Central Administrative Tribunal - Jabalpur
Chandrahas Dixit vs M/O Defence on 2 January, 2025
1 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
Reserved
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, JABALPUR BENCH
JABALPUR
Original Applications Nos.485/2013, 486/2013, 487/2013,
550/2013 & 706/2013
Jabalpur, this Thursday, the 02nd day of January, 2025
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AKHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA, JUDICIAL MEMBER
HON'BLE MRS. MALLIKA ARYA, ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER
1. Original Application No.485/2013
1. A. N. Shukla, S/o Late R.L.Shukla Date of Birth 02.08.1960 R/o 214/1,
East Midland, Khamaria, Jabalpur - 482009 (Μ.Ρ.).
2. Smt. Mahinder Kour, W/o Late Khem Singh Date of Birth 19.11.1953
R/o H.No. 900, Near Gorakhpur Gurudwara, Jabalpur - 482002 (Μ.Ρ.).
3. R. K. Sen, S/o Late Suraj Bali Sen Date of Birth 12.07.1955 R/o 331,
Jdhav Ka Bada, Uprenganj, Jabalpur - 482002 (Μ.Ρ.).
4. K. K. MALVIYA, S/O LATE J.K.MALVIYA DATE OF BIRTH -
15.05.1956 R/O H.NO.100, CHAMPANAGAR, MANEGAON,
KHAMARIA, JABALPUR 482009 (Μ.Ρ.).
5. C.FARNANDEZ, S/O LATE JOSEPH FERNANDEZ DATE OF BIRTH
29.08.1955 R/O UNIT NO.9, KACHNAR KSHIPRA OPPOSITE
G.S.COLLEGE SOUTH CIVIL LINE, JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
6. S.N. SANYAL, S/O LATE SAMBHU NATH SANYAL DATE OF
BIRTH 15.10.1955 R/O 1408/29, A, RAKSHA KARMACHARI
COLONY, AMBEDKAR WARD, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009(MP).
Page 1 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
2 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
7. SURESH KUMAR THAREJA, S/O LATE SHRI LEKH RAJ THAREJA
DATE OF BIRTH 10.12.1958 R/O H.NO. 3119, NARSING NAGAR,
RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
8. SMT. M.D.RINGE, W/o D.C.RINGE Date of Birth 01.01.1958 R/o
H.No. 110/1, YADAV COLONY, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
9. HEMRAJ MEHRA, S/o K.L.JHARIA Date of Birth 04.05.1961 R/o
H.No. 473, GULOWATAL, GARHA, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
10. DINESH KUMAR, S/o RAM KRIPAL Date of Birth 03.09.1975 R/o
Qr.No. 10/1, Η' ΤΥΡΕ, E/L KHAMARIA, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
11. D.D.BAGHEL, S/o LALMAN BAGHEL Date of Birth 05.06.1959 R/o
H.No. 1531/1, NEAR MAHAKOUSHAL COLLEGE, CIVIL LINE,
JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
12. ASHOK KUMAR DAHIYA, LATE BAIJNATH DAHIYA Date of
Birth 15.04.1967 R/o BEHIND MISPA HIGH SCHOOL, JAI PRAKASH
NAGAR, ADHARTAL, JABALPUR 48200 (MP).
13. SMT. FRANCINA EDWIN, W/o LATE T.T.PAUL Date of Birth
07.06.1953 R/o D-A12, AKANSHA RESIDENCY, NARSING NAGAR,
RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
14. MAHENDRA KU. TIWARI, S/o J.P.TIWARI Date of Birth 14.07.1961
R/o H.No.7, KESHRI NAGAR, MANEGAON, RANJHI, JABALPUR
482009 (MP).
15. S.K.VERMA, S/o LATE S.C.VERMA Date of Birth - 02.03.1967 R/o
Qr.No.15/16, Η' ΤΥΡΕ, E/L KHAMARIA, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009
(MP).
16. ASHOK SURYAVANSHI, S/o LATE SHRI GANESH PRASAD Date
of Birth 02.07.1962 R/o N/48, ΚΑNCHGHAR COLONY, JABALPUR
482002 (MP).
Page 2 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
3 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
17. ABRAHAM V.O., S/o LATE C.OONNOONNY Date of Birth -
20.11.1955 R/o H.No.101, AKANSHA RESIDENCY, NARSING
NAGAR, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
18. TEERATH SINGH, Date of Birth 04.02.1954 R/o NEW BASTI
SARRA PIPAL BAJRANG MANDIR AZAD NAGER, JABALPUR
482002 (Μ.Ρ).
19. K.S.MARAVI, S/O SHRI RAGHUNATH SINGH Date of Birth
02.07.1959 R/o H.No.2467, GOKALPUR, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
20. S.K.BOSE, Date of Birth 08.11.1953 R/o 903, ARUNDEEP VILA,
BEYOND S.A.F. LINES, JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
21. K.R.KUMBHARE, S/o LATE R.H.KUMBHARE Date of Birth
12.04.1957 R/o H.No.3227/12A, S.B.SINGH WARD, TULSI NAGAR,
RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
22. R.P.TIWARI, S/O LATE K.P.TIWARI Date of Birth 23.02.1955 R/O
AMBE COLONY, FUTATAL, PANAGAR, JABALPUR 482006(MP).
23. BALIRAM VISHWAKARMA, S/O LATE SHRI MANIRAM
VISHWAKARMA Date of Birth - 16.01.1954 R/o H.No. 157 N.H.T.
PARIYAT, PANAGAR, JABALPUR 482006 (MP).
24. DINKAR HIRASKAR, S/o LATE KASHI RAO HIRASKAR Date of
Birth - 31.10.1954 R/o H.No.851/420, SAI KRIPA, SHARDA COLONY,
SHAKTI NAGAR, JABALPUR 482003 (MP).
25. P.R.MAHOBIYA, S/O PRITAM LAL Date of Birth 07.06.1953 R/O
VILLAGE-NEEMKHEDA, P.O.TFRI, JABALPUR 482003 (MP).
26. RAVI SHANKER NAMDEO, S/o SHRI RAM LAL NAMDEO Date of
Birth 10.08.1959 R/o H.No.3515/1, BHAGAT SINGH WARD, RAKSHA
NAGAR, BADA PATTHAR, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
Page 3 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
4 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
27. IMAM KHAN, S/o LATE BADAL KHAN Date of Birth - 26.09.1953
R/o Qr.No.14/7, 'H' TYPE, E/L KHAMARIA, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
28. SMT. SMRITI DUTTA, W/O LATE BADAL CH. DUTTA
(HUSBAND) Date of Birth 01.01.1954 R/o H.No.66, NARSING NAGAR,
NEAR KALI RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
29. S.K.GUPTA, S/O SHRI RAMESH CHANDRA GUPTA Date of Birth
21.10.1959 R/o BAJRANG NAGAR, KARMETA, JABALPUR
482007(MP).
30. SHYAM SUNDER SINGH, S/o LATE SHRI BHURE LAL THAKUR
Date of Birth - 07.07.1964 R/o H.No.532, NEW ANJALI COLONY,
RICHAI, JABALPUR 48200 7(MP).
31. D.K.PATEL, S/o LATE SHRI CHUNNI LAL PATEL Date of Birth
28.06.1960 R/o H.No.1122/1, NEW COLONY, CHERITAL, JABALPUR
482002 (MP).
32. DULI CHAND SAHU, S/O LATE JHUMAK LAL SAHU Date of
Birth 01.07.1956 R/o WARD NO.6, BARELA, JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
33. H.S.CHAUHAN, S/O LATE RAMPAL SINGH CHAUHAN Date of
Birth 01.07.1957 R/o H.No.453, KESHRI NAGAR, MANEGAON,
KHAMARIA, JABALPUR 482007 (MP).
34. JAINENDRA KU.KUREEL, S/O SEWA PRASAD Date of Birth
09.07.1955 R/o H.No.442, STREET NO.10, SADAR CANTT.,
JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
35. SMT.KAMLA RAJPUT, W/o LATE PERMESHWAR SINGH Date of
Birth 11.08.1957 R/O AMAN NAGAR, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009
(MP).
36. SUNIL KUMAR DIXIT, S/O LATE VISHWANATH DIXIT Date of
Birth - 21.06.1965 R/o G/11, KANCHGHARH, HOUSING BOARD
COLONY JABALPUR (M.Ρ.) 482001.
Page 4 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
5 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
37. P.K.CHATURVEDI, S/o LATE G.R.CHATURVEDI Date of Birth
22.03.1959 R/o K.P.PATEL BAGICHA, CHAMPANAGAR,
MANEGAON, KHAMARIA, Jabalpur 482009 (MP).
38. SMT.SUNITA SAHU, W/o LATE SHRI C.L.GUPTA (FATHER) Date
of Birth - 05.04.1959 R/o 1744, WRIGHT TOWN, JABALPUR 482002
(MP).
39. MAHAVEER KOTWAR, S/o LATE RAM KRIPAL Date of Birth
26.09.1960 R/o Qr.No.20/3, TYPE-III, WESTLAND, KHAMARIA,
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
40. SIMON XAVIER, S/o ARUL DAS Date of Birth 06.10.1963 R/o H.No.
1295, DIWANBADA, MANEGAON, RANJHI JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
41. R. S. SHRIVASTAVA, S/o KASHIRAM SHRIVASTAVA Date of
Birth 09.07.1961 R/o 222/E, N-TYPE, EASTLAND, KHAMARIA,
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
42. BALAKRISHNA PILLAI.K., S/o LATE N.K.NAIR Date of Birth -
04.03.1964 R/o Qr.No.7/8, TYPE-III, WESTLAND, KHAMARIA,
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
43. SMT.KABERI CHAKRABORTY, W/o A.K.CHAKRABORTY Date
of Birth 30.10.1963 R/o 18, ANUSHREE VIHAR, KHAMARIA,
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
44. SMT.MADHULATA KACHHI, W/o S.L.KACHHI Date of Birth -
25.06.1969 R/o 886, NORTH MILLONIGANJ, BANDHYAPURA,
JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
45. SMT.NIRMALA SHARMA, W/o KRIPA SHANKAR SHARMA Date
of Birth 10.02.1968 R/o DI, PRESTIGE TOWN, CIVIL LINE,
JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
46. PARAM SINGH GOND, S/o RAM SINGH Date of Birth - 12.10.1957
R/O VILLAGE-TIGHRA, P.O.SONPUR, JABALPUR (MP).
Page 5 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
6 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
47. K.L.INWATI, S/O LATE BABOO LAL Date of Birth 01.10.1956 R/o
H.NO.1425, SHITLAMAI, JABALPUR 482003 (MP).
48. SMT. MEENA RAIKWAR, W/o PRADEEP RAIKWAR Date of Birth
10.05.1964 R/o H.No.501, NAND NAGAR, MANEGAON, RANJHI,
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
49. SHITLA PRASAD SONI, S/O LATE BHAGWAT PD. SONI Date of
Birth 07.12.1955 R/o H.No.1003, SUBHASH NAGAR, MANEGAON,
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
50. RAMESH PD.KANOJIA, S/o LATE SHRI KASHI RAM Date of Birth
24.03.1959 R/o H.No.1034/R, ALOK NAGAR, ADHARTAL, JABALPUR
482002 (MP).
51. IMRAT LAL SONI, S/o LATE BHAWANI PD.SONI Date of Birth -
28.02.1955 R/o H.No. 1053, MAZARBALI GALI, GARHA PHAТАК,
Jabalpur 482003 (MP).
52. T.R.PATELIA, S/o LATE HANSHA PATELIA Date of Birth
03.06.1954 R/o SHARMA COMPL. SUBHASH NAGAR, MANEGAON,
RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
53. G.P.SARATHE, S/O LATE SHRI M.R.SARATHE Date of Birth
01.04.1955 R/o NEAR BADA PATTHER, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009
(MP).
54. PRADEEP KU.GHADSE, S/O LATE SHRI LAXMAN RAO Date of
Birth - 24.04.1956 R/o 76, AMBEDKAR COLONY, ADHARTAL,
JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
55. PURSHOTTAM DEKATE, S/o LATE G.V.DEKATE Date of Birth
04.11.1959 R/o T/27, GYAN PRABHA SHAKTI NAGAR, JABALPUR
482003 (MP).
56. GULAB DAS, S/o LATE ANANT RAM Date of Birth 23.07.1955 R/o
81, MAHAKOSHAL COLONY, ADHARTAL, JABALPUR 482003 (MP).
Page 6 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
7 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
57. R.S.DUBEY, S/o LATE O.P.DUBEY Date of Birth 05.03.1953 R/o
K.P.PATEL BAGICHA, CHAMPANAGAR, MANEGAON,
KHAMARIA, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
58. ASHOK KUUMAR KOSTA, S/o LATE KHUSHAL CHAND KOSTA
Date of Birth 20.06.1960 R/o H.No.321, BEHIND THE BAWLI POST,
GARHA, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
59. R.K.CHOURASIA, Date of Birth 31.01.1963 R/o 2144, KACHIYANA
MOHALLA, NA RSING H NAGAR, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
60. C.K.PAWAR, S/O LATE MANOHAR LAL Date of Birth 17.05.1961
R/o H.No.2106, KAJARWADA CANTT., JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
61. A.K.RAMA, S/o LATE RAMAJAYRAM Date of Birth 01.07.1958 R/o
H.No.1717-II, AZAD NAGAR, GOKALPUR, JABALPUR 482003 (MP).
