Karnataka High Court
T. Pandurangarao vs Radhamma on 6 February, 2020
Author: B.M.Shyam Prasad
Bench: B.M.Shyam Prasad
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2020
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE B.M.SHYAM PRASAD
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.7674 OF 2018 (CPC)
BETWEEN:
1 . T. PANDURANGARAO
S/O. LATE T. BASAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS,
AGRICULTURIST,
GAMA VILLAGE,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 427,
SHIVAMOGGA DISTRICT,
BY HIS REGISTERED GPA HOLDER,
K. H. GANESH RAO,
S/O. LATE B. N. HANUMANTHA RAO,
HALIYURU ARAREKERI,
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577 427. ...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. P N HARISH, ADVOCATE)
AND
1. RADHAMMA
D/O. LATE JAYAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
R/O. GAMA VILLAGE,
2. MANJUNATHA
S/O. LATE JAYAMMA,
S/O. LATE KHANDAPPA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
-2-
R/O. BELAGAVI,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 527.
3. N. NARAYANAPPA
S/O. LATE JAYAMMA,
S/O. LATE KHANDAPPA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
R/O. BELAGAVI,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 527.
4. VIJAYAKUMARA
S/O. LATE JAYAMMA,
S/O. LATE KHANDAPPA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
R/O. BELAGAVI,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 527.
5. SUGANDAMMA. N
D/O. LATE JAYAMMA,
W/O. SURESH,
MAJOR IN AGE,
MAHALAXMI FANCY STORES,
HONDADAKERI,
SHIRALKOPPA TOWN-577 428.
6. N. SHIVANANDA
S/O. LATE JAYAMMA,
S/O. LATE KHANDAPPA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
R/O. BELAGAVI,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 427.
7. SHANTHAMMA
D/O. LATE T. GANESHAPPA,
(W/O. LATE THUKARAMAPPA RAKUNE),
AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS,
HITHALA VILLAGE,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 427.
-3-
8. HANUMANTHAPPA
S/O. LATE GODHAVARI,
D/O. LATE T. GANESHAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,
CONDIMENTS, HAWKER,
4TH CROSS, 2ND MAIN ROAD,
JALINAGAR,
DAVANAGERE-577 001.
9. PRAKASHA
S/O. LATE GODAVARI,
D/O. LATE T. GANESHAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS,
CONDIMENTS, HAWKER,
4TH CROSS, 2ND MAIN ROAD,
JALINAGAR,
DAVANAGERE-577 001.
10 . PRAMEELA
D/O. LATE T. GANESHAPPA,
W/O. LATE PAKKIRAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS,
4TH CROSS, 2ND MAIN ROAD,
JALINAGAR,
DAVANAGERE-577 001.
11 . PADMA
D/O. LATE T. GANESHAPPA,
W/O. SHIVANNA,
AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
KALMANE VILLAGE,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 427.
12 . B. N. VISHWANATH RAO
S/O. LATE SITHAMMA,
W/O. LATE B. N. HANUMANTHARAO,
MAJOR IN AGE,
MANAGER,
PCA & RD BANK LTD.,
-4-
BHADRAVATHI,
R/O. "SNEHA ROOPA NILAYA",
60 FEET PARALLEL ROAD,
OPPOSITE, RMC GATE,
VINOBHANAGAR,
SHIVAMOGGA-577 201.
13 . GEETHABAI
D/O. LATE SEETHAMMA,
W/O. DHANANJAYA,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
HALIYUR DURUGAMMANABEDI,
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577 427.
14 . BHAGYA
D/O. LATE SEETHAMMA,
W/O. SATHYANARAYANA,
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
R/AT VRUSHABHAVATHINAGAR,
4TH CROSS,
BENGALURU-560 079.
15 . B. N. JAYANTHI
D/O. LATE SEETHAMMA,
W/O. RAJU,
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
2ND CROSS, VINAYAKNAGAR,
BENGALURU-560 079.
16 . B. N. BHARATHI
D/O. LATE SEETHAMMA,
W/O. RAMACHANDRA,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS,
MAHIMA BEAUTY PARLOUR,
OLD SANTHE MARKET ROAD,
BHADRAVATHI TOWN-577 301,
SHIVAMOGGA DISTRICT.
