State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Dharaben Vijaybhai Gadhvi vs Uma Education Trust Rajkot on 22 October, 2013
Efiil'-1..,mm..
THE i:flN$i§"M'ER. E}i:SPUTES "R;E.i}F.'E§.E§vAL :CD}i«§§%€§SS'§{}N _ GviI§.££R..«§gT STNFEE ».'¥§H?:§ih--*EEfi.as3*.B.R¢.i;'3 .
' I-=€I%3_. QF .... ..
Emiging mi Iaf iiamgsiaim Na, 2;{§?' flf 293%?! '{}§:1arahe.:1 ":»a";i;,i-a..3«*hha;i Gadhvi C53'. E%§ai'1§:5.§1¥3}?1.a.i Q, Eala fit-...dvn--:a.§.<a S1<1iE{I<1ar €fim.pj§€x.§ Nam?
,j'a§rshre;e T'&ii:i_e;:§ Ram ,]"u.naga1ii.§1 .&;3§J&i3.ant "§a*'€l"$1,I.$ ilma E::i1.::::.a.t.im1'Ti5:;*ust Rajkm T¥.".1r-flugh ¥'ri11cip.a§g'Pramu'kh.
{}II';£§ Vidva Ehswan fifssmais i?Bu.s "7f"aI.k.'Ees Eiaiavacl iflasafi Rjajkm Eflffiififlflfifilfi ji;i.SfiC=E RF. Eh-uiakia, Fkefiident Smt. ,_h-'E#'ti P. }=E%T£'§§; MEi'i'i§:i-E!' gm: Th.a;\E::I:s:$:~g,% Me;m'h»er .xXppe.araI?scE:
isvir. "'*.«*;ii;. 1?Ei;:'j§si:1"sz1.J =flvE§¥*'=fi%"fflfE' 'far the app£::lEa:r1't 'E';=nt}mr§, a§.va£:a'$e ffi¥'."fl'1'E:3'i&:E_»§-flVE§«t'.:§£-'_2'£'i§ {E33 Eufitite E'st..P. ¥11vTh.n~§.a$:i.:a5 firegififlmt} g:'1;i;'I"&$-E'iEi1'i; a1;;fpe:E.§ar§i and HIE. hmre filed m.m;}E.ai.n*: heffirait tifaé:
{Ia:ns°a_.:m&r £.3:isL;mtes% Eea:iTTre:ss--'-33$ iF':amm, Rajkm fis€<:i£I1,fgf!' Cfi%I1":'£pi;'1;i}f'2':'i;'i.§ Ew, 15*? srzrf 23%? and 1?"? {:3 181 $1' Eflfii £553 cimztmmxi Que-5"fia-n flf f'ai:'i'S;
:1 was :ii%3:*21,"~;mi'v;.+*efi.,. ti":-xe D:i$§r'ii£E:ii%:;rum1:méa:rd anfi 31$. tile': :ts:;rmi§33~£iim5 3 mmmmz an ?1ExE--§E.'i§ W:§'1§i'E'Eh§r* ~.t§?lr;_§.;~. ¢:_:a:3E1?i}$E1E.i§_.1?Ti{$ .fiiE.&-ii :%im £mn1piainant:s w«.s:1*e:'z- s§'iiSmi.S:iE{i. ag»grim:"a::2:i $33: an-fl di%s;3ati:3f§_ed wifia. Em 3ud.;,g1€1f:§3;:1E; anti maxim? at' me £Bistr:i§::t '%F?s3r1m1, r:m=*':s1'#5:3%l%.2:ii':1;ir_:'i $3?
Cflmgiafint 1%, if}? £33" ma? has filafi the 'pm§m*_:§ 21'p§3~E.a;I. ';!3afm*«e. this Cmnm.is$ima;. Fm tjha: gaistxe mf ca%nv'enLie:r1.:seF Em: paX"E'i§';$ are a::i.{i:x*£:==ssa:i ti1:.1e.:.ir a;}r'i_gi.m:1E. ;:mmem§.amr1%.
