
<""'"?"
!~<
CW
("'25
W":
€327
CL"
W1'
M
F235
Cit?
~"'"'¢
L13"
333
<" i"
J
.¢'(//_,(»<«'"'
afi'
a Y
.E§:€ 2;€Z':iCE2>, 993.3 {f:?"i\'€E} 335:2 @236 :":fIa;*1a::€€s:?: fiamamig
Sscenzéifg 31": is :/;:a§?;:,:s=é téizzczé c'§:3C::.:I:'-:--i:_%'::~%i_s.
praéucezvi $3}; $23 '§:2:~;;::"g:::::?3 {TQEEEEEYE}/'.-:__8$§{§.V:"~..::f::¥"3_._V
.532
ezséészzse gséaceé é: '2A;{}:.;§{3£ 39" :0 s.§i'*5;?:'2;r--5.:'E?:*;éz%et
Casé of 'zhé Ciaimarrgs is: ?:7_":;;§i".}:f'Li'}
' 1
§€f€'f:3§E€'.€? is ;?:<;,??2 %:V§'§; Si.3;§E.§:;:§§€€%;"§§v"A~.E;18,i;..; £1:
Ci}§ZSC§GéE3£ Egifsd igéa "f:Eéf'a.f: figs his '$201136
azid. {hag E36 27:r§_f§ gviéeésas "file
éeciar {hex éhe
€§8iC'€'&$€:'H€f§"Vi'<x"{%:§::"%§V:§QV4.;$3'? 1% Es: Eiegcs
gabmiéfiaafi 23:36}? £3 fame 532$
fziéeé 2%.? ::§3;§::$ 3"? guézgésséefi maés is
3:%18f:4;:'£§,"':V€:*",'-A.%i§®CE§§E'§£;3":€ ééggzzsii §:G€§G? ax':
%:E:3£; ins éfijfiféé §'a:"§&§"T:.!%§&":'.'if§}}:§38.
i»:a2f_g:.::é';i €:;..§f: 'gigs '§:é§:n.g;a":3.E staaéfi :33: :é;3::n::: géiaaasafi
.'_.':E;.é"€?£a§::': ;::2€'§%'Eé{}E'E szmé ths: Eéaéééééifsg' C:>L:§£§
226?: ':aa:@ éigssrs <3: i§':SLiE"3J§Z§€3£' €:z:::r:;;a:2§,:
ml
3, @333 s'a2§;g::s3?i 2:§@§€§a§é $'i;§3:§:i3$é0r:$
rsiéazzse 3923a'/52:3 'EEE8 §E".':'iFiQ€f§. r:<>i,m3€E f¥f;;:f',_fE:_€
1
<79
'
,.,. .
agpeééazéi §2':sL:::'3:5:--::ié% <?{;>:":g;:;&:3;z' :31: 'sh CE
€s3>p«::>:"':$::i in 251% §€e.¥ l§§?,mESQ?""'S----§'_=?:;';:§€}E*s'£i
'?'9? 31315 aéga Eh? {§§if§f?§" ?}:ags'~%:é '{Zé.é_s".{:01j::f":--..§:%.T_'
§
ME?';% E'%§<>.128:2§§2€)i3'§n A-fig'-ass"-galh§::'§':§.:;;V:+:_,gH . £h€
.a
laarfieé <tw:;:.3.§3s€§ SG3.,i*3*§'3? fa: $32.6 2.1 "}€.&§wf§:§€d:5§}'%;' {E23
§fES1;E§E£'§;:(,?€j' s:@:m:>&?:%.'
6, i"E;fe.~.';€'8.2"::§:£§ _,::_:é?2::;S;'{§'_Ej~_§§:*'=' €226 cégimanzs
A:i¥I%":'a':%V*ge s%L2§€": pigcéd 3:1
f€f:Q3i'd V'e;s3§li;§:*23 :§:*a=:""7§':*§.é3 ?T::..;; 5;_E; gay :0 eséabéisiz '$3289: $335
3€c%§:€r:ii :§s.;'z:§z:€:" Cé:}{i?,EffE{§,€{% €336
.__i:: %:E9§;eé.«-:<--«iiéflaézzz g3::=§:$:§@:s:> T325 é;:s';2_§a.:2€e
aégés: E%¢§§1j1§':f€{§ {he w:é':"é€::
s'é:$.A?$:z:€%z"::"':f'I§";A3:.: {he xi;/x?«;s a géfiééaiz :*é{§a€~§ 9?
