Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

H T Narayana Reddy vs Abdul Rahim Sab on 15 July, 2009

Author: N.Ananda

Bench: N.Ananda

EN Tiifi HE¢fe%~Z£ c:::am'= (5)? KaR?~E;33'"i"§%}{i§ A'? B;aN<:;g:;fcfi:R5%;.--.T...

DA'T'E;EI Tait; THE 15% BAY :32? JUL'? ;3e:i§'9 V  "  H

BE,;F'£'}RE   >-

'THE i~iC)N'BLE M'R.JUST'I(f§§ r§a%5§. ;a;fa:A:5¢'if:gé   

C:.R.P. NC; :;1:};j>;300§"' .

BETWEEN

2, HTNARAYRNA RE1:§::§?--.  4  
ss;'<:;« L2'§T'E'.: Baum 'T%Li§"¥Tg§si?F_'fi;fRfE;'3i3Y_*V _ 
gem s%.B£>§E'lf" $6 Y?a;5;1'e::,. ; ' ' 1 AV 

M §.A:.'.:i"§§"§a*g

W55; 5* ~1x;;é;Ré§§ifi3%é;»§é'§;§3I;::§"V
5:333-.;a30U*:j'V5A:%ymfzvgg ' -

w

E3:;'3'T§'H A§*€:EJ"--§;"~IC3,  ?i':j€f}§3E»--'£§'§;=i§A<f:E
KR PURAM HQBLI _  ' 

 aAi~;€:_;§;a:,«::;~RE»5€>a.__a::;43.   PET'§?iéf';§*éEl§ES

 {"831 _§E¥.3.=;€.§A'f§',¥i{:':>:«.'f'€f :3 MA§m?€'E-E:;fa;»§ 3% EVEAHESH s§,2«:m~2<:+§¢
   

Am"  -
3, "~,.«13;:;zI;:;. EEAHEM S218
;S5j€)'%,A'£'i:; iméjusb; zsaum

 ..  Sififig nscggsgg 312 mg mg

 _ Q' ;§;«;';.';»-- gfiafiggigjsi

WES EIETE §'aE?s§¥L F'3AE~£§M S332?»
fisfififi z§B{}U'E' $55 YEERS



" 'iéfi

iii};

3 {cf}

fie}

 éifiasizrga:
" 1..€;;<.0;~%L;%'h3..AE';§:JL RAE HM Sag

MC3HA§\:'iME?.f} ALE {MANNL3}
53,70 L-ATE? ABEiUi. RA}iH'e«'E SAB
;'§C3:E.ifI3 ABOUT 42 YEARS

ESIVEAIL {fig EMU
SEQ L-:'3{FEI ABHUL RAH§?'s.r'§ Sf':?;;  .
SKGEKB EXBCIUT 40 YEARS I

sfiaaadgnafi  Hfigfatim, _
8,10 1;.,{&a..-';*E4 ABDUL mam: 5:38
AG5:::» ABOUT 33 YEARS  "
ASEER H{§SSAIE*i  

gm LATE ABDUL ';a:s;s;1%e:Lsz§;;3  

AGEE3 IXBCEEET 35 YEA-F35  =  

R'E:$PGN[3§3E"?T'S :::;2.';w-*§'fs:_::::'w::W{¢s:i; 3.3:}: @375" 

EE{}{)}i3»E x»fzL3«_..e;<:»E,   Piffififfiv _:j:s:}§Ljz
Mfliififéfiifi/'1%§f'U§:A. PC: ~ '

Mc:§i~:.5'M%M§;§r«z§%ég53:i'i2z%iLii§a
Sm. 3,.:A'Z'a3E AB;:::r_§.. ::e:,z;i:~«::M S-AB

;;':GE}f3 Aargzé-'?"3c; '¥:::AR$

  g;;;'::;;:V§}";2§s:§;3;s*:' 32 ':'EfaR;'5

% RE;:sP§jf:4:éE;NT~s iii} 35. igg; ARE; REA;

':s;af;x,:£:I%z: MGAR, E<;.R.f'UR.€%.M HGBLE
§s»'1g§_E'*iz§BE§'fi.PUE€A 90$'?

