Karnataka High Court
State Of Karnataka vs Vijaya Khandappa Jadhav on 2 December, 2010
Author: V.G.Sabhahit
Bench: V.G.Sabhahit
KN "mm HIGH comm mi' KARNATAKA
amen}? BENCH AT mIARwAn
mxrnzn THIS "mm 03.3? DAY 0? DECEMBER, 2816
PRESEWE'
'mm HOWBLE MR JUSTXCE v.G,sABHA;;:;'é§:'V*»- .
Arm _
'mm HOBPBLE MR JUSTICE 3 V p;rr:--':*EQ;V » '
(ZRIMINAL APPEAL No»A:s9;f2pc4 4' M
Ciw . , «.
CRIMINAL APPEAiL*1\E_fo. 3_?G.f2004 };A}-
SEQIIVIINAL APPEAL' '2~I3}';%3.234;'9;.1eVv<}v4 .'§;c}'=
CRL.A.Na.. ;16'9/'2U04 §C}
§EEE§3
STATE ()1? E{A§3NJ5\f£;A§{A
BY §r{A§;A{I} H AT£'x;.C§ E
.7".APPELLANT
(BY :§R:'"Aféé '1§»;na,£i?:L£,«, ;;::>%mfi/js;?;:2j:%:
&§§3
1
\H&fiYA§flANDA??Au%M3HAV
3SYRS ' '
N.m2A'*{AN KHAT§~;::%APPA &}'AD.E§.AV
V. 45YR$*.
?uEAR$®LNARAYANw3ALAv1
'45¥R3f
"zRAMESH§G§sHNAPPA?AvAmE
QQYRS
' ;BURESH
A'3GYR$ H.RESP®NDfiNTS
1,"?
WAS ET?ElNTEN{';'ED TO UNDEZRGO RI€.}()R€;}US iE\/§F'}R'ES{L§E\'a';"'«/"E}T?}§'\IT
FOR A P"E*'ZRi.C}D OF FLEVE "'r'EARf5§ AND TO PAY A .F§iNEJ C)?'
RS.i?3,€}U€)/»--, IN DEZFAULT TO UNS}32}€C}€f} §:*3§.MPLE;Z £M?REE*$€I}NM'EN'§'
£'3"C}E'~': A PEI.REO§I> C)?' SIX MQ.NT§~;§S3 FCER "THE
§"U'N'{E5HA]%'%LE UNDER SETCTION 3045:; EPC. 9.13., 'mg :¢:.;:m:9;;\;:%;%,::;;s_;
SHALL R'i..i'N <I3<jj>N{.ZUF<REN'{'LY'.
€RL$A..Na.. W0/2504 {A3 ._
W3" 'iI'.'§VEE3?_{g
§3§TA"§'EZ(f)E3'§x:ARN'A"E'AKA V ._
BY ;:<iAm<;;;;:~{.ATA<';-1' P<>m<:E " }XP¥3I3'Li;AN'£'
gm ESRE A,:1%.PAT§'L. A§3DL';§fr'3m
1; \/1.km.m .E{'E~%§A1\f :3_A?P;tX}J)i: ijffirxék ~ . V_ 7 ~
*
{XL} :Is:;£*;éA.~:f1r\..1§;i,;<;1-%:£§iiéi:~i::»é§:«*r§;zx .,IA:§:¥%A.:? <5e.5'{_P»"33> = ..
ts: "§'u'£§gf~3%AM §"<;5§AY'A1Q*'§2"«E:§L€¥;L;%V§ 45 Y'E{$;§_ V. 4% M2./§E",s;'Hs"i<::?%.1:3£-£:\:'e.P:*=>A T/WADE;
2 y E ..... ..
' A " ~ V _.~:§':;I7§;2fs;f:E3'?e;~{:'"' 36: f*si§;§:=.~; §?3EE3P€I)N{)1.E2N'E'S§ . M .-M_,;:,j;..«A}:2E R,/'Q5I£{ALAE<UNDEV1L.LA(i%EZ ' jrr;;>; E{ALA.£}H.ATA{}E . {3?3":f E%;§R§ €§f% A Hc>LEy'/WNAVAR, ADV) V .="'a*;%~§1:3 APPEAL :23 FELEZD "UNDER 5j~§E3t';3TZC>N' 322%; 5»: (3; <:%2r<.§:>o{?,r" PRAYENQE TO GRAN': LEAVEE, TQ EELE AN §x'£7>P}EAL f1 11%? EPCT z~?:.m'§ accuged No.5 was; itailvicttczd Em' mzvéng c:<}mzr1i¥.€'t:a:§ the <:>ff€m:<:» _punish.$:b1<3 Lmdezr S€C'EfE.€)I'1. 3048} 'WC. ACCLEMCE N<.>s3.1 to 5 were Saexxtmnceci Ea; u11c':ie':::"g0. ..V'3"3;..Tz"§1({.}_§fC3' im;;kris<):':£1:€23t for 2:1 pe1".i€.>CE of Six zncknihss and ':0 ?7£,€}€}€;);" eaziath, in d<~:fau3%,, :10 u.:'3ds:rg<.} :-:si.mp_1.<::*'irt1.:'p':"iS::.».;.M1mcmfi fur a; p<';*::ia::=<;§ <_'>f' Ehme m.m::E.hs for U161':§)f'§'€7§7}'(3(:?:f§)££,§}.ES*;h51-'%)}.E:? "a::.1m.d::?~;1". Se£.:t%€>n 143: E90; :5.) 'Ll1'}'C§{i';{'§{§V{;3% .;;i5:1::p}€.:._ i:'1":;s_3'r:is=T:$;'33Tm?:j§1£4 fm' _ perimd crf six m<:»nt§'15s z~,mt:i to ;:>e1§J=.gi':'A'i"i\z."1c: {sf '?.2;Cf{}Q/¥¢§€El%{'E1., in C%€3§':»::'LL}é, Eu 1_:z11{§s:rg;<.> SiIT.1 ?;)jk:'--'~iYI1fi}:"iES{):'i"'1*£;§i'%T3_*;f"1§§"JI' a §15<fE"i(".}C;§ wf t:%':2:"m:é m0m.i:1:%; E01" éihe offmzce p'ur1i's1f:e;§.jE€ ::.':1r'.%*<*ic;3.i:*'--f§3e3§:f%:é<>n M7 "EH3; {:2 uncierrgo aémpigz 'i'rz1;§z--*iso=::mT:%11§f:£63: ;5r::",i(:_>_gj§ 5;? six. m<V>:1tI"::es 2,-md ta pa-:;:7,,/7 ;;2.:--§."?sm3 <':f 3:2 :':}§.NZi7%';}{;'--.5 aaeachg"§<v:::....sE%3'£"a::1,11'£ E0 L13.1<;ia:~s"go :ainz'§:.>E:;:
§Z'fi§M""§Ei(.'§f_1i'}"i-f3.E'}E ukjaf' ii.E1.§'€Z'f3 rmim§ih:~3 fm' the <;£"tE::1:1<:.e 'f31,i2'}..F:&%3}'7aEE1,E313t:"_ "i.1'if'1:"3.(ffVf' ;*§é;.<§t;»-Qi"£"'E48 EPC; emd to miciergm ssixxzgaie "i'E'Lf3.§I3Ifi1§:E'$(;.§'eI'3-A!(I"1€3'£".}.t §af.%.'£,"_£3} pemad chef six ':7'1c>.m.h.::~: and its pazy :31 Fine? 23$' 3<?.E"3,£}{}QV t;:=§.ci'£'V1p in criefault, ':10 unC'M3rg§<') aiznpiér Empr'is;<;m1m:e:£'1%::
L"'%"§?2:'~.T§: gm-,*'2fi§§dv {)f:T!;§'3'1';t?€:3 mom tha far the <)§fE,*1'1c@ p':.:mish.a=1b.§e 1n"1(i<3:" 53€<f'i:«'E%T>f'1- I'/"W" Se<.7:E';i<.:2%;1 249 IPC. A<::c1.z&'sa%::;i N'o.E% vvaa "..,:>s@z1t:e:37@:§i<I% Mg; uzxderggze ri.g0:"<?2L:s~; éznpr1§s<mmm'1t far 22 ';::<<-;rr'ie;:)ci mi" " _§'."§;v:j §}"g_~?a:1m 2.mc.i 'no pay :3 fine: of ?5,{}U{}/ in <:i<3faL:;%t m :;mde1r'g:i;: k§':»,gé '\..3 ssimpit": im_pr"isc:mme:0;t :f0.r 8: period wf six mamhss ;fm" éi§1<=: £>§;'f<::1'1<:e3 pxxriiaiiabita un<;ie:' E:3c:<;Eim'2. 364(1) EPQ it wzm <>r°<;i<:*.1"c2e:3:
1.:.§1a.$ all Ehe &aem:t"m<:eS sshaii ram c<>n<:'L1:*rc:ntCiy a.;:'is;:"Z_ t.}_;m.
2z<:<::_zt:~3m;*i were: e.=:m:i§':§e::<d to set-woff xmciésr Efieazmian ;_§'E:
xxrg-as ;:2i::'.s<; €.)F{"§fi?X"€'?(§ thaé; if the .{1?.n€: £;1£'1'1('){11"}i.f...,£'S'*~.§'{f?{;'Z'.§l§'\.»'<?I"'€:§*(}'.',"
e:{>m'1p<-:m=:.ai:.£{>m :3»? ?'2L:">,O€Z'30/~ to bejg3a%.ciA '%;<:.> '*:';hé3: A*vg_§.'£E§_ decaased.
132;" Tirlat "hating aggrieved jL1C§.§.:§iTTi!€f'i1'§:.v{')§V€f§}.%%i;;§.(TT'i€§§"1 amd S<'?P3t€"31"3.Ct'i in1pc)s;6:.d .2.,é:3:';«€A.:{;1 z2':c:£:%;,v1v$A:":%€1'iV [\§<:>.ES 721315; p:"z3£?3:rrec§ C:"E"A.NQg1.2i34/'2(}.{§V4r'Lés€;E;:'%%:i1}.g_ %;§%'.:'V';%%;'<_;L2i'E. him of the c;':har-;3-:63; £€ve:I.l<:¢:c:§.« >:--2&;__v;?z:ai:/3=_~"s"{ Agt{5':;£5f.--§;':iid Nf{'>:?..'i 'am 4 }'1;am:? am: 'pr€f§:1"2"¥:d §:'.*i'§,""£'}-*' Eflg'-"':;E3';.:V:i:*3.1 'éi ,__';1'i_f:i7');f2_ fizydgmem 23.3'? <:rmvi<;:%:i<:'m emci :<;<m't<:~r1's:%<-5 _p:.3,Ser:i:d. é1*g;;1.i.r:é3?t "hm: as»; {hazy h:;»;ws:'. ;«2}1"ea<:i§.,7 saeirxrefi ,m,':¥; 1:§*:{2_ f:='»t"'§f'?5"."("3I."k(",-!i'.. H<mw-:xr<J:r, Lhé: :'§§:.22t<: ha.:~:; p;"<:fa::':"r<30} V'v.<IirL;£%x:NQ':{'i€359]2{}O4VV"'é3é€:§<in.g far @r:§r2.a.z1cemc:m of &;<;':m:::nce _'EZ5h}3{§&:§--€f?d'<.f§:i'}}',§}'ii:,_ aigcuaed N{)S»1. to 4 of hewmg; c<'3n2m%*:L<::dA {he E}.§lf:E:".':§i{TI%:S }Z§{i1'"fiE3€i.1?;1}f)§(i3 m:1c;ic~:r S&<:"{.ie;t>;m 11.43., 1433?, M8», :?31M~ 1'/'W "._"$€E?€C2§T§C}"§'! '§f§'3fr<f3 EPCT and Cz"E.A,No"1?{}/2{}{')4 is; fi2€3<i by the §§§,:;v£;<~: '~. ':-:~<::eR'i~:*i1g Em" ::=m;f;a23Ce1'nct:3E <>f::sen1'.er1(:{3 imposscéci L"E§3C}1'} a.<::<::us~:e(3.
-- a;:>p<:1.Ea11'{ in CI."§.,A.N().1234/2904, 3;» "E."'E'1<;3 z'I'1ate:-:r'ie1Z 'fac%::~3 of Um: (32:38 Eeradmgg, upL<:> 'i:Ef":e:i-1:2 a'p}:3{-32.1323 \A-*'iI:h :"<":fc:1°r:'i17:(.t&% E0 the rank of éhe §:>:;-21*ti<fvs3. bef<>'fie thcé mm} €ZIjfz::'mr": ram: as 3'0Eic>wsa:
H; is; 11:16: (".1-1§:3€'. vi" {her pzr0s:c:cu'€;z;0:"2. :;h:2_e:" (+}a:aws.a.:L:1%<1:fi::§:."T {ci{:€:<3;21::~3a=:€:§.} hzgzci. b€:':':r1 g§r2:a1:1t;€<:i 1iC2fiTf1"E€_'.£'f'f{T}"~€.)}Q€Z':.',' their §Ti::;_§,1<'3:M"':{¥'?3<;> Q:
in $1.326: v§§'§21g;g;e Eéexlkuxadé. The a1c:c'm&sé*:':;¥ iriaci c3§:2}'>'<;>$;.éd,vil;;rr"
mi" i:.h<:: :~:~;2:2'id Eiaw-.~';z1<:&t far 0p<-mixing ~.E§C{"a.1(')1" :a§"i<i>:y;:a i':.'1u T;.'%=é2.;<=3VV"\;t1'V1"l:¥::gs;<;i' arid "
'{E"mr<i3 Wm; tsramity 'ba%3Ew<3_:<:n the I;"f-£'-*}:?ai£§-3z'fi~T~)j.£~":.i"s.l'j $1m:§_Am:;é:"3<':E;3t:m 0:? Eiziéy. %"2';:a'miJ.jg 2:117:51 the &"iL'i€3i1S~.2Lf:i£3£.7 -.