.': é:$ 'ii: §::rs:s':§a:":5 fiagaré f:~;>:I:: €325
3323: §€:::s:::§a:2a:'::a,, r€§@:§§ Fifi
V *._ "E'°€§?{}f"*C5 ;e2,E§ Etzavé ;i:2:'*::;:%.m:s§ azzé Efzsgss
}§s§§:§£;§4:§%i"§v:::_§": ;":2.s$ §§£§£ifi§"E§a, is €:i:%%:E':'€§'3{"§ %:}:a2: was
éG€:;:§5:2:;<; Ezaxrs ago: beg/3:': ségasxa/'3: {Q bs eééihgr {age
was 5:' '§2:§:>§:§€a::a=3::E 5:39. WSW; is £36
'iiéis i:3s;:;:'2.az:1€:€ has {i6§a3e:=::"§§__
eifédieizce Eézaé; 32:3 €§;«::s{:u::':'3e:2V%;s 8.§f§ §:*:::a.:E'::'C's3.§i_'v,'b::< Ezégz
':0 §'%:o:/*2: '£313: {Em ::i€<:é:%a£=s::%.g§; "».:i€f§§'i?.
~o::2,
:::£3t01*::'§:<%§€ rgrzd {he
f:QIf:§8;?£'i}/' hag :29: ifsefi game
éi$<:§e;:a:.::::;7§:3~:<3 an? giaceci by
tbs: €:I2s;mar::£3a s0 :35 3:315
a»:<:ide:1%, 73}; {$16
fj€%C€aS€?{E &a_3;'4:E:V'~:/;:'§'.§§a§'1?a{:§€v3;§§a 8.3% in
M-cg'
HM
e3§is;?"':§,:1=:. .%i§*?v,€' -2:5§a2: ii: 33% 17:: ':he
>4;
C@EZ"}j3§E:"i§';1'i% §S* 'aha Eeafnsfi CGEZEESSE zsislfia
SE3 SE3? 6.}? $323 §*€§;w;::":€é 2&1}
?;;$4§§.{§:4A.'§§§§?E§fi;§€§?£ ;fi§8f?'"'$§§§§§Q?'£ "E'?$§"i:spe§*'€:'
Saéaéf Vééséigiag :?:;':§% $3 rzaéi sgzzgéaé $9
p ..Wx
»w
M)
E'. the Eéghéi Sf 'aha .;::.f0:r€sa:%:i Canierifégzzg
gem: §'e:':w%.?<§, :*».7E*2.€'{i"2€:" 33%? §:2$:::i*a:':é:<=:
zrsazis ::>a;:§. €9.88 £02" SE28 a§j;€aE_--':'é§$4€§' 1
afiéi Vsbezber She ::>':a§m,a:2Es aégg :'r:a,:'*§'é"'<>"'23':.8f=:i:E:ss3V "
fa? C<3E"f:§§€§ES8;7{§C:£ii bfswlngg €i:2E1_;9;:::€25i»._"~5;'§€V
ggzieszéeyzg 'is be £i33E$W€E'€C§+'
8. E38 €33" as r':§f:€s §'3;9:§}§E.f§'i}f. '€}f *z%:eV:"::'i:éz3_ra::<*:&
«CG§'i'fl§&':'§,f;' '$3 {':é':I33C$§"E"1€é:§;.'_§h€5f"§'éé%E"I'i§v5: 'i7V{§*:i;Fw§EE363 E9: the
'§Z1Si3i§"8.f{:{7%Zi'7' €€;::s*;.§:é2::};a:g;;;.g{§,E*:iéy;r;§}f' 3:1 ihs Céaim
maée ihai {E28
'Gris main/39:5 saszzgh':
ii} "Se §:,z: _:"s:é2"aa93;§?<§;. 13jg»_j "*:,§ig: céaémamig' "§g;a:;gE: fizé
Eeafizeéi {"{Z§i'i.,§3S€§ {G §=:%v€:'a_;i éaaumsaés 33:2
;a«2..:/':<:3.._%?iE:s sf i%=$"§:J,E 33$ 335.2 923 ziwééi
%§;*:5"v-.;<f§i€::{: 5:f:V":"s1z22'W$ E36 Eaaé rm': §%s§12%:§§;
ei:£*%€:l?" £32' 2326 €§"28,§"§€ siéésst Eiieé <32" :25}
Cb
w
m
(T)
gfiaateai :3 :~s%;,€:2%.?' $37333: {E16 §$€3€E3$€§ aérgg
"§.;%';;_fé.%:.E :"§::§;£:r§§§ 'E°'h§ €1%§i§'§? fleas ef
