Delhi District Court
Criminal Case/431/1994 on 13 February, 2007
! "# $ %#
&'&(%) * +%
", .-
/0/1/0/0/1/0/1/0/0/1/
$23 *4,56%
78-9%;: <9=?>0@ :
- A- %CBED
2FD
GH *I
JLK
FMNDOMP4 4 JRQSI Q T4!4 UVD
GHW*7
X
YZKV[\]29J^-
_a`cb dfe!g1hi`Ojlk
m;nom?pVqsrleutv`xwPeHy zS{cz}|~
_ SburfeuO`oqem?p t
m!hw6w
hmOm?pVqsrleum?pp$e!ltveFy c{VncOn o,S
_tob
rfe#x`Oueumop;qrfeut
mOOj`!hx`OqAhp `O y dOCqRnc,`O`ud,rx`Og0`
_!bx
rfe#x`Oueumop;qrfe`ft tllw6exfe!g wPm!c `OfrOhw¡x`,g.eOoq`x¢,eu`Ofg eSw hce!ft eFy = - T4!4 UVD GHW*7 X YZKV£ &HI92 2FD ;>+7 XO¤ D ¥ 8KZ2 ¦*X >7) - 78- §F<F¨ © 4!ªc- / =O« © !DJLK¬ D®VDF¬© ¯D J0¤ D2 D*-
§9- °*D
Y±04!4SM¡ KZ2F¦*X
;>+7 9DJRQ?4 ¥ K2 ¦*X
>7 / <F²V© ³¬ D
Kl KZXFD
J
X D2 ¬ 4 J8 KZXFD
J´©
D
2F¦*Y7Kµ© ¯4 YX9K¶-
_e,bxrfeumopZp$eOft
eut
m!Oji`Ohfexm?p y ·,| w ¸,{ | , |0¸ ¹»º
¼
_µp.bx
rfe#OjeS`mop;qrfe`ft tllw6ex#`OfrOhw e?½c`Ohx`oq´hm!_hp `,oOb1y º jec`f,ex lmlq9¢;,h¾j¿q$À tlji`OhueSqgh`!j¾n _¢!bx rfeÁp0hx`Oj ÂÃg ,e!g´y Ä9tvÅVOh¿q$qex _ rSbx rfeO`?q+eumop w}ft?rm!g ,eOgRy ¸!n¾S~;n¾~cSc{ B6 T &' ³ Æ% / n Ç g1heopÈg eSw},ueÉmopÃqrfe3p `ftÊq+wmopËqsrfeÌtv`fw6eÍm?p ,g mSwPextlq´hmOÎhwqrx`oq m! ~ c{Vn¾SOn ?cS fm?qsr)qsrfeÉ`xt t?fwPeSÉÏÃe!g eÐp¶m!,lÑh3Fhw}rfmOfeSwÒqÁfmxwPw6exw6w hmOÉm?pÃmOfe ¢,m!j t?rx`Oh `,f mOfe j`x;hexw ,cg.wPe Ï¡h¿qr wPmOe ,mSt?,ue!qw h qsrfe wÓ`,e g eSw}fextÊqsh¿ÔSe!j¿ÕleVjm!f¢;hf¢Öq+mÑt mOOj`!hx`,oqd,qRn],`O`×d,rx`Og0`c Ï¡r,ht?r qsrlel fmxw6wPexw6wCFhw}rfmOfexw^qsj¿(ØfmlÏ hf¢(mOgTrx`?ÔVhf¢Íg ec`fwPm!fw¡q+m)leVjhe?ÔSeqsrfe wÓ`,eq+m)le qsrleuw^q+mVje!,g mOfe!gaq´heSwvn ~;n Ä*t t?fwPeS Ï eOg.e'`,g1g eSwÒqexÐ`,f(eOOji`,g ¢,eSÙm!