Sri. Obalappa S/O Soppina Obanna vs K V Lakshmana S/O Chinnathimmaiah on 23 August, 2011

[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Sri. Obalappa S/O Soppina Obanna vs K V Lakshmana S/O Chinnathimmaiah on 23 August, 2011

Bench: D.V.Shylendra Kumar

O V. I " " A . . . . . .. 'V AA : L:;;:mi"'m;:*§--zzxssm EVEE:

IN THE HIGH COURT OF Kamgmmm AT BANGALORE I}§aE.e«:% H1153 i.§:.€ 23"? (E213: <3f';%1.zg3..:${, ;3{}E 'V BEFORE: ' THE HONBLE MR JEESTICE 9 13- is:?:+1*a*LE2s§n1=z;;§g'T;e:';L%:&§+1i,a%.I;§ 1-1/'r'£i .Pezi:';2'0r: 231:2'; z>z":éia;5--.(:é5?:?-sfz'; - , «. "

xamwmm SR: {>I3AI,APE3A Em"; 3<>ppa::\:A <)1%;x\éNA R/0 C}A'.E"I'I E-I{()SA}-I'AE.,LE '!.1*'§I.U§§ HO[4AL§<Z,§iZRE_Z 9 BEST. C.E*}TE'.I'iQAI}TL_,"%'§€'C}z"-_s. _ SENSE :>§:<:::AsE:>' (:23 «:>,:<As':1;§<%A.zr>§:;:»V ' 5,1) LA"i'E?; <3.EaAL;x,:-'é£3A A<}E::?:v;x§3:::»:;:[' 8 *g';?::zxR';=-:.b cm: ;_fOIN'£_' it: "

{3()I\£?€f§E§E§:{fEfxE; , ~ SE-€§M()':§1A" §?>:§":§_':':':{3?~:§a::~2 iv'-s " gt 1-«-Q '59» ; : 3/ En T'v;_;:§m *'{E--§.'é"§§j.i;}{f§ $323., Séﬁmz "2-?aE{k:.2§"1{i§ §:<_Ev&5.E L 'éé %;;':..¢s:§§§;£=é.M;xz\§A

-.T'::;fs:T2-.<j§§--«~f§i:x:' TE-§i?¢i?v'EAI;%E-"§ ;i+;<?;§2:§A::~ sﬁaséfg, "44 :«'2;a:;:§~:5§ '---E:z;<.> E:'3;.§'§{févi?;3¥EE*i§1E,E.,E 13:13:13}; *§:m,3':~:g {TEEKf?v'EA{".EA§,,UE?; ::>;:+;'§'*§{:::::'§' _ :1: E{.'»£g§,;*=;':<i;'%E-'£s":f§;*:E"~éfa " E: {>312 E-%i;'<I} E335;%;<:}::s:'§-»z;=a.:g:,:

§"ﬁE.'§?<E§.E%*{ ':::a:.,:.:2< at:«»§:K:vi;2_<'.:;:L:.5§z :.::;"s:~s'_*;'3-'2,§»<..:-*_:"

"?§ 2 5,54! 'E.'E~{§§ E}§"i.E3I§".E"'.f {§€}E'v'I,?\;IfE§{'3§{)I'~E§'SE¥2 C H2 KM}-E€}AE}.§R §3§$'I'Rf{3"[' C Hi §.i.?vI2'7a€}A§ 1.} R

4. EkSSISTAN'§ (3{}§'v'H\:'HSS§{)?\Ji*ZE3€ 'E"r'iR§ KER E3, {TE-1': I EiT'v'E:'X{3:;'*«.§}L§ 3.3% SR1 K. S . S}'{I'VAE'~éN§-X Sf G K. 53, E'E1XNJ{.§NE3AP§3A AC»? E. ?J§j"--'LJ'C}E?..

B . KS 31 P"§AI,L§ 'VI.§,§.xEi€} E3 BINUR HOEELI} K;'%.§)UR 'I¥¥.§lJK C PH KM'AGA§.,U R {)1 STRI CT {ﬁg ESRI K.S.RAJA§'PA S / G NANJ1§N§}E%.F'?A AGE OR E3nKO'D1PEALL§ V'I§..,-L,5&(§§§ V. ' ~.

BINUR M<>'13:.,1. KA:::t:¥g "EZ<'%L{,1'E<: _ ~« CE£1KMA€.}A§;UR £§?;S'I'E?;1'si":'I.V ' _ . * f 'R_ESE>(}E\EE)EZ}'&E'EE3 §By Sri Yadhavﬁ &..S'.2f§f;'E';. 13:-..:sEiL1pai':-mi;l;"L{ivS. fbr MI 55 2*a.E\}21ga':'zq?;1;5§3a ASs(>3;t1§a:.é$5;'-A=:i'v&§;« Eér RE $2 R2; S2"??? $9; <;T)i*;1;§»;L:;'512:i; AGA €;0'r"?Z3'*& E231:

- " SR5 W R£»__ are !'3ei"V€r,§}'

2)':

