Sri B S Yeddyurappa vs The Lokayukta Of Karnataka on 7 March, 2012

[Cites 1, Cited by 2]

Karnataka High Court

Sri B S Yeddyurappa vs The Lokayukta Of Karnataka on 7 March, 2012

Equivalent citations: 2012 (4) AIR KAR R 451, (2012) 4 KCCR 3441

Bench: K.Bhakthavatsala, K.Govindarajulu

E») 3, 'E'h<:*: S*.2pe:"i:1{5::€is:*11i :35 ?'a:;[§§::%€:

E'ia:"§':ziiV21R21 ii0%::2§!:,:i{EV;:, M S Bziiiﬁiizge

3):: §iﬁ'ﬁf}€€i}§EiI" $<Es:iE":i% E3é::3g::1§:):°€r~55{} G8 E , ii. 'FEE Eﬁﬁzzcipa} $6;-'€::"<:*'{;:11"§f, Q0ve:'no:* {>5 E{.3rr:a1t¢22k2":.V Raj B'¥;2.:;1var1.v & ._ -- _ --. V 2 Bang;11or€~58Q QC: E. E;:3sps:§:ie;3>g:.1Vs {By Sri B A Beihiapnga, Adv, fetar R~} and 3}» {By Srnt. Revathy A<:£:1nai;h Narde,_ ?'iCC}E3,__f_G}:'"R~'3,.}V {By ftisrzi Nagamandgu S1: CGu:1se2. f§G.:f " A L EVE/S. J L13': Lem: fer R4} ' This W1*ii: P€.;£:iQ{;._ is;§§§§d.. ;§:.9Ei:§31§§3VV $5 227' 9:" {E16 COE1S§§'i,El{iG1Ti sfE:1éia, -Vggzqsiégg :5: '{§LA1.i;'*$3;§3'?'::"1€ aftiargipiainé filed by R43 daze' i.E2.§§2S§ E?_2z§a§:2::i€ Efzssyesiza uzzﬁer Secii<:ms '}"'}8./Q anﬁ §;"§{i§{§} 2:51»? $3?s:.;_:%§:>;": E 3_{2;E~«..af éf:::.§;'E7%eve:f:*;£Gn 0? Carrzxgiém"; zicfi, Q88 véée A,T1I1€Z§{%.i;f'€3~,?i; atés; * §3@:i:.£€>vrE'«.::z3:§ié3;g;' 9:: 55>? @:*ds::'3, {E36 333123 E*:.2:3;ir:g Baez:

?3:%32:.:*d ;*:n~:E;'-_::"a33é::{2?SC§ ;;EE:r §,%1"SfE{}§§§1{i€§7I'i€§"i§ 0? @'E'CE€§'$3 33;". E/%E*v}:';3;E<;:'E'7.a:f§z{;::;a§;:3.§ iéaéégie {he §'o§.¥;<;*»s;i:1;;;: €,'EI:}i§S€3 {g}.

The 'backgreund far reference/'a(:tia:1 isgas 1.;:;.{ie:ij A __ {E} Thf: spgart in *:;%:::> in§€m.:.1t§0:1ai ;::2*:::eS"1.§>f'7sEﬁ:é%:: zmd' _ sxcepi.

:§€s€.rz:i:>:": T?{_2:% } sf ihe KL Ami are mist anéi the 5332318. irszz are during: 121.3: 34 }:21:5 ::_i::é-:'i$ ihé" mining ané expert: cf high i\Z;L1E'£:vii"i.$.V"'i?'Of': §r"e_if'<:3":-: {ha minim; in Béilaryg "£T:,;mku:fi---ar::d '.C}':.i_'§ra,é:irg:2, EZ>isi:*3Z;::ts vsary hzcfaiivs; :'\27\iY%ih'Q31633,:.;1?fé'i"8;;;{€:'€{}Sl Qf prgduciiisn sf iron' ore 21: 5:233, and {he myaiiis-$--:f§9*~_b€ [Apajd ~:}§i€:L"_j&3j;::§'éV::irn€::i being abys::7Va}'i§z' Sui' V pe2'Wi:on for ::11'ffer€r:i graéfifgs ':5?'/If;t;*i?:'if a2.i;3'i;f5_é:€ié"é6ri§>z§s S§?'Si,€H}iC ﬁi$1i@:'1:i<}'i§<sm é:izi625:0 p:@u§i;VV":f1arg§n$. This has §€d V.1O *ai§eg;::'1:Vif{}:.1:3A Sztaié C§§T§£p?;i{3IE amé C{}F2'1%)§~é1§}?:S (2.? ':;hr'0::gh iilegaé n1inin§§--:v:V§,h é§*:<3V_.c€;::;1§;:i%::§:1?;;§;bf the 5iU,ih{}E'i{L§€$ in ail " '~ ,§€i'~Ji3§._S' {}a'~;§;:'::::i1€§a£;- ..... .. V {Iii} T§3é:'x3.e22'::2f:3:ir:t3r;i"~-in is arders yiée I1i§}§i§C€i§§{}§E Ne. A:-:*:' §\?<),C§ iifﬂfvi 3994 bah :>a;:;;:_c'i':% £i::>~:*<«'::a€::'*~:5::£ 561* §}r§V;;=£:,£:, f ::3§::Limg § ga.§:.;1rf:2: <35 E 3828 sguam E/£111"; :12 {ha Si;-":*:e, ._:4:2e:§33;_'§ §§"§* Siaits z:x§3i:>§é:3£;ia::*:/' miziiag '$53 the T §:*.;1'E3E_§<jj §:;€r<:§<}z* zmd :':::;f;§éE§=:<i :35: $;m*é::3s:E7é:::* £3? am ' §33,i"i;:§éi :3? €§§?§32k<i~§§ '%2e«::5;V2;;:*£::'~; sis? ;;:*§:12::% 222:2'; GETS '§>a>a:"§:2;g' §\\k\ /.'§/«(S \\\\ xx 3» .3}. \ , 33 $32883 iﬁmzagztzzrs-H}, éihe scsgs sf i::'s;*$3i§ga'£§{;fz $3; £1735: Lsséiayukia was {':°;'>i'§;ﬁ§},§ 22;; '£0 §.€3.2Gi38ﬁ. ﬁgain, £3113 ﬁ7ﬁ¥€ffE:§$f%§; 23:3 naiifieaiiixz éatsﬁ 2é.i2.2Q§& exiészésé ﬁiﬁ . i:':%;esiiga':§sV:; 1.2; as 2432,2633 {'£?'£ﬁ€ §§.¥3I}€}i'i.3?§i&M-J}, agaizz 332$ §0wamV:::$:z{ exienéeé {ire swaps: e'§ :::¢;€3%;iga';V?:a:::§"z::§: :?;:'>_ if §§.'}'.2GE,8 {wide §g%:1::€}§1.s.I$»£i}. @2113, iﬁzé '.:>~.§f;e§3e V the lgkayméiia was {mm 1.1.2856 is }§I.?u 6' if is pieadaﬁ in pa:ra4'.;-5?.' ihat Lekayuktha submiiied 3 .. 2:' i irregaiariiies ssmmiited by 232$ Eharam Sing}: agé Smi. 5:33 Sari ;£?:é::~..1ii§a:1ag:ng Birectar of Eviyfssra Ea:Zir1sra.:$"*.§,i:3§%it:%i:' §§;é ~~ 7:313 busirzesg by Mysere %.!ii:";$:'°ais Limiteé, '§{1%, iti:.€: far as Sr': ﬁhamm Singhg was :33: §;fiz2sV.:Ef::;#§§§§;::::;:j§* Qmzsragr af Kamaiakag 821:, 5:': 'She: 333$ :;%és: ;.%.€1:§%:::z::j£§23__ ma sVp;3<3:'%:.:r:§é§' was givezz ie him iyefers "$213 izzdisiézzzﬁi' a:;::i"_"_§1_%"§3;éna$ is kiiayiz ihg same ihmzzgh Qeréaizz "'§" €1i$:z§§%.§:: c%:'é>13§:L::£:'§§:.:2:§§s:;r£:::g ihaai iizﬁ Laéiayazégiéza Eizaé iizﬂicieé €326 £32.; 7:_j2.§s=; éégayi siiggziiég iéaai: 1:323 §x3ii%§§:2ar'$ chiidreigg %;z:%::; j, :7é:"*§ i»§f:%i*T._"§':*:is:ss;é$ gf Eséja ?:*§ra':':a Eidzzsaiiﬁzé 'E3135: havg f€'€§§§?$§ V :.i§f,§;r§a%§§i31-»v{;§;::E€§,§%&§{3§%§§ $31 :?§:3g2::s:§= mé 3 31133:: €35 ;*:"§§$&{;§;ai§§%;: ;;&~«»».»,m»»«._N' %~,,W,,M---\ .. . . . . ' . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . 2 \»$\\\\v\\v\v\.s¢\\\ ;;>§:§}; V'§§§fjaé;; 2f§:€:--.§:;c%::z3i3:;é$ I3.§1EEf:ff>§€i?€§, {:2 '£26 §'£:'.'§3{§§"§' 3? EB'. 1?" i6 and 50:1 in ism: 9: E}:*:'+z121z:;: E':':;::~;¥; 0:" Siniéh Evesi Mi:1i:}g {j{:::V:pa::y 1,ir:V1£'i:€/{E 9:' amii Jixfzdai Gztsxgap :3? c{>::°:pa:2i€s:

{:23 aha: L{3§{2:"i§s'i1}§§,,£§ é3ET€{'§ in :;t<;:':3§;":g iii} {:0::<%iz:§§::>;2 :" éhszi; 13:6 p€:,i¥1éa:1€r $213 £:{>mnzii;£e{§ ai§€'§_T;'e"j€;§--- {}ff€I1CCS uiiﬁési {he P:*ev<:m"L§er: sf C::{f1':,i;>f§;:i§1:. 'E§:C'f;,"

1988: V ':2' _' {xii} ihszi His Eixsaiiezicy the €:{>¥€rnor'>%3u§'*E§arr::3;?;::z}§a.a}:§:}A ﬁrréd in :13': giving him an <}ppQriV§#§11_i. iy' Qt" befbre {he ziccegrtanite §§"'feVpar:.":§'f' and fgremliirzg an order s:~:ir';_<;j'{'§.»§::?:1 AAi::i:':;iV3.fe Crimina} grocteeﬁizzgss agai.n;:3§.h§Vmﬁ = _ {Vii} 'éhat on accsixunf; of" =u:1.if§a€;€raE mpari sf j§'€:_ii?_C:f;§31*Ts'image is 'éarnisheé: .... 3 . .' A 1 {viii} t§';,a{ Br. U S3i::_Ag?:'%vEé%'«vr_€2;:é§§::r?; §.§:§§~§.gai.es that 'i§C":€£"€ is no :*ef€::'::::<:e :i;§'xa;hé.i¢3éi:§§€:: §f1'if<::§VE1"E}€Q?; of ms peéié%3né*.__§:: §f<~:é:§}_<3{§té. _e"f sf {he ':;§3;msa:c%:ens €€f'€rr:;j t;«:3 i;h§vr€'i?3§V M V' V {EXE %12iS""§é%i:<3rded in his; E"€§}€3£'§. ihrazé 'gate me? {:<}r;CEu$ix,ze: 0:: {h€ g:"eu:1::§ are z*:3q:2i:""¢a§:

iA§ée;::§:% _g;afi.:a r§12g »:::;:1i::3d:<:i§c;ns in {he rggesz s;:.§3:;':§:':¢€rj5 Egxgr Dz: Vi? 'J Sizzgh:

{ ' --f;E:s3:1;3:3Eai€~s £11332: éha-> §}e::§§i::e:':€:° no ;., ........................... .. ._ \\\ (2/;v§ii} Eizaé {ha tﬁreé E';

Ehs {:{}I1"§§32:'i§Ei€S 27::'1.c§ i'E1e:*€3 was :30 qaxestisxi :35 " :na}:i:":g f;2*s»':::ru:*.:>11f)i€ 1:2? u:2i'2:::{>z::*21bEe reafgiy f:"(§:'::' i§':s:-;'r- 8:213? €3~<)¥»::>r:1::1€V:3*§ in this mggeircé: izriviéﬁt iihaé 'she Cs{3'a-'€I*I1l3.'}?5i§1§', 0? iixiézz h;~?;::% SSE}? :;:hr'Ié.--<§3 AE€'£ze§i<5_ {<3 zihese §}i:'e{t{<::; §}spa:*{;::":e:§t {>£*7%?§£§;_§3s 51:36: iiE€{}§U§:g"'A to :*€:p<;r*; :0 {ha hégai {he $§€é§'&::

Leave Peiiiien fiied by E'¢'£V 3 Kk;'iii:'AA E"€f€§€f1C€ {:3 {ha l€*a;::*:51s_A éf>f A Ce.;1I;:ra§ G'€)'v'€f'f'£ﬁ}f?fY£., {ha z1bo'«€~sa:i& _.C0:tfipa::__i<3S éhemsehzss :'€piiec§ go i:%é'é" sf .V£$fE§f1es, Gevernmsm; €;f cﬁéufiiﬁiiiig {E12/xi"'¥'h'e----vVSpe§ia} £63556 Pstiéisiﬁ " Supreme Conirf a£:C¥V__?;VZ*12%£%.V {V£1is*;,¢_\>v;1:%; ;_: €> sta5yjH_§.:;:ier grandad by $16 CV§u:'i;:"~ " * ' _'Ev1./'3. Sam/h West Mining iiargzpgiﬁy, :,§S*3§f'S£:€€Es Limtiiiéd and Mgjg. Efiiiayanéiggr VM:r:é:r21is"' Pvt Lfa;a'.¢ addreaséd 4:e::ss~s~'.:c;;g;e;:Vv3:'3'.2:3:_Q,.v5;3.20:o and 31.3.2919, %é3§é{:%':vE:'§y, '_t1::_€ §}ir€:<:":{_>r <35 Migzess anﬁ §€G"iag};§ ":ie':.::':§g';g_ '*:§1;3'%...§:%:£§';~% was He :3i;.>::jg ::>:'c§€:' g§a:i'{€<:i by ?;Ih:2AS-*:,:fp:°é:;:§--._€;::iir%;;. '§'%::s: i)ir§ciC:r G5 Exrééngsse am? {}9<}'§{.>;3;;s;: :32': »«::E-;;1§§§':{:ai4:{>:': sszggézé by 1&2: EvE3:m7si;r§; GE Vi%zE:;;a/£3? "£§<§a:€:*:2m£:1i:%, sf érzaiizx, adciréssgi-iii éhrsé §«::%i%,,»;:"§§ 9:: E?.8.2€1%iG? E§:"é.3'2%T§€I} and 2§}s5L2{}ECi T :::':{i...1_y5'<:>L:;g%:i a;S{>L:%, isggai f:;i;8;i;L1s; 2:}? 'aha $§::<3:f:}Za§ '3;s:g;.a?€ ?€:iE;:;3:é, bué; %:E"1:;'s §f§§EELi£}EE€§" E;;1":p§ic;:t;€:{% " V £23' {"2C> §:1::E*;1 <1? ::>w:";:F 1' 2 i V) km 29 {xix} 'éhzai €336 L<}ka_:;::k£Va1 has :':§d{)"g}i,{'?{i pick 21:11:} zfhoose :m3{E:@x:i whiie e:>{s;:si«:}s31"i:1g;_>; §Tr:s.::> d§3:71:::*;:<%z2%;ss§ whizztét Eeasis 52:26 ':15: ésaziaihxdiz é;E'::3§ {he $211115: E'xr'Eii~§ {i<:3r;s:"~---

