Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Non Medical Scientist Froum Gr B C Forum ... vs Rajesh Bhushan & Ors on 10 January, 2024
1
Item No. 8/C-4 CP 211/2020 in OA 1843/2018
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi
CP No. 211/2020
in
OA No. 1843/2018
This the 10th day of January, 2024
Hon'ble Mr. Tarun Shridhar, Member (A)
Hon'ble Mrs. Pratima K. Gupta, Member (J)
1. ANILA RAJENDRAN, age 49 years
S/o Sh. R. Chandra Sekharan Nair,
R/o Flat No. 416, GH-2,
Bhagban Apartment, Sector-28
Rohani, Delhi.
2. DR. SWATI CHAVHAN, Age 31 years
D/o Sh. Sudhir Kumar,
R/o House No.234, Lane No.10
South Vanasthali, Ballupur Chowk,
Dehradun, Uttrakhand.
3. CHARAN SINGH, age 52 years
S/o Sh. Lakhraj
R/o RZ-19B, O Block, Gali No.-2,
New Roshan Pura, Najafgarh,
New Delhi-110043.
4. SASMITA KAR, age 48 years
D/o Sh. Dibakar Kar
R/o House No.-B5/45,
Paschim Vihar, New Delhi.
5. MEENA DUTTA, age 55 years
D/o Late Sh. F.C. Nag,
r/o Flat No.74, Bannu Enclave,
Road No.42, Pitampura,
Delhi-34.
6. SUMAN GUPTA, age 46 years
D/o
R/o D-8, Bhagat Singh Road,
Adarsh Nagar, Delhi-33.
7. MADHUSUDAN CHATURVEDI, age 26 years
S/o Sh. Vinod Kumar Sharma
R/o Flat No.2, Honey Apartment,
Ward No.6, Meharauli
Delhi-110030.
2
Item No. 8/C-4 CP 211/2020 in OA 1843/2018
8. REKHA JAISWAL, age 44 years,
D/o Sh. Balbir Singh,
R/o C-7/10, Yamuna Vihar,
Delhi-110053.
9. NASRESH CHAND SHARMA, age 50 years
S/o Sh. Kurey Singh Sharma,
R/o B-331-A, Ashok Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi.
10. UDAIVEER SINGH, age 46 years
S/o Sh. Sukhpal Singh,
R/o House no.279/1
Roshan Vihar, Sadatpur,
Karawal Nagar, Delhi-94.
11. MANORANJAN MISHRA, age 38 years
S/o Late Sh. Nilanchal Mishra
R/o F-21, 1st Floor,
Om Vihar Extension, Uttam Nagar
Delhi-110059.
12. RAM KISHOR MEENA, age 52 years
S/o Sh. R.S. Meena,
R/o 151 Type-III, Timarpur,
Delhi-110054.
13. SAROJ BALA, age 59 years
D/o Sh. Harikeshi
R/o E-302, Sector-17,
Vasundhara, Ghaziabad (U.P.)
14. GIRRAJ SINGH, Age 45 years
S/o Shri Radm Kishan
R/o Village-Dallupura
P.O. Vasundra Enclave
Delhi - 110 096.
15. RAM KUMAR PANDEY, Age 54 years
S/o Late Shri G.S. Pandey
Sector-1, House No.-32
Vasundhara
Ghaziabad, UP-201012.
16. Harendra Bhagat, Age-54 years
S/o Shri Thakur Bhagat
R/o B-2/204, New Kondali, Vasundhara
Enclave, Delhi -96.
3
Item No. 8/C-4 CP 211/2020 in OA 1843/2018
17. Mr. Vijayanath.P., Age 29 years
S/o Sh. Pavadi.K.
R/o C/o Ajay Kumar Tokas
202 C Room No.4, Munirka,
New Delhi -67.
18. DR. ISHWAR SINGH, Age 32 years
S/o Shri Laxman Singh
R/o A-246, Janta Flats
Jahangirpuri, Delhi-54.
19. VINAY SINGH, Age 36 years
S/o Shri Jagdish Singh
R/o House No.852, Sunderpuri
Ghaziabad, UP.
20. Surabhi Mahajan, Age 40 years
D/o Dr. S.D.Sharma
R/o C-111, Vikaspuri
New Delhi -18.
21. Renu, Age 24 years
D/o Shri Kishan Singh Bisht
R/o Shiv Park, Khanpur
New Delhi -62.
22. Poonam, Age 37 years
D/o Sh. Mool Chand
R/o TF-05, Sankrite Apartment
Burari, Delhi-84.
23. Preeti Diwakar, Age 34 years
D/o Mr. K.S. Sagar
R/o House No.71/B/H
Street No.8
East Chander Nagar
Delhi - 110 051.
24. Priyanka, Age 28 years
D/o Dr. Pawan Kumar Gupta
R/o Flat No.14
3rd Floor, Plot No.65
Kakrola Housing Complex, Dwarka
Delhi - 110 078.
25. Rajesh Kumar, Age 48 years
S/o Shri Gopal Parsad Gupta
R/o E-138, Gali No.11
Bhajanpura, Delhi.