" * _B;x§m:;A:x:>RE:«§s30 G48.

 $2: :3::::3m;§}:,as:'APPg 333:3?

 {}UC3E,}fis.§5'?A i?f51T}§}'{
SIBEEEE QECEASEB E'? Eilfi LE5.



 '~-'fax;<1"';;3{?E-zggfiug SATTAR $333

{83

4293}

<,.p}

SM? SHAEKEMMA
Wfi}. E<'.RISH?°«1AREBS"{
E31' C). LATE DC?i3E31XT¥*§£§Y£\E7'P£§ REDEEY

AGE: ?J§.:'§JOI~?:' ; " ~ 

ipiffx: S££E'£'H:'i£€z§£%*iAiJ':'xL'r'§a (j§<':Ai5EiIi'£'§*:1«_ 
H.A.{_,.. ROM)   
8AN€3AL{)EE--5€:i{3 £243,

$E'£JAYAPPf& V     
aga. LATE §C)DD;fi.THAYAP¥i%§ ':§E.:,>.r_W'--- '_ 
AGE: M;-men?    '-

SMT. SHANTHAMMR   ,

w/0,, NARAYANAS1&?_§I$§¥  V'  _
Bf (:1 L;§'I"§:'I; .£:a'<:3_afi;{:*;~isa%i;a.?P«...'=R;'e:£::§$r'
AGE: §v$AJ()E?;1__-'     .-

Rr§S:é5?i:3:~;:*:i,':§'_;:~:*1%:s"'i,;{i§:'>3; 24¢'; 5&3 BIA:
3:30:32' *:;1:..'L,:g$A§;~, ,_€}'§??§?;"H£{3}~Z S€L'-Hm');

WHiTE--FiE;i;_D"E§QA'E3__.7 ";%3§'*»;i\¥GALC¥i?E~55Q 848,

$54: §X§3jfi*»":;?E, SA;T§."}i;5;;i?< 

fiifii§,u.L1%TE;"GI§§§")¥3SEi S1538
V-31-ra*e_§'A..*,fsg $fECEA7$?Efi BY ms LE5.

 > 1::;<.fr3 :4 FR

7 F2'-atsgfi ;s*s.g_é«::*r1':;~;" 62 'xz'~;:;=aRs

kfiéb}
' ' g-'a§;%E§ Aa<>:;'r :33 YE};iRS

§§J::.:s§§.V§a;i;e§x:i~s;a
B;  'LATE £3923: S:'¥?}"':%§?f 3&3

"$54153 ME). S5;Hfi:§"~€§'§:1E"'

SIG. LATQT AEBQUL SETTZER S2523
EEGEB §%§3C}i§T' 35 Yfifififi

§E;=SPif}E%TE3E1N"§S  gsja} "TEE :-ac: AEQE"; Eéfgéz



Bid}

3"Y,I'€::;« P9 1, E~§{}if}Ef3Y BUS i§'E"f'iE'€D
--JA§':»§MA MASJED EQGJAEE, 155? CFEQSS
14"; WERE}: ¥?iH§"§'f§§3i§7ZLf} E3313
B.»-"&?*3GAi,»C>RE~56Q €148.

SEE Md. Afiifiikfi
Sf Q. L3%;'§"E- A3313 3, -'E3:'%.'F"EZ%ETf -8&8
SEEEEEE fiE€3EASE§I3 E3' Hifi LES.

:3{c:§{a: Sm. SHANAWER  SH;<1NEiS?7__

W/0. L-AITE Mé.ASL-AM
AGED ABOEET 38 Y§;Ei§'S.

