The State Of Karnataka By Circle Police ... vs H K Mariyappa @ Vasantha on 21 September, 2010

[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

The State Of Karnataka By Circle Police ... vs H K Mariyappa @ Vasantha on 21 September, 2010

Bench: K.Sreedhar Rao

§x

{O

IN Tl "I1-C IIIGII C1(.)E_,§I"{"I" O19' §{z\I-2.%\};'\'I'!\I{:'\ AT 1.3:\.i\§'C}AI.()§-{Ii 3

I).~'\"I"lCI..) TI---I 15 ''1'1- £1': 2 1 ST 1_.>.;w 01'-' s1~:1Y1'1::Mt-;is1:1'z 2.0 :0 " 

I'R1:IE5I.£N'}"

'1'I{i.-3 1 10N'1sL1..«:. MR. {.J{jS'I'1CI~3 K,§I;1:1-2:I>:«1;:x1<-.'i§;\(.)~f ~ _  "

;\Ni.)
'1'1---£13: 1--~1oN'131.1<: M1'2..:t.s::s__'1'1c:1§;' 'E:3.'V".IE?'IE\ITI   :;
CRI,.AI'I'I:3:\1. No. I"8Q'7/V2()()}-1-  '  V

I31§'1"\VI§I'2N :

'1';--us: S'F!\'I'E or I{A1{N/\'I'A1-{A   *

BY CIRC L15 POL1:.jI*;v._I_I\ES}_'I5-C'I QR  _ 
I{US1--IALNAGA1-__'€   "  

{BY SR1 G . 1:3} 1.A\iA';>q1 
ANIJ: V H M W ' V
3 . 1----1 . R 'Ix/14.»/\i'a1YA 1'>:%gx,éw§$A;r<:*1'1-IA.
S/O':<:4_j{\§%..z31>1Jx_\ ; _ 
_ A_G1«31.) mg (f) Lil? 5(')=.\~'1«:A1-as

-  I1,';-).&:sUN1f)AI'2]\""S/O KALA}--31-3/\
~ . 3 ' A_C:E.i.1')4{\%3O[J"l' 44 Y1')/-\1{S.

  ,1 71:31 12$-'v1'31"2;\1J1A.sz\ " C1-----I.AI\§I')1'U\.

 ' S /Q 'E:{.€L%xI'IL;\I)l)1'.[\1
 /\c;1~:m1\;3()t_s"1.' 23:2, YEARS.

'    Iiii:1{r\Jx\1{LJM;\R, S/O KALAPP/-\.

"-~ Ac.:1«:1) A1sc>u"1" 29 3/'1:/x1-<53.

'  5'; 1----1.1<;.s(:>:\zmss1I1-<:1<;=\R.

3/ C) I{.r\I..!\I)I3A.
AC}i:C§_) 1"\1:'3OU"I' 39 YICIXRS.

. . .A.I.'1'I'C'I.,L!\N'I'



<)t"t"<=;r11(.?c m1(lc:'r Sc(~.tir>:'1 MS of IPC. 11': is t"1:1"£.iT1o1' ;'.1I.1¢§_ggc('1

21;-,f21i11:"st' 1'.1"1c 1"cs1)n>11(.1c;:1"1tss: tlmi. 011 1.11:) Hzlid p1;21cc._ (1:-,.«1_'1"c. :.é':;.1_1'(:!_

timc due to U16 (1i.sspu1.(-' 1'Lr1:u.i1'T1;;; to ieI"ti11g;" of \x--j4:5=£1'c1'._t:(>u.i'--?

f1'€'1d.si. 1'1'}c'* 1'cs';;)()11(T1c*111:s 1'1z.1\«'c ("-;i.)'1]T11".--'1i'1(Cd V11"1'.'1'1:.1'j<1(41i._fg')i"V

E\/I:=;111_ju1'1z.1£' I121 2-111d Sh i\-*z.11"1'1e11'1:ei' «V '--.i_1i1.m'11"1'<..)1'1aIVI\{ "  '(I:i'..1'  '

1x'.11(>\x.riz'1§,;;1_\,-' (.*2111si11g i'i'1c:' (.1crz1i.1'1--v..}'15y.Vba.s::5;.1i.1ltfix1A;gV'v_i..1iQj1i"i"'\Vit1'1

