Karnataka High Court
The General Manager Bsnl Karwar vs The Managing Director North West K S R T C on 11 January, 2011
Bench: N.K.Patil, A.N.Venugopala Gowda
EN THEE EEGH C{)L'R'E' OE' §{.£'xE?{E'\?!'J§':i;E<Z'/5; CERCUET' BE1'€C§'% 5%'? B?-EARWAB;
m;§;§«:,§:> TENS THE; mu 13m' ('$3 &ANUAE€§*' Qggj' ..
PRESEN?
-ma s»§<;:~«:*g:_,.§: f%¢'£'R¢}i,?E§'§":?'zl.fAE§'f€«. AW , _ .. V. "ma HGNB LE MR¢JU€S"E'§C§ ,1§f€':ir'€;:c;<;p5/giég §*€EESCELEAP€'E«i{)US E<"'E.--.i%iS'§' Ag:-Efiggfgfigé. 'N-<Tfs,:a;:'?};2%; ;*?.é>i3.€${:vm BETWEEN:
mg :?;E;NERA:;_,;' :a}:;;a;;.}r}%§:A<?;i::?:R:: = 33%.: E§[i§'xEQ:?<x;'é;:k.E?.' 'r ' 'V ' _, _ » ¢ ,..APPE'ZLi.AN'§;' {av 82%;,.x;%'.,,:x;:;':s;%:~i'2:':§5:;;z;§'x2:'rx3%:':+:; A@jfg',f:.%' ;1":E"~3 D :
'§"§i%E §»z:AN;:::}.:N§} 'B§§:éc-fig?' V §"~§{)R3"'_§~_%§ a7v'gs:§<PVK3;R;?c ' "
CE::$:'Ra:.; €}E"F'ECE; {§{}iiUL mag;
"V V _ I _____ ..
' . _ .¢..%%E"LSE7*{}E'*éEf§EN'§ {Bi §';;B;::,:} A§%z',;_:
'T§%€E"$ AP?E:§%3; §'E:L§:B LfE'~§E3§ZE% i%§".§i'"E'i{L>E'£ '}..?3§'§_} {T;;F' "..j%»..:z}:.a;...;é;<:*:5 §:iI}:'i§:"\2'$'§ -ma 1.§UD{§R='§Eff'€'§' mg &':?i?éE€E} DATEB :;:_;2{><;2§:; §%§SE:§EE} EN zvm: §'é{,}f§%'%2;'2{}%i}3 <11»; {EEE 5&1: EQIEE? Tiiwffi ?E%L. {IEEEFEL 1§U§.§{}%I{E?iE§)i}§"€} %.';'\§§} ?ué'§¥f;§':,fEBEEE E A-%iT2E§§..;, ;ié§z~%{I'§} §<§£§*%;EE??'a?E EI}EE§§'§'£§S:3E§§E'=§{:} '§'§%E-S {I°L:'%E§'s:'§, E3E§"L?§Ef'E{.}?*~E " "":i's:'}§% {fiC*3§£P§:'?%'§E§;%'EE{f> Ex) THIS §~'*;§3'P€;%L C{}f¥;'E§N{} GN P-"'{}E% Fiikifiée §iE;AR§§'\E{7§- THEE BEAR, A.N'VENEj{Z§Cf}?ALA {}{j}'v¥§3A§ J, BELEVEREED "EH3 F{}LL€}'§§§EN€}:
J§§}§Bi§EP3T Tbs gxgapcllamt 'mac? fiisd 2: gigging §e'3§i€i<)n u:1_<iéf'$.€C_fE£:'{§-2?:
166 <12? the E'v'i<;:2ic:>r VeE:i;C§€3 Actfi againfi cizxémiszg eempensaéian G? Rs.€>,QO,€I>E )€}/~_A:(§W2"i:g:ié cia§.:i'::1g.§§:sé.'igfqgg A' fine {ram-.<>r srehécicé bearing re;:gi_s¥:r2ii;'i1:>:2"=N<>.KA--'V--A.3§'/iie'§ Cczrztendézzg that on 28f{)3/2{}{}'E'L'5»_:§:%: drfiécr {pfV5g_h€;EJ::.hi{:§e;§M Pa,/izzihindm jegjga %3€:§{>r:gin.;;§ £53 i:,Ié;..='hiE<3 fin§§i;*i:1g fmrzfi Ar23~:<::~§a to §{£2.fE§.-'"£1f §.iI1£§.'{'}1'1' §f(3E%.C"§"§§iZg.ESE' fa::.?,<):":; at C§".§€'I'f'é€Z§ijy'&3 3 KSRTC E':2:;2;~'.; <:<>§':§A%i_.ng:; _ '*'<',=:%;".€ "iEE%'_'? ":>:§;:;§:';'.$'E§_i3 €§1:I"'{'fCE§§{}E'"§3 aérivtzzz 2";-:::~:"§": §;:§":d n€gEége:"::1}fV"b:y 'dri§i{3:*,.é:§:'h§§:: é3:<:<>id§:1g EEK}: giacéciezfii iiihz-1%.
