Karnataka High Court
P L Chidambaram vs T N Babu on 25 October, 2010
Bench: N.K.Patil, H.S.Kempanna
E5 TEE Kififi fifiiffii" §§"
fififfifi ms 3% gm my £3? m*m§§;§@,A%%:i2::;%:Lé%% L % R EQEESEE'?
33% saxmg mg gggngé Ea % T}-E I+£§H'BiE» W, ;§§miz::§ R1.»
am. §¢.§I..:.a§i¥§'£'.'%:$.f??A2=§'._ 'V 393:5 {BY is 3¢é§£%§<&x z¢:;$;A;§;3%z$:: & ,%S$§€f1&T%5.e§E3'%§,2} %%%%% :*2e"§;»;$z?'% "
= A ":a§m3s;:ag£Js:?, Ffiflfimsmg.
»..,§'?' "§%2*;~,.»?s.:§-:§'..§_fi¢.éi§ '%§';§,3§i"§f'g§fl{§.:i§.E A Ezgssfigmsa 5% :.:m ' §.%§.}fi§-£3? ;- azmgzafi § fimagg igfizfiéé §&§fi.§§§§s: 23$ . E fiffififi _ $ia»;:.;§ug§ga fS%;¥';§'*§f::§_§____§§.;
kw?' E&§€%;%§.x§R§ ~. 3% £3?" $3? fi§'%i R733 E3 E2 » §E§3.."%£";'E§iT%§
*I:~§$ 31%'-g :3 332% mi: igéfi ;;:;'*§;%3:z~:§f §:,?§m§3§;:~é*:% fig fiazaggzm §gm.:::_§ki,:;:s n fi?,;%;--$S;$jX%"~- 2s%=f§;51x§§ 2a::::.a;§z::;: 5:54' 'Z'§~E 3:33 @' 3% .:%aa§:§?;g;%;§;§i&::?'§%--;»% Efii. 1!a:?§¥:§e%' §:§@:a:¥;«*; :::§%g §::.a::;, %.;i:aé§;?§${;25%;é§z€; §a%2a':':;*:*A gag;;:;§1s;;«;*§%:::*; , = §E%;;fm«::}"2-5 9% $:::§g{'§g?f:ée:"$§;::*:::§";%~s%% fig {E}? {:£3E&§%€$fiiE'E:€T%§';»..__ M *'E"H:§§ .§§?FE'-fi§.,. aVa',:;4§$;";§(¢€;a'._ §.%s§=;*vv%1.':::":§3:;A:"~:%,§%aL 3% '};*§£§ §.§§:s5; %z%;; 3%.: §a%;:':§ £5 33;?%E;%:1f::..f§*u§%%:E.,Eéf€.f:%§ém¥@€%£.':~:
%"' %% %§§»:§; cm-€§fA:§ A agaimfi 22$ jfl ?§E§§ Eiwgzéw 'E.3.i3'.§U.2€L'KL3§ gmégfifiii ii}; Eaiyfi :w.r;::':?g §§;:%*:;;: e;::i;%?»,*z~5gg§. aim sazamfmm amm 3% mm ggmm ghzssfaigafim' Efiffifffii 5% %z*$%;:%t}"'}; 32% 2*;«§mm.§ gw gm §:ém§§:;2;z%§z:é:i--'V.';;_§%;3;§é§§:§a-:3: azzfi az¥a:':§§ $.'i§x'$:§"{§fifi 3. saszzg af xiii": izztarwt at fiéiifi pa, £3 agajézfit fix V' §E.€Z3§€§®§{£}§§~» W "gm agégfiéwzig $2": a$;=m"a.§r:%;. ass? ' tfia 3 fiugfififid 31:': agtg gfi ixafizt': amfiigifigéi, [ __fi_M,,_W,..
35 22 'E'§*§s:': Efififif §$.€'§£'§ :3? téaaa cam 33%:
33% apgeiégné: wag agfifi &&1a'?: 3%: ag Safiiwaga Engirzmr azzé €35 was Eggk mfi héaiféégi gzimr ti;
$12.9}, ml §2§$*2;:2§'§f§i§. at $;':,:~:=;;§:: gymg %§i2._ §':ij$ r§;;%5;%* ' "£§€:§;2% near aggiéfimi was gmém fifimfiavagfi £33'; §:.§%.;% §gd 3;, gm mm E%Ea.§«ifi-$'3;-§§«%v§%»j§_§ & ragig m;a§ @¢1i 3,21% iiafifi-Eifiéi agsigzsé Erma iszé tiw imgasa
-- ilrzgjumai E135 mg §?'¢i2§-;§?§:V. -
E, ~ may I"ig:{'l'€. fiiizgar afié 15?: figggssr ::f";s;gé;: Egg:-2&3 aw: Egféz, % 63 *.Ml M9 K Qamgmmné §*a.$>:'f';"§:a2*a $5 hfifii 'mam ea? fight @ at Efiwfir 3%'? mid £9 Z1-.&m;::*3.%:fi '§?*"i}'i2Ei%§§ saw? 1: @331 mfiagé §?& §%z.;.§az* fiagmmfim magfiamfi txifix iififig =5'; -
:¢= .
