Gujarat High Court
SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION/12434/2008 on 20 January, 2010
Author: M.R. Shah
Bench: M.R. Shah
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?-wd???%{?? W $Ej???&#???>?[???O??? ????^???b??w?7}{?????????_?D?? ? ?s?E??E?? ?? ??o?fQ?x??? ?G ??v????]???A ????4B ? ?r4 ?Z?i? ? ?r4 �h?? _?^.???F?.//??????? ?^? ?{?K??[??? ?? ?F9?.s P7??????2? ?????c? k ?? ??0?? ?\4 ?? ?? :?S?????x??v2?? ??^ ?^ ? g.|$ ?7?F?x?o 8R?? Lp3?3?)�T??1? ?S?????c? a?$ ?)?%P??O@?? 6v?w%?O?X?o\???< ???s?7 ????G?? ???s?? ??^??_?9?-+? ? ?:9?V?? ????~a?Z?kO? S A ???R# < S=? ' ??? 3?? ?e???l??A???j?loU??dD??K ??YOo7 Z? ??[Q????#;?�? ?i M???4?q????\?P??W ?= D??r ;(?O;??? ??3??m????OG ???v? ??e???m?e??:?????s?|??Z?q???e ? ?????????by'????y??N???? ??=f?[?< ?G?WP7m??9w 4 ???v?Ux?9? ?
??? ?/?=? ? h??c?\O???O9xI m?b???? -??q-Z?-X#?Y????,}? ?1)m<(? ?X??)`SO?5???? ???GX?mf ? ?????f? ??0=?so7 ?j@???? ?J?nfy?�? ? ??/@? ?v? P?????? ?"?ni?�? ?[? /@-�jK?? ?E@???y j P_I ? ?\???cTn ???S{ ??` ^/= ??-?#?_5= ?M?#??t?? }T?m[ 0?{v??`? ?^??vXP?D???03?/* ???> !- ?-?Gt?}0?u tY?{?? ?|oka?? ??~???# w {? ???M???? ??)??=`U .?\?|7 ? ?G???g.r?p]?,C ???????
? p?#s?H??#?x??A| ??M???f??? ?O????a?n/ ???A?� ?? ?=???? ?d????v?{??m?x-?niw ? ?]??8d? ??nOa???^XA ? ?? ???A?b&?? ?^? J ??? ?�? ?? ???A58?n 4v???l?U ?E???<;?/???G????u??? ???_ ?
,????? ??? r?E?|?z/e_?????f?z????5?????????? ??z?I?O????E??? { ?-} ???'y?9~? k?�?y?]?? ?O=;? ?F? ~????[??w?_?�?????n?:??z?ps ??X?????~?????I?$A ?n? ? C?????* ?O?Y??]!?R? ??? ? ??V|P? ? f?h?`x` ??Q ??%??f???%�U?}? h?;?? !r?g ???^??s{e??e???d? ?V?�?3f? ;S?fh?T??n ??5??/%?~#??7%??????0?;!?W�???#? 6aA (Wdb????'?? ?F? 4??`K? ???`'??| ?H??�dA?3? ?% g&?Olx=? + ? '?Tq?*N?R?VTq?
U??*6_B?*xh??Y?{??G? l+?G? 7?6 ?RF?p?e?JxP??E?"[??c??Q???x ?[V??? ? ? ?~+?? "??QP?)? ?N Q?iS*;R?N????P??K0??G '? 4??8v?(?Bc??] 7l[*??C#?\? ]?|??|? ~?????? ????E??bk?u??~ S/ ?~?a???t??l? ????; .|`O/???} ??? ? ? l?m????dq{g?w?t? _ -? \???^! ?~?pm??[ ? ??-?r? _ ?? ??? &??? ????>~?i%?~???? ?iRHi�Q?N~??!m??S??;+??g?d?YS {???=?X??? ; ?????D l!?7_?I???nE0??D?KUl???? P @????q???? ? ?? �] ???}?xW%??|aN ???i2?e ?y?? z??????AK.????Y4?~v?p???2??2&??U:??}'-?? o,l G3 ?R?0~?i??? ? ??^??^??!?v?? ? @? ? Q S}? Y??V ???+Z |p? -? ??x -???w?? T ?? ? ?� ?? ? ;X?,?l*??x? >Uv J9?1??A? E,P?% eIH?]D ? D~5t???"??,{ ? $??8?? P?#h 6? "h ??-^ YF7?Z?C? ??j?&?C 0.m?Sk ?' +?D ?�???`? .x \s? a Og?W? ?!c`?U?? 0??? ?3\!?e??'M�Z?\ ?? . ?2?CPk?a???4 +? ?? )?/2?$ ?K0?�6c?PV??& ? ?B?? d?c?<0?") =??G|?D$�o?.??l?H ? ??q'? E?` YD??q??a(?B,?d??6Y??a?%?> ? ?e*&??