911%}; is igzéiécti; ihsz? p£2§££i<me:* in 'size 1*€§}<;r::

{fax} iiizaé ihe :°eg§:is£:"a'ai<3:: E}? 81:3 F'i:':*+si. §:1i'{>:ﬁ:_3;1;3/:;'_{.>:": §?ié;§é:"'é f by ihi'. L{3k;3.yz:k::1 Psiiite Eb? She f_@i'fe;:r..{:€:} ' Sectiozzg '?,8'9 and 1f3{7a}{Ci} rjxv S€%?'i;§i}:fi_ :3(2}»'V_::§f"'V Pr€v€nI:iz;>:: sf COf§"L§§2?;i9E": AC: §Vs.ii4£':a§ge11:

{xxij {hat the p€ti£i<>r:e3r had filed ,TE_'€:i£i'<:;3¢ IE1: E*v70.2§/%39,f2{}§ 1; <31: v _"AV<53.§fEi'é;f _ ~%"}.CCaS§GAfA: H Chaléénging {he pr€hZr%1ir:_::r3 rL..V.u7:'€pQ§'§~ the L0}:a};u£<:£;a, and A<:':;1ri:2gfF§:'i;e:--iﬁcticisézéf/' 'Writ; Peiiiééea as :'_,"h4é iajeié éi'c{;vé§t€:%£...~:b:,r~* HES E><:::=3E§€::c§x E}? " ggéainé was filed and §Ir'€§f,§f_i.i;§1€f Wiihdrew {he '¥'J:'§: :3./*al:3 :20 dscisiaiz on 1"i'1€Fi'éS;! .

{xxii} zhgé the regiis-§§*:5::ViVe§:-__ ::A>'fv S gas 323:3 by iiha Su§qe.%j§§::€mdez:i,' L<}§«:22yu}<:;a§ is: 23.236 bad '§3: V;£'§2'::Vr{r {hes a§§:3ga%:i{:sn, 0:352 S:Tra;'::n h--:e1 sé ::i4f':s;§i';s.:1%.§§ 5; privsxiae csmpiaitzi in PC? 'E'Js;:h;2,-.52§V:' iéisi §}e€iéi@ne2* 21115 «:>i/heyg a{:céL:--sr:%::§..__'{t}'::a§E$:::gi:3g C§c:i:~13{3é;;?fi{:a*:1§€3:"; Cf 121115 in '~.?§:::¢§§§' ihaﬁ. {E13 (said Eamti wag purchased ?:>},«" .. '~;'§E:°§;LR.;z.gha*aJ§::§§a% Sn: 'xfija/yegidra amﬁ 8:': Sonar: §*:Z.z~V;:.%::":;2':i':" 313$ ihé': :~s:2::1:::é was aaid :33 fav(;>:.,::° S€;z:§.I?;. .. .f':.?%77<ts;i §§§i3iI1§ﬁ: €:2:'::§>2i:":§; L:::A:ié&/{E magi 2:<:::?:}:"d§z:;g 1:3 £136 said €.?(}IIE;E3§8.iET[,. 333: 2522231 saiiz §H<>:g;j;«2§ g{1'£%i§fi{72°1'£li{}§'E was; paid to éhe ;>et§¥;i<i:e:':t§:' zmcii 21:: eI:q1,;%.£ry has '@8612 a:*dm'e3€i:

ixxiiiié iéiaé; flew {E153 E,<>ka}I:1}:{2:, :23 z*:s3pa:*§;g'§:s'£::§$s's -- €h2;t ' {}':€ é1r2m:?;a,{:iio_r: ssnizeréd be:wc;:=€Vr: the 50:25; 327:?'-. " s::}:3~i:2~i.aax: :3?' {he peiiiiener am 1316: s:1%3__ha_:1<§ angf3: A ' Szmih 'v'€e:§{; Eviixling Liméifed 0'€;E2:+r vi_3 :;1 gham :';ran,saCtio:1 Vv'h€f1 an €i2qV{:.é.§§? gs p€:'":d; §n'g before the L»<3kay2,1k;:a PG}E':::--t:_: & ixxivi Ehai ii £8 imgxzrmigsibie in"4"ia1x;. féssgj Palms z*egis{;e:"i::g Aime Cass3§. f_1:}r the=.aii{§g.e§"*.::§iin€ and {ha ETR £3 bé=._q1:a3Ei€Ci~; ..

{:<;:{V} thai when the géizﬁd the maéiexx, it isV.. ,%:«3*?I:.;__p€?mi$§SLi'b'1é_ fomzf the games L<>E<ayui:i2§A"VTV}3<>E:§V:%§ 50' _9"::.r;€ asgzaﬁa maké an §nVeSii4g§a7§i{3r3 ir:§'GV'ti§"é§«,.,g§é ' ixxvij ihai; 2:c<:<3r§if1gg; i(:A S'eC.ti«:ér:;-3 éaﬁ E3 {:5 {he K L Act §S.SfLi:€£E'1C'é' .:i'0"i;i:;.€ Eznié haaringg sf €318 ;i§€E:Z::_2;'{;:;:31;:j:,' {%a::ié3'::2;3_§_;2:si:3d is 38 gages 31:26: 21:1}! :I:"€:I':':Ti.=i;':,?":'§_.%'§3€3:?Ed21§i{}?};'[f'€§GE"i,/§}"1§iEEg ssqzzires Ea W E15361" hea:'*i:1;.§ the peyssns : V <::<:sf;if:£§:%m_a~:::§:' A' i}:>?§_:§§'V':[V;":2:a%;V *i.h6~._I,@E;;<z§g:;i:':;a, wézééa éiﬁaéiézg' 233133": CE2a§£,<3r-2i2, si;%i:a:1'::z*:€;:::?,€<E §3E"=i}S€i?'L1'f,§{}f§ :35 231:? pcé;ii:L<;:":9r zzyﬁssr" §::~%:§3¥§§§V(2:2:s :3? ?;'s:2»'€:1i§0:": Q? €{;2r:*21,;3é§,e:: 2":<éi;,

-2»;;Lé:s:i ?};£i'z:'§§'1g;§ reggzrzi 3:': '$336 ;3{>:e;:":;i€;z: £35 . p<:+::§'é§:>z':£:* 22.5% {i'%2.;'::a§ §'«;§§:2%ss¥.s:%z*, é:E*::3 :'€£%{>§*::n1i?°::<iia.%§a:;:1 3' i i .3-..,..,, ,,,, ,, .

but in (2G§8} £4 SCC 58 :§'?C~"§L'v'IE*ZSE'Vi CEE3ENE}§?w¢%X,__SAN'E{E;E%" '. :'5£'§E3 C¥T'E§E%:RS '\fEE<IRAE'2fE CEZ_§z'EE:E\§T j 4' €}'E'i~§E:;¥%$}; ~ ~ {XX::<:'vi§i} ¥.Eé.2":*é '§i7§E€§'€ 33:53 (#21225? {sf 21C':1i<.3:3__ ::3z:d 'iE":€ :'<3Ei::E'" A . iiigiizzzeii in 2338 Seitaizd 311:? Ei,I'€"§i}§%)'€..'?;hi3 v S8.EI1V£3~._8.$§: V' {hes {TQLESE sf a<?':i<::n zmeji ihe :"eii€£' '€.i:1i::;:e{i in V fiat Suit, $16 ssecarad sL1i§:"<?;}nz1Qé'56 {§::;3Vé'iri._ered i;{:%" h83J€ bﬁéil brcmgghi in resp€Ci_0:T_:hg; 83:31:': SU§3j€{?'{'. maizerr 33 iha firsi suit {relied 5:1' 987 {VALLABH :i2gX;':~;_ vsi,""':jR;f L-gag. 'Amié QTHEZRS}: " _ {><:»::>:i><;}:I:1at Wi'Lhdr3.wa1 ":31 gﬁsétifgian unéeg"

