Karnataka High Court
Sri Ezhil Vannan vs Sri Anandkumar on 17 November, 2011
Equivalent citations: 2012 (1) AIR KAR R 859, (2013) 2 ACJ 1166 (2012) 1 KCCR 248, (2012) 1 KCCR 248
Author: N.K.Patil
Bench: N.K.Patil
'_;.W.z EN 'I'§§E EIGE QGURT' fifi' E%I'§$'§"'A.E% AT EfiJ§§r;§,7§$}RE §'f};'¥§.'.§£E.f} 'E"'§"--E'EE§ '§'§*§.E§Z E ?'5'" E.,}g-733'" {}'§*=' .?*sE{7§'=£'§'§ii/§§:.?§EfZ-R :E~}R?:IE§ §:§E"*€'.{:
"$355 §~§@§€'EE,E §iR.s§{E$.'§i'§€}§!3 '?§';§:'.§z:?§V::;""
ma "mg §m2?s:*B:;,,E ?%iRfi_'€§'3fi'§€§'7€f;SUR£ :§§§4*A.Rf%.Q M,§'«:gx.N<>, 51%;: _{3:E§' 20 §.{%"F1.?'?»"7§VVE ,,.2g:
E C1§M'\:";
:az:.§'<-'gwgs. §'?fé%§9.{}§?' 2<}.:;<:s--. _ ' E3_e§.We<>,n_: ' Sri. §%Z;:E':*;'§ if_§L:T:i%j:2-::'::1., ' Se/'s:}. E?é:;2:=:£?_§.::.';-.
§£;"'z;1§'.(;1\E'<.}'1§?3;' H _ 4 '§3"€=.mE§i;;=::'1.é:.i':'§. §?i3;:?{i-~.§,jEA ' ° E*£4{}.E'-"§a;E'§%. ;<a:';:E::g; <:.:.;' _:fi<,-:T4:-"z-, §3§:a£z':gaZ<}:*é:j:€L5,_ ' . A ' _ Sis}: 55%;'K%Z};:.>;.:»;a§§<:§'ViVi¥s:'L%.:i§'2;:5 :K::§v<;}<:r.z:1{%} ' §3{E'ifZ -
§{%.E'V§ "K? < T j E. 2? i'? ~~'=§:§§f§}{}€..§ V Ef_§&'Ti§i)LE.:%=§:i.§f3'§_,Z=£:iEyéi1 :2-'$5.;/*s::g<:;::*2=~ V ' = . '§§%:;e':1:'%_ ;'t%32:;é_:' QEEE 5:23: '§3:'m~*"2'2 fi E3 1;;2;:':§ {E H".
, . ' 'z'i§3g3t':E.E2z:'1 1.
A V '§?£.€Z; ,§§:3;§..° ,?€<>'€'i<%e: 2;.) R24 R3 EES {'fi.f:I§§_.'_3€'.3"1€~§{'.'{.§ Mai":
E4-y{j{§r\ {iaz:3.d {}'?;'€}€~}f20.E $3 '§"'%':is; E\f§.E?§%. £55 fihs-<'§. L1,./S .1?'.f3{§} £22.? fi{"€. V _§:.:d§;;z'm~:':"n'. a':1':z:i 2-m?":'2.r<;§ {'§21,é€{i: EE«}_f{§3;'2€§i{} §'}'c1;',~32*,.%§::'«'¥_'§"~.}_.."~ ?\E{;.3E3€:3;'§,z'2-{}{}'f? {>21 iizér: iféééé of ¥'..E'":<:: $4?" ,5";<"§z§§.. i.Iu.éi~;§£:; E%§2':'§aE.E €T2'1:".2::2;:-%s:;, E'%«'i::;*m%.3{i*2; ':'s;'i':'»'%iT'§I §3a1:'1§§22i:>§"s:%. _§;:«-;j:.§°iE}z i..£'.':a% :':.§2;1§§":: p::E§.E'.;'{':~n for £'{m.';§.>a*§§&:,:I:E_K32": T: e:'T2§":;:;3§':{.%:3:'§":e:'::' at' £'.i.'=i_}I§I'1§,".%€.'E"i$2-ii.i.(}E'E. " ?%a'E..E52;'»':. Na}, 8801 OF 2338 }3€=%we L';'f'i'} :
E:§;2:":;_;;ai:}§":? Pw£'€7i,:'a§:{:Ei€'.z~:§1 'E":=;§.:'2$g:3(>;*i: Cwpz} "efzfizts :11. ..