ftl?>??k ???$ ???UT ?? ?)B??S?GP's"U, ?3e???X9mT? y??_!5?U?{ 5>Ubh???T ?s?QD sN? i! x_ cls?0 ?`?? M????s j| ?%~?\??-??
? ??/?L?EIx?? ??$ GR?M?
??b`B??g?iUJ)?f ? ?G??997??? ??dzi?e??)? ?x ?j?V???xK????)^ ?R?! ?\C?
w?R??1 sh? +??? ?? ???yZ ?Pz? lf;iW? L?? gk??(P??Q????Yf???sY?< ?*? ? P? }-? ?W G?s ?? l?? ??P n?I????8;Ga? ?/??@?`?I R) ?Z A?{VB7????v???${O ???5?D??yK ? ?�"?m`???v? {??k*>H}?FB m? ?yH 1L$?-*/q??b?`b/J >? ???? ?/LD??L ?IR?h zH S ?h /? x? I?9??
? k&i? ^ ? $?
?U r(n??9? i? p $E??t ,?H?G??RT??? *? ,ZM???5?|?],? [B pF m??\??? 7 A,oFF?'JX??[0?? ?U?h????
?L`o]? ?6F??ySV?? ?.+5?H? ? ?((???,u??+4???? Q?W? gJqG??Oh 5???Sz#o?Hqa ?]?8? ?f??m h?h??J????|??�?0 ?????WE?K? ?7?.?k?,???% ??? ?GJ?O?? !?M?? ??t??Dh?4 I:}P?3 h??>Z?>�?Z?1 ?*hP !????8??FqTD )??
??K5??s?I?????q?.lp?H??f x??B??05V? ?UjAI???)???????$?Z?Kh?3??tq*v?H ???t?N2???U ?P ? ? W? ??:t? ??l?m?M?J?=???? L_6? ?f?z?4? ?>??? ?Jp? h?s R?? ?J??z ?)d?
;+?_ ?? ?~ ?,2 ?? Gd?( U? ?? C? ???cs0n?%?Dm"?,l? ??MY?|?[??T??=u?'?t ?? E~ :o?^ ?fNm m?)?r[??T 7?=?xF jvd0?OGpUR%?; ?%iF x? D???E?X??'?k?$?tb\??FJ??2DPhM??M?R?"?? ?F)W?h? ? ??ego?xX??2??@MQ?1 Pn?:?V?d? ??|?~?vCr?`b??S??]$X?#? ??3)'?^ ?HyS????TPE?U??B?Q?\????sr%??I? vB??C??? ??a?g?^ ??4p?0?`L?P?4i??6N ?g #??k??R6?/??k"??z??po?/ N"y?Iy E.????&Gw?q??O? ??3 ?"??3?_s ?$t???s?9? ? ?g"?S ?m?u???I3????(;_[3 ??ngm?T_O?- y $!?? ?? ??{??r_H8??B1? ??S????i??&g?AI??T? V?5 ?hD? ?
?t %?Q? ??0!7?>?W3z?4HM?c?
Za"A4l ?@?7: ?? ???a?r jB?> ?:zkb??j????? ? ??m?Q?@ ?6@? ?<3? ?{?c?8w-?C?W ?????? ? ?xpQ??V�)? ?#?? y?? [_ 5q9??? ?????-pk);T ??RoB?] ?dQ ??Cjf?"Q??c?I=??;?0? ??wu??J?N??j?R?