3{€£§{b} 2??-Lélfl 'i'AL-LEZEM

SEQ. E.-A'§"E Ezie:}.§¥..SLA%v€ 3 _
AGED ;%8C}E_§"E' 1E.§__'_f'EPsR.S  V  »

awe; 

3; e:>.._ ;,A'r:~:V P~{£_Li'».. %  _
;e;«3E,i:3 A§s'c:~ui;L4.:¢s_Y'£s:;3;2:_;s
F€:EZE"*..__£§"{_ §~§§:'3._ :xr;~::;'*;I§'i~:§:?"sM'r,3ie:mAw§:_§:  E.-"§H;§§*>$ 23:75

§§§§E§P€}f%é  Ti} 3{r;i'§{c} fififii Rffi;

 s§${.:x:'c3. 191, "s~:Q;;§_m" we S'i'§*~.Nfi
"~JAf§#i'?.sEz3§* gysasgza R£T3fs.Ea._ E sagas, 34'??? zazmzs

»  §V§§§T'§*§'§§§:i1LD Rama: E'-?EAHfi;Ef3§;1fA?ii§€:A E32333'?
"  Bfi,§§'i??%.i{}E*E;.~56G <:>4&

Big}

 ism E£Ei§'.jg'fa§§R&M

"tam, Lgayyg ABDUL SAT'F§~.R 3&3
A(';";Ei.'Z:- A8€')U'i' 32 YEARS

 AA . Rg;:':' 8YIN£3.19}£§ E§{Z3£§}$Y B238 Siiirxrm

3%.:-.,ar~.s:A ?~.«€§a$:E§£5 RGAB, 1 =:_:tm";3£;

V'  1'4'm:z:_saR§3, '\i€§§§§'EFiE-LE RGAQ

;FsfL%H1%.§3E'€APU RA .'P'€3ST
B5"€\.§"€G§"iL{}RE~5£§if.3 S48.



ifiifi

é¥{gQ

4:13}

*?{C}

A L='"~'*¥~i'€':x'

'-J1

MRS, ssaaam

Wm. AZ-EEZ

Djfj. LATE ABZZREL :'§?;TTz§i% 853
A039 ABGUT :28 YEMES " '

be/A: §~:::;m< ._.a«:)c:s:-m:r;, aaamaészégxzvmzgfia *£*§~;;:§z.§=:;.t;"f--.,___  7

B3%.?'~E{}Ai,C}f€;'F;«56€! 08?. 

SR: 33131;; BA.SHEE'~R  .
Sifiififii EEQEEEEE B'? 323 ms. _

MRS. NEAQBUL  .   
w;»;>. LATE :'zE3DUi.,= ::;,'%,s;::::_:=;':2«.aAB.  _
AGE-:.:3 A861}? 68 Y'€;g';§:::._ . '  

SR§NAZi§§'£?;§'L£';LL(1_ A 
9,151}. Lgéfffi A£§§_:.:Lv E?A8'}§ .}Z3%J:3.
gag; '    
E§E%i:--.i;»7';i3:';;*E§§<'   . .

s; ai:=«_.A §.}ATE§ &B?}'{31;*P,_g&;E§1§.§3ER 5:429
AGEi:2.._A":§€;fi§§ :3';:<'a';E.;«.R;<3'

-' -  ':3; :,.4§*;'E A'g;fs.:}iL«BASHEER SAB
'A  "2'aG}Z'<i3 gagzgr 3?" $3,333

:'§§e_=:.i'§:.a§.::':;:;;:V.1~~

'S; 0.' 1;3§.TE§=ABBL?L BASHEER 8313

A '--.44A€,e:«:.;:: ;~3.§&s3s.:": my 30 ';:'E:X.RS

RéS.;r3:3za::3E:§~:?:§ 49;; 73:: 4(3) ARE; R] A;

 " ' -$Y*%~§€};3'91,H€f}C}$EBUS STSE?
=  $;§='m:*:: 2%, 3:4, fvEAH1%f}E;Vf§?i.§R;% P83'?