AriiicE<:$ 228/2V2?:»~.v§§_;hG::b:«.§;é:;.ﬁ;--§$§§om»:§{0 £116 fresh petitien '§,§Tt""S fé'Av§§f}d€%?:fV 'xi.?§{i§§1 b2:.:_* é:1ch 9. fF€iSh peﬁxiorz En the ~ 'invahring $31316 subjeci _{§':<:.b "§J§98'Z} E SCC 5 §SARG{g1}A 'ifs. STATE: OF '§'REXNS%_1?QR"§ z'~';l9'P_SLLA"'£'E '§REBUNAE.J, M ? '1' '<'Z7%E?s%i.§{}E;;L.;§§'iE £é'§'H%i2F»1S}; {XE} Q83 :§ft£..}_VE§f:{i«.;2%'*--{BQARL'r Q9 E'RUS'FEEE§ {BF 'SHE Egéfé ..f{;s~;+T " *E% <i;~':?zf§B&Y Vs. D§LE?§*§UM£:R V Rfaﬁi/§zi:¥E£?§:*§§€<z"i?~é§;E"E-E NAEEEQERNE A;?\;'E% r3"mER§;2 3:: 'i;é§'::: §}§_}.ig*:5£l."é:»"1s'Ef'§€3E'€i ﬁI1"1'piQ:»J€§' apgoézﬁs Esgaﬁjg é':-<:.ain&::i §,»§:*Easm:£3ZE fa? §I'€E§€1'i'L§31g Eiiéé §}1"G::%£3C1iiiZ}g ' 32:3 {f3;§%fE.'. in éhét ezzqzziry whez: aieiizzgxaﬁni; {>§E"i::::3:"

._ %_;x;2és; 3.§9r%3s'i.€:§ hy ar:2:}i'hs::' e:>1"fi::%£3:: xasizs wag 230$ ,sh:§«%.z::¢: ii; 33% §e;,§;2§§}; §§i'2§§§3,f?d p€?i'"5i~3{}§Z:§, aha €:"zq:.,:i:"}:

% o 'm\\ "

2'?

tbs iiectisisn :3? {E16 €<}:V::V1«:7i§, in {hes ab$$:':::</3 sf sazzxh gm <>p;:=e:"tVL2:L1itVj; af hﬁéifiéigg Eiable is be {;:,1::1:3}E€Ci: _ :

ixiiéi} {2§{)3}§% SCC 3&3 {S'§'§{E'Ei Q? §'§§'§E§R E.Eii} __i Esiizési;-ma §&f}'v15:NE ;i'{:\éi7} QTHESRSE ::;:1~~:fr:€ ;:;':§:i§¥g: ' E35222': p€§so:L whoge co::s:iu{:: is b€i13g:iA_Vnq1,;-irséi V at who is Iikeiy is £36 §:'€§udic::;a§i.y .21i"fé»:::.§é{:1..':>y §§1C§L1i§':y'. amiss :0 sgzsh pérssré '§_§'i':%_g 8. .é;:;€':f;V;£:::

non sf ihe principles Q? namrai }_;;:é":::7e;..ufailxgiaeLﬁ eenzpiy with przénc/ipE€$' fTg3%{ic¢waz:diAA alt-sram §€{f'§€E?Z wouid rigfii an individuai. Right' _§'(ipL?.'i:,VEV'i;i:i{}::":?V:: i<5 a:'§"aVc€?; 9; é::'.g'h: ta ﬁfe' Eianita 3_rigEj:'i' _s::£ :gn _ii:d:§%%d1;aEV'"ziaza be heard? §3€i"@ré ébejiéfggx by the Comrnis3i<>~:«:- . _ is; j:S::.8.}iz;:f<:::*:3},%. v;5V<:~<:i0g:1i§sd: gjxiivg g2<>o:?; 3 siﬁc $8?"{v1"5;:;}€;*:f?«:'«::§i:-.,_§;5.m'ARASHTRA 2.29;. PUBLIC C»§N€:ER3\§'?§>?é"--~<§:33x~ERNANC§: TRUST AEQE} C)':""£*§E§Vi52i'7s}MA = Sf:-__ '§3.%ﬁn{ pasgéng; :5:éV€:'$€ _ ?€fﬁaf}}iS;G'bS€i"€é'{,i'§'}Vi%iS agaézsgi CM, xx/'Em was me: xaxiiheui {::a§Ein§ 22:2}?

V"z:éL§:pE2i::3Tf:V§Ve:j£'i'?<i§';ﬁ2V ijinz did me: me:°i*:1 atoizsiéeratéazz. C{;;:,§i::--':31:é};::Z,iA%§';f: CM 2zs;;§:£':m:é a§fs1*&:§:g _:}p}30§'E:.1::3%.__€,§% E';s:a:'iz*:§ is him uzzazi; 2%: Ssmipissiﬁ

-v._ :'::3§>,'2::ie:§ priraitipksg ei::§' zgamrgzi j2;:s%;§:':<:: Eiezzcsy §*?3::;21:i%:$;' S£éE"iiZ7f§L§'%"f3E§ §}Zi:~75:'Si3'£§ 3.;/gsziréeé SEE :>§€:'3"€ .' " §§"€'.é§§;"i,":i?§{E{§1"i'€{?':L zzznj :2:1w22,§:a:::;¢eé, iieizstziz were: V..i_i,:_2L?;»:%§-': 5:: bi': €X;(}L'§EE§f3{§.I \ 21~m,\'».,:',s ' y ix 3%: .\< < {xiv} {E08333 SCC E3412 [€)f'J1NE§ RETREAT QEENTEEE V9 STA'E'EZ GE' EiE:§{2'3;L.5X s";§'~EI.} €2'E'HE:RS} an éhs §3::)§1":?.; Elsa': {he ;'::§i$diciie;'1 é3.§'3d€fI' seiriizm 482 sf Cr.P.C has is 33% exeycigad :s§:+:ri:1g£j.;z <:a:*€fz¢:§E§; zmgi w§:1--2. ' <:a.2,3§i::s:: aiziy "\R"§"E€i'f3 such exergtésse 1:3 gj;:f;:i§§"§€§E"'3E§:~;"~ aha': {est Eaid éegwza in seztilien £82 iiTS€';b1f. ' ci:*Cum:si;anc€$ uzzdsr which ":r1he:'er:;A " C§:'cum$i,an:%e5 may be €>;e§cis:3é['~..;gr€: {3}:A0Vgi§».g: effeci; :0 an ord€r under the €r.P §€ (Ellie abgzse G5 the precess f}'f"~i;'h€ €1(}L1iEA"'i:'Z ;:fi'd_A {st} i{> Qihemvése secure sands 0fji::éi;fE'C<9; . V .