??`+ T?c?V7;?? 2???Z?f?>??.?lT %?( !????[?f?y Fk? m ???E?m??IP_?%!gJ??d?/y?Y9 ?OW??6}?=??aT ????? ?!_???6r? 5 ??.?K?G?)?w?????tK?L?F??'# ?H&S G?)U??,b=? t=?s? ???0?H??6@P=[?Log?6?l _$? ???? )? 5?6?$?UtH??2 ?4???!??n?2CC? %? ?cF??l P? ?g???3??Y=I? ??k e=~+??+?:?+?S? ??? K?? ?3??X\uMJucN ?u? ???N?\rW??)?}7?+?pZW? ???$PSjA??�n??a?9 ???{O ???? 3w?? + ?sl ?{ ? ??9 ? ?? ?xJn??a("?F? +;?U??^|? ???T??Z ? ??{x? ?c???Em ?`A i#?Z,ifVq(?/?? ? ?`? ???? ?HE??V?(?mO?? i6f?1? ?? K??Z??%?(?&?(??|??L?AiW? ?b?v:?t?R?? ,?
Y??m?F1M^U ??tR?R? X?? J$??` 9???[o?Iu?0 ?J;"]]?k?T ??]?????w?0?j? ?$??a? ? ~Yf?q?G??: ?;?@D/??5?xM=?????(PK[?d??a?;>?zP;jm0�? {.???? ?.?P0?]?
?
3?y???x?z/?????J?W=CvOX2 o]p*&U,?J? ? ??I 5?"???^C? Xy?\IDi? Y??E`b0??C?F ???( ???g??? ??{ ?ba Z??(?2?[?[_%?] t ?a9?? e??e ? ?: J?\?Ct] ???~?D????K?kB?U.? K???
?/ -???TlC0t?i W Wgd7AS?o??_?m5 ?? ? )? ?? ??2?ZK?Z?Z ??"| "??H?U?3??8? u*+???;/?\Qu?S?fo ?J[??? PK l nm?$��??��PK � � �?-w<������������ ���styles.xml?Z?o?6 ?_ah &??GbgM?.[? ?64?WZ?m? )?Tl?? ?eJ??d???P ? ????_?K?? ?0z??7?4b1??[??? ??t??+?Z? ??,?SL?/?>?b�???1?[o#ev ,??
_ ??h ???b??K? ?x'{?
P???n???m/Z ? ?b%z?? ? ? ?E????
?)*m?%?~??kiiGTS' G N?? ?a Xl?%?Y ,??? ??-"? Ok??&2O?/?
??H?S?'q?G$7 ?? ?A??{??? O{?+@??????r ? c=?i????4?r"1?c^x???t"K;B ?? 97( ??awg?x? ?c %?? |520S?B ?L?? ?t? ?h? ?g?y? 3SV(%???? eL? 7? |?9YyA???,?D???P)??62?)? Wr?"?@dDF@?' N?#??n ?1J??????6@f?e?z?, ??T!N?Gl? ?cO?< ???1? ??!S???1^?<)J?UZX??(?Hx ?qH<. ?4u??
??? ? KwFa8 ?6? ?w!$ ~> ?? ????@ ? G?G?~?)r?1???}?vk6?P??G?d ?&1f?c>J?
?0?o ? % ~D?J?? IY ? ??e#??? ?Xu u?n? J ??\` j?r?? ??A%?>??c ?? s? 5 k?)?> ??s4?e?z+??YQ???PF J#?f ?Y?[JK?Cm)?-o?? ??L??hS? j??)?!?t?] N??
