Karnataka High Court
V.A.Narasimha Reddy vs Government Of Karnataka on 12 March, 2012
Author: H N Nagamohan Das
Bench: H N Nagamohan Das
:3 :az:EEN;s3<Sm W3. 3 as RAVEEN AQED YEARS R-4 '£0 6 ARE REA, 22:13 M KA\f'AL KENGERE HOBL1 8A;\.?GAE'.QRE 393%: TALUK '--
BANGALQRB , §{ELSf?i3NDE;NTS {By 3;; RAEVEACHANSRA R NA:i<;:,' wgpa S3': N/SQEJUND REDB':'fl=E§r. CQ.§;--.:Vs§§J, EQR 3;': ' Sri. RAJAGOPAL Ng«:§:T.:V?:1%AD'v%.§ R-.£;"5§:j_~5)_ THESE WEE? §>1E:'i:'iQN3T'j'.-ARE jE1LE;aUNBER ARTECLES 226 AND 22??%._.§E4:«v.Vf*§;~£;::V_C<3_N§j§m:f;f_:G:\; GE ENDIA WITH A PRAYER TC} QUASH mb: :\€QT1F:C_;~;:'§0N DATES 29,a5.2o(>:? UNDER SECTION :,5(%'::;QF'% L;£:NB._;aCQUESiT1®N AC3' ENSQFAR AS SCHDULE'.PR9pERj*£_'j~:s' 'si7§}'?siC£ERNED§ VEDE ANNEXURE P ANS ETC. " _ " V' ai?
EHE:gE'wR:T@~Ei§:T:§;Ns H;w:N@ EEEN EEARE AND ERVEIS ::é::':R'%'.,QRBE§S;' mgs {},A":C. ?\EAG5:?¢§{}§.§AN $53 32 V \{vE?..;Ef:}f?}%E..E{};L®'%fENG;
"' ' GR§ER §;r:~--.§E:s;:;<;g. .aAf:i'2 'pa/iiiiiame Ehiii §::i%%;é<e::<5:s«; E/::':2=':: 50:' ifas 35;;
" " --~ i.":'c7£__§{§:af;::g §3i1§f:ef,, 2: méi $5 <;:s;£%a>:'a:*%; =32' my 93325:" azszfié, érxéeé €31"
H d%:"9>c{is";:: aguzéshiag N{f::§§'%e:::§%{:§§ ?'~k:a BSAESEA{§§£i§§R1?;;'i§f2€}{}6--?;iE{}'? {§:':§i3(§ 2€i{};i2{§{§? aiafier :%::.:%.é£::: iéiif} :3? Ike i§}'{§,€§ ,i'a.;%§u§s;':é%<f;r: AC:
ii} S6{?Eii?E': :1}? thsf: V GE] {§§,€}E.2{}{}4. The BSA is mw fsittmlizisg..§:;x: _ V §2}.jg'(1%U§ £5 £226: E33225»: zzcquémé ézzciuéing 33$ Ezmd bé:E<mg%::_g'"E.e:> gseiizézagzegia Pa:/Ei:i(:s:":<;:%:'s in iheiz' $§2':E€m€n: <7-:5 :>%}§é;::;1gé{:%:'_:s; '1'£<:>V.'_:%:.e:V.,V_W preiémimary n(>tifi<:a£i0:1 izontszncieci ahaz m4:zy'é7e'§::z2id ?§.5{E§a pa? SQFL as; ::::)mp€:2sa,£i<:rn ané :here:"<):e :h€j:"'?»:g:%: 5:{:»w gm é:1f:3ti::c§23:;::> quesfien the aCqui;<;if;§oz:. Thay _h';z7;€ _fi0£ 2!'%:);;:.§é{i..any 05 Ehs c<>::di{i<>ns mposed by zhis C033: 1;: .W5E_'. §€g>--;"~.4iéi'Zi%éf§}f2€%03 ané cannected rnaizers; Sin<;"e":?:s;g§}0n£}E:z2: €N'{§S. .54 iG'*--x6" v':12wr:: veluniariiy given up certain 13:15'; b6§:ét;,g§ng" f:z'§§'2:%V:::«'f'{;rV'§0:*:nL%:i§@:1 9%' :3. mad iii the Iajyouz the EDA has:5:3-c<;:§yey.::flxyertggiii iands; as €G§T}?€1"'iS3,E§{>fL {)9 éiheise g§0:.:n§S'*sh<: ';€s;3:3:;éé;iis. {ha ciaim of §€Eii§O§}€1"S. ii He»;:%:é a%';g::m<~:;:Es'"<:n_é'3:3i§: {ha side aad psmsaé £316 cadre wz*§:§:s.:;pe:.§s;~ _ ' 85 E%::$;;*2<t§:3:fzs"--:2';'iaL.'I_:'~i§:. 3 ~ Lanai A:::q:::§:~;i%§§{:~:: {}E'%Eé:€r fiéssii 2%.
_é;1:;2_§;::2és:'::_':Vf: s;§":%<>w§~.:2g';%%:<: aiséiaiés; if kind asggzzfiaéiéaszg zmeii $26. :~;;3m:: is é:_f:€§:é_2': " A _ V' rsspegdszzé NC:$.2 ans} 3 53% am caiisédsreé {fie rsqasgi sf peziéesasrs {:5 drag {he acqaigiiisg prsseedéngs am :23 L"
betterment shargés. Them is no aczzegtable exp1aQ3¢{i§'fi'-...ft§:f:; _ respcsnderzz N93. 2, &fid 3 fey net cengideiéigg 1:h¢ :;3q:;e:~';f cf ':i1::,_L petiiionsrs. Tharefors Ehfi acquisition ;srQ§eedi::'g_s are 1§aV¥31'§:2A :33' be quasheé.
:5. 0:: 39eQ5;ZOQ? ihe r:g{i¥§§:§g;;§:;. 15(2) of {he Lané Asquigiiign Act: {Q ef taking gossessien 2:3 an e;:<'£e;é{§;._ in dispzzze that szzbxquent {Q '€I1$VV::a'-gspgndenz Gzavemmem E3; eXercis§ngv:"'§Qélv§: @f the Land Acquésiiien Ac: §s::e:§f:';eé C:::tain '«::...;;éxfi§1€XU§:$~P dated 29.§.2§GZ fi'§§'.3Q.?;§, fi;::neXgre~?¥" fiaisé i,§i%.28G'?, 3§.Q8££3$'? 3:5 sagas. sf {ha fieiifisaiiens ' V vissggé i3:s_é:%;e fi:gi'V§:5é,s§§$:':§:3::£ -~ Geysmmgni éaizeiéfyézzg {ha Eanés :5
-. éiféifiiif; <3§~Z?§;:C% zicrag. Raspéadeizzg :3 and 3 ii} iizsfzz siazgmsgi sf
--'. ':}?}§£§rii:;s3::§"§£3i£fi £323: 11%;; hgva i3bj€£if3§ fa: §€IEi3§f§£%§§%E'§ Qf ihg E233? iha §§%?€fi3E}}€§'§$.. Eizfgzg fizirizxg £313 §e12r:Za::::§* sf ibis zvzéi '»»p223'c$§d§§gs E: S azsniégéeé 5:13: csriaég axwa: Qf iagdg am r:1::§:;§iifi€r:i; §?:'9m ibis aémiitsd maieriai $2": rscafé, %: is cisaf.-:53:
{ie::{>i:if%r.:a{§§:2s am issiseé by $13 £3@vsrzz:z:e::i._wi£i§{31:i 03' 1253; am if} vioiaiierz {if siatziiszy :*${;1;§re:f:€=:1i.7..A_ "§3'::riE:e;f" i1r.;::§e":' éeiisiificaiisns are asbiirary in r:a:1:f:;._V_é:a;;i feér" an _;e:<:i:'aiiéJ§1;:§~ ceasiderations. Thsrefarea {he azztire 3C.§l¥§Si{i$i3.,§1"{}C43§C1i%"1f§S_. firs iiéegai 2319? had 31:: law.
>2». ' £6. Learned cgjgiixsi fc::f:' fiéé' :';$,a;3§':;:1§§ie:_1isV'c:;fi£en§ 1:132: 333 eariier eccasign i%u}s"'::%;:;:i:,ia"--_V am connected mattars disp$s§:§~---VQt; ixpihzid t{§:€v..x§.:iidi{y of a£:q_:3isi:i0:3 pmceedingsé ézfier 323336 sTaV32rs::g1" years? {£33 peiiiiaasrs have apgeachcd this £:<§:.ssttf {fig 1:i':_e 'grsiéazijgféi of daiay am iasheg the writ psiiéigas a3:»*§;}Lia_b1ic :3 be ziiszgggfsgsd. 1:: suégefi Q? this sanéanzien reiiézget: ..§}z;c;::£§M z;::§"*:=2_s:::& giecisiazza E deciins {<3 acsepi ihis _QG:z:6:::.§§?i:A. Q? E:e 3r§é}%:j;E Véafiéansei fez' {ha respagfiezzig. '§'§:$ Si}§3£'€§:"3§ ii} Siaéa '§::§::¢§a§ V3, Qagaéayaisizzgh {§§i9'8Q)2 S€€ 4?} E1331 f . as V "Lsgaé izzaéiisa :3 gibiisfisiz 131333;; »j§§:'§§iir; ciaiéiy " 'E<:ée§:; ii gemraia {ram £215: §8§§1}§&§' Caigsegi sf pargaaai zsizza, 13'i§§i:§y gézgi, bad faéfi": aazéiisg' i§;::a1i§a:€g {$29, exegaisrs cf gagwaz" «~ »- Sfiffiéiilzififi caiieé caiaarabés $§fa:i6;:;§:':i' K, :--::~:er<:ise or fraud an pGw<:r ané <>§':e:::§mé: cweriafys' ZE'}i::f§'s/'€:'é, ggaszsésnsa ané :~;a§is;f3.cii<>ns; ~« ~ §_::.éh;<:a_ a:ta%'r:f:ié:'2§ . ' GE' finds E26};/Gné figs sazzctéeizad p1::i*p<:€§;;:s; Q-fgéywaé 53;' $imu1a§i0n or prezension sf' gaéniegg a i<~':'gAi:i:':?:e:i<a gjéxié, V' If Eh: use ef power is fuEf'i1}1nen:--v§f"*~..§eg§ii%na._{;€ 1:113 actuatisn or cataiysaiign by 1egiC*id:;;E. Tbs acfian bad whsré Efuéf €3'i?gj€.C[7§.$'vEQ f::§C§} an and different fresm the 0:16 "far éi;rh%Ch.*'Ehé'--§§0w.€: fifétiki/iS:fi&§ g<3a:i.ee:5,by.sxtfangoiisi C'QfiS§{.i€§&fi{§§iS, geaé 91: bad? bu: i'1:*'::E4§\i%;1.t;'. {O .:_E:§"e:n_::'::'Si:5::en:, When zhe cgsfiodian <>§=..p5ov Ir is i:;§:7hie%1a:e<_§."i:1 exercise by CQRSi{i:rEfZ§fiGfiS' %i{iiESiC§3€?: tlzsjse, fer §3!.'0I'flQfiOR of which {he poééver' is Vxzeste\j"L.;h'5.§éu:9{,~cafis ii a ggiourabie: €X€§CiS€ ayzkiis ;1r:c1fe;:@§V¢€£i':ius;i9::."
§1'; ' 'éi§r::ai::*V Na§é'a«.E_§:_:§1;SE§ia§ De;ve:§<>;m2a3n§; éxuiizeriiy u§1§3§1'idfii§ §f £23 gsiighi {sf iargs 253253;' 9.5 wig; have 'E:':8§€ im'<:-A5;::":em by b:)0E<:;:g «.f'Eaia sag», bag, :3; Eh: iime, it " i;:V:g§s;s%bE§ :9 égmrzzt £2211: ihé E3:a;§?0:a2::s:<§s 23:12? 538%}? §:*::;::;§'€.:*€.ss; hays $3651 §€§§§'§V{'::1§ at»? éfiizir prmzariy amj wig; SGEEFC8 9% §;i.v&.Ei%':<":<*s<E is: 21 mes: .?}f{}%I:i,'£iF'§:' anaj éééssiafida Efiafiiéffé' w:1:%2{>::{ §'<;:E%<m.?§€;g 5&5: ggscsziura " ' figasiécé 391% {has u£?§$L:.$§'§{fi§?h€f$ §vi2;nufSC2'{E8§éf2{}[§ E it is heid zgnésri ééiay it: fiiing £333 wfii peiiiigsz 0:" {Es getiiiagzer havizzg gcquissceé is £126 gracgaciizsgs by gaafiiecigaiizzg 1:: .V 'V §§€I§iii}"}=' iifldfif 3.54% has 13% sabsianca -~ Furzhef, €¥€§ if régpsgdsnis accepieé azzy a::2eu:.:_:WV::_f_'fere§§ " "fg'3<: " 'V agpaiiani is; an effert :3 36:66 9215: {ha aéguis§..ti 0 If:j., §A%3§1é:3 ' the eniire acquisition emarzategé _ fr::;:§ix_ tainiéii A " "
netification, any S€£§}€EI'1€I':§ an t1'£e*¥r:§:~s5._s thefssf cagzigt be vaiidateé ---- Wheiz ihe 'magic nfiiifiééiififi'¥.§§d€I;.iEf§it%S1§1 _ 3 the present: land is saughi a~§qu§r$§;i"3;:.>:§i{§.y§iiated than whatever méney ihai Lappé_fia ;:£;iiéd_--~;;§é£i5,;V_~ 3% iis awn risk agzgi Jihe§:i§9i§fi§§1:i<x§:i'§%:§$,V'ma; fienefii ceuici be deg? 4§f%._'f}§)€13§:O{i5€§iL§fiG§%i5f India - Ari. 226 ~ vi",?:3{1a;;§i3§;d 'V:»:;:a§s%V M+.:§z:sI1af§;:¢'s 9: fraud - Deiay "
1?, '¥3§§1::1§é2?«3r' S15 Eééiéé agexzciss éniiiaie aciiezz fer a:;§g:;ir§:1gf::g§:::%'ifs,..{':3V£: i.Va:::i..$:i:%1ersx'a:1.d {ids gsnfirai pubiic W333 'as 11336:' §§€§ iii}? same is far a gfiiiiiiilfi gghéis §3*'¥;}1"§GS€, yaias, :*€g:§é;:§»;a5ié'$_ 311:3 §:2;}{:$>:i};::'é E3 fsiisweé. A3: 3. Eater saga if ii seams 1% Egéizi :%";3{"'--:f:;1eTsg' raguiaiigfig arid maceézzre E3 12:}: fgfiezaseé, gm ;3§:E§a::jé"i$ aégzgiaé, gzéssia and sigma psiicjg :3 aéapzeé azzé fa:
'V s2;::fa:§a:si:s"Qaizgiéazaiieag gsmfi észzég as éeisisé §:*s:§ fifigfiifiiiififl, V %§:.%¢%:"l£§:=: gzsssiiézz 0? éeiay azgé; Eaches fig as: 3. ggrgssgzzé :0 éégrzzégs ihs K} {J1 \3V§"§{ ;i:€:§%:i<:»::s«; The gsziazzgc GE' 2s<:ii{>:2 'xiii; a:E.:~;:2 :f:":;;>::';?é aim 'fiaéz, éé§t" '~--.' E<n<>wi:2i§gc :35 f:'a::<i. 5:': 'size inieiaaé '§hé"'§§:§§ii<)§:c:'s ;:.::::3:£;:._ E<>"}E§E:{§FévT ahaui {E23 deisiign <3?' cezmért Ezxraéjs. $2212: e:;s_§7..::§§:"i;:_:i;:*s..janiés §:'r:<)£_AA1;sE'»{j} {>5 b$t£e:*m€.::i ghzurgas in 1'::s;;:te<:{ G§1 £;f:'i"7i:ZiE}'~§a}%§;f.f.:; {%:ii;::g§:.. _I§:f<>rma:i0n Aési. immedéaieéy {he 'Wm§s::_§i{i<>;':§:i:*6: éhe dslay anii iachssg is E20? 2; g::"9u;i::i taznéiégg ,s;I.ui% :33; §;:?:.:§%é:.;:1c%: . E8. in [ht §}:":':€:§§,§'E}iE1i:'cViZ':s?4'§*E€3:§§f§C2l€3(}¥1;'»: if was grispssefi £9 Z/3;Cs?fJ§;~fi it: was zssisiczeai {S '?§§ 3;€1'€S. E543: Eha: mam {bar} 58% of the Eands arglsfi <>:i4f'~frV<}'n:. g:'a1u§':::_iti{:§%. if the yeasanse assigned 3:33,: the V'{éf"':z;<::'é::§s: éands age 3:?/'Vi/E61? {hag ihsiéy éssueé §:eii*::;i:3;k:j§?'iééiiiésaéiztsg"2§2i§h<>a: izzapeciéfig zhe :s;:<>:, <:<3::<iu£I§ng {he '-~::;s::*v:':}: ;,§'_ éizs xaziihmzé seiudybzzg aha greémfi i"ii:«£1§§E§7,/ iha ~;§2~.:.{§is.:%:%:':5e by §%§%§§3g in :1 :'<}s>:':: ;:::2;*i*<%;::.:i the: sxéasnz {)5 E2232? ax: §E"E§i§. ?*%::§é§' ~g;%_<§'x>:,r;3:. i 'a::;:;_a§"2_;}:>pz'<3::{:E%2 %::; ljfiii' czzgiesfiizgna {Ff 133:3 ;>::>we:* is 2: f:*.2a;:;«:§ an $16 in $23 §%§::;:l m::a:%f§::;::é<}:a§ "§;€%:% amss»; r%<2i§§E:3<L Bug ¥%:e:*:
A:3::;2a/Vzzé as be §2£SE'~}€d {;::':E}; :0 aha: sxéazzi 2:? £%§?a2fi zzmzs, figgzzirs iii 0R9ER W:*ii §)€E§§i(}IES Zéffi Ezesrcby :i§VEg€i'~sg:<§. Thg izzépugned preiimi:2i;:i§« ' zz<>z§EV'ic:1:'§{>:i': éfitezd ?§1:.2ix}2$:he fh:a{:xs§£3cé1hg¢ §a;e§"@P932{x}3Ag:z::§e n<>I;ifi::a:i0n issusd u:1c§erL'V"Se:£é;:~n "v§_'§{2).. cf Lgnd Acqa%si:}.a>:é~,.A';;.£ inf_s<>:. :_'<3§::1;e§§ is «ii acres Em Exziorzging :9 the :jé:%":§u»:2¢:*§; is ~€§'VE;i'21.SE':€'é'fi5;V ' ' V C£'>§:V:4é:q;:2;§§E;i,V deéég (Eats/<1 £i%.{}Z;2G{}9 ' 331:3 {}4,€}4&Z;Q{}<} W32 Angsxugca-T ané T33 am deciarsd z:Z<;LimzEaE.%¢_:i is Eawg ' E {fired S36 R<:g;is;%;;*;:r :3? Lekaf;/u§<::a 1:9 {i'<;":é:{ ..firae§;:<: 'Mi: g>€é;§ii0z::~,:, as; sasingriézzigzt umisr Sesiégfi 9* G»? £326 iézgrizaiaka L<7sé:3j;a§<:ia ;%::i am :4} §i'Q§J€3'i{'i{§ $3': ::::g%<>r:;i:znc<: witia Act. The ?:::2Ei%0r:<::"s am: §:1s:3§:s:%.>*»: 9 {i§:':3<.:¥;:3d %i<:: SE3 {me ::<3§ie.a <i::§' Elba: {3?:E§§"€ wréé §E&§§°i"E«; LRSIDKB.
égciuéiag the affiéavitg wéih {ha Ragisirar ef L0§{a}?L1§{§a wiihin {$125 weeks f§<>irr:»--£a<.i3}%. M ' Srdered accardéngiys 2 E§am__és::£:gV""'