3*;--isss%--«i9§;'z?:f§f§0:'é as §éT';1:t,E;;:: :;:-s;:w:§.z~Am'1cLE::~3 226 AND 22? 0? T'E-EE {':(1NS'§'E'£Ti.}'Ei"£.v{}?\E t;i:r;«*- E.E"\§E}§z'xg §RA';'EN'G Ti} QUASH ayagggaag PA;S?SEZ§} 'vzsay ~51"-:~;:£~2: .;:xsa'S:.S€..exN*£.j (1Z'€)F\z'§i'\/Hfr§S3§(i1E'~§§§E~?; 'i'AREE<;ERE3 EN CASE N<>.s<:,x:~3'::'~--; .1 ;.:;{}{;:37»{:ra§--j_;:>A*§*§§I:>4: E 21290:; R-"EDE£ §%NNEXijE€E3e£i1 Am; TE-iii <>§z:>:€;¥+2 - PA5;=iE§.'£3E'} . :3? ':'§»::§<: ::>:~:;>m'*~z {fi{"}MMi%SZ{3>NER, c:~i;K§;aMTA<;A:;..:;R 1rx;1r_ <:;«-::$E_;~.-"Ne.§:>':'§,;€:}s?m5-c::s§ §}A'E"'EE% 3: 22.29%; s'&NN'E'fj;E}'R§i P',

- E-*E§'TE'E'§{3'1V'\§ V€,'Z'{}§¥/1i'N{i§ GM E?'{".}E'~3; E"f{.E*3E.,,-EFvE§f'§j7'aE{Y E"§§EA§2§N€§ EN €53'>:;§%<,;J;::>,r;*:<»::é;..:};:2: 'E'}--{E2 <::<?::,im rmzéga mg; §?<3E£.,{}'\f~£EN{}:

§REER "\3f::*:§,%i;. §;:.:1§§,§i:':i E3; pz.m:%:;1;<;€r «:35 2:: ;_§;*;:..*;2E;e{§ Earwi r::;@a%g:S2.:1*'i:"ig;j Q E?é{.'i"é°?§é§ 3% ;%;2::";*::as»:< if} 33' ?%§{;'; 58 is? §'§é1§"§i,EE"§'EEi§}%3,i'€i Z "':§?_:é§E2j--2g;§; §§f%3:"':.:.';z' .'%'§.:;>E::§§¢ §<Z;:{§a2:3" ':,.aEm«;; {T:§:§§§i:.;:'§":1:;-:;f§;2s§.':_.:2" i§'§f3~Z5§'.'§"§{f--§.,

2. 6' 3..

E/:;~.' ' ﬁg?' (. ésax §%§e m && aéthzimixlggg rigggiatg ﬁ;ii;.'Ec ami inE.:::r:=?s;'£' in £;h.i$ Egmii ::11.';::ie3' 21 sale i:.r;111s:sa<?'{:§{m dmssd b64993, €3xe<%:_.2i.&zd by I'€?S§}{}§'1€i_§3E§:§I;% 5 21:16 8 -- 5;<::f1§a {}f K N Na:1§z,i;'2;dz1p;321.

2, S:.:'E:sjé:%<tﬁ', Earzd hziti Ejcvn se;<3E'{i" £'.?{'>' "{':h €i <}§: ":,'£*L'1'1:=r. pei'§i:,i:t:;m-_>r by re:sp0:1_df3r:t;s 5 and v%;~--h<3 ::1"é.:_,_mr2,V a£:t;fi:i};°é€E,_ r*ight:, titfie same} iI'i'E'.~';'}:"€'St', to i%he"'3and é;;.r1cie.r 33:1 a:%§2::*1.ig3v1 s::1E<;~. ' trexnsaizttiaizz {iated 28~"5«iiQ9ix*. %§}*;{f§(jf"L1'£:€ii Vvfézhe fé:'5%;:

§"~*E3SpOEEdf;'*.B'i1, who hem}V<§§E::=jr11éf:'tiﬂi:§>L'~'§3c% .VL:1.<:1opE:@§'Aséﬁn 9'? {me Chikk:eﬁ;h1?§:1maiah Eiihézixéﬁi£:§1§r§:.:":1z§_iﬁiﬁi'Emd the -saaiii Ch£ki§a1i:.h.imn121i21_E1a-- vhzzdi-g{ir:::-- E.;5::rf;d.V"':1ﬁt.C7i'.z%19 2;: grezrzi, <>rde:° dated 8w8~§S«§?:5<4:;1i:L»V'i:§: _a. of 'ahrié §}epu_'£:y Commissieﬁésr .;L::.:{§é'1'--' »{i-f';'f--§§".{':'.fS'Et%E."»'{i "v.g::E:1sssess aiharésasi zmées 37% 43 ' hi J .43?' i'if;<x '.§5§ I" ¥"§[3'1, 'r.t'z'"'r':r9'1 §a:: ﬁr? 3": ';x'e_rE1 (3 §"";§--'>£'----'£?1 €tf'i':.nmr§ zuaxm \]X,.V':\.£\_,'.£ xxx; V V:_V.v; '.u_ !_11_')'V °«'_§L..LV.1%.A' v-..-:..s-V .i.\~.,-s..a.,Luz. A1.a..¢w AA :53 =_x~zV.\..«x 1 E}; :1 mg; f"§'€3€3 af ':::¢s:_ am» . %.E'*;.s:;§ 'T'=:ssV;i:;.:£ Rzzieg, ssubjéestri, €19 v3;;'3?.<}:1s <3{:=nd§éé@:':s;";;é:ri:i<§:.z_1212"f:j~J .s<§§1<-3 <35 per:§2a.:'::@,z1_%': §T:{>;§1»~;2Ei€:nz:i;§<>:z 0? ii: Q: g 32%.: 2.5%.

