Karnataka High Court
Sri M Ramakrishnappa vs The State Of Karnataka on 20 September, 2011
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
Bench: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
ANI}:
Efimig §3'2?':<Ez1'1.2~:v2>1i.}2 i D/G EVE E¥€.§2r:'121}<;ri&,;hr1;=.%ppa 2'-Egézéci .21E3<}=a;t'. 29 3x't3:m°5:; :'%..}.3 a:°€= :'@$§{ii.:'1;;§ at §'\2":.{§5§_ §E2?1ng3§21:1z?z§'.E':;T}'uram Nezix" Ef}€}33h.i Gh.2?:t'. .N§&1'£"'§};"£i.131H'1EE 'E"'e.m;31€* B21:'1ga1i(;r9 ~ 58(2) €}'f§} ' {Efiy Sri K Rzmje;-m T316 Siaie 0? Kz1.1"":'1z;?:4g:}_<:;1 E)ep21ri:rrT1e:«::2i: of {'3<)r:':-:1":L%:f{:{;_ J V _L A:'1:i £r:{1u§~31;.ri£:*:€§§ V§d12.:3:.:§:1a Sfirmziz-2. "
Baxziggzziare -558 Q€';é-- A _ ' 'V 1 R€'f}Z°€-S€3E}§,8:T§"bf{_ ii.:3§:§3>'z"2i§1(_§'§fp23.-I h Se:>'1"e"E.2?::'}5._ " ' --. 1 ' ' . = ffihve }*§;:;1j:é'2:i'a1k':::.; in d1-,%.S'E:r§aE f¥;.;:''€a":' "
Eifiigrvfii <)p§1?1:'=,j:11 E &_§:"5a:>Vza.3."é§,,? ?<l;_> 34» _;-' 3? {E £'7§0{;:r, E*%3_215éE;€.1*r3'£'.E'32::§;3a__ §3;1_§'1S§E&1§, B u iiiiiiig , E"v5:¥.,,%.';.§a=§.!§E?§ an 355:5.' Reaiz d E%}21n§,§2iLE<3:*s::«~« 5&8 {Bf} .._1.5é:%§.}:"a:%ss:::'"§%;.<3ai by Em {?§";3'.€f' £€',:><::%::7v'L:";1E.:vs.% <}i'§'E:?.€:'.
" "= f.§.'}".iE€_",'" 'AS;:?<3:.»;":§z:~;i L-a1i§f§ .5'-'acigzs 2? s:=;§';.130:[z C%i'§T£z:e:' ;'§.Ef:«.V'E3;vN0=3,:'2., IE {§m:~;:ss. EE :F*-'§€:£>:z §%Z§3_{5=%z':€:"f1§{;§i{i.;1n§§5 G2:::€ih§:'122§§g2zz"
~--._Ei%:1i":;,:,.f{§--ef:§f<;: 4?» 5&0 G09.