-5-
17 . DR. T. GOPALARAO
S/O. LATE T. BASAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 85 YEARS,
R/O. GAMA VILLAGE,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 427,
NOW R/O. 532S, AIKENAVE SUITE,
411, PITTSBURGH,
PENNSYLVANIA 15232,
U.S.A.
18 . T. VITTOBARAO
S/O. LATE T. BASAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS,
R/O. GAMA VILLAGE,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 427.
19 . N. KRISHNAMURTHY RAO
(HUSBAND OF LATE SAROJAMMA),
MAJOR IN AGE,
R/O. KANUR HOSAKERI,
NEAR DURUGAMMA TEMPLE,
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577 427.
20 . N. K. DHARMARAJ
S/O. LATE SAROJAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
RETIRED KSRTC T D
BEHIND GELAYARA BALAGA SCHOOL,
HAVERI TOWN-581 110.
21 . N. RAMESHA
S/O. LATE SAROJAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
KSRTC DRIVER,
R/O. VIDYANAGARA,
HAVERI TOWN-581 110.
-6-
22 . SUNITHA @ NIRMALA
D/O. LATE SAROJAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
C/O. N. KRISHNAMURTHY RAO,
R/O. KANUR HOSAKERI,
NEAR DURUGAMMA TEMPLE,
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577 427.
23 . NETHRAVATHI
D/O. LATE SAROJAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
C/O. N. KRISHNAMURTHY RAO,
R/O. KANUR HOSAKERI,
NEAR DURUGAMMA TEMPLE,
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577 427.
24 . PRABHAVATHI
D/O. LATE SAROJAMMA,
W/O. PARASHURAMARAO,
TAILOR,
NEAR BUS STAND,
AYANOOR VILLAGE,
SHIVAMOGGA TALUK,
SHIVAMOGGA DISTRICT-577 211.
25 . VEENA
D/O. LATE SAROJAMMA,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
W/O. P. MANOHARA,
TAILOR, SOWALANGA VILLAGE,
HONNALI TALUK-577 217,
DAVANAGERE DISTRICT.
26 . K. H. GANESHA RAO @ B. N. DEVENDRA
S/O. LATE SEETHAMMA,
TAILOR,
HALIYUR ARERKERI,
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577 427.
-7-
27 . VITTALA
S/O. LATE SEETHAMMA,
W/O. LATE B. N. HANUMANTHARAO,
MAJOR IN AGE,
ELECTRIC MECHANIC,
HALIYUR ARERKERI,
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577 427.
28 . SURESH
S/O. LATE GOWRAMMA,
D/O. LATE T. BASAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
R/O. BELAGUTTI VILLAGE,
HONNALI TALUK-577 217,
DAVANAGERE DISTRICT.
29 . CHANDRU @ SHYLU
S/O. LATE GOWRAMMA,
D/O. LATE T. BASAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
R/O. BELAGUTTI VILLAGE,
HONNALI TALUK-577 217,
DAVANAGERE DISTRICT.
30 . REKHA
D/O. LATE GOWRAMMA,
D/O. LATE T. BASAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
HONNALI TALUK-577 217,
DAVANAGERE DISTRICT.
31 . MANJUNATHA
S/O. LATE GOWRAMMA,
D/O. LATE T. BASAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
R/O. BELAGUTTI VILLAGE,
HONNALI TALUK-577 217,
DAVANAGERE DISTRICT.
-8-
32 . RAJANI
D/O. LATE GOWRAMMA,
D/O. LATE T. BASAPPA,
W/O. YALLAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS,
AYANOOR VILLAGE,
SHIVAMOGGA TALUK,
SHIVAMOGGA DISTRICT-577 211.
33 . SHIVAJI RAO
S/O. LATE. SHARADAMMA,
D/O. LATE. T. MANJAPPA,
W/O. LATE. SIMPI BASAVANNAYAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 83 YEARS,
AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. BELAGUTTI VILLAGE,
HONNALI TALUK 577 217.
DAVANAGERE DISTRICT.