WE~i§'E'E;§7'fEf;§,»E3 R33};-ti}
E§i§E'J€}f'sEJéf§.§?f§f;-36{} Q48,



46:5;

4%}

aga:

SHE MSSAR

S,' (3.. L-ATE ABDUL BASHEE-R SEAR
AGREE RBi'_}'1§T 36 YEARS

'Rffii NEAR DEESEZL SHED. EV) QERQSS

"§v'ARD-3, dU3'TIC{?; BIIEIZTMAIAEE L}§'i3"'€}i.§'F 

§{.RF'UR13aI\!i_. §§3§iT'=§GAL£')i%E~5t3CI 

SR: Ifiivifiib   ..--
3,10. LATT3 A9*s::sU1.. BASHEE-R sag 
AGED ABQUT 33 Y'E}A§€S   *-
RIA: r»:::>0§2: BLEILEJENC; '

POULTFEE' FARM COE\2EPQLf§€i3;§"§ <:-r2<':>;~:~:S  "

WAR'{}- 1?', DE;vA3Ar=31§;:2A_§.Ai:4;';§<_.%?~i:¥e:.9g\x:
BA?=§{}ALGRE--E~6C: ::,s3_5;-- _ ;  

SR1 SAEJAR 
3; :2. ML351"§;"Gi¥::g;);;5;.E€a.§%:'sfa " « 
$I!§¢E Es'?='€§;E¢%«.§% E'£3_'*Er'§f'E~3§$ LE5.
3M9*:<.'J3xYA:;r--LéN%§:~;SH§g'--- .. .  

13;; Q, '':m*:: 3".%::a;;:{ :5 
333$: §\«iE3gJ<':T}i?:_'v~. * 

   ..... 

sgagmz ' - f z1§'g4:>%»<§&;:;R ,, S%€: :'§§éV;is;_:;%.'i¥;2«::3 '-3; <3: 'm*:'E S&E«J&1*~I z%<§}E:«:_Evi:5;J£f31'*<E ':Z"éRI £3333?

ago. LA"'£'ff« again }"§GEZ: f*.é¥E§J{;T¥ E SE33 §'~3E3;'j5,(fi€ fifiéifififié S; #3. E.»2'-'ETE1 53=A.E;<}§§E'«§ §~':€Z',:§§: Mfidfifi Ssjé} Sféi ,%E;EE:ER Eff}, LATE SAB-JAN AGE: i\r§.fiu}€3¥% Sfiifiéfifi :-'$,i{I:>, LATE: saagazxs AGE: MAJOR SR: Aiwéxmxk Sff}. LATE SABJA?é AGE: Mfadéfifi S:§ViT'. FAMEETHA 3,1 C}. LATE SAB«J3%E'~§- .

ifififia: MAJOR ' s3xéf:f~.%'..:3:i;»a;%';§::::;;:;;m.% ' "

Wm. §=::.«3§a;;:«,.R _ _ Eff) IATE ._ * gag: Ev%AJ€;1-R _ F$E;5Ei§3€C_}§~3i}E§TSv'E3§g}'V~7§"{}-._5Eé?EEEEEC ;::g;a,;

JA'y'3,§9fA?vi. SH ET'1«."-'E? L-A"§"€%'¥.}'T, '"§"'EN'§' 5:305?) iia.

" " 35v_As;%,_;~m:%3:, ii. Ea;?=a:«;%A:v:
B§'§'§GAL{3E;E}45§G {::3:5. '4]$§v§*:*§"'-:::?:';§§gz' W] :1 ':~«a2':f::E:::t: 3%; H536 $4399? 35 YEARS "'t~ Rf;-"x:'~_N(13., EQASTEN GAQLI, i1E'€NiY}'sPPfi RGAD .A §£L?'2z€BAR Pm', E3£%NGA§xQRE'"55G gag. * " :'§MT. C.E~§i§)"§'E§£A WIS" HYQER SAB .%C%E?D £386? 51 §*"EE+§E'13S E f £51: ?\102, *9" BLGCK, Jf*s':'E§§'\§i%C%f§§€ B£'i.NG£'sL{}RE--S60 C313. '-XII

