Karnataka High Court
Bapu S/O Satalingappa Narsar vs The State Of Karnataka on 8 February, 2011
Author: H.S.Kempanna
Bench: H.S.Kempanna
"'E"E~§E¥: E"E§€f.§.'§-E iff;{.?EJ'" : \ {T E E ii; E} E"? E5 ESEE {LL "E935 E {E U gag" F§"7§§"§'§§E' ?*'%'§"§§*_f,§§EV'%€";'%:§€§'_§.m,}E%" "
B ECTE s'E§Z7?;;T'~J {$1233 :5;'s:} :éz*§:§:'A§,§Ix:'<:';z>g:<T%;J;iga :*~4'.;x%%:sif:;§§:'- - [':{2E?,: 24 ';;'"§'<Z_/':R:'~}._ SCCI: A51 T3'iE%3E:}vE:;'§U «war: <3:,3E3§':3»:«:wAm V: -;z§?Z;a:.§~?a;::?:
T A. §'}E;E?§?: {Y 3 E,.'%7':"=P:E3;i'?g"a;" .
(:12? EERE 5:3: §:..;ir;.rx fig J «Y 3-1-=_.E}§_l*«;L¢ 3%}-{E-'3 E.§.§."ZE"~JFiZ.",E"--33 ?' V ' " ' E---3E-<':"'§'§"§"E€iiE?e1E2313 :3:%*:':'I::<:.;;
E E:*1E':;Z£'*>f3»':4'§§§"'f§ "§"{]73. {'.f2§»3.£7':..T'%§'§.:' "E"'§1§§<Z x ,,./2»,.:
'if 3?: E. EC' 5} Pi '«.jé.éé22r2.>;;:°a._§se E;-':2':<"%. %.:§*:%:-;.
k x.) W» » W:
>--.--"
nvflmql m r'"
.1 "W .....n mama:
rem-M flu M:
K 1 PW M 2 we 9' J3 \ >""Vo 1 x M L x WM"( ./-"4 .--.m u .1 Mme.
'~../ » WW! .1 /""'\ aw?
aw :
wk:
W4' ,2 mm m-.:
'PW a ;
W» mm mm *2 M?"
J WW 5' ,m.
4'H 2'?
5-.
\ W< N' A .» x. u M'-um ,....
-':_'§--§'::%¥; §>§~:':'*:"§"2<__::;'=«,.I éifeiféiz/§§§EE<"2 {.2221 §;«%:::':':e:--2; ;:Ii;§%:§§E__: T"
.§...fi::?a':'i "Em-'«:. {f>§_EE€i'E' ?2%i}E-ii E-42:";L:,<._t:::r§' v:--. "
[n':""' > V '7 .35 "' ' " (V, ' V', ,_1 3' ~._ ., 2,; :a§:_3<, REE}? § 7; ,4 3%; 2%,} 'Q -bi ,-.E2f--.x:;_~.g§_;_};g;_ gi-\}m_.C 5§:§-;;'é_m{m§ E,"€_Tf§;_fif~,~}'{.é?E"{'?{'E Z343 Q fiifiq §,§§';.m€' '" ' 2"::>{§;' w<f:§E 7i:a<3'§::'ws;%a:':': "if zI'a'L%€;' §_:3<"2:~";§§:€$:::':& §«f§--,'§2EL"'_{_;s'§ "
izizss :n:.:m2;T}E;2§§':;2=1::% ;_':::'*{}<'a.%z.=:"§§§:g;
mzzz 1,.-">g'§."é;i..3§'§;.__i,§1¢.§V:z£':*_g" 222=~;%I ;:';r:: émi:<"§ ;.2:;;.<::'TE 41;:3a%sai";%.:.::ev<'§_ ;.::':s wk E3:-;§E"§3 "x _"fr :53: %§:z;'* ;;32;:E.%'1.x%;;.1}=* ;_'2:':<E. =:%:2':2:::sem;% :'>§i:3:«'.='éI:"i...E{'.%LEQEE. ;2:':<§ sea;
r 2a<t<éa..a:s;::,<.§ ;'%----i2'; 2:::;.a'i E';-~.{.§ 'ax-"§ss;.:& 1-'«.,:'a>:"s': 2; f é;§':s: {'t:;'>mpfaa-:'i':':;e..:':?L éfiééi asma';f:2§_§; é.E:«:=:::':'é'«¢s7':¥§__§ 1 é::;.'L 33 3 _é?:<.i ' _ "£5"; § "a.;é;,~*-:.';' _{1§{4'v-adé:: :-%;.' "'§Z3§;f1:r%%.-' I; VA 7;%::='a.E.§] ii: 3':-:2: :a=s::»;a:.<'§' 24-;f;..:§.§_.?f;T;2.:1{E:_%d s:.§".{?2};§é":"; ._ 'iEf:%:: , =;n_g§ E snééé wig':
' 2":{_:>i 2&2-3%} E'}if*§.ii»'i'é'E'§ §:é;'*%::éTi%;uz.:%-3?':" gsszcé 2:»?