""'F§§1.:1§AEgfiéijrigzi §f}z:%§:1;.:2§'%;' {:{}§'E'1E':}Ef:'sf.%§{}E'1%;"f§' E35553" §i:.;e.::T":<;§ ?:{f{§:,::$:§..§{i;::§.; Ei§2zi':;,:;22§{::§"s% ijifisxri §I}§:~«§i':rie::i..3 §i%2?z::g21Ee2'a-:< R EZ%2..s:':<é;z€ E4322} ;':¥»f E,-i:::%.1;,€'f .§{a:':3 £':;g;:%{§ ;::E>s:s2.:€ .32 jg"{:'£,%i"'E§ ' «. E-?é.?1; i'i:£:*_;:*:€ri«:. ' Kfimewmw Kg' 21 Ni}. 322$ €'S¥-5'3 £I'm:~§ss 4"' EVTa.i.I1. E i3k3<:ft}«:., 2"'? Si.2-zgger, CE": gmdrzz Leigroisé § E332z.n.;__,§a1:3:'€ - 568 0&9 61 Szii R S§7£;i'V2'iE'£1j S,_f<> §,,.3.Ee §{21r:1z1s2.vz::1':§ Aggci .2':'E)<>:Tz':T 5&3 y<;%::.::s'=s Rfa E\Te:>'S.E_9, ?"*'§E Cmsss K§%z'*:g.g€;'§ S21'€.a=;':§iii,::-;~=. '£":m2'§} Ej-3213:'2g;a.E<3:*::: ~ 5166 £368 , . . ; §{i;:§§,vpQ3'1£Z<-: j:1'f; 55! {B}? 8:": Vs-;=,;;'":}<:2s€;r;%ssE': I}<}dV{?E*z:::1i', AGE! £'§:>:°"E~ii1 RM4:
Sr: Pravt~:€>::': .E{2zmar E'~?;?;i}§:>t:e,.&::§ixi)<*:'a:€ fag" :32' R6; Sr: T Shesfsagiri _R2a<i_f }'~'§dV:)<t2i%:{--:L"£'%<3V2°V8:5: R-6' S€'{".-"{;'.{i} This vméti, pe:"a:§§':£{3:'2 is 5:Ti§;{:%<f"1:::':f{§::::f A.éf§_§<§£§;=:s; 226 8: 2227 G?' §.:'1€3 C:;3§1st,i§1:,:i;Tim:"; *ui:7 . :I:'i€;E:'.;;;*,_ §:>£;'aj;§§::%;§ iii} quash E3-E"8}:i{E§§.Ei21§'§f z1§a€':'a.,f§_':1_2:E==_11{§§:i-€7§l::a"€;§€;%§":é$sV...£:;3V:é:,2{;=:ci by ihfi R3 datfisi 9.29231)'-2?" wire 4';'5'?n.'1;.'i_5_<:1-R. am3fA~.:::a:ed £55,299'? made P1E"§.X-S in V~~:e;::; 1?"'at* «?éi}"3?'{?'.: §}$t.§§ii£>'§}€":;S em: ::9r:£:€z"§'1<«:%d 3.115% €::{:x; ' ' ' "E'h1?é: 'i'K.:"Ef'fi g3c'i:ii:;ii:§:€;--._'<:£>:':2mg an :f¥:}r p:'@}in2i§1e2r§.; Eéezzriyzgg in v{}:*€;=-::pg.v 1';E...*:;}sa day: 'she: =::<}u:*€ mads": the f{§E§i:<.2;;::*:;;;?:. " V' V ' GREEK Eégimzt §m;}2;;§g;§§';ié{§: é:E':é;% §}r€:Ei:':23§z3.2;::*§;' _ :':g§;§T.§f§€'<22%§«€§'§:":" 'éiazifiéii {3*§:}»{} §,?;€}{}? §E'>::2r:a*:><::':s's;;% E35} :;:_:':<§ €E':s:> ¢iT'§:"::;:.'§..:i:e%,Efi<:2:£§@;: <§2:f(,€::'; E5,{}5.2{}{}Z? {£%,EEE'3€.}:'Li§"é?w;'§§ §§§;'%%E§,€fi{§ 3"