C€::E"{.r;?-2.}. {)E'§.£<?<x ' K" H §}{>uE3i:;% E¥%<}a:'§.
S§:a3':é}::izlaggzfl, §ii21:':g,§aE<>:"<::; ' E13}; :33 §€;1§:::g§;:'2§ H _ ;:):*ap;_>&:E§a::T1£'
{ifiy S$::::°., §,}.,$'a;fE:§ &%.}*"é3. Eig; ::»1:_;1:*;- _;'»":l:t<E:: {.2 {:22 is; $2215} :
I Eizmi §%f;§'i3".I.If§£'>i§'E§ V
- .,_E:';' <3: S;2..:';{i 212:? ' ' 2 , E'z<E;;-ggifiéz, T T£'33;}'§§;. ,1:i::.:s, 2 £3 ? "
..'_;:E}{."?m1§"":«?:?:%,;'é'."§_.§E{.?::1.E'V §§h::2:':':. . §:>z.:§:e;:;s'* ' g}"»'%..1"°:LI2.§f::§:7 {:{j}§.§£E§»_';Té% §":3:-.;i..L "'§33.%é:%::::.§§2:5u':':.2-43%.
' .2E': S23Q'£t§ai.%":';";2?:n':: $§§':gg;§L 'V:4)"ml}r-""vAwwA'>V":«vwWv1'}:l///;wnnhJMIMJM'5vnnnnvWvWw .» "M IIIVIIIV .. V 7§;S_ft.}. izé-5%, $2--a:'{:§;2':a§" E":'e:*::-'-€2'2;.2'3'2 Séézzzgzhy ' §*;f£'.1*. E*Es2't::.2£.2::;%;§'2p::m. Eféiizié, §5i§2,'~'2 "'é'2:E::§bi;
if}: 2..':"z..zr:§2§?::-=;;.:;>z :22 §:}§.§.+:E E'§{_': ii . T"?
m:">§':*é:E.'.:. ii f;.§':{:> {".2:EE:":é;E mi" rigs: {'*§€£.§£¥;"£?££1§'3'§'. §§'1aE.. 0:": ::§.<.:<'%z:::,1.m: <3? i:E.":.:'-? i§';§:.::'i€;:2s5~;, hi? Ems}; ':';T:§a:§:;z': i",§"'é:Eé'?%.iE§'E{T'E'}?§ 2:53; :':~:.j;.-;;»:m<;::m; £233" ms:T>:"€: §'.§'§a=2.:: iii :2zm"::.E':.s::~2.. :4m<§<2::;_._:<';§"2a:::= :=_e;m'§;;"e:U_a _§:*€}ifi?§.'€}E' .J Emse; .s€.:2:{,::{T§ ¥'.".Ez2;-'gig Eiztr 23%?' «Ls? §"§'1€,*. <'7E.::é;£§21;2:§Vi." <-3":
2r::*2"1g3z:t:s1*£..€::::£ %>e>§<.m,«' };::':e:~<2. "E'h%;: 'TE':*§'§::;.:.;§2aE'_4 <':j;.;aia§j?E'_;.tf'< f::::v {E1} 21§\;.:e <:{}':':s-;§{.ic3:z'c<:§ ihés p2;:1?::1 2z:":<"}i 22g«:.>:':y°s:.:§i}:%€€i E3}; i=":.§m 'i;ij_éL.'2~:fvi::*:;:.§; 11%"; 5: pcr%<;}t£ <3? €.:*e:2:::::':€;'1€. '-ii_h'<:::f::: w3;'?:;_ £.;:Z"1A7&i_§'E}§}j§¢}f2?i§,i{.§}'} ii}? Eeégq 'i'E1é-3 {:.§;?:§:":1:m€{_ .:j;:§g:»§i':_:;""'§=::}§v§:':_§;p::%'i:f;E:'V'"<:<::§1:%§dez';:E:3E%3 {,7 0 FE "v'"€;"'yE'3;§3 {T26 ,
22.n2<}:,1m §.{§W'::'£.1*{§S m<:;:'§§.:7.<:'z:;§7' :%Xj§§€;%:%"' V:
m=:>:1r.i$12.i.mg;§ _..:?::%{T;_;{§_'. 2;1:';a:*i 2.8if<:?§"§.{§§ifi_§, V' v{?:h:a;:_°g;es=.'--; du:'i2':§;_{ E"E'1_€ ;::=é:z"i<:::i of '*;:.'z'%.52?z.j§;,.:f:z€{:'é:. ;j§é':.«ji am iihcs; a{iv.i5:~;e:: <9? €;he::~ £}<><':€.<)r he z':1*£;;%2'a: §<7ea<;?§:% i.2:k€:%:'1 'i:§:;=f€§..A_f:':%'§ 2:::'f:<:E §%}1§<>w 1.: g} §'.E"€:3éi'EE1"§{?3'}{7, Ebar §"z;;'z,.2_:*-- :i::<};':1.§i:5;:_, 'éfléiz ;é:':2:%€§:,::':.§: {:5 '%E1e:: :13; i.:§"i€8 5:~;:,:$§:z?zi.§:é3{§ by E':§:*:;":§ me 36334;; §;:4:s'"§%}':%::<,E ps?r:';:'za:2{;é'§':E' {.§§S§éE%;:f}§E'i§.}' emfi. Ei§{><':":*<}::"
{i.§s;z.:b§§i:::; Eff: ms? =1j?>{'§i€;'*;§'T3 5 $3" £353?/£2 Ea éhszé iE&t<§--'i,_ §ii§i;%?'E{f'é".§§~:§.":E§T}, £153 :'.':':a% :'§g_§;E:'{: §<;aa:-11:? §§:':3..E} ziimd 2:3: 2 E f§..{f;= E1h€:f:r.--é9-%?§'2{}§{'f E::{7;{%§;" E-'?'z.::*':'E':ér§; 2:5 :a;é..:>:2é'£:<.E €§2;e:€', 2*§.z*E'i§E:::?éa?;§. §3E§;:_§;}5 §Ei§:.:;:ni.'§ Hi: %§'E{? s:+:s'§z2:':'2g:;% 3:2":-':s:E §'22:§=»:» :15"; '£125? :"%::';";.E;>z;<::a:'--ai§: . »3;":£'=£:% s'a:*:;':.= {'1}? é"§va' 2,2,I;r'";<E §'":<":- §"':2::s:e; E0 s,;*%_T.':§"'i"':"-:.=.:' %:§"'m*:=.s xxmvymv».v.vA'2;1'L\3R'u>5.\'£5}\1'¢)N\'9lQ3( waazm mg» ,,.,.Mm..',M;,,mM W ' ~' ;:2:"2.<.3é'..}':€;' 3:91'? 3,;-«':':*2im_~:=.:. 'W'i_f'§.'2 Ei'::}m"ii}-»' {er} Ezim iii; 1a~'i.€:§'1{'E"';;:w §':.E':«:% §E3E(i?§'£."§'~f{. 2-::"<e:"'§":.::=?::§ {)2} ii, p:;*;'éz3<:'§§<".2i§§};.:, "§"'§'::é3?~ :"::=.:zm§:':i'§'2<"¥ {iii 'E/E': '2v§§'§': '_H'{"} :$<::z:"':i1'::.1:';2-i'§:3é;:'- i:'1::'{%r«:3=%§;%. 5-4:£':;"s_..§E ha E'{?.§é'.'.';%S§é*f{'§ 2}: fa_::£>:1_z* :'_:s§_' E1;*:e:* <43 :~.':.;1m §':.»T;:":'i?f, ~§.iji':f T'?V;i.i'i§:;¢';¢'§f_Mj';';»x', {E13 :it.':g.}{}ses.§_£'. E133; mg-=_=.~ §Z'§$£Z'£"{f%.i*$;. '§'.§':€* E-{::{g§.£:;E'z*}I is {§I§.E°{?€'.?v'§'€"f{."§'» ':0 :'¥;'é§1"i::'i':E--5E§':{?;: E1}'H<}é§}"};E {ie%§:>:3s:--:E§',»:*<;§ Es}: ziw. {Tf<:}:'f;;;is:.:jai..Emi'E.:':{E'./E}§3f.}T':;._%$£(_"}.é%§¥%€§§ /A'2{3'§{§ H3 Ehé'? C{)I'§f}€} "ElE§§€}§E ;.:><%§°s;ss..:-:12;-2.113.: ':31? E§%:;'€:=:,:;;;_?':._ ;§:.i§~. 2é_':.:':TE'z.<3:'is;q%d <::§fi<::'%:*. €1:.}::*'€":§%'m.»-'i Eh .
Ei'};'2:;va;»*' iéwi? :
\\« -