High sauri, in iheA'e;:erci;=;-eof iiisv x*z:1§§ j:.{:fis5€fii';é*{¢'i0:1 urzﬁﬁr A:'E.228 5:531' §:Vivcst§ga:V£0n czniy in the #3:"-{if--::é:s§"";:9}€<%;r~3-- 213 Cage sf abL1S€ ::;§7 __i:;.f§é5:rigéi::0;:V_ and men- €30f'£}§)3iE};ifi(','€ V;é4:"{>vf.s'*£'é;:;:% under Chapier Xi? 0f Cr.§3L§ §s ciéa;'E§.f'%i:}a;§i€--._§u:,.-'Bué EYSEE in guch Cases, i*§%g§':*:.:;> :;;*; €:52:r::;;;"i;'«§5:'r{:<:§; {ha paiice as is haw ":§zéVi:::*est§g,§::€§_Q:2 is :9 Ezra {?§}E7;C§L1{E§€§§ bu: Car: iriAé'§s::"éE3f f;:Y}.€ absamfagce sf 'iihe garsatess as ' "A§1>;V'<;:t"~'§ﬁ:';'f_§"' ;'-1/Q?" éﬁ :34: Cb :;.:«;2~a :";' 1-mi" §;;_§.z;'é<:;2::R 35% {S R;2NGAN;xR;:$;a:;::»§ _ :~,2fr;s.f:j§:' %i££RNA'"E'A§§A) an 222$ pom: ihai ':»i§E€Z§.€Z"'ii' S§c%f}:{3:: §§}3}{a} 0? {E26 K L Easti, 5; <:{3§>y <2? 'aha {»i:~{:n'1}§'E:«;§::: shgii ':39 iészwaréed is} the §}L§§§§{": _ T~__s§é§V:s*x.?::::*::fg 22:16 {ha {:<;::2;L:>»3i€:1t, 2:u:%:Va3:§if; <::0:1{:<5rr:§:{§§ .V;_§gf_i_::;:*§" :'::::5z§£i:2g§; §Z3i'€5§:Ii§V'i'E§1"§§.i,E:'§g' é?:f":€§§§§i"}/' zmgéésrr 511%} w...m.....m..¢, \ mé%e» A§%Né$& A z €'§§ \ 3% %§, 3%') €:i:'i:me E\§<}$:3£i$;".'i?;Q'i§ £62' £323 oi'f<é::c€:~; zzzzcier E3€3{7?;§£}i}S '.?,,8,9§§3{:§{Cii} r/:22; S€«:%:'_:i<:=n E2{2} cf §1*:'*«i%V€11i§:f§:} sf €f:;:*:*z:;>f;Vi0:3 gxc/2% 1988 ganés is biiézzg i:":v:3s%1ig21§€d. Ezzszve d:-jzzitﬁai tbs ;::e2:i§§0z3e:' ihazi ha hgcé :29 z*<:£:3 in :"si7sn:z::e:;g:1;ng_ {he 'by the €0::<zpa::i€s Eb: mizzing glam; and faveuz' 0:' abzsseé his c>ffiz::e. it is s§aV%Véci.__ihaj:: Ea. V_s{{:r;1 <:?'V"%'A.,§{'1_§::*9;§~eS has been reniitied 'go MKS, Prsrana Sf xviﬁch tbs Chilciren sf '$16 pe?;§:i0:1€r 3:56 is aisa siatsci {hat the chiidrexg and a§j»., ﬁ1'n<§:4._'jééiiiigzzer have récsivéd rsmiiiancss %'2'€§&:::C"fbfe.s.:V§;}':r9ugh chequega :9 their iiEd§'»§?{t:§L19J $23? the Eaw iaié §--C'V'm 313 ?m§ 'S 'F9; 'ifs. Tbs Lskayuéiisu, Bzmgaicsre ar;d:VV'{'2ﬂ'2{f::S is} the prsseni Case. '?h€ cempiaciné fiisgi géisha in PCR §'sE<;,2j2G2E Eats? rc3;;_i4.;<;éj:a:'¢-6 is ziozhimg :9 £9 xvii}: prssaiiii 9356 an& E3036 '£336: pei:.i%;i:::':.

'Erik Z 5-3, §3::>E1i:2;:§g:>a, k:::2:"n€z:j Caazgksai apgjearéﬁg {er §fCvfS§'(f;§:i§§?AA§1E ';?'S;§f}§>.i, 223:3 S"LE.bII1§€§':'%8§ ffnaé €%@EEEii'i'€€§,§}? hzzgs ::m1{}:m'£V ';§:}f.:7:*%:;--:*»:3Sé:~:=, §}ai{E :9 2%' §:'<a:*;?::":V:: Ei'3i:{:£i$;i{>§E '§':*us;%, of '3:?§1§£'/Z": ﬁgs: E s 3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ' . . . . . . . . . ' . . . . . . . . . .. .. . .. . érizii wééé LE2:1i«:e piaifa in ac<;70:*<ia:':':? €% .:»«¥i:7i'": M * ' pz"<}{?<:%<:§2.::*é3 <:x<,;iz2§3iish€:§ E3}; E2;*»J«iL"' "

353. in the Eigjsé; sf {ha a.:*g;{L:m::>1:is a.<iéré:":.=;sé;1 13}: i;:h'.:%_i5;:z°::€::§"~.. V"

Cmmsel for £316 pariéaaa was fGi'f1'3i,2}21iJ§3 {E/ii?.f§?'¥(}V§ii/:15;_'§C?iV:}E'S V£VE3:9"éi>':;1:'4 cengiééraiien:

{i} Efﬁhethez' the is nei n1a%n%,ain;3h}::...(§n VILh€"»_gf"«:§23_n:éi f:jZ£i.at the ;"§3éi'f;.§;::f1.i}:1€i*fs safiiéf é.R?§1ii...9ét:{ion ,2? __ «:i'£>fs::<;is$€d on V 'i¥i§,hdE"8AE'i,"} {ii} W.j}:é:V£?,éz*" 'i;h§ §fé:34§¥:;§ pséézésn is :19:

V:i:a§%;%,a§V§2:1_'$£<§_ " ihs ggmumi aha';

_.':heV:'r::'* .~:; ;mci§E<: §:srsv§:§2i€:>:3 zmdésr "'Lv.8s:%'?*%iG2": éé"8':'2 e{ C3293 {gr Qilsishigiéi A 'V <;:f§;*:1:i':;--r«1E p:'<}<t€€C1iI2g$$? V" §§i§} L<>k3;j;t£§'é,2§'$ reporé caiiaié ~ sazjm W223?' fivE§:'€iE'¥£} 1§j%:}§VE§3;'7§:"'€Vif' L1E'»'E§'§ELi} :3}, Ch2i§':,;€:'~XXV§§ " fai; ;X;r:;':s:><;u:*s%--V'€} is wiiizéa S{?G§)<'3 9%' §'£?f€31"CE'1{ii? <3? E5iC% §€}§"§ §}'1£3€f,§i';' by ébaié .\\.,\ .5 J13./X? 9)/>3<< < W N3 Cs£>1»"€'9.i"Z}i3i"£€:tf1*£L G? Kzzmataka under $<~7+e::¥;é<}:': "}"[2A} £35 2216: KL 5-'§.{%{i? {iv} "§€§1€:i.i:e31' L;<:r§k;«:22}.!:.:E~:i;21 was :"s:?~:<:§::::*€:ci {<3 a::{:r:z;:;>§j§ <;%;§?.E': fﬂ£i'a,2S§:$ {$3.} and {3} cf $uE:% " ;'S€€:ii{§};"§ {3} 9f Sé3£:'é.§:}:§ 9 c:§"v%;_h§": KL §:':E'tf1»*~.. .\ {V} '%2Vh&the:1° gisrima 536:6 :;:21ss<":__§s: ' gﬁ:i{:ié3}_A ' {>121 $33? iizfz L(>kayukia £39: V:?j:g£3:Aéri:3g'a.M_ * . case is: the :::f£'eziéebS'~.,}1ndér._srzzjéiségg K39 and 13{i}{d} :~;a§Fs§4¢:i_¢n :";3-{1:2j2:§ the Pr€v6»:"éi*,3',_e:1 'I 51" ' » €:§5{:3j:*ec{§o:9i' A<::t,£988' atV3f;:26:{::r¢§%;§? 2 x M {vi} vsheiher :h<:~-- H . £:}:*ci€::*I A =__e:::f' v,séa§h;f:ii9:: g:*ai§,1£€:"% A-3}!' 'thei G'évér:§1 0r"'t:')___é:1itiaie <i;::'in':i;n2§§,_ ,. _--: ggainsi the __VV:;>{éi:i.?§Vi'é;f:z1:::;f _ b éisgiseqgzentiy §Q§§_,N0.3§ _z' 2881 fog' '£316'{}§'fF€2'}.;{§C§> §.:%{i€%,.'-~S€CE,i01E 38,9? ami v§?;cii$n 13(2) 0%' ?§l§"1€ §3;:*€':.r"<:::_2,_V: i':'§'2"2 Qvf C<::s:°m§':ie:};": $61,, 1§8S? 3.: éiﬁééﬁxzgéé' """ "E1951 ars 1:212:45: 2:0 bﬁ " ' i.;a.i.«i§si'-=.§ﬁ".?