'_.:1":?;:.::%:' fi%a:3:_%ii{§;'2s;§ 28$}; ;2m{f~§ 2§§§{~/'2} raés-iep§r<:E.§zr<%E}; 2}? E'.E"_:§:"-.* " §*{:é:":'2_;2z:'z";;:,§a::=2 .E:':<:§22;::;§:'é2;:E .:'%;:"§:a$ Ef}{s:.*§:%§<;;3§z:<%§'V:E: ,§§<.:é,§ §€%%%%*;2 W4"
2. Sri §€a§:jz::'1 §{:,::na21 the §<3a:*:'aec§ zi:<:»'u:'::<;:€:§ Em' Ii;E3;:;% p<:tif.§@r:€:~:'s s~;;ub:;":i:'.:§ £'h:1'£, the pi;":t;§'z,,2Z<:>::'*:«s;*.§*;<-;; zg-we: i:§.jm"~r.'i-éjgezi. r€§3r:3s;a=%:3i.:1i:i'v€:s; if Mu:1i*a2*e11ka'é.2m13f:121. He $;z_:.Ej«mi{s5;-- f§j;Zi;a"E.------ ~ am: Said ML:niver1kz7;'é.a:11m3. iihe ._::>w:r3séér Vi:-é'f=.'§,»':";a='~," $é:i<§1_ V a{?€;1.:_§r<;':<t§ Eéiflii, {Em hetxf §§§%a.t.h ii"; *§j3"--e{§' .m:;%;z;:L§1i<}%i'T--:
flair}; E2': I"€S§)€C§, <3? {ha-. E:»::1d in_v:fi§u_<3S*;=i{::'.r'r.__s.:.2'£1$V image of that fi:*s¥:: §_">eii£'.i{>mW-2:" iéégrzla§g:;*i--5;§§§:r._a":}:.§§a2. "if: ':_E3isvv:§:'egT;'2£..rc§§ Ezéi bringg ii} my §}0':;i(:<;. 'V§9§§;§.§i:;2: {A;1n{5Xure-E12 far 3132:: yea: "§§;E'Ii€"'t'<',='"&'¢£ET1{".f{:'; i'._haE {ha mania g:>§ is; @105; shim;-'3': in this Eviaezz ::I:1e m=:{:{2§:'€§ <35 rightfi ($55; «:25 fiééi Eirfii. §>eE§é.iz2'r;s*.':", {he :<"s:;.:bs5--s¢:%:e:}:,1€3:zé; ZiE{/7,f{:§§ii5$v§§,i{3.*'§E. ;*mE.i§"i{:a*;:i.:>:1§e _h2:2V:=: fix} ::s":<::=:s;s.a;1.riE§: ."W[/:§:2*%_va*:_§ :1 5.--.§;?:w"M-- 3fi_"§££.1'§"ii';": {§:f%§:a:- f§rs:--»,:i: p&%%.'i§i<.>:§::t§". 0:": éihig sghart: V' §?{§;§E"§_{i ._:§:=1.§>:::%;?~_::E'r:€: 22,€:qu§$iE;§<;::: §>':*<}<::€::;%§£i:'2g_§s £L"f;"t E_:?.2s_"E:>E&% :s;:a 5%_}e:r }::-£3; s;z,.:§3::':i'§:S 82*: ?~?;2?:.;"g;§ gm Ei':.:n:2::".
Sri §%.:=:mjzm E*::::m2::::'* $:,.;%3'i::_ié;$ €'.E":€:'é:: §%1§:% ;*é:%-$;;}<:e.:1{§.€:1':'E:
't f"'""@W'z§ %'"
§';2:Es'--;€-3:§.}* 2322*:::§ i's°:m<§;:Eé2:';'€é$; {,7§,§i?:§'E2§'EE§~__§ is: 33:': '§L§'"£{i' » 3;':;»<»m;&§%.x . 3 wmm%§ammxx -7- "?'. E? ?.,i.E1"E'h.€'1"; tihts §}é:%?;i§:i<}m::§":'%§ g§ri:==:*.:a11£*;@ i.$ }'1C'»i'. avg? ézhg»: a.{éqz.:i.s§i%'i:>:': <31" the isuzii as such E:w.,:t: si1'v"§-'vi?ZjI""-.f:,§'§¢.