62. S.S.SHIRPURKAR, S/o MAHADEV RAO Date of Birth 01.01.1957
R/o Qr.No.7/12, Η' ΤΥΡΕ, ΕE/L KHAMARIA, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
63. KRISHNA KUMAR, S/O RAM MANOHAR Date of Birth 01.07.1959
R/0 86, CHAMPA NAGAR, MANEGAON, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009
(MP).
64. J. L. RAJAK, Date of Birth - 18.03.1960 R/o H.NO.3140, NEAR
TIWARI BARAAT GHAR, AKTA VIHAR COLONY, RANJHI,
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
65. R.C.SAXENA, S/O LATE SHRI SHANTI PRASAD R/o 4/1,TYPE-III,
WESTLAND, KHAMARIA, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
66. LIBNUS KUJUR, S/o GERA KUJUR Date of Birth - 16.02.1955 R/o
H.No.567, SARRAPIPAL, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
67. C.L.DAHIYA, S/o LATE P.L.DAHIYA Date of Birth 01.07.1954 R/o
H.No.49, GOKALPUR, JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
Page 7 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
8 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
68. KASHI PRASAD, S/o LATE J.L.RAJAK Date of Birth 14.08.1959 R/o
H.No.306, SOUTH CIVIL LINES, SAI TAMPLE, JABALPUR 482001
(MP).
69. ASHOK KUMAR, S/o LATE JAMUNA PRASAD Date of Birth -
31.05.1963 R/o H.No.4723/50-E, J.P.NAGAR, ADHARTAL, JABALPUR
482003 (MP).
70. VILAS RAHATEKAR, S/o LATE P.D.RAHATEKAR Date of Birth -
24.12.1957 R/o BLOCK NO.2, NEW AMBAR VIHAR, GUPTESHWAR
ROAD, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
71. G.D.AMLANI, S/o SHRI K.D.AMLANI Date of Birth - 01.10.1960
R/o 227, RAVINDRA NAGAR, ADHARTAL, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
72. BHADDI LAL, LATE KASHI RAM Date of Birth - 20.05.1958 R/o
H.No.3399, AMAR NAGAR, GANESH GANJ, RANJHI, JABALPUR
482009 (MP).
73. S.N.MISHRA, S/o LATE RAMJAJIWAN MISHRA Date of Birth
15.03.1957 R/o H.No. 1885/72, KASTURWANAGAR, CHADMARI
TALAIYA, JABALPUR-482001 (MP).
74. SMT.M.DESHMUKH, W/o PRAMOD DESHMUKH Date of Birth -
19.07.1956 R/o H.No.874, P&T GATE-4, WRIGHT TOWN, JABALPUR
482002 (MP).
75. RAKESH SINGH, S/o LATE DAMODAR SINGH Date of Birth -
25.08.1959 R/o FLT.No. 205, ASHIT APARTMENT, RTO, CIVIL LINES,
JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
76. ROCKY ALEXANDER, S/o LATE J.A.CLAYTON Date of Birth
30.05.1956 R/o H.No.K.H.-16, CHAMPANAGAR, MANEGAON,
RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
Page 8 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
9 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
77 VISHNU KOL, 8/ LATE BALI KOL Date of Birth 10.02.1958 R/o
H.No.672, LALMATI, SIDHHA BABA WARD, JABALPUR 482001
(MP).
78. C.N.SUBRAMANIYAM, 8/ C.V.NARAYAN SWAMY Date of Birth
12.01.1960 R/o H.No.3135, AZAD NAGAR, RANJHI, JABALPUR
482009 (MP).
79. G.P.MARKAM, S/o LATE B.S.MARKAM Date of Birth 08.07.1956
R/o H.No.2482/1, TALAB WARD, GOKALPUR, JABALPUR 482003
(MP).
80. SAJI MATHEW, S/o LATE K.G.MATHEW Date of Birth 17.06.1969
R/o 1524/9-A, SAMDARIYA NAGAR KANCHGHAR, JABALPUR
482002 (M.P.).
81. S/o LATE C.L.BAGGA K.L.BAGGA, Date of Birth 18.02.1958 R/o
H.No.1237, P.O.-HOWBAGH, GORAKHPUR, JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
82. SMT.S.MUKHOPADHYAY, W/o LATE S.MUKHOPADHYAY Date
of Birth 01.11.1956 R/o H.No. 1408/6, R.K.COLONY, RANJHI,
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
83. MADAN, S/o MUNNA LAL KANOJIA Date of Birth 11.09.1960 R/o
FLT.No. 418, ASHIT APARTMENT, RTO, CIVIL LINES, JABALPUR
482001 (MP).
84. BHUPENDRA KUMAR, S/o K.C.RAIKWAR Date of Birth
10.04.1958 R/o H.No.609, HANUMANTAL, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
85. D.K.LODHI, S/o CHAMPALAL LODHI Date of Birth 06.06.1955 R/o
242/E, N-TYPE, EASTLAND, KHAMARIA, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
86. AJAY TIWARI, S/o LATE SHRI C.L.TIWARI Date of Birth
01.01.1961 R/o H.No.3221, TULSI NAGAR, RANJHI, JABALPUR
482009 (MP).
Page 9 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
10 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
87. B.S.CHANDEL, 8/o LATE INDERJEET SINGH CHANDEL Date of
Birth-05.06.1967 R/o H.No.256, NANAK NAGAR, MANEGAON,
KHAMARIA, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
88. B.B.SONONE, S/o LATE SHRI B.S.SONONE Date of Birth
24.05.1953 R/o PLOT NO.90, DR.AMBEDKAR COLONY SUBHASH
WARD, KATRA ADHARTAL, JABALPUR 482003 (MP).
89. A.K.VISHWAKARMA, S/o LATE LAXMI PRASAD Date of Birth
23.04.1955 R/o 676, NEAR BELBAG, POLICE STATION JABALPUR
482002 (MP).
90. R.S.PAROHA, S/o SHRI RAM SUJAN PAROHA Date of Birth
28.10.1959 R/o 318/2,'P'TYPE, KHAMARIA, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
91. JODHA SINGH, Date of Birth 14.07.1954 R/o 318/2,'P'TYPE,
KHAMARIA, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
92. C.P.CHOUBEY, S/O LATE K.L.CHOUBEY Date of Birth 28.07.1957
R/o H.NO. 3227/24 A, TULSI NAGAR, BHAGAT SINGHWARD,
RANJHI, JABALPUR, MP-482005 (MP).
93. V.G.THOMAS, S/o LATE SHRI M.V.GEORGE Date of Birth
22.05.1958 S/o H.NO. A-11, AKANSHA RESIDENCY, RANJHI,
JABALPUR, MP-482005.
94. JAGDAMBA PRASAD S/O SHRI RAM SUNDAR PD. Date of Birth -
01.07.1952 R/o PLOT NO. 457/20, Μ.Ρ.NAGAR, PHASE-II, SATNA
485001 (Μ.Ρ.).
95. MRS. K. S. ROY D/o LATE S.C.SAHA ROY Date of Birth 15.12.1952
R/o 635, MANEGAON, CHAMPANAGAR, RANJHI, JABALPUR
482005 (MP).
96. V. P. SINGH, S/o LATE LAL SINGH Date of Birth-01.07.1952 R/o
450, GHAMAPUR WARD, SARKARI KUWA. JABALPUR 482003
(MP).
Page 10 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
11 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
97. SMT. 8. BEDEKAR, W/o LATE S.V.BEDEKAR Date of Birth
17.05.1952 R/o H.No. 303, VIJAY TOWER, RANJHI, JABALPUR
482005 (MP).
98. SMT. CHHAYA SEN, W/o LATE AMITABH SEN Date of Birth
12.01.1951 R/o H.No. 405, VIJAY TOWER, RANJHI, JABALPUR
482005 (MP).
100. SMT.JITENDRA KOUR, W/o LATE JAGJET SINGH Date of Birth
01.05.1953 R/o A-3, ANUMIT ENCLAVE-II, SOUTH CIVIL LINES,
PACHPEDI ROAD, JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
101. G. P. KASHYAP, S/o LATE GORE LAL KASHYAP Date of Birth
11.05.1946 R/o A-3, ANUMIT ENCLAVE-II, SOUTH CIVIL LINES,
PACHPEDI ROAD, JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
102. PRITAM SINGH, S/o LATE C.R.PATEL Date of Birth - 20.04.1952
R/o 3238/1, TULSI NAGAR, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482005 (MP).
103. G.P.SHILPAKAR, S/o LATE C.L.SHILPAKAR Date of Birth -
28.10.1952 R/o 125, NEW TEACHER HOME, SUHAGI, JABALPUR
482009 (MP).
104. RAMESH PRASAD, S/O SHRI INDORI LAL KOSTA Date of Birth
- 01.06.1949 R/o H.No.326, DURGA CHOWK, PHOOTATAL,
JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
105. R.N.BALA, S/O LATE K.N.BALA Date of Birth - 11.05.1949 R/o
H.No.972, CHAMPANAGAR, MANEGAON, RANJHI, JABALPUR
482005 (MP).
106. N.K.TIWARI, 8/0 LATE CHHOTELAL TIWARI Date of Birth
01.04.1950 R/o H.No.3221, TULSI NAGAR, RANJHI, JABALPUR 48205
(MP).
107. S.K.TIWARI, 8/o LATE K.P.TIWARI Date of Birth-04.01.1950 R/o
VILL. RITHORI, P.O.SONPUR, JABALPUR (M.P.).
Page 11 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
12 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
108. S.S.RAJPUT, S/o LATE B.D.RAJPUT Date of Birth - 02.10.1950 R/o
H.No.329, BUDHHU KACHHI KA WADA, MANEGAON, RANJHI,
JABALPUR 48205 (MP).
109. C.L.KEWAT, S/o LATE U.L.KEWAT Date of Birth 01.01.1948 R/o
H.No.3382, GANESH GANJ, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482005 (MP).
110. B.D.SONI, S/o LATE S.N.SONI Date of Birth 12.11.1949 R/o
MARGHATAI ROAD, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482005 (MP).
111. PURSHOTTAM LAL, S/o LATE IMRIT LAL Date of Birth
01.07.1951 R/o MARGHATAI ROAD, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482005
(MP).
112. R.N.DAMBHARE, S/O LATE NAMDEO RAO DAMBHARE Date
of Birth - 08.07.1946 R/o SAKET NAGAR, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482005
(MP).
113. G.S.LODHI, S/o LATE K.S.LODHI Date of Birth - 30.09.1950 R/o
SHANDHA SADAN, BAJRANG NAGAR, VFJ ROAD, RANJHI,
JABALPUR 482005 (MP).
114. ASHA RAM, S/O LATE CHAMROO LAL Date of Birth 09.01.1951
R/O MANMOHAN NAGAR, BARA PATIHAR, RANJHI, JABALPUR
482005 (MP).
115. NET RAM, S/O LATE RAM RATAN Date of Birth 13.01.1947 H/o
NEW SONAR KERANA STORE KE PAS, NAI BASTI, RANJHI,
JABALPUR 482005 (MP).
116. P.S.MARAVI, S/o LATE B.L.MARAVI Date of Birth 26.03.1948 R/o
H.NO. 3294, SUDARSHAN WARD, GANESH GANJ, RANJHI,
JABALPUR 482005 (MP).
117. SURJEET SINGH, S/o LATE GURBACHAN SINGH Date of Birth
01.02.1953 R/o RANJHI, JABALPUR 482005 (MP).
Page 12 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
13 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
118. S.P.BURMAN, S/o LATE NOKHE LAL BURMAN Date of Birth
24.09.1948 R/o Vill. KANDRAKHODA, PANAGAR, JABALPUR-
483220 (MP).
119. R.K.MISHRA, S/o LATE HAR PRASAD MISHRA Date of Birth
09.06.1947 R/o D.D.COLONY, MANEGAON, RANJHI, JABALPUR
482005 (MP).
120. PANCHAM SINGH, S/o LATE HAZARI LAL Date of Birth
17.01.1948 R/o RANJHI, JABALPUR 482005 (MP).
121. MUNNA LAL, AGRAWAL, S/O LATE MOOL CHAND
AGRAWAL Date of Birth 01.04.1949 R/o H.No.597, UPRAINGANJ,
MOLANA KI GALI, TAMARHAI, JABALPUR. 482002 (MP).
122. PURSHOTTAM LAL KOL, S/O LATE GAJADHAR KOL Date of
Birth 18.06.1950 R/o BEHIND GOVT.SCHOOL, RICHAI, VFJ,
JABALPUR 483220 (MP).
123. D.S.THAKUR, S/o LATE GULAB SINGH THAKUR Date of Birth -
26.12.1946 R/o VILL. KASHI, P.O.-PANAGAR, JABALPUR 483220
(MP).
124. P.K.DAS, S/o LATE D.C.DAS Date of Birth - 20.03.1950 R/o H.No.
1313, DIWANBADA, MANEGAON, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482005
(MP).
125. B.N.GHOSH, S/o LATE J.N.GHOSH Date of Birth - 27.08.1946 R/o
H.No.3426/37E, BHAGAT SINGH WARD, TULSI NAGAR, RANJHI,
JABALPUR 482005 (MP).
126. K.K.CHOURASIA, S/o LATE SHRI RAMCHARAN CHOURASIA
Date of Birth 06.07.1948 R/o H.No. 136, NOOR HINDI MIDDLE
SCHOOL, PHOOTATAL, JABALPUR 482003 (MP).
Page 13 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
14 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
127. KANHAIYA RAM, S/o LATE JAGANNATH PD. Date of Birth
06.07.1948 R/o H.No.399, NAT BABA KI GALI, DIXITPURA,
JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
128. MOHD.SAHANAWAZ, S/O LATE MOHD. HAFIZ Date of Birth
20.07.1951 R/o H.No.631/21, RAMNAGAR, ADHARTAL, JABALPUR
482003 (MP).
129. SURESH SINGH, S/O LATE RADHEY SINGH Date of Birth
02.01.1950 R/o 221/E, N-TYPE, EASTLAND, KHAMARIA, JABALPUR
482009 (MP).
130. S.N.NAIDU, S/O LATE TAMBOO SWAMY Date of Birth
13.10.1948 R/o H.No.346, SONPUR ROAD, GHANA, KHAMARIA,
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
131. P.D.PANDEY, S/O LATE RAM SUJAN PANDEY Date of Birth
15.04.1946 R/o H.No.4055/1, SUBHASH WARD, KATRA, ADHARTAL,
JABALPUR 482003 (MP).
132. SMT.USHA TOMAR, W/O MOHAN SINGH Date of Birth
30.05.1956 R/o H.No. 1346, KAILASHPURI, PACHPEDI ROAD,
SOUTH CIVIL LINES, JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
133. SMT.S.N.KISHOR, W/O LATE CHHOTE LAL Date of Birth
26.01.1950 R/o H.No.1075, PL.No. 19, HOWBAG CHURCH,
NARMADA RO JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
134. CHINTAMAN KASHYAP, S/o LATE SHRI RAM PRASAD
KASHYAP Date of Birth 17.12.1949 R/O SOUTH CIVIL LINES,
JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
135. Dalchand Kewat, S/o Late Bhaddi Lal Kewat, Date of Birth -
01.11.1946, R/o H. No.964, Indira Gandhi Ward, P.O. - Garha, Jabalpur
482003 (MP).
Page 14 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
15 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
136. Smt. Annamma Thomas, W/o Shri P.V. Thomas, Date of Birth -
12.04.1952, R/o H. No.2894/10, Saket Nagar, Ranjhi, Jabalpur 482005
(MP).
- Applicants
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Department of
Defence Production, New Delhi - 110001.
2. Director General Ordnance, Directorate of Ordnance (Coordination &
Services), 10-A, S.K. Bose Road, Kolkata - 700001.
3. Chairman and Managing Director, Munitions India Lts., Regd Office :
Ammunition Factory Khadi, Pune (Maharashtra) - 411003.
4. The General Manager, Ordinance Factory Jabalpur, A unit Munitions
India Ltd. 482005.
5. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Department of
Expenditure (Implementation Cell).
- Respondents
2. Original Application No.486/2013
1. D. K. Namdeo S/o LATE DHIRAJ LAL NAMDEO Date of Birth
01.07.1958 R/o Opposite St. Joseph School Ranjhi, Jabalpur 482009
(Μ.Ρ.).
2. Shivdutt Singh, S/o Late Narayan Pd Paroliya Date of Birth 22.12.1958
R/o Diwanwada, Champanagar, Manegaon, Po-Khamaria, Jabalpur 482009
(Μ.Ρ.).
3. Girish Wate S/o Shri D. R. Wate Date of Birth 22.12.1960 R/o
Q.No.3481/B, Type-III, Sector-II, VFJ Estate, Jabalpur 482009 (Μ.Ρ.).
Page 15 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
16 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
4. Ayodha Prasad S/o Late Chhote Lal Date of Birth 01.07.1957 R/o Plot
No.47, Panchmukhi Colony, Near Shriram College, Katangi Road, Jabalpur
482001(Μ.Ρ.).
5. P.V.Varghese S/o P.V.ABRAHAM Date of Birth - 06.12.1946 R/o
Q.No.3307 Sector-II, Type-III, VFJ Estate, Jabalpur 482009 (Μ.Ρ.).
6. P.P.Sharma, S/o Late Shyam Lal Sharma Date of Birth 08.10.1953 R/o
Plot No.D/12, Patel Nagar, Maharajpur, Jabalpur 482 004 (Μ.Ρ.).
7. Govind Prasad, S/o Late Girdhari Lal Date of Birth 09.08.1954 R/o
Q.No. 1979, Sector-II, Type-I VFJ Estate Jabalpur 482004 (Μ.Ρ.).
8. Mangal Prasad BHAROSI PRASAD Date of Birth 03.12.1955 R/o
H.NO.2423, AMAR NAGAR, MAHARSHI SUDERSHAN NAGAR,
RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009 (Μ.Ρ.).
9. MAHENDRA KR JAIN, S/o LATE HUKUM CHAND JAIN Date of
Birth 10.03.1953 R/o H.NO.2102/2 NEW KANCHANPUR, PO-NEW
KANCHANPUR, JABALPUR 482 004 (M.P.).
10. K.L.CHOUDHARY, S/o LATE HARI SHANKER Date of Birth
11.04.1959 R/o 1450/2-B, GANGA NAGAR, CHANDAN COLONY,
GARHA, JABALPUR 482004 (M.Ρ.).
11. D.K,.BHARTI, S/o LATE DEO RAJ Date of Birth 13.11.1955 R/o
NAPIER TOWN JABALPUR 482002 (Μ.Ρ).
12. CYRIL CHARLES, S/o LATE ALBERT CHARLES Date of Birth
06.01.1958 R/o 1524/10-1 SAMDARIA NAGAR, NEAR FULWARI
SCHOOL, KANCHGHAR JABALPUR 482002(MP).
13. BEDI LAL SRIPAL S/o LATE K.P.SRIPAL Date of Birth 03.02.1954
R/0 19, SAKET NAGAR EXT. MANEGAON, CHAMPANAGAR, PO-
KHAMARIA, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
Page 16 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
17 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
14. SUBHASH CHAND JAIN, S/o LATE ANANT RAM JAIN Date of
Birth - 22.12.1953 R/o PLOT NO. 19 SHARDA COLONY, NEW
KANCHANPUR, JABALPUR 482004 (MP).
15. K.K.RAHANGDALE, S/o LATE DEVA RAM Date of Birth
14.07.1957 R/o H.NO.93, UTTAR MILONIGANJ, MANGAL CHANDI
MANDIR, BADHIYA MOHALLA, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
16. G.RAMCHANDRA REDDY, LATE G.APPA REDDY Date of Birth
27.01.1953 R/O TRIPURI CHOUK, JAIN CYCLES STORE, GARHA,
JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
17. RAJKUMAR THAKUR S/o LATE SHURAJPAL THAKUR Date of
Birth 01.07.1958 R/o Q.NO.1977-Β, ΤΥΡΕ-Ι. SECTOR-II, VFJ ESTATE,
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
18. GANESH NAMDEO DHENGRE S/O LATE NAMDEO DHENGRE
Date of Birth 01.07.1958 R/o H.NO.1968 NAI BASTI KAJARWARA,
POST-TEMARBHITA, THANA-CANTT. JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
19. NISHAR AHMED ANSARI, SHRI ABDUL RASHID Date of Birth
01.07.1950 R/o 1677 OPP.MPSEB, JESU, NAPIER TOWN, JABALPUR
482001 (MP).
20. HARISH CHANDRA ROY, S/O LATE MOOL CHAND Date of Birth
29.06.1950 R/o H.NO.1744, GANGA MAIYA, VFJ ESTATE,
JABALPUR-482009 (MP).
21. MILIND KUMAR S/O LATE SHRI HIRALAL Date of Birth -
08.06.1957 R/o PANDARIBA, KAMANIA GATE, JABALPUR 482002
(MP).
22. KISHAN LAL, S/o LATE PHOOL CHAND Date of Birth 01.074.1955
R/o GORA BAZAR, BILHARI, JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
Page 17 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
18 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
23. KRISHNA KUMAR DUBEY, S/o LATE S.L.DUBEY Date of Birth
16.04.1953 R/o Q.NO.3335, TYPE-III, SECTOR-II, VFJ ESTATE,
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
24. AMARJEET SINGH, S/o LATE H.S.BAGGA Date of Birth 15.07.1955
R/o Q.NO.3257 TYPE-III, SECTOR-II, VFJ ESTATE, JABALPUR
482009 (MP).
25. PREM LAL, S/O LATE CHHIJOURI LAL Date of Birth - 08.08.1955
R/o 1163, RAM NAGAR, CHITRANJAN WARD, ADHARTAL, 482004
(MP).
26. S.K.SOOD, S/o SHRI V.K.SOOD Date of Birth 10.07.1957 R/o NEAR
RAM MANDIR, JAIPRAKASH COLONY, ADHARTAL, JABALPUR.
482002 (MP).
27. SUSHIL KUMAR SAHAREY, S/o LATE VASANT SAHAREY Date
of Birth 04.10.1961 R/O BADAPATHER, J.P. MEMORIAL SCHOOL KE
PASS, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
28. BHAGIRATH PRASAD, S/o LATE GIRIDHARI LAL Date of Birth -
01.07.1962 R/o H.NO.186 SONEPUR POST OFFICE, OFK JABALPUR
482 005 (MP).
29. RAJENDRA PRASAD YADAV S/o LATE GHASIRAM YADAV
Date of Birth 04.06.1958 R/o OPP. NES SCIENCE COLLEGE, MAIN
ROAD HATHITAL JABALPUR 482 001 (MP).
30. JAGMOHAN PRASAD MISHRA S/o LATE R.L.MISHRA Date of
Birth 16.06.1957 R/o GRAM PINDRAI, BARELA, JABALPUR 482005
(MP).
31. RAM SHIROMANI TRIPATHI S/o LATE S.N.TRIPATHI Date of
Birth 30.11.1950 R/o E-7 PATEL NAGAR, PO-ADHARTAL,
MAHARAJPUR, DISTT.JABALPUR-482004 (MP).
Page 18 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
19 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
32. SANTOSH KU CHOUDHARYB S/O SHRI SUKHLAL
CHOUDHARY Date of Birth 24.09.1961 R/o Q.NO. 2607 TYPE-II
SECTOR-II, VFJ ESTATE JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
33. BHAGWAN DAS, S/O LATE BHOORE LAL Date of Birth
05.03.1956 R/o NEAR DSC LINE INDRA NAGAR, VFJ ESTATE
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
34. DEVI SINGH TEEKARAM, S/o LATE TEEKARAM Date of Birth
01.04.1953 R/o LALMATI, EAST GHAMAPUR JABALPUR 482002
(MP).
35. BISWAJIT BANERJEE S/O LATE ANIL KUMAR BANERJEE Date
of Birth 10.09.1956 R/o J.P.NAGAR, ADHARTAL, JABALPUR 482002
(MP).
36. SMT. JHARNA CHATTERJEE W/o SHRI A.K.CHATTERJEE Date
of Birth 29.06.1959 R/o Q.NO. 2113 TYPE-II SECTOR-1, VFJ ESTATE
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
37. SMT. LILLY PHILIP W/o SHRI M.K.PHILIP Date of Birth
03.11.1954 R/o NEAR GATE NO.4 RICHHAI POST RICHHAI,
JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
38. SMT.KUSUM MISHRA, S/O SHRI M.M.MISHRA Date of Birth
22.06.1954 R/o RANJHI BASTI, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
39. KUM. PRAMILLA YADALLU D/o LATE Y.L.MUNIRAJ Date of
Birth 07.01.1953 R/o RAKSHA COLONY, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009
(MP).
40. SMT.LALITA NANDESHWAR W/o B.Y.NANDESHWAR Date of
Birth 15.12.1956 R/o BADAPATHER, RANJHI, JABALPUR 482009
(MP).
Page 19 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
20 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
41. SMT. SAVITA SHARMA, W/o SHRI RAKESH SHARMA Date of
Birth 25.06.1963 R/o PATEL NAGAR, MAHARAJPUR, POST-
ADHARTAL, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
42. SMT.MEENA BANERJEE W/o LATE B.K.ACHARYA Date of Birth
02.12.1961 R/o ASIT APARTMENT, CIVIL LINES, OPP. RTO OFFICE,
JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
43. SHAILENDRA KUMAR SHARMA S/o LATE RAGHUNANDAN PD
SHARMA Date of Birth 01.07.1959 R/o KIRTI NAGAR, ADHARTAL,
JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
44. ONKAR DAS S/O LATE RAGHUNATH DASS Date of Birth
15.06.1952 R/o ARUN BOOK DEPOT, CHUNGI CHOUKI,
KANCHGHAR JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
45. P.N.PANDEY S/o LATE B.L.PANDEY Date of Birth - 01.04.1959 R/o
NEA5 HEAD POST OFFICE, CIVIL LINES JABALPUR 482001 MP.
46. F.N.UPADHYAY S/o LATE TRILOKINATH UPADHYAY Date of
Birth - 28.07.1956 R/o 2436/2 GANDHINAGAR, NEW KANCHANPUR,
ADHARTAL JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
47. RAKESH KUMAR S/o LATE HARIKRISHNA Date of Birth
01.01.1959 R/o JHANDA CHOUK, SUBHASH NAGAR, RANJHI,
JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
48. DHIRENDRA MOHAN S/o LATE C.B.L.SAXENA Date of Birth
10.08.1959 R/o 1197, VIJAY NAGAR, BEHIND KRISHI UPAJ MANDI
JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
49. RAMESH KUMAR S/O LATE RAMPRASAD KANOJIA Date of
Birth 01.06.1961 R/o 121, ASHOK NAGAR ADHARTAL JABALPUR
482002 (MP).
Page 20 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
21 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
50. RAM KUMAR PASI, S/o LATE BHAWANI PRASAD Date of Birth
03.01.1956 R/o OGI MOHALLA, GORAKHPUR, JABALPUR 482 001
(MP).
51. SURESH KUMAR YADAV S/o LATE PREMLAL YADAV Date of
Birth 01.08.1958 R/O BUNGLOW NO.5, NARMADA ROADPADAM
SETH CAMPUS, CANTT., JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
52. P.N.SONI, S/O LATE SHYAM LAL SONI Date of Birth 20.05.1953
R/O AZAD CHOUK, MAIN ROAD GORAKHPUR, JABALPUR 482201
(MP).
53. MOHAN LAL, S/O LATE NARAYAN DAS Date of Birth 18.06.1949
R/o C/O SHRI CHIDAMI LAL RAJAK, OS, G.S.SECTION, VEHICLE
FACTORY, JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
54. MOHD. SAMEEM, S/O SHRI SHEIKH MUNEER Date of Birth
15.01.1959 R/O SITA PAHAR, PACHPEDI, JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
55. R.C.CHOURASIA, S/o LATE J.P.CHAURASIA Date of Birth -
03.03.1953 R/o C/O SHRI CHIDAMI LAL RAJAK, OS, G.S.SECTION,
VEHICLE FACTORY JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
56. ARVIND SARVATE, 8/o LATE S.R.SARVATE Date of Birth
18.09.1952 R/ OPP.AGRICULTURE COLLEGE, VILLAGE SUHAGI,
JABALPUR 482004 (MP).
57. RAMPAT LAL, S/o LATE RAJKUMAR Date of Birth 05.04.1956 R/o
C/O SHRI CHIDAMI LAL RAJAK, OS,G.S.SECTION, VEHICLE
FACTORY JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
58. JAI SINGH THAKUR, S/o LATE N.S.THAKUR Date of Birth
13.06.1957 R/o NEAR GATE NO.4 RICHHAI POST RICHHAI,
JABALPUR 482005 (MP).
60. Ρ.Κ.ΒANERJEE, S/o LATE S.K.BANERJEE Date of Birth 10.11.1949
R/o KANCHANPUR, JABALPUR 482004 (MP).
Page 21 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
22 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
61. V.S.PATEL, S/o LATE N.S.PATEL; Date of Birth - 26.09.1949 R/o E-
9,VIJAY NAGAR, KACHNAR CITY, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
62. PRADEEP KUMAR GAJBHIYE S/o LATE G.C.GAJBHIYE Date of
Birth 27.08.1958 R/o KARIAPATHER EAST GHAMAPUR, JABALPUR
482002 (MP).
63. KASHI NATH VERMA S/o LATE S.L.VERMA Date of Birth
04.03.1951 R/o H.N.1187/10-A SHAKTI TIRAHA, J.P.NAGAR,
ADHARTAL JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
64. NATHU RAM GUPTA S/o LATE ACHHEY LAL GUPTA Date of
Birth 03.05.1950 R/o 475, JAGDISH MANDIR, GARHA PHATAK,
P.N.TIWARI KA WADA, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
65. LAKKHOO PRASAD TANTUWAY LATE BHAG CHAND Date of
Birth 23.06.1952 R/o 3608 GARHA WARD KORI MOHALLA PO-
GARHA, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
66. KAMAL SINGH LATE LAL BAHADUR SINGH Date of Birth -
01.05.1948 R/o 30 MAHAKOSHAL COLONY, ADHARTAL JABALPUR
482002 (MP).
67. RAMESH CHAND AWASTHI S/o LATE BIHARI LAL AWASTHI
Date of Birth 15.04.1948 R/o H.N.4 GANGAMAIYA COLONY, VFJ
ESTATE JABALPUR.
68. RAVINDRA KUMAR S/O SHRI PREM CHAND Date of Birth
15.08.1959 R/o DWARKA NAGAR, CHUNGI CHOUKI JABALPUR
482002 (MP).
69. MOHAN SINGH CHHATRIYA S/O LATE KRISHNA BAHADUR
CHATTRIYA Date of Birth 01.06.1951 R/o 1093, NEAR GUPTESHWAR
MANDIR JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
Page 22 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
23 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
70. GOURI SHANKER NAMDEO S/O SHRI NARBADA PD. NAMDEO
Date of Birth 23.06.1951 R/o H.NO.1154/1, BEHIND LIG QTR.
JAIPRAKASH NAGAR, ADHARTAL, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
71. S.K.SHRIVASTAVA, S/O LATE SHRI P.N.SHRIVASTAVA Date of
Birth - 23.09.1951 R/o 587/100 EAST, KARIYA PATHER, PO-BAI KA
BAGICHA, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
72. R.D.GOND, S/o R.D.GOND Date of Birth - 02.07.1955 R/o 2353 NEW
KANCHANPUR, LALJI KE DERI GALI, NEAR RAILWAY 3RD
BRIDGE, ADHARTAL, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
73. DURGA PRASAD LATE HARISHANKER Date of Birth 12.04.1955
R/o C/O SHRI CHIDAMI LAL RAJAK, OS,G.S.SECTION, VEHICLE
FACTORY JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
74. M.R.MANTHANWAR S/o LATE S.A.MANTHANWAR Date of Birth
15.11.1954 R/o C/O SHRI CHIDAMI LAL RAJAK, OS,G.S.SECTION,
VEHICLE FACTORY JABALPUR 482009 (MP).
75. SUDAMA PRASAD RAWAT S/O LATE DULKHAND RAWAT Date
of Birth 25.02.1950 R/o C/O, H.N.1187/10-A SHAKTI TIRAHA,
J.P.NAGAR, ADHARTAL JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
76. SHEIKΗ ΙΜΜΑΜ 8/o LATE H.SHEIKH BATAU, Date of Birth
08.11.1950 R/o H.NO.2246, BAHORABAGH CHOUK, PASIAN ROAD,
JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
77. HARI SHANKER DUBEY S/o LATE K.P.DUBEY Date of Birth
07.05.1950 R/o H.NO.2225, WRIGHT TOWN NEAR PRABHAT
BRIDGE, JABALPUR 482002 (MP).
78. BHARAT LAL SAHU S/o LATE PHOOL CHAND SAHU Date of
Birth 16.01.1950 S/o NEW RAM NAGAR ADHARTAL, JABALPUR
482002 (MP).
Page 23 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
24 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
79. DEEPAK RAMCHANDRA MULEY S/o LATE RAMCHANDRA
MULEY Date of Birth 02.05.1951 R/o 836, SANJIVINI NAGAR, POST
OFFICE, GARHA, JABALPUR 482003 (MP).
80. T.K.CHATTERJEE S/o LATE H.K.CHATTERJEE Date of Birth -
01.04.1952 R/o FLAT NO.209, D BLOCK, APSARA APPTT. SOUTH
CIVIL LINES JABALPUR 482001 (MP).
81. P.G.BEDEKAR S/o LATE GANGADHAR D. BEDEKAR Date of
Birth 01.03.1948 R/o 157 VIJAY NAGAR, MADHOTAL, JABALPUR
482001 (MP).
82. SMT. SULBHA BEDEKAR, W/o P.G.BEDEKAR, Date of Birth
21.05.1950 R/o 158 VIJAY NAGAR, MADHOTAL, JABALPUR 482001
(MP).
83. SHIV NARAYAN CHOUKSEY LATE KANDHI LAL CHOUKSEY
Date of Birth 01.07.1948 R/o SHIV NARAYAN CHOUKSEY, LIG 35,
SHIVNAGAR, HOUSING BOARD COLONY, DAMOHNAKA,
JABALPUR 482 002 (MP).
84. V.D.BRIJPURIA, JWM S/o LATE N.L.BRIJPURIA Date of Birth
08.11.1950 R/o V.D.BRIJPURIA, F-26, GOPAL BIHAR, JABALAPUR
482002 (MP).
85. Smt. Alice Chacko, W/o Shri PV Chacko, Date of Birth - 03.03.1950,
R/o Joy Villa, JNRA 40A, Vatta Pppa, Trivendrum, Kerala State 695028.
86. Smt. Aleyamma Varghese, Shri MD Samuel, Date of Birth -
15.05.1951, R/o Smt. Aleyamma Varghese, Kaimounil House, PO -
Elanthoor Pathanam Thitta, Dist. Keralal State 689643.
87. Ram Chandar Kori, Late Pannal Lal Kori, Date of Birth - 01.07.1948,
R/o Ramchandra Kori, H.No.1582/1, Bai Ka Bagicha, Jabalpur 482002
(MP).
Page 24 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
25 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
88. K.S. Koushal, OS S/o Late Shri Dasu Ram, Date of Birth - 09.01.1950,
R/o C/o 121, Ashok Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur 482002 (MP).
- Applicants
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Department of
Defence Production, New Delhi - 110001.
2. Director General Ordnance, Directorate of Ordnance (Coordination &
Services), 10-A, S.K. Bose Road, Kolkata - 700001.
3. Chairman and Managing Director, Armoured Vehicles Nigam Ltd., Regd
Office : HV Avadi Road, Chennai (T.N.) - 466654.
4. The General Manager, Vehicle Factory Jabalpur, A unit of AVNL,
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482005.
5. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Department of
Expenditure (Implementation Cell).
- Respondents
3. Original Application No.487/2013
1. Chandrahas Dixit S/o Shri Suresh Chandra Dixit DOB-01/07/1955
Qr.No.567, Type-4, Sector-2, VFJ Estate, Jabalpur -482009.
2. Gurmukh Das, Late Chandumal DOB-12/05/1961 H.No. T-4 Datt Villa,
132 Napier Town, Jabalpur-482001.
3. Smt. Aleyamma John, Late Thomas T.M DOB-02/11/956 Qr.No.579,
Type-4, Sector-2, VFJ Estate, Jabalpur -482009.
4. Pitambar Pd. Jharia Shri Ram Das Jharia DOB-16/06/1956 H.No.991/20,
New Shastri Nagar, Near Rajesh Chowk, Tripuri Ward, Garha, Jabalpur-
482003.
Page 25 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
26 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
5. B.P. Jharia Late Ramdayal Jharia DOB-12/01/1960 H.No.968, Behind
Old Police Station. Near Ram Lila Maidan, Garha, Jabalpur.
6. Remis Xaxa Late Carlus Xaxa DOB-18/01/1955 H.No.678, Near Holly
Cross church, Indira Nagar, Jabalpur - 482009.
7. Mohan Lal Choudhary Late K.L. Choudhary DOB-01/04/1956
H.No.2738, Purani Basti, Jhanda Chowk, Ranjhi, Jabalpur - 482005.
8. Najarius Lakra Late A. Lakra DOB-27/07/1962 H.No. 151, Bilpura
Colony, Near VFJ Estate, Jabalpur - 482009.
9. A.M. Bara Late Munju Bara DOB-08/08/1955 H.No.508, APR-II
Colony-2, Bilhari, Jabalpur.
10. L.N. Pathak Late R.C. Pathak DOB-19/11/1954 140, Indrapuri Colony,
Narmada Road, Jabalpur.
11. Smt. Ponnamma Surendran Late K.K. Achari DOB-27/11/1953
H.No.201, Bilpura Colony, Near VFJ Estate, Jabalpur - 482009.
12. Sugriv Prasad Late Narbad Prasad DOB-01/12/1955 H.No. 547,
Ladhiya Mohalla, Soopatal, Garha, Jabalpur - 482002.
13. Girija Shanker Late M.M. Tantuwoy DOB-26/10/1960 234, COD
Colony, Suhagi, Adhartal, Jabalpur - 482004.
14. S.K. Belwanshi Late Dhan Singh DOB-01/07/1955 Qr.No.442, Type-4,
Sector-2, VFJ Estate, Jabalpur -482009.
15. A.K. Chakravorty Late P.C. Chakraworty DOB-01/07/1954 Qr.No.502,
Type-4, Sector-2, VFJ Estate, Jabalpur -482009.
16. N.R.Garhwal Late Pooran Lal DOB-07/09/1953 H.No.3227/21, Tulsi
Nagar, Ranjhi, Kandhi Ka Bara, Jabalpur - 482005.
17. D.K. Jhariya Late Tula Ram Jhariya DOB-03/06/1956 1433, Ganga
Sagar, Koshta Mohalla, P.O. Garha, Jabalpur-482003.
Page 26 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
27 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
18. Mohd. Furquan Late Hashmatullah DOB-01/02/1961891, Ansar Nagar,
Gohalpur, Jabalpur-482002.
19. Atul Kumar Late P.L. Sharma DOB-12/03/1958 1762/15, New
Shobhapur Colony, Jabalpur -482009.
20. M.K. Shrivastava Late G.P. Shrivastava DOB-30/05/1954 H.No.B13,
Patel Nagar, Maharajpur, PO: Adhartal, Jabalpur-482004.
21. Gopal Krishna Yadav Late M.L. Yadav DOB-18/01/1955 306,
Jagdamba Nagar, Maharajpur, Jabalpur 482004.
22. Dilip Kumar Shrivas Late Ramlal Shrives DOB-01/07/1956 510/36,
SBI Officers Colony Double Story, Behind Krishi Upaj Mandi, Jabalpur.
23. Felix Barla Late Theophil Barla DOB-20/11/1953 H.No.1, Pavan
House, Behind Amba Apartment South Civil Line, Jabalpur-482001.
24. Pran Nath Jha Late A.L. Jha DOB-14/07/1960 Qr.No.580, Type-4,
Sector-2, VFJ Estate, Jabalpur -482009.
25. Manish Ahuja Late Hansraj Ahuja DOB-21/11/1970 Qr.No.490, Type-
4, Sector-2, VFJ Estate, Jabalpur -482009.
26. B.V. Frank Late L. Frank DOB-23/11/1958 Duplex No.93, Dutt
Township, Sports Club Tilhari, Jabalpur.
27. A.K. Shukla Shri J.P. Shukla DOB-01/05/1962 Flat No.304, Amba
Apartment South Civil Line, Jabalpur-482001.
28. R.K. Chakravarty Late Khushi Lal DOB-01/06/1961 H.No.482, Near
Shamshanghat, Village Richhai, Jabalpur 482010.
29. Smt. Asha Lata Dhoke Late Wasudeo Rao Moon DOB-14/04/1951 Flat
No.401, Vijay Tower, Ranjhi, Jabalpur-482005.
30. Ο.Ρ. Chate Late P. Chate DOB-01/03/1950 H.No.767, East Karia
Pathar, PO: Bai Ka Bagicha, Jabalpur - 482001.
Page 27 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
28 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
31. Smt. Pushpa Dubey Late R.R. Garg DOB-01/07/1950 1046/1, New
Shobhapur Colony, Jabalpur -482009.
32. S.K. Tiwari Late A.P. Tiwari DOB-05/02/1952 2897/4, Tulsi Nagar,
Damoh Naka, Jabalpur.
33. Smt. Savita Devi Late Mohan Singh DOB-29/10/1949 H.No.362,
Ranjhi Bazar, Chandra Shekhar Ward, Jabalpur - 482005.
34. G.L. Garehwal Late A.R. Garehwal DOB-01/06/1948 H.No.1488, Udai
Nagar No. 1, Near Durga Mandir, PO: VFJ, Jabalpur -482009.
35. Y.K. Judah Late S.D. Judah DOB-11/06/1947 H.No. 1899, Prem Nagar,
Madan Mahal, Jabalpur - 482003.
36. K.L. Rathore Late G.L. Rathore DOB-01/03/1952 H.No.706, Near
Belbaugh Police Qr. Belbaugh, Jabalpur - 482002.
37. Α.Κ. Pandey Late B.B. Pandey DOB-10/03/1950 H.No.59, Jagdamba
Society, Janki Nagar, Jabalpur - 482002.
38. L.K. Mathur Late Sarju Prasad Mathur DOB-29/09/1952 249, Ashiyana
Duplex No. 1, Napier Town, Jabalpur - 482001.
39. P. Chellan Late B. Poongan DOB-04/07/1951 H.No.343, Anjani
Colony, Near Richhai Filter Pump, Jabalpur - 482010.
40. S.P. Dixit Late Bare Lal Dixit DOB-01/07/1952 E/288, JDA Colony,
Sanjay Nagar, Ranjhi, Jabalpur - 482005.
41. D.P. Yadav Late M.P. Yadav DOB-18/05/1949 H.No. HIG 11, Puneet
Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur - 482004.
42. S.N. Lahiri Late Subimal Lahiri DOB-01/05/1952 Flat No.213, Asit
Apartment, South Civil Line, Opp. RTO, Jabalpur - 482001.
43. V.K. Mishra Late Pt. S.D. Mishra DOB-02/07/1951 H.No.840, Shakti
Nagar, Near Bhole Ki Kutiya, Jabalpur - 482001.
Page 28 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
29 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
44. R.K. Patel Late Guljari Lal Patel DOB-23/01/1951 Village: Bilgama,
PO: Singaud, Jabalpur.
45. A.K. Pandya Late B.S. Pandya DOB-01/03/1951 H.No. 16, Ashok
Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur-482004.
46. D.S. Thakur, Late B.D. Thakur, DOB - 23.09.1950, H.No.979, Galgala
Tiraha, Tilak Ward, Jabalpur - 482002.
47. A.S. Verma, Late J.N. Verma, DOB - 18/10/1946, E/280, JDA Colony,
Sanjay Nagar, Ranjhi, Jabalpur - 482005.
48. Smt. L. Ravinderan, Late Narayana Panicker, DOB - 06.12.1952, Flat
No.304, Amba Apartment, South Civil Line, Jabalpur - 482001.
49. Smt. T.S. Nair, Late Vasudevan Pillai, DOB - 05.02.1952, C/o Qr.
No.579, Type - 4, Sector -2, VFJ Estate, Jabalpur - 482009.
50. Smt. R. Sathyapal, Late Padmanabhan K., DOB - 04.08.1952, C/o Qr.
No.567, Type - 4, Sector - 2, VFJ Estate, Jabalpur - 482009.
- Applicants
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Department of
Defence Production, New Delhi - 110001.
2. Director General Ordnance, Directorate of Ordnance (Coordination &
Services), 10-A, S.K. Bose Road, Kolkata - 700001.
3. Chairman and Managing Director, Yantra India Ltd., Regd Office : C/o
The General Manager, Ordnance Factory Ambhjhari, Amravati Road,
Ambajhari, Nagpur (Maharashtra) 440021.
4. The General Manager, Grey Iron Foundry, A unit of Yantra India Ltd.,
Jabalpur (M.P.) 482009.
Page 29 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
30 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
5. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Department of
Expenditure (Implementation Cell), South Block, New Delhi 100001.
- Respondents
4. Original Application No.550/2013
1. Subir Kumar Banerjee, S/o Late P.G.Banerjee, Date of Birth 28.12.1953
R/o House. No.930/A, Alok Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur 482002 (Μ.Ρ.).
2. Ram Singh, S/o Late Tilok Singh, Date of Birth 04.05.1953, R/o Harduli
Kala, PO: Harduli Kala, Thasil:Kundum, Jabalpur (M.Ρ.) 483110.
3. R.P.Atulkar, S/o Late Tula Ram, Date of Birth - 28.06.1956, R/o
H.No.72, Badi Omti, Jabalpur-482002 (Μ.Ρ.).
4. Emmanuel Daniel William, S/o Late Daniel Willaim, Date of Birth
17.04.1953, R/o H.No. 1333/4, Pragatisheel Colony, Narbada Road,
Jabalpur - 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
5. Shambhu Prasad Jat, S/o Late Shyam Kishre Jat, Date of Birth -
05.05.1955, R/o Kanjar Muhalla, Baldeobag, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
6. Sanjay Woike, Late Shri. Dayal Singh Woike Date of Birth 30.06.1957,
R/o H.No.635/3, Ritwik Apartment, Gorakpur, Jabalpur - 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
7. Hiralal Yadav, S/o Late Gokul Prasad Yadav, Date of Birth - 10.02.1956,
R/o H.No.785-B, Shanti Nagar, Street No. 17, Damohnaka, Jabalpur -
482001 (M.P.).
8. Smt Prafullit Masih, S/o Shri Vinod Kumar Masih, Date of Birth-
09.02.1954, R/o Qr.No.135/2, Vidya Nagar, GCF Estate, Jabalpur-482001
(Μ.Ρ.).
9. Smt Karuna Pal, W/o Shri Mirinal Kanti Pal, Date of Birth - 01.06.1954,
R/o H.No.2889/11, Saket Nagar, Ranjhi, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
Page 30 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
31 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
10. S, K, Chatterje, S/o Late M.L.Chatterjee, Date of Birth - 30.06.1958,
R/o Qr.No.356/7, Type-II, Parel Line, GCF Estate, Jabalpur 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
11. Shanta Ram Wasnik, S/o Late Nanohar Wasnik, Date of Birth -
02.08.1958, R/o H.No.370,Ram Nagar Colony, Rampur, Jabalpur-482001
(M.Ρ.).
12. Smt Baby Banerjee, W/o Shri Asit Kumar Banerjee, Date of Birth -
29.11.1955, R/o H.No.106, New Adharsha Colony, Ghara Road, Jabalpur
482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
13. Gend Singh Paraste, S/o Late T.S. Paraste, Date of Birth 18.05.1955,
R/o H.No.65, Maitri Nagar, Maharajpur, Jabalpur - 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
14. Bishwa Nath Saha, S/o Late L.N. Saha, Date of Birth 01.02.1955, R/o
H.No. 765, Samikcha Town, Phace-II, North Civil Lines, Jabalpur - 482001
(Μ.Ρ.).
15. Ram Siya Yadav, S/o Late Rampadarath Yadav, Date of Birth -
01.07.1950, R/o House No. 3080, Narshing Nagar, Ranjhi, Jabalpur -
482001 (M.Ρ.).
16. Shant Kumar David, S/o Late Samuel David, Date of Birth 14.04.1954,
R/o H.No.1350/10, Near MGM School, Guptshwar Road, Jabalpur - 482001
(Μ.Ρ.).
17. Purshottam Lal, S/o Late Diwan Lal, Date of Birth - 01.06.1959, R/o
H.No. 1558, East Ghamapur, Sidh Baba Ward, Lalmati, Jabalpur-482001
(Μ.Ρ.).
18. Smt Kamalesh Khatik, W/o Late Dhani Ram Khatik, Date of Birth
18.07.1954, R/o Qr.No.1711, Near Sanker Sah Nagar, Rampur, Jabalpur-
482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
19. Smt W. Deshpande, W/o Shri P. K. Deshpande, Date of Birth
24.09.1957, R/o Kripla Chowk, Gupteshwar, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
Page 31 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
32 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
20. S. C. Jain, S/o Late K. C. Jain, Date of Birth - 27.06.1954, R/o H.No.P-
549, Shiv Nagar, Damoh Naka, Jabalpur 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
21. Raj Kumar Shrivas, S/o Late Ram Das Shrivas, Date of Birth
01.02.1955, R/o H.No.2018, New Sobhapur, Near Railway Gate, Jabalpur -
482001 (M.P.).
22. G. Sadashio Gedam, S/o Late Sadashio Gedam, Date of Birth
23.05.1953, R/o H.No.915/3-A, Behind Navin Vidhya Bhavan, Napier
Town, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
23. Subhash Chandra Jha, S/o Late Daya Ram Jha, Date of Birth
26.01.1952, R/o Flat No.306, Block - D, Apsara Apartment, Civil Line,
Jabalpur 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
24. Rajesh Kumar Sharma, S/o Late B. N. Sharma, Date of Birth
16.05.1955, R/o House. No. 201, Vijay Tower, Ranjhi. Jabalpur 482001
(M.Ρ.).
25. Santosh Kumar Sinha, S/o Late B. P. Sinha, Date of Birth - 09.07.1957,
R/o H.No.715, Samdariya Colony, Kanch Ghar, Jabalpur - 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
26. Sheo Narayan Singh, S/o Late Deo Singh Thakur, Date of Birth -
23.06.1954, R/o H.No.400, East Ghamapur, Lalmati, Jabalpur - 482001
(M.P.).
27. Mahesh Kumar Kori, S/o Late Mewa Lal Kori, Date of Birth
26.06.1956, R/o H.No. 177, Tulsi Mohalla, Bai ka Bagacha, Jabalpur-
482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
28. Amar Singh Verma, S/o Shri Hari Singh Verma, Date of Birth -
01.02.1956, R/o Qr.No. 138/1, Vidhya Nagar, GCF Estate, Jabalpur-482001
(Μ.Ρ.).
29. Smt Narbad Kusmakar, Late H. L. Kusmakar, Date of Birth 05.07.1958,
R/o H.No. 19/B-5, Sai Bihar, Near Railway Crossing, Rampur. Jabalpur -
482001 (M.P.).
Page 32 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
33 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
30. Saranjeet Singh, S/o Late Jaswant Singh, Date of Birth - 10.05.1953,
R/o B.No.61/2, Ranjeet Singh Marg, GCF Eastate, Jabalpur - 482001
(Μ.Ρ.).
31. Kanchhedi Lal Kotwar, S/o Late Pardeshi Lal Kotwar, Date of Birth
01.01.1958, R/o H.No. 4204, East Ghamapur, Kanchghar, Jabalpur - 482001
(Μ.Ρ.).
32. Bhogiram, S/o Late Mansha Ramss, Date of Birth - 01.03.1951, R/o
H.No.783, Adarsh Nagar Colony, Manegaw, Ranjhi, Jabalpur - 482001
(Μ.Ρ.).
33. Purshottam, S/o Late Mullu, Date of Birth 10.01.1956, R/o H.No.63,
Saini Colony, Behind Bailpura Talab, Bilpura, Jabalpur - 482001 (M.Ρ.).
34. Ramesh Chandra, S/o Late Sadhu Ram Shori, Date of Birth 03.12.1954,
R/o H.No. 1439/1, Raksha Karamachari Colony, Ambedhar Ward, Ranjhi,
Jabalpur - 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
35. Arun Kumar Saxena, S/o Late B. P. Saxena, Date of Birth - 17.07.1954,
R/o H.No. 4928, Punit Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur - 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
36. Som Nath Pandey, S/o Late Baleswar Pandey, Date of Birth 11.12.1951,
R/o Qr/No.2/15, Goa Line, GCF Estate, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
37. Pradeep Kumar Tiwari, S/o Late B. M. Tiwari, Date of Birth
01.07.1954, R/o H.No. 1101/2, Infront of Hanuman Mandir, Yadav Colony,
Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
38. Ram Sewak Soni, S/o Shri Amrit Lal Soni, Date of Birth - 27.03.1963,
R/o H.No.829, Anjani Parisar, Opp, Mishra Compund, B. T. Tiraha, Garha,
Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
39. Lal Ji Sonkar, S/o Late Teji Lal Sonkar, Date of Birth 10.09.1959, R/o
H.No. 1280/1749, Near Radhaswami Satsang Point, Narsingh Nagar,
Ranjhi, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
Page 33 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
34 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
40. Ram Singh Rajput, S/o Shri T. S. Rajput, Date of Birth - 05.03.1961,
R/o H.No.07, Shiv Nagar, Garha Railway Crossing, Jabalpur-482001
(Μ.Ρ.).
41. Shailesh Kumar Khare, S/o Shri Ram Singh Khare, Date of Birth
23.03.1964, R/o HIG/18, Housing Board Complex, Station Road,
Kanchghar, Jabalpur-482002 (Μ.Ρ.).
42. Ashok Kumar Kori, S/o Late Chetram Kori, Date of Birth 01.07.1969,
R/o H.No.103/A, Om Nagar, Basti No.2, Amkhera Road, Gohalpur,
Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
43. Kailash Singh Thakur, S/o Late Ganga Ram Thakur, Date of Birth -
02.12.1953, R/o B.No.06, New Sharda Colony, Kanchanpur, Jabalpur-
482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
44. Sant Lal, S/o Shri Ghasi Ram, Date of Birth 11.12.1951, R/o H.No.381,
Mandla Road, Bilhari, Jabalpur-482001 (M.P.).
45. Smt Reena Mukherjee, W/o Shri Subhash Mukherjee, Date of Birth-
03.10.1958, R/o H.No. J/2, Burn & Comp. Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
46. J. S. Saxena, S/o Late Ram Saran Lal, Date of Birth 13.12.1954, R/o
H.No.665, Samiksha Town, North Civil Line, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
47. Smt Premwati Shalwar, W/o Late Bishram Dharanwanshi, Date of
Birth-01.07.1954, R/o H.No. 101, Kushwaha Parishar, Pragati Nagar-IV
Mile, Tilheri, Jabalpur-482001 (M.P.).
48. Mumtaz Ahmed Khan, S/o Shri Murtaza Khan, Date of Birth -
05.09.1961, R/o H.No.981/2, Naya Mohalla, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
49. Ramlal Kol, S/o Late Bhaiya Lal Kol, Date of Birth 15.03.1956, R/o
H.No.800, Manegoan Purani Basti, Ranjhi, Jabalpur-482001 (MΜ.Ρ.). 50.
Anup Majumdar, S/o Shri P. L. Majumdar, Date of Birth 16.06.1961, R/o
H.No.06, Jawhar Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur 482001 (M.Ρ.).
Page 34 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
35 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
51. Kamal Kishore Koshta, S/o Shri Chokhelal Koshta, Date of Birth -
20.07.1960, R/o H.No. 113, Sai Colony, Sanchar Nagar, Deendayal Chok,
Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
52. Arun Kumar Khare, S/o Late M. L. Khare, Date of Birth - 01.05.1958,
R/o H.No.111, Ashok Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
53. Prabhu Das Bain, S/o Late Devi Deen, Date of Birth - 20.05.1955, R/o
H.No.2903, Sonvalaya Sidh Baba Ward, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
54. A. K. Shrivas, S/o Late Badri Prasad, Date of Birth24.05.1956, R/o
H.No.2043, Alok Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
55. Smt Munni Parste, W/o Shri Vijay Bahadur Praste, Date of Birth-
01.06.1959, R/o H.No.322, Shukla Nagar, Garha, Jabalpur-482 003 (Μ.Ρ.).
56. Ramchandra, S/o Late Badri Prasad, Date of Birth 02.07.1949, R/o
H.No. 1176/F, Modi Bada, Near APN School, Cantt., Jabalpur 482001
(M.P.).
57. Shanker Lal Sahu, S/o Late Nokhe Lal Sahu, Date of Birth 01.07.1959,
R/o H.No.118/17, Ram Nagar, Garha Phatak, Jabalpur 482003 (Μ.Ρ.).
58. Parmanand Sen, S/o Late Chhummoon Sen, Date of Birth-01.11.1951,
R/o Village: Bilpura, Purani Basti, P.O: V FJ, Jabalpur 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
59. Narayan Prasad Sharma, S/o Late Ranbir Sharma, Date of Birth
01.07.1956, R/o Qr.No.196/3, Vidhya Nagar, GCF Estate, Jabalpur 482001
(Μ.Ρ.).
60. Vinod Kumar Khare, S/o Late M. L. Khare, Date of Birth 30.06.1960,
R/o H.No.111, Ashok Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
61. Shyam Sunder Dixit, S/o Late N. P. Dixit, Date of Birth - 25.02.1956,
R/o Qr.No.375/1,Type-II, Panhera, GCF Estate, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
Page 35 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
36 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
62. Laxmi Narayan Soni, S/o Late D. L. Soni, Date of Birth 30.09.1953, R/o
H.No.615, B. T. Tiraha, Gulauwa Tal, Om Abhushan, Garha, P.O. Garha,
Jabalpur - 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
63. Rajesh Kumar Tiwari, S/o Late B. L. Tiwari, Date of Birth - 24.05.1952,
R/o H. No.481, Rani Tal, Garha Road, Jabalpur - 482001 (M.P.).
64. Ku. Arti Das, D/o Late A. C. Das, Date of Birth 03.07.1956, R/o
Qr.No.123/3, New Tute Line, GCF Estate, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
65. Smt Lizy Kunjumon, W/o Late O. Kunjumon, Date of Birth -
01.12.1957, R/o Flat. No.208, Ashit Apartment, Civil Line, Jabalpur-
482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
66. L. N. Pillai, S/o Late Ashok Pillai, Date of Birth - 27.07.1950, R/o
Bunglow No.03, Premnath Compound, Cantt., Jabalpur 482001 (M.P.).
67. Kailash Chandra Khatri, S/o Late B. K. Khatri, Date of Birth
01.07.1951, R/o H.No. 1975, P.O. Premnagar, Madan Mahal, Jabalpur -
482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
68. A. K. Manodhya, S/o Shri Mouji Lal, Date of Birth 08.05.1950, R/o
H.No.1393, Anand Kunj Market, Garha, Jabalpur 482001 (M.Ρ.).
69. Narayan Pd. Pandey, S/o Late Bhawati Pd. Pandey, Date of Birth -
01.07.1953, R/o H.No. 1187/NB, Shakti Teraha, Jai Prakash Nagar,
Adhartal, Jabalpur-482201 (Μ.Ρ.).
70. Vijay Singh Rathore, S/o Late S. Rathore, Date of Birth - 30.06.1957,
R/o H.No.249, Gram Madai, Near.VFJ Masgid, Ranjhi Thana, Jabalpur-
482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
71. A. K. Verma, S/o Late S. N. P. VERMA, Date of Birth 1.02.1959, R/o
Bunglow No.T-7/B, Type-IV, Upper Line, GCF Estate, Jabalpur - 482009
(Μ.Ρ.).
Page 36 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
37 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
72. Arun Kumar Diwan, S/o Late G. P. Diwan, Date of Birth 27.11.1952,
R/o B. No. 72/21/, New Cloney. Type-IV, GCF Estate, Jabalpur - 482009
(M.P.).
73. D. P. Jharia, S/o Late Banke Lal Jharia, Date of Birth - 21.11.1955, R/o
H.No. 1658, Ambadker Ward, Near Tripathi Building, Ranjhi Purani Basti,
Jabalpur-482009 (Μ.Ρ.).
74. Smt Nalini George, W/o Shri E George, Date of Birth - 05.12.1950, R/o
Plot.No.205, Gwari Ghat, Jabalpur 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
75. Kailash Singh Yadav, S/o Late Darshan Singh Yadav, Date of Birth -
12.07.1952, R/o Sadar Bazar, Jabalpur (M.P.).
76. Virendra Kumar, S/o Late T. V. Parmanand Pillai, Date of Birth -
09.04.1948, R/o H. No. 772, Sadar Bazar, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
77. Smt. Thankamma Mani Nair, W/o Shri Manikatan Nair, Date of Birth -
28.04.1952, R/o Sadar Bazar, Jabalpur - 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
78. Lalit Kumar Raj, S/o Late Hira Lall Raj, Date of Birth - 01.07.1951, R/o
H. No. 2398/3, Bedi Nagar, Nagpur Road, Jabalpur 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
79. Purnima Shukla, W/o Late R. N. Shukla, Date of Birth 19.09.1957, R/o
Qr.No.132/3, Vidhya Nagar, GCF Estate, Jabalpur - 482009 (MΜ.Ρ.).
80. Pushpa Chouhan, W/o Late J. S. Thakur, Date of Birth - 08.01.1957, R/o
B. No. B. 11, Samdaria Resident, Behore Bag, Jabalpur 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
81. Smt Lalita Yadav, W/o Shri Roop Lal Yadav, Date of Birth 15.10.1951,
R/o B.No. 12, N.E.S.Coloney, Gorakpur, Jabalpur - 482001 (M.P.).
82. Mahesh Prasad, S/o Late Moti Lal, Date of Birth - 18.12.1958, R/o
H.No.9-1/3, Malik Compound, Sadar, Jabalpur - 482001 (M.P.).
83. Brij Lal Bhumiya, S/o Late Kallu Ram Bhumia, Date of Birth
05.05.1955, R/o H.No.01, Kishani Mohalla, Barela, Jabalpur - 482001
(M.P.)
Page 37 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
38 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
84. Krishna Kumar Mishra, S/o Late G. P. Mishra, Date of Birth
27.04.1950, R/o Sadar, Jabalpur - 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
85. Ashok Kumar Gupta, S/o Late S. P. Gupta, Date of Birth 10.09.1955,
R/o H.No.222, Gokalpur, Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
86. Kishore Kumar Malik, S/o Late S. L. Malik, Date of Birth 14.09.1956,
R/o H.No.A-13, Sai Colony, Suhagi, Jabalpur - 482004 (Μ.Ρ.).
87. Prem Kant Mishra, S/o Late B. N. Mishra, Date of Birth - 04.06.1949,
R/o H.No.790, Sneh Nagar Coloney, Jabalpur 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
88. Arvind Kumar Namdeo, S/o Late N. D. Namdeo, Date of Birth -
01.07.1957, R/o H.No.295, Kotwali Ward Hanuman Tal, Jabalpur 482002
(Μ.Ρ.).
89. Smt Susamma Thomas, W/o Shri K. M. Thomas, Date of Birth
15.12.1952, R/o Flat No. 15, Prestige Apartment, Civil Line, Jabalpur
(M.P.).
90. R. S. Saxena, S/o Late R. S. L. Saxena, Date of Birth 01.07.1950, R/o
H.No.665, Samiksha Town, North Civil Line, Jabalpur - 482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
91. Shiv Shankar Thakur, S/o Late Udit Narayan Thakur, Date of Birth -
01.07.1959, R/o Qr.No.3038, New Coloney, Sector-II, GCF Estate, Jabalpur
482009 (Μ.Ρ.).
92. Jageshwar Prasad Jharia, S/o Late C. L. Jharia, Date of Birth
14.11.1958, R/o H.No.825, Near Sindhi Timber, Durga Bai Ka bagacha, B.
T. Road, Garha, Jabalpur - 482002 (M.P.).
93. Praveer Kumar Bose, S/o Shri S. L. Bose, Date of Birth- 27.05.1958,
R/o Qr.No.367/5, Parel Line, GCF Estate, Jabalpur - 482009 (Μ.Ρ.).
94. Tapan Kumar Das, S/o Late S. M. Das, Date of Birth - 01.07.1957, R/o
Good Luck Apartment MIG-I, IInd Floor, Katanga, Narmada Road,
Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
Page 38 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
39 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
95. Ku Mena Pali, D/o Late Ram Bjarose, Date of Birth 04.07.1957, R/o
Qr.No.370/7, Parel Line, GCF Estate, Jabalpur 482009 (Μ.Ρ.).
96. Barun Ku. Chowdhury, S/o Late B. M. Chowdhury, Date of Birth
17.05.1952, R/o H.No.17/A, Vatika Vihar, Near Saket Nagar, Ranjhi,
Jabalpur 482009 (Μ.Ρ.).
97. Smt Shashi Raikwar, W/o Late Rajesh Raikwar, Date of Birth
14.01.1957, R/o H.No.631, Goutam Ganj, Gwarahat, Jabalpur 482001
(Μ.Ρ.).
98. Ashok Kumar Parey, S/o Shri.S.L.Parey Date of Birth - 02.05.1952, R/o
H.No.140/4, Type, Vidhya Nagar, GCF Estate, Jabalpur 482009 (Μ.Ρ.).
99. Sunder Lal Dubey, S/o Late J. P. Dubey, Date of Birth - 01.07.1951, R/o
H.No. 1514, Lalmati, Near Gopal Hotel, Jabalpur 482002 (MP).
100. Shyam Sunder Singh, S/o Late Ram Saran Singh, Date of Birth -
04.02.1958, R/o H.No. 1877, New Sobhapur Coloney, VFJ Road, Jabalpur
482009 (MP).
101. Onkar Prasad Namdeo, S/o Late Kalu Ram Namdeo, Date of Birth -
25.07.1949, R/o Plot No.59, Jwhar Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur 482004 (MP).
102. Reoti Prasad Tiwari, W/o Shri Ram Nath Tiwari, Date of Birth
30.10.1951, R/o H No.75, Sharda Bhawan, Shivnagar, Garaha, Jabalpur -
482002 (MP).
103. Raj Kumar Noah, S/o Late D. Noah, Date of Birth 02.09.1956, R/o
H.No.07, Brij Mohan Nagar, Chapper, Rampur, Jabalpur 482004 (MP).
104. Shyam Lal Wadiwa, S/o Late Fach Singh, Date of Birth 12.02.1954,
R/o H.No.748, Adharsh Nagar, Mane Gao, Jabalpur -482009 (MP).
105. Roop Lal Kori, S/o Shri.R.L.Kori Date of Birth 15.12.1951, R/o
H.No.414, Tulsi Mohalla, Baika Bagacha, Ghamapur, Jabalpur-482002
(MP).
Page 39 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
40 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
106. R.K.Dubey, S/o Late D. D. Dubey, Date of Birth 13.06.1958, R/o
H.No.515, Near Bada Jain Mandir, Garha, Jabalpur - 482002 (MP).
107. Smt Mercy Singh, W/o Shri Rajendra Singh, Date of Birth -
24.11.1952, R/o Tilahari, Jabalpur 482004 (MP).
108. Animesh Dutta, S/o Late.Shri.P.C.Dutta, Date of Birth - 21.07.1950
R/o H.No.TF-7, Rada Tower. Ranjhi, Jabalpur - 482009 (MP).
109. P.R.Sugathan, S/o Late.Shri.P.K.Ragawan Date of Birth 18.06.1951
R/o Pezaunilkkunnathil House.P.P. Peringala, Mulakuzha, V
ill.Chengannur, Alapuzha, Dist. Kerla - 678581.
110. Chanwar Jay Singh Maravi, S/o Late Jay Singh Maravi, Date of Birth -
03.08.1953 R/o Qr, No. 132/2,Old Vidya Nagar. GCF Estate, Jabalpur
48209 (MP).
111. Albert Mandal, S/o Late.Shri.R.S.New Ram Date of Birth 14.08.1958
R/o H.No. 1351, New Ram Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur - 482002 (MP).
112. Cyril Dsouza, S/o Late Alex Dsouza Date of Birth - 09.02.1954 R/o
H.No.44/7, Mahavir Compound, Sadar, Jabalpur-482001 (MP).
113. Arthur Masih, S/o Late L. B. Masih, Date of Birth 13.09.1952 R/o
H.No.308, Sarkari Kuaw, Bai ka Bagacha, Jabalpur 482002 (MP).
114. Ravi Shanker Khare, S/o Late Sita Ram, Date of Birth - 04.04.1951
R/o H.No.302, Dhobi Ghat, Bhongadwer, Cantt., Jabalpur 482001 (МР).
115. Mohd Saleem Khan, S/o Late M.A.Khan Date of Birth 12.06.1951 R/o
H.No.368/53/A, Nai Basti Ghohalpur., Jabalpur 482002 (MP).
116. Ram Lakhan Sharma, S/o Late R. N. Sharma, Date of Birth 04.01.1949
R/o H.No.4574, Sanjay Nagar, Subhash Ward. Adhartal, Jabalpur 482002
(MP).
117. Deorao Gajbe, S/o Late Vitthlarao Gajbe, Date of Birth - 21.06.1950
R/o H.No.73, Sattanand Bihar, Rampur, Jabalpur -482001 (MP).
Page 40 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
41 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
118. Smt Suman Verma W/o Late J.S.Verma Date of Birth 10.03.1952 R/o
B.No.960, Saket Extn. Champanagar, Managaw, Ranjhi, Jabalpur 482009
(Μ.Ρ.).
119. Francis Anthony, S/o Late John Lazras Date of Birth 16.05.1951 R/o
Issai Mohalla Gorakpur, Jabalpur-482002 (Μ.Ρ.). 120. Smt. Basanti
Anthony, W/o Shri J. S. Anthony Date of Birth - 24.10.1951, R/o
H.No.87/A, Narmada Nagar, Polypathar, Gwarighat, Jabalpur-482001 (MP).
121. Narayan Chandra Sen, S/o Late Gobinda Ch. Sen Date of Birth
13.02.1951 R/o Flat No.201 Dutt & Chandha Enclave, South Civil Line,
Jabalpur-482001 (Μ.Ρ.).
122. Mohan Lal Kosta, S/o Late C. L. Kosta Date of Birth 16.03.1951 R/o
House. No. 122/3, North Milonganj, Damonaka, Jabalpur 482002 (Μ.Ρ.).
123. Asho Kumar Rajput, S/o Late H. S. Rajput Date of Birth - 03.01.1958
R/o 4/57, Behor Bag, Jabalpur 482002 (Μ.Ρ.).
124. Bhasker Rao Landge S/o Shri H. S. Rajput Date of Birth 16.11.1958
R/o Anand Coloney Beldeo Bag, Jabalpur 482002 (Μ.Ρ.).
125. Bhoore Lal Kori S/o Late Chhote Lall Kori Date of Birth 03.01.1952
R/o Nai Basti Ranjhi, Jabalpur - 482009 (Μ.Ρ.).
126. I. B. Mishra S/o Late R. B. Mishra Date of Birth 12.06.1954 R/o C-8
Top Floor Atul Bihar, Wrigh Town, Jabalpur -482002 (Μ.Ρ.).
127. Shyamsunder Satnami, S/o Late Jhagroo Date of Birth - 02.10.1949
R/o H.No.491, Sanjay Gandhi Ward, Kanch Ghar, Jabalpur - 482002
(Μ.Ρ.).
128. S. S. Bais, S/o Late P. S. Bais, Date of Birth - 23.07.1949 R/o New
Ram Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur 482002 (MP).
129. J. P. Sahu S/o Late C. Sahu Date of Birth 18.05.1955 R/o 150,
Khaipura Bhantalaiya, Jabalpur 482002 (Μ.Ρ.) - Applicants
Page 41 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
42 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Department of
Defence Production, New Delhi - 110001.
2. Director General Ordnance, Directorate of Ordnance (Coordination &
Services), 10-A, S.K. Bose Road, Kolkata - 700001.
3. Chairman and Managing Director, Advanced Weapons and Equipment
India Ltd., (A WEIL), Regd Office : Ordnance Factory Kanpur, Kalpi Road,
Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh - 208009.
4. The General Manager, Gun Carriage Factory - A Unit of A WEIL
482005.
5. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Department of
Expenditure (Implementation Cell).
- Respondents
5. Original Application No.706/2013
1. All India Association of Clerical Employees of Ordnance Factories
through its President, Shri C.L. Rajak, C/o Vehicle Factory, Jabalpur -
482009 (M.P.).
2. G.L. Bhatnagar, S/o Late Chandrika Prasad Bhatnagar, Date of Birth -
19.05.1955, R/o 548, Choti Omti, Near Sportsmen Tea Stall, Jabalpur -
482002 (M.P.).
- Applicants
(By Advocate : Shri Akash Choudhury in all five OAs)
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Department of
Defence Production, New Delhi - 110001.
Page 42 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'
43 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
2. Director General Ordnance, Directorate of Ordnance (Coordination &
Services), 10-A, S.K. Bose Road, Kolkata - 700001.
3. Chairman and Managing Director, Ordnance Factories Board, 10-A, S.K.
Bose Road, Kolkata - 700001.
4. The Chief General Manager, Ordnance Factories Board, 10-A, S.K. Bose
Road, Kolkata - 700001.
5. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Department of
Expenditure (Implementation Cell).
- Respondents
(By Advocate - Shri Surendra Pratap Singh in all five OAs)
(Date of reserving order : 12.12.2024)
COMMON ORDER
By Akhil Kumar Srivastava, JM.-
The applicants are seeking benefit of Grade Pay of Rs.4600/- in the revised scale of pay of Rs.6500-10500 corresponding to the pre-revised scale of Rs.7450-11500 in terms of the Office Memorandum dated 13.11.2009 (Annexure A-1) issued by the Ministry of Finance, Department of Expenditure Implementation Cell.
2. Since the issue involved in all the five Original Applications is common in nature, all these Original Applications are decided by way of a Page 43 of 56 ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 44 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs common order. While the learned counsel for the applicants argued from the documents annexed in OA 706/2013, learned counsel for the respondents referred to the reply placed on record in OA 550/2013. Hence, these two Original Applications have been referred to for the purpose of this order.
3. Brief facts of the case as projected in OA 706/2013 are that there were four clerical grades in Indian Ordnance Factories under Ministry of Defence and Central Govt. offices in India, in pursuance to the recommendations of the 5th CPC. These grades were LDC having pay scale of Rs.3050-4550; UDC Rs.400-6000; Assistant Rs.5000-8000 and Office Superintendent having pay scale of Rs.5500-9000.
3.1 The LDC Group C post is an induction/appointment grade post in the Indian Ordnance Factories along with all Central Govt. organisations. Similarly, UDC, Assistant and Office Superintendent are Group C posts of departmental promotion grades from the feeder grade, i.e. LDC. Subsequently, the post of Office Superintendent was notified as Group B Non-Gazetted post having pay scale of Rs.5500-9000. 3.2 In the 6th CPC, there were three clerical grades viz; LDC having Grade Pay of Rs.1900/-, UDC Grade Pay of Rs.2400/- and Office Superintendent Page 44 of 56 ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 45 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs (merger of Assistant & Office Superintendent) having Grade Pay of Rs.4200/-, in Indian Ordnance Factories along with other Directorates under Ministry of Defence and Central Govt. Offices in India. 3.3 As per the 6th CPC's Gazette Notification, it was recommended that pre-revised pay scale of Rs.5500-8000 and Rs.5500-9000 in respect of Assistant and OS should be merged/upgraded with the pay scale of Rs.6500- 10500 pre-revised in case of merged OS. As such, an order dated 29.08.2008 (Annexure A-4) was issued by the Ministry of Finance. Therefore, in terms of the aforesaid order, there would be only one identical pay scale of Rs.6500-10500 (pre-revised) for Assistant and OS, i.e. merged OS.
3.4 In terms of Ministry of Defence letter dated 01.10.2009 (Annexure A-
5), the Assistants were merged with OS w.e.f.01.01.2006. However, the order issued by the Ministry of Finance dated 29.08.2008 was not implemented and the pay was fixed on the basis of pre-revised pay scale of Rs.5000/- and Rs.5500/- for Assistant and OS respectively w.e.f.01.01.2006. Although Assistant Grade and OS was merged together but the identical pay scale of Rs.6500/- was not granted to them.
Page 45 of 56
ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 46 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs 3.5 Further the Pay Band-2 of Rs.9300-34800 for OS is not justified in as much as the initial pay of Rs.9300/- was calculated on the basis of Basic Pay of Rs.5000/- (pre-revised) by calculating 1.86 factor as per the 6 th CPC, which was not in existence in terms of order dated 29.08.2008. Since the basic pay of OS was upgraded to Rs.6500/-, the initial pay for merged OS would be Rs.12,100/- (Rs.6500 x 1.86 factor = Rs.12090 rounded as Rs.12100/-). Therefore, the basis pay for merged OS should be initially Rs.12100/- under PB-2, instead of Rs.9300/-. 3.6 The Ordnance Factory Board, Kolkata vide order dated 10.02.2009 (Annexure A-6), has sanctioned upgraded pay scale of Rajbhasha Cadre in Ordnance Factory organization. As per the said order, the pre-revised scale of Rs.5000-8000 has been revised to Rs.6500-10500 (PB-2, Grade Pay Rs.4200/-) and pay scale of Rs.5500-11500 has been revised to Rs.7450- 115000 with Grade Pay Rs.4600/-. Therefore, as per the 6 th CPC fixation, their initial pay scale was fixed to Rs.12090/- and Rs.13860/- respectively. 3.7 The Principal Bench of this Tribunal at New Delhi in OA No.1165/2010 decided on 09.04.2010 as also the co-ordinate Bench at Ernakulam in OA No.856/2011 dated 13.07.2012 have observed that pay Page 46 of 56 ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 47 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs scale of Rs.5000-8000 would be merged with pre-revised scale of Rs.6500- 10500 (i.e. fixation of initial basic pay of Rs.12090/-). Similarly, pay scale of Rs.5500-9000 would be merged to pre-revised scale of Rs.7450-11500 (i.e. fixation of initial basic pay of Rs.13860/-). 3.8 Since the pay of the applicants was not fixed properly, they have raised their grievance before the Ordnance Factory Board but to no avail. The applicants submit that their case squarely falls within the ambit of the OM dated 13.11.2009 (Annexure A-1) issued by the Ministry of Finance and, therefore, they are required to be fixed in the pay scale of Rs.6500-10500 revised as Rs.9300-34800 in the Grade Pay of Rs.4600/-.
4. The respondents, in their reply to OA 550/2013 have stated as under:
4.1 There are 129 applicants in OA 550/2013. Out of 129 applicants, who applicants at Sl. Nos.38 and 57 are holding the post of Personal Secretary, Gr. "B" Gazetted Officer, having different mode of recruitment and different channel of promotion. Therefore, they cannot join together along with the other applicants. Similarly, applicants at Sl. No.39 to 42 are Personal Assistant having different mode of recruitment.Page 47 of 56
ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 48 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs 4.2 None of the applicants were in the pre-revised pay scale of Rs.6500- 10500 as on 01.01.2006 and hence they are not entitled for Grade Pay of Rs.4600/- in terms of OM dated 13.11.2009. The applicants cannot be equated with the employees who were in the pre-revised pay of Rs.6500- 10500 to make them entitled to Grade Pay of Rs.4600/-. 4.3 As on 01.01.2006, some of the applicants were in the pay scale of Rs.5000-8000 and some were in the pay scale of Rs.5500-9000 and to rationalize the pay scales and bring them under one Pay Band, i.e. PB-2, the 6th CPC recommended to merge three pre-revised scales of pay of Rs.5000- 8000, 5500-9000 and 6500-10500 with normal replacement pay structure of Grade Pay of Rs.4200/- in PB-2. The Pay Commission also recommended that in case it is not feasible to merge the posts in these pay scales on functional consideration, the posts in the scale of Rs.5000-8000 and 5500- 9000 should be merged with the posts in the scale of Rs.6500-10500 being upgraded to the next higher grade in the PB-2 with Grade Pay of Rs.4600/- corresponding to the pre-revised scale of Rs.7450-11500. In case a post already exists in the scale of Rs.7450-11500, the post being upgraded from Page 48 of 56 ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 49 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs the scale of Rs.6500-10500 should be merged with the post in the scale of Rs.7450-11500.
4.4 Consequent upon the notification of CCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008, the Department of Expenditure received large number of references from various Ministries proposing up-gradation of the posts which were in the pre-revised scale of Rs.6500-10500 in PB-2. The Ministry of Finance vide OM dated 13.11.2009 clarified the issue and made it very specific in Para 3 of the OM that the posts which were in the pre-revised scale of Rs.6500- 10500 as on 01.01.2006 and which were granted the normal replacement pay structure of Grade Pay of Rs.4200/- in the PB-2, will be granted Grade Pay of Rs.4600/- in PB-2 corresponding to the pre-revised scale of Rs.7450- 11500 w.e.f.01.01.2006. it was also made clear that a post already existed in the pre-revise scale of Rs.7450-11500, the post being up-graded from the scale of Rs.6500-10500, should be merged in the scale of Rs.7450-11500. 4.5 The applicants have wrongly interpreted the OM dated 13.11.2009 as they were not in the pre-revised pay of Rs.6500-10500 as on 01.01.2006. 4.6 Further, the Rajbhasha Cadre in Ordnance Factory Organisation is totally a separate cadre. The pre-revised pay scale of Jr. Hindi Translator, Page 49 of 56 ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 50 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs i.e. Rs.5000-8000 was upgraded to Rs.6500-10500 and pre-revised pay scale of Sr. Hindi Translator i.e. Rs.5500-9000 was upgraded to Rs.7450-11500 in the corresponding Pay Band of Rs.9300-34800 with Grade Pay of Rs.4200/- and 4600/- respectively. However, the pay scales of Assistant and Office Superintendent have never been upgraded. The pay scales of both the posts have been merged with Rs.6500-10500 in a corresponding Pay Band of Rs.9300-34800 with Grade Pay of Rs.4200/-.
5. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the pleadings and the documents available on record.
6. Learned counsel for the applicants argued that the issue involved in this Original Application has already been decided by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in W.P.(C) 4606/2013, C.M. No.10601/2014 decided on 14.10.2014 (D.G.O.F. Employees Association and Anr. vs. Union of India and others) and the Hon'ble High Court has accepted the request for grant of parity of pay scales to employees in Ordnance Factories OF with that of identically ranked employees in the Central Secretariat Service (CSS) and Central Secretariat Stenographer's Service (CSSS). He averred that being similarly situated, the applicants are also entitled for similar relief. Page 50 of 56
ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 51 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
7. Learned counsel for the respondents refuted that the issue is covered with the judgment of Hon'ble High Court at Delhi.
FINDINGS
8. It is evident from the record that the pay of the applicants, who were drawing the pay scale of Rs.5000-8000, Rs.5500-9000 prior to recommendations of the 6th CPC, was merged and placed in PB-2 of the 6 th CPC. The Grade Pay for merged scale of Rs.5000-8000 and 5500-9000 is only Rs.4200/- and for those of Rs.6500-10500 w.e.f.01.01.2006, which was merged in the pay scale of Rs.7450-11500 is Rs.4600/-. The question that arises for consideration is whether all the three scales of pay namely 5000- 8000, 5500-9000 and 6500-10500 when brought up to PB-2 should get same grade of pay?
9. A Division Bench of Hon'ble Delhi High Court in D.G.O.F. Employees Association (supra) while dealing with claim of the employees working with Ordinance Factories held that applicants therein were historically equal to Central Secretariat Service/Central Secretariat Stenographer's Service and enjoyed equal pay and all benefits flowing from Page 51 of 56 ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 52 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs equal pay, thus, they, at later stage, cannot be treated unequally. The relevant extracts of the said judgment read as:
"1. The petitioner (hereafter called "the Association") is aggrieved by the impugned order of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) dated 18.10.2012 in O.A. No. 39/2011 and the further order dated 01.04.2013 in R.P. No. 43/2011 (hereafter called "the review order). The Association had sought a direction to quash the order of the Ordnance Factories Board, Ministry of Defence (hereafter called "the OFB") dated 01.09.2009 and the further order of the Central Government, Ministry of Finance dated 20.04.2010, declining the request for grant of parity of pay scales to employees in Ordnance Factories ("OF") with that of identically ranked employees in the Central Secretariat Service (CSS) and Central Secretariat Stenographer's Service (CSSS).
XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX
26. The petitioners were treated historically as equals to CSS/CSSS employees and enjoyed equal pay and all benefits flowing from equal pay. This was based on the previous four instances of determinations by successive Pay Commissions that they performed equal work. No other evidence of "complete identity" of work was necessary in the circumstances of the case. The materials on the record do show that the Sixth CPC stated in more than one place specifically that historical parity in pay scales ought not to be disturbed. Such being the case, this Court is of the opinion that the CAT fell into error in holding that differentiation was facially justified, and could not be gone into given the nature of restricted judicial review. Consequently, a direction is issued to the respondents to fix the members of the Petitioner Association and other similarly placed Assistants working in Ordnance Factories and in OFB in the same pay scale as was given to Assistants similarly placed in CSS/CSSS, Army Headquarters, UPSC, CAT, MEA, Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs, etc. with effect from the same date as was first given to them. Consequential pay fixation and fitment orders shall be issued within eight weeks from today. The writ petition is allowed in the above terms without any order as to costs."Page 52 of 56
ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 53 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs
10. But, in the instant case, neither the applicants in their pleadings nor in the reply filed by the respondents, it has been averred that prior to introduction of reports of 4th, 5th, 6th or 7th Pay Commission, the applicants were treated equally with the employees of other organizations. Thus, this Tribunal relying upon afore-cited judgments cannot ask the respondents to pay same Grade Pay to the applicants equal to the employees working with other organizations especially when the factual position is still not clear.
11. It would be pertinent to note that a two Judge bench of Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India vs. Indian Navy Civilian Design Officers Association and Another; 2023 SCC OnLine SC 173 has held that equation of post and determination of pay scales is the primary function of the Executive and not of the Judiciary. The Courts therefore, should not enter upon the task of job evaluation which is generally left to the expert bodies like the Pay Commissions which undertake rigorous exercise for job evaluation after taking into consideration several factors like the nature of work, the duties, accountability and responsibilities attached to the posts, the extent of powers conferred on the persons holding a particular post, the Page 53 of 56 ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 54 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs promotional avenues, the Statutory rules governing the conditions of service, the horizontal and vertical relativities with similar jobs etc. The relevant extracts of the judgment read as:
"14. In view of the afore-stated legal position, it clearly emerges that though the doctrine "equal pay for equal work" is not an abstract doctrine and is capable of being enforced in a Court of Law, the equal pay must be for equal work of equal value. The equation of posts and determination of pay scales is the primary function of the Executive and not of the Judiciary. The Courts therefore should not enter upon the task of job evaluation which is generally left to the expert bodies like the Pay Commissions which undertake rigorous exercise for job evaluation after taking into consideration several factors like the nature of work, the duties, accountability and responsibilities attached to the posts, the extent of powers conferred on the persons holding a particular post, the promotional avenues, the Statutory rules governing the conditions of service, the horizontal and vertical relativities with similar jobs etc. It may be true that the nature of work involved in two posts may sometimes appear to be more or less similar, however, if the classification of posts and determination of pay scale have reasonable nexus with the objective or purpose sought to be achieved, namely, the efficiency in the administration, the Pay Commissions would be justified in recommending and the State would be justified in prescribing different pay scales for the seemingly similar posts. A higher pay scale to avoid stagnation or resultant frustration for lack of promotional avenues or frustration due to longer duration of promotional avenues is also an acceptable reason for pay differentiation. It is also a well-accepted position that there could be more than one grade in a particular service. The classification of posts and the determination of pay structure, thus falls within the exclusive domain of the Executive, and the Courts or Tribunals cannot sit in appeal over the wisdom of the Executive in prescribing certain pay structure and grade in a particular service."
12. We are also conscious of the fact that claim of the applicants seeking parity of pay is against the established policy of the Government and Page 54 of 56 ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 55 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs implementation of the same will have wide ramifications. But at the same time, if some benefit has been extended to similarly placed employees by virtue of judicial pronouncement, the other set of similarly placed persons cannot be deprived to receive such benefit. It is nowhere denied by the respondents that the applicants are not similarly placed to that of appellants before the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in W.P. (C) No.4606 of 2013. Similarly, the applicants have also not come up with the case that prior to introduction of reports of 4th & 5th Pay Commission, they were treated equally with the employees of other organizations. Thus, in the absence of any specific pleadings to that effect, we cannot arrive to a concrete conclusion that the applicants also deserve similar treatment to that of applicants before the Hon'ble Delhi High Court. However, since the representation of the Association, as stated in the body of the Original Application No.706/2013, that the same is yet to be decided, we direct the competent authority of the respondents to look into the representation and redress the grievance of the applicants, in accordance with law. On scrutiny, if it is found that the applicants are similar to that of before the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in W.P.(C) 4606/2013, they shall be entitled to receive similar benefit. Let this exercise be carried out within a period of six months Page 55 of 56 ANUPAM ANUPAMMISHRA MISHRA 2025.01.03 10:49:01+05'30' 56 OA 485/2013 & other connected OAs from the date of receipt of a copy of this order by passing a reasoned and speaking order.
13. With these observations, all these five Original Applications are finally disposed of. No order as to costs.
(Mallika Arya) (Akhil Kumar Srivastava)
Administrative Member Judicial Member
am/-
Page 56 of 56
ANUPAM
ANUPAMMISHRA
MISHRA 2025.01.03
10:49:01+05'30'