" --..i_a:§}§' « "_'§»f:*:'2:,;'*é"':>:'€'i€;*iL' " ..QL:r a:':a:s.a:;}'a:' {<2 'i;§::€ psizzis. -is gag anézciere E'3{;:é:3"£, Es; {E}: £31 {his Nﬁgéiﬁivﬁ' E3<:%:§é: ﬁg; {ii}: In éfszs §\§{%§;:Ei§i'i.--"ET. § § E E E<'°*-u Point N0 iii}: in ihé ?€€g21i;1'*ve3.

Pisizzi N8 {iv}: in ihff skiiéizizzitive, P<i's§::i*é §\'<::, {V}: In {he N€ga'é.§v<>.

E3':}i:1'§; {vi}: ii': ;'xi'i;§ir:::21:i}f§3b. Peiné, No. {vii}: 953 pa' finai ¢;:'dt'3If.'-.~ I Paint Na i and ii

15. Preiiminary abjgctions are {ﬁthat Writ Petition in W' in S6 far it rsiaies is the E316: L@%<:3.yuk1:a against {he p;&$é¥.éVé{;tion was wi:hciVraWn uncenéitienaliy égjzd ._ ihe:2:%§"o§ié~_.f;TE2,€preseni petiticezg is get mainiaézzabiég {ii} :h2:%;..s§f1<t¢ :_%:é'-,p%:'£--§';{i@::er has sgughi {$33 162165 cf quas:_:z:;g_ ce.;§;':;:.22;;__§§: ,_ga:e;§"'22..;.£s;:2m 1, FER 2:; Crima M35/23::

fer '§1€ .:::~'§fé:";.<Véé:3.a;:3ﬁ€r;:EE§iE:é,_o:13 228,? and E;'?:{§§if£§.} rfw S6C?;i::::3 13$?) As:/, e:;::*'éhc3v ii'iE.%}j res,:§:2<>::d€::'§:;" E3i§p€§°§f1Et'i§1§€ﬁ'§ 5%' ?9§§€€§ K;*;:*:_:;:1§2é}§a L<}R3.j3zé}:.§;a; Ba:";§aE{>r<>, ihs: §eii%,é<':>n a;::a:?;€:' éizi, 212$ 33$ 'f}12'I.j?'=§:f' 2353:. €::3:':.::§%;ié:::V§{>:3 :::a§1:2{§i22_ Eli}? :"::22i:r:w£2:§:::2b§€ :28 {he I"€3'§3}8§:€ ' _§iiia:eé'%.;::z<1.é.--é--z* s;1=:s:i:i{m 2:2? {jrﬁfii 15, 's2'sf€ havéz peruseéi {he fiié: r€rE21t;i:1g 1:3 W P ?'éo.2'§343{3,f:;G}..E__ {G?££»E§§...:§}. ikfhezz {Eris ?€ii:i<::n wgiéa iis':€{:'1 far Qriiers 0:1 Sri Ravi E3 E'\§.21§k, észirzéed S<'3:11i=.:>§ $931339} .2:pp£3a:i::;§_. :7Qr_if:*:aé'- §e'i:¥;io:1e:: S'i.?:bE}Ei?;,':,€E€i ihaz {he ?e'iéi§eI: f1'12£_}3~~ [£363 é_'isn{§:«;:%.${i w§iVVhdra:v:3, In View :3? {he ssubmégsion maée by {f:i€A~§éaf;?:€'ti '${',I"}V.1€)HI"g iiaunséi, {Abs Divigiam Bench diignxisﬁgvéi-~__.i[h€""E?x;§":%; Wzlihdrawng but acided a ridsr "L11'£§T0E"1§iii{};%éf;§-1&5".~2 ﬁn Sri Ashcxk Haranahaiii, Eearned 'i3;:_1L'§:§*:~ii<g 'shat as an 29§8.2QE} {Egg Writ; ?€:;i*;;i<;3n_ C¥€}V€§'I,'}Qf g"rani»3d an Carder 0? f§);f".'{3?§'SéCiiié%f}§{'€';f1.€i an 22.,8.20.'£1 respanéemi NOAB,/' E'3:;£§»;é;' Sub Bivisien, Leiiayxikéa, /V20': 1 far §h€ Qﬁénc/as azzzder the ? C Lbs: p€'L:;tis3n€:' hat} is shaliemge :'€gf:{$»"_ét::*1'Vr:§ "f;;'=¢;V§?: '..éi:?rim€ §~E<::.38;2€j21 §L ihes Writ §>'v&:Eii;2;_<;i%:' 2&5 VbQiA'i,E':'s:'13%1?isi@:: B61303} if {his ﬂour: fjffﬁﬂ E23 a{idVi.i--;g.§ ra :9i':i%s3;f '*'._Lg: :2é_:;ﬁ€E§.::0na:E}f". 11?". it ggréézgeizé; {=3 :n:":n%;§{>:2 ihai. whey; zézét aggrievﬁii :' §}€;i_':§~f>'§§:7;_§1.§3E;}f{i%§{i??3 {::€}'L'§i'°ES, piezzééxig é:i{3§a%.§c3z: {>§§::::<:1an°:§i:é:31 §:g.§h%;s, 40 View {ham mere as 1T1€2"i{ 3:: {ha '+.?%'ri{; E3'e:éi:<}:1, ii: se;h<>u§e:1 pass 22;:

{>:*ds:32" 9:1 :n€r*i':s, 3:} '§}::;:%; {hes .:2g;§;ri€v€:<:§ ;)21:"i3«' xvii? h21vé:"'V:<7::":1-._ <3§3;::€;:*i;z::1§§§«* ii} iihaiieilgs 'sine game b€=§:;:*§ {E18 a1;>pe§a':;e C<:%:_,:'tf;;. in {he §ﬁSiE1{1§. C2133 {hare is no I"i'}€EfEE §8EE ihzié {he .:1321':;i_:%i*V éé§:iS_"§':éé.£vr*eiE.. and Wham 'zhe Cezxré itams ta} 2: C{}E1{'/h2SiO§1 tVhV:::; {§i:€i'f?'ViVé:S ne"'r:1é:fii__ in :;7'm: \.3J:*it; P€f.;it:ic»::, Eearzzsé C::>g::1$se§ §;'é§*'«§}f2e g§'%5i3;£i:>:}.€rTV§ﬁ1§;:%:§ xvithciraw tbs Writ Peéiii@:1 V:::1co:1diiVi0nai;_~}';'«.x_: 'ihgji fad {hat i'€Sp€3f1&€:1t No.3 herein had ":»:a<_.ja$<3 i'1%"1HCZ"i§Tf}€ NG.3<Eif 2011 fer ihs s::f§'en€§_s Course sf actien was {a disrmiss libeyty to take Sud': Ceurse Sf f€§}1€(E§j{ regariﬁ. learnsci Cazmsei f::rr the relied upar; 3, ﬁscigien :epor:sgf"~.;;g«--;::R zgsaaawa TRANSPORE' $BRv§€:«: '*~Js. _S'i1qi*:: ':?E2;:g§S§3G*§§3' APP§,Lm'2:E: TREBUNAL. GW'A§_}§{}§§ h<V:"f:' ':;?::~z:'§>9§::%;, {hat wiihdrawaé sf ?<:':,i:i0n 'v§iZiE;éi;!¥3%é'gfsirgzzisgien {(3 iiiiééiiiléff 23; fr€3§': §<31:i?;§:i>§1 is aha: 3323953 {E26 '*5sf:'§%; P€::ii3:;:::n W33 1%:iii%,:§:a1az:§ xzsziihg géarmésséenz §3si;i':;i0:2r3:* is €:r:i;ii,E€c% 2:3 {sis aﬁ£é'§3¥1€i' §3€i':§i§{>r§L"%3i'§:h :*$§%::'€::':::;t%: ii} the: fggimzmiég ufgsd 2:2 '%'iEr§§ V.§3Ci§i§€}I3~'EiS fxﬁféifié ass éZ}§§*}€jf'i" :::{:;:~ya:::»:s:,:{;:: if: vizrrw <3? s+;L:V%3ss--::§a.:s:zi¢ s3v:$;:*§ef,a ;§ § \. x m.g<$' W"

r21re:s::i of iiha rare citzzss \»i»'h€f'€ as case sf 2:231:56 {>5 pG'i¥€fE'" af im'€5€§g:::i§<>:': zmd f'}G§1wC{}ﬁ"§§3§if;1i1{i*€ wiiviz £7219 p:'0*xzisi:>11s u;:2{i€:r Chzpptér XE? {if {:12 Pjx" C étkziriy made 01:2. _ ZS. Repzziaiian 01' 21 man is 2: vezjf; p:e<:ri0:1~s {i3§11g: f}:.g§;»Jggazg} cherishes most in his Eéfsx E: is 2: :--?gF;»>s0'§1;%.2;V~:%f:;fi§hi: }e:>f a man. in faitz, éhe whole sxsrcise é:--f§§:iz§:'is%k€s inyiiile is {a acquirs fame, zzams and repu:Aa.f.i:é_r1., Q"f'i'ig§€'».g%«1§§Ch 3. man Qctcupies in ﬁfe is '§;i--£:ré§d§;3§ zaemevai ef the man {rem that G§4fi*:fV.€E uf':§p{:'{atio:3 what 316 is afraici Sf his éazlvééigé 60638 2301 East but rc::pu':;at;i0n is per:%:'a,§§e--ai¥ ' z"epuiat§0:§ Quﬂivsg a mag, '§h6:*€f<:s:*e, {E16 '~5§'§C1€ :11{:;éf??:'5e%;:§.i:--i0i:v,pééigsd is 8:3 Weré 'Eife' in Aréicla 2': Qi':.':§:.§<\?V€\-.CU?:é:§§'i{3fV§3§ §€i':":§ix$é'{;"é§:€V*iiabE€ §f1f€1'€f1C€ éhaé; ;"::*%;ié:§6 2': 05 she sheuié E35 iaiiéza is 21:63:: gymieztééan $5 :3f¥::3f§;.,§3;:'"€ azaéﬁ iéggiiﬁgz '\¢:%§fz§.'§e a §§€3"S{'3f1 is aéézzé, isaai, aqziaiiy £::san;>:*5 ih€ 2f§3;;éi:.§;V::é:'@;: :35 2: §'§€ §f»'E-EEEIZ :ﬁ*:;§i11;;; 22:5 ﬁfe ané after. 5133}; wmztiggg actiém "'33:5T.3;'V'§:€ 32:2 Ei§§€§EC§€S 172?hi€i'E'i Eﬁliiﬁiﬁfai %;1i:::: rssguiaééazz 9%' a ' ' ». V}g§§'?'V§Z2.f)_Li:£%":3€3§§S{}E} mszzéci ::i€:**a22i:31}; {','{3:}"§€ us::>:§€z* %';%:::2 Sé;7G§}€ éiafs'-"i:*Ei<*E:*: 27% ?&'§§§%2%3§?§ .\$ 'X af 1:116 {:{)I}S§'{,E?;,i;2£,§€>i1"g Thzzs yigghwiw to :repu.t;21ii{>:3 is 2;: par? :35 :'igh{_.._§0 iifs, wE1i{%h 2: §u::d3.:21€z::;2%§ :"'§g_;§;221;V g:2V:a:*2::':i.€ec:% {<2 C'/"V!E3E"'}? C§'{§Z€'.3:"§ <gl::v:--:§i:é;z:*."--

5§:~éic:§e 21 3? {E16 €:{3I"1:ES?§,iJ£§lf§{}I."/1, §TE<%::<:e. me §)€E'SQ§E Sfzcsisid 1siep_:€'=sé{:'ii. sf sash :°igh:1 :0 r@p::i;:aig:<:>:*:, e:>;<::€:p': in .2:.:s.<:g}_rci2;V::'<7Vé'"'wééh 4.22:1? pE{}{Tf€ﬁ;1J£'£"'€3 €+stai:>1ished by E212? Evidge Zéjiﬁé-{3} . S N H:::G::>£: vs. 'mi: }:Q§§AYUE{'E'z":, BA'§§_ $5333: miss V0'zV§{E:.§e:$:_:

2}. ii wag a iii: {E2156 ta 8.313 E'€E'_§}§f{iC<.€3 p€'::tii<>ne:* with rsgard to allegaiians, but }:§ai;h the. .?i;§1€v§1{)1;7i§h:¢S::;i'§E}"%=.:{aﬁ€§ is faiiew 'ihff §rinc§p§€s of ::a':;u;';é_: ii; V'ii:3---vzizﬁentian that Ehe amber sf 113316 rspari %§i€ of the péﬁtioner in 53 for éhs kith and Rim Qf éihs gsiiiionsrg Thé s:i ée3i2éi'<3:1V the petiéisner >3u§}p0:"is {he Case sf gaiizigfasr p.1*S§9£Si%§i'; Lméﬁr gectien 482 0? €r.RC~ Canrxjéi.' "i?1k€" :»tﬁ§x'?a§;-L,«:::*~.::'ar::::1éé};'"'i§€ jurésﬁciésn Q? 'fgig made? aréiciﬁ 122$ azég {ﬁdggséiiziiiszz Gf Endia, Ehﬁre is 2: ﬁagrani Ei3ié3?i.3.§,§GrE Q? §::'9i:::é31;3E%:.~;§I_ sf ziamrzﬁ _§iiS>€§C€'.;/ 3%;/aizzisrgf §r<}2riSisi>:2s: ii :3 _a_ :i-73:, {<3 50%;? 3333:; §;%1<f:é2:€: :5; 12:3 m:::°i'i; iii 'aha prséézginazy <;?:5}€{%:i§:>%:':«:Vfazéggd $355 $1329 :*e5;p0n§€n':¢s as ":52 éhe z::21i:1%;a§:s1abif§ié;,}I of "L;""MW"""""'"°w /"M 5' {he Writ P'€:iiVi<}:":' Ht'3I1C€i, we zmswssi' {Vim pain: N:>'{§} and {ii} in th_<:_ nsgzziive.

