Karnataka High Court
Smt Asha K W/O Venkatesh Bhatta vs The National Insurance Co Ltd on 15 July, 2008
Author: Anand Byrareddy
Bench: Anand Byrareddy
_. ... .....r..n.m. - Ina! ; uvwnr ur nnmm:-\:ArLA t-maifi ('.0-URI OF KARNATAKA 1-HGH (SOUR? OF KARNATAKA HIGH 1 M3...
E53' ETE; Efififi CQEJRT Q? KAR§§AJ'§'AKfi;, BANGAI,C?RE mcgm Te-gzs THE 15?" may 0? mum' .'--3_fl1t_".f§':
BEFQRE "f'I-1£ Hr;%zaI=3§;E zam &§s*m£E ..n---.----....................._.. 3 $R"r£.3H&K W; G mmmfmfi mgm 4t3"'zr§:..aR_s _ -
Pi'8.=§f22} "
3% mm'fimm§.%;a*"3;Q'€.X ' gay aw : ;
L *r*§a=§: Esgflargngfi BEE$Tf3R ._ T933 I*=£§.*§'.iflz%i'.s§;E} mavmma {iii} Lm €;':j§'ia E,fi;$;v£G*mR3 Rfififi ?'?E;$~H%? RA A , :2 gm mmvgm ca sw.1;;;s, 33% mm mm ggmwasammg magma: mveuvr 95 Rmwmmrrrs $3' : g E}? PQQEAECBA, A}Z3'v3§CaPx'EE FQER1; IQDTICET T0 R? 1% §}§$?§-$333 mm;
é .. .-..wr . , ..A..?_A..¢.'.,,»..w... 'NJ! amnuunsunu r-nun L.UUKI Ur KARNATAKA HEGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA §-NGH C *3"
mm msagawfizaas Erm? AEFEAL Is msn --:;;;s :33; 1; 2.31% ye; Am: atzamszr mm Jammy? ARE! AWARE} §a*r'&':@::§§e:;s; 3395 maagn 3% was rzc;.5se?a;2;'3u»:4--}j'~:)2«;. ma m,.§: 5:? ma :2: .mm,. mmg, {1flIfR'E'__Qf"i¥""éifi£§J.L«__"' _ €i.§§i3'$."Ef$ Ea amhmm-L mm, fiETR{)PE}L-2'I',§H,~A.&"RZ€éa%.;_'_' mwzaaag gsmsméi, yam? ---. ' fimmgn @233 flfitfififififimfi' "3{£3EiE€I?§Gv-.' Emmagmm 31? fiC§££FEH%'fZ§Z3l§. A j; ' mm mm {mmm ma? is-ax ma1.. .
3&3, £::'::;::€JR'§ EE§.»IVE§E§} *:$:::-EA mnwwma Eiafigé am mt:
floumszé fa}: " AV in an aura
r£::émh:~.:§é5&§";.3%:;. afifikrad gz-mm us ax a4:§.=*es;e"zg1t havim met with an midm.
"2._ we-22. afimr Ema' tmazzi. was kafl; with a A whixzh wag amassed ta tk whsie _ .}._%i.f';§z:.efl*;.,§:..A3F;.f.2%4é:. I: was an 313%.: hasfip the appcliant " W the mm: amramz Claims manna: far mwmamn: 'The Yréfimaaé hm gamwedaé. to 'T & mm wmpenmfinn af Rs,,'3'G,fZ%/-, with " 1:125:-mgr. 5:: £3 mtg, wmm is madam" shazlme. Z
- nu. .- uuuni ur nnusvnanmn Hméfl COURT OF KARNATAKA FHGH COURT OF KARNATAKA H!GH I *3- Em 332.1%} fag tbs agmliam: vzmxld wam::1.a% tlwfi aha 'f'ri%u% has awatrsfifi V. mwariifi $333 cf magma £3; ' 'time baa am. acmuné, {::§ aarnimgs fisgefim in a Ea~§§,,%".fl€§§-- Em ax; zn of wmpaarzaatimzag .§ was Rsh_,§g:'::m;-V 95$ aurzm the pafizuzi as: per mm:
aaé mm }.; p'$£m~ mare than tlzme a:~am:t1z'.}*2;~aj;ti1j'V_2vg:' vwouéfi has in fit sum cf Eauiaifififiiigfé' $m5Jad. In 32;: Ear as the awargfé' " 235%" towards gm d.?Ea.bf1ity 'E amxzmt awarflmd *m termad as mi' mm r::ap&m:t3r, the Trfirunal Z _ augfii, $a:=2' $.::§f@a gm azlaim 9:' éisabifigr mt manly in Va; tim mg axf mm aapacity but aka the _ as-hm tm &Ewab§fi?ty maid afibct me VT €55": ik aemmi W333 amt: fiam her V U aszpacifiy, Henmg E116 '§'§%$um.1 aught to haw appfiaaé E316: muifipiier azmtimé in t& Z {ha pfii'%E>€3 K M V' -5- Emumrsm agmt in whisk gas was enwged Emraiemfi tkm is run dagrmfikrz af V. warmits. £"1:3I33§d*&i"$.§§¥»:?n Ear yam. $1' a _ V' , mum ?a: £3 .a.«;§:;é;1:;1iama_ aactua} $353 cjf eeming er $35.5 $3?
qzfimtian af gxant nf the muzzipéiaz mcthmezi mag the mm :35 Rs,a,:;w_z»g ::x3mputi11g aw asmeh to $3111:
--ii§iI:i; The amount emf ::%;sa;'m';:i9;':%a;~iasra§;é§a~.1§js.§ mi' _:u1w';.it.€m§ am am abeve ..... . ....,. . uwvn! ur :\nruw~\IAI\'A mun COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH 1 tha §~afi§ u;§2&¢.==,z° Ef crampmmatxhn wrmld be
5. many' maid resuit 7m unjust bfifit tfic agwfiant. Tharc is mi: warrant ammymmaiinn axfi waulé submit V VV rimé', éhg "ht: fiiamisaeé, arr: mmidaratiarz cf 'aha £%'I.)EJ€£:i1fi?U=fi3 put-ferth, it T in aerimmm é.?$}:m;te tkxat 3% apwilaut wmzlti be :afiét}.s5z:i ts: Es.l8,Gi3'i§,f- as 15253 sf wt? durfim the:
parimi 3%' traamsnt, In 5:: far as mmpaansaatiozn towards Z nan:
. . .7.,.§.... vs nnmw-umm-\ rnun LUUKI Ur KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COUR? Q? MARMAYAKA Hifil-i C -5- {has ééfiafiéégz is :-:
€312 méfifiamms a§ such §.?Eah§i1.3,:* ia lass c.apa::§%:§:3 'aim mam eat' mmmnmtiaon. K is Em? }'m1::€°'§.z:€£:& in re31a*éwx3 tic: Béwabfmgg awsgizi afiesct 13% a:;p§£:B.a i'z:tA 'V *' am. amrt flaw. ' 5 it}; it afimas ma mm be fgiétabie 1::
car flu: ma and t}:1&a*efe:az"»::§ mmpematiorz muifigziiimé': mf $3' a beam meflwd, tam af mnnay anfi for want E; 'm5%~'::'jV Vmefiésure, 25:13 mzlfipiia matlwd iis it 31:3 justafw' :9 award cszxmpwatian uzfi __ tmfiieafi axrxfi, gsw, {in age, aalary j gzgmfzzagas Q1' aiiaabiiity, m apwuan: uraulcl as " .®5";Rg.1;,2fi,f'::3fiflf~ tnwartia dfiaahifity. In so far as §=i"é£qezfit%m are csancscmaml, as mars is dfifinitfl loss kj L%{f£* gm tag natura ef mgmm mi disability, agsgmfiant wrzuld ha fiitfilflfi ta R3.15,@W{=- inwards 1335 $5 fifi"};.4fi.?'.'EZ§'{i§£~=§,; ""§'}1e aypefiam is thus»; enfiétlxyci ho a g whiia it 3% true that Efiiiéjaf