34 . S. JAYARAJU
S/O. LATE. SHARADAMMA,
D/O. LATE. T. MANJAPPA,
W/O. LATE. SIMPI BASAVANNAYAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS
SUPERVISOR,
PCA & RD BANK LTD,
THURUVEKERE TALUK 572227
35 . DASHARATHA
S/O. LATE. SHARADAMMA,
D/O. LATE. T. MANJAPA,
W/O. LATE. SIMPI BASAVANNYAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. BELAGUTTI VILLAGE,
HONNALI TALUK-577 217.
DAVANAGERE DISTRICT
-9-
36 . K P VIJAYENDRA
S/O. LATE. SARASWATHAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
TAILOR,
MASUR ROAD,
SHIKARIPURA 577 427
37 . K P DINESHA
S/O. LATE. SARASWATHAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
TAILOR,
MASUR ROAD,
SHIKARIPURA 577 427
38 . CHANDRAMMA
D/O. LATE. SHARADAMMA,
D/O. LATE. T. MANJAPPA,
W/O. LATE. SIMPI BASAVANNYAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS
AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HONNALI TOWN 577 217,
DAVANAGERE DISTRICT
39 . SUBADRAMMA
D/O. LATE. SHARADAMMA,
D/O. LATE. T. MANJAPPA,
S/O. LATE. BASAVANNYAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
ISSUR VILLAGE,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK 577 427
40 . KASTURAMMA
D/O. LATE. SHARADAMMA,
D/O. LATE. T. MANJAPPA,
W/O. T. VITTOBARAO,
AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
R/O. GAMA VILLAGE,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 427
- 10 -
41 . SUBASHCHANDRA
S/O LATE T RAMAKRISHNAPPA
AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
TAILOR
R/O OPPOSITE VIDDYUTHNAGAR
1ST CROSS, 1ST MAIN ROAD
K H RANGANATHA BADAVANE
HADADI ROAD
DAVANAGERE-577001
42 . SHARADAMMA
W/O LAXMANARAO
43 . RAGHAVENDRA
S/O LAXMANARAO
44 . HAREESHA
S/O LAXMANARAO
45 . MURALIDHAR
S/O LAXMANARAO
RESPONDENTS 42 TO 44 ARE
MAJOR IN AGE AND
RESIDENTS OF GAMA VILLAGE
SHIKARIPUR TALUK-577427
46 . KALAVATHI
D/O LATE T RAMAKRISHNAPPA
(W/O GANAPATHI BABA)
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS
R/O AKKI ALUR VILLAGE,
HANAGAR TALUK-581104
HAVERI DISTRICT
47 . JAGANATHARAO
S/O LATE T RAMAKRISHNAPPA
R/O GAMA VILLAGE,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577427
- 11 -
48 . CHANDRAMATHI
D/O LATE T R RAMAKRISHNAPPA
(W/O LAXMANARAO K B )
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS, HOUSEHOLD
"LAXMIBAI-NANDAKUMAR"
BEHIND BAPOOJI HIGH SCHOOL
KUVEMPUNAGAR,
DAVANGERE-577001
49 . PUSHPA
D/O LATE RAMAKRISHNAPPA,
W/O MANOHARA KATAWKAR,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
HOUSEHOLD,
VIDHYANAGAR,
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577427.
50 . RAMESHA
S/O LATE T.RAMAKRISHNAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 53YEARS,
AGRICULTURIST,
GAMA VILLAGE,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577427.
51 . SMT SUJATHA
D/O LATE T.RAMAKRISHNAPPA,
(W/O JNANESHWAR)
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
HOUSEHOLD,
SHIGGAVI TOWN,
HAVERI DISTRICT-581110.
52 . K B SHANKARANARAYANA
S/O LATE SMT.LAXMIBAI @ CHANDRAMMA,
S/O LATE T.MANJAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS,
LIC AGENT, "PARIMALA NILAYA",
- 12 -
16TH CROSS, ANJANEYA BADAVANE,
DAVANAGERE-5770001.