R2, §3:»::.§~ET; é3$::{>c§, 'ix; :i@a:'ia3r 3: Eamaéurg
aizé. §j::3<:.§%?;:,2 is {he €33.88 82253: 9;' {he SE:1§:i§é{:?.g;:g3a
E<:23pié22.é , Eéasbézfl E.,V<;><2'T:<:é;%/"ggg 33: 333636 {§ai?tiTLE§f:'i%%';f§E€EE;1§;'
was izhe {',Ei'z;iS€ ':0 '%;;:»:E_<€ 32 xxieszznmihal: .'i{Eé€~
_é€é§as€d "
zafggs rm: ::23é<:€:Q :13: Razzéaciurg E:'«i}$p'é'éa--'§ "§1?'€a%:::--.§fiéf;_'
aad se:><><:;=r:{§§j;> ihe de<:€~'é1s--.«:3_<E wI%1§i;=i é:§:i:.§§;7;.g .>2;:%:6
§11$§i(}?C}?"€_T?§*E*; feifa d;s;:W;r: afiez §Ei'}f._3 shééeg, is
sL:b$:a:"::'%az€ the s:«'m"2--:e.A"':_i%::': i:.j:'s;fJ§i*:§f;;:"2VAA{i'::._sgazzzggny E233
.i g
?::V;::"£§iE2:?.__{Ea>s:ii:;:*::€:':'€$ §:G::§::s:~€& B}:
thé siéxé:2/;_2::nés;*'.,3«ai:;€§: E4'~i§_E:Z; -3 ix *§a.::c§:a:33_r::a_§ Eviifi
:"e3§@§:, §**=§25§ %:h€ eshargs shes: Caaigieaé
?3E%'T.E esvzzié '5%::€ 3?
Ex'? J} Ea 2::s.:'é<:5.?:€, Eihsxi 232:3 {§.§:€Z'€&S€C§
§%'-T°"; ézz 333%: aéaéa §i:$g§é§i§z1§
'{§:;~a»:s §'§§2f"§" <3? féze
9. ?E?"§€ §EESL§'f8.E'i{f€3 :33 :13? abfze *:e;:«
eségfbéégiz ':33; §:'°<}pe:* £3316; =:@:2a='§f:C§:2g {WE:§€;:':_:::w«é_ '-i_§:'z?:.%:
331.? RE ;§me:% sfizargge S§"':=Ei'%3'{ §}i»2E-.s~3€<
is :29: ';3<§$:3%bEe ass/€§%; éigeb $3-§';*:§n--.f5é:3i:'v 'V
farward 312;? "£316 a§;;3€E§a::m:i'$ <':A.s;}:;:;j:':«;:5'Ef»§:::"
9:336: hsaszéii {he i§§§§"':§ (3? 'gigs £':§1'{3:I"g_"j€ an
iI':§éC8J:'iGfi iha: ihe cha:*g___é""..Vsi;:..¢%$': igvfiisvvsi afier
{3{31'IE§§€"'§':i{}f": 0? {he £321:/*.eC3:é;ga*é:5;e,: dié {mi fizié
éihat SE35 E2":CeEOE'?::1£C§iii.""&§7a§'€§;:".§V€fIE _b};"» %{§1;€ zfiecéassad
bu': HGT: Ex/§_aZ%2géi::._:5é~:<;;fi 523 {as a8 E3726 éeéajs
is Cc:n<7<:>':<::2£:i*=':§§QEfifsis €j'<:::V:"?" ..%.:_"; {E26 séecéaiori F$f§ff€§
Ea :'%f%2:;%__ -::23L§":a::~a:':'€s"v:;jt}§:>-z§,:::~;-gsré Ema séaieii ééfiat '£323
ésiay £15: %:Ei:é is fie? {am} is was cEa:i:2:2¢
E2: 'V K)
Egaajé sgugiaézéssii 233:: and he was
:23: }§2:E:&£ ::§:&, Es wag ':&3»«:s:::
23»
§:*::,:si§:::::€§i
$35? Eaesgééaé §:{;::a:§§ri:::3s:% "{E:8f: "{§'§%3 §;€€:i3'B.8€%f§ Eégé
_ *_'%33:':5.§:: :%:§ § :2: :2: 2";
W: "
«Wm
55?: Ezgz 3 V
"*3
lwwvw
("£3
("E
(":3
M
WEB
W"
W
S13:
M,
9}
e""';"
C?