_ §~'<~::}§§.§.:::;i;€is".., __wE':<i> <7_':2"~:._i.:f;':_s:".=: ié°'ig_%:e.:; i"§E':E€: aiéd i§§:ie:°€:;=e;':: in éizs E4'./'§E..§7fi§."f1V..'.'§:§'7§. ::§§:f{f§;'Ti é§};'*'%1'122.:":::'2z;>:1 z2_aj:ra,.a? 2::g;'g__:§"§m7é:<§ ?>§; €:E':%é s';:'{§e:":s ?,::'é,f ;'%_:«;s;§s:aé;2;?s::€l: {fizT';::m":T:i;<:;5:»;.§a,:»zT2as.' in '§".:;?3'§E"§E5 53% a's2°{§{%:':"

26/ /""

%%§' "':%§'§%:t:%§.; ' _ 4 daieci Eﬁw E2:--2®£3z1» [capy at 13s.i'1§1{':X1.Z}"€wE {<3 '{}"1{:: writ _p<2:',ii:i<>r:E ;;:;ass;s€:%{i zmdetg" §3€*{',{5.iGI'E 5 of §;h<: §§21:":':2.:€,:--:E{:;z S<:?>{<%€:i.L:Ee%c§ Caﬁes and S:_?'§'1:%d2;sl.e%d '_£":'ii3e:e; {Pmhibiiiarg sf i§T:*i;ém=;;é;£"é%f;'.VV{;f Cemaaixl Egaaaiiss} ;'§.<?;§, 3978 [for s:~;hm"i', $19 A;:i;_'§ V_é1~:<1{i 2_?§f"ﬁ_:'nt£:;'~:::5i_« in z1;3p::~:::1.i ':33; 1?:..'m;% E736-:pui.y C(;}H1f33iSSi§}'i'i§%f'._ p7;3:s$_i'r;--§g;'..V_Leﬁi*§'gi_<:;"

:,1nde31" See::t;i{>'n 5A of the Ac?r:_:'~:,s per"€':I._d€»:-- {>:"{i<:é.§--A.d..2.ﬁ.éd 9:99":

2099 lcapy at A_11_meX:1rc;:--F to-"t.E1;.é=xx;r'r:t. pei:it.';a>11.} amd has s{>ug;i1'E: for qma5«;hi:1g.',§ af ihéégé {i;d}:%;";<3. 'w. ' LL Under '€:h.~::-2'"%«;::§§3:.:g=::€:d -.£§r{§'s:%r§;;_"3;L:é;i"2.<:2;f§t;i<%S :.;amd&=:.r 'zhéz Act Eaadg' '{'):;:{"i,_::€:'<;E'93121::-_Vi=;}1£;%~.§§{iEq§"&§::"i:V. iemci 'iamlng 2% g.grani;€d 'ézmd e':1'1{i. V]:1;1_i?£}:1_.g 'E:a:;:_&::;1 -5;-;i;i;€E' §'m:_...i.§:é:§ ﬁrssi, time E3}? 2: petrssarz <:E211?:11i:1gg..é.<}'--be.e:";:ég_;§;§ ..#»§14€Vi'f}f;jEf'.VV'é.';"ifilyiéff <.>rig§n.21E ;;;1'e::':E;ee: Lg: firsi, :*<:*ss;}€;2§1c§e:%:::'iV."%:21$ .;:>:3::" .§,E5rj:f:"si:.;éi.{e "i1:'&iﬁSEi(fi'.§{3§E Ciziiiezi 2;8-é3=w1Q93 3,2: a.fé;€--::* ms: Aa[%'i;..{j§§%:1%:3g i3:1i':{3 E{)§*<7:e and 115:: '{3ei§2;; pr:-><:<::{§<;»d g}::£r§::i»i.'s§;i.%;-:3 g;rz::':€éé}i§ by iihéz s;si;:::§;e;;': g<;:sv%3m_:*:::_@:§.'1t: E155 iiimt»; .. "':}:éi:§:s::;1::?:i<3.:1 as»; Kéfifﬂ 21.5% 32¢: s.=;:.zE>s%;z%qL:e:":':, mg:s::::;::m:-;"«":;&:::%:§e::;~ w'E"2i{?}1 §}€'i'iii§€§§'1z§§§' {§€i':'E'§'e.~"f:?{§ i.i§§e'-2 E-'ifiif zraidaégi _ 2:31:35?' E'§es.{':§,§::'§'é 452} 0? 'é.§';<'::: IKE", 2«::'1::§ head? €':§":é:?*:"z::§'1::2:/"*::;:, <ii:'s:<:£;{r:é 'A .3':;2s§:,z:.7::§é:i:;j;.§: {>15 §'.§1é'f': E;m:.§ fa; §E'::,*. ?§§f£f§'§iri;'f 2%:'":s:§ Ex} §'§Tf$'§',{'3I£'€? in //'.z' 3; V :' favaur of :°<és;;.><3:1<?§e;1i:§a E. and 2 ci21.imE11g 'E0 195.3321} hairs; of the m"i§;;i':'mi §g,'r21:1t.e,€5 Thia arder thmxgh <':ha.He:1gg;é:i in appeal beféfzre 't..1*::=>: E}e::§3uty C<>rnm£ss3%a:>:1.e3' E11V:«:__'§_}'g§-:?fa;L Lander S6-:<:'::.i{}:"; SAHA} 0f the ;ﬂ§L£.'fL t.h.r:: 13:;:pui,jg..{'§g§:z1Vri'1Vi.$:;i_o;é»<é:* avirzg <?'ii5;e:'n.i$$ed {ha zippezzi gsigzﬂf ':

8?. 32.2009, {Azlnexure ~ 'F' U)' V\%f'}'§:"i':'%'3'iIiEii€\3}fé;';£?V::. . 3, E': is these, 0:rder$ which in }i.h:Z3 writ p€titi<3.n and SEE M B .vLi<33_:L*:'£§c§ {:0u':A1&sge?E for i;.hv.3 péiiitioniér has zirggsésgi 1.110% i3:1V2§idai:.€:* the impzxgneai e:'<i..é'-.:f§;. 5:"