(f`!hjn3ÂÃHt m!Oje?q´hm!Hmop hÔSeSwÒq´h¢O`?qshmOÑt?rx`Og ¢,eÕw}rfexelqÏ `fwÐp0hjex n ¼ m!,hexw3ÏÃe!g e×w},,OjhexÖqmÚfm?qsr\qrfe `ftvt?fwPex n ¼ rx`,g.¢ceHp$mOgAqrfe(mopZp$eOft e ,,Ohw rf`OOje ,fce!g dfextÊqshmO ,(¹»º ¼ Ï]`fw pg.`OueS#`f¢O`OhfwÒq qsrfe#`ft tllw6exfe!g wPm!fwÊ ?q+mÏ¡r,ht?rÁqsrfe? OjeS`xceSfm?q9¢;Ohj¿q `,f tlji`OhueSqsg1hi`Ojn ¸Vn ;mut m!,leStÓq qsrle`xt t?fwPeSuÏ¡h¿qrÛqrfeumopZp$eOft e`Oj¾jex¢,exqsrfecg.mxw6ext?oq´hm! e?½c`Ohfex w h¿½HÏ¡h¿qfeSwPwPeSwhÙ`!jj x`OueVjÜ,`O`'d,rx`,g1`(`fw ºÓÝ3 !Ä8d ¹cÝ h¾jj¾h`O `fw ºÓÝ ~O (Þ ¼ dOfce!g w rf`O ßO,`OgÜ`fw ºÓÝ ¸, Ùà wnH ndVnHk9`x¢! à à `fw ºÓÝ ¹ fw}fextÊq+m!g O`ÓáaeOf,eOg dOhf¢Vr`x¢O`Oh`fw ºÓÝ `,fÄ*d ¹fâ hjed!hf¢;r`fw ºÓÝÙã `,fÄ*d ¹ O`, dOhf¢;r`fw ºÓÝ zOn n doq0`oqeOeOoq m?p fm?qsr qrfeÐ`ftvt?fwPexÍ,f,eOg dfeStÓqshmOÐ~c ä åÊæ ç æäÛæ Ï]`fw g eSt mOg.,exV Ï¡rle!g eVh fm?qsr `ft t?fw6ex Ojec`f qrfeVhg h,fmxt e!ft e `Ol p `OjwPe hOj¾htv`?qshmO#coq9,eOOhexqsrfejec`f,eop$e!ltveelÔVh,e!ltveVn ã n ¹ rx`oÔSeÍrfeS`Og )qrfe(w},,hwPwvhm!fwmopAqsrfeÌèP n)Ä ºlº `,fÙqsrle3ce?p$eOft e t m!cfw6e!jv`,frx`?ÔSe#fe!g0fwPeSqrfeép0h¾je;n ¸ zOn ;m ,ghf¢ rfmOe qrfe ¢;Ohj¿q3mopHqsrfe `ft t?fw6ex fe?Sm!l g ec`fwPm!x`,Oje ,mO,oq ,g mSwPextlq´hmOêrx`fwÍqmÚcg.m?ÔSeO p0hg.wÒq´jO ]qsrfeë`ft tllw6exéÏÃe!g eêh×Fhw}rfmOfexw^q fmxw6wPexw6w hmO3m?pËqrfeÜ`,gaq´htljeSw h3Å;fexwÒq´hmO!nìdfeSt mOfFj¿O 9qsrfeÉ`Ogaq´htljexw'h3ÅVfeSwÒq´hm! fe!jmOf¢,ex)q+mÉt m!Oji`Ohf`Ooq]d,qRn ,`O`3d,rx`,g1`VnÎrOhg Fj¿O qrfe3`xt t?fwPeS)Ï eOg.e rx`oÔVhf¢ØfmfÏ¡jex,¢,em!g8leVjheop mopVqsrfewÓ`Oh#`,g¶qshtljexw¡fe!hf¢wÒqm!jeO,g.mOfeOg¶qshexwn {Vn ¹ q#hwÍhg m!o\mop p$`xtÓq qrx`oqÁqsrfe\mopZp0ht e!g w(mop¡qrfeíhoÔSexw^qsh¢O`oq´hf¢Ñ`x¢ce!ftÓ g eSt mOg.,ex qrfe×îohg.wÒq ¹ vp$m!g0`oq´hm!