?HBi? ??Mm?? "? y&???F27 ? ? N?}?1?Y ?1? ?j??p? ??n22 g?D?Z?z+?K?P-h??8j_??z?n?K? ????)?" ?)"?W=?e??�??b? _? ??? -?Y2???H )0'A?P???%}? ?? ? l??F??*??-W_??? %F??["7>?w}S?I G4?/?b??s?Q)?Hq? ??? ? ?r?>????%[?"X??9?? ??9N?G?:???? ?NJ? ?{ B ?x??m?(Of-?%?>/?:?? 3/> ?S u??"??v!??,B?|Ppr?~? u? "Z??????g!?3?{Pb ^?????
|E r{,2?mB??? ?V? ??B???W?�???>????j??z %iR?A #?$? ?I? ';W????r1?8??? ?aL ? ????brx??3\ .8?`6??_O p??Gk&u? ??w?Q ??a?B? ??6d?7,?? m?6? ??4?T pX??V??+?j}?u?%%? M?KVX ?5O?f|Q?L.a?EY3?(k?.a?f~Q?,.ap?_?? ?m\1&)?X@m?+?~?p? 5?< ??$?5h??J?y?a???J??[ L??,!nK? ??j???#?|?k?.? Ow.O z? 'x% ???:?j ???c?z8 ?$v+ ? ~I?StN????]? 5?n?U?? ?\ ?fi?k? [ ???????~???M?^???j1^? ?j'`( ??D ? ?}H???YuN? ?K? ??Z?gR SG??h??????`? ??+7k? ??\ D`?? ?K??:??d? ??5z??M s' ??co ??`(k?l?9 #? ??w? ?~??v??y?3?? l> ? ?7j?? ??C ?{? ???? ?p;V?F???t ?D?Y ????KZx? %?'????4?yp ???RP ?U ?A???M???x: ????jZ? (:w ?p OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 ashish 2010-03-23T11:17:31 1 PT1S PK � � �?-w<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png?WyX ? ?z/KGM? ?M-?L?2?27,5QA1eR? L?% m??2Dd?p? x*h?5?+????????[?????{o??????s?Y??9??H)KIHH�???.!?Cb?n?n?H?\ du?5?? ?2yAVbf??vb???K?;?y[2?tfZV? ??M??m?? ?? 7 ?d&/ ? ?????#?,1)?A?.???BD&n??'nmd$?'ZP-??#? ?G???
????9!f{;|U?&S w????aHN� 6?A??? ???/?iY? I??z MJ?s? ? ?? ?????QM?e *(?? ??}c???!;*Y??? ? ? V ?z???&??j? ??q \ ?+9?0? @K^???? ?Hn@H?f # r8r?W?j?.S$3? ?? C??? ??$?j? ? P? !???? aQ?-???) ?_ ??t7?z?m??C4?N m?U?Z:)?_? $??
B???L????. ??.}?????m?t?-Hfq????b kN ?:?D ?? ?? +??u?8???S]???r?kI??;? b?t??q ?!?{??cD?{?W?o?0 A???+ ?VW6??}fVt?MY2??x ??( ??z?o ? HU.(?w??? ? ????2 UF@7???6? T_y??r?? ?s??* ?* V 5#y?h? ~ ????#r ??? ? :????"Y??e?so???' #? ???W? O ??Mh???+ ?? ?�??U?Q)?pNU??????L?=??sxS?{ g"?*3??c?W ???x?? ??~tV? e%?V.V:?{v y ~>y ?F?? ? ?9?1^?r+]d ?? ;?MF?,? Z?2/?}??" ??? '@??bw?? x??W2~?g}?? ,M B???.??M??}? �8??? ?b?? �n ?}R??gt?l???r? >d2?w?,P;R?]???A?c d?? ?o?
|njS??W??3E)??H???7? ?%?" ??1??H ?? AT ?}?~n?)??_ap?0H?70kE?* ???h?"? ?? ????y�?????f ?Xy?? ? ?L? 5??_?>1?db?t(~>? x?5?L?\ ^ ? 0C?2a???F??*?=? ?6e??ej??)m?}?C ?g_A.bl ???LU?t 1?u?A?y??-?h?