4. it é:t:;.« 5ae zfif t}1é" ;3r(;:§e¢.:1i'1%c§n':«ass ':;1nfi,1r1<::c3 in Ezhe €3C)I'E1§}§££iiX".s.'t'. :£M'§.-l<:%<,'§"I:_3§;x/'o_ :'£{:"r?..<.;%map;:>a%1 t.§3a%: i:2e:% is E11163 T€S.§fI§€7'%3.i} vs:V)§'""'§:<§;éEvL}i§M<"e.;!.1'4V:MV(§j.Wriiiiigey Heir }:e:.ss fiw: iim:;E;h::sr:;«:_ ;':'§e:?z%;a»;1pfg);;1_, L£§u:5sV,E":( >.E»{V,'_ "};'".V3"172;;'s:&<r';-3'_.";";.&.:"1':, E,%1'1a111<2:u" a.11x.C§ (§z:ij2:1%'1ar1:;1. {C1.€3C§F€A1é:S€i.é?C}E.} {ii.1"1.C§.'?j?7F..Cf},' were .Eiv%.z'1g separately' d<}mgg; a.g;£'ic:Lz1LL3m1 ,Wc3E;"k. e;_x':'1::.§ .a;é<i*s::.,::se%c§ had C}bj€{.'€(':Z€i E0 (i}e1;§a1z.";a.z1a Em" having ".z;>3§)'§Lé?»§'}"i'i'7k{i;V&.";§ fi'3.§3 E§Cé§nce to 0993?}. ?;.}f1<;% licgxzw Sh{}§.} in {.119 v'i§i:&1g§c3. <f;§z: '::h@:V-.:§§:§1%ar' <}f crcjmplami: %.us':t., an '23-8-20()}.. at abut: §.0.I:E=O z3;.§fY}. 'i'§:*L1.'k.a:mm Dalavi W accuszed N03, xzwhcu Wéiifai czritunk, "«'fi£';:-'i"§"%f1{;:" 7{1e';'.':éiI' E336 h<)%.:Ase.' af C1£1jE.i.11&EITi&1 and :fs£',art:&?:d ai11'32..':s&j~;i;r"1g3, £\{f%-_V:é'{».«;
3,141 t= .
E} {:}E?,}E£1.t'1'cTi'E'1£§ ;»7m<:i mack: gala-xta. At %:.h2:x'£ time, Mé1I°1&'f§7:i PW" E 1_, Shzskhappaai »~ P.W.9, the <:@';npia§'.nst:1{'. {PWJ}, a1"1.c§ Pxmmzci - .P'{W'.7'. and m:i":é;é:fss; pexazéfiad a2£:CL:s62d. N03 amcl. 5.-18}<:€C§ 'm7Vr§;.__t.{;.gz;» ':10 ms; L%1<'M,::3<::* azéd mid imém them; hm: 8hVm;11d I'1c'}i; 'L"1".§'é:§}i€.'> '"£"§? :m'é~:a:i'te:*, t.hey vwni E0 '{.E"1cér 2:ig:"1l<':ul.tTu1*z-3.} _".~?\2'.<,1iv_3"§%:..z:;:*.:\§% }_'"1::»:.v<3;%"
§<':€L::"1"1e,d &.if3;€.'..§" z1g:"'i<:uh:ura.1 vx-701%. {A£"ac:'r réé%;s,:--Ef1*;'c%i%E.__L :f"1?'<:.§:§3A' €;E§.f',1'"i{3E,.l1?LL1'fE3§ work, 1\«'Ia1ri_.'1:;§"1:% 5. _§',Wf:..£: "went _g.é3JA . };;e33'{i'1s':::.*'. 'm 1E1€..M;:k5 }'.1€38;i'.' 'th<:t= }:2.0u;<3€ of g'}«{..'.-Cf"LiVC".;:'%;L/T:.(:.:--zl' N05 Vé%.x.f"~_2V_ U€'}'i1':'.:§'iE" :=.~fi'1&rcE waszuss me-3a.? Ehe 'E":aus<:2 0f théi 1:'.'ié'1'1Aév, ;.»1i:n_:s5e(;i. Noiéazgi to ES c:a;:1'3e tugeafifaf-.'2AV1:1 Ci'v'::$.é;};:r:;€%§j« Ms:-zzméhi ~» 1%. E. aiakiiigg,E'2;%fi3;;'Z-:M311(1i;"€;}V.£§i' V7.f,E"1f§,jr' £§2e3,* had. ;r:.<>:::u::~;ec§ "§'hLz§<.z«:&mm é.h.<:';: 1'21<3§"1":§.11g>.; ane:§ had.
E§:'i%I"1"£ héégtzj Ei7.u:e1':;:':«f, {§.;;v =6.-i"§'1(#"i E1h<:*jy aatexriésd :"z1u.1{f£.ng;i geziaaia .<.-Jmd Em hearing; éihc gz-11afc.2a., i§h<«rkh:;:~:.ppa W <::;:1.I1"1@ *E.."rmre emcé Nm"aya.m1 ~- ac:(:u.s<3c§ Nuiz? a&;s3s;m1t:€C§ \:xg*i:tE'_"2 '*._1he <:tE.u't>. Sfieéng Egiia-M1, (§~a}z:z:'3£1§12:x, Elm A'~»f3<;}ETfE_§f)1V}E1';I'§§5i;.l:1b?; }£iE7E'd E\!Iar1::thi PNVH 1} went £10 I"é'$S{?'i.'it'3 §§§'35;:.3§§}'1a§3:?"3_ A§7'.W.'}'.3 and 21% 'that ééme, Th%pg3a:1mz ;Mz7idi.k 'V..,'P.W.i§A€3Vvz£%:d_ Hanmn2,1.m:he1ppa1 W P;W.€t§ ais;<) <:z.;u":<1c: .:"":..11'1:T1%~;1;g {.0 '> "é:h<~: "sspsiyt amii. Aucu.s.£z<:i N115 2msa:u.:.iE:ed cm me: he:-2:-:a::1 of ':\e§'Z\» {M}-21ja't1a.:"1a é31I'3.<';§ he ssustamied bieeding i§}.'1juE"if:S aim €633. {:iL'\}\I"E1'3v Wham the a:<:»m_p1ainam went: to mscéue (3-aM§ar2a1m:1, e:>t.h{:>z"
&1C(§."i,'iE"&€3C§ V§jaj,,ra Jadhav ~» a<:c:us&:d Nai, R21¥;1"fl€?S§'3 "§"'2:-W:-:-.2A;i':;:a.V_- 2:1<:cL::36:t§ New a:n.c:§. ThL1L<;aram Daiavi ~« 2;1C;:Iéié%e:€<::i..'_' a1s3s;~>;:.;LE{e{L3 }aj:e;m_a.na on his €",'3f'fIiS amii an .__z'%gh*$i._ E-m:r;r;Li' 'ahu.m§::» zxgad whc.1i: iHamur:1a.:'2thappai, -- P.W§;€> '§vé~:;j1:'----.¥;.Q'um:§3<:¥'::'*: .' {3~aja:":;am=7a, he was aisaaaulteci .fc:1(iCLJ"&§E?§'§..'§\I<}.3 that \wn:1em fc>Ii.1<: astarttwci arid é;ez»:r;f&jV§j1[::szV:§<:§ zmfélfv' {mm égiuz E¥%2'}3{}Ev Th cérE:zs::f:7t§i~~,. bL;:EE0c::}2<:' cerm. ta §<;a'igi12.1tgi H0$pi§aE':;;::1'cA§V a.c:§v§.<:<3 Of me E}c:;{:m:" ~«~ RW. H1.3.'§:>H as iim €~.~3'L,EE':§~£{§"£'}f'}.€§5€iV ht": to 'bszzr givaré ¥;f€i"E.iT?§"11€:i £"gZ in ':,%%s.§% A'£"t.<:w Gz'gjanam:-3 'W»:€£E~§ 3':-;h:Zf1:.<;=::::§ e'm<:;i ;;1d:r1%§"Etc:§ 'ii; ?.W.i M {be <:»::>r:'npEa..é.m1I1'E:
an-'<~:t1:_;:'tT<§ Em: jpc3»§2L<:_(i.% SEa.i§m'1 ancji. E<':;cig@d. the <:<:>mpiz1§z1§ i:;>:::'.'£"<,m:? E'."=Jv_.i'f{% »"\?.«Af'E'iii'): "W533 w'<>rki3'1g Pzfliccz inspscmr', K2-§§§g}'1&€:E'gL "}?*ic;£'£~€j_§;j §.";V.:'<'J"I'1 23~8-f2001 at JEOAEC} }.},rr1. "§I'E'1c:: (">12-1} (Tt£"3}7I'i}31l£.%1:TT:i"i.E:-'fkigfiiti ':33?' E3'.W.E. was grednzceci Em wr:%.tri.n§.7; as; pm' A :"'§j,K_;p_ 1 "
X"
2"
.A«' {r .. éi:<-fr L 5%, {)3} the basis of E:«:.P--"i, F';W.3.9 3;'*egi$Em'<:d ax ::1::.-;:£«:«a=: in Ka}g;;h.a£ia.gi P(1}§i{3{i E§i,atic}z'§ <;'.3".Ne:>.143. /200$" PWWEQ %"@a(E aver £;h:":: c<)m<:*:13:.£«s Of E:>s:{P'----1 $9 the CI(}l'1"}_"§)1E§iI"£E":'§'§"}i ::z1'":<:.{V.T'~.';;'§£'?:;:r adniitiinggg the <:02"rec:€11€:Ss of the :;a.1"m':, $';.E1t:* ;::§i.;£":*L'§::E;'--;%.-zfgézmg :.3.:ff'%:><:~:%<;'.i his ihum'b fi;n§3rc::~3s31Z:fm. 'E'her¢:aft{~'e3*, E:)i'I§Vru'E19%'.§;'1{,LE§l?:j1::%"Eli&'i:A§-{:T.fi;£." T;}x"}.€E FER :0 Likes: Court; as; _per E:;:5LP~~ E;,3.fj. '-:F§,:.€?§}I'€E:1'3;?Efi;'1i?Z 3€fii1k",i 'p.mm'--::é;':(ied t.r:> tbs? sscene of Q.*§f<~:'m.:e é1:"_1ci'aV<:<:L:ss'<;é«::§.V<.,vvz;::*{:"; amt. _ "
é'r'i\fi-3.i§Eib§€".'f as: it was r1;7g§1'£; "Ht: CE'ifiIfl~;£;;3_V:i*'LT3 in Elfi 2953}; at abmzi 7.08 m..::":. {he :~3<;*.¢:nr;--: {if (:>ffe::m:¢:: zsmd; hf; .E3'2:u'z=1:§'E12,:rar:": -«-- ';r3,w1.%:s EUECE »~~ '~:"i.'1?.]v' '_'vE'g.VhiE%]T.'i." p§*<:*.5,=.<&é1"x<::e, has <.'I€§}Z'1d.'L.ZC?;€d §_Zx.;9~~5 ami. "i':<*<..>m E136 :'3<::€:"'m:% <::e'f=fes3:'1<:Vé;'W3-~ :13 E3 -- Stéckg and §\/§..(). E U »-- :»se2.mp§€--: é*n.::;§i.. SE'.:r1i1€:Y1ti%x"}t mi PKW.T17ih Hg:
m*:E.'1:.x"v:'1<?'C§ E0 9:.i'1.F"5 @<:'>E'-ia:<-:"'.:~3'E::%'1}tio1"; z'«m<;é r'eC@i\r€d '£'.b«-::3 ;i1"1f<)r':'I3e:'£;3L(>n t.k"12:*;_Jt:'"'4i7\}e2¢_i_;;i:":gju"2 haitévs%...H\:u.mb€d ta} fie. .§.7£'3_} EJI"§.€?S, E--"fie: $631.? the »re;vV<§§1:é:si.?:.i{.j;3. "1"._<:§"»}'L1<;i.i<:§z11 Mag-§istrai.t'@ ta i2':€:Eud<: the: z:)i"£'c=.:'z':{::::> "'a\..¥.§"§i'é.",.]§.i;T?'3'" {PC as gar E3x.fP--1€% arid main he '[;>£:"0"<?._:-V-,~e:c:i.g?:'d' KIMS H0:-spiiai with h'i:~'; Staff" r:ns:1:"nE":>m":2s. He *.,s3<3~§:11:"€*;i ":52;-12fL<:E:1.e2:W;£~:, E&3ha.ppa. -- PDWQ and Mahade'v:.a ~ QWWB M % _ ;:m:>;(:'§ :L.1.§T'V " "
2-szmii it": fiméz' p'f€3E§f3flC('3, he: c:on<:§.uc:t:<:':d irzqzzm-3% Inezhazce-Au" am. tbs-3 d<--:?e?u:§ ¥:><i:dy mi" {}a1}e1nan as per SEX?-~23 mad 63813:; §:.h.£-: bc3€E;y fer g;>m:s€:. ;m<;>r%m'r% <:>ca':m:r1ati01"1. PAW'. :3 ~- LD:'.K ftagré <:€311<:§.:iCTt':<:d ma gimsat 1"m3mx=:~m t:%:*«:£41.I'{'aiI1z:"ai:i03'}. fixmdammei «~ ;1'1c:>~'§:h€:_1."v.c_J§.f' %f..§f.:é d<~:=c:€:e?1s~:t:éd pTOCiU{:<:3d ?\/.i.(L).€> Shir: b€i<.';r1gi.r'1g tvc;;§'?Eh.V<,f*. zxnd mg: &aa:'a.;'1*;c-1% was; SE'iZ€C3. made? .r13ah.za.Za;" 'a--_ §?4I?>_ iV:'a 'VE.17;z'~:
p:<"€3<s:;<::m:e <::>f pa:'2<:he1ss. He recardzrd 1&6".g;tz1£:€»n"1€;;~::fi;£ss <3? <;r«§.h&:7r wimes3m:5s arzé dL:.::'ing inve%stigé§*%1§{5':3., ht': {;--:«1m<':>_t.:) §<': now Ehai a<:<:':.§_se:~.d pa"-3:rs,=.<}ns~3 were ,5-xisoy"'§:'é3.k:§1§§; 'V"'U."€fEEif.f£1E1v'vI'7';'i. "ism KM./E£:'> H<.3x:%;;::}".':;;.aA3iv Hat ve:'ifimii the-A: s.:(;>.;_mc:' £:1vi§d.' ac§c:i;s§i;':cE' 2%)»? W Na2..ra3_r2>..r}a3 \2v:.a::%:s iakiémgg t.;:*e;--é;'£:zz?s_&%z'}'i<§_A £i.§£'V'.§:T1}J{<?;T2i?E3f]'§; ':a":1dT <M'.i"£E."'{' at:e::us;<-xi p<»:r"&:+::3ma, e1§i.<?§:'I 2:+;:};<:i:':'jsg ':,z*€:_:¢:;:£_j.r1m:311ii". }1_é::s:"L_'E.<?fE: éshtz hc>s3pii..aI" Ht':