2. SNIT. NAZBQGN wig. DHAVA SAB AGES mom" 43 ntgizs Rm; ..JC)PADE IN Gem'. LAND BANASHANIQERI '¥'E3MPLE -

£::'»ANAESH.z%.£VEKAi€i '_ BfiNG~ALiT)RE;--560 0:37. RE$_i.2§_3_C}N}f}E§*";E*€5f':3 :3; $12: J.PR'AKASH, ADvC;<:ATE; 'fling R':;iéfa}, mic; ?~¥€)TI{3E TC £}'f{'HER RESP{}?'€BE?%""§'i§';?!S ;:>:S"P§:§$s2=%:§ WITH) TEES RE;v:s3§<::N F'E;'%.'i':'¥.§f3N E8 F:L;§:L; :_:;-5;. 1:5 CFC z5x(3§xEI\§ST THEE 5")?'-3¥'Z:§1?% mrrazzn :2m--_:,'.2(§<::_2 eagsrgsv am ;.A,wc";«.:<"r:x: arm <;S.i-3<::. 6'34/9:3 ON THE EELS ;_<::2=~' THE' .'2I.3s§"}<"-'f_§§.z5;:C?§3L.CiE'E":' SEVEL JUf;<;;;E;, E3P§N{?~AL«:.i)R_E;3 D1$MEs§$§.I*m..m.:';Jc:x:=<;1:«;i.§"i:,E:s u;'<;3 :7 R 2: {:13 {%3:!&:(r_i:: <3? (":93 _ - ' T§§2s;"'§:;=2fik';is:<ii§§:.; i=*'e:*:*:i:*i:c::~2 C;z>:~;::'i\:a3 cm: F':'_'3E A;:;§v::$s:c3:§ THIS my, 3*-3&1. C;v:1,$v§JB§*;°«E;§£a«I3_§3.f§'Ir§E _m;:::.m::w::~@:3; . R '?E3_.E Hlaféfif _is_§i3t§':Id Vfi;§1~ admissgiané with the conga): caf «§.t;a:*;£¢é?§ %.;f.".-'rAm.:1$ei f§f""':::'e;;:'t h partigs, it is taiwxz up for final ' =.<.ii:;';:v¢sa3;' _ ' ' A Eize 16311136 Cieuzzsei for pefitianers, A. _ 3, ""§"7'hé 'iriai $310113": has 1°eject.ec:ifi.1.e é}§}1}}iC£~1'£'i{}E1 fiiad by _§3ai§i=§:&:ier$f:§e:f€:1§§a;1ta {gr miectiaza. at" gziainlfz The suit was W§'_,E,1i§§'%i€."£.':f6(Td§ 1733 {£15 ysar 199$ T9315: trial (720111? has framfid ~ Vi;-wanes ami taéai is tmdtszr pmgress. %:c%Wm"dm

4. As Couid be seen from the im;311gm=:é 01'de1f_;.___the:

d:::f€:::eci.ants have s01.1g}1t for rejectian of piaint ilrging of ciefbnces avaiiabia to £31,511: ::iu.t'i3.1g :3. The law is; fai1'.'{§; well settled. In _c§:1§€i=_td o::'c3.1_1*5;i(,§::_:9Vg;;zj; a"pp§i<:a"€:£o31 11:1ci6r Oitier Vii R11§c:_ 11 CPC;;fi1e iZk> 1;i,:fif Wiii ii.a{ie V is Consider th.::* piaint averzziéizfis. a1}{i?£_1cii;[ .the £icfeI1c€ avariiable to ciefemiaxxts, £3. Thttitfare, the revision :*;:t'f:7'%ioIi«._iSvriénsmisseci. Sd/--= Judge