E E: is .req'a.1ir£e£5if_ ta Em nm.E=ei that: "file g-;:r:es.e_=m. appmi has §.:m==e:-3.3:: fiieti by i§3h;arra.ba«n "s£'i§a3~*hh_ai GaflE1.a:vE.,J §rri.giI.°=__1aE £mn§;3§a.i;E1a;m {sf {Cun1.§;:i.aint LNEL RES? emf 2:m?%, 8:1 g-(ring 3:}1'm--1.,1gjh 't;hs: mam-::: fif alamai it i:F'ém3pim*;E:
tlxzflz a;3§3ea.1 m.var§m- has; 1M:'--:.=E'--:'§'3.;. szigmed §:a§:r .-S§.€.'l!';I.'IB2 mm azfim am 11:3: ihe a%§peI.j¥_=a:n.t;. "Fu:'tI%1e::*,_ 'iimaa miii-:.aEa.E;:'1a.'I*_::"~m_ ':3? id. ai:i'*va.a::x+*.::a.?;ie?.*; ifihgrié '3.%=iaI:u:t='$h E:»3.E.;1 §}.i'fi={il1£E{i &'i3.{}iH.'I.g t:e'e.#'1?_.'Ejh file. 1':1emse:r {if 3.;3pe.ai its agirm Hm: 3..igm--::i Ew Ehfi a}:ajp<eEEam'--i:mm3-ia.im.ain'§. Hmwgviaxfg. are am new 1-*:::t*s'm*i:;:ag;~ 'mm %es.=.T§3y::we.=:
a:5.;:=ea%:'ts uf "1ir:as:a'E:H:%r%.
Shari fans af tbs: casséz: af' the _§:-esazati smsi 3§:rpeE.Ea.m £::~EEl=:?:"r r:%:::3%::1'§iIa:i::1--an.'%t;é$ hefm=e-- E:%§.ssvt1*:§<:'?c Fmum are as mrtssfisr: '":§'Etm§
--wmp§a;m:a.m gm af$.I3'T}ii§.§$3.fl-Iii in {Elsie Ffiii i:i;rEI.§:ge 1-ma ''m..»* the rmpnaaera-t fur ihe year .»$:.x:mr::i§;11g ti: i1:~;t':.*, $11-*3' mid tha fa;+:§:%s as jgfser 'fiaae ruiezax Ssaif F§.'£I1iE1I3=£Z§iZi h';".fii._i£:ge3 im:"E:u:ii:f1g figp-aim-11$ .h.awa: fiEiEi.'ifi.éEi:i§ m iifltffiafi-E thsg fE¥2'S-i m 'iiliw timie Hf w.h.i.::h Wag flbjettfiii tea has 'WE C1:3=:rn;§1.3;i11;ia1='1E:; sami ME':a:&1* $'i:t_§.:.:'i-Ema sf" Kim: §'TE Cft:ml_E.egi:E.. "E'h=:=3~r.'Ef"s:;tE°=e Lkeajgyizagj *s+*a3r1._ga;&a11a:ss:: agaixlat thsis S=Ei3;I.fl:ET*:f?1t:§- mm n_1;3;:ms;§:::ii. t'}i1€£&é ffiéii hflie, me «:3-mmnem im.s>:t:§§u.ti»::::1 :d&s;?sf.1;u:s:€£:i the interim fif mafia $E'11£ient3. Ft hm Emmi: fu:rE;1'3;<&r ajiE£i--:~g-Eizfi 'that: iii the 3s~.ea'r 2i=E§=§33~{}réi= E:E§~E§»Li-«E35, }'u:s'ti:: E: R3 S"§1;a[h Ciamm..m.'iE;£=Et»sE: hsaia ::1£:t'i. :$.1::gf:ge smfi am~* i?§j1mE3:.£ii.=$é: Trim faea. in ?:~?'$}';J*iE'.£ {If t'§1at thee flpp:mI"1e§'1t. reainv-argaci fmm marsh.