6. Gr€}1§:::i3.f:.1_:'ge§§;i b§,%'E§§::::':1e§§'{:{:'m1$eE far the-: pe'§§t:§e;}:'§;e:"

am: that, in é'.§"§;<:f.?*Eizséi-.__§ns%:a.nce, 'H113? éaraii czmnoé; Se:-3 :2:1_cE€§';<=3%i_9<>{i 13:3 §§:';3.:":*;i€<iZ Eargd, i1".Eé'};SI1":'i,iC%2 21$ the Eami, $229' dV:2--s,:b%"e&=';i%%3.A22 §;§{::z'é%:?1r:1<3n§. Ezjmﬁ Eiilfi E";_a€§ been grezntfiii as E;;«:%:'<r_a '::;;rj%:€.:;§%2§ pagsed; %:>}; 31216 1I}e::§,21,:E;§f C<>mm§s=:3§.<;:'1€r§ ii ma '§3s_@e3zj:v'§;:f;s§:f":{.ad in §?a;:»"e:3z:z.z= {Bf C%.1§k_E<;.2;:%_%1%mn1a.§23;E";, 22 §:>é::rs<>:";_ V'é§e§<}T:':gi1:gj; " €10 :;C€}§':f§;%'"§'"é~:T£ s€§.f.;; <':<>:*:m:'a,:_:_'::?1€:f3_,-2 aa7Er:i{;:.%§ EEFEES 2303:, «lo ' . ;r:<ie_a.§'§§;:{'§; gm 3C <%{>2'::':§m:":§é;§L :3§.'E;Ew::" 21%;, izézaé '§I§§"i"é{'? <12? ggrgzizé, GE"

.01'; '-

7 8, Thirci p{}i'f13;", urgeci by St: Narzzgtizad is t:3"13,':. 3:"€sp0:1€ie;'1i",s5 E and 2 ems. "um; cm'..Ed.re311 sf Eh:-3 gra;:1t.eéE%;.»bui.

"{;h<3 firsg ré-zspmidem; hag cfieiimeti 0:11}: 2:5; z1d<3§;¥{:§2.d_ 4'&2£.}§1- §;¢u§;=:1§_. the secromi r<?£apo11ci.e3m is his wife araci the §_r__Q+f'1§; i'e:A_T'E:so"€.hT&>§'"_' 9' thézm etlelimmg is be adapted ;:hiic:1; :"€:r1,"«_T 'i'i§; ei:§ d€311'£€}I1S:ifii"£?JI.()f"E:§ the faliacty _c:«f_ t1r1e =§:'ia:1ms;T,»--{.h}3t.A' at] .%.hV5* in8t::1:1£:<':: of sixth p<»3:'s0m;§ {§";l f;".'~V.:._'A:5xI7¥sf%iS{£%:i'E1§.,'JV:1:{€)I"i'gI?}'}.i%Si.G1'}€I' should mat have géitcier Acté: etc'

9. It 35; §.a$t1:«; §°orcib§_§_;" 21$ ':1ht= ezgxriigr poinﬁszg VV§:é.3§ing beer: mitiaiied by thﬁi g;:§i§1y in {he yea? E9993 wh6:'e22s§...s'a;.'s*je3:a:f:*:jVgr-::'.£':;i',T§éi?z:$'"-:.>i' the: yeezx' IQ84 i,<3:. mere 'sham £8 §F€3£1§'S:§ ;::°;:¢r €jI:':_é9 g:923:2"i.,é§;:2d when 33% €?'{}§'§di"€.§O§2S may :20":

E6 Q;:»é':fr:3ii:::«: a3:1j~,%*"-::r3;§§_;'f_§;=r,. i'.§"£€t ,é'%.§s-3i5:aé;,:a1n'z, €<>mmisssi{>2§e:3r ceuié _.:*:::2: "7:7::¢3n;vs;§ "bé;'.::<A§7::";€-3% ;*:£:'{:§;*~;a in zeggééﬁift. :3? Eaixi 'ﬁfhiiih was i;:":7::"::é':z{:t::;%{:*§«*gs. gggrgzxziz. iﬁfdﬁf :31' thezé §;<:*a:° E954», &V3ﬁ3&§%§%?e§%§§$§€%%@¥§» §§§§%;£"

8

:8. It is an guezth ggrauzrzzzdg. Eegsarzied <:<:::u:1s3€§ far the p€>f.:i£:i{1=ner sszlbmiiig this wrbi peiii.i0:z aiesserves j'Cé;§ bf:

ezlbweci.

2}' Sn the ather hanci. Sr: Yad}1av P'LZSh§32l'E'<':11'1i, Eeeirrzed CO'L.'i'{1S€}. £103" E'}T"1Jf;': MI':C'S§':Q1Ti{§Ef:I1f.S' .i afnéi 2",; havé SU.p§()i"i€d the imp'L3gr;ed €}I"d€f~S éxzci hEJf§;" € E5{1?3IIE.§f'[.f3d'--u that there is {:0 need for i11te1*f£:i"ez1c§: it1..w';<i1i.=jzﬁgfiadictiora and 'ghaii the {}rée2:*s; péiﬁgifwfi b3_.fi".hé:"-éuthariéiies éiréé perfectly valid in Eaw and in C@r;s0na:fu;:% :5Vwit}?{~.t;1*:;:%1_'»§Q§fs:)vis§ons Of the ACE and i4he:"efc;fé"W;"it p.%:i:Ti'I;i<§ii S§2g7;,1~§t% hei disgméssed. 12, Sré ;?'§GA_§ zxpgieaféﬁg {er the {he evrﬁers :p21;4$s£¢dV7E3:§r='9 '§'§'§;C.§;;1i;'§';:>r:ti€s am": mreéié sLap§a'rt,€ﬁ by §€gaE gf:.{:5ii'.ia:: 22S':".:':3§;1_;<_:§:{;i by ?;.?:E:»3 {:'£':«U.E'?i', in 22. ggasti m:m'§<3r af