€3€'i§I)'L%.'t1<5';€.3 P';.W. 15 r€""?5"'tr.0'k'e€:p xv:-;'£Ti:h {.>V€f.'..'£' aa.<:c:115sa;%c§ N02 zcmzti "£0 p;9z§_<iL'a(:r:: him":?.'fI.c.:r"b§S diséiilarge fmm {he E'1.{i'):5epéE;;:.E ant"? };;.~:':> 1"{'£L'L§2"_§"iE?{Ti V"L«:.¢ i'}h;z":' }_3Cs".ica:*. Stzitiora. (i}:r1 the S3:E?:§3"£rii". Liz»,-1}', E;h<": ..P<3E"Eg€:<§ E(SC'{')}1:VS3'L'E3bI.€3 xfifficu ham a€:cm'npe:mia:C£ {Em eiead: 'm:><:iy aVE\,*.T54V.V1ti'.,¥{.§{.";.7.' E0 5% appa1"e§s3 foamd. an Ehii 'mradjy of the «fie-:Cc%§é1:;<:<fi é;xf;.*1}c_éA%.h€: same: were setizcai undcitr malmzsm" Ex.Pm4 in i;}'3.€:> "';r;miL--s:<3:<'§é<:: of Faickiragxpa ~ P.Wf3n and Pe::ra.:~;§"2.m';51I:'1 -W ]§3?'}v'v'_' 4. fir": am-.2 $312736 day, ASE ---- P.W.E8 pr<1sdu<:€?<ri e:1c:<:i;xsmi ;5€§£i*< _ % ' _ &~X;;:T._3".i'::j§T:'1 'N'm.E:"> -- €i§ur."e:'s.E.1 with his report. -W E?3x.PvE.8 and 3m: z«:.1"§."<3ss;t.ez;§ e:ae;:e';:13:3§m;i NOE: and in'f.€:2"mgated hifi}. r' Xcc.:,1Se:~:<fi Nuxfi Was; e:::><a3;"z3§.:i";.<:t"i by' the ciactm" and pmduced him befearéx t§'V1.§:t f?é1.g:1"';t e-md he w-'ms re%:1m-azzsied. to judicial cusamciy. 0273, ?LV.:.:'}_fj5 v.i:a:é.2i's3{i K.'aLL<u.;:1d§ véiiagé: €~'i}"1d i"c:::<.)rds3d 'I316 t~.e*,'i:i'e;-1_$.'*:=32=::V'c::Vr1Lr';:'«; 'L;-E7 Paw" '1?' Ammd and other wim.esse3:~3~:m<;=§-r§é<:c%'.z"t%ne::i'"z'§:'i;: fi...1v11'_%f}§'; 5staa.€':<:?:mm1t: of P.W;§. Thei1"ez-1i"E;er, he :j:13cx;:¢:?iAv€%€A "pO':«3t::fr;§f5:f.t;é:1%%1' mp<::>r§. gm'-3;" EZx.P,17 from .{?',s;_a;_ 13 xa.'<?s;.m"<:§_' <':§f_:'Ei.iE§«;:e1.t¢ fr'cmi1 P.W.12 :'e.§_§ardi:1g E1716: 1:.1";~]:'1;ii:;3;'€EV§§'E3uSi1&3..iV1;:tT{§'Rb};{5'.ik3{,L 6, 17, 'T3 emd TECE and 3m.'1t."€:;he .:§éi;2;l&:d ef{r°':j.cr3.@:~3 f€;§i§' <:.thc;r:cnia':a1 m:am?1nz-1t:i<3n« H6 'mCeiveti$:§*':.e"sk;.:.ch of fihé' -s3<:e:w~: of of;£'e:f:{:r: fmm P.W.D9 2-n.2'£;}:1'z::.>:ff:mi:'Le%e:: A'z7if1'L1-- .§§E1EiEi_§.§if'?€i§ <§'pé.i:';§'%';<§r1 0%' ii;E.*3e:t Métdéczixi (T)f£'%.<:e:erz"v:§'.'xzV'.'L3 aiuésfirg V\,='.-rh4€':--:}';{'<':w:? 'the: injuries; metitmtfmci En %;h<3 ;:=a:3;<;£:r'1+:<3r"€.a:3T%:'*;;:<_ 1'*c;g<;sf'é.._<:€,;m:'<iEre <1:a1;1s€.C£ by 'f\/19.1 {<75 ':\/§.(_f}.':.":"> and 2:1'§'iier;'§c:1(};1":'1<":ti<i1m étif thér inv€s€;.iva.ti0n i§'1<--: ffied c3'1z;:1:'-r<~r smiseéi V"25:ga§§;':.Si.'*Em:'z:§;:c:uss.@ci. "§'herea.fte'r he reizeived time <::b&:n2%c;s?& §V<}1*: 'ar€p?<;rt as pm" }L§x,E%2O and pr€>C§uc:<::%<;ti the :«;.e1;n";.q2s 'E.):<:-';F':.n9€3 ':::E"{€:§"t::t(:;f.3:t.F'§'.. Since ihfl o§'fer'n::a: Tu/S. 302 PPQL i$ maalviss %:.>3;' Mix: €I1.§<;;surt wf Sm-23310113; the case \>'~J'é£iE.~2 ate>mr:1ii;§e3CE {:0 théif Cznurt, Dharwexd amci m1.mb€:reci as E-RC. N0. 148/ {)1 ._ V'?
cE':ar'g;;m W'é'i.EE% fmrnésci aggainaij {ha ae";:c'ussc--:d as pm" t}1<:7 ailwzrfgc :€~.:i";{--.:z;%%: Eh? <:a3mn1it;:.ing the off€21<1':e:~'s 'L1,/S £437 £473', 148a, 324% r/W S363. 1493 IPC anti $386. 302 E"/"W §%':<3<:. 149 a.::{t.L.:§:?»;<*:d p§e;*:aé1C2¢::<:i net guiitj,»' emci {:§a'1mr::<:i to "E33;t::*'i€%€§.§_'--..__'"£"';r':.§:
§:'.?:"(f.}E3€f('3'L§€§.O'£'i in aprdcér £10 brirlg; Emma g.:1;£iE% »:?;§7.,.ij§*;:::3 '£:agf<.:1..;5-;c>r;i"
¢]:3X€i'§."E"1%'i3€Ci m-*iL:*3<:sss<:s; as per PW. 3 $1.}: P,W1 '£j§n.'C§_ggeifi.'1'1!"3&§§"§{¥§',C1 c:i€;>c:L1.m&:m';:2; as; per E2x.P."§ to aT19:at§, "P;/E'.€:','; §}..t:;':§ warm rnz;ir§<x:'d;. (fjm béhaif of 'r.':fz:<-',*V'VL'?:2$:,§<;1,3_s~';::;*(1 " f.{.>:v.V':E34éi:':§x\?:3r€7 gmt m.arE<:.s:<:i E)<:'§n§3; "£'.',%'w :"<':~§-rT:}{':e:..rL_1't ,\ §n;.'.Sc<:r. (.i';",.P.C. ss%;ga:.é;,e3n2<:n€;; ;;e<:c2rd<:%:;i£ PaW.'?', E3 amé E z":%r:<;3i)E%<:E.i.xré;=.Ej§:5a-L%;:§:f mz;n"1<cd in ms:
{T:€;%1"£'E§;?:§&:?.i3:"1§.7- ., R' "
€'>;'t_ T}"§€;i"iIr é'.:V ~.s':i:1.€1*;,E;¢ (:2{fT'EE}7{£: excqtused as/S f:%E.f.% C.r.§".C' r::é::»:;m":k:d.. 5£"'%*:;:':'i ai;i.t:ft3r1C€._{§1"7:§'?i;ie z:=s+::cL2.s:3<:i £53 Ekazit €11.63.-" }":.a\I<3 bzjctn fa!s::5E5;_»;' %.2*s%;_p3V§cz-z'Le:i§:i*' ;s:_1_+:__i;:;}.*:€§; have imvm" 2,*Lse:Sér;.m'E'r;<*:::i {':e:;V;'z2s::[:z41z1:;:. <:>:fV'.'E'3',V'}1'.é':~?»,f:,A %T?:.,V "'?,__ 9}, if} emd: 11 and is. was 'shat (3.::j2:r"1e1'n W}'.1{"_i vs;<a:=.§m--.'mam."ji--h.<fi :=E'i{.)L1sat3 {éf A13-Nezrafgezin and. a$sau};ts:d N}a1.:'e;13»'2a.n a'1;1<;1"<>tE1s:3r:%i' 2-mzi. a. c(;mp'iai3c1€: has b€"3f:'1"} '[7%i§%d wh%C.h is ' '_¥€':'F'Vfiv§§f;{ in C2"'i.§§3.€3 N0. .1.4i2/OE "by P.W.1'[:} §'1ir1"m<;~:1f 2,-1'2:3:;'§ §;,h€;? , m.e:7:<j;:,1';<3<s:{;i wmi"<~: mm Ema aggreat-3m":»; and. it, wafi P.W.f1, {L3, '7, Q, $§§ E0, 13 and Gajananzia who *:w:1":t e:m<.i caused ézzjurjy Li} 'i::b<t--:
E.E?;€3{i%}E%{i?iZ'3 zg-.1.:V1d mihez" wornen f<;>§i-é; of the zfazimiiy zmd a<:Cwr€7Ei:1;_;>;1y <:omp§e21iz2E has; '§:><;'s<;m filed and 21 Charge ssh»:-:c:tA was fI§§_<;;'VL'3,_'£»}£I}Ci c<:n':1m.i't€;<ar<3§ :0 %';h::~: 8€:$$i<)nS Cm,1.x'£; zsmd wazss. 1'1L::"n.':;>¢féé:'<?l'«.é:§.::i I Na. /€32. '§"h<~: accusactd cifid :10: Etzacfi any ::i_cr:i.'rm:<";;V&;j €.w.,5:i'ci6;:r'1.x::z:%"
in i7%12'$ ~:::as;v:;%. I*:E:;>\2x=m:<:r at {.116 iilfiff of1"e<:c);"dé';:gaia'E':{:%§71i'cé.s"n1L1.3. f 33.3 (3'::,P.€jT.. €;'.€?>pjJ 0;" {he REAR. 3:2 _Cr;in:€;--N cn MET/*f;--*Ii. ::4Cgg;.§,is:a€:€f::".&i's:% by P.W,7£'£3% ::2.1'"m§ Wc}':.1n<;§ C€fU.f§<3é"i"'{»®§'» Of A1Z',.._Ma:éj'E.1A1é:' \&-"ifs: Sf i:§L:2":3S;§'*:~/XE}, Pa=':rva.Un§ .v§*;iV;c3 \f'ije§y7M¥;_ :,-ind L£l§§.¥5:E}fiEi W'/{L} Na.my23n%%2, :~3<';.:€m;% of 0§'i'<»:mi:<:*, gfialicih;a§:.--uzfi'.n<%gz::V ii: {haze sataiti $2156: w'er*€::' pm<':h1<i'.::%d., « v '"§'}";<::"t.:?i;;:i £i€3Lz3' €._é1';'17?_;m" ;:<i:e':33iC§::rir1;g Ebert <:c'3m'@:'11;:i<'>1"23 (>5 the §Ii"3é;1I'.Z3.<*'.?€§" PX"<T}S§;'Ci,-ié{€?FV<"'E:*;§§'§3C§,%£"iI"J,g €01" the: §3[£.':L{.fi.? éI:':§"Ed Ehczr. Ee.:z;zr':"z«:-3:?m'ur1'Sc*§_ V;;1;:;.p.a?:»azri.r1Ag"'fi'<3;* accu Semi and afmr 21 ;:2;;}:"§::<:é:¢1t§;2g '<1ij§':<=3 "._,.<Z):§'"€15'..'l""~. <.ic3cL{:*:*i':ér11;z1r3r <3v£.<:h~:m:<~3 um 1"€)<.'()r'd, E35; its ,_;§La.2€Ié::r1i: 2,3.08.20()}_ pasgeci the %:'n;':>L:g:1€<;i. jL3.<:§;;,>;133m"2':. oef Cf_'>3.'i'S/i€Z?§L_§{}"i."l" 1:51:16 :%.'('3.E1'Lf:'.?3'1Cf:? as; I"€i'.f€.E'I'€3€§ ts} abow. We 'h.aW;*. hezlrd the '[<=3a:"nc*.d 60111136} eip;><3a:*iug far t'Eiv.g3;*~e:.-:.f:::us::s2d, k;*.::'::"r1t-":d Additional ;":*3ta£:3 Pubiici. .Pm:~';<3<%L2.E,02* 'liar E E7:
"é:.he.=. 5931;;-M6? a_:'1»::3 .1*cpE3r 21z"g;L11'11e':r11.:s 5.2": mlch of E"ht3:a<--:: €:i..-E:.',)E)(fiTéEi.E.3fi;n He::2v.i1'"1g r<:;;{a:"d 3,0 {ha :;:c)'11'E.<;:mi<>m; '1V,11'"g3;e<:L fhifi ;3:.'}i.n'€'.ss V{2"i;:.1_éi 'zmséit f<::x:." QUE" dfie?m':i1";a§.ion in Eflhziss .z1;)pezi:E am:
1.. Wheiheg' the finding of me Maj V accused me" 5 befare:-'E?%'e"*E3eS§3é{;mS L. appefiani En an. A. Na» ¢':234,;:}4..sag»sasn_§+nt:é§; ,,.,, "*1T' ma offences pun§sh_ ab£e LMS"'--143, .
324, 304m) 0? z_P;§]'*~;..s gusésggeg' 'asrfcaféisg Ea':
interference in this ap;p;Véa5_f?"~.._» ' A H 2" Whether Ehe§_4.Sefit@.§7ce;. §Asfhp.Q3$:iA.upQn accused ma" 5 in Cri ,?3x._'!\§{§;~-.V:§"8'Q/CW5"'i§; fif§adeqL,ea'ze 9:' ca£Es*é--:3;'enha'hti:'ar%ég:*r%':"?..:'L.._ V
3. W'hé£3;:¢.e.aé} fbé--. «;u€1§_gfhes'§i A._0¥f" .:é.'Cqf;;s'ittaE passed by 'é'h1e;_"--1.t}~'i'3;:7'-.._Ca':;,u%:.--__écqv{;:téé'e'§g-M to 5 for me
-------- "a;/S-. 3'0?:3, 550%/2%.; Sea -349 of EPC is Z _ _a r':d: c;'aE%s "far inéerfezrence in Créfi A 4:}"%wha:,gr,deri>; '
31);" R?!'/"C. "a,_I'25~;\.w:*.;* {E33 §;1bmre p<)im.:; as m1<:im':
v§<}§.§§j"£ : mcégmemg of convéciéan gagged by ' " I ihe iriai Cour? %s gustifled am dees not cafls for interference"
AA Eifiéméi NGEE: in viewnfourféréding on paw: :30. I this Semencez imposed is; justified 330$ a9?/5* ham §:.>e<-:3": flied by the: <:oz'r1p§a.in.m11; being aggrie-ivcztd by tziu: jL.2dgme::n'!.. mi." aitquittal passsaed in the: said <:a.s:~:.r:&. L63;-;'z}"1"l€i£"} c.:m.m.s>3Ci :;»H;sbmié.'t.<é<:i 131552.? ms: rsividc-mce of FXWELE, 63, M}, ami 11 s«;mf'§"m"s frzam c<>m:radi.c£i<'>ma .r:-md 3:I§"1p}TC.Eb333§)i'1'i'Ei§§§$..,.§B;.Ii*C§._ ;:m';>se:';<::1.1i:i:m Ezag zmt pmv€d ?;}'§.€ guéit of tile: €'3,{3(..'L'.i-F--'>::t§3'~."§b i1:"2._I' §}.avi.:1g £'.€)'f§'NTE1i'L'?€5<§ 11.3%: (.T)ff('31"i€.'.€:3E"5 U. £'3;€;'<¥~A.{.11) fjzf AEPQ', <mg;i".m: tr; hav<';: bmn 5-3;Cquité;eci'<.:f 'E.}"1r::":A~:a.ii§ 0.i'fe1::'1"c:éjr .<;g{ E':a_';§xriz":g;; _ {T?<;"}.1?"I'.£1"i"':'iEf.<E'C§. The ME.1"éa.§ (.7{.>L;:2:'t. g a.?e.(:;§§1i1i€§._;£:€)*(%:: $31.91" %:h.«:=: m§."f1€3£'1<':&3 11/ E3 £302 {PC '§"1<;>i§i'ii~.:_1g «$3.91.. c:<>;1'§:{;n.iE.Ec:{'1 ar.>.y' <>ff<é.°::n.<:<:2s&3.. if} am 523.: as if. ;fV§3V§:§;iA::'s }aj2'az3.2.z;£2z1 &1i"}.Ci itauseamggg his C1,€;?"é3;'t':f"2A:..J :'E"§€3::.§l,11T€§.:i';;€1" e':sv'c2n :;m:~:L1.1"m11;<g; ii§3:«1%; 1.11%-7: §3£"€L£E1<?f(i";.'i\i3SjC).¥1 'E3as"p'iK?%ve'€1..§;L:é'§.f{ Uzi" ihtz aC{31J.f53fi3d my fox"
haazvimgV1v._<::::::'rr;mié;1.Ea:*ij-..«j}:§f<i1'ié;::A '13. LECM-{1} (:25 {PC tin": rI:§€;m'§;(t1"M':€? §E'1"1§}€}'55f'3d. QS.4'€?:;5§Z€Tv€;'f:3sVu'§%'§.V€'.i3L1i'£§;3."'_."j.hE: SEiE{'£1(;'; may' be ':"<id.u.<:{3d. M): {hat 3<:n.;.g§z2{:a:A.;3:::ri.::.>€i~ :+_131"e;=ad§.* undergcéne as actcmsed rm. 5 we-25.; 1&2"; '€:7L3..5§{,{}C."§.'y"' §';L}i".4éé.i"~;_Efjf;'E'§.(3C}. of three :fy'{?€i11"S c'm@- m.o::'1.i:.h mici 'I23 ci.23:3Is«; '.i?ue;"-'i;'e::%.g.é>;.;*C§:;_ a»;2i: (::i$ed No.2 and 1ibes.*:m§ View may §:'.><t E.2::E<:s=::rr:
Z"€3g€{%'.¥'C'§i}'?;§.§ ':;3:.1:~'§ §;>1.méshmm1E.
ii 1"'. L<2a3"r1ed Adciitionexk Sfelie P'L::131.i<: E?':"():a<;-:s<t1'1L<;.>;"
that '{.§"£f§ evi<71e1:"1r:L'~: Git" P.W.}_, 6:», 3"', '£93, £6) a~m.<:i 11 fig . H ms: 7iii'}"}:_i,};v3'°.F.-'.f.£.'i' N C<)g§':'n'£i, CO.i"1SiS?I1€:*.£'1'fL, t;ruthfL11 and 1"<31iabit": amti '§hi"i':E'<?.'f{}1"i"i illhfif a::vi<:i(~:m:@ a:iea1"iy preveés beyomti ;:'<:~a:~;;<}1'1aE3i<:3 dcxtzbi, £§"'xa.s..ii n.<:>'E' 0:<3§§,r A53 but a§.=sc> a-iii t}f1t': aoctuseed Z to 5 ha'v<=:- {3C>I'E'1ET;"i'}D.€;.tV€13'(..§ 1€:1e3 Uff{'31."1€3i'3E'~3» §31.miS'na.b'E€ L:/ES 5392 and $04 IPC a1§.s;c>. t:}:{:' mffe3:;.€;:<:=S [hr w'{1§<:.}'1 th.€~:y* have: be<:'.n_-'<;c>v-n$;%i.{:':.'£L':{i «:;9m§_i &"se:'2L<::'z"x<:e 3Emp<s:~i;<:<:3. ugaiim A5 is Vzyz-*7z1<;a.3;.}.y Z ifiéj(i§.C§L"TE£§'Cif§"--.A_ a:v1{:'3. 'i;h(:%E"€f:'f<'}§"€3 éjhest :21 ppeiml filed by iht; .$§'§z:1i;€V'::<"_w;e2'§: '§::2€:r e:ii'(:w:':d ;;m;;;a e-iii ihfii' £N':{:1,1§t'SE?d may be cm1vic:":ed "Vim' havtérig (i<)i"§1r$1§i§t:iir3:i %7.E1€;? {>f"§€r:£MM1a:<=:s3 11/ 8 SH}? Ekild / w_'VAS<*:;:V. i(":»~§fi71PC a!c'}:':,g2; vziiéh EEK: _:EL1.&§'§X"37£€ff}'3.'i. 03' Ccm;v;%<:tion 2-mc:§' :36-311'mtice):"21E:'<:%gavc'ij»*~ ;:)a::::-Asmii 'i':>§,«-" ihe trig} {7.',<:>L'z3.*"t.~ 1 2h W(f:«','%1fi'VE3':.'CEi'lf€5§:%_1_.}E}7 c;:cm$;id€:"e€§ "Em: <:<3m<+r1?§?'i<.>1"1€~.; <.>f Em: §e::z;11":*;«!-;~d '€3{)'Li{¥S€31 "<3._2:~ii'";'m.=<5' fear the ' :;-1rE;i§:::--§. it ckrezz' mi sc:rm;TV§z}y ztxf' 'é:':%?:§:' n":_2i~:;v::ri':a1 E51": r<3<:m°d ih:«.1t the ;:)r<i)ss@c1,:Emz': is; ~._f:*::~.'£};.1€_:'"i§g :f;zp<i>n this e'v1i'{'2':=:?: m6 {bf PVW. 1-~~£:<3n';pEaim:--1r1A: who i$ aszfim "'W§:§'E"£{3S£3 and Pwwsafi, "F, 5-3, 9, H who E:.§.l"€% -me i£3'.Vj'7.'.i3'"Vv'Li'.{.{ ejg-*€-:"aIi.§€:f:es:\:¢:$ as 2:350 PDWTR' who an s:y¢2w1?1.:AA1e-2:355 to 'E;}"1.<*: émsitigént and raise 9.1: the e:vi€§e1"1.cs;'. :3'? PW}? Wm has V~ *§$s1i'e.d wzmmcti <:€::'t,ii'i.cat<§ in '£."(;'.$p{i*C'€. of (}ajzma.m. axnd §74'.W'. 13 1/4;-firm 1732213; C?€)11{i'LECf§€'& p0sst.m0.1"t6:m 6xa1:11i:1at'im1 v»*%':Ea:'§'2 {,'.§t%£?£.I'1_y"
ix.) {}€3.£3(} p.;z1'3. P.Wk £1 Mz€:2"L:ti has é?§.§&3<.} ssp0§<:.e.n 1:0 abézui"; A? In 4 e:?bt.1s%ng Ik/.ia:"L;:ti an tile gmund thaexi: Czaaitlée b¢':}(mg;i'n.;;: to }"1m1. Eiimre s~:tm.y<:::;i in the Ianda of A1 :0 4-. Has: f1:s:"E1h.c:31"
ihat a«::<:usc:ci staflged. £1b%.,'E§3i}"3§§ Marutgi. (Lin _s:si?£:*'<';'-%':5a,';:;--..__:}:'i:i3f2 C,W.iE8»~E§}1@1<happ22 came: E0 thtsé f"€fE3CL3_€3 Q§T..,1\/§L2=:xjL:'E;i§ ._ A2' a:~:;sse:m1i'.<::c§ Sf'1ek:§'mppa>.1 xivith E110] sLi.§:§<:j":m' _'1&i$é--..*1:3':;§<:,§s:1A' é7§he}{i1.2:a§>pe3. £1:-ti} ciawna (M. :'~;r:%<_~3i1"1g; 1;--?j1<-3'=53:-1z"n<::.v-'§?ai11f:s&:1t'Lazici (}:»1jaz.r}a2n:9z went :0 z"€:~§c;:1,:e: of V 57% :T%:§z,.m:-:{~;}"'a e:1Vsa:%a3.u§-ze:<,4; C7:a§212';'§:::1;s fl am VA:é"£Q=\g--1.(."§. amd £3-.:1j::me11Am sm:;t[23i11e'3d b1.€3€t'"1'iVI1-§-_'§'VI1%§V{J'%.i§§S LE3? 1..'m=:m A1, 3 and 4 Wiih :i~;':1.E€:i«< aim his }"1€i£.-¥.C§','"£;%f;'€"'V€;é*{'; ::£}I;;% at' the vm:1.'is;t' rm:-rgicfm and Q')»K1: '._Uf"1~t'."'.= "z::.:'= ¢ E):-":1; $1.9 Eeéfzp .E£2g_;' i""£'§1'§3S'$<iif7, p.w.€'I>»-- .EE§.:~u"12,1mamt'§i:g§_§§p;;a, ' _ ii--Maruti, P.W.§«~8h.ci{£1a2p';72a:, V PW:I_§U¥'}'§?:ippazimatat that time came: {h€:'}'E;' zmd §;.h:3:__\;" xarsrzw .5-1i;mg bc':z.at:3;z3 .j§:>§jy--..V'£he.5 accussaci. Ase: swan as C%a§a1mi1;t1 R311 ciowiz. L}"H;'_. "é9_1,1.$::«E'i't:d3"~v.L_<;& him b{>c1i'§V. His; "'{&'ifG Radhavva, m<>L§"}.¢:'r <}ur£Cf§.e1vs,.:_::'amii .Parvathi.~tE1c~: wizfe of {}aja:"2am-1 C€?d.'1'§€: t.hm"<: amd i'}.1a7:*7yf' W61' "r asssz2'u§*£.ed by Laxmi, Mam" L§1'c':2., Pa.-:uf'v:a1t:é a:z.:":{.i " _ i='£a;m:-,*:Ea1vva:» '§'i'1:3r<2ai":'ie2:" '}ajam'1z1a. was; f:ak:<e1:'1 E0 E<;:::ia'a;_;}1ezt21gi §:hef--: witm":s~;s, nc:£:.E1it'1g specific: has been 67£icit€<i us <:i§r::E";:;<:}'i<::v'é3 tiw a'*:t.7i<ti<:*.::'t:<:a? rfitgaxreiing the incidem, thaég mak plactafi 1'1:-=:z:>..r t.:§1<:
hcyum'-3 of A5 mat Maruti had gem: to '{.eathm* the: bL3.N§)€;»§L§$;'.§_§] ihe Ea.;".:d.. M: is alsm ezéiatitéed in the cross; exea.rz1i:1:a'Lé_<§i'i'£E:=.:;::_..__i 1;' is 4 . iv. k# m;»t i::z'w:?: E10 SLEC7g_§€S§ {hat C}2;ja2":a:1ez was %'10.i;~~~-.E<v.éiE%E:£'J'§f1'§§: .«:0<.:<:v%"
.§*z<:.a}é,}"x. ezm '£h<~:: ajiatxgr ai" uf§'c3:1cc% as hc": @215; (_.'3}")'£;":i'Ei"i".§'3C¥ ,fEbr1?'_ $"$E'5");'{}f'l.:&Z.QiTE: A' gm:-§.;L:;;":H E1; is; zmti {rm} {.0 azzggefi. Q26:
ssL2§atz--1éz':&3d. emtatétexatafi é3::ju1"y zmd' z-:2 2'-=;H}*'.V1c"i §;<-5:
h.€E2ET~.3 '€:.:::§<.e:1 c:2r,--"zEit1'§<-.?:; fm' g§1flé{;:_i_11g Ei3T1C:3:vv'*'f;3{);ix"i€i of §;E'1.<~3: 'Em'0t.§3<t:rs:; §f:a.d £3l.<';',(3€)i"1"lp€iI'1§;3V%i-'-' ' 2*iV:1ui~.:_:i*iE.:'V'~r;»¢:.I:a.'£.:'1ed én me: ?3?0'L::~e.::: and t§).;;.i«*?;;:e':- the i,m';%ide:r'1t w?:'};i{:§: E16: h.2":;s;"Vc§§:f_:ai'§;§<:?E tZi1a.i; he haea :3;'1;.z~::%,<::c§ A53 a."b<'>'w;[ 'a:}:"".v2.;-'.: "'1Ci.£7§{?fi'f:: %:Ef}Q33)E, t.€:>¢i;_i%§"§3£ai<:<v: in tbii r":1tm1§1'3§:>; wlmxis N23 md <.:e':>m<:: %:i:a__E:.1é'w;§i1" §."1<3'u..3e .f0R* Etlrzch and ét.E:1ej.r had. e',--1dvés§~c§ A3 a+2.§;%3£}." V A IE P_.FJ$'.<._;2~Es:aap'pa is a pancha far {he i:1.qu.@3i'A-wE*IX.P.;2 é":"§.¥.?a€T'§'- ':'].§;i*. "?i*1fi%;~;V,_ £Eé;:;{Ss<2d abow; thfi 'i.E1Q1li€i'S1". €3€}E'}d3.lCE;('3d. on tile? d<:a<'é'~«..b<3<+i.'g},L*'mf7~'{3-2x;Lam3u'1a and 11ot.hin.gi has '§:'m€:n e:ii<:it€:c;f in Vélm §:iw:i;<:r§;x:; 6:X;?~.;r21i.na1;%o3"2 €10 ciisbériiave his {iVidC?3"i{':'€ii :*<::g1a_r,z?n"d1?11g.A-w; {he _ 'iE."1{}V'L,»lf*'1i"§'§'l €3(.}I1d%;MffEL€3d 91:1 t.'ma+ demtfi b<;>d.3,:" as per %::'}e:.;~_u<:*.~':'s'L Ex.)
9./'2 PWWDIU. He knows the a~{:(:1a§$€d.K H<>u.e3€~: mf Gajz'm:«:n2~3. £«':1Z"i€'£ V%ja'a§J:«;1 e,.§:e1.<;i}"1e3.va {A 1.} is Situated at {it dis.s£:a.n<:€ (if 50 fiwhfmm his; §.'mL,2.:~.3e3. He $353133 fllfthffif' d€p€}SCd ¥;.hat z;éL§;:w:,m". 7_ I.1_é<>.1_:1t§f1:'~3 bzmk (vvifneasesa eaxamfirmci on 13.O39i2O{}3) 252%: aboL.i_?..{E63,fiij'-§3:;;§:.__,_ ::h:m:°: W2-"$8 Ei ggaiaéta just in fmm of thfi <:;:'i?'V.7\/';%jAz3j3rga t.Iad.E"1za:v~«A.E( {Lin heamag the <:l'i€:'iE3 11:: \n7:3;'i%:f}t.}":-ér{:A',. "H.<".:"v'V»*{»*-ass=:i;1A his: }*1<i>m3c3% then. ME i:hr': e1(:<:uis&:d: pe%:s~si:11S' _picki:";§g'VV;uj; cgazgiryési _ *vm:7n Mkwuti and Sh€§«:haAppea., A2¥vNé1;'a3ya:11z»§:a$s£;iL:§£;éi§d Mazrmi \I&«="itE'1 £51 s;~.=.i'éCk' cm hits; %"1{:t'z;-1,_cl?~._ AZ' assémfltz §_§*~..Shc;%kh2appa1 xsvééih 2:
E:;':i1?(;}<"; am bizsa 'izead. On ssezeimg s3:»2.';*1:1£§";§f:§§.I1~sae§f, Ci;-:zjem:;1'z'1a-- <13;s"3r::m?z&'s<~:::§j '§'i.;;;J2§:fnj§ra~'P§W. Angeié";-{iéa»_'E_'f"J;?.'? and E:f:§1.Er€:sm~ P.W.1 w'et1€m 'E:§'ia§. :.*c-7:é§£t1.s~:§"'€%.i7,Nia.r,§;:ti;* A;:3--SL::1"e8h a:am:1e:% Em-rhirad. {}E§j2'rZ1"'£ "c"§;:1E'1Ei g;;.;"1:i'i '€§sVs;:;::1£i?T.:3€i-. '».v*;:11 the sat;.%:';:i«; am his h<~:ar1<;i ar'1.<:':
(}a,3§a312::1n.la:: VV R6211 C§{".3f\7i"iVf;~.. iZ)iT§ '€i_hE< "jg1:"m1;1d. (fin Seeilméé Meir sgamcz P.W~1.--E§§L1.£eS'h $~iI€:1..{.'-€;<.}.":.hé' z*<2sCm3 =;;1f"(.§aj2&:":2:a"::1z-1.. At '£:§"1a:3€. time: «--._/H. ,v.i_;'%;f;"3 ;;'m<:,'iv._A4% aSée';':;:'}'i.'€d {}aja.r1em21 vvith :~3$;.ic1<: <:>vm" hé&--,: :"ig§E11;., 'E.<:{%;" s:=}»§c2" v'..3f"i:;\5L*'~Vz¥g.1ic§. left ;<3h0L:3dm1 (}e1jaaa'1ar:a. :~3'u:3"a::i'2ru'-rd %31.:=:.é:::di11g mj'1.i}:°i®:~a {}i'}'.:':_}'iA§::S he-zad. amd REE} dovvn. and [E36 ER-'§{L¥'1BE§§§ vv2:~m as::§&sé¥1'u.Et:Ix;% Afi. w.i.i.7h 2: stick on his; 16:13; Kllflfif ametfi A2 _';-:.7s.a3:~;2:1:;:§€:'é:*:f%; PMWV1{}++~Thip;Qa';'"3..:1a xvs,-*'§t§'1 zgz ;<3i:ée;:E<:: ma lam Exeztzd. m 36 Ths%1"a3:a:~zF%er §}'1<"3y have shifaéci the énjum-d (§a1janam;«1 'La bL1}£s.;">c;k (tart tar» Kaiaghaztgi. 'E'h&:y W<~:nt to the £§a3z§g1"§_;;m3:.gi P¢:>M::<~;*. E§E;+.1é:T§<;m: r;:§im<:t1y' azzd P.W.1 §c>d.g@d a. <:<)m_p.Ee:i.r:.:. Eimas i.<;E€m..i.f%<2d. M'(Z'}'i to 53 am 'fhfi SUCERS 1236363 'E7.>y__-"cE":e 4E}fL ,¢_ V £231" am:-3au§f;§z":g Eifld E116 1'1as.: idenVL§fi<;*.d §;'I:3§:* m:;m;.'g;;;c:'s.:,;.i .
19.. it Im €iiCi*:.e:d in Em: crib-sssit__éXé:1m§?3a%..i<);'1&<>'§' "'§§:2i'é;
wm"1<";3s3s3 thaw. the? a:'§.e<:¢:5z?zs<::ci G;::3j:ie;:ana "LEf;zA3;(f£ v{;_>;c5e;:=:."2€Ed_ "'e;:; v~~EK:1'i§.CJE' "
s=;§'}<5;:> in '§€.a1lL{u11<3i village: and 0:_1,,_€;hc%__v<:.:fy {§zs:y'&f_':.hA§~3 §;n.<:ic§€:3€ ézéawfy En. t;}'3&§ ;"m:3rn;éz1g :a.tF§i.L3O".a.11"§;L} f{L'?}; z':}§.d 'S0}'I"1.<:* ggzziatzea miss? me .E.":<1uac;: 0;? c§&:<W«:~:e:23ed vIC3ir'éi:i.j'f:13i':i':E§.f}.'c'}L.,""--'A{3§5;1"§xfK;{)1'1'} {E162 m<'>z"nir'1g--:;' .i.t1cid€r::3.'E., VE.he1~é3V \/Véi:i:?»1'1:>".:3:"i<¥:"r1i'§y be€;\::,r€~jéi"i the. 21c:C'2;3$.§.€::<'i 25m<:i. C%E3_f€§f :&V I'"2éEz. ;§:~.E~%;i:v_V w;1';~s' 1:: {fig} h()~¥.,ES® in {he mm":1é;;'3.gg on %;.E'2<:é exiieiigércfi CE;-,zt.s';*.«.0:£" i1"§(:i€%A§*:n f 'iQ{>'§:\p1ace¢ On he-Baring zihe gé'~.13E1ta'~;% ha had g0:*1€:% %.;%::.. UINI": sispdti W~~Ei€:':.": A3 m-as QL,i€:1ET("T3Hi.Y1§;_{ 1'1€'3.':*}.}" the:
§"1t3mi§'@: (:4? d€:Ce:a§:<;e:<f§______{3vajansma. E)@c:€:as€:Ci €§7}::1j:-1r1a:i.1";:;2. had .:):§:.'>'€3¥j1f;?d_ If'}'§.-tf§"]_.:E.¢;'§t,.i§E)*£" saahop j'L1ST., IE3 days prim" ':0 the §::ci<;i.<mL E1: '"Z.:s.§ "'?L_:;it?im5"é"7§.é.a;é in {ha Cmsea érxarrlinawéam that 1:16: had not §.§;m:.§: m E=Vai31}:.s:Ah<i8 2>v§":e.n. the én.c§d{~:m tools: p1a.<:€:. Or: *:4':"1e;-u'. {fizzy
-.383 <1?' 'chkitilfz \2w=i*.'z"E: in their h(m.sc: inciudigig ME-1¥'LL€iw"P.W.11, '?ip;)5':5;.n'na.«~P°WA.}0 aarnci dacmsed €}a;;a1m1'1a ::~;iu<;:<: thaw: \w.&: 51 \.f:L X 5'?-
aé in 27 f€:S§;%V%€lA [}aja:m'~.1.13a was» keeping good hcr:a.£tlh on that zfiay. Ht? §}.§:i&".~?» de3.ni.<td i:.ha'£. on ihat day Gaje1.11a;na 'W813 not §<<:=»s:ping g<>s:)C£ §"z.ee1.£E.h 2-mac}. Jim has no: Vv'iYi1"1€88€d the §.z.1ctidr:m a2.V:';ti.._1'.§1_a.t a.i3CL'lS<":d have 30?: 22:11: all :5:ssa'u.Iteci them c:i<::fpQ;-ikéd'--ft?>fy?.._:%"2:i.m and it w.:a.s himst-rif, Suresh.~P.W.1. amd (}z1§3:32;§i.aV¢ti¢3V¢&3:3/sad zzmd <;»t.h:=:zx<5~,: who wcmt; 11323.1" the h{;wL:s1§:é Qf A221 jz:;2.i*;d 'ezS:"saVL":i:£*TL-->.{_f€. 'H;1;,€:f é:1(:C'L.iE'§€d. and that. :5: faism: {:<)m'p1z«.}.1?m. h;:-gs; 'E36381? fj'm.£-;':=;%;;r;=t-V<':i }<»,a:ge§1i;*2:§iT §,h<:?z13» 26% P,W.7'+--Ax1anc3."'Aé.$ §.}":(=:"V'z1e::pErE§::w.?g?fl:>..f <LT'r:2;§a::':':-3h29i2;aM zamcii he has; Siaited éhasgé (}ajar1;3u.'.:.a was %'i_~2v1'l']..'_(}I" umitiezr :,m<::§ E*33'n:3.§«:}+1s1p;322.»PuW.493 1Via1r:}1ti»P.W.1-..A§ '*a€_r«E:{hééi cstoussin b,["{}'U.7€3i"S. §3".Wn E €.:f1<3jT1;im::L.;<w Lmcifi E21? ("§%2:__;':3n.12.1r1a. About 1'/2 _ye;z31's3 E>ac1< {Kr'."i3C'l"1€;'.SE:':r"'é?XE1§T1'l§$"1€3§§ '€_%§3.~. 2{)O3} ai about 7£<}.C${} mmw he Wm; ?;;1_ ma h.<:>Vi[:s:'~':_'.Sitt;.a.técf¥ just mpposiée to th<:=. heimsm of 'V ' «,(}ajg'%;"é'a'm;+§.A. Em Wa.8V:i't§:%'i::g some: galata in frcmé: {)5 the }"u:>"a_'ass€% 0%."
§<"i&:<:riés52.s:'g<3':t?i.' £}a_'§:m.a.11a. On heeliringg the <:2"§.e:*;*s Gf C§'8j£i11é1l'1Ei he s:e'§_:r:cé"i:hm"«:§'E";1.r'ii3':§z1g and saw A3 qLLar"r€§i'i.ng 1?»-*i%t.1:1 (}23j2:1u:&1r1;L ' }"iim.&§'e1.§',tA..?.W.<6-~Haa_1111m&1nt:ha1ppa, P.'W.10«Thipp2mna.-:2 and '..:"1I\#EAAe:.i'*z;1;.;.&é»'£32\?*J 'E E. whca 233180 ::2:=m'1<3 1:hez<"e and s<:<_.1$<:£€:d A3 ass; to
-- wfgy her: is; <i<)'i'r1g gailemia. being dméxak and Se:-.m; hizm avvay from ;t*;fi} %':.':':-37&r€:12?:tive%s;u 02:3 £.h€.*. date: ofi:'"1C1l<:§.€n'£., in the mw:r':":%:'2g;; at Haas.e':amam.appe:w~P.W.6? S}'2e1<appavP"W.9 aaurui '"ET'1"2i}3pa-1:":n:;:+ §31'vW.1.{'}, in me sense who ammlg the :--1ccu3ed Eii-3S:';€:1{.'§3f€:?{"§ -.__T7m~é }'1€;'}11t"$iE'f ziéf (.}a;je1nzaz1z;1. is asituateci in the midsi: Ejfif t.'E'1r;t.{"<:'--i}}§z:égC.,' }"}.()'i,1S{? <35 M23TruE;i~P.W.1 'EM is E§it11Ei'i,E?d :.3d}a<:e.m' €10 .§1E'i*€ §.'1.g') u2é%E~ r;.;'§'~? {i}2:gCaa.x':ana and the Mquoz" sharp of C%a{%_a;1a;3.a Waig iii":.§j§1tE3 §":.<.§t§S€.._V §:)r¢;::ér'i':iE.vc'i&5 itaseii" ever" a. keiitaz. A1 to "A5 ':'£'iv%;=":g"satér;3a.1"a{iA;e:.1:§é~Qi '}"'h<:°; E'1.<>m;<:é <.:}§' A2 at the viLE.}:3i g'<_:%--._V§21"::1;1;z$1'::°=.rée:%, fiéshfi svzzijyh Ae:§j0i11i:1g fihéé A1 is &§§\~g'Lz21%;<2db S0 aim: the-3V hUEJE$€:' 0%" A3 s'im:.a'&:.a'-363% fax" 2€3.V'«'&3LyA.fhI"€}1"I'1 A4 is; not r't:Eeazt€e:i 'L0 A1 V}~ivé*i"1é'.~,s'VVde:1jiie.d t§ie""é:u§gg€.:sti{>n IE1;-1': in:
has; 'm.11~'i:_7<2a-~;me§5;5;_e3c§ $r;=::ic%E.¢nt '£%'a'i§~v1€7:*c314§'I'£-Hflfid by 'E":'§1;1;1 aimd ix": iii; Ck*313£;>$if"£§§_ f"a:1--E5§t:§.§,r '1'xf§f"é.>:AI"V<i':€f:*VA'L?;.~:_3"heip aha cz:}mpk-zme2rT2.i. :ha:21.2g.§}'2 ii wa::~; the: {ii(§"bZ'4T.§}.5§£fi.Vi1'1.§1Tf1T,'?'~f'v'h£"}.'_."%.7~.'ti'I'1i1 ;1<--:ar -gm ham Si'? of A12 2;-mci a2V:_;:e;z:a.3,::;j3t:ééCé. thmzi' wjmai 2.»; false <:0:"m3£a;':2¥:. has"; hsrazn. z::ga1.in$t. '*2 'E73,W:§%"-Pshaarati is the vvifer mi' dciceaaétd (3+aja3'1e:z";aw ET'>}::i.«:3 hi"-9:3 citégéingzéeti E21 her evicierzca t§1::aAt, ::ic:{:<2e1sc3c1 WE-3&3 Ev1<3r 1 };1'L£&?ebéELiEd;'~_ SE16: knows {he accuseci in this ctasavs E%§"1C§ £.E'1a%:+y &'i.I:'€ ('J a'bm:€: LEO at "E6539 she was.-:. zzakiazjz an <~:y<3w§t;.1€;:s.;:a t4<:,> aha:
im:id€:%:3t. (")3 t:%":a:f day, the ac<.:11$€d. rm. 8 ca-117m: 1102.-if Eljttir h<;>u8c: and scwldeci Eimr Exmabaxaci in fiiiyhy Ealzzgtxaagcii"~._H@3.' hLz8ba:';d exnd 1f6:1:m"W::3 Saint hirn. away advisaing hififl. i"1'<r:1 'V'i<i2__"(§§%'f?7__ azfzy g;;a1at.2;~1 .:':.<:e:«w 'l;h<:i.r" hou:~sc'~:. G11 {ha sz3:n¢r~Vd2aQ';~.. a;z'%1.~.V¢:-2z1:r3§::>1_,:V%L_; €}€>.0{} ;3.m, whiiz": am; wa.:=; in "i2.<~3i.: %1Q:Li2,:i~'m}, aiamg'-v§'t%.E2«__ .%°;.v¢:;:~:. <1:k1i§ei1"<3:1, mc)£:hz'.:r«»in~Eaw ~ €f.}V1,,:z1§e1rz3?«{f1.:=_:. "gmcé V':E11_5"§«;zs3E%:;11:"1.e.}c?: <C¥e3:_§a;--;a:";.e.r, A} 'm ASS aSsai,1h@d 3"//":;fW§('r?"L<;'¢,-a_"Ifj>}lC>€;3' PXW. if} W-fish &s&'i<:1<::'s. €;):'2&';;§3 '%'3.zs:V*;r'£': V§:ms'i:';<3«;*i {.0 me"-A: :=é_§:~0i" AS ££i.S5%€itU.h.".€d on Ezezzaci aiazd ht: Ewes; :mss€Laa.i:'1r:cE"1f_}'i%a--@d%:23g i§l1_i'.':§f§CS E.:~}:'iaT"§_ _t;_l%:§£:':'c-::aMfte:z* rem of ihc: :;Lcc:L1s;<2<%_..a--s:«=:;1i.2~£§.tad"'1 "m_jL:s_;_'r;>e;1:'1k;;i~=;:wcE::' s:§_'1s1*. riglnt <':ye;*, .§.<=:fE b3:"<.:>w arid s:§--I%r1'<i>u'§<ié:fj' -~ ._§?ik3rVM'h_1i'Shahci b€C&11'}.'14.'"3 :.:mC0:(1.s<;%i0'z'1ss a1."1.c§ feéi §:iat1xm1."',__"E::{e:t9&;:{r21i; "Esta? m.0£ihm"~in»§aw, S*:.2:*t%s:;E".:~}3'5'\/'~f.i., E§E1e1{.2§§;§s_:§:)p2%mP.W'}€%-..;:md Ma:'uti~P«W."i1 amfi {>tih.m"$ :"L,:&3hs:*<':':5. t'hie:.r_e. P'.17kf.-E 4~:5§.1v.}.1"&3S3{} shift¢c.§ the i11jL2:'c3+:§ £m:'E11<iiz':g:; G'£:3jELEE.é;1§}Ei §":;.2_ [':;§}§{_;j.'b':s.§I0s:k@E2a':;t Em Ehe Cévii Huspimi at E§a=+.1g§hmggi. E<"'m:r:r1 _ §;§'"£(V;*-E":C"'-~ Us-aj£€..I::15.i}1es vva2,:~3 shifted to KI1\/ES I~2Zo.*3pita_1, ivéubii, am:i V é:*§i.<::dL an %;}":a::% §'3€X.*; day m<>rning;§. f.§.b<% has i.ci.€n?.if3;e3d M<lf'>$~ E. {:0 \.% % ammég L§U,L}'>{3 exam. While he was» in fm1"H: of his hfimws, A3 camw m':~a::" 'shes: houscr of (7'xajana:3.a. 21235! he was cfirunk at mat 'f..1§m:;n Hm,1:»:{:: of {Tsaajexnailex is; next E0 the Emlgae sf 'C.}.Tlé";'%4."';?$.='i'i.$¥.'}'€":'E,';E'€« azmrzi abc3~u.% 15 (ii;-yffi _pr°i<:>1" to the Ciatér of incidenfi;
112:6 <;§p:':r1<2=<:i 2:1 Hqum" shap. A3 was; a'mmi.ng:-- 3:3 had <'}p<:~Vm'-rd iiqucaf sE1(";p. At tI:1e1t;:;tirr:<3;.,A [<;j:;a.gaT;»:a=;%§;:z--,= §hVi[r;'.3§es€:1.:,Ff,T. P.W.1--:'l:k'11*e:Sk1, iP.W.'?'--A:1and and' {;"3.WV.""§.'GQVIazmégé' -g;:::2V.§:;£.ficad; /$5.3 &sa.}'i.1."a;;.§ tlxatz VV.§'1f;'.1"J E16: himsc3if' i3 Ej§L::1ir1§< wh§§'*.hé"%:,:§ qi1::;'m;*1'"c:EEi:'1g \}Vif{.h <Z§§a?:_j§m1a-mag": on 8,3122: gf;(§i;Uf1d _ti"1af; %.*::::. ?,]'&éi':.);'{}1:)eT'1§Tf(,i the §.iqL:<)r ssiwgja e:--m<:£ Ehssjg s1t::.:r:€.'. A3 £741 EiiilE>S<?i;'«§};fidI~.Ef}:.¥3:§f 'mtur.t'1c::c:I Ex) i:hc3é'r h<3'L15se:.. }9_...'i.FJ¢.E_. 1'-.h21é:'i ta1<:é§:.2'1 tE:1.{5:'v'%:_21t;i.:k-2:f.€c>r gmzinggg. A} to A3} 'G»"m"§'%--':§§5fiE1V:E'§TC'E}if:;ig.v_'&\"§--31h'--._{.%';3_fa':3%1:'i€r. :--1'boL:€ 'me': Gzfiaiznatm 5;Lam;i1*.1g'. '£'hsi%' §§.q':§11«5.::*'-,:§§1{>p'=,jA1§* {he \7ifiéL3.g§':f. Hi? mass: i"%...£:"th§:'t" d<:*g:><>sac?d EE"ia.j_E§ *<[:.~:f: i<:+¥::a:'££ ' _.{>f inaztédrmt. at ahm::t 06.39 ppm. _ \N'hmj's._§_hs: "s;=Vz»f§.s'.4 i:*:'~3:1i§s h(}};,i§§€3, he hmlrd A} ELO A5 c:;ua:"I"c-rllmg w:"E:E"1_. EVE:-:;29:;fl;'E.¢Pz;';?iJM..?: 1. m;re1.1* {Emir house catm: shecie Hf? xareiai f:'§'2€3%'{"é3%_, 'F§'§"::"}"'i1Ei€.:?§€i'vSilfifd is at a di$ta.m:€3 of ab<t>ut '2 35 Riot: E"r'<:.2n:: €E1<:éié?"--§"10L1':;1;€x'VThe Land and hoL1sc~: of AE«»Vijz:1y is 1".i€XY, to Uléii" _€ta1ti:ilL'% :~;Ei's::c;.i. A': éihat éjme A1 to A5 wars: E-L§"H1€f{i wflh. :»a:£ic:'£<:;%s. " _ E7x.2¥?--3:32i'&1y"::a.§1&1 asgsemited him witla ::'i%{:i<. cm his Lzafi" h:;m<"i 2;-m<:'£ *'s§%*'« 'VJ L) he 3321:;-zrazd SC'{"('321H1i2'3g. Gm heaz"i1':g_«: the eac:.rea:m:~; €§'::%1j21z1ar1z.a, f/'.W}1-~t¥3»L1..m%$h_, Ha1n21m221231:a2~~P.W.6? i\'Ie:m,"£t.i-~~{3,_'%E:{I 1 C}, 'i"%1i'ppanI1;:z~-C.W.1 1 and; AnandwP.W.? ca;-zmzs {there an->*:%_V I"€;'E§C1..%¥? Eéxixézm AF~--E%ur<3s3h 21sS2m}§:.e(.i C':a3'anam &&~*i1:.1"x &§-E;i.c*}gxét"z':;i.
hemd by attmnimg f2z°(:wnr: hiziad aide Qf <.}aj,aa::22:aeL_' é:Vr1c§" tiysé €"«:t:_S=aiz:*.._V as;&;z:u,11.t; (..}a::j2;a':§z1:1a1 ;a~3u$i':zm"1ed b}ee€ii.'m.;; :i'.'l'"lj'i.QVEI"'L{;':VE%. {"3';T1, i'Ei.§:§~tE'2Eifé§i:§§ 51:16 ha iT{a%f:E C..'§OVv'E'L A1«»Vijaj,«', 'fi,2=-~Nai.ray*é:mA, A33§71.i.£~:;';:%,',a"v:ga13'1-':;a1f1c:§ = A4--.§2m*nt:::sh aim asasaméterci Ga'§a;.f2Vé1;1_ xnzfiéh s£fi1c.1<:~?, a1§f<:';\rc*:r ihe:
beirtiiyx '§"E'1:-2 sgmcusvsd p€E"ETS§ §.}128'-_ 21:::§_8zf-\.{.i'3;t.é:fL<'d.A"FEWD6%P{e.:.2:"1z:m321nt£3 szmd {KW} .10 1\/Ia:*u.:;iv .P.W»;-éiéaB;ha,1"s2t:§.§ CW.1'13.»l'C3-undammejsz Q1161 {SW15-«E?23.d%1z:ifi:>ai;%a'1:a.zte<;i& %§';:}xi7Eing 2m?:.§ V9»'C}{;:(":&1ffi%E"3g. {)2} S€.T&?,'f:Z};£§ Eh \;2<,*m"n»::::2~'1 §;fgl1.=;::._;
'hé:r5€.ci f:3fi§'e:ré,"'th.é'§ ac.c:1::s.<3<ti ran é':"1';«'\;'é-,%:\=' fujxrn ms: sapai-I, '--.??+'Jx1E§1.;;5&:shA'--T.:ah;if't.e.d €If§2:1_j;;inm:1a azmtzi Elna? injL.':rec'£ p<':r':<;z;m:3 :<)7"Lf:,_} 2{i; b€:)::'~s§_3'1'§,8*}I Tfm3r€e1f€;<3r C§§,--:jam2§na was ss}':é§f't<?<:i €11) E'{E1\/135$, 'E-5§r.;bii Iffjfi""§L¥'1'1£§'1{?31f Km-:a4?:me11t. am? }'1c=3 ssm":<:'L'zmLf>{-:<i ':0 the ,i.n;;::;ar%.c:&; an 'E"h?t;"".. §1{:7X':L Cissy 12"10r$3i7:2 = j.§--f;A §;:~; eéicized in the CI"OSS <3:><;amina%;:i0n. <'::§T 'i:fE1£$ j w§.:t:'xé3e:zs;'%~gPW}? Ehai it is 1'1<;2E:T true U3 suggest that. be has; not ».,&.§iie1i..€:_§:§ ha-:f«:).2m. the Police ihaat. A;3--NamyaI"1a did ram. s:S:sa3..L11t *§>x--{i'{h@'_tE.u}::: am 'h'::e:-2 ieftt halmi and he has dVenis:%d the: sa\V1§;;;:~;<2&;t.ic}2":
' <ii::a?:a .'{"'x'i'i';€:§V ' tha: he '§'1a1.$. E1533 vvétnesaed iihe incidsmt: and f.ha1 ha %a d<~:p<.)esing faiselgr. Ht: has; dernisad ciafbnce 0;? t:h<:~ z;1<:c-.~.1_,_;$.€c%i wi'3.ia;tfE':: is; SL}g§._i&"tS{i®d E0 him. it is; a.I:~:::J e1i<:i.1:s3<i En E":_V1?§%'~:;'V.<;§i':"a:>;é;5s, €X21I33iI1€1'[.i€i)F1 t:};m'£:. it 1&3 false to Suggzaai. §;ha.t: {>17-A4"t}1<:.,c:{e;-:%:€,*'A 1,)? .im:Edv:r1'1'f;, ALE'; did not some and _<;§Lz2a_r1"@1_' wtéih'-:<'§cr€is::.a;3€:C£.,. €:}&?aj£°i£'l&%JE'1Ei in <:<m.§".2®{::§.io1."1 with St..a1r{iifzg <§_AfA'[E"i[c;u€irf §5.E1<:sp; is:\1'LA...g:.E'1?€:T--. viMazg;eEr..
12:75' PW..H}~»"I'hfip§;amz3.e1 'iAs~."---«:T1_§j:'.~'",v:--}_ an' §:":_;'L1.i*e<;i..c<:y&r\2v.it.:':e&§s; zsmd hm "Exams ziczpwscéd £:}r1a%t 'cm. thei;-.c%Aée"{§i7,ifi«:'_.ide'r1i, at 2;~:bm.11. E.{}.3(} a>;Ln:1. .b€:~ was in fr{):?i{i"'<;§§*xié: A{?ije>u.:scé.. «._PC3 cams: me:-ar E:h<~2 i":o1,§:§<3 csf (:3:Elj.E1.l1'E3,I"i£i;?:§iI7z'(3 ~s$;:a1r*c<:Vd cg.jua»if:'§e}ii,ng with him" A3 we"-ass; r§:*Lm.§E»s: af t':§'1a{."E]€1ne. admséeéi A3 saagrézzgg ;*:i-">.z».:":'£. ii is not p1:"<:2pa3:" ta. C_§i;;ié:%l.1'°I'C'1iV. ' "e1.i;%i3ui" 17.30 gum. an é;h;:n <iies.y' his-1 g::amwt;;~;_, §":i'::",L"3.%s;'<:*If vwr3.i'--<3 En '§.EE€i1" 1:2m,:sr3. At: {hat ftémct, <1'.}_&..i€:%l"1'€;%§ mi.~;;«11" thé"E'1'?c'}L:ase of Afi»-'Vijz?:y. His §"s<::L:s.ae ix; at 21 ._3i" ..:*§.'§;'z.{):1;:-':4 50 Emit: from {he $aici péazcet wh.<:%t"'\*;: t:E1<:3 cglgzz-srfiéi we2$'g?_c;-¥.A.E§g am. Cattier shed of PW9~«Shcel«:ha_p;>a. isa Efiéieféii' §E"1<3 hm;.:es;'1::%:~;_{>£" AL-'Vi3§ay. HE: wen': maax" thaa piam where: the: was; gcreiug am, A5wE3z,1.r<2sh assamlmd Gajzmamag. xméh ' ~'s€:§g:}s:. am _E"1§.:ss 'ha.n<;i 21:16 Ga_;7a;r1a2'1a. {€11 desm-'n., PHWCL AWE-?.ur:3$.i'1 C . »""~L U 0?" t§'1z':~.-3 x>vi'i:'zV1<;:'ss5 to daily his pI'€S€3'K1C(': at the 'spot aw: in Shaw "them he: was not presemt at the scane (.;»f{' inci.ci(=:,m:..
'26. E7'.'vV.HwMar12f.é is the a.1i1Q'Lh<-":1" .i12jL1r€d f.Ey'CE7$'§";§;II:; 'f;§ Ha $8 the y<:>L1:'1gg<:%'r 'bmth.er of Shekzxppa-wP.W.§9n ..
é.h23:%i 'E:<ms;e of {}a_§ar1a1na is near ?;}"1Eti}"_§fj;{j)L}E%i»t'£'. A'ti'"é€k_1%75'(.T.1};§§':"~%..C.,GUV aqm. on 'him dais: <13!' i1'1cid<:1'1t: he §§f21.s:_"i1:@..Phiéy hr:>{:i;~";e':*.'; T1,:}:a.m111. {tame meaér the 1"1oL1s€' :)i?_iC:.§ 211.3';-7i%3a%_1f1:"c?a gm G1$3.-i:-§_.cfi..;}.V'§I?VL1_L;'£»}I"}v§§ him in c:m11'1<--:<:i:i0r1 with ihe §.i<;_11;(u>:i"'«$.x~}E:1<>.;;); <5?§&2;§e2:221n.e1 55% cirrgysg prim" E10 {ha E3.W.9~m §5:§h<=:'§<;Em;3§:>2:a., .PyW ?'_~A;r2an ci_ .:913~T'L§.:§<I.E.§.E"&'$.i'fE fl{.":t. £0 zxbusé-3 C31' m.i;1 Eé.-nd1 s"é11i 'hi_17a?' 1:521:31; zmd Wt31"H. i:;:":m= Eh:-'-A: .izme:.§ €..7:i'; §\£ari1T1:'i7.£}<> taiic ;;7aii:£<: f<')1"- gr21;4§.;:a;g;. A? 2';1hC}'i.1{". €fi.(}{_) pm. whim ha":-.vv:;1s t'et.ii.1r§1i,:2'g..__i€;»..hiss '§'1m.:s£: If1"OI'I".: §"'zE:=; §a1"1c'i v;:§.€h <::;.1i',E§<::t, Eu: 'Wm; -tak§_n.g._Vc2L{t.1e 'E0 the <:.z31tt,!.€: :'~§}3<3€§. 'Tile d.%&;i.;«U_é.;c@'I3@t'x,v<:2er1=_h<>'u$e and ~:.:atf;1e shed is. fazerii, Huu::~.;£:' of ;~'%x.'"£V~'V'ij23z'y'"'§:?; §é::§c11" them" cattie sshed. At that: {Ema A1 {:0 S w<s::"{: '1§:§iV?.'V§T§_Z"');§g;--A ;-=:4:.:a:a 1.§:m§;hc>'L1S<: of A1 and they wem awniecd with s;€§ézt§é':%:. Al'':@ /%..5 eaxne to a.:~3saTu1t him asskmg }.':§1'1'i am to why 'V be: Q'i,.iE§i!.:i".€;*}Cd with Ai3»~Tu}<aram am. thax {fizzy r1"1<:>1"£":ir1g-5. HE: " :aé,:%:;'::<3d Vé<."Vr""€s,-11315.1": . C320 hea:"3§1":3' {he §3CI"€E1.ffl8, (3¢:'°ei1"::--m , " . . > "x;§~ 1- PDW.§.~»St1w;*:s%1, P5W.'17--Ar>.and, 'P.W.9~SheE«:;Eraappa emd P.W.1{}~» T§r:ipp:»flm.ne.:: came: tghem. A:E3~§3§m"esh :;2&;saL:'Et;5td {;'r:s13'an.2e:n with :~;%:i<:L;: cm hm haaaci. Al ts) A4 aasaafltttd <;T%e1ja11a,m. 'v»»':i:§fa. :é=,»#:j§<§E:<;s on hiss s}1.0uEder, bac'i<:, £12106, etc. HE} sus;€;ain§t-3"bh:%_::-ciii§:g__' in_;§L.:ries§ cm §"1i:~3 head. Accused §.'>E}TE"&3{)1'1S 2'13'.-.".?1~I3;7'..'vX:'§;{f'\'§",'-_{'.%"'§%.'N.?f" An:-;m<:§., P'.W.10»'T}1ippEi.flfiE%,, P_WR9--'S%2e}<.;Eiaj;;3;i~;;a Ha::.m21'm;mt:h. V'V'EiE~3 aasezultéd <.7vi:ij"E1 s;.t.i<:§é':e {§:3 t;1*1c'>:TVV "i~?-§s_': 33.01; exanzirzad by "Elm Doctor 3*§::gz1rfii~.. 1 :}'xJ'_--;%::<:1"r";§uFi:'3.g :;i:.s::: :'--;'tj(:1~<:5 31:": their 3 V"':£"'::';-"3...1'1' .vé'i's?'i,«.'a':?z\"}«'. V%V;é€i':E)%Ejvt'§{:jC\§ MVQ1 in M.{7}£§ as sticks E.?z.SS§i£1iL.i.£§if1g9 M is»; £:?:ii<:%jE;t*.("1 in "{.E;'}*?."{ffE'€§S$:1€X3_f{iiY18¢E,iC'ii§. "C)f thlfis witmzxexs Q12:-xi ATE E0 21;'1§i----vn§E;2'<:::' vé .a_;;er--€.s: w*'er~;-7'"Q%:{§.::'t§ting far s3ta.:"tir1.§g I1§cgL:m' s£";z:'::p im3.:g:hc~': v"i1Ea'ga%:L"-~.,}'Hc: a'§*:;[:e:a_:§:5"«:§<*32?1;'<3:§ 112m: Suggesticpn. {hat E19:
E33-:3 3301; Wi'E:1_{::ssge:-=,*dV' t§'}e 1.':1Ciiic:tr1t. as narrezietd by 'E.1im eméfi it wasg V;(Tfi_§_¢;2_;'a"m;'3;:': azfzti' v-<)f£1"1€:;rrssV who w<~:m.: f}€.}Ea.}." the hc>u.s<?r 0?" A12 zmci z;s;s,~s2m'1:L::_d v£€:.1¢.3"§T}?§11'§;~'»f;'fC§ and WGifI1€'>1."l foiic arm *ah:»;;:t he :33 degatysizzgg i"::L1_m:'2y,.
u '1;2"?";= if chézaz" fmna the e:'3vide;r:zc::e of %3.W.€';"> to P.W.1} .::h'a£;L..§"10t§.*:§:1g has; Vbrsrmz. eiicitetci in the cream-3«mcé.xa.mir1aticm of _ t:h;:::<;";é=7:"*»*ar§$I";<3s$::%Ea ta disjsbelievt:-*. ':1*1c«2i:" e3V§.<:i€.1's.£:@ thezai. $171633," w"e?':"é:
p1*e.:s;m1t at iihé: aims ef the incédcsm; at 10.30 pan. wI:1e::.:"2 éhx;-3 :;1<.t<:11::;<-rd 2's':b:,1ss<:<i (}ajana;": 2'egardin§.§ opening of tfhfi-: §3£qL:;<i31" $sh.0§:» arid. -am: mcridrrm of &'iSS£:1'L13.'i that took place 21:; 2:-§;€:fi;. E €:.S.I3(} pknm am this &;:;1m<~:: day on 23$O8.;2(§01.
zzraaking S1Jigg€£"c'~.'»'€i{")E"1E§ that {hey hewe mm: .i:hr--§ "
i:V:ci<'£e::nt. zsmczi §'h$:'f:§?' wrsm ms: prc"-:s;c:£}t: ;;-:1' i:.§iaa":._ s§_;_7(;x*;_ é:.s:*2<":§ '€73.01 .' in<:icit::r:E htcm ié?i§<.€3E1 plzaaze em n.V9.;3"_z"4'29.%':<:~:<§ *;}_)5'z"'ifxxem §{:;§ c:a<:C1,;2":m£E m-3a..£" 'me hcmsses <35 A<t¢{JaL§;:%;4'<;f. 'a&;_h'E31;.E§ir:. €§§a..2£f%1z"12a.,r;'1 and :'..>?;}":m":~3 hewqr %3$$E%{*1lt'@:%:r% émd ("2*§fi:c§AAx" {}:1.1'"<:3<% amcfi w<m:1z:':&'1 §"<>E§»<, 'RI"\«'§1.i<'_".§": has 1:>§;,.-*~.:j;V,V'x'.'£iAA. jtV.';§T':>»§;*'gwif:r"1t:&ss;<ésa, £;hc;: E"3"1§:1t.i'?¥'i2?z.3; elicfitiaad. i«n_€h.«:-3 <:1::0s;s:;; r3_>£21rn.Vitd'2i.:é.¢'m 11:13 2'1<>'t: 2«.;ha§<;m*1 §;htE*. <;:re:<:iiE:>%ii:};r~--e;::f"_i:P1<%; wié:;jsr:ss'e:s 'éPWs;¥{§~I:>3 'i, arm>r1§g; 'Et1"mm, P\:V~€;§, "E", 9, iifiaand 11'£i€f't?,_;§i§jLi'i'5:C{Wiyé'-17\J§'tE"1€3SS€{%, 551:; 1.21:: Mme £23 g:.wc>*:/$301 by 'fling: Vevidéincre..<:ifP_fi;V--12 who has is:'~;u{-3d iihfi' w<;rumi <':<=':.m:-i§%_§:¢ee1%£:c:~Ls»2: in mS}:::r;::g;:1; <>f',::h@ss: wi'£;r1e*:s:"~::3ss. Th€I'€:1 is :20 ]'"I1fi.'i'i1". in €hé:s:n,€:<>n:e:;i;EE;e:>f:':'--~.zaf the §.<-rmmzci CiI)Uz1"}S€§. a'zp_pez:'m2:'1;g; £62' Ehrsj éi£"';:w;>5i:=:.i__§;;3A:"£Vi'.' 3:"V§_1:z§%; incidmlt did not. 0c:<:ur mien" th<:é hejgmsssz eigwf _ A.£iT{TL.%'..'[:'5~t";',<.i »._;'\Ec::;f£" agmtl incident oCe::ur:"e<i m'--:a:" am: Im;>L.::--;<: <33" ;'3'L13.C'§.!}5$f3C1 E'\§(}.:2 and Ejhcé c<)L::1:;c:rvC<>:npiaint. bass been filed "by ' . émfi '.z:i::rs<i£;m.c:%r:;i which $3 registemd 21%: ]£{z:1igh21t:a.gi Puliczo as; €;ir:z";;1c3 I\'0.i.4A;?,/2£['}{Zi1 am}. zzurnbered as S@$S§.onS Cam Nc)'87/T2062. ii; £3 <.::Ec:&:»;u* fmm Lhéz 5-scrutizay of matjmrieli on mzczmd mat §g%.pa.r{ fr<_>m §L3f()d'£,"E(;iiY"ig;_§ {he FIR iodged in tlrzzzz Said {tame by f'x(;:§f':;::_;;Le§§ 1\Jk:;.E?3 é:':i,g&1§Y}S'?»§. {M}:5sjaua.n and others and. W0'U,:'1d s:§>--:?*_;t.§3'E%:Ie" A2 and £\,i:"-5, i}".£j'L3,.'£'}" <:e1*t,ificat@:':; pertaining 3:0 f».r£i*é.'>'r:"--:¢%=;b f'1<i>V'i'E<:','_M<?:: m:'h<;?2" :na.t.eriai whatever" $3 pr<>ciu<':._;:r6 J'7'L'£§{ .1'suTbst:e/$1":ieé1"é.£§'.__€;h.::' C0:1{€3:m.i.<.m 0:" in ;<_:>1"obabi.fise thzé <i§_§3f;'e11<:'§::.V_EE'iaa'£: t:§*:<-9é{:':g::%<:£_s;t;:"7;?;;diéi not 'L".a3A.i«:€:* _pk:ar;:é: ;n<::a.1" the }1ci>'u$e cfifvfié _Wh6r<§in_i:fié:€:$;.§é#g~$:;}.1<5:<3i <3?" She: cc.3.m_pIlVaina1"1i:. 35 ('3zaj:2éTr.;:,-ii? is-'sit'§..z;1§c:<?§'é3Jici that éhcst ém;ri{iic:%m, hari 'E'_&'%.1<;€?'i'1 ';f:Ea.:z.c&=, when E\/EA;3.IVf1§':'a;i;E'V'§_F. 1 to T;et;h<:2"' t'§'1€: craiitie in 'E.h¢": <;t:»;ui'é;'Ec£"{;:s?1*:e<:§[1, The"V%:'%.:£d<:*§1c¢;.0!'-§?Ws~&% "to H is cogent, <':0:'1$=s§:'~3'E;<:%'1':E, trm.%'1§"L{'z :E';'::'?'1(T"§.":"€.':3§§§i?L1.bK'Zi..é3L}T1d"i.1Q'.V'i€i.',h' 0%" the 0bs6::va':'E0r:.s; made ':35; "L123, '{}");<:"v:_p€:»i1'1{4'H'1€1t'a3zriEsé".f{>f' det;s3r1:m7n22t;icm 15:1 {hm ctaasae izeniy . ,.,':?__"é"'i§,'c1'?.V.,t.'€Ti'}3.§"E,.§_'.'-u?,'v.U3;-3. g;1,u1ti €">'f"AE§ fer the <:'>£'fc':m:€:r:~'s p:;missh29{i:3§e3~ 1.m<:i<--':r 41?, M8, 324 and 304» Part : wc: t"¢:3a<:'} wiéfiu E§<éc"f§§€§;": 'i4f:'~9A'ii_;??(';3, as <'EtC.CU_Si3d E fez.) 4 Elam: Raf; _pre':f€,*§w;id 2:11:13; _;;*s,\;:wp<e3~:;a.':~.2a;<_;;;'ze1i:<1s'£ the judgmem 0:" cc>r:vi<:té€>1'1 and s<m£:&&;":{:e ~. "}':2z:1:ié:si:%.c1 aggexizzsat. Shem and they have mrvsid {mi {he sezfiemce ' aijsd _;;>z?:'£d {he fillii and. ii; i8 ciear fmm i;hti*. <«3vi.c§{::n<:<-3 05 P'J\f:~;~E§ ~59 : Q';f."._\_ ' 5&3'?
'~> '€*.<e";5 48 m 1.4 51131:. it Wm; A5 who zasgauitcd. am the-=*. head (33? {f}a1§a1':12:2:":: vxéfifz :-::§{:3T4<:_::§'§'-n All iihc-.=. <:mbs, MOs~1 :0 E3, have Vbmé-:11 rcc:m{ez°e.::d mam $1116: Es;_:>0~€, Whiie drawing the? spa: E\/I:-:1h:é=z-2:3.1"_;%?»f§-"$12.2: mv{:3£.2§gjat%.:;::n wffictar ass per EZXKP-5. M05;-41 in Vi-"£3f'€"'-'[?%C§'i...._' sis.-=;ia1r::<i with biowd amd ?fhez'<~3.fore, '£'1";:3j,j§3.aav<:": .1-2¢;%'::"§;>-:3.{;f?':.r'3 ét-[::m_f["<>:: <.:h<2;rn.%<':;--3£; <~3x2:xmi:1z3.t:.i{>11 and it is <3§<:az'" f:*<:T:':i' Em; ':Mné;m:'3"%§:i';E.__ mieg' recwd. them 1"1a.vmg 1*<;*.g'a1"d £5271:-?iz__<3 caviaiig-'.f2c'e <;T.&I'V'§§V§;'J.<.;/Mi», _§1::h<'é é1'1jL,:ri.<~:.se. $~:~sL'i5--;§:za:.me:t<:i '{3}; Cizfianan .i4i;s«";e diL'i(": m .';71:S;fa5S.&E5l1lf.g \&:"§t':.h :5: C-£Ew1bv ..i<~ :29. muss, '§>:~.1<.sV:_:j:;;:1g.r;;, d.ép;>s.i~.:';z..i-an hiss €':v§<L§é3:"1cc: :}1aii éE}C(2OE"€§ifl§.~.§:"%Z€)'§j7';'i'1; d<:taEh'"Wa,%§3' Q8LiSE?Ci.."{1L§€? M} 1:"<~:s3p£raE:0r_y fa.i11;m:% ; <t<321saE}r3f.:;r:1'111' ?,L2g3Q'zf;.._ head mjL:2'i<:ss s;'L.::a%.a'im:t<"i e:m<:§ :;;szcc:<>r~:§i'm§;1V,'ms: £12334' "pc1:*é3tmn2o1*$;em repori. as pm' §E><:¢Pm M} eimd flags»; :;ii'::;:§Vfuzfriishead. his opinirm that Ehe: §njL.2r'2es c:<.>:,1E<i V' 'vim:-::+ <;:1iij$a;A€:§.AU52Aa1:aa5;zv3u1'£"bjg' 3t%C}.~::~3 Hke T5/iC}8~1 EC} Li N'<:)i;}3.i:'1g; has b<3'a'311"<;:.!\iC~i.%;€:Li. E'z.w;_ fltfie cms::;weXam.ina£:i.<;3z': of PW~~~1:?e £0 {jiSh~E?1i€V€f %;h'c: E:v'£dé::1":1ué§_ 7'€;§'1z3.iT {f}a"g§£mz--1:3 $L.zfferc€:x:i E"1c3m.i<:idaE <:§a:%2€z:h. _ ',_rF}"1(EI°€?f{..¥§'f3},':_ prz>:~;e::<:Lz¥;i<:>:1. has §31"OV('3d Emycimd :'e;:as3cm2sx'ble fZ'i{)'L2.§§)L ' v~ '§:.F'1;3{t "aZ'r«-&e1jz:1z';2;:2'2 s.a1,1§"fer~ed hcamicidai dézath. ~(.
i%;§'
38. The azvitieztcttz of PW$~@ {:0 'H WCJLHCI <:E:::a31*1§,' pmvez:
bf:fi,"C}}"id re.aMs0r1z:1.b.':(:*: d.<;}ubf; $1123.? AC<:us£-:-d. No.5 'We':1f~.§ 25: r"z"1aé:*[':};)<::* Of 'E;1.fl,LC'1\7»'f'Li§ as;se:mb§y formed by Ace-mseai N03 3.
é'u1*'t%"1e33;'a.:":<:e ejzf 'the: C{;>mm<.m object Qf uniawfui havté e?::.:=;~;Sa":;2A1t<~:<:i and cauésed. i}i1_}:L%}"i€E} fi.$ 'fJF"fif's~:-6, 1 TL, x:v}t"1§<:h. 13$ §"}I"(}V€':d by the (:vi.dV.<::1'1<:e3bA:'ai>f §im§.:%.:ng§~3 of 'she iriaxl c<:>:.11*ii ihai'~v.A {':::§1S€C§ N0}53;jz3;j§;21:>'€:1§éi{:i§:' ha-35; V a'.:<>r'nmi'a::@<i. oE°ft:13<:<:~s»:. pm,"-3i:s[E'1a1'b}.a'"'L§éfi<:€£<::%'-»_$3ec!..§Cm's;. I];;4;":3, E47, 348, 31534» 2:°€:z1c'§ vvéih 149 IiF*Q,'":s 3%. T:E_},t?"'§:}'§"Xi :,£1¥.'§€;'§S3¥;:§V.{')I'1'«.VAW'§9}§§ff§h. 1"eqs..1i.r€r(i m be <:<:>1'm;ic:Lk:md 5'13 sfzs. "'£:e";:'3I._t§1e'-. Q'§[¥fi:n_Cé:>_ V"v».%hi;.r:.'£': Accmseci "N953 E1513;
¢;Tf{}E'§"LX1.'1i1 ,:E@dn 'ET E:1'1€~;z1.;:(>;1€€<';1.ti0n +511' thcsr iearrzed Ad€,iité<_>1":;:-1% ESP? ééhzat ma {3f.§e'.;'1e;:e3 C{}Yf1§j";§'iLi.{3d.A/hE4;§:.~"j3'»C()LES€?'di Nofii wouiti §2211.§ \rai.t%1in 'Ef.h{"3' é:.iem_bi'E: 0'E5";":;_:Lé:"<;i.<«:*r §§ur1'i..8't"1ab1.<: by c71€:21t.h at imp:"i;~1m~n1'nm1i; '-v..f<)x~v-V.1.:§...§{*:~:,.a§1.<j~ :}:1e Oi' the tmizli court i:.hza;t Em: {:~ff¢*.nce _cei>:":;.mé.fi*L':;z§$ h§'..T_AC.cusec§ N115 is am offergce pm1iss1mb§<;s> 'L1.1"1C§€.*1"
E36-f'§{iSV§f'}E3 ;3Qé%A'1.§%3i:"1A~[ EPC77 culpabie §1s:>mi<:ide m::é: an2a:2L:':1Ei11§,-g 3'0 H1L§.3"€'j.<;*~T.", c;?.r:'<311em,1:~1 Hoxwver ac:<;:or{iir1g; to that éeiairnmti "r~;o"L1i"1~sg;<:*1. '§'c)3;" A<:<':L1:~3ed NC}/5, p£"'i)S€C':;§EiOY1 bass fa1i1.c3€i to ;::>'mv<=:. {Pm {::k;:1z":.r'm:s$.:«:Jn GE 0ff°<3m:<:": by me 2=.1<::::us:~:d. ii: £3 e;:1ea1' fmm mt'-: 44
am; :::cmtc.+r11;2;or1 oi the State that; the Amtusetd Nmifi }"i«';5i;*I:'» €:<3'r.Tnmi1:i€d the 0ffe1'1<;e punishaxbic Luudezz" §.é§e<:'témn i3C>;% EPC. zemd €.>E,E'1<:*.r' a<::CL2s6:d are also iia.b§<: as; they we-:=r<3 p1"(;",5;'§:*.i:';"£.."."s_Vr?: virszw wf tziw pr<3\'r*i:<~;iQ11 oi Section 3.49 {PC whi<:E7,;""%1'a:2.-$5.'~--?r:{et:'fl irwc.>}<e:=d in 3.1113 casa, carmat be :&1c{:ep*:.ed.
E32. Fxxrtiaez', so far 521:3: the 8<_:3}1€Ve;:_}:ie;A. is (':<..>_nt::;:':Ena§{i§'--fl'i'é»[.1 <3f§f<=:.r:<:£:t umdézr Sectierz 304 P;%*iv1f"i--.._:§.. figs s€«*iE'i}§ i3'"r:;;)§\%%(;-g;.1"zi:52;~;:; fur life our i_mprisQ:g1VfI?.$§2z%V_v.o§~ 5%-.13'!:§<3:<::%f:;i<§V§<::1"&pEion fear 2:: t¢:=1;"m. ':.*v'his.:h may siiaam é;£}S:'s{'.3 be:
§ie3i:.::§¢: :0 fi:1<:u T'zj:§3 ss;<:=:r1t'{:1':.<;:e~:»:E A<:m..1s«::d. N0.i:3 {:0 f;1L;*:»m";r:z9:gr:;:}§;"£gc.1r(m.3"'ém'p:"isoI1ment fox" {Eva jWf:.'€-31'f'33 a:,id. to _f:ia;j>fi.a fine? {sf ?55_,O{}_O/ ~» and in ci€femit' of @222}-*:'12.e::'1t @£'"'f13m:, t.<f;> L'i1"1d€I'§.3;{} 'fL{:"%.h'€5:A_ §1'::§wris<>'z21'r2<2r1t for Six 'rsM;;::':E..h:-3 for the <3§"x;'"e.?::r_'1c::<ir ;:>:'i:;;'V1V_i;V:+;§rV1a.'£"2E<: 'e::ié{m' 5§e<;';t'.ic:n 304 Paré; E EPC1 '"E'h;:u'; V' '--}12:vi':<1g{§'z*é;;;§§:;z.::*c§. t<> t'E1.:-3"ii:é"t:ums{.2;uf:c@s uncier w'hi<:h éihii. e;.>i."§'€:m:e V}j:e31Vj::.; TE<:éw;*~zi"»<;c§.5:i£h:;iitgrd and the age: 01" A<:<:.u:s€2<?} No.5 azad ut'E1<:?r n7e?a%:,€:z'§a§:a:_1jc:é2,:*§:1g L§pO1i'1 me <§'LZ€38'€i€3fl {if $<3r:tem;:<:*. zamd. V.<;g%,;se:'z:*1t1..1;:sr1 lafgf §3u:r1§sf~;E"1mcrm imposcéd for {he 0ff<=::'2+::<-3' p":.11"1i:s}'m't7}E<3 v~f§;mcfé:%f'~.S~'5e<;:':iio1.1 304 Part: 1 WC, it £3 (31621: H1311: a;<T:m;r:-:1'm:% of ' "'rigg§§;)r<>L':$ izrnprisozlmczm for five }7t3'E3.J."':3 and £0 pay 2% Eimr of
9.} *% ?5,{}O{}/~- a«1;:'1d in dczfauit of pa.ymenf; <'>ffir1<3 to Lmdm"g<> :i'L2:"E..hc:.r 3§mp'i"ism1:T2et1t for ssix months, Cannot; 25:1; afi Se-1ici '£0 be:-2 €3XC&:E%'i.V<:i ms to can for :£m;erferen<:e3 in this; a'ppea.1. I's{f'1v<a.%zf€--.._f;}1-::£i the:-at A.e;a:L2.:~:e<:i Nafifi has gt}: a son and mar3:i<*:dA '\;7'.,.'f;>.r;'£.1]'C41':"i'f§§i1~3f'_.:§T,%f}'..._ imeié" a gmurzd 2:0 miiigate the Ci1"CLi§T1E'i'££L1.1'1tjL'C?i€5'*E'z§§~.£1,315: 'sgaici §;.~;m'ur1<:i we;-ma aim) t.:ak€:1 1:1ei'm"e t:h<3V=._h3a1_r-rzegfi SJ1?f§'E~f~i(}'i'}.E'$'\ §L§._(7Eg§§E;}' amd -we §.£'.'"?&.1I."}'}€C§ E33:-:*$s3io:3s Jud.g<=:,_011 L",*{:)~-'>_'1vSi(i€f33{'a'5,.iC5ET§V'Of a:.;_§.§_§'£".h<?r ;'$EiiC§ s;tc3nteE:n'£i<m::: maiy, 113:3 i.}fr1pc}&é{m"jl é:h_e $e3ri'::¢{z'M2.Ce:i (}f ;I"§§?_;€f}I"€3o'E;35'$ i.m;:>ri&.§cm.:z1em' Em' five jm<:e_1i"%:,_ 2«3..m1i. ta} 'pay: 3; fixfizes of ?iE3,0{}{}/ ~ zsmd in e;"E<3i'"e;:L3 1.1: 05 pa.jgr1";'1e'm: "»;:2.:§ .f'm§*:, -'"~1t<_t§'f_'u.:":--z;i&:r"g>;{%s f'L'zrt1'§7:<?r én'2;3§"is;c;.>.nm€a.mi f~E>i§'§s3f:}=; mi:3__n§1_'§s=; 7E1<>€"'=Qiffehc{3_Jmdear §§fE<;.t€'i€3£".: 364-
Pz;z;ri: E £F_9¢I,'.~--.-.. §X{%;i:"_<3rci A ggtiyg-fix-"<:: &"1(,3I¥%ci~-?;}1é":1. Ehe sc:11t:€:11c':¢:2 i.mp<:>s:;€:<'.§ an A<§ZiCLivEj3€3t§ E\3<;~=":2 i§k::4';.=»".AL€3§f<:fi--;:{§"undei" sce(:¥:i0.=;1 304 §?~'e1.:"t i EPCI is *7; 'u s;":'.ifi.<-xii .
in viexi-"'--:;:§V__Ij,h'e.::1§'{:nfews.21iCi reexasonéngss, E3 is ck-:aA1.1* 'é.§;'1.at. Eizgk'-»aV';:;>;3Vcé:;.i g£_§§.t:24:__1 by the: f:%'s§a{'€ seL':ki.z1.g <21":heia::1c<::>;nw.m: <3? :<;1c:.:::t.:?.mc:c:Vi1?{1';"2<;,>V3ac:{:i L3:§O1"1 Accused No.53 and £20 <:0nVi€_i:'E:. all 'i:§?:<~:
_ Ac:€:1VVi&m:tc%"*--§'\lt%§:s:E. {:0 ES for offences punisgheabiriz m1<:§.{--::" iE'>r::<:f:.i.c:>z1:%; ~,,'3'\:EI»\:;3'-.f°§H'1f_§V"«r"_"i*{}"/"E" {PC 3*¢;>a<:>§ \V'ii.}f1 Section 149 E'P<fi is Eiabias W be _ fli.s3fn§:'és¢3d. Ac<:<;rd3§1f1g13g we hold t.E.1at 2:123 tile *;b1:"<;=.<3 a::}:>p<:éa.§&:e