a§te§_§&é#§a::ay$§:3§ fifiza m*§a§ mzfi. éawgazmnmry z:*e':2*'1a.e:f :*§§:s%;a:§§:~--.;:;2.a%&1*£$;§ é {$123. sf fix: awaafi gmzéiiafiaé; égzjméfiag 1 aa-ai :2 aim simpie in naizzra méé 3 mzfi é aya grifismzza fig; gsaaczsfimi 23%' @3233 auaigfigifié ix': 'aha §,r:;i32?£j&f:':;}Ii;** ~ aggikai 32% $32 wm§m;§:§ {mi 3 §::é§' k V' :}m §§=I%$§:i:%3E mé aésfi 'iIé2§§;$3;"'§§?éEfi:f";i?;. &;::'g;%:.:*::'m§i ~ might haw syn: ffififififiéfiéiifi ;=a_:I:Q';:::2:z " €%3i3?£':2j§fi;€"§£$§ zéazzzfiiafiéngg. fggasri¢;%::2;'::°§'j:%":%;am§;&.:é.%.'::§;2g%.:§$% mfi mfiégaé mvggzzaaas , tiflfi mzssszaiszzizég iéaa; j%:;%{s§.§§ zgfiiégzfgaéfsgé 2:3 fééa 3; gkim @?i'§§m:; 'Ea§;fif.E':::§ wffim fim '7§'3:i§:3.:;a$;3 ._%§&§z:i:2g1"'v%bé<:s3%§$:::§§:§§:s:z as? 3 mm af %:::;:x;i;g::é::s:i:%;% $32 *§*§.~:§:mm.2 gnaw arfi {:22} 2&5: fiifi gjémzaaf fiséw fir': gwariéégégg mmgmmaimn $5 ; §1,5f€;g;:;::i;§+ %§§.%.h iziififaét 35$ §%% fram EEK: gm fif asiaim 232$ fiaéfi af figfigéés Egéfiéii agfiiafmé * éfiaziizsm 222%' &ém§as::1m":.i§}§§, aaazariiw; 'rig "?:*ib§.mai%3 3 a??.2§fi&";i»:".':i:. fififiifiiifiiifig ifémi aim Cfifiiiyfiififififififl awarifii iay éziéga TE'§;§}§§.§3§§ 133 émaémgugtag flag §':';_::§.:u:r;a«fe1-- _ &§§§fifi§"§'§g fast $33 agsgmléanét, gzzgé ' §§§€fifi:.£% far ihfi _43;~%§§;;::3;.&a-mi fa. V k' £i:.3m§&:::; Ear mizaéiifimfiifi ;$::ag:::% iifgéjész. é, .&fz&r gaggfzzi j;$%':»i.1.3-z~::;§ '§e$%&f§:f:3g§j:"1fi juégmmt wgfi aarsmi ;;&$;.ae§§:._?:;§r %§'g§;'§;:§}13.%Z;?»$££;._i'@%§aE"3é.t V'§:::3a:*g€.:=s £3 témt fiia '<4;=;2a;.f+..':z.*;€'%,éTéx§3:*;."§*,V. ' aria? £513 $§2,$%:§_§.:':§ii E33; aim Ema? E3': ¥:§;§$§'L§.%$. E-Ear: hag mfimy g:§§;'%a? §;;'3I"§§z§ 5%' 2% fiagw fig: ths 'fivifi mi' é.1*f:w:£f2;€%;j:3§ fifi aizgxifimfigzi ma §:§rge§*Zm, asszmaaggéi 32$ {§.§;;§§.§}i§§t§ &.i §i":§% tg aim %g§:§5i.§'.§ ;%A:g%%5%% mg mg xgrémie mi?' :2 aha mm as g rm é§;§::é-g§§:::: tizzfit Em E233 3&2: Egéggg mgm mwaras V' wages? €2'$ fi.- § fi§uE§$ éfiaé agfi ag%m§m fifigfgfia '§'§'i%u::a§ egithmzat aasafzg mg: magi 23$ éfira' 3:2. {EE EEEQ fli3 yam wfi WWW"