-- ..¢:§'& {#1551 $5 ~c:v;é;

"'§-3i;::*§',:§":g.§ §:'@m 1:431:12 £'f:E3;E%€;*. <3? §3.EQ§;

as '§"§}I'ﬁ':I4'§i3':_ 56;?' {rm mag '§}£iE°'§'.§{?Ei§E§.'E2:fg' 21$ :;'mi:§a:::§; in pa'-:r;:«55g :'E£'}E{§§§f§g Ehaé: SE19 ";§'g"€}'i:§§§~§{}§:é§ {sf '§.§§€':f gm {Ea} 2;a;;3p1§f ea}-"§:%':': in §*€3E?§§'}%1':§?'éIl 5;?" §)':*{":-- q g _:a;<<*f c<};.'1s31'i.'i§.1:£.f£<)1"s21E g"z'2'-zrzt: <:='z:ders aneii e've:'1 w'h.a%:: Ehcié par"E.£<7L1121:"

mmmur:it,y x;va$ 310?: i(i€::"m£"i§;%i:i as SCXSKE' prim" to the C{}1'1Ss'€,i§1L,1E.i(}'E"§ 3.1151 {E16 P§'€;?,Si{i€':I"iT.13.El} <):'dcr$ sf i¥::<;é yeaznf'-E:9§O and by é1{£th.€3£'i'$."i§F if: :5»; wi-iii s§e:t.E.Eed 'E:._h::1Ii'. if the <::3g:21_f;':»%;ti*1.ii;3.? {me which 159 §d;e11?;1fied 3.3 a &3(}CEz«;iIiy ba{7:kWa.§dV eéigxéaés :«1i:;§_ 9 later 3, PF€;3Sid€I1ﬁ',iE1}. order is issuaxig L111;cier.V1¥%_;i"t;isi:"i~€_$'iﬁéiéziiﬁ 342 of the C0r:st.£t.uti0n of E;1.r;{ ia, i;.}'2a'f<i5:; gaéﬁ.:£§nbu§I?§"?§é'* (:hara::t.erize 21 land 1-'Vhi(',h E::21.d"bs2:x::3';': gf&1iitfi&'§i§ fé§VOL§§' of a persson belonging £0 S'C4_/€31' ;;§11g¥vfba3_§:=€>§:16:s a ggraméid iand 'ﬂgithill the mezining af s;:x;>r€s:'s§Vo':§\; .,g1is it €}C(':E,i§'S in Seczﬁerx 3[E]{b}

13. E; ESWE13-3%?>SL?;Ei§T3-iifﬁif-5}' iii'3s3--"§ear:1:':£i ASA 'ghafé: in an ide§1t13<:a..E'_{::z,$s€ {ii=.'?i'a;:::3:._.};.2f;é.;3t.é3*<:§ in favamr :3?' .22. §3€z'ss:>:1 beiazzgizzg i'.«L§ " §{5;.raAr?:c:'~~--" £té<:>mmu':3ﬁ.}; aiscg wha are 3.2't€z9:f§é:i.§y::§y. Z~§:1<}1ér:i:'***a::§ K€}?'Q,?T?t€§ gem; %1:«,1$ b€»e:{: dzzaiiéeii by .,?jé';.:§g;_§é3 <>§ Eiéfiéss <.:n:>'a.1':"i: is"; fiihefi. ittasésr vi' T S§§§.F¥ER, :23 A8338? T L3 '?8§§, asésé .%k€L"¥§§.-.}.".§ ':'s;%§:%:':"§::2/m': 'Tics E£§L'€,§2§i§§ g: 99: 54;

T {:%§}3.V":_.*:'._§':_A:.'3;i':$; £3? §:22i:3"ag:"2::;3%':s%3 'E? 2:;.:2<.§ Eﬁ I"f;?2'§{§§.E'E§.§ :T:;n{§s:"&r:

75>, .5 =:$'>§3'/»k"<§'iW2{%$£"<\ « KWX"

10

8. At' the O££{i'S£?i ii. is seen am: by virtue Qf cerégficaie of (fClS'{'€ iSStJ.€d by Tahsiidasz Sim. Taluki. ,\/»mrfee.>cL:re if is seem ZTE':a:i TahsiZda:"--. being wzﬁpeierii auihorifggg wider {he law, has Céfiifiéd that' Sarzxlaraztgaiah--pei"i{:iQtier' L. V hereirl is a person representing K-c:_'ra'z%'L:i["---- 'V' con'm1un.i£y whittfl is brougfzi" wiz'i1ii~":_ Scheduzied Castes l£!'E.d<~ff?' i}1e.... Coz'1s~i"£Vi::'t'£9'fjg . fI1(3§iCL I950 {S(:f1edu.EeoZ Castes '{«"_}rde:r_ '--o;s_ deslared 39%} PresideniQ1"Iz'1dié:;2-; T '