;1.i'§é;>§g%::{é N3 2-z:::;£:;2s::E'§:r:;% Em: <v:..>:":':;::27:2:%:':2,::2%: E':.2--aw: '2,>--=':s;-*2:
if §;§<ii= §i,.':§"'?:§"'::1':"§° s:az:'€;';é:'§.*:é'é_§.<"»<'§ E-E--§(E:1¢':%.-5 in {E 2...: {E 6 5""! {I§{'<f'.§E'E"§"'é:¥EE{f{'fi. %E':%_5'~s §.2m;':.:.:;>2aa;::" f%."::,.a;E £12.'? ihéi: E':;.':;::1~:E:'~::a <35 i;'%:§.::-é. :=.{';_;':':;§§;_=3:;a_:m: 2-'駻";»;"§ A~%jZ§::1':f;._ Q"
m:'":'£s:::».{§ :.:.:":%;.i<%.§p;aéE133; E'.:«;--:3'; bf; $E":{f m'i::=;{'%§c'E"§<::'*:;;.:;E §%'§«:fié>a:§;iTa_>:3;:;.se_V "Eng: E'é.;'::.&»; 23133:: '§':éEa%{.'§ e:?{'m'ég.:sE;.:i§:§: 2=;':'§'_§;"?;"~W§:s"}r f?§¢'i:T:'Z:-2' _§:§<3i§a::>;fwzzsis égisss E'»3'<'s, '§?8;':'?:{1%L%_{3 ;:m{:i ":':;'we;3 €'.V:;2_T§:=-%;':%'§1'é_L._:.:§§§v i; "s"V :5-;z2,i_a:% ca.:~'se, V. %:;2s%s:;':'V g:_;::"at<.s§é.£ai';% zmaé VL éjjwgs <;>§"EE?:i:.'":a%z£rs::; ;i'<:<:' "%'};:vc 32'}2i{?i§i§§Z"'{.}'i.%'i"§£§ WE.i:§<1:é§':
L051' ;T::'2a:'§. as éhéit <%:'>:::§§:§:;sE3[:;;::':i =-s ;--2'a.:§ia'j_J é;'s'l%:f:?m.:.:~.e §§'Ej"a§E"jJ, 3L',§:'":a%: g}@:§.§:"%{;»:1<_é:" %;:a::
"S::'§V:{'?"%;t:A';a>'2?; *~'s.;'.%,€E': :+1s'é2i§<:,.§aé §:.'§:é:'% '%:'".%il'{"i§i w'i':§a':§'7» ':::<;s.:':_:: 22':.:§'[:<?.§ €:.'E:{.% '%:~&§E%.,a:a:.";s;r..:" '%*:;':..:%s .. /-
"".:»:'}::2V'pEai§r::'a23'": A. E1": '%.'..§.':i&>s 'i'_i£'i§?§é'f° Tizafi n':;-z*;',s23"§;2.E vi??? 1':':E{'*.O%..:
§;T1(>%'1. gmzfii-.;': E':ims:;€:§§ :1-w222.%i;:E3E:;é> 21:} §§'1é': §:'2::€:s:;§'%§;>;:.:_é'.i<7;:: {7}§'fiat::'-'tr sag'; 25%;?" ii; is; ::2<:':. 2-: {E3 <',2'.i§-Eéfif 'aa 1 ':"::>/Eiaétzi' 9% ' 'izgazéi 4, 'E:'E.':c <'::£"§"::%:':a':£%::; E:'i§:.§€T3§.:f;€fi?{fi :2%..j;§;:Tz§z":s3§%' gi 'pégiéii.'§;.v,:'é€r'%:
zmzé Emit: {>%;T'm-*.-:*s§ in i;,§*1i:a <'::2';.s:~,:::: iéss _§;>n£>: ':I:~:':{?::£s:° E§<::3%é'é:}é:s 3 584% 3%}? rfw -%e=.::;:,, 34 {#35 M33. é':é§V»;gE:"e=*:_a{§y" ;:<3§§':?;,e§:(Ti {:§':fi: 'éizgz?
bfim» aizgm-3a:E at égilc :'1e::i::'é<:....<::f'_'i'.-f%.1;<;--": ._{':s;;:r:f§£;ainé;E':'i;, wim. $§<:;§«:Es:
x>arh§.C1% misgéiwj,é:1'::§éé2:':fl€'d €,;:1§"é.'.Zm3V :?.%§,jEj%."a:§s§§@r gurzgz.