(rlubs. keuhi. s1.c>11er:;. Imilic 1"cr,°%']')"t%(:'%_:i\'c.1y.. I1"1(I'1'€'U_V *E1T1c.}= 2111*

z.11icg.g<3ci to I'1é,l\~'C ('1c')111111i{_i:cd 1m.i1?cIc;1.f L2';§1::.1Ti1':{51'121b1c 111'1c'1c1'

Se(:1:io11 302 <')i:"~vI'P(3 _'-- It.¥_iss f;L.11:'?1101".éT1'U"€).§,§'€2Cif'Uléil on 1.119 EIé'»£li("}

  

;>1'c1cc. ti1'uc~ ¥:;1.11(jv1-"'('}».2i.i c=-*"--~1:.1.'1_L'*"--ij'( ?';;t;<:.:.1;c.1c:=;1rs» 1, I3. 7 a.1"1(:i 8 have

zxsssextlltgéci J2::.g:._;cie%ffs11;a"a_{'P\VI)IW Su1"1(12':'u*a [PW2) a.11c.i

I.,aksI'11T1'1e==1«:111'nz;1 [*:?\?'\I'7j) \-\*it}:'i"«r:~h.1})s. sI,<"):'1<::a and ]<2.1.E'I'1i 211'1("1

L'a1LISC€i--.SiiT1}jVi(!_i1"1;_jwl:%1'iC'f-E £0 I§'1c-:11} and 1.11(:1"ei'<:)1'c {.1"1cy ;-11'c-'

":'1i]::§.;'crc1 11:; iviewc uon1111it1c(1 n_3J'!'c1T1(%c=;r 1111cI01' Sc('£.i011&s £5324

L1--*/\.:..zT- S Cc:r1'.j:.p.v1"1  of 1133C. I1. is a1.:so 2-:111(':'.\L'{ci¥(i_ z-1g3;;,1i1"1:;'1. t1'1.c=::

211(.I"~r(:sp'(3;'JVc§~t>111. 1.11211'. 1"1(:. Ims 2-11)c11.(:(:1 '1".I'1c m)111111issi.<")1"1 01'

--«

_'i'n1_;1'(1c1"""Of Me11'1j1,11'1a11"1a z=m(.1 S>1'1i.v;11';m1.';1 ;.11'1(1 21ss;z..1111t of

_'  C;'._W;~,;"i to 13 by tin": o{'I"1c'*1' 1'cS1)()11(iv11Is z.11'1<'i 11'1c1'(=}.')y he

" '"I*1'é1s (1on111'1it.l"'cd 2-1.fc_)1'csa1i<i <>i"£b11("cs ;;1_I<):"1;g wim lhcz: (.)l"i'<r1'1Lrc

1.

.11"1('1E(;:1' S(:('1io1'1 H4 (.)1" E.I"(".',. iXi'%.t'1' ._9('t(.'i11'it'1g._§ {.i"1(f' ,.

//'L rc$p<.)11L1c)1t's l3n~i'()rc t.!1«;' (.Im.a1'%._ the 1}1"n>ser<.:'a.11i<)a1 in ()1_'_<}c1' "Lo p1'(:>\-1? its (.'£1:'S(' has c==*:x:'z1.11"1i1T1c('i in ail £39 \\='i11"1L,=s.s4<--}§.¢s..}.-r2'1d--_ 5.301 1'11z11'k('c'i I'§xs.P1. 1'0 I'-'I1-E9» zu.'1('i p1"<)(1s..1(.'%(*<1 ;\'i(I}j'fs5';] '1'}'1L> L.1('i.*i'c==;'.11L'.'«.' ()E'1hc'> 1*' ms-;p(':1'1L.1Lr1'11 j;'<.':';1"9--:.>11cpt' 1o'I'jz.1.l" 1_"1('11i'2,3} a-md he 11:15 _<_._>,',01'. me-11"kw;'i I'E_xs.])'l t'<.)aW!Vi)2--£_).A' '.E'»1'1<:. {?T(j)1_.11'1_.:i'}.2_.: ' its-5 bc1'1a"1.}i'1'12-as g§(")t m;ar1u*<E E.§xs§'v...C"1».éV1<) (j;._-';., ' --Af'E_:c=?1-9''--;1'1EF:.i1'i11;; 1.116? 1)1'()SCL"LL1i01'] a11c§_ "L~1'j_1c Li(§'f';€?'I.'1..C'(.'.'"'--.}C&'311"1'1CC'E"' E,~3c:=,si(::>11ss Jx1(.}g_j§e was 1.)1£?21sn=*d to 2.1n:qL.1i1. £11'? :'{V.11g-:_i*L?SpO'r__1(:.1e1'1ts <.)E'1l'1c-:

(:)I"fc1'1('c. 11¢} 191: '*;«.1V1 fi a § _)pt-:2'-i E. '1«_)'\1""'..:1'1r..'- , _SLf:i.1t'(_'.

3.

:L_{211i<.ia1.V"t'1iL3'1.;11L-" t.(.)V';be-> 1£1L.E11(,',hC1('1 on lhv basis of ,1.'}"1(_.'VV{KID_»1V}.)};E'1'11.1;"'..._;If-!()1'1{? 'Iz.:_g2'1(Eisl'12a. In the (%omp1z1.int;' 1'at:v1'1é1s '.'$'? '<1{(:."d»--.1}'1L1I' his t12Lt'1'1L'-*1' }"1aL.1 f'm...u' s<)1'1s 2.111('E..<§;1'acr "6!2:11.1gg1'i1"c.1j. (..)1v11 (.)i'w1'1o11'1._ 1.1'1L> (*.01'npl21i11zm1 was I~11_C~1'hi.1f(i~.As<r";)i'1.__2_11'1(1 H1215" 1155 .-;is1.(-*1' \.\'z1:~s 2-1 1.c-'2.u".:l_'1c1' in ]~"i'cr}.3i3.ai1c:V 'i3E';*1:1(i;<51 a.1":.cI his s0c():1.L':} E:)rm_1'1er \V&1.':3 :1 I-ic>.21L.E '.VME'1St."C1Iji"l"1, Mz.alz.m11':>i S('110o}. it is i'a.11'1l1c=-'1' rstzilml 1'.h;:1I' he w 1"\\'21S '«--xjvsi(':Ei1"'1;{ 511 Ht'.'b}'j>E.i}(..' z;1Em1;;' wi1'_l'a 11i.=~; wiii-= 2.111('1 his ' l.)iT;n')1:.l"1(:-:'s, sister. 1'11011'1vr and §_;§1'z:11'1(111'1()11'1e1'wen' 1'c.s'-*.i('.§i11_s___{ in Ilwir old E'1m.1sn 2'a1"1('1 tkwy lmd pa1'1i§inm=.:(::l thvir pr('>pc':'t'y. Thtit 1a1"1d l'x~E<_>11§,_:i1'1§.;' E0 11"1uir l')r()i.1'1c;:1's5 is lay 1'.}'u'.:

{i side of Ban21s}ian1iai*i21m1na 'i"ernp1.e Gate": and by __E1he side of that propczzfyz the prciperpxf of his Seriicir Lii':1£I:1.i'<f,'f'-S-V' son Mariappa and their brot.hei's pmpe1'i:y wzigé ::si€i1i.éit;:éd.;'"'*-*1 * He has further stated in his (éo1npiaim:', t'h2ii "£I21ifiéip';:§21 and his brothers' land was on the liiwér p<)i'i;io;i mid " the;

land of his brothers was on it p.Q1"ti.oi_*;_:

was dispute with i'€gE?J'(i_ Iiittiﬁgjniﬁifhiﬁfgtiil' fieids betxveen his family 1113 Senior Uncle Mariyaippgi«{$:i;ic:e§:A__Arn§L>i{é:: To settle the said Rf:,)§a11V(T1.1ay'c1th was also beztweeri tliemselves and thf3VV"'{7VV1V?.1;i(3lV' date of offence on 29.8.1999, i3.ih., his brothers NIa}'1_f11I"i'cU'.h&1 iandv' "*S.h'iX2"a..3'21.;n21 xvéiiii. inside»: the village to engage the fgiiiacking ginger and that the compiainaiit a.1.s0'~«.w::':ij1i 'bei}'1i'r1d his brothers and w1'1i.1e he was towards A :'thg_re$f{i..--{Xrhicli lead it} village thare he saw one Ravi and i' . iﬁiiiidéra sitting on the culvert. nearby the said read and '' ~»;ti*iV:;1t he Weriii near thizm aim} ifih.£;y' é1S1{€:3d him a beecii and the complainant gave i:h<::m and thereai:°i,<3':r he stood n 1'c:;_;z'11'(.ii1'1g_;' 1:1'1(> \.\='e.-1101', Ni£.i1'i&.1}')}3é:1 2.'1.1'1(.1 hm 1)I'UH1L'I'.'-B 11__21.\'v z.1.ss+a11.11I"¢>('i Lmti c'o1'1:1'11i{'.1'c.(.i 11110 r1'u11'('im' of 1)ut§1..{}§__}«1_ié+_ b1"ut' 1"1c1':"=.'.