4
Item No. 8/C-4 CP 211/2020 in OA 1843/2018
26. Dr. Abhay Kumar Sharma, Age 42 years
S/o Shri Ajay Kumar Sharma
R/o WZ-245, Inderpuri
New Delhi -12.
27. Sattender Kumar, Age 44 years
S/o Late Shri Mitra Sain
R/o House No.138/11
Block-A Bhajanpura
Delhi-53.
28. Chetan Prakash, Age 39 years
S/o Shri Satya Pal Singh
R/o 512, Shastri Nagar
Meerut (U.P.).
29. Jyoti, Age 33 years
D/o Shri Gajjit Singh
R/o Village P.o.-Dehkora
Bahadurgarh, Jhajjar
Haryana.
30. Shasi Kant Sharma, Age 45 years
S/o Sh. Ram Dekhan Singh
R/o D-2/531, CPWD, M.S. Flat
Dev Nagar, Delhi - 05.
31. Ramesh Sharma, Age 47 years
S/o Shri R.S. Sharma
R/o I-42, Arya Samaj Road
Uttam Nagar, New Delhi-59.
32. Sachin Khandelwal, Age 36 years
S/o Shri Mahesh Chand Rajoria
R/o 78, Bank Colony, Alwar
Rajasthan.
33. Krishana Swaroop Pandey, Age 34 years
S/o Shri Girraj Sharan Pandey
R/o ID-1/9, Nehra Vihar
Karawal Nagar, Delhi -94.
34. Mamta Rav, Age 26 years
D/o Late Shri Ram Prasad
R/o S-Block, Pandav Nagar-110 92.
35. Sameer Kerketta, Age 58 years
S/o Shri R.S. Kerketta
R/o F-89, S-2, S.F.
Dilshad Colony, Delhi.
5
Item No. 8/C-4 CP 211/2020 in OA 1843/2018
36. Vikram Jeet Yadav, Age 46 years
S/o Shri J.N.Yadav
R/o 7.Y, Chitragupta Road
Paharganj, Delhi.
37. Karamvir Verma, Age 60 years
S/o Late Shri Mehar Chand
R/o H.No.-59, Gali No.1
New Basti, Narela
Delhi-40.
38. Anil Kumar, Age 57 years
S/o Shri Mohal lal Kalra
R/o House No.-1695, Sector-7
E-Block, Faridabad, Haryana.
39. Dr. Priyanka Singh, Age 38 years
D/o Shri Rajender Singh
R/o House No.220
Sector 10A, Vasundhara
Ghaziabad, UP.
40. Uma Sharma, Age 42 years
D/o Late Shri B.N.Sharma
R/o B-117, Sector-55
Noida.
41. Dr. Ved Prakash, Age 41 years
S/o House No.1056
Street No.1, Shiv Mandir Colony.
Alipur, Delhi - 110 036.
42. Harmanpreet Kaur, Age 28 years
D/o Shri Sohan Singh
R/o C-365, Sector-19-C
Noida, UP.
43. Priyanka Yadav, Age 29 years
D/o Shri Yoginder Pal
R/o A-9/G-I Rampuri
Surya Nagar, Ghaziabad.
6
Item No. 8/C-4 CP 211/2020 in OA 1843/2018
44. Pritam Singh, Age 42 years
S/o Late Shri Jaswant Singh
R/o F-95D, Pocket-F
GTB Enclave, Nand Nagri
Delhi - 110 093.
45. Chandan Singh, Age 43 years
S/o Late Shri Kundan Singh
R/o H-1308, Ajnara Integrity
Raj Nagar Ext.
Ghaziabad, UP.
46. A. Anbarasan, Age - 44 years
S/o Shri R. Andi,
R/o 1631, Laxmi Nagar
New Delhi-23.
47. N.Muthukrishnan, Age 59 years
S/o Shri A. Narayana, Chettiyar
R/o -60, E 2A, Santhi Nagar
Metttupalayam, Tamil Nadu -641301.
48. P.Chandrasekaran, Age 52 years
S/o Shri Mr. Ponnah
R/o 46, Main, Alwarpet
Coonoor, Tamil Nadu-1.
49. Anupam Kaushik, Age 27 years
S/o Shri Rakesh Kumar Kaushik
R/o A-96, Azad Marg, Moradabad
UP-244001.
50. Ravi Shankar P. Goswami, Age 25 years
S/o Shri K.P.Goswami
R/o Village-Patuwani
Post-Bijwani, The-Bidwani
Distt-Katni, M.P.
51. Vijay Kumar Singh, Age 61 years
S/o Late Shri Purab Singh
R/o Z-524, Timarpur
Delhi - 110 054.
52. Mukesh Kumar, Age 48 years
S/o Shri Ram Kishan
R/o C-59, Preem Vihar
Shiv Vihar, Delhi-94.
53. Dr. (Mrs.) Alice Verghese, Age 55 years
D/o Late Baby Vaidyan
R/o A3, Tagore Garden Ext.
New Delhi -27.