¢ Point R05. iii £0 'vi

22. Sines 'she matsrriai an 3163::

overiapping, W6 f}I"(}C€€€Ii {.0 {aka up fer (2€2ffi$i§€E1'.€1{,§{}n. V A A H H 235 The K L §§:;1s Karnataka L<s:g§sEaiur€: .'£LCC€p'E,§¥1g '$6 A:iI:1i:1isf:s'aE;§ar€ Refornzs Comnzié-§i$§i_'T' institution of Lakayukta for "p*;1i'§::gV:s1é::.» the standarés of pufbiig administzfaiiﬁiir, b§rVV}.c§ii:§1 1*§bLV inié compiaints against adminiéiyativvré §;k.%:tio;:s§AA 'iggaiixding cases Qf csrrupiiong favsritVi.§;§é VVV'V%ii§ indiscipiine is administratiozi 2:;s' av;€:._%_V;.i:;ery maiiergﬁ '§"::€: gézsssisiaéé GE Ezzcééa x »?:_s33ez2% ﬁiéi 9:: 3813'! ﬂag? =3? aﬁaaagary, 3§85. The 539%:

%'::72m*;€%= i%5;:fa::s: <32: E§.§."§9§%6 2s.b§§i:=i~;?§i:zg? Efigiizzzzéte z ,,.

.<':%ié§'%::-::2_§S:'§:a:ég ?1,<_':£::>:'(§i::;2' iii} $<:s;%z%<:';:: 2%: {sf éhe E'; L .:51e;:é:;§ "'a:is:::'?"::g;>§;:5z3;:"» esonzpiaim; 5):' apéiziazz rssaiéorzissté Lznsiér gab» $e{%'£;i<3:2 {E} emzzi {Z} 5}? s3e::t:{;>:1 gas the C886' zzzajg 13$:

{{7} may :*:2a§<:€: :~::,:<7h <:sr§:i€:* as :3 éhe {:tusi1r:;£§jg' £3? <:';G:r%.,:m«:>,m,s; r€s§€~va:'_:i_ _::::> = i::ves£4:g2:§i{>::. 33 116 2166:1123 fizf' 2?. In :;h::» éecisian {N,Gur:d21P§é3: V. Si:;a*;€ sf ihs i£'£V€S?;§§,8.'{iOf': by Loiezayuiiia is v'A»«§§*.ver and the au{hVoriiy $21331 failow ihge fuigs Egivéfefsrs, it Wag necesaayy fer the £VZ%*»v€V#V"¢{}:11pViai:1: to the petitiener and _.?;9._ ané afﬁizsyd an C:§p€>:'iuni:}; is mg Csmmems an $16 said Qsmgéaini, Thus. {3} arid {b} 3? sub»»s€<:::':0:*: {3} 9f_S€Ci;i@:f:_;§ $0 §;3_V{:§:::§>i§€:d wiih Er: me fiiaiéﬁﬁf ;g>r::sv:d:3§ ihﬁreixz. ."£T3§ :feCi:2§§e:j:"<}f §€£:E§'I1€3ﬁ singicé: judgé was €:0z:§'i,:*r;3€{§ by :..'§}év:isi<;:: 5? ~%'.Ei;~';£"i"1;,. Séarigiim Banah. 213.3 Efiéiiﬁ éhaé; Ezasséztsg ' 5:' am: K 3 Hi;

z*§%.ga§a_:é> i§E€*"~.?Z§ﬁ'§.§ (.}'§§,f:§"$GIi§€q£E€ﬂ€;?é3 e::%:2V::éVer:2§}Eaie3d gmdaz s5%:C*££0;: E3 §i;'A%::'i, prmsigéaﬁg {sf cigmgs Ea} zméi Eb} $5 sazib 8€€;%;§@n ;;.éa%:.éi'<;a»:r2..A',? V%§z':v€: 21:3 be :;t::,>:"z2;2§i§§ {2;iz:§%3 Siaizs :2? Eiarzzaizﬁia V. . ~ :*é3§:{>r*;,é::j :2': E232 2%??? éfjgéi. ééééééaéi. ?§}%:;3;§.:iC£s~;2, f:isn?: E. i.:£':é}'§"i U} CM §§1"<:s:.1m:i ihes pc':°:ii'ii<>:1<:%.:: 1"€'S§§;I"1€d as; CM. He wag C'{}I1ij€f}T1§1€3§ :..:':.1_~ Eiwazd. in 21 mgsi; sshéli i}:2er€ ms mézierizzé §}§€1{?€(7§ 9:: §€cé.:f€i'-.%;:::T ' sséaigiish ihzii; {he §3<3E,;i?;§<:x::é::* 'nag :§f1€}'W'i': any €}{§'i{?i.E'£§ f2w0}_a%' ::;a :i*:éA £Z';C§I1'1§3€%.f:i€8. The SL3? <?h21§§€::*3gi1M:gg graizi G§"§':a::.se::- 321$ ;;.€j:i:d1:1g_ '%:n:%f0:*<3 Sugjrézize Cezzzig Mining £63.39 was gréim/éii 3:: i"2iv:}i::.c=§ absva saiéi a::<:>mp22;nies, '::':3? {ha Séaisé ::1£§':é:§:

206317, during' which gsréoeti, the;§eiiiii€§:fi.é;A'"'a;as_VL'n€§;§h€3::gt Mizzisisr T101' 21 Chief i'vEi:1isie:*. figs Mineral Concessian Ruiés, E960, '::§>§rs:>v;;E" in E/ha':

Csntral Ggvernmerzy any official favaur is ihs {Q 2839 is b€}'@ﬁ§, any ages €:0::1pr%3he::siéf;}.'g 38¢ E'u_rfT;_h€:: 9;' ziéii;§0n made is {£23 Lgkayzjkia is u::d§.:%\=3.<%:€i;Vie;é:;§"~ sf is in Eﬁiaéiﬁﬁ, ii} iiisgaéiiies and irr€gLﬂ2s.:i¥;§=5::§ 'V Eﬁeﬁaiy, "?m'::ku:: and Chiiyaéurgg ,3' .

t:;> E§Jf=2§§§: '§he :*€;:e:';«:"¥;, 9? Lgkayzgkéa 21% N§22 is 0&5; E.}:',{E.'«f.Sir:g}3'$ F€pO§"E; ii; is C3.piiC%§E€ﬁ as "?:%é;;:'V'.SA €:%{§:V:i,h 1%E€s§:, Eifﬁming 'é::€3E'£"1§}&§"1§7 L§:z:i;E,€d". E: 333:3 1&9 {?C:{:l'Eéi'€ﬁG§1 ' %::?:%_:4f:: é§§ég3;:::i_:i:i€§firmzggziizzriééss in the m§%1:Z:r:gg; '§'he:*:':§<2:*r3§ we hsséd €LE'3&?. E' "J I U'! §}§'€'x;'€?f1U{}E'1 ('sfCi<7;r:'1;:p§§<3:1 ﬁcti, 1988 {at ;1n11<:3>s:L::'€--;§E} an ¥;E":::% §ii{:..v:T:>'-fi_ ~. 'i"€S§}{}i1{i%i"§1i, I'€<>.3: Q:*{Ee;%:' GE' S;;zm'r£é{>:'1 dated z3;:1z1::a>:z::*<%~Bf; an %'_E":<:> $312'? sf r<:7s;;;c:):41::§e::'%;V §\§0.«iii amid 2;-'::':~ v~§17é§,€'f'J§1~E'fi'£,«. p<:>::'iia:z:1 sf {E16 §4ZegL><;>:*':V 211 €iha;>1:€:"~Z'i}{§I Q? ihc E*§.A;:;'z:2:.€T21L:2?{ z§,<§E«;::§I::Ki::__ éaieeii i?:'?'.Z?.2Q§} £223: :'~"u::1e>;:m'&--C) an 'Eh:-%__ f;E}.<: bi" '£h& ?fZ;i'r:;f»1V1a1§21"; i,§k21y11ki.22 arss qzmsheii.

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court