OI1 1,110 1):-1si:s'.s of t'}1(> :;*($ié1}::}.;1i1.1t'. _..1"1:1C _}){)1-iirv i1'1\res51.i_L{at<=*(:I 11110 1.110 n'12.1.1'1'c:1f z3111(i'.__l"i}(=:('1 (_t}'1*gL1';;{s 21§;2;21i1'1:~;'L 1.110 z1m"%.1s;c.*(_l for I110 <§'i:7i:tf;}'*:{1(%s })i:--11_iis;.1T1:é:1131Ej '1"1"1V'1c'im' SL',('.U()1"1S 143. E47', 1::e;';'*:~3Q()2.j:§24L..:gn§[ILA.1A14R/xv*'sL_ec-m-m E49 of IPC.

5. I3'\~V_ N ':;;;?'%.ciI.iV}*.s&]'1éL TS' 1 1"1::_ (':<'>':1--1.}.>wia1i11;.1.1'1t'. P'-1c--' 11.;-is sAz1.t':eci §. )Vc.i'<,>1'£~.'ﬂap C{jp11'§ 'i>;:.1 't'11o Séiflécr m;11"11'1c%r as i"o11m.1 in 'Lhc-.'. I*'1'r'lT: "I----Iisti:$I1ip_1;'i'i*~:.1}[i" '~~i..«:.~"111:11'1<c<E as Ex..I-9}. Ht' }."1a1s also é.;i;:;§11e(1 EX.1-'2!M;il"1212a.1.1' w11i(.:}'1 xx-11$ ("ﬁrm-v:'1 1.)c,?1\4=\«-'c<==:r11 2-1.1ﬁ_' 2-=1i"':J;i' (5.i3()W;'tﬂ:«.1'1'1. 0:'1 1"}"1(' 11c':X't day. .__E5. «' f-.I:?\3X;24.81.11'1C1e11'21 is §1"1c i1'1_§1111'(.1 (?yc\vi1':11(*é4ss.

-- 11:' } 1":.1.s v'--eV;A11.«s'zs""siziltcd t'}122'1t on the ('later of <)f'f'01"1("c->. he \vz.1$ V;-1I:"sz;..4_;.:)1'cEéx::.1E at t}"1c:.~ .'~'3{.'('.I](" of oi'fCr1L'.'L=> ai ;1}.')<>1_:¥.': E).0() 1.3.111. Hg.' has 2:15.50 e'-11'.1'rib11%.(*<.I s.spc<:ii1<=. ovmt z;1.(..:1'.s 21§_{éEi1'1$1 Ihc 2.1(.'<'rt1sL'{i.

//"~' IE}

7. P\'\-'Z-3~Jz-1\.*a»11'z1i;'11"1 is also t'.I1c c_v@\\"i11'1c=*..ess E10 "H10 i11(.'ic.'1c.111.. He has 211.50 sm.t'c=-;t("i $112.11 at" 1. he t.i111c_*. of i1:('?i£"1(*--A1_l'1'--.. he \-=va..~::'. 1:>1'cs;m'1f and E"u'1.s:3 .~_acc11 :21.§.1 the z;1('c.'1_.1smi.--p:r"<.?s::Vi"1~£"'2=3_f.j + 1.110 sc.'.c1'"1c-' of (.)('('1l1'1'C1'1(,'.L'. O11 5(?(':?:i'1"Ig§~U"1t"-'_£1(IT(.fi.i'§::_'i€E "\-\"i_1j 11 rlcacily \vc21;')(_.>1'1s._ he \.\.-'£-15 s('2'11'oc'1 ;111a('1V1§L*.1'3Ai' q11>it'_tj:; --. ijii; assisicwi P\-V E to s11ii'I. 111v (--i._g- u.,3;1sa('(.i V.511-i.3»';'1v1'z2={1~--11'L'i.'"':,iV11<.1 Memju1'1z:1111e1 to {.126 11<..)s-f.g)i1_£:a.E.