7
Item No. 8/C-4 CP 211/2020 in OA 1843/2018
54. Devendra Kumar Saxena, Age 58 years
S/o Shri Gyan Prakash Saxena
R/o 937/20, Baba Kharak Singh Marg
New Delhi -110 01.
55. Ms. Shilpi Dhan, Age 50 years
D/o Late Shri Surender Dhan
R/o House No.790, S-Type
Timarpur, Delhi.
56. Dr. Sunita Patel, Age 41 years
D/o Dr. Harihar Singh
R/o 72, DDA Flat (SFS)
Mukharjee Nagar
Delhi - 110 009.
57. Mahesh Chandra, Age 48 years
S/o Shri Jay Ram
R/o 1/52, MIG, Vasundhara
Ghaziabad, UP.
58. Dr. Pramod Kumar, Age 45 years
S/o Late Shri Raghunath
R/o C-16 B, 2nd Floor
Parasnath Paradise, Mohan Nagar
Ghaziabad, UP.
59. Yosman, Age 41 years
S/o Shri Kanwar Krishan Dhar
R/o 282, Ground Floor
Shalimar Garden Extension
Ghaziabad, UP.
60. H.L.Meena, Age 55 years
S/o Shri Bhorey Lal Meena
R/o Quarter No.23, Multi Story
Timarpur, Delhi - 110 054.
61. Rajendra Singh Rautela, Age 58 years
S/o Late Shri Narayan Singh Rautela
Ghaziabad, UP.
62. Neeru Kakkar, Age 53 years
S/o Shri P.P. Babbar
R/o Flat No.31
Capital Green (DLF)
Shivaji Marg, Delhi -15.
63. Dr. Ravi Kumar, Age 51 years
8
Item No. 8/C-4 CP 211/2020 in OA 1843/2018
S/o Late Shri V. Ranga Swamy
R/o 1707, C/o Shri R.P.Singh
Janta Flat, G.T. Enclave
Nand Nagari, Delhi -93.
64. Anand Singh, Age 41 years
S/o Shri Desh Raj Singh
CC-414, Sector-18, Millennium
Apartment, Sector-18, Rohini
Delhi -18.
65. Harish Chander Gahlot, Age -58 years
S/o Lt. Shri Ramphal Gahlot
House No.416, VPO-Kakrola
New Delhi -78.
66. Raishuddin, Age 55 years
S/o Lt. Kaim Ali Khan
House No.798, F Type
Timarpur, Delhi -54.
67. Charanjeet Singh, Age 55 years
S/o Lt. Mohinder Singh
H.No.-147, Plot No.135
Ram Nagar, Delhi-18.
68. Dinesh Rani, Age 33 years
D/o Shri Devi Singh
H.No.634
Type-II, Sector-IV
Timarpur, Delhi -54.
69. Kalu Ram Yadav, Age 46 years
S/o Shri Sugan Lal
CC-Behind B-104
Near Malviya Nagar
Plot No.51-52
Old Roopbass, Alwar
Rajasthan-301001.
70. W. Tamizharasu, Age 39 years
S/o Late Shri M.A. Williams
R/o Qtr. No.32, GPRA
CPWD Complex, M.S. Baburaj Road
Kallai, Kozhikode
Kerala-673003.
9
Item No. 8/C-4 CP 211/2020 in OA 1843/2018
71. P. Satya Babu, Age 46 years
S/o P. Mrutyanjaya Rao
R/o D. No.2-18, Main Road
Dowlaiswaram - 533125
East Godavari District
Andhra Pradesh.
72. Suresh Chandra, Age 49 years
S/o Shri Jay Ram, IIB-247
Vaishali, Ghaziabad, UP -201010.
...Petitioners
(By Advocate : Mr. Sachin Chauhan)
Versus
1. Sh. Rajesh Bhushan
Secretary
Union of India
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Nirman Bhawan,
New Delhi - 110011
2. Dr. Sunil Kumar Gupta
Director General of Health Services
Directorate General of Health Services
Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi - 110011
3. Sh. Sujeet Kumar Singh,
Director
National Centre for Disease Control
22 - Shamnath Marg, Delhi - 54
...Respondents
(By Advocate : Mr. Gyanendra Singh)
10
Item No. 8/C-4 CP 211/2020 in OA 1843/2018
ORDER (ORAL)
Hon'ble Mr. Tarun Shridhar, Member (A) In compliance of the directions passed in the captioned OA, the respondents have issued an order on 06.10.2023, which they term as a speaking order. The said order is annexed to an affidavit of compliance filed on 08.12.2023. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that even though the respondents may have passed the speaking order in terms of the directions issued by the Tribunal, however, the said order fails to redress the grievance of the applicants/petitioners, which they have agitated in the captioned OA. Learned counsel seeks liberty on their behalf to assail the said order through an appropriate legal remedy.
2. In view of the above, the present CP stands closed, of course with liberty to the petitioners in accordance with law. Notices are discharged.
(Pratima K. Gupta) (Tarun Shridhar)
Member (J) Member (A)
/akshaya/