v;e:>'u§é§ '"ij;e;r:~:.n £;1%;§':,:€;jC§ to 2% a':m>z»; daghed agairzgt {he Vziézéeéés if "21-gzégéi-v,i';.f<2.r:'é.zmé a-iémgi §"<3S:,:§%; '%;§':.<=:re:3 W253» $:>:ie;r:S§w:- C§2i§TE1Ei§€3 ¢é1':1§§€£'i"§;{T% $5522-"zéitkz T326 w;%hi<:,t§<% %12';_<;.i:r;;;3; b<3€--::te. §~;<>§: .%$pa£%rr:<i iii; ;;a.W;a:*{*Ev§?Z':::.€é;{§%féfi}{}{}; ~ =2:<;;:::$ ';"§§<:::§= 'E3};'- £;?':1s;7*::::*:'é:2§;{'-«f::»:'§3§ién:--;é3:--: 2212:? 233530 ':":'§::'€ Chzirggsa E32-2_ViI:.g §I2(:u.:":'€e:'§ ':x.:§:a':2é'---- i;E?3%:i; ?<:§1.}}<:§:: W:-3:3 inst 2-:2?2~;i§.2ib§.a= fat»: RS6, <:Ez:§::": ;:;w::~'%.i:i:>;: 1
\ _M,,,;.....-:A''''' \'_,;«?"s» "2 ' \ K3) '2; '§":3<§ §'{'f:§§}£f}E"1€§€'£":'; ':35: §i3é.:wg_-: ss{22t::%:?:1:§:":t. sf {T}§{3j7.f'3{?"é3';("3;i"?_VE=3, <:§>::f:iic3é;'£.es:i tézai ifiéiziifé. Tide? z'%3sp<'}n{§enf:. d€f1§~:".{§ %h::§ «;ii-TE fisfffg '* maids an §_:h:t par'; 9? its déivsif ané <::{:r3:si:~::--:i--:':§.'_:1i~.V {E2634 eacciéezii. qiié net 0<:€m" an a.s::€<}m£§ @§..r2ish--T_2i:: £§"--.rm.
airizvéng <)ft%1<3 '::>2.;:s«: by *;_t;:~; drévegs,' __'§'h<»: §;o,a€<3:ré;:;1E ;:;E%:*a.:iir1g;$ Eezéai £0 ths {reaming {sf f%:;s;u<:S alnéi diEi=§.t;g;:§' '{':h€. €3:<}ur&:«2 {if %;r§aE__._ for that 2i.ppC};E213}§,'i%?§§K§Y«9w1 'c1.r1<§§<3:v§:é;,P~i :0 if:
aware maréifid. 'Ri':$p{):j._§V_¢£1_TVZV (firm-*er~EK/§t>ha1:1 Pa:1duz"an§ "'Jig§;*§%§:*v. _a§$§:"{:(:ia%:éL<3fi 0%" the matszriaé «:::~ri égf:;3s3w:<:re:1 'iihe firs: izssut-T: in Egirm that the :%;<':<::m<£ iS$i.'i€ :i.<3€:; ::;>f:.2;.z"'%-:~3::% §c:}:f€:<§'z~3:§E:::%.. T ?"%.<-m. Cara:-:;r:3Cfiz:r:i".§j;;,, §}<3E.§'§',§;€_EE'i W213 £:§isamVi&3_:=s{~:{"£ aé%i=th ::<>Vs%<--'.$. '::E'»z§b§2':g; E:g--;g:"§{:vec%$ BSNL ham; '§:§1::<{§; éjnisg ' _;s.?;D§i§':.E _ ' ---------- ~ "