8. P\«'V(5~R_.z_'1\-'i' 1A1:;-1s_ =.:11s=.<_) ._si"i'i'lVc4d~.." 1:i"1z-'1.I' 116? \\.r2;1>..~; p1"c=-r..'s.'<:r1"1t. at". tI11€T3-- i'.i1'1§¥(f" o£' i1"1.(riLi1(§1'11 §111(i '*.'I"1'e:'"wc2.1poms held by the 2-1<:(*.u5c(1~V.._pE_ 011$, >2;-1'1.1c*1*f11.:_;'S ;;.11.é;n st.u1:cc'1 the specific overt ;.1("%.£As ;1§,>"a..i1'i's;.i'f::,1a1IM ITb1"1"e_ :3'1'(::(_";1sc(1 1:)m':5()11s. '1'hc (Ecfo1'1(*c' 11215 sL..1gg<:§ix_.f.t.i in U](T'I11"'('I)§$'*CX211'I'1illE11,i()1'1 t.h2:1E" 21 false 02.13150 é1121.3»~1j:-;e*11°i"i1c(} z=x.fga_i1'V1st.«11'1L' u.c:'(~.11sc(1 pt-'1'S()1']S.

9."~,_"i:"*.*g/'.?'=-:1.:-1ks1'1m;1m111;-1. is z'11'1<..>11'1c1' %1"1jL.11'cd <.:_\;'(.%\,>_\=-*it.11.(:.§:;s';7I.S1'1c :I1.l$(.) <lcp('>.~;c;rs E:)<~£'()1"n=-.= t1'"1<=.* Co111'1 t'1'1e.1t' s1'1n> .\\-'£1.F'> pI"r;si;11i" £11' I.1"1c s(rc;'11(: oi" ()(:c111"1'<'1u'('. 21.11('1 z1.'1.:s }"1a.1\.='i1Ig "--sc;e_3_:1"_~1.11c: i11(.'i(1c.'.1"'1I' anui ;:.1.1.~ao z'<:('c:r%\'i11_g i1'1j111'ic-'S an the 1'12i11<1s 0i"t'110 e1<*.c11.=';(-.::(.1.

¢_-».

1.0. I"V\»-" 1 =1---E..}r..J :'1a1'12m1::11 1i Ne-1:121ial'1. 1'" "-l.':T~ <:'<')11('i11<'£c(.1 ;")0_~;1 1n01'1.L->111 on 1110 (.1c-'ml }.)():(1:y5:.."~ ('§f_ M;-11'1_j1..111;u11:1 z"u'1<1 IT'\-«'2(5~I")s'.Sc.)1nz1s11c1<;»11' 11213.--;}E*>1"1<':1iV1(~:i;{~<1""A post. 1'm)1't'.c:n1 on $110 (lc:'2;1.c"l 1"30c.'1_V 0-£7 'S'1»'*..i..\§*:'2:11"-§4'11}1Ve4L'."[*:ff5hi.§v1._inf"

1.1'1em l121\»'c iSf'%1.1L"(1 pt):-5% 111c)1"1'.m11 '(xj.1'E.--i_1'iA'(ra-:11Cs._i'1-;1,c_i,1'1::i'\-ﬁg?' 0pi]1(?.(1 t.1'1z11' {ho (1C:=;11.1'1 is; (:11.1§'--jgV3'~..1,11cr to t'1'1e? 1't.'Spt'("£.§\'(t cE(><':'c"z'1.<:acd';