1-m.1dm1£. {if 1" and 3"" War ii.n.€i'm§i11g the cmn.1:rEa.i:mmE &.I";laiT3. 5? __
3.,.5m,:~ fmm. Ezhflrsé :3¥'u«dm1'§:.$ ¥i?l5'1£3 tfiflk adm'i:3.3i.Q-H far {Em yaar EfiE_}<=}~fiEs.
.2 'The s;t?u€§.£'-2.n.ts thfirafure 'made repms§::1f{a.E.i£:1'1. rm flgfilrflilfiflt' §.I"a£ti.'EElE.i£:1I3 imzi it iiid Imi: care in give: :an.5.r regflgr, "£"ih.erEfre, fim x*::nmp:i§§.raam' and fi§_'I'."iE¥.' si§;1§}:::§wt$ _E%1.avs:~: aiiagam that is d§§f.§£:i§E°E.{l'§' in :'$»"l?'if3"i€'i€~'-3' :3:1.'tE:e paw 3? EM: {:+§':§m.3?:§§i§.t aiisfi fiieii t,:'u.m.p:}..a_§.3n£§ '§e:fm=r& EEEE "B-igtriit. Ffl=E1§£i3TE. Tim :3x'§§eE.}ajnt he-'rE.i13. p'i'%Ei"_{;"t'§¥Zi far :"4tefm'3fi af "%43,fii1S_f §'i:%*it§'§ i:1i.;er'&-:a.'i 13%.
iii Heam 'fl."lE adxsa-cam fair fin: rezéprzéctixrse 3:21:-*ti$*:$§ We h~:a=w§: :§:_E::::1 gmm Eh;mi_.:g'i*1 Kim ja;::ig;'::m::5.£: mafiérmi by thfs i.3'i.$t>ri:t .Fm°'um. am the £.*;Em:Li;?1.§iE1.s"1§2i§E.%I;'.3 §§}1{3E*$'IT§t is us by the-: }ZE3£I°§1I§.1?;.Su Tima j'r.1::Egn°1&r1'E'. ami m::.m*:'i :S}1m»?'$ xtiitiat Ihfi Gp1}fi1'_1EEf§.'$§ £ia's.»='xe fi_§3§}&'73.i1'i'€C1. $31135} flbj=EC?;ii'£I m '§h€+ fimxngfiaifit nf the s£::.':m.;}Ea.im.n£ {3'::'i'1er$ ami 'm.a.m1§'z* --::::r;n.te::1:ii3&s;§ Elm:
{Em Fumma Eiaii. 12¢} ;Ei;11:*'iS£:?§.§~:':Ttim1 €12: a<:.I1"i&:.'m.i.11 iim m:n1§3§%ai11:»*;s in '1.»-.-'§.E~~'§fi*' 31?' the Vsgmciak £:m: .§§p:ii£atifln m.11w?mJ emf .E£3f.}? and. s.pma§ (T15.-$3.} +fi&p1;1i:§.£ati{::n I*~£a..'1§:.;3fl8- sf ESE}? whmlra {he {::m*r1p§am.a:a§: =a;n.«.ai mixer S'm=§isE'n'Es: Eimre mmred Eifififflrfi if:m1:f3'1;:.:faE>¥§s Eiigh. Cezmrt 'Bf «E3'u_i.3..'raE a_ga.:irs.$t t'he~ fljpgfifliiefltg th_:a.t it§"£.--iE2 EllT1i§E1iI"§f r=Er§m.rt; altiaai-E the EZii1?'¢.%%£:%E:--a3;1* at"