53 . NAGARAJA
S/O LATE VARADABAI,
MAJOR IN AGE,
C/O K.B.SHANKARANARAYANA,
LIC AGENT, "PARMIALA NILAYA",
16TH CROSS, ANJANEYA BADAVANE,
DAVANAGERE-577001.
54 . NARAYANA
S/O LATE SMT.VARADABAI,
MAJOR IN AGE,
C/O K.B.SHANKARANARAYANA,
LIC AGENT, "PARIMALA NILAYA",
16TH CROSS, ANJANEYA BADAVANE,
DAVANAGERE-577001.
55 . VIJAYAKUMARA
S/O LATE SMT.VARADABAI,
MAJOR IN AGE,
C/O K.B.SHANKARANARAYANA,
LIC AGENT, "PARIMALA NILAYA",
16TH CROSS, ANJANEYA BADAVANE,
DAVANAGERE-577001.
56 . VENUGOPALA
S/O LATE SMT.VARADABAI,
MAJOR IN AGE,
C/O K.B.SHANKARANARAYANA,
LIC AGENT, "PARIMALA NILAYA",
16TH CROSS, ANJANEYA BADAVANE,
DAVANAGERE-577001.
57 . SUNDARIBAI
D/O LATE LAXMIBAI @ CHANDRAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
C/O K.B.SHANKARANARAYANA,
- 13 -
LIC AGENT, "PARIMALA NILAYA",
16TH CROSS, ANJANEYA BADAVANE,
DAVANAGERE-577001.
58 . MEERABAI
D/O LATE LAXMIBAI @ CHANDRAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
C/O K.B.SHANKARANARAYANA,
LIC AGENT, PARIMALA NILAYA,
16TH CROSS, ANJANEYA BADAVANE,
DAVANAGERE-577 001.
59 . K.B.LAXMANARAO
D/O LATE LAXMIBAI @ CHANDRAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
"LAXMIBAI-NANDAKUMAR",
BEHIND BAPOOJI HIGH SCHOOL,
KUVEMPUNAGAR,
DAVANAGERE-577 001.
60 . SUGANDA
D/O LATE LAXMIBAI @ CHANDRAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
C/O K.B.SHANKARANARAYANA,
LIC AGENT, PARIMALA NILAYA,
16TH CROSS, ANJANEYA BADAVANE,
DAVANAGERE-577 001.
61 . K.B.MOHANRAO
S/O LATE LAXMIBAI @ CHANDRAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
ANJANEYA BLOCK, PJ EXTENSION,
DAVANAGERE -577 001.
62 . K.B.NANADAKUMAR
S/O LATE LAXMIBAI @ CHANDRAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
ANJANEYA BLOCK, PJ EXTENSION,
DAVANAGERE -577 001.
- 14 -
63 . SUJATHA MALODHE
D/O LATE LAXMIBAI @ CHANDRAMMA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
C/O K.B.SHANKARANARAYANA,
LIC AGENT, PARIMALA NILAYA,
16TH CROSS, ANJANEYA BADAVANE,
DAVANAGERE-577 001.