11. I"V\fi3f3fC'.'.I7'I gall' C',':'1'(",1e 112153 sialml 'V:.w.:1.«::>:§_;:%'>:-;1_:2;<,w {T0111 PS}, K11s112111.'1a.1g;zi1'., --ijf'1'igg:T1'T1c-?VC.1i';:'1.1£"}.§=' «_ M-'5 ]"V'.v('£V.i'('.'1I(.'(i me: (,'}v:1c;*1'a.1 IT~I().~apiE,z»"-1 '1. }{1'1.=-;1"12 1V};'£'23,gé:1%T ':15u;1'(.v'1--..Ei:m1'1(;§ two (lei:-1('1£1':)()(Ii(,%se viz. Ri'1i\7£'l1'<1.1'112i 2:11'1(.1 I_z'-1.171';11"11;i_tVl1;1. §11_]1.11"c:£E I..,z.'1.><_11'1;m'1ma zmd '.J'c,k-_'--'§m.:iA.1'.?%1T1L'2L1 £')L%i:'15"--'!17':¥22a.I",§'i(1 1),'/' L110 (1()(Tl'()1'.'5§. "{'11c1"cai'1<':'. ht:

]'f.,'V(?V(}1'.,(:1L'€1' "L1'1«c-s-*_ "".as1;1t_.<~1'11<-:111$ ml' .}e1vz11';1i2111. 1..-;:1.1<._sl"1111a11'1m'1;[1 xvhiltf-;~i1<):'i(l€'.1<:t:i1=1Egg 1.1'1<=-* §1'1('§1.1<'sI. am! .~ae11I'. {lac ("loud t:)<>('1iL-we f<)1' }.)<')::5':': "1:1m1'1c:111. 1'10. ('.'()1'11311t'3"1.('t(;?('1 the i1'1v(.=$i'§gz.:.1':i01'1 and » '1'"r.>.V<',é)%1"1..1¢(r<l I'.l:"1c;~ SI'£1[(T111L'.i1i. of Wii.::'1(:.'5::a(.?s4 and i"i1cci 1:1"1c ' ('}'1§£.l1'g(3 s:sl'1vv€ z1;._§:1i:1:st {"1110 ;{1(:(.'LI.'5('(1 pc:'so1'1s.

12. 1-"'\~Vi'.'>9~S1--1(.j) 01' 1.11:? K11511z5111"1a1§.2;z-'11' 1"01i(.'c_é Ef~3t.21I'.io11. 1""1(" 112155 :~;E.e'=11.£'(1 111111 011 2?-).8.':'.3S'} 111* 1'c'~.§'.__1;i4.-'.s"'L.r..{.1'"<:;i(t'--_ 1.11.0 ('E--LS6' z_1f1'm' 1114:' 1'<.:<.'v11.>1. 01' two (lcrz;1t11 1'11c=r1'1'1(1:--A-4;':*E'1'(:111:1'«T 1{11s1'1z'111"1a1g2;z11' (.,1<1\»'c1'11111L-=r1'11' 1-1('>.s}:).it21-1"'017.r;11"1C{' :Vi;1.1"11_~}1.1j4a111z11:111;1 a1'1ci S1111-'a1*;:1.11121 2'1.1'1c'1 2.111c.1' 1'e:<:':(__11'(11i11gj%11:'1k:_:§§1.z';1¥;:é1'1'1M(*1--.1I «'..11""1_;1'1.«'1;

(_'m'111:)1z1i1'"1;11'1I-PW} :15 1.101' 1/"_:S)11E}1T11'1(1_'111" 1110 of1'(:111"t1: 1~')111":i:.~;1'1;11')1c i11'1(.1'("I:,%L'('¥E'.11)I1'é;':< 1302-. 3241 1' / W Sc=i:c':1':iu1'1 149 of 1

1. 3. "1"1'11c-gf' 1"1:1\.r1-=;é £11.'.€SL) sp()kL>11 1.0 1_\!21.1f1(}11S."1~.);11'1}:. "p.1..a=1y('~..g.1"' by t1*1('r.111 in 1110 i11\«'césE'i;g2111i<":1"1 .z1i'1rf'-._é§111s($~,_Es'1.1}:)1.}()1'tc('1 1"1"1e 0:130 of 1.119 p1'0$cc,111.111111, 1 11. is_1'1"1;11'1"1,t.1;:e 1-;*..vi('1c11(~c 01' 1.1'1c:.~;L" wit: 1'1n*ss1='s "2'11'12;:1.1v_""31;.11Q1 1L'&11'11'L1C'1'_$'Q1$?51(')1'1S J1.1(.1gc 1"1;15.~; 1'1c1(1 111211 1110 ,,.