.Px:*"im-.-any Educsa.-'1::i«m1 hm mt "hem cm1fir::1*ae£i $3'? I'~%';§tii3.r1a§3. £:a:':+.mr:*?:i$3'it:m fur T'ea€hE:§s' E:::im:a§im§_ {NCTE} and themfm'-E tfiiaat ffi5f§iifl'I"E. ha-5 Em signif:i%.{:an.s:§: and is me-min§£a3s._. thai {Em Q;pp{m.:e'r:E. im§it"u't*e ism: mi: :~:'r:)'i3g;'f11'E.E'§,+* dadmiteii Em': iE1§;€£'F'jfl:&1§. ;m_arE::.s {1'!¥f 'ma smde:1*i:% dug Em 1=*ez:sg%£:an:<:& as thegs' §£'3il'f'if3£1 §a.rt§&* in 5j;:wesa:ia§ Emil. §~"a_§};fi.iTif;'fi§1ii€3¥'i scarf 31:3,? that th.-E 331.3%: E:'mt1=1m;it*%tee-".3 impart: %va$-- ~'s:xs=z.mifs$:'i_i::<:i:i 'Ei3~*5«* mee ;_i1{:1:11a;a1;s,raa'hEae EZw'.:'.:':é""§ {if flujamt. zmfi ilh&'.*' '*.=«v'i?§ix:§%:. ha-3 Men iIT1£I'iE"=§:E.i:'$;$%fl T13§s'i:£he 1-:mp+:'::t:e%1at is in aficflfflfinfifi w§;tE:t rules am E"+EgE1i$3EiE}?F§.iS a.:::%~;:;I M gar ihé fi:,i.3*v:'E€t$§¥trs am? the hEl.i'lfi'1;1FEE1i£% High Ca-tart' nf {§1§ja;:;*;aE: anti %iE'XtE:§§ agmaunt has itaeum m:':Tile:C'i§d fmm the 3tt.1fiEE"b'§.S'S_.- it £1115 f1;1ri£hmf ha-ae-:1 Ei£§ii°if't§i.i'.ifi.9E(§ $iE1.a*;i'. $u§:mf&.ittEfl rajpmri mi fi.:..j2&@§%,s*' 1-:<:§;E§2@S§ that fee ::Tha*rgefl his the £}m:_'.3i?33.'iz':§¥it imtitmiimx wag fixed by ma hflfifi'13i*3§fifit H.ig;h :":mm:% fliff Eéujazrat and ma extm ¥':s=e&:$'_'1 a':::Eixa:r_g»eci.., it my; aim bean .s%§a.%:§:(i in ma regmrt that mare: Ems hm-;n ma mani§mE%a£:i@m. in time m.arRs.. i..:~1§'tE$g=, it h%3.sTi3=§:&es11 suhzrxittmi. Elm:
tjhéx ::c3r:n;:%_E.a'i.:1t':£ are req'u.i._resd in he dismi+3se:d as it a'n::sEEmr rmmdi. flf Ei.t'igEii'iQn by the -Eflmplmnaixtg.