Q
533
E§1a"+:i»
e
(
W
("W
mag E:2:§e:"§;<;:m%:aga:g §:*§~{:':::?s :32?" Egg":
:s'%;~w"'
,«'
$*;§£.E%3.f§}--§"i.;if%3, -fa::1§a:*a.§ 3%??? zygm2:5::;_§_g £§f€::§'§ 3;::f2g€%.:f{£:§::$'z'
§§;j"§3;3'§fi$ E9 €18 éfzeaaiy TE:-s ?}f%s%'£ r:::§::;_'2*?: !§;3s"e
ti':-aé: %:§./2% éagih ézraar an §,€::::3L:,:.2f:?: 9*? {ha
sizsiaziizsasi by £226 &§§%:::~$e::§g
aisg E133 :1'9'*: isfizagi ciispzzissfi'-:§r;""':.:E¢:%:::b:é~fi
§§E$%.I§I"aE3I3% {:Q_E§37§E3.§}}%
3}.-Q, §'*e': i3:fi"'%,§;:%;:f&'§s.gA:§'§;i' 3%?-Vé':*:"'"':E2.:;}_":1gE2
:%:3::¥$5- 3:13 §S£3§i}i'%3I--I.§§;'g%$f?§1§;££E§§'§3'é§{$-.'_,~:.iVf2.z: ".§:§;§f;_;é m=a_=*£:é.'i*-%--aEj$-
i;a;'u:~:es §;::::1% %
Wm; 5.3 g.§'§;a'§§%$E?:a@gi' *e:y':%m
$19
"f"3
<35
£1)"
CE&i:'::a3:%s; age 333%}; gifE;€"U.£E'7":{',€' $5 the
eiiazégssé 59:" ihf €§:;a£::'::2:z2é$ é%:aE 'git? §n<:_:a:§é"':%.f§"~--%A«h
ésseaseéé Wéiffi. 'aaEs<::3z: 9;: §{}'ei'€S§mi'€.§ §:f};'$,{;:€?;''' "§3€E7v ''
mezééég ami {E26 éiaiteaseci haSé:2g:"';f¥::T:::*.§:=§'e:::':§é--::%S_i
anafi 5: Vézazzge axis-:3: «;:s§ E';::.§":»:§ $35 »?€'%~"{§f:€
S'L1§3€§E!'§i§{L?E":y'" Sharges §::: €«;~:'«23_ Egéiezz 3:?