64 . SHIVANANDA
S/O LATE T HANUMATHAPPA
(MOTHER LATE KAMALAMMA
D/O LATE KAMALAMMA
D/O LATE PARVATHAMMA)
MAJOR IN AGE,
R/O GAMA VILLAGE,
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 427
65 . MANJUNATHA
S/O LATE T HANUMANTAPPA
(MOTHER LATE KAMALAMMA
D/O LATE PARVATHAMMA)
MAJOR IN AGE
R/O GAMA VILLAGE
SHIKARIPUR TALUK-577427
66 . JAKRIYA
S/O ABDUL JABBARSA
MAJOR IN AGE
R/O HAROGOPPA VILLAGE
SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577427
67 . MOHEMED SADIK
S/O ABDUL JABBARSAB
MAJOR IN AGE
CHANDKANKERI
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577427
- 15 -
68 . JALIMULLA
S/O ABDUL JABBARSAB
MAJOR IN AGE
HAROGOPPA VILLAGE
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577427
69 . VINAYAKA
S/O JAGANNATHA
MAJOR IN AGE
SANRUDH AND COMMUNICATIONS
MANJUNATHA NILAYA
MARKET ROAD
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577427
70 . MANJUNATHA
S/O NARAYANAPPA
MAJOR IN AGE
R/O DURGHA MENSWEAR
MANJUNATHA NILAYA
MARKET ROAD
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577427
71 . SAMIULLA
S/O SUNTI SABJANSAB
MAJOR IN AGE
ABILASH TAILOR
R/O MANJUNATHA NILAYA
MARKET ROAD
SHIKARIPUR TOWN-577427
72 . K H GANESHARAO @ B N DEVENDRAPPA
S/O B N HANUMANTHARAO
MAJOR IN AGE
SELECTION TAILOR
R/O MANJUNATHA NILAYA
MARKET ROAD
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577427
- 16 -
73 . NAGARAJA NAVUDA
FATHER'S NAME NOT KNOWN,
MAJOR IN AGE
PROP: SREE RAMABHANA HOTEL,
R/O MANJUNATHA NILAYA, MARKET ROAD,
SHIKARIPUR TOWN-577427
74 . NITHYANANDA
S/O MANJAPPA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
MARUTHI GARMENTS
R/O MANJUNATHA NILAYA
M S ROAD, WESTERN SIDE
SHIKARIPUR TOWN-577427
75 . PROMODH
S/O LOKAPPA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
LAXMIVENKATESHWARA METAL STORES,
R/O MANJUNATHA NILAYA,
M.S.ROAD, WESTERN SIDE,
SHIKARIPUR TOWN-577427
76 . SURESH
S/O LATE SHIVAJIRAO
MAJOR IN AGE,
SREE GAJANANA STORES,
(MANDU MERCHANT)
R/AT MANJUNATHA NILAYA,
M.S.ROAD, WESTERN SIDE,
SHIKARIPUR TOWN-577427
77 . THIPPESH
S/O ANANDAPPA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
VITTAL METAL STORES,
R/O MANJUNATHA NILAYA,
M.S.ROAD,WESTERN SIDE,
SHIKARIPUR TOWN-577 427
- 17 -
78 . BASAVARAJ
S/O RAMAPPA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
MANJUNATHA PLYWOOD,
R/O MANJUNATHA NILAYA,
M.S.ROAD,WESTERN SIDE,
SHIKARIPUR TOWN-577 427
79 . GIDDAPPA
FATHER'S NAME NOT KNOWN,
MAJOR IN AGE,
BEEDA SHOP,
R/O MANJUNATHA NILAYA,
M.S.ROAD,WESTERN SIDE,
SHIKARIPURA TOWN-577 427
80 . BASAVARAJ
S/O K S SURENDRA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
PRIYA LADIES TAILOR,
R/O MANJUNATHA BUILDING,
I FLOOR,MARKET ROAD,
SHIKARIPUR TOWN-577 427
81 . KUMARA
S/O NEELAPPA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
R/O MANJUNATHA BUILDING,
I FLOOR,MARKET ROAD,
SHIKARIPUR TOWN-577 427
82 . SUNILKUMAR
S/O BASAVARAJAPPA,
MAJOR IN AGE,
JANASPANDAN OFFICE,
R/O MANJUNATHA BUILDING,
I FLOOR,MARKET ROAD,
SHIKARIPUR TOWN-577 427
...RESPONDENTS
- 18 -
THIS MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL IS FILED UNDER
ORDER 43 RULE 1(r) OF THE CPC, AGAINST THE ORDER
DATED 18.07.2018 PASSED ON I.A.NO.XXVIII IN
O.S.NO.20/2011 ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE
AND JMFC, SHIKARIPURA, REJECTING IA NO.XXVIII UNDER
ORDER 39 RULE 1 AND 2 READ WITH SECTION 151 OF CPC.
THIS MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL COMING ON
ORDERS THIS DAY, THE COURT DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
JUDGMENT
The learned counsel for the appellant submits that the suit in O.S. No.20/2011 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge and JMFC, Shikaripura is dismissed on 22.10.2019. As such, the present appeal is rendered infructuous and the same may be dismissed on that ground.
In view of this submission, the appeal is dismissed as having become infructuous.
SD/-
JUDGE RB