W. ::1';:i2<:':§; <::}m'.2:<_«:e-3'i azgaspearézzg far Iihfi' a.p§:v<3T§_§:T-:2":': C633:-néia %EL:%;:fi;'€ij,'§':<3 E%§§,fiaC"E"' E'-3-%'%fo.~,.; zmi; sapgreatiaziad. Ehé: ézviszisizézfie <3"? 'zifsa, E '§L{}f_5:: in Em: C§':2§°'€"i':'{'E. p€':1"Ei=3§€{i?L§'Jz': :~1:":e:§ 02:: ac<:<>=':,::':§ <25 mi§;-- "§i§"§Et?f§'.§£i}13 23i{§{}_'§,':E€{§5 iérzpzzgaaéfiii {':§°§§«3s: e:':.22m:3 3.1:: be §3z:.:;&;=:-iii. EEES 'iré:%Jé3E. {94::.2'i;A' £i;.is3.:m~z«:&:§'3f: {E125 Cizizém E:-€i§;:%_'i,'i{>:éZ3* La-srned £:{)U.I3S€i§ Submits; ifzaé; ihzsugh 'the: p:}?:{:::"r §m='<2:3'aige2€:.i<>:': km...
:3 fiiinggg :3?" 'She <:E":a§"§s:é Sh€3€'{1 ag>;21§.::.s;i the diivmf {:35 826 esppeiiamz, afiiér Eriai, :§§<é:"e is 2:33: <:s:"{§er cf 2a<:c;;i§f%;.'§.2:.§'~31$:' :iv%<ie:m; Ehém EZ:<:;E3v€is a.n{'i 'i'1::~r;{:s; :33? imp:.,T:g:1.{:'i:i, is"
unjyzsiifzeci, 5, S21 Qaabziiir Eeeéifméd c::}':;{r1:;e§'[2z:}3pé3g":r§.ng far the ré3sp{>nciez':: by t21kigg%"~11s 2:213;-u.g§<;._ ?;.§é€&.:=:a;'§£d::;/10:5 sf TPWSJ. to 4, sxhibizzéd d<>Vc::m€:r;§_-; éind a::e§.:?z::i' e*§.%i.é€>:::{:e: of RKFQME, r_~'~ wzyuid <:e:f:E€:m_tI {fr V ' tjhé '?:f§.i;3"%;11":é:fi E";2i'::~:._§;{§:'r€C'aE'y agpreciezied ihe: mridenais; <":«:§'_;:*€:<:<§':"e.:%. 'ii-?:::V-- fézjzaiimgss recc}:"d<3d being if":
s<>z1$<:=:,§zz:':<:é:'['2s:§i':_§r:. :{é3E'f _r'n:3§I::z"§:;2E_ ""s§upp<>:°'é;<:c§ in ihs {arm :3!"
me-'iC§:5:2.c{:§ ms :L:::.:3::"§éé{fe:"§{:é:% :"m:€;€<*3:r is Qzaiiesé 533:1 1%: §:2w~e:----«;;:<::°:.:a;e£§ {Egg 2:°<3£<>:" K Eiscpizzg in 29:52:? .f%":':§e:z3s§§ 'Sm: pain: fs:3f€ <:<m:;§§:§€3:°a:%;i:m £3: "ifif§*:€'§;:.?::->.E '§:'i:'bu'r:aE has; <:<>mm§.€%;<2:§ sléfifgi a=3*:"<:s:: in WMW X x 6 The émpugzmzé judgnmzii :13 flé-1\>¥E€SS 2::;;::xp<%2::i s3§;:--mz:§s§ disiéééagzéd. E«§£:vw<%é:'€:; ii p».J {:i_r<':mn$§am::€$ 1131:: zzfiics are {ié:"«:*c::tr::c:5_ 7 _ 2":-t:~:§p§;"<:?:év€* e:*;<:s:;'€.$.
sand }'£€Z1{_'.{'3, {he aize fa<;ft.$ _T " ~:-gmté to =_'§§2§§:':°.
Eqmv