9. That apart; _ '1-he c3z'2'gi21.aE j'»,.re:t.o:--*d.:=s produced by the Eéczgﬁaad '.H;ig'E'zT CQ££7'§' Goverrzrrtem. Pleader', cVQ:1i13,i:1' =__;1 ciwegtk vvéslip denoting the r1LL_rI1ber' _'of_ }}'7€1;2'iS"..'e::eri;/'iédA by Tahsiidar. Even: €:':: {£31113 i:?1eCic_"3Zip Tczhsiiolar noiitﬁeoi the A33isiarzi"~C0:i*:iniss--£Qrieij~gaging that Sarm.arar:gr:iia,?1, »'s'mI; Efar3;§'§'na:'t:?zappa erdirzariigg f::»*,s;i:iz'rzgi%._ at f;<':i£sh':r:iswagc:r*a yiiiage Q,' Sim Tgf:E:rT§>:;,_ f3(??"?§{§Z1 rce:'prie=sen;iiz1_g Scheciuleoi Caste {,jF_;<o;~i'3:i:_?:'za}[" » E{3:f'.{: 'éS3:fi;r:The§* geenﬁgg z;e:*z;['i{:aézZan; 9]' {he SC?:f£8cf:aZe;dV VC'€;,;§é;<3s"~.Qrde:: E950, Part E maﬁa zmciaer '-Ehe' mi Erzirg; 54 552a? {E18 {:o:3:'€"',__E€;'cé;"a?1;';aV'.i:~:. "_€.;'2CEz;,::d(3d in {"328 Eisi Q? Sr:hedu€:e0"{ C.':Ls:?;(2.S:.

éﬁ§1?.--,":{;:':ﬁ§1r "§i£'§f$'v::i;1:.:a tzizaiz the presemi. <:;:1%e. is; 2:17: away: 213 gar *;'h§:=. c:r£gg§.:33.E E'€'.{,'.0E'§S in this gitzi-3%"-«._2:Es:~;§;'§' ibzmgé that: i;E"2;%3 :2:E";E;ﬁdar had igaueii :2: iii': '§a1?{3L:::* Q? $::>:{:si';:ac§ r§;%s§}{}:1dm':€ éﬁai: étéze ig 21 §3€:2E{>.::;§.%§.f:g§ ii} E{{;r5;:;':':(;: :?.:>:§2zm.21'é.ii',§;; I;'h2:é;: {~:=%::%--:'2_ sz:_%::'%;z§:z:§:3;;§ '{é:21§" :~;s.::§"::':»é:>E :'%$:~:*E,%§'Tia":2::§'::%; 9;": z:-s;E*:é:1:§": §*£:éi2;2.:':{':€t is : x\\ gm Q 4mm% '--€iO§I}E}I;"§:%.1i7;§'§,}? v.%::21:f§ié:§"s:§€~::g{:z"ib€:gi as i7§€:'f§3E"EiE%S{;".{§ (31213-S68, as Ehe °%;£::'";I?.§§'§iz:V§':f§'m9*:;?;§%:Fﬁg €}1'"§{'3'. :mr;%@;" <§€:;3re.s»sa-sézcé a"%Ezs,s;~:ssé:s d?:o:;'§:asf."

i.h7:-:--.§é3~:*:}vEsi<;§§§5 ef tim .;'~E{"?§. 2'-'z;}pE3z E2': £'é3S:p€;':{E?;. <3? 2: Ea-"mcé. 9%' '§'.,§f:i$s ;':.:?;'§"L:r§:

1 1 piacfz-ttgi 'tay €:h<;% iearxled C{}L.i1'1S€i for $116 p€i;Eti0n€=z'., i11di<:21i,§3.s the <:<>n:;:m'L:_:}éE:§; 21.5; Kararna S€£.:._;,;, f.hat iioes :1«:3i'. "--.:r:;ake muitii €1ifi'62'em?s3 in m1dm'St2md::1gg the <:<)mmz::.;:_i'f§ :

SC/ST <:<)n1mu:":ﬁ?:}: as mﬁ: {>113}? {:€rtifi€21'1;€ issued by {$163 t.21hsiicia:' 21}i1a1i, €3Xp1"€;'SSi()1i1 imtixssiorz asf K0r'cafn;;

