Karnataka High Court
Smt Nagamma vs Sri Mudduhanumegowda on 8 February, 2012
Bench: K.Bhakthavatsala, K.Govindarajulu
" * :2 $:§:'3;m,:§§'§.g.Ka;§;%:a§:é-----« *
' sf {:2 ;;:TE;. $R3§»:j§3é?A;;::~a
-;:<::v§:»:'2*;--i?,T "x¥'*E'.£2;, '
' .-WXQE Sg§§;;%§{§E»'iAR»
. :1§3:1:;:2? ~~":::%'§;;AR.£«:~§
2 €'}i3?7::.§jEQEf£§E E%{3Lil
'-2.'*":'::i;: 3~~gaRE:;
_ -j:v2;i;2;';é? E:E$:'§!;g§!J%.;.éAfi,§5'fE&'€j§1 §%*:":;':'%:§
:3»; ma mag CQURT OF E{z3:R:'£A'1'§;1<A 35:'
mnrgij THEE mg 8% gay $§'.:F=23Em';駧" ::*;%';:'72 k V'
?RE5§§T7, fi L : f
"mg Z-iO§\§'BLE £3r.J'£3ST§{7%'1~-§_iBHE',_ %%'*;>;>m7i;§:fV§'§§g% }: u
gNB,_
"ma E~§GE'€'§LE MR e3'6.;$'i"i{?:'ii';":{ .{§§'¥?§_NDA§}§JfiLE§
MFA N(}.1§§3§ €3§}.2.0é3'f .1§1v;
BE'E'W'E13N:
E. sM.NAGA:vi:§gA, * "
W/G paasarz, _ '- _ '
AS332 Ygg$,R§:~,._ i:____ V
GCC: H(}'USE;"i?£>,D. _ _ _
25 fiéazfi'.?§§AEi§A;i?E'g'§$v€&L%;"'._ ' "
WES 8Ri1'€§'§fAS, -- ' ~
AGE:::3@ V3433; _ _
QC€::H€}USE 3§>;:,::a
{::s«:<:::-_ ::<;v::>f::£$; - .
:2? 3§§'?. 8%%§"€:"Efe;E%£é¢i2K,
/
E»)
§1'i2%.GABf "fQ'\5f S '"§'A§.,=U§'{;
B:%?€€§?:3f,QRE R¥.jRz3;£»., EHSTRECT;
Rffi?' H'i§Di§'»JEZG§:RE,
Ekirkfififii TGEVN §.?*JB TAELEJEQ,
§A?'§{§u%L§RE §{§jRzi'§L §}§$'E.'RI€T.
{BY SR3 SURE£<$Ei M , LATL?R~:'%{}¥'}
3ND:
1 9 SR}.M'£jDDL§HANUM§GQWB:'%;~»__»
$59 SRi;H§;N£§§ei£fl;NTEiA§
;%.GE:M.AJ{>R, $C1C:B{§S£E'\§§i.S$% -
E~"{;'§[§1 S§€ANBHGGANAH;%.§;LE, --_ "
8&1-{{2ANE\E&Hs%.T?§ P883', . .
E'~i§AG£%.D§TALUK§ _ '
BANGALQR:av55Q:§2q::.._ L' '
2, W15 :>:v:;§;:*:;irs:5g;..as§;»s,§ss;3;é%:? _ H
UNITES INDL5; ::~;;§;_s'sj;g:§2;.z3;,'§»;::':.;E"T*s::€>«_€ 1';:'*§*?9.;; '
®mx:@.,5£>;.:3;§8..,%_ " _
CH£?T£%£:':§R B?§A';§%E\§;.4 .
am F'LG{'}.R, ::::'?%é ::§%Qs:ia "
SW EVEAENQ _ *
EvLALLESHX%§'§'2RA,?vE, " _
5§N§;m_QRE~§8Q@a3';
'RES?G§\€':%§:N'§"S
V" gB§*v:;':s:2;E5;2i::§;*a2%3fA Rm g;::::*a; FGR R2, RE: 33322133;
{E/S mggz; $5 ism; as'? AG;::;i2:3'§ mg
_.3i§§G?v'EE1E*€'? -aim AWAR3 §§;'ET'EEé: ::am3,2;><;§ @3333 gas
;%{§¥'§§,§€C:'~3E;_Gf{%4 GER? TEE: EWLE Q? X??? §'%.§§§TEi3?<éA%L S:\§§§5.E,,L
;§<:;§@§, Eyzgsgigaa §*--¢EA€3Tii r::::>:;m* <3? gmgag
"f':;--'*:§}S'33f;$, §vEE'§'RG?QL§'§'E.AE'§ AREK §z'~':N$ALE:3§P;: {$CC§§»E.53§
.§§<V%f'E¥«%--§§:S§§'~ZC% 'me: Cifiiégfi ?§;'§'Fi"'E{}:"§ '§?@R amzisfiawggygaaa
... --
\
§
''§
"§
\
\
\
\.'-:
%s
M
*2:
§-.
#3
'\§_.~.
{C-:2
\:'-:1:
51:?
- '22
.k N:
-.3:
~:
3
"SE38 APPEAL Camizm :33; E03 Hggé-2.R:N€,..2'_:i*:~£'%Svj-zfimg A.
BR..B§£&KTf:{AVA'I'SALA L ' % ED 'mg E'f}§,Li3X?%?'E'€ T
J<{m&&gxr$ E Q
Tbs 3p;::e§a1:1%;;s, whe arfié
Na.3m;2(:2s4 an {he §EE€: ._0f ;3;.fi:&i.t§Q:1a}.".;if;/i%C9F-. 'g'fi v,
Bangaiarés City? am befors *:E2§1é"'-VC<32;r:'----§3:';:a}fi;3g"2%:?ié;*:: {ha
impugned judgment :%.a:.';_€d i..»%';'G*§_;2GE}:.§ mé.§%'%;e$:e:~as§d€
333$ ihrs: Claim petition prayed for.