? h?0??.Q?' U?? {?G?oU?? b?`n?| ??x?5?, ~?T^[/Vy ???G?? b??E? ?? OU> k] ?? YD???s?Y?????A8??: ??]?s?L?"J }c???m?1b? ?.?? ? 0 ? ? ??3 ?hU ?l ?Z1`?? ?X ?+? ? ??A}i1->?W.Z"K?dZ??22???~?_???/h? oe??6?u UH Mqt ??gcB2h??E?B?k?o9? ?B?d?` ?7???E e?s?[??q??O???vA @i??&?|? t ?G?w????z???? ?i??*?^??G??p>? ???*?+??[0{E0???;?87? ?.;??PWk ?H?_Ay? ?s? | ??? ?q???% ?`kNs ^??RW????U? ?906NVt\??3 ?? ?w*63????V??r? ?#6G? ??? ???a?L??_?t ??7+??x!?R??^6?1 ? ??? ?I?@;yZ?Uu?? ??jr??4(??>h?? ?!? ;??G'??IP ???;?? _???nl+?~??7_?>$n ?vza x-e ]?{??'???c???V??kB^\? ^H?y?U???v??*$?? G~?? K5 H`?^??�?*&?9???W?d9???a? ?G? ?:?aB=cL?]?|*V{T? ? ?\R??4??y.??,?)? ??? " W;;k ??)??: 23??N"WAk)??g?Q0?(?W??d??0 ? ? ?&??++? ??z ??"???>?vF??veG??8????# ?(PeB Y?i?0?g??#??Z?l? ?@*????,1?S?/O??? tK?4z? ?b ??? S?_ ?3?q ;?l???6??+f7??F*? ?? ?p?? ?vA6?zV??z??T?)?[??`?R? ??#w?? ? ?
?? ,???~ ?L?? { ?y4p???p*n_??U ?ra?m? ?/yL?p?H?? z{?;?x?>?`??{_ jM?8"??i?�? ?-
??=?38j?'z~?G ?f ?# ??~?5?6 ? ??uC A??}??y? x??]?1?Y? ?r???CI??e1 ?g ? ????MOC ?%?T?? ???[???P????>?sD????? !??P&?} y??? ?.??pg;cHe? ???;8 ?[?? R ??J~?o?} X ?i!??H ? ^?V??A3?x }#h.???f? ?0e YU? !?{P??c?????B?4????i?s? ?, ^%cr d??!I?avB4?H ? ??
????ja??7??bv?�?? ?q?ZGW?*F ?NQ?g?Z??~v? ?< /????t?H?:?f5y?^X ? ???t?? D?`???$?Mo??;???k [?)xv?J?!4xd_ ?o ,6>q??y?? ?w%?1F??^E?$ ?i?_6???uu ?p? Lu v? ?s??y ?Y?K? ? ?g?7?. :d4?? | )? ????`? ??e ?? m? ??>?)??`?J"J |X???? K?+?<~?o UiI??L4? ??}?wQ??@W*KF?Y V ?? ?Jn'??}YbR?^ ??Zc???? ? 1 ?v??Q r?8h?y e>l??`2? p?4?]I_ ??/?&??Y??/ u9L?? ?d?T?3?????I6f ??y? ? ? = #????h?=~? ?{? ?/�??8??? ??Ny?|?? ?% ?=??j??h?L??n ?&3 O?;a?]???2 d ?H?2u?~^(H???Fd�??8?? f?7"Dj F????' ?4?@??jr K(? ??O?D 6|??a ?R g??@?&?x????.LW?v ?\9? ??????f ??V?c%?vc?i?Z ? ??!?? ? ? ?T?? ?+?6g?E??
?u ?b?#??w?@??_ ?[ ?? ??;?~ F0E@??cL? ??m?^?tB? Yd??p???? ?[????0?p#?
?? E_t8?????8a?6 ?? ){?oW L b???V ? ; ["H ? ??f???s?J ?<6g*? 6?:hb m??$?b?`??Q^N?M???F???tz/? ?=XR?z? $R ????d?\??%???W?? PK H??I? ��G ��PK � � �?-w<������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???k?0 ??? ]??S??X ??A ? ?k H??\??? ?? ?~]K??? ??&?ZF;?Nh??~?c ?L?B?)? ? 6 ??????m??j?D???m ?6??Y?b??A?, ?a?m 0_???\? ?,b?$?? ? ?R??? t??? ?z}h (:I?? ?"?u???15 S??"? ???? ?U B?w+ -;]*????T? \?qY?iU????l7�G???r?
_H??D??F ojT?#???n9??;?Ik? .j^????? ?i"?O_? Iv ? ? ? ???r??? g Top