5 {in page .13 as-f the jufigtment, tha imri-:2': Fmum has iieaist with the ~{:§m.£1EE.Y}.E:'i~m'i nf' 'iiilegai a:ie=fi$.1€:t'i={::rr1 -mi mtemai. marka and rgnzmrsew mi exams fags and i¥.ieg;3;ii.'w mmmi"i:t:e:fi 'E33? the *:::=;*g*1p=€3n.-ant §.n.sti'tu'timf1 and Emfi K3 the mm::111;§§un that as f13=Ei* 'time regmrt s.ubmit:¥Efi. fig? Mr. 1R:.ava.L fi:§::r*&~:':~tu%:*r surf ;Primar§: Ed'ut:a:tim1 nm:;hin_g rem.ai;n.s is he {§e*¥:-ermi.inEd. by :=:*i_'Em%:'r ¢';im;§&"fi Wham it 'sews decifie-:21? by the ha:1m;1,r:ahie High ¥:{m:rE: m S:§e~s:§.a3. %=:ix:Lii é;p'p1iL:a§.%tian 'Nu. EIFBI {if 2%? by Rs, j'u=fi.g:m.e:ni: atnd sariierr fiamd '1.}"'.1..mQS. T§1eri~sa:ftLer§, Ix¥C"I"i,E §:3:.h=n1iffise:& its regmirt daetaads };..fi:u~E.u»Efifl:§';$'1%):EiEfifl'@i Aifter mquir"-gr it camfi 'ta the Cfl1T§tiT:i$Si¥E§f§$. t;he:*$ has been rm i'T'&'flaa?£f£i;};%:E;Ei$:1'$:i:l§1iTi azbsnm the 3m;rk::s;; $2} the feesfi is being s::%:I*;:'a1*=gaaw.s;'§. as fimssd 'has the E+Im:s;."'1.:.~%I§r& fI€iiTg}:: Cmm: and Tm E§ig1>1e::r extra fees has 'been. chargie-d:; {3} infra:3trux:'tm-a is fl\§3§i3§§E$.Eii'¥IE.. w'EC a'm:::::&:%p%£s fiTfi.~'E repu-rt mi' 'in.q'u%i.rfy* C'-fl;IIf£fi'I'tiE"tsL?3E arm aubznitfi the: mama 'hefu«m tI,E1E hm':-m.1r=a;hle %Cnu_:°t far 'E:i1:§=i.r kind imfmmaiim1'X 5 Tim .E:3:.*u_m has same ms ifhe ::%u:x:ciMu$:im: that the cam;a=l.a.ii:1am$; have mt chaifiengefl. title &b:m'e~ r~apva':"?c+ Ra-e§::in.tgf in mmd. an asmacts sf ting maxim: tfifxe fiifitritt Fnmm mg the basis :::1HEm §u.d.§gms:.nt' tie.¥'i&s":E§'§.N:1 by the h=unm,1:rab}.=e High Cmm nf {3'ujar.a-t and in view maf thxa :re:p.=::m=_ mi NCTE has mama m the. ii-$.:1£iI§E.i$ti.E)£1 that mere is nu def'i£i.e:'r1€-gr in SEFi'Vi=ZE mi. thfi part' emf the Gppenent and 33.33 £:"ame H3 me »:£:rn;x:i1;§sEm1 that ti§1er--E issp rm mar1ipui..atim'1 Sal} fair 33 dv§sds;1:£:%'t:i1t3'13 fif intesrnai marks $5 m*::a*7:cerr:.efl. as alE.eg&:fi fire ::n=mpEainantsi T'iiaeé- Ifiistrietj Fa-mm t.;her:efm.*aa fi.iS'Ti'£1i.§-Séfifi the i'2~flmp§$i.nES... % F 'Wk hatva aim gflllé §hir:3u.g¥1 tin: jI .mégmen'i* remrai M' the c:--:1:rm:fia'int and E1-eagrd iiixe Suh'm.i3sim='1Ee am he-§t':aE.f 9f the parxiets; Wnéf. ars:e agrEejm&:nt: Wifii the fi%€i.$is:3:i..'1 'ti&¥«:=&?:fl h*f 'Elm E3-Ti's.jt::'i::*i"é; Fmfum mail? firid M infirmiw camnmted by rim Bi5t.ri.m': Th-:3 ::r::*de:* paesfisefi. ibis- ihg mmrict. Famm an:-2&3 um r&C}1i'§I'E any Emerfyerence in «a_p;g:3fiaE.... "§.'h;a am:-eaii therrafmre raem3.§re$ m be §i.smi_ss&fi, =i:S'm.i:s§.ed as:-§:$:11"EiIiI1g}.5r*. Na urder as ta csysetsi . Vhé TPrur1n:m.ca&d an t§1":"3 : flay uf fla::ta'::she:.:3 em [fR.,¥'1.. flhm.iakia} i?r§:.sei:l§:tat:
um. TI§§mk$£4ar§ 1'_1'yo:i P'; }la;n.iE' Es-i§e::?;1'h-e'r Evim:1'h--er