.P3:'eside'ntiaE order; °WhiC1'}. is m'ﬁ5i=éib}I' xzvag:-'~£3?'céhv-1<:§g{§iﬁéta%.f.0:'3r, éaéées the issaue 'bey(3r1d: £3::1y xxrifﬁtﬁe Subjeéti E21116; iss Lliadoxzbtgily 3; of 21 parser} §3eI()r:ging 'Ea 4§fs%§ﬁ.'i_n2;%F$i{§y pfﬁxgisiarzs of "£116 Am'. am at;t;€aé:tC?-::L;"_ " ' 14, it 32155;' zi§.${:é :;1:%;=:r'i:.§Ti.t.»c§§'bf?Véihe }€'.§:1§"§'}.{;"'.{'§ EXGA mat mere 353 §.§".'ii',§'I§E§.$_§<;E €3i.7:;{§<'-é1f:V<:€._ §,=<::'${}'n&; he§{3ngi:1g :0 SC §"ii§§j,:5-T'; g1.m;§:.i;%1*g2.':.TV ﬁg 31 ;'°ec{>r{i wE:§(:E"2 <:<>z1§:E1::%iv{:'§}-= <:--:as§.ab"§i$E2.e:i ze ex 99 xk A 12 E5' 1%, is Si§br§1i"§j.f€f{i *;.h2:"t tihe xximrar 'take:} in the 3215-36 of KRISHNAPPA S V {supra} haa bﬁﬁfl E'<>i1:>w<:::i in iixxrai ¥ {ie»%:1§"1é:;:' S'i.1§38€f{§1.1€.I1'{. C21:-36$ vim in S NACHIMUTHU jfés. H B NAaA.%U' [ILR 1999 mm 2506} ;:.:r;{: jja...§s§_:jj:in aha; case of T M Rmaazm vs AssIséf:'A1\i:% Ci31Vi?}£f$SI€Z3iVQiE?;R'§' TIPTUR SUB»-DIVISION, TIPTI}_'R [iLr§"--:2o0f.:¢:' .1 ]:s9";=:: " . and théerefbre the first gmiriéi by t.hé:-ieafneai ctounael for ihe gm-3t.it,ioner Ca11r:3;3é:_ %121x7'€3 e;;;13%"a1,fv*aiT§~Mf<)1" qu2:sh_%.n_g the i1"I1pL1g;§}€d OI"d€§"S.,_ _ 36» in S0 §:7¢1r"';2;.5s1'*:.§':;§'séig:.g§i::m§g' §ojtL::j'1€__:.2rged by 'aha Eeeazmeci c0u3::_$@E ,fc;"n,:. .,thﬂ::3 §55t§§.i€i0';§g:=.3:t §::"'::@>:2{:erned, ihis Cauri has :%a:»ns'is%9ﬁ§'i§?'4 %:£:ké;r£ "A-:f.h'€< 'é;Iié%.a{ meat, pragteéa-dizzgsg iiaitiaﬁed under {ha A¥{:~f.; zagre m;_<3?.i;1":f:§sp<3aé£". 3% §}€i'§"S{}'ﬁS 'Q22: in YEESQETCE ;;f:f"::z::'§;§€E Za:i:§5«3~-- ---- -2325? 2: pers@:: p»ar€.i{:Epaﬁ.ir:g ihcsi-3 §:{:"s;:sst*:%3::':éV€:1i":1;_§>:;<s . 'i;§i3ii:-5:3; mam :12 tim <:<3z1'£;@Xi <3? an 0g:~pe;>:'tun§%.}»* being §,§?i%;r:-§:f:'é:é:_,-«iii. §}e=::*sa:': Wm; is af.t:2rr@:'2'é(.E}i in p€}SE€»€E3S§OE§: £3? 'éljm Ezznei if §§€':_f-E§h€;'f ES 2:. ;Q1::"<:Eta3:s;;e::" 211151 319%; CEa.:imi.§3.g; 'u_:";é€:" A Vé.--Z§:s:. ;:}:9£';§i:22a£ ;:___§:"22a.':'é:{3:é;%,, 22-'}"§:> is; §'i;?{§E§§}f€i{i 32:} 'as: :2=%v'§<:i;:e{§ §"%°:>::: $155: VA _éz5::f:§;fL :19 r<%§2::a.:m:a= ii; {.5} 'IIEES s§i::2si:§;% 313.35% E'§:?f%§[,§§'.%,,E§.€f Ea} '$133.5? §Sr2,1;:'"2_':,<:{i 3"§'%Z§?f'<7§§'£2'2?'% <. x . >3. §{§2i%$§\K§§ﬁ&$,W$§éeWlV&& 13 {:2}: hisfher iegezi hﬁirf IE; is <}nEy" zit}? Staci': ptzrpcme nmiiize is gixrezx to i,h.€:~ purcithziger 9:' his; re:%pre:ss<;%:1t,21t:f§é%:3 or W'}'1(}f§££-3{}f;?X?€I' mag: be in p{}S8€SS§{}1f".E 9f the iilerefem deszih or Utherwise of any 0f 1:116: pa:'i.i5:.$' £i}::«:-3's 1510-2" _ ' in any way cause eiiiler ezbatenlemfg of tE<;é;é*_pi*:}c:¢€'<iirggS_ render the {:~_1:°de1" paSS£'3d by f:..§1.,e§ e111thQrity 22?.:é;:,211'ity if: fie': eye 0? Eaw! on the premise :41 dead p€'§"5:§C3l'i. 'ﬁle argL1n2em'i;::§:j. éxiecéeed in a. situeitien, of {£516 pv1f;s!.~":s-*».{,>',_I:--i' in respect Of praeeedinga E'? £::.v_sQfv;1):'. §ir':'-3-"E; respandeni, is 31.94; 21 §€:§;_§;:E"--;_§rai1f.e€ and; asiaimmgf anly as 2:.

aidagﬁed s<f>':';; "E:::_:.§';a_:§: ;:=};i§?ing; 31:1}; i?v=:3:f'{,hwhi§e nmierizzi iii} ss%.:;p§::;{r%:. 53313 <:§;1.i:3'; if;-% {T{}Ii{".E§i§"§"i(f{§§§ in 'ilhéft 'firsa:t: mgtarzete. {E16 g;za>::Ej:'r;%;:3;r;)i::2i~::*'«:Ei-=3'«':i€;é;__@nza;bied ix"; pm: §<>r§h samth 21 §.":{}f1tE':1'£'Eii{}§": 'E19? Eiizia sésimgﬁk'.7.':fé3éi:é€3§"; %;_E';&§'. t.'?:e> p@"§.;1€:§{>z::'i1* Eaiiziészaif £3 21 §}€E';'3{}§1 '.f<..:afh{> h.:j;S'A.;€ié:*§v&%d i;ié:§£ ifégsérming Lzrziiei" s::<:h 22 §>€r5{};1, :18 V~:L_;%::'%:..:1E55éL"é§::t~<?:{i €iX%i'ii§fE.§.'§',€§{§ in §';:va}::;" 4:}? fé:§";s.:7 .§%::.E':€;':3' sf" *2-*£:e:é;@<}§' ac? ' g3€{€,§_':.i<i::'::*::* §§ 333; '§i§".§§';? :.»2:='::'§; iém ré;é5sg3§:}zT:.&a:?-::_":';: am? 3;. _§3:3.::"':»:;<;;2:'§ 14 claiming right, £21116: in'i:e1"€tSt undsz" first r<:é5p:,1=:1ée'ni'. ::=a':1110%E. §.at,e:* Ei.I.I'E."}; :'012.nd 2,-m.{§ say §;Ii1.3..t. he slams 1710:', Eiewe any i:}%.erer5sE: in tzhizs $1fab}f;*.€§;, Eand e'a.e::.