/ é agméfg gzzfififfl zizmlzzg %,,§§@ ifaairmzfgi pmisfi hag awarfifi 31°11}? ~» 'mwarég paxs. amfi mwarzfig Eggs :3?' afiefiiziiiwg fiéammfsrig mg . W%§:2$§: are $2: the Eswsséf aifia 62:: "' '§"§m€:r?é's:sra:§ am élaam it $3.: :3 am3::3h"§:1'€;;"%2§§;€Iifi;f7:£i§'§e"' ?"gas¢%*;%§::zz;'{ii$:_: paizz azzai §*:;§%2*°i:g$ 311$ %T§$.§Z:{§:'.ifv~ V ::::¥§:r<:i§;:é_'v«~Es:2$;€3: éf r L' a§m2=:3:E53::i%§ §§§£flm§%'§3"§£__fi§£§; " Efizafiz ' ?%i;E:;*:§:§€$:a$&£i@r: fig smmagw appaiiant has §}§fi:§:::;*a&{£':;m飧1$£;:aE}%§$3 §.é"§;5x§2* gmm;;:3 mi 33.2.. 'éfiw fiw '§'§'.§h::::m§ is rmmfig is %_§§::%1§_%}:z:*-:€~;_:§ z::::'f:«. "{:?::$ ég%{2*m:{£ aim: aha afi:§3§%}.%21t hm V' wzms mam Ema iha pwcéazcaexifi ~« §£%"&§'§,3 the amlfi Emaé, ?§ ,E§'z:%a:z.%iz; {ha "i':*§.E:z§§;:'2.§§ 213$ awed ifi amt V' mag mm?-zgrzmfiaii Egwargézg ' ' zi:;g1.2;§*°%E"2§2§ fssmi smzi aztgxmiwzt ?:§1&§'%fa?I3§'"fl, Ea ' ii: ii :5; awayé ffiiiifiiiifiif « mwafig iéfi Ezaaazi ' V' aggséfiimtr-4': ..a}§ma:%aEs*fi"§.m part;
3. W *:*r:*m;m: gg Em? gmagaag mamgnggziazg éfif %;;?5,%f§}€§;» iagrarfiég %~'2§a..§:é§ _ £ €3.33 wzvégég "i'i'25 agsgfiggiigzzi = ::'%iT:m;3%§:<f£~ fag? 3 §:sa»:*§.::s£% gf' Eé} £33353 :15:
ha mug': Esaws tgaiéafi héé ?€$%:Aaz§¢évv§§§E§*a¥ :;§"§:z.*$ai$:flaz'2i Em' a gerfwsfi fif E m£:§§§§§§a"4"§?§?2a=1*g§£%:%3§ "é'>*;.V:V%§£.r§3€é;:%i€'§ gm just 321% gmger Em a%f&;.:%t:§.. %§ iztgmmfi %id;s::§;4 V '::;,%7*.._:*:iiE:*.:c§V.«~§'&s%".§ mzfi fiiygumtamfia Q? 121$ aésé"'§:;5':%$§%';«a'E§::$%%§;Vi§% iifitfiiifi apgwfii gw hf; '€§°§fi éiafig mmfiz azéfi a*.;t;"a§"é
- gagafié :23: gays §§m:::?;:2::m 5:33: am:
%;=..§ -:j;:_§ : Eaa: fiédifiagmé %£Ea%§§§:* Eméfiaisam iifiéinm & Pzéfiféiggl gig; aéuzzigfi gggemggg ..*a,L.:%%§§§:*: /r 'ma amfiarém, gaivfia 5&5 é'£§§¥a*"efi::1:ifiaz'§ * V § fiifflfi '§§"%7:§§{$ ffasm {Em fisig {sf mmigt $3' «:::::: egg fix: §.::"¥.£.'£ $5 55% ; mmgaamafifigfi fig' z*5g§:ak;k:§:§%; Q 5% mg: gragxzmmzzfiéfi iiiéfiffiéiifij 'm::% . $33. %%@ mm a? &.§§€§§?i£"§,? g%§;"¢;gemli". aashggiaziasé Efigziég fax 3; pat"-ie:}:;{";fi _ §.13.;:}a: éégsgavsafaig fig? asggaafiwr 3 is tn firiiijfifggf iéfi i£"1'€sft.'.3i'%§'§ ' W ;V ., §$:3:3:£:'*:;§i';:_.g§ §§i§:§~~.§?§§;'§§%;?§§f}§E&€fi fiiififfsfisfi ahafi shaié Em r* in $3? imzmfifiéazfily ma dégmfiiéaig fix €:$m%*2:°z*<g., '€41-4.; é;'€*§2.aw"M-- iha mg}; ~ ..