Karnataka High Court
K. Manjunath vs The Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike on 8 October, 2020
Author: R Devdas
Bench: R.Devdas
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 08TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2020
BEFORE
THE HON' BLE MR.JUSTICE R.DEVDAS
WRIT PETITION NO.3437/2020 (S-REG)
Between
1. K. Manjunath
S/o Kallappa
No. 03145, Working as Pourakarmika
Aged about 47 years
Dasarahalli, Bytarayanapura,
Bangalore.
2. P.Narayana
S/o Late Varadappa
Aged 45 years
Employee ID No 04523
AEE Kodigehalli Sub Division
Bytarayanapura Zone, Bangalore.
3. R Raju
S/o Ramaswamy
Aged about 43 years
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee No : 04470
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
4. Sundar Raj
S/o Late David
Aged about 56 years
Employee No : 04463
-2-
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
5. C Narayanasingh
S/o Late Chandra Singh
Working as Pourakarmika
Aged about 46 years
Employee No 04491
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
6. Venkatesh
S/o Late Lakshmaiah
Working as Pourakarmika
Aged about 47 years
Employee No : 02971 Bytarayanapura
Bangalore.
7. Lakkappa
S/o Late Gangappa
Working as Pourakarmika
Aged about 51 years
Employee No : 02960
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
8. Sampath
S/o Late Narasimaiah
Aged about 46 years
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee No : 03185
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
9. Murugan
S/o late Govindaraju
Working as Pourakarmika
Aged about 55 years
Employee No: 02914
-3-
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
10. Harish
S/o Late Karivenkatappa
Working as Pourakarmika
Aged about 35 years
Employee No : 03201
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
11. Govindaraju
S/o Rangaswamaiah
Working as Pourakarmika
Aged about 45 years
Employee No : 04669
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
12. Narayanaswamy
S/o Narasimaiah
Working as Pourakarmika
Aged about 53 years
Employee No : 3118
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
13. Kondamma
W/o Kondaiah
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee No : 04508
Aged about 49 years
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
14. Anjinappa M
S/o Late Karemuniyappa
Employee No : 02870
-4-
Working as Pourakarmika
Aged about 53 years
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
15. Gangaraju
S/o Late Hanumanthappa
Working as Pourakarmika
Aged about 52 years
Employee No : 04665
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
16. B Govinda
S/o Late Balappa
Aged about 42 years
Employee ID No : 02789
Working as Pourakarmika
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Bangalore.
17. Gangadhar
S/o Muniyappa
Aged about 50 years
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee ID No : 02912
Dasarahalli Division
Yelahanka Zone
Bangalore.
18. Gurappa
S/o Late Patappa
Aged about 46 years
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee ID No : 02663
Dasarahalli Division
Yelahanka zone, Bangalore.
-5-
19. Akkayamma
W/o Patelappa
Aged about 46 years
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee ID No : 02896
Byatarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
20. Ramappa
S/o Late Chikkappaiah
Aged about 50 years
Employee ID No : 02888
Working as Pourakarmika
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
21. Thimmarayappa H
S/o A Hanumappa
Aged about 48 years
Employee ID No : 03111
Working as Pourakarmika
Bytarayanapura SD,
Yelahanka Zone
Bangalore.
22. Munikrishnamma
W/o Late Munikrishna
Aged about 48 years
Employee ID No : 04503
Working as Pourakarmika
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
23. Govindappa G
S/o Gangappa
-6-
Aged about 48 years
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee ID No : 4499
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
24. Sriram
S/o Nallappa
Aged about 49 years
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee ID No : 02958
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
25. Krishnappa M
S/o Munishamappa Late
Aged about 57 years
Employee ID No : 03561
Working as Gangman
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
26. Venkataramana
S/o Dekappa
Aged 45 years
ID No : 02996 SMM, AEE,
Byatarayanapura zone,
Bangalore
27. Raju
S/o Chikkanna
Aged 44 years
ID No 04676
AEE, Kodigehalli
Bytarayanapura zone, Bangalore.
-7-
28. Thimmarayappa
S/o Late Appanna
Aged about 52 years
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee ID No : 03192
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
29. Munikallappa
S/o Late Chikkadeshappa
Aged about 50 years
Employee ID No: 02976
Working as Pourakarmika
Dasarahalli Sub Division
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
30. Poojappa
S/o Late Munipoojappa
Aged about 56 years
Employee ID No :02661
Working as Pourakarmika
Dasarahalli Sub Division
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
31. Rathnamma. K
S/o Narasimaiah
Age 48 years
Pourakarmika
Employee ID Card No : 04609
Byatarayanapura
Yelahanka zone
32. Padma
W/o Late Subbarayappa
Aged about 46 years
-8-
Employee ID No:03009
Working as Pourakarmika
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
33. Rajanna
W/o Late Shanthappa
Aged about 44 years
Employee ID No: 04971
Working as Pourakarmika
Bytarayanapura Sub division
Yelahanka Zone
Bangalore.
34. Akkayamma.C
W/o Late Chinnappa
Aged about 46 years
Employee ID No: 02984
Working as Pourakarmika
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka Zone
Bangalore.
35. R Munikrishna
S/o Ramanna
Aged about 45 years
Employee ID No: 04459
Working as Pourakarmika
Bytarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka Zone
Bangalore.
36. Sanjeeva
S/o Late Doddalakkanna
Aged about 41 years
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee ID No:
-9-
Sahakar Nagara SD
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
37. Ramakrishna
S/o Late Balaramaiah
Aged about 45 years
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee ID No: 02678
Dasarahalli Sub Division
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
38. M Obalesh
S/o Late Hobalesh
Aged about 44 years
Working as Pourakarmika
MOH Division
Employee ID No : 04478
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
39. Gangamma
S/o Late Narasimaiah,
Aged about 55 years,
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee ID No.04638
Byatarayanapura Sub Division,
Yelahanka zone,
Bangalore.
40. Thimmarayappa
S/o Late Muniyappa,
Aged about 51 years,
ID card No.02658
SM Byararayanapura zone
41. Kanthamma
W/o Muniyappa,
-10-
Aged about 40 years,
Employee ID No.14448
Working as Pourakarmika
Byatarayanapura Sub Division,
Yelahanka zone, Bangalore.
42. Lokesh
S/o Lakshmaiah,
Aged about 48 years,
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee ID No.04672
Sahakar Nagara Sub Division,
Yelahanka zone, Bangalore.
43. Y Raghavendra
S/o Late Raghvaiah,
Aged about 50 years,
Working as Pourakarmika
Employee ID No 04651
Sahakar Nagara Sub Division,
Yelahanka zone,
Bangalore.
44. Munivenkatappa
S/o Thirumalappa,
Poura Karmika,
Employee ID card No.13195
Aged about 51 years,
Dasarahalli Sub Division,
Yelahanka zone.
45. Narayanamma
W/o Kempaiah,
Age 48 years,
Pourakarmika,
Employee ID card No.04645
Byatarayanapura,
Yelahanka zone,
-11-
46. Papanna
S/o Patel Narasimaiah,
Age 57 years, Pourakarmika,
Employee ID card No.03216
Byatarayanapura, Yelahanka zone
47. Muniraju
S/o Late Muniyappa,
Age 53 years,
Pourakarmika
Employee ID card No.02875
Byatarayanapura, Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
48. Narayanaswamy K
S/o Kadirapa,
Age 48 years,
Pourakarmika
Employee ID card No.02768
Byatarayanapura,
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
49. Nagaraju M
S/o Muniyappa,
Age 52 years,
Pourakarmika
Employee ID card No.
Byatarayanapura,
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
50. Anjinappa
S/o Late Balaji,
Age 46 years,
Employee ID Card No.02681
Purakarmika, MOH Office,
-12-
Byatarayanapura,
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
51. Ramakrishna
S/o Doddaramaiah,
Age 48 years,
Pourakarmika
Employee Card No.02674
Rachenahalli, Yelahanka zone
Bangalore.
52. Papaiah
S/o Malaiah,
ID No.4675
Byatarayanapura zone,
Pora Karmika,
Age 34 years
Rachenahalli, Yelahanka zone
Bangalore
53. Reshma R
W/o Rao Sahb, Age: 35,
Pourakrmika,
MoH Kodigehalli SD,
ID No.04630
Bytarayanapura zone
54. Rao Sheb
Poura karmika, Aged 40 years,
ID card No.04633
Byararayanapura Sub Division,
Yelahanka zone, Bangalore
55. M.Venkatesh
S/o Muniyappa, aged 42 years,
Card No.10461
-13-
Pourakarmika,
Mahadevpura zone, Bangalore
56. Shakunthala
W/o Chandrappa
Aged 45 years,
Pourakarmika
ID card No.10570
Mahadevapura zone.
57. M.N.Shivanna
S/o Ningaiah, aged 38 years,
ID No.02504
AEE Vidyaranyapura Sub Division
Byatarayanapura zone, Bangalore.
58. V.Mahalakshmi
W/o Selvaraj,
Aged 42 years,
ID No: 02491
AEE Vidyaranyapura Sub Division
Byatarayanapura zone, Bangalore.
59. Lokesh
S/o Lakshmaiah
ID card : 04672
Poura Karmika, Sahakar Nagara
Byatarayanapura Zone, Bangalore.
60. G.Shivashankar
S/o Late Gangaiah,
Aged about 51 years,
Working as Gangman,
Employee ID No.02312
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike,
AEE Yelahanka New Town Sub Division,
Yelahanka Zone, Bengaluru-560 064
-14-
61. B.A.Narayanaswamy
S/o Late Ananthappa,
Aged about 45 years,
Employee Id No.2315
Working as Gangman,
Bruhat bengaluru mahanagar palike,
AEE Yelahanka New Town, Sub Division,
Yelahanka Zone, Bengaluru-560 064.
62. G.V.Venkataramana
S/o Vemanarayana,
Aged about 43 years,
Working as Gangman,
Employee ID No.2670,
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike
O/o EE Yelahanka Division, Yelahanka Zone,
Bengaluru-560 064.
63. N.Muniraju
S/o Narasimhaiah
Aged about 43 years,
Employee ID No.2318
Working as Gangaman,
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike
AEE Yelahanka New Town Sub Division,
Yelahanka Zone, Bengaluru-560 064.
64. Ansar Khan
S/o Late Lalukhan
Aged about 45 years,
Working as Gangamn,
Employee ID No.2357,
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike
AEE Yelahanka New Town Sub Division,
Yelahanka Zone, Benglauru-560 064
-15-
65. Ravichandra N
S/o Late Narasimhappa
Aged about 50 years,
Working as Gangman, AEE Office,
Kodigehalli Sub Division, Bangalore.
66. H Galappa
S/o Late Hanumanthaiah
Aged about 52 years,
Working as Gangamn
Employee ID card No.
Hegganahalli, Dasarahalli zone
67. M.Muniyappa
S/o Late Mariyappa
Aged about 54 years,
Empl. No.03595
Working as Gangman
Assistant Executive Engineer
Kodigehalli, Bangalore.
68. K.Mallesh
S/o Kenchaiah
Working as Gangman
Aged about 44 years,
Employee ID card No.
Hegganahalli Sub Division
Dasarahalli zone.
69. C.H.Ramesh
S/o Late N Hanumanthappa
Aged 42 years,
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No.1850
Hegganahalli Sub Division
Dasarahalli zone.
-16-
70. K.Rangaswamy
S/o Late Kalappa
Aged 49 years,
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No.5474,
Hegganahalli SD, Dasarahalli zone
71. B Shivanna
S/o Late Bommalingaiah
Working as Gangman
Aged about 49 years,
Employee ID card No.
Hegganahalli SD, Dasarahalli Zone
72. Mylari M
S/o Mallaiah,
Aged about 44 years,
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No.5482
Herohalli Sub Division
Rajarajeshwari zone.
73. D.G.Siddegowda,
S/o Late Ganga Boraiah
Aged about 41 years,
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No.5477
Herohalli Sub Division
Rajarajeshwari Zone.
74. Raju
S/o Late Ramaiah
Aged about 40 years
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No. 5480
Herohalli Sub Division
Rajarajeshwari zone
-17-
75. R Puttaswamy
S/o Ramaswamy
Age 45 years
Gangman
Employee ID card No. 08659
Byatarayanapura Yelahanka zone
76. Shivanna L M
S/o Late Doddaiah
Working as Gangman
Aged about 56 years
Employee ID card No 1858
Hegganahalli Sub Division
Dasarahalli zone
77. D Srinivaiah
S/o Late Doddaramaiah
Working as Gangman
Aged about 47 years
Employee ID card No. 1477
Herohalli Sub Division
Rajarajeshwari zone
78. S Basavaraju
S/o Late Siddegowda
Aged about 50 years
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No
Hegganahalli Sub Division
Dasarahalli zone
79. Gangadhar H M
S/o Siddalingaiah
Age 5 0 years
D group, Employee ID card No .00976
Byatarayanapura Yelahanka zone
-18-
80. Bylappa
S/o Late Muniyappa
Aged about 59 years
Empl. No. 01591
Working as Gangman
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike
O/o AEE Byatarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka Zone Bengaluru - 560092
81. K V Shivarudrappa
S/o Veerabhadrappa
Empl. No. 10202
Aged 48 years
Working as Gangman
Harohalli Kengeri
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike
82. D Rudraiah
S/o Late Kempa Lagaiah
Empl. No. 03560
Aged about 50 years
Working as Gangman
Assistant Executive Engineer
Electrical Sub Division
Bangalore
83. H H Lakkappa
S/o Huchappa
Aged about 57 years
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No 5444
Herohalli Sub Division
Rajarajeshwari zone
84. Malaiah
S/o Ranappa
Aged 52 years,
-19-
Employee ID card No 02278
AEE HMT Layout
Dasarahalli Zone, Bangalore
85. H S Shivaraj
S/o Sannappa
Aged about 47 years
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No 5438
Herohalli Sub Division
Rajarajeshwari Zone
86. R Jayaram
S/o Rangappa
Aged about 46 years
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No 5431
Herohalli Sub Division
Rajarajeshwari zone
87. Ramaiah
S/o Late Hanumaiah
Aged about 54 years
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No 5456
Herohalli Sub Division
Rajarajeshwari zone
88. D Chandrashekar
S/o Dasappa
Aged 41 years
AEE Shettihalli Sub Division
Employee ID card No 01250
Dasarahalli Zone, Bangalore
89. Shivanna L M
S/o Late Mayanna
-20-
Aged about 55 years
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No 1858
Hegganahalli Dasarahalli zone
90. P Rudresh
S/o Chadaksharaiah
ARO Office Beguru
D Group Employee ID card No.02546
Aged about 54 years
Chief Engineer Office
Bommanahali zone
91. Thimmegowda
S/o Kalaiah
Employee ID card No.11779
D group, Aged about 53 years
ARO Office, Utharahalli
Bommanahalli zone
92. Muthaiah
S/o Lingaiah
D group
Employee ID card No.12969
Aged about 51 years
ARO Office
Kengeri Sub Division
93. Bylappa N
S/o Nanjappa
ARO Office Mahalakshmi Layout
Employee ID card No.05327
Aged about 54 years
Chief Engineer Office
R R Nagara zone
-21-
94. B R Devaraju
S/o Rangegowdru B L
Working as Gangman
Aged about 42 years
Employee ID card No.01508
Dasarahalli zone
95. H Somashekar
S/o Huchegowda
Aged 38 years
Employee ID card No.01893
ARO Office, Shettihalli
96. T Ramesh
S/o Thimmegowda
Aged 38 years
Employee ID card No.01893
AEE Office Shettihalli
97. C B Krishnappa
S/o Late Bajaiah
Aged 39 years
Employee ID card No.1468
AEE Office Shettihalli
J C Office, Dasarahalli
98. M R Ranganatha
S/o Rangappa
Aged 53 years
ID card No.1936
AEE Hegganahalli
Dasarahalli Sub Division
99. L Ramachandra
S/o Late M Lakshmaiah
Aged 52 years
ARO Shettihalli
-22-
Dasarahalli zone
Employee ID card No.12978
100. Anjina Murthy T
S/o Late Thippaiah
Aged about 49 years
Working as Gangman
Empl No.03467
Aged about 41 years
MOH Office, Yelahanka
Byatarayanapura
Bangalore
101. H K Rudraiah
S/o Kempalagaiah
Project Division
Byatarayanapura
ID card No.03560
Bangalore
102. K V Rajanna
S/o Late Venkatarayappa
Aged about 48 years
Empl No.02874
Working as Gangman
Chief Engineer Office
Yelahanka Zone
Byatarayanapura
Bangalore
103. P Anjinappa
S/o Late Pillappa
Aged about 41 years
Empl No.03497
Working as Gangman
Joint Commissioner
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagra Palike
-23-
Yelahanka Zone
Bangalore
104. Suresh Babu B M
S/o Late Munishamappa
Empl No.02565
Aged about 53 years
Assistant Executive Engineer
Byatarayanapura
Bangalore
105. Joseph
S/o Late Rama Murthy
Aged about 38 years
Empl No.03476, Gangman
BBMP, O/o AEE, Byatarayanapura SD
Yelahanka Zone
Bengaluru-560092
106. Munikrishna
S/o Late Ramaiah
Empl No.03563
Aged about 44 years
Working as Gangman
AEE Office
Byataranapura
Bangalore
107. Y S Rangashetty
S/o Late Shivananjashetty
Aged about 51 years
Empl No.03482
Bruhat Begnaluru Mahanagara Palike
O/o AEE, Byatarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka zone
Bengaluru-560092
-24-
108. Muthappa
S/o Late Erasappa
Aged about 53 years
Empl No.03608
Working as Gangman
Assistant Executive Engineer
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike
AEE Byatarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka zone, Bengaluru
109. Srinivas N
S/o Narasimaiah
Aged about 39 years
Empl No.02511
Working as Gangman
MOH Office
Byatarayanpura
Yelahanka zone
Bangalore
110. Krishnappa
S/o Late Munishamappa,
Aged about 57 years,
Workign as Gangman,
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahangara Palike,
O/o AEE, Byatarayanapua Sub-Division,
Yelahanka Zone, Bengaluru 560092
111. Murthy (Narasimha Murthy),
S/o Late Devaraj, Aged 38 years,
ID card No 3664,
AEE Office, Byatarayanapura zone,
Bengaluru
112. A Narayanaswamy
S/o Late Anjanappa,
Aged about 53 years,
-25-
Working as Gangman, BBMP,
EE Byatarayanapura Division,
Yelahanka Zone, Bengluru 560092
113. M Krishna
S/o Late Muniyappa,
Aged about 45 years,
Working as Gangman, BBMP
O/o AEE, Byatarayanapura Sub-Division,
Yelahanka Zone Benglauru 560092
114. H S Raveesh
S/o Somashekar,
Empl.No.03025,
Aged about 41 years,
Gangman, Assistant Executive Engineer
Project Sub division,
Byatarayanapura, Bangalore
115. Narasegowda
S/o Marishamaiah,
Aged about 39 years,
Empl.No.014454,
Workign as Gangman,
Yelahanka Zone Office,
Byatarayanapura, Bangalore
116. Ashwathaiah
S/o Late Dasappa,
Aged about 50 years,
Empl.No.02994,
Working as Gangman,
Assistant Executive Engineer,
Administrative Section, Bangalore
117. A Gurumurthy
S/o Avalappa,
-26-
Aged about 39 years,
Empl.No.03519,
Workign as Gangman,
Administrative Office Yelahanka Zone,
Byatarayanapua, Bangalore
118. Srinivas Murthy S
S/o Late Shivashankar,
Aged about 47 years,
Empl.No.02468,
Working as Gangman, AEE Office,
Administrative Section, Bangalore
119. Narasimha Murthy
S/o Late Obalappa,
Aged about 31 years,
Empl.No.03502, BBMP
O/o AEE, Byatarayanapura Sub-Division,
Yelahanka Zone, Bengaluru-560092
120. Shakil Ahmed
S/o Late Abdul Majid,
Working as Gangman,
Empl. No.03527,
Aged about 55 years,
AEE Office,
Byataranapura Bangalore
121. M Rajappa
S/o Late Muniyappa,
Aged about 49 years,
Empl.No.03495,
Working as Gangman
Assistant Executive Engineer,
Byatarayanapura Sub Division,
Byatarayanapua, Yelahanka Zone,
Bangalore
-27-
122. Ashwath Reddy
S/o Late Hanumanth Reddy,
Emp.No.03126,
Working as Gangman,
Aged about 51 years,.
Administrative Section,
Byataranapura, Yelahanka,
Bangalore
123. Shankarguru
S/o Jayaramappa,
Workign as Gangman,
Aged about 44years,
Employee ID card No. 13280,
A Narayanapura Division,
Mahadevapura Zone
124. A Ganesh
S/o Abbaiah,
Gangman,
Aged about 49 years,
Employee ID card No 13862,
A Naraynapura Division,
Mahadevapura Zone
125. Munigurappa
S/o Jayaramappa J,
Aged about 44 years,
Working as Gangman,
Employee ID card No.12128,
A Narayanapura Division,
Mahadevapura Zone
126. Ramakrishna
S/o Munivenkatappa,
Aged about 49 years,
-28-
Working as Gangman,
Employee ID card No.13774,
A Narayanapura Division,
Mahadevapura Zone
127. Shankar M
S/o Muniyappa,
Working as Gangman,
Aged about 40 years,
Employee ID card No 10864,
A Narayanapura Division,
Mahadevapura Zone
128. Muniraju M
S/o Mylarappa,
Aged about 54 years,
Working as Gangman,
Employee ID card No 14187,
A Narayanapura Division,
Mahadevapura Zone
129. Chayakumar
S/o Late Gaviyappa
Aged about 28 years
Working as Gangman
Employee ID No.11967
White field, Ramagondanahalli Sub Division
Mahadevapura Zone
130. P Sayed Muneed
S/o Parijan
Aged about 55 years
Working as Gangman
Employee ID No.11955
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
-29-
131. S M Shamaraju
S/o Muniswamy M
Aged about 41 years
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No.11950
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura zone
132. Venkatesh R
S/o Nagappa
Working as Gangman
Aged about 35 years
Employee ID card No.11952
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
133. Venkatappa
S/o Hanumanthappa
Aged about 44 years
Working as Gangman
Employee ID No.12125
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
134. Anbalagan G
S/o Govindaraju
Gangman
Aged about 41 years
Employee ID card No.13095
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
135. Naraynappa G
S/o Gullappa
Working as Gangman
Aged about 53 years
Employee ID card No.12129
-30-
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
136. Krishnappa V
S/o Venkataramappa
Aged about 54 years,
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No.
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
137. H H Govindashetty
S/o Krishnashetty H P
Working as Gangman
Aged about 54 years
Employee Id card No.13738
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura zone
138. Naga
S/o Narayanappa
Working as Gangman
Aged about 37 years,
Employee Id card No.13921
Marathalli Sub Division
Mahadevapura Zone
139. Gundappa
S/o Late Papayya
Working as Gangman
Aged about 55 years
Employee ID No.11956
Mahadevapura Zone
140. R Balu
S/o Ramu
Gangman
-31-
Aged bout 45 years
Employee ID card No.13925
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
141. M Srinivasa
S/o Muniachari
Gangman
Aged about 45 years
Employee Id card No.13920
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
142. V Srinivas
S/o Venkataswamy
Gangman
Aged about 43 years
Employee Id card No.13919
A Narayanapura Division
Maha devapura Zone
143. J N Venkatesh
S/o Narayanappa
Gangman
Aged about 44 years
Employee Id card No.10433
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
144. J Muralimohan
S/o Jagadeesh
Gangman
Aged about 41 years
Employee Id card No.13601
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
-32-
145. Ramachandrappa
S/o Late Annaiah
Gangman
Aged about 58 years
Employee ID card No.11449
Varthuru Sub Division
Mahadevapura Zone
146. P Devaraj
S/o Puttappa
Working as Gangman
Aged about 46 years
Employee Id card No.13602
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
147. Hanumappa
S/o Ankareddy
Aged about 59 years
Working as Gangman
Employee Id card No.13926
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
148. Thirumalaiah
S/o Narasaiah
Gangman
Aged about 45 years
Employee Id Card No 13927
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
149. P Ramesh
S/o Papaiah
Gangman
Aged about 45 years
Employee ID card No. 13924
-33-
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
150. Krishnappa
S/o Munishamappa
Gangaman
Aged about 49 years,
Employee ID card No. 13922
A Narayanapura Division,
Mahadevapura Zone
151. Muninarayanappa
S/o Muniyappa
Gangman
Aged about 48 years,
Employee ID card No. 13929
A Narayanapura Division,
Mahadevapura Zone
152. T S Ganeshappa
S/o Late Sevlla Muthu
Working as Gangman
Aged about 54 years
Employee ID No. 12127
Mahadevapura Zone
153. B T Venkataramanappa
S/o Thirumalappa
Working as Gangman
Aged about 49 years,
Employee ID No. 12116
Mahadevapura Zone
154. Krishnappa M
S/o Mayanna
Gangman
Aged about 41 years,
-34-
Employee ID card No. 10604
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura zone
155. K Siddaraju
S/o Narasimaiah
Working as Gangman
Aged about 46 years,
Employee ID card No. 12124
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
156. Balu P
S/o Mariyanna
Aged about 44 years
Working as Gangman
Employee ID card No.12121
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura zone
157. Muniraju K
S/o Krishnappa
Working as Gangman
Aged about 50 years
Employee ID Card No.13737
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
158. Nagaraj S/o Late Muthappa
Working as Gangman
Aged 38 years
Employee ID card No. 14099
Mahadevapura Zone
159. Srinivas V
S/o Venkateshappa
Gangman
-35-
Aged about 30 years
Employee ID card No. 13606
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
160. Narayanaraju
S/o Lakshman Raju
Aged 38 years,
Site No. 11055
Mahadevapura Zone
Bangalore
161. Ramesh Reddy
S/o Goplaiah Reddy
Working as Gangman
Aged about 44 years
Employee ID No. 11958
K R Puram Sub Division
Mahadevapura Zone
162. Nagaraju P
S/o Late Narasappa
Working as Gangman
Aged about 53 years
Employee ID No. 14098
K R Puram Sub Division
Mahadevapura Zone
163. Gundappa
S/o Narayanagowda
Working as Gangman
Aged about 37 years
Employee ID card No.11956
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura zone
-36-
164. Narendra Kumar
S/o Ramaiah
Gangman
Aged about 34 years
Employee ID card No. 12126
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
165. Kempaiah
S/o Shambaiah
Aged 39 years
Site No. 13581
Mahadevapura Zone
Bangalore
166. Shekhar
S/o Gurappa
Gangman
Aged about 49 years
Employee ID card No. 13604
Varthuru Sub Division
167. Yellappa
S/o Gundappa
Gangman
Aged about 38 years
Employee ID card No.13500
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura zone
168. Ramachandra
S/o Hanumanthaiah
Working as Gangman
Aged about 51 years
Employee ID card No.13776
A Narayanpura Division
Mahadevapura zone
-37-
169. Prakash M
S/o Muniyappa
Gangman
Aged about 35 years
Employee ID card No.13579
A Narayanapura Division
Mahaedevapura Zone,
170. M Manjunath
S/o Muniyappa
Gangman
Aged about 38 years
Employee ID card No.13578
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura zone
171. Chinnappa D
S/o Dasappa
Gangaman
Aged about 48 years
Employee ID card No
Varthuru Sub Division
Mahadevapura Zone
172. T Venkatesh
S/o Thundaplpa
Gangman
Aged about 40 years
Employee ID card No.11954
Varthuru Sub Division
Mahadevapura Zone,
173. K R Ramachandra
S/o Late Ramaiah (OOD TI)
Aged about 51 years
Employee ID card No 02338
-38-
K R Puram Sub Division
Mahadevapura Zone
174. Prakash A
S/o Antoniraj
Gangman
Aged about 51 years
Employee ID card No. 11056
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
175. Ramesh
S/o Hanumantharayappa
Gangaman
Aged about 43 years
Employee ID card No.10788
Varthuru Sub Division, Mahadevapura Zone
176. B K Chandrappa
S/o Ramappa
Age 38 years
Driver
Employee ID Card No.
Byatarayanapura, Yelahanka Zone
177. Manjunatha C
S/o Chikkamanchaiah
Aged about 41 years
(OOD SDC)
Employee ID card No.03391
K R Puram Sub Division
Mahadevapura Zone
178. Muniraju N
S/o Late Narayanashetty
Gangman
Aged about 44 years
-39-
Employee ID card No. 02857
K R Puram Sub Division
Mahadevapura Zone,
179. Muthuraj M T
S/o Late Muthaiah
(OOD SDC)
Aged about 57 years
Employee ID card No.05123
K R Puram Sub Division
Mahadevapura Zone
180. Muniraju C
S/o Chikkamuniyappa
Aged about 49 years
Gangman
Employee ID card No. 05891
K R Puram Sub Division Mahadevapura Zone
181. C Siddaiah
S/o Chikkahanumaiah
Working as gangman
Aged about 44 years
Employee ID card No. 10794
A Narayanapura Division
Mahadevapura Zone
182. Y G Narasimha Murthy
S/o Late Gopalappa
Aged about 51 years
Employee ID No.02691
Working as Gangman
Bruhath Bengaluru Mahangara Palike
O/o EE Yelahanka Zone, Bengaluru 560 064.
183. A Muniraju
S/o Anjinappa aged 43 years
-40-
ID card No.1796
Dasarahalli Zone Bangalore
184. M Ramesh
S/o Mudda Ramaiah
Aged 38 years
ID card No.01774
ACF Section Dasarahalli Zone,
Bangalore
185. Siddaiah C
S/o Chikkahanumaiah
Aged 38 years
D group
ID card No.10794
K R Puram, Mahadevpura Zone
186. Lakshmi Narasimha Murthy
S/o Venkata Narayanappa
Aged 48 years,
ID No.02280
Byatarayanapura Zone
187. L C Nanjunda
S/o Chowdappa
Aged 42 years,
ID No.03670
AEE Dasarahalli Byatarayanapura Zone
188. Chandra
S/o Late Kodiyappa
Aged 41 years,
ID No.63069
AEE Kodigehalli Byatarayanapura Zone
189. Jagannath R
S/o Ramaiah aged 38 years,
-41-
ID No.03580
AEE Kodigehalli Byatarayanapura Zone
190. Thippanna V
S/o Venkatappa
Aged 44 years,
ID No.2715
AEE Yelahanka Old Town
Byatarayanapura Zone
191. K Suresh
S/o P Kosu
Aged 44 years,
ID card No.03219
D group EE Electrical Byatarayanapura
192. Venkatesh M
S/o M Muniyappa
Aged about 43 years,
ID card No.03208
EE Electrical Byatarayanapura Zone
193. G Satish
S/o Govindappa
Age 41 years,
ID No.02407
EE Electricals Byatarayanapura Zone
194. Srinivas
S/o Late Sanjevappa
Aged about 51 years,
Working as Driver Assistant Revenue Officer
Kodigehalli Bangalore
195. Siddalingaiah C
S/o Late Chennaiah
Aged about 52 years,
-42-
Working as Driver
Executive Engineer
Byatarayanapura Bengaluru
196. M Nagaraju
S/o Muniyellappa
Empl No.02966
Aged about 34 years,
Driver Assistant Executive Engineer
Byatarayanapura Bangalore
197. C Muniraju
S/o Late Chikkapaiah
Aged about 47 years,
Empl. No.02834
Working as driver
Administrative Byatarayanapura
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike
198. Narayanappa
S/o Late Hanumantha Rayappa
Aged about 53 years,
Empl. No.03682
Working as driver
Assistant Executive Engineer
Sold Waste Management
Byatarayanapura Bangalore
199. Narasimha P
S/o Late Poojappa
Aged about 48 Years,
Empl. No.03470
Working as Driver AEE Office
Kodigehalli Bangalore
200. M Narasimaiah
S/o Marishamaiah
-43-
Aged about 47 years,
Empl. No.02268 Driver,
Yelahanka Zone Office
Byatarayanapura Bangalore
201. Nagaraja
S/o Hanumanthaiah
Employee ID card No.02301
Driver, aged about .. Years,
Chief Engineer Office
R R Nagara Zone
202. H B Ramachandraiah
S/o Bachgowda
Driver, aged about 51 years,
Employee ID card No.05328
Executive Engineer Office Project
R R Nagara Rajarajeshwari Nagara Zone
203. Krishnaiah T
S/o Thimmaiah
Driver
Aged about 53 years,
Employee ID card No.08595
Executive Engineer Office Project
R R Nagara Rajarajeshwari Nagara Zone
204. Ananthrao
S/o Naresh,
Aged about 51 years,
ID card No.12970
ARO Office,
Kengeri Sub Division
205. G Shivaraju
S/o Late Gangaiah
Aged about 45 years,
-44-
Driver, Employee ID card No.07694
Mahadevapura Zone
J C Office
206. M C Vasanthamurthy
S/o Late Channaveerappa
41 years, ID card No.12324
Bommanahalli Zone
207. Jayaramrao
S/o Ramachandra Rao
Aged 39 years, ID card No.01401
Dasarahalli Zone
208. M G Srinivas
S/o Gururaj
Aged 41 years, ID card No.10652
Dasarahalli Zone
209. B Nagappa
S/o Late Basavaraju
Aged 39 years, ID card No.01842
Dasarahalli Zone
210. D Chandrashekar
S/o Durgappa
Aged 45 years,
ID card No.132
Yelahanka Zone
Byatarayanapura
211. K Mohan Kumar
S/o Late Krishnappa
Aged about 30 years, Driver
Employee ID card No.07979
Mahadevapura Zone
J C Office
-45-
212. Vsridhara
S/o Late Venkatappa
Employee, ID card No.13263
Aged 38 years,
Bommanahalli Zone
213. M Venkatesh
S/o Munisubbaiah
Aged 55 years, Driver,
Employee card ID card No.12033
Chief Engineering Office
Mahadevapura Zone
214. H V Nagaveni
W/o Munegowda
Aged about 44 years,
Employee ID No.2662
Working as Computer Operator, BBMP
O/o EE, Yelahanka Zone
Bengaluru-560 064
215 Geetha P
W/o Channabasappa
Aged about 39 years,
Computer Operator
Employee ID No.2287
AEE, Yelahanka New Town Sub Division
Yelahanka Zone
Bengaluru-560 064
216. B R Shylaja
W/o B N Amruthesh Kumar
Age 54 years, Typist
ID No.00812
Yelahanka Zone
Byatarayanapura
-46-
217. Premalatha G
D/o Gangappa
Age 41 years,
Computer Operator
ID Card No.03282
Byatarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka Zone
218. Uma Devi B
D/o Basavaraju
Aged 45 years,
Telephone Operator
Byatarayanapura SD
Yelahanka Zone
Bangalore
219. Suma Balakrishnan
W/o R Rajeshwaran
Aged 38 years,
Telephone Operator
ID Card No.02163
Byatarayanapura SD
Yelahanka Zone
Bangalore
220. Puttegowda K V
S/o Late Venkatesh
Aged 52 years,
Driver, Byatarayanapura Sub Division
Yelahanka Zone
Bangalore
221. Prakash M K
S/o Krishnappa
Aged 36 years,
ID Card No.16044
CE Electrical, Byatarayanapura Zone
-47-
222. Honnaraju
S/o Late Honnaiah
Aged 57 years,
Tax Inspector
ARO Marathallai
Mahadevapura zone
... Petitioners
(By Sri.Ravivarma Kumar Senior counsel for
Sri.G.Sharada Bai., Advocate)
And
1. The Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike.
Represented by its Commissioner,
N.R.Circle,
Bangalore - 560 002
2. The Mayor,
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike,
N.R.Circle,
Bangalore - 560 002.
... Respondents
(By Sri.Ashwin S.Halady, Advocate)
This Writ Petition is filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India praying to direct the respondent
corporation to regularize the services of the petitioners
by implementing the resolution No.311/2014-15 vide
Annexure-A dated 28.01.2015 passed unanimously,
and to provide them with all consequential service
benefits from the date of their joining the various
respective municipal councils/village panchayats, by
virtue of their absorption into the respondent
corporation, and etc.,
-48-
This Petition coming on for Preliminary Hearing -
'B' Group this day, the Court made the following:
ORDER
R. DEVDAS J., (ORAL):
Learned Senior counsel Sri.Ravivarma Kumar, appearing for the petitioners draws the attention of this Court to the prayer made in I.A.1/2020 which was filed on 18.09.2020. It is stated in the prayer that the respondent-Administrator has issued Government order dated 21.08.2020 published on 27.08.2020 in the Official Gazette regularizing the services of some of the employees of the erstwhile municipalities and Nagara Palikes now merged into Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike. Learned Senior counsel submits that it is an admitted fact that the petitioners herein also are erstwhile employees of the municipalities and Nagara Palikes being merged with the B.B.M.P way back in the year 2007. Therefore, learned Senior counsel submits -49- that this matter may be disposed of with a direction to the respondent-administrator of the B.B.M.P. to consider the cases of the petitioners in the light of the representation made by them and keeping in view the recent Government Order dated 21.08.2020 passed by the State Government with reference to similarly placed persons.
2. In the light of the submission made by the learned Senior counsel, this petition stands disposed of with a direction to the respondent-administrator of B.B.M.P. to consider the representation made by the petitioners on 03.08.2018, 03.11.2018 and 14.11.2018 at Annexure-C series along with the recent Government order bearing No.NaAE 563 MNY 2014 dated 21.08.2020 published in the State Official Gazette on 27.08.2020. The respondent-Administrator, of B.B.M.P is required to consider the representation and pass orders as expeditiously as possible and at any rate -50- within a period of two months from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
Sd/-
JUDGE GPG/VN