17._C111C1'12.1111:c_ 01"eyi--'.1fiE:11(*ss<>.§=, 1--'W.=~:.1._ 2, 7 51: 12 z5;11'1c1 ("1(>('.E01"S'

1.:Vi:.1é§':1(_>c is--11.=1(:§1i ('.()g_{(.'I'11" 211111 1.119111 1'10 c":1'c'1"_1i1.)i1it'y in 1111* 1111:2181? of E1.1':1_c> p1'<..>50v1.1£io1"1 z:1_11(:1 1'1.11"t",11o1* 11c1(1 1.1"1a.1_1" 11115 115 :3 "«j(i':1ES('1'"O11 (.'12-1811 1:)L't1..w(:'c11 two ;_§1'(,11.1}.)s z2;1.1"1('1 111 \--'1t-'\-'\-' of 1110 'Ve;1i1*i('>11s (11i.s<:1*c>.pz-'11"1('ics 1:)<'>i1':11c<1 01.51: 13y 1.110 p1'(_1sc<'::.11'io11 <'*:«;1sc 111? 112155 1"1c1(1 1.11211 1'1"1c 1'(*:11 ;;_'(.:111ks~;is z=11.1c'1 (_11"i§;_{i1'1 11:11' 1.111:

()1'11.:11c1-.> 1"121:~; 1.11-11.11.; s1.1;)1)1'(.?ss;1*('1 2111111 111 111211. \-'11-rw <11' 1110

5.

17. SH' 'i3'3l'sz;1\«-':=1:1i Si1'1g3;l'1. lca11':'1(:(1 S1,'? s1.1i.';>1nitsglhhlizgzl.

in View of the lZ"1(~.1 ll12"1l'. 1.'l"1c> (l<}c11n'1(:11l.ss sc:)t.:gl«1~~:.-.ﬁt").__l1'''l''ijLi '' l"ilc(.l 33}:-' 1130 ("lL'.i'C.11c"(: 2111:' Elm 1'Q".('()l"(IlS of plE.l')ll(.'..(']ll'l:t?l"l(.'.%'. $111? 5-'s21n'1<:% xmiiy l')(i:'. 1.e:1_l<.cn on lilo.

18. E"lewin;§ l'1e:._*e.11'(:l l:)ollj1""~.s5i(les§"-;--mc'l_ziillfli--':5._"(;f--;u'r3l"1.1l perusal of i'.i1c \I;11'i()1.1s_. clon1.1A1l1'.:.<-égﬁs'Q2-aalczl '"1'1i1.21.l4(jlTi§£E1.l§5 on 1'c.rct0rc..l. \.>»»'c 13;-1v(=:' 10 c_)l)sc=:1*\.-'v*1-lmlfiljéc? (l:"(I>Vl:"ﬂ,1')'lizliIll"WED-(.})I is at W'(.'.l.l clrawn upglt5v.111s1<f*1'1l lxlvlg.i:';l1'=.giycS i';l:1E\ spc('..il"i(" <..)\.*c1'l e1(:1:s 21;g;z1.i1'1s+:'t'" a"_i~l_ {hi-":_ 1'us-}.y()'r.-1.(:lc:li1Its. AcL.ic_>1'(li1"1_s_{ to the }')1'(')S€(',Lll.i()11"'(E~:Qf1;S_C. _c5:'\"=i.§lic.r:'1cclfill 1110 i:1_§11r0(l \\-'i1.1"1cSsc*..<...s 1.0., P\-'V$';1._'~2 a1_1.c'l :_fi'._(fa.-v__1i'n(:=1: be liggglatily l:)1'usl'1c>cl usiczic-w. Tlm d:->r_">f'(.)1fs ll ll1;:1l\'c».cli:(:1'l'il"i{?lf..l tl'12"1t: P\-'\/$1.3. 2 and 7 are 1l"1L:

l'1"n_jL.l'1'<3(:l*f§Eyc%ixzlt"11g~..ssc%l.$s§l.l 111 lll1(?S€i* vi1'c.'un'1st:z111(:cs. 1"(:lyin_g l(~)1'1vl"l1C'l.l {):f)'l_l'1l10i'i._C§'l- the clo(:.lo1':s (?0il}_)lL'_'.('l with film l"1is1'.0r_v §_§i\.IC'i~1 {.31 't}'1é§;% A(.lO('l.()i' l.:)y E--'\~V2. (.l(':1m'l:c%s t.l1:;11 all 1.11:5 ui\s_{l'11"

l'-- §§1!lT¢?:l.1St?C.§"' .1)Lr1'.s011.~"s wen' l1'}\-'()l\:'ti(,l in 12116.' (.'cmm1i:'ssi<:.>:1 of _l :"11Lt'1'<l'(>1' ml' §'l"1(,'. ('l('¥(?C?'dSC(l. "'l'l'1<' sf.:'1u.*.111c1'11 §.;'i\«-'en by I-'\-V2 " -U1": T110 (iz'11'c* oi" i11(_'i(lv1'11 2:11': ;'1i:>om. 'i'1..i5O ;').n1. L'-lc-*zi.:'l_y vss:--1l)li$l"1(*s {lull ll1L:?I':L-' xxras a p23'11'ilull);-1t.i()1s ml' all I110 {hit \'"i('\-'\-' that 111%: s:+L*11t.m':<rc';' of §x'.I for 7' _\_»-"c:'z.1:'..Ls w()L:}L"i n:1('trt E'1"1c c==~1'1<i.~; (')i'_}1.:si'ivc:?. I'It'1"1(.".('. vvc pa'-1ss the 1'<')1l<>w'i1"1_;; ()l'§}k"'ET,. L'. 'I'J'1.ca (,.1pp(;?(:1l is (Mow-<,.>(.1 in part.

if. 'I"!w ()r(.Ic3r Q/' (t('{.1IIil.f(.'1i pasmc-acl !':)j.,'----.z:J'a"..:,{ Ic»2.c:fLr':;_1cd."' Se$si.or'1s Juc.1,(.W\? is J'ac:.'(jJ.fy'--_ .;~'=_eét=. "e'1:g;'.ci.<;,_[A' I€(:s;:)<:)r1(le2n1':;--I ('I[f:1"(fi_ r.1Vr'c3 I I" 10 (TJ__['_'/"er1(?<.? :1: 1.c.ic:.*r 1.0; ;1 ."%"(')'4 1 aciiv} Sc-'?(:t {on 324 ?'/u.'- and 1'I1(2_g are ser':I{;j*':c_jcac1 11..-0' gjecuxs czzrtd to in d.(;j/'c.1uI.I'. IO _)';i.\i"!'V':iT1V(:V=;I' perioc'l Qf six months '.~/ﬁr' '{'zc:Icr Scci.Ic')r'1 :*3(.)4 {I} r/1.1.' I49 '.Fa.1I;I.'§.1ﬁ*A::.;Vlf'1(ag.} are s<2n.tc-3r1(fcec.l Io L1rz(,Ic;*:*g() pcI"[0(i Q/' one gcctr (?(1('.1"i ﬁn' Ihc 1 ur'1(.i(.2r Sc('£':'(Jr1. .'..32==} I"/Ii.' S{.'('t1'on. J45) ' _ ff}-?'Cif. I--3(,)U': Ute' s(mIm'1(.rc:?.s; 10 mm (xi)!a(.'urr<:r1.{'lg;. " iii. {'3(.u'l f)onc.:1s; cg!' the r1*.s:1.'J0r:c.lo:_ml'..s; curl" {.'C1Il('('3ll(.'(.I. iv. /\('r<:usc'cI :'\J"o.'~;.1 to :15. 7 (_'IU"I(ii 8 (.II"(E' car'm'I.ic(:.1 to .°.cI 0 mt.c.l<i.>r' Sc*(.'lI'()I'I 4-28 (,,'r.1'--'.(f.'. [hr (110 ix-:%r£(:2(.I O ' . . I .

w.

//5 I'-»J cieiention w'1de=r_qone by {hem as Lmdcr ___§'rial.

prissoners against the ser"ti"ence rzow z'z71pG5§erd}"--_ The triai Court' c'1i:'<:(:*£,<:%c'§A,, to cf:'ei1"'r3-*'.:'_»01:i't, senteramzs cndetred abovt-2. ._ _ ' .

TL

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court