:3," [{}n f%i14e "i?;}:3:%s.§é~'; &>f 1.3%"'{;:{fim";3Eair:E; E26353: by i'h_§::a wry E32:-3%.i"fs.iVx:m.t*::: -2: {:;_ :'>f>§V>'E}:i§VVVA"§::if§EA§1{L% Nee» §_?8;'E®"§® ?;'m:~; 'c.':§5_%{3 'f;»e@:'1. V'%Té3§;:§E%§.€f'€"<3§.i %:§';§% "'ir»e:::*}Y ggmw p<.:Ei§:=€ 2;2;;;2-1m.se;i; éim:
-1" ~3 5 R Aéi§§§%§{'§_i§{}EE§'=;?.§§ 'w,'J§I§'§%§i§}n j::;h€ :2<:<:a;::*'r§:2':<::s£: §'1;{s.f~.§ iT;;=a§~:a:_:'2 g::fiZa*::T:@ :21:
s ;i%,a:a'::::;-'a,_;:':;é. 2;? i1"i§§f§'::i;'£::":e:%€5£s '§::§'12;%é. :;§$:,:?ar:2aE:': E'.E':_é;:: é,.za?<'> :%..;':
h li?:<':;§;'::'::*:a:E,'.§s;é': 2%,«*.i."§_,.'§": 'fizz: §'€g§;§':i. <i:s:§' ;;»:3éE":'2af';e:,§r i.s:r.§ :#;i:','z'2_aé:s=3s::%-. in " -'vé':;-;:é-;E;'zg;,,{ ':1.'§5'T:2@; :::sg;::2%<:'§ éz'z§.'_.<; <_:ia_7=§'::"~;§.<.§a;% :3? e-mii ;i§.22:.§':':
.:2I:.:.":zE §_§_";ae;;? <":»::r '£."a;-"-«;-"<3 2=':<::;:
1% 'é':s:=s::::.": ;,.§:';-:§T§§}:=;>{i 2 z-EUfi?:°%éi§3:{'§i{I%E,EE?i§ Js_.:<:;;,::;-%. '€ __§§z:5~;'%.§{§{'::;:_€.%a:az.':. 'ii? €§<>e:*'é.§2":<> :°:%:'§2:z?:i;§' its?" :"E";a: gwi iE"%_a';%':'2z-%%:"i:a7 $3: §E'E€,'.' :'*--§;;*..<::;a.:§%_:.5 'é 'E "g3;:::%%a §"'%'*:v §"<"3§§:::%.Ff§'sz;g;
'§'§";{::* §.3a=:€:E'éi.%_€,m'»* F2": "%_:'é1{=%: E3?' E3; :«2:s.§;'§"c:aai: in {3;i;':'":s:ti '['xEi:b 3?'? 26 ii} <;;ai§_'_ V ' iE~§'g.2'a'§'§<T:;';E. é:E':é:> :~;2=.2:s;:'i, §'i:s<'}§.'%{?€:
~ u-" -x -E': 4 K; 5 1' VA'): * ::
3% <--: m1w:.,{fm-.sj_ an ._ ; '%;>;:*a*§§ 0:": §":..';:a~; :';=r:};a:<[t2.1':."§.:':g,: £1 _'§7JE:';'${)E':é§..§ '%:;.::_>m'"§ " __ ,'.{}{}{f?3:'~ a:'ms: :'~;m°<.>i'.'f;; films' 2-» "-.:":':a%e:E _g><}§é<'-ax §:::::"%'.:%;§ }E"'3.¥i'EEf' ' %::»a'-.% A §':x:;':E $2.: 332:": §:?.a*.a: "' g a=» s:',..\ V K?' fa}: _ am;
.33 §:'2':..2i§}<:s1;:a'~.4; :2?' ;;:*:°1's;-;:s~;'é. 'A {IIE f if
2..& Aka
-.3 avvr-mi"
if s:'s§":zz_§;E :":é;2"é«::3 '%:i.::.i2:%;<:-£2" 2-;%:2:ii;:%':s§:-;% is '£335.? E?{,}fi{'.é',i 2%; 2'.::'?:{.%. *«;a,:*§":e:': :'é::e:g:s*;:'<*::<:i €92 %'E'1{i ;3r;.:;;'§_';
§,'::a.'s;Eé4s: §;3;zi:§'.:'.:"1° ii, Eéa-': :-«;%':L;~?{§E iiszé. f.;':,E'"iT:E_'§éEE.: *éI%.1:=,=: §}::7€?2':%sa§€;i:z.駧m'té_ ':';.§':a:s<s:ee:::s:;G E.=3b*