2. VfE:§é"'éipp€i1ant submitg
éhaé ?'§}'€'2 examined is §fC%%f€
Q23: Sr: .353 3 rsgult 0:" ihe injuries
.:;::Si:a§I:€§__i4:2_£:I%:éi»._§I€§At<>§"aé{;§§€;':*:. Bu': the '§'§:ib:ma1 €§°Z€'€§
£2 &§S§¥$fiE'i§V_3.d;§:§§iQf18§"£SS'L§€ $30.} in Eiegaiive Eiaiding
'§;e*i§':;Z§§:;§i*"V faiéefi Ea §::rQ':?€ Ehai éscsased
..§=V::f"§;§'Sf3/§é§;§§E'1 V€1§,§é:§§ 0:: Z:€fiC®2}.l'E€ Si aasifieniaj ifijary 332:1
dés:}2V£3s%3f:g§' "i--§:'é 213233; p€?:§":§8?:.
V " We Ezave ;:;€:*:§s€<§ 133% ECSR.
E §§§
3 am gcai markefi 1233; Cizarga Shset, Pa1':c1<':::s'j:W;.:é:§4:%:j;':"'
Efifmzzzfi certifieaié, Discharge 3:,:m:naNry_,H__ %:za;i}:§$;ii<;{::::£§"
:*&<:§:'é§ déaih ceyisifiizaifi azzé ascidigérzzé %€:§§éi§eVri J
gag" E}§$.?1 ia 238% T223 '{'rib:;::a3V;'V._§§:._.a.§3§2%e;:%i§iii>¥é;'=; §§. '
evidezzcg an recsré answerég tiie
affirxnafaive holding th2;:.--- Q16 "s;.:si2:;i::c--:;i...i*::3.ju1*ies
is: the mgior azzciéerzi diff; a;,%:§i;_"vz.;§f:g3§geni driving
sf £113 193'}; by i%;§{':i:i1re;*';" «.:a ::i;i5':é i'§§$::a."§ isstze
§\3f3._: in fafieti is
pmve fiiéjufiéfi sustained by
him in aijhe éismissézd ihe claim
§&ii*:i::>:':. '1'§;i$ E3 'i:'.§":11is appéai'
: 'i'T'§_1€reéac:3m$::%:ar§r eviéemse ':0 gzevs
fi,%2§'i§*§§';,,:::a%::§i' ages: 3.3 3 resziii sf izzjarigs fiagiaizzefi ':23?
hifig. ::";{i§:é §;§::;5i%:ié:* acgééezai.
2 "E1: View :31' $22 F22}? fifizzizh €3%{ZiSli%}"3 yapszieé
wag @323 §{~"::3§;:%:f1 gxayzfiamma 'ifs.
6
flepzzig Geyzerai Manager} €229 fribuzzgzi j§,iS§:%fi€§*--.§:1
aiisrnigsingg $38 {$212312 §e:%:§*£"i<:s:1 :31: 'me grsziafi
<":ia.i::za;::*:S Eaiézzii $2'; preys that {ha i:;§:,:r€d 'ifi.§€{§:"z:$" ré'
regzzéi, cf tins §f%§u§"§€$ szzsiained $3; 1913;; in 'iii:.§'--:::Q€t:;§f_
aaciésrzig E1: Para :2 9f ju§ §;fii%:--n%: f%§i::§Lt'fff$§
Karimamma; Vs. Bepuégg Véihaii
"a Ciaém péiiéiors §resaz%;'::?fid of {he
M9§;a:* E/'ehiciés ficii bedéfy
iflguries in § far
§€f"S9?3QZ ifiwfifds
e,x:§ense.:.:;q :9 €S{£ZZ€€} car; an
5212?: pezigfiigfé £e{:::i'}"z§ @'€s:;:§*:r_:j:;:g' as Q reszfii G?' :;'s::'?;"éS€§E,£€1?;C€
Q5' bmfiéig _Z§§:ijZ»ii?'2}i'E'.S: :~:'z}:s§':f':.£r:€& in {he rrzaiarr fig-sidem', be
g§'fs:,~L3€:é;:A::c5§§:"§%§§*~.§jLi.§ ,5 fag?' éegai :"epr€3€n§a:€:>e§"', in View
{fig j£§?'?3 $555336? :f§;3.:;;'}:§§§:3r: ihéi '?r'§b1.:naf§ is j:18'§i§§§€§ in
V' _gé:$:"::iS%3:::;j,2; sziaim §}€'E§§.',§QfL We 3&6 E38 éE§€g§&§§£§;* {gr
§?f§fi§"§??i§i;j;7 E3': ihs imgzggzzgd G:'i"§€E".
E;
\
ff<<<<<<r
.|:li...43<\x\\t\\\t\\\\\\\\\\\vx&«««§vvvw¥V§ vVm§» uWk\\vV\
\§v\\v\\.\\x.w.\.\\\\\\..\..\
:2p§3s:*:;«'a.§ faiis am: *
3.535%.'
3 .5
§:§::@%
t
sis,
ii
3....
mg
cg»
Mei
W1
1.24 a 4,: «G . 1 3 S
1... ti. +3. , E Q 8 f, yNV €VJ ,3 my La W3.
m H E G "§%§§£§§2sés.,.§: