Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Hari Pal Singh vs M/O Railways on 26 April, 2022
4 OA No, 7159/2019
*
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
MUMBAT BENCH, MUMBAT .
ORIGINAL APPLICATION No.719/2019
Dated this (Ny esel ous day 36" of April, 2022
CORAM: Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (7)
Hari Pal Singh, Age G1 yrs.
S'o Chandra Pal Singh
Rio Sanskriti, Plot No. A-5,
Sector -- Near National Compiex,
New Panvel, Navi Murnbat 410 206.
Retired Sr. Senior Section Engineer
under Dy. CEE (C) Dadar,
Mumbai 400 028. aw Applicant
f By Advocate Shri Joe D'Seuza}
VERSUS
f, Union of india (Through)
The General Manger,
Central Raihvay, Mumbai 400 OOF.
a 2 Finance Advisor & Chief Account's
Officer (Pension), Third Floor New Adm.
Building, CST, Mumbai 400 ook,
eputy Finance Advisor & Chief Account's
Officer (Const.}, Near Platform No. SOWR),
Dadar, Mumbai 400 028.
hand
4. Chief Administrative Officer (Const)
New Administrative Building, C. Riy.,
CST, Mumbai 400 001.
Ai
Deputy Chief Electrical Engineer (Const.}
Dadar, Central Railway, Dadar,
Mumbai 400 O28. . Respondenis
{By Advocate Shri RR. Shetty)
019
he
ad.
OA No. 719/2
for Responden
counsel
aq
¢
ORDER
ty, learn
-
ii RR. Ske.
Hi fo Sh me Cet 7 HTS, :
reneens Fe Od @ ei an DOF RAY et Lo fi t 20 by t Z De te if he apple OFF el f ement oF DCRG, af pair s :
ind FS
2.
a vy, t & ra OA No. 7219/2019 ie 9 With reference to Para 4,1 / to 4.15 of the Od, the respondents respectfully submit that fifteen point six four (18.64) metric tons of musterial was Stolen In the 2000. However, the same guantitv has never oi
i) cas a ~~ f, oad been recovered, and further, the deseripiion of ?
D oy Fe rene ert ry tepee ahs se i and recovered materia: wos Net AUSSING giateria matching wneil receipt of letter fron: Retiway Protection Farce. Panvel an HLO8. 2073. A copy whereof is enclosed herewith and marked as Anmexure R-4 for its true meaning and effect. A careful perusal whereof would bring Aopie the patnt % £ ae 1S in favour of the respondents that the question of th stolen material having stood recovered ar least in the possession of the police oly become final on {A08.2013. The respondents further submits thes one of the Stock Verification Sheer was for Ry 05,06) \ and the next one for Rs.2.34 300 further ihe Narrative Report was for Rs. 90.810 and accordingly there was a shortfall af Rs4.2h.07 1 recoverable from the retiral dues ef the applicant which is only his DCRG amount had been withheld. in the light of the aforesald position, sbhice now the oe i 2 eYivpacel to err. ah er anterd police have confirmed ie receipt oF bie mates fal respondents are ready aad willing fo release {he DERG to the applicant as aad when the material tn cames back into the custody of the radwaya, Th z respondents therefore, prays that the present O4 & clearly infructuous and does mot jwearrant any ry interference and the hands of this Hon'ble Tribunal,'
5. In view of the aforesaid, the QA is disposed of with phe directions to the respondents to consider aril settle z oes payment of DCRG to the applicant as adn nissidle to Rint in eccordance with fhe relevant rules and instructions wikalet "9 AF OA No. 719,20 three months of rece £ Posed Be a is OA the ngly.
z ai
-
Aces
6. re ey FO CaNTs.
Eat HG OFd.
Z terms with OPES RE of ng claim
3. (Pension) {29 fO BPGNE respondents. ~ weed 4 i Lees Med a f ij 6 : 5 a Ge + . a a) oe 3 iis i) o '-) 3) (fi fy nm be ¥ oo a e a "s ( 4 Gi ae Rms we mai aa AS os i 44 a ' whee a " os D> ais _ ica] at as 43 43 £3 43 4 shel oy (G i re Be is * i) a Vn Gh ao o et . a . e yy 4 wp oA " G a +4 as uy (3 Ci . on . "t Fel q ed (5 C " A nan 6 @ ec a Ss S99 ° a oe £3 a te aX is 2 Ss © ££ & 5B w& SF E 6 7 ; @ . an nie ca an uy nov ad ae x. coal aS s pe 3) - . i] rf ga s FS = 5 es = 5 a G© kK wi rh @ ca a T ""™ @ 2 8 © © © » " vet 7 ra) a ' St ty =. t pone i " "4 a re Ly od mm ka Cy oy = & ¢ & 8 oe OG oo bet " «e : ) tt reat = F & BF EF. Pe @ seal ey w w es ty ei 6 aa or yO - So oom poo SS "3 eed c ba " ' oh, - 4 24 " Gy La 3 ' " 24 : 4 el ue "5 % % oS Pa po uw i i at . i) w et rs 2 fF FF F & & Fy ; i i he t w i ¥ a sad BS & gy & ee us re iA 3 re ; Aa wy ' om & SG 2. =. Ba cs "4 Me bf 44 od ord Cc & a ; Bo Boos Som a ca 2 6 vd 5 * Bg OR , 2) aa o ; ony ss 9-2 6 & & 8 = 3 Sn » GS 4 2 = 4a om eA ' 6 ti Pay He r™ SW Bg BE oy ' ad ca a a . a) seh '. z Se 3S € SS 4 am 5 a fee cf wt oe At ee a ty Se, : ti 0) ds ; 5 perl "4 'ss es ; ie 4 aaa) ee ees : Sh : " d - ' 44 z > Seon "a a) t > a s gs 4 fre 5 on TS wo Roos we ow SM " 5 (3 o t ~ pen ec s cand S bed SA a ig 3 4. M4 . * faa tee ke = a ty Ry wl Be 4 xo 4 j wpe os a ! c a a S Eo @ RB RR ge ; Q ra ad 43 oO « wd ~ ed 5 o S br oy le Pod ne = a 44 Hf) 6 CS ra ON, wy n an or n a a rr a! « a a o ia Ms a | 4 1B " ~~ SS Bo ay 8 gy 8 v a ie 4 Oe fu gt oy cs 8 " #£ ££ © 8 8 om KS oi} . @ ' Me © Bo "4 oe £ = S$ £ 2 8 to wn ce et ct ©) ra a $4 ce: i ref ral ir.) nn a) =< 8 of F e Mo oY " v4 a) a Xe :
i J t Wag pad pie} nee 4 ayy whet - Oo - ~ oo ®@ E& 2 © B BE Bp FE BF pp Bb B & cs @ 9 os 03 = = MD ee eG 5 se £4 a0) a * so] uw $3 id ey . 4 va © OG s Bf BF es z 3 elo gtk iA BD etl » 6 SS & » BS § BS = SE 2 gio oS 8 @ 2 © £% 2k : i . , ¢ > ts ; 4 O 5 5s 2 2 2 oe F oa ae " Ww ce un M4 w "4 a oh v4 "y gos - » e 2p: # E a 4 | ot i) v M Sa y ) wo «(CO » a Ee yy i Fo ~ ce Roos Ae jee as = @ i v 4 $ 8 & wh Se @ . B oot mde % 'Z 7 3 x tt 4 e€ & = OC mp B@ & SE wm = w - ch ' Ae "3
a) a ) ia : a "mt fat i it a on fe t fh a) ad ut w ~ St ow ~ w& fy B thes 44 , a 'tS & .
= oo 8 4 ££ BS ow 6 is B vd ie i , Oo ia « as oot, ~ we fa os = me" * t G 4 44 et S) ° 3 ot tee SE os id ut Gq GS a cy . id 3 £0 1 ~ oe Bo op BO Sh om oe ae : + ' mS 4 ; oO . . m 2 8 . es £ 8 & 8 : ran (3; $4 2) u 5 Sed thor 29 wot = te 33] a thoat at x hoe 0 feb ; pa @ 4 gc 4 nt o a at oS 8 FF of & a ae 3 iB in 4) cs oh w@ G o oF © 4 i. 2 Py ad oo G Sy By ede aoe a >, * Ly mm a ' c veh fw " - G 2» & s ge |B a as G D v '
8) ch be c re 1 by "4 Ao fant es , Bs "4 re vi kes ed ! So) of 2 ca oy ¢ rat , ' 5, 4 i om) 2. a4 & . ed . bo oe ror ee: rr Bot 8 Go ® oh an a te <H G i Q Bs G s 1% i a M4 i M4 ca £2 2 aA i Oy re Gi ea O4 No. 715/ Sean Naaa le % ee eee wot ke.
nt os Nw oa ip wo Med th G 13 ie) m wy w w cand et Ad tT a7) ean a a So & a Q oe ha ms oy its ou "e aa y cS " red "c a % as is Ed 43 @ 3 end Q ne 4d wv na Cn ki Yd 1 oy ies: ny Choe yo B ne 7 A f ty iy tis vet ed if 4 ed rod Ad hea a > eee a) x aD S ; me "rg co & a ©) ty ed ' * cs $4 on 13 Na e ed rt om . op oD God a g ae * 6 G i , co on M ca vA ™ tet " st £3 wp ans a) eg og Og , o © : rr a re od wn 0 MM oo ch 4 G @ a4 4 rd {3 u fo - oo coe nae a es a ee im et Ka na ry ty i m Mi ayed a oO mo Be | 4 fem AS ar4 Ag ty Y g a heed xf iB C3 nes aI : a : door - Sk mG H a ay) St Gj . a i 4 a) bet arog ft 44 Fe 7 i a 6 'rf ay * "a nH & roa "3 D 03 : py G ¢ a3 9) g vol ul 4 152 ce ee) ' v fie ord ve Ms "4 t . ke Td 4) ; va Ets) a & a b 4 rt : Bp ped 42 PJ Oh ay - C3 o 5G q we} , th & , 3 aS may as, ri Kg Oo go . on 5 ved a 7 o i 's) wo aa $2 és Ee) A ot 7 . a) ' Me 4 G} if .
"¢ th am , ® oj ae ved 6 its 3 is oe Go, @ 2, x bey "3 43 By nin 4 ~ , : " Ch we io eat } us A 6 rm ay y MM i) 1 HA " % "UGC pa 4 es _ a + 43 " ; a i00] G C a = bye ¥. 4 $4 1 Sai ; is) a re ? mm & re) ed et 5 ' ed ) ao O ord S. r t ba i) a ho wt "bed ba & 7 u td tC os 0 in ra rh ~ $4 43 Med (6) QO vied ce TH , a3 s € wd " Oy in Sy rs) (i $4 ey Set a ns mo Ls ee cre ns; ce o
- a w up . i ' n - hi do ci rf Mey i pO p ooo % eo mp 4 oot MOE ca) OB Q a eS, 3 rt oh orf a ve Oo 77 , ce a 44 a im od $a vi * hy CQ Po 44 oy net o C o : no af ae e a a) a (fe fy 4 a é 4) 3 > 44 in wD a , D Go 0) vy) *d 8 " :
Sy " Ci cs G " 43] na €} . kj Fes x" ord
4) 40 i @ ta bey Oy ri) 7 ae 4 4 : i , H ny ES ~. . ea 43 Apes i a ope fas 6 bad £49) cae 4 4 ad rd . " Aes. H et " $4 z ks wv J wo is) m n _ fo © : Yet . 4 Peg f e ic , es ' in a a 4 ae) a 5 ) : re aa . esd Q oy Ea i Co ca 's ao @ cs & Ad ~ ip ce het . i be a) a rd a ial va hee cs 4 2 , w ; vst s 4 co a at 2 '4 ae Oo 43 4a 5 . ws a @ os , 43 % o a M4 Set ta ied ® rn . Gh «a od o 3 o fhe Be eed yd @ ng o 3 ed, 2 wD 6 i Cr wd mp n mn o as! 3 # BO ss: O 4s "3 C a O ee : : w a) is ie 4 00 3 4 5 om 4 3 nd to 4 ae) feo Dy at fo od wi 4 is ¢ a 623 ca cs) d a a Ps f : ® w a a) Sef ra CO er . iG 6 coe £3 0% et hy ot G a @ q ce & wm ad i ris i & Gj 43 ae) 4 in ite) w zs «3 ny 4 4a % $i 019 OA NOTFLO2 ) der Kaur Oberoit Member (3) we we iBarvin