Eeagt 34%-?{}{}®g'-- §::':.i§':%ZpZi€:r
gggéieé i}:e.*?'r§':}L:?;"a;§».i}s '«?é»"§;f'{},§Eg. _
E3, f-a':..__ b V.-Csmpsnsation is
9 '§f:~:1"§'::9%;;.é"é';:§ §"3éE:iE§" €;é:'§:<:€';*: iacanze 3.':
"1-S-s,;:4é'V...5:<}:2s;éd€:'é:":g '€328 €:fié<*5Ee:::c€
SEE §r%3€€;:r<L§§ '3::2:§;352257-:1é;~:fi§:;s:* 9:? fiepgnéagzg as Weié
" -------- «:'i&<?6%2i3€>s:§; ?3;S{§§j'~ afauéeii 37:85;/'8
'€225? "i':'éE};maE, §:CiZ%3>S€§ii€§E§Ef;
7z::::E§é:3E:_€: 35%; ':Ef:€ 8.§§Esi}'é,;%i'E'§ ?J§§E§€§" aha
" ii§.€f?"€?§"i§§€Ef§:{f'\%«' 2/2*'i"i'i {7QE'"§E{:' E0 €<%ig'iT%E.,€:%$€7§%g'~
f
'*é:3VLf§é3§;"".»i'§éT*{,'§iE<"f§§:'3§; Egwgsrzég pzE?s®r:3;§ 63353363
"{3§%%E:€ i§éf'{§7%: 7» *7 ':':{;::; '§§3z;$ éihs aizzazizzé
uzzéair éfizéa Ezaszafi &Ei«'i§.3"'fi€§ E332 E313 '§':*§'a':.,2zmE :'€q':f.é§:€S
-m 'be maééfiéé as::<:::*§i:§gE§;:, 5% far 3.3 fize
zze-'2:j§§:::--$€;§ £3 §:§:':':::$:~'::&§§ '$216 gamg 213 $a::::*--
a2E5az":i€:§ '$35; the "§'r§§::é.,::::aL
hfiads €213 'E':*i%:::;z:{2a§ hag 8.2is'é:'I%'f§$;§'
iimi Caz: 33:53 imérsagfisfi its §V%'§_{§G§';5
1._§:*:::r::% .. 1 ' T<;¥f§%fa?i§.$ 5 :v:'"m$;§ 'lfie. "§'§::;;§: 2%:-§ é;s;}{a.'§ '$5-e as;
fggw:
'§i::;::: f:'t*£{;'§€%§. Ga 'ihe z:~'£E:€:'* Z%:anr:'z ihe Suémisgieg €33" tbs '§"%.L'Tf~;§*.iL>32§L$:fE'{S is in zrilaw 531" 'she d£%..Cé-siézéiz 9:? {his €"f::;=m"é iéés $2235 5}? Eajaj §§E£§.é'__z?iz"u '€':.é::;,__3' Ins, $3, Lag" vs, ga:~i§:: K:::s;§g%»"'*V:§3§§£'A'4 £*€33444§;'2Q2§,§ the §:a%>i3ét§i.__ samgarzg' iiazzggeé Eye 3::?<::%=:i'.:.-->__«:E gr;-sfaiisiév'é}.§E.é§d_.3<>1':z afiathsr jzgdgizlezzé :32" this :°€§s;f_ff5sfi EEK 26$'? Eigggaiaka §§§ :Q%?A"§.3a§?l§%f'- :2§:§§§a§"£z Genera? }I:zstz:'a§'w§ §G;?*ZfZ§Q;?'§f;" v-f,..«i321§*€:5g.£ ' 'figs? Bgiif, Niragzjazz arzé :*1§2.$%;§':;é--.r} ;i"é__. £'..%7,?"i'«E{:ii'f};§ _.%:§5:a§:; \}5hs:: ihe pGE:§<:j,z H V50}: Ewe wheaéers and issued is;
;3?*6mi!Q:~:m '<',7i}'x?€§" €326 mg: GE GWEESF 3.12% :{;%"-iiés ..v7€~--%::'_é:};€ §F:su*: aissa 3:3 {:28 éhéré Eéghi 3%' 'sits %§%:'?:"%S8;§§ éeaéséaag <'"Z> hag %;::§r 31:5 0:': the émgzsraas . Wm?' W {W} in {he ;;§:*%:s::::€:':%: C%S€ gigs}.
§>:'Z 3?; €33' f:§:$ afsmsaéfi mfisfizzg '£228 aygifiaaé fifiaafi §i':§§ {E6 izészsargficé £=£§I}:}'§E8.i3.§? £3; §é'§$:.§§ss§:$§'T'-.$§:é,_;é--- ----I £335 cram; <>'§§:«"::::§§:: éééaé E52" iég aiigiazeé 5:: gay:
1%. The aizzezgni in zieg-::§;2:§_ft'*--_iAé e:'%:'§;_$::e:i iraggmiiieé ":3 éiha '§':*i%1::1a;-§.,, §;§§%z:§':a:iiE2..Mt§j:e §f;CfR';