\,eOfm!gaqmop¡t m!hwPw hmOïmop¡mopZp$eOft eÆmop qsrfeopq1 mOOj¿Ð`opZqeOg qsrfe(`!jjex¢,eSÜg eSt m?ÔSe!ga;nÐ rle(m?pp0ht eOgËm?p ¹ oÔSexwÒq´h¢,`?qshf¢3`f¢,e!ltÊO Ï¡rfm rx`fÚ`Oj¾jeS¢ceSFjée?pp$eStÓq+eSðg.ext mlÔSeOgaO Ûx`OueVj ºÓÝ O`ÓáaeOf,eOgd!hf¢;rì`f;h¿q q+eS ;,g1hl¢)qsrle(t m!,g wPe3mop]r,hwut?g mSwPwPñ¶e?½c`Ohx`oq´hm! qsrx`oqTqsrle3tv`fw6eÌhÙÅVfeSwÒq´hm!'Ï]`fw g eS¢Fhw^q+e!g ex `opZqeOg g.ext mlÔSeOg¶ mopéqsrfe ¼ rx`Oh m?pðqrOhw tv`fw6e `,f qrx`oq qsrle eOf,mOg.wPe!ue!q feOg¶q`!hOhl¢ q+m)g eS¢;hwÒqsg.`?qshmOmop qsrle t`fwPe3hwÁO`?q+eS(,{VnS!n ?,S `oq n¸S,, n ºÓÝ `!jjex¢,exqmfeqrfeumopZp0htlh`!j Ï¡rlm#eopZp$extÓqex g eSt m?ÔSe!ga#mop qrfeutv`xwPe ,g m!le!gaq `,f;,g1hf¢qsrle#t mO,g w6emop rOhw e?½c`,hf`?qshmOwÒq0`oqexqsrf`?q qrfe ¼ rx`!hmop qsr,hw tv`xwPeuÏ]`fwÈfeVhqsrfeOg ,g m!ØÊe!fm!g g e!f`!hg.ex'h`,o `,,feOgn ¹ `fxÔSeOg¶q³x`ft?Ø q+m qsrlephg w^qËhp$mOg1`?qshmOg e!lm!gaqËò½;n ºÓÝ3 |ZÄÜ¢FhÔSe!op0hg w^q hvp$m!g0`,oqAt mOOj`!hx`,oq à wnAO`,`Ìd,rx`,g1`É`Oj¾jex¢Fhf¢ïrx`oÔVhf¢ ¢,mOfe)q+m `,g0Ø}e?q m!Ì~ nc{Vn o,S Ï¡h¿qsrÍ` fm!j¿lqrfe!lex`f¢#t mOfw hwÒq´hl¢ rfeOg8,,g wPeO x¢cmVj,e!t?rx`Ohc O,wvn ã | ñ ñ9,wvnzfv|$ñ `,fp$efÏ x`,feOg.wÆ`OlÚp+g.mO rfeOg fmVjlqsrfeOfeêwPmOeOfmSfÕqmxm!ØÑmOoq(rle!g ,,g w6eVn Ý rfe! e?½c`OhfexÙ`fw ºÓÝ3 ;tvmO,ji`Ohx`,oqËce!fmxwPeSqsrx`oq rfeOgAtlrf`!hÏ `xwcg.mOØ}eOÏ rOhtlr Ï `xwóqsrfe g.eS`xwPmO w rfe rx`f ,oqÙqsrfe wÓ`Oh t?rx`Oh h rfe!gÍ,,g w6eVn ºÓÝ rx`f g eSt mOg.,exÍqsrleH ¹»º ,g mSt exeSFhf¢,w`Of h3wÒq0`oqeOeOoqÛò½;n ºÓÝ | ¼ ¢Fh¿ÔSeOÌo ºÓÝ) feop$mOg.e ºÓÝ ºÓÝ) rx`fÉwÒq0`oqex)qrx`oq qrfe ¼ rx`!hÙÏ `xww}x`oqt?rfexÐpg m! rfeOg feSt?Ø mOé~ ncOn ?,S Ï rfeOëw}rfeéÏ `xw w^q`OlFhf¢Úm!oq+wvh,eðrfe!g rfmOfwPeO CmOfeðfeOg.wPm