38. in so far 2155 the q1::s3:5ti{:»n af E-'Vh{Z2 are. _pi?€;%<ti}§'t:§ 'iegai« V- heirs of the graxaﬁiee is <:{}1'2::et*n<:<i,__;t...assu;;':"a<éS'§T:?f§:pé'rian{:¢ V and s1gm:fi<:2mce when the iami is 11:9 1:"ésf:tU;t,<».:d Asﬁisiianf, Cemnzigseéoner Gr V<:3:"'é1iis b7<;ha§f_ tiE1€:""T1¢:h$i1dar§"

who has; :9 E'('3S§§§'.Lif.!.'5' the 1anciAVf;<3V ft'if:€'"§:1ja11.{.ée--var heir, and ézhemfore the 'Fa1hSi§§i¥§'§f'}1;é*;sv {if this aspect arid it is not I1<:.§:§:f:is':s;;:ry '£291 j'Lirisdic'ti0rfa to ﬁxaminﬁ %;hi;:;' :f;:§z:V§%$€iV<}z1 {féiiiﬁﬁi in am;

vazazy afffﬂji'%.§¥.é.A:{¥%'§;§§E§§={}£='*'§:h'%% Cgnzmisaiazmr <32" {E13 §}€pu?;:y 0:" {@163 :>€h23:§°, as i'.§;€ bassic q3;'3€s§;'€"i{3a'1 in iﬁfge '§.3F{}€€{:¥Qi3§E}g§3 ':.md<--::* ffhe A{*f?; is as :10 whe€;he:* '"~Ei§i€: §1:::?3j§%,:5\§§: §_;1:'":& §'J§s~:.z..._;;_,§;';.zz1E:€d Ema? and if ;~;<> 1%-'h€E:h€:* ii: is'; %'.:*£g:iS§e:*§':%-.§E'~ :2-i<?:2a€'.i{;:: {)5 Q29 :i%<:«ﬁ<§ié§{:::;<%; Q? me: g.§,E"'Ei§§€'.. w§':é:f;Eé?{%r '§'.E"£5;§§5f§f£f§E"E"€;?{§ ?}§=:fa':"r:t i1E":é: ACE. <:{;m'§n§§ i:1€;a §€§§'€;T'€ and if €.E:{: é:";::§':3{e:3" is; 2i;§;€3E' £:E'::=: Eégit: §"z€§f%§ :;:¢:m'2€ Ema §{}§"{T'.€;'7.? i%;h€:é:§2i:%§° if; %g/ /' A . '§'€':'{é¥?ié 15 has-3 'eézrzjén a.<:<:<§r:"zp22:1§_€3d by 21 prior perm_ise3:~si{311 g_;Trz-1;n':.é:d E}? {.1353 Sigma C::>\e'€r'nn1em:.

19. EE: is; =:>11§§; i'.h€S€ t.w's:3 yasdstiztksa whisk 21:3 H be emp£<)y€d {G tea. the c<>rr<:<ét:3::§s§ 8%' iﬁé Grders §a:-336313 by the €3.I,}.ﬁ"i€)'{'}..{Ii§3S:'.}lI1(%:%'%j"iL§i,§§.:j}§3?;f"i%; any other cansiderzztions.

20' Tm: ether argumggé. anti the transacﬁon am af more.'"E:é;"::1"--f7Qi§é:f. é.:é1§iifc_ﬁi}e:?+_Va1f"{.e':" the initial g.3::'a_§1t can be (ff 5:18 is naiicad above, fihsi cm '2 M §~§9'E'9§ for the i:1v21i.*;£i~e1i:§.u§:!:V»». '0if*3,3}.3_ i.rf»§:§:%§:t.§'en9"§i11 '*:€:rmS of Se:-:Cti01r1 1} af {he A.<:i. é;;1€%. 'fékiti; éhaii giueméi W213 W213; baek 4.3% é;eca.ci€$*a§g<;: {tar}. §L:=,{e'§f~7d0€%s Hi}? make 2133}! &§fﬁi%:i*§::'1<;:e is " < ji;,h€ €}f}i@§f_%b<2VV%;§21ss:eé{%::§:...§_:.n;der the pmvissizms iii' the 33:93'. 2}"; V _ Ea: ..§?g;g.E:£.~..<>f' ﬁle 2fG{}'=z"€f :':xa:n§r2a'i;i<>z3§ it is '{<3imd Ehat. *is.h_::€ .__@:'€§<::f:s;' " ---:.1:>::.%${%€E by '£h:°% az.zE:h{}:f§_t;§s&% are Eéifijg £2':

" 'V. {?.£j>EEf§<}§E§£;§'}.§i:€ ':2-:§.€.E': 'é;§":_€ §}:"€}§~""§S§{}EES §E':<;é :"%§;:E;; szzstizzigéazbia T ':i:§,.:"e;'4:i?i.,_'€:§%:_&é;.r"sii: §§§ :30 se;<:<};>§'-7 fa}: é::':.:?:§3:'€E%:'§é:":{:63 geﬁiég.-E:-..E/1 s;:.2::E'2 {}:'{Ee:*ss

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court