¢;': :*<:%ceiving;; {sf %E":<=3. <:<>n*:pé:*;'1$ai'.i<:r:': 23.m«:;'m":'%t_*.3__ §:$:gi" . r€s;3<'2:1:ier::. N<.>.:"3, '§'he%§r <;::>m:<é:":7.....{gm _*t§€€'"':%§§df%3s3:=3§::::iL-V Wé_"€._E:_s:i>z;:t. i.:1fi::%'r§%%ri:2§§ in the 21<3c;:.1§ss§.'t':i'::§;": 8' '§'}:m %,€::1abiEit,§; '*it_§f:€ "$0.3 disbursillgg iziae {:23z:1ps:;'::*:s=;2i€:i€>11..*:gii;£{§'g%3;) %:.§:é":?eSf;»:;rzée:1€; ?¥Ea..§ t§epe:":.€§8 an f;h;:=~. infiéégfiaéf'-v:}E'V§IE§§;«::sv::if?' p;f<;{:<i£%di::.gE3. if the suii ES .':§)%fi:,§Ei}'.:€V§:}§'1{E1'f'3 m2E§:'fyi:1g;§ the g'e':2e:'a§ ;:c;%;vé::""%é:.§ :iEt'j{2}:;i:é?§§5~ d£§e::a--.:rne,.:'::'. 21:16} 3:216 Sééfifi' iéeed zmgé ifiii. §é§='%§'-czxié _{4§'::3j:'i"'*%:.Eé€' petéfizémérss are Elhfii isrwikgi <>w:":<:3r$ <}'§'VE:i§1<é ivzzxiai Jim. '?:i;:,;";r.:;<:3a§;i:}:/2,, ii: is émiy i:§':&:':": éhai". :i%3.€ A p€i§V§.i%*;:}e::; §}$C£}iiz"ii?§V__€?§1E.§i1§€:'{§ igzzs :"€aé€;E§_v=:: tbs: a:é€;:n§;<:z":552z.i.:{3:':, §i'}; L*33?;.~.E;{T:§.'3;._Vi7§:'.i":"<'if3';5€$1'_}'§L'§.E2Zi§'{§«', firm rs3$;m:1{§.§;'::'1i. Nqiifi zmzy E1:-35%: é;;e::%' .:"§%'::':}:-*§;%§"*--V'i.ir:_éf' a:':2<;':mE': fmm ?:.'E":e E'€;'/S§§}{}§'§{§€E31'{. N95 zmgi 3%.. 'iézi? §'}é':"{§"{i£§}'E'i:%i',§"§§ £22' $.15; :ar%3_<}é%*v€;' 23$ €::":'?:4;E:E€:{t§ £19 CF: :3<:%3:§Y1u;;§:% '::§':a€;*; 2::::1;{::'%L:.:".2_E,5 C<}:3x?:*:rs~;;:*é}r3 if £§'::-3 {.Z'.%v§E {:{}§.E§T'3I' " :.2§.s'§:{3E{is; §:?.:_<a'- '§.-'§:1;§.§{§§i,}' mi éi.E'3%- ;g::?:'1;3.:'23.fi g;{';=a2,?<'%:_* <3? a:i§:i_.{_>r:':€:::§; _ 3 ._ da<t1.:mm1é; 2}iE'1{3L ihcé sezzfie (£65751, E'é"§e:é :;j.:z<;%é:=;"?i'i.<):": of i:Ir3;:"é §'€3E%}p{}'I§Ci€i"i§'. E\'f(}.iE""> rr3i;.:,1§'";;2%1'1§; thra amm.mi:$ <;L2.:=%s:3§:§.{'32': <3?' tiie §}€E',i'{i.{I§IEéi'3£'S r::%c:teivmg§ the ~ ;2.riS<3 211;. 211%, 'E'1?_1:: pa::*i:§:'%se haetvéé €152 K-x.i<,駧~:._;}§st: in Ehii Civii C€7§E.1.§'§l gghtére €),Sj'§<1Ei3§,/ :f 9, W§.E:h <i'hé:t=.$<;-*5 (3?}SE%Vé'1?%%Efi{}§'ES.A . is ciispssatéd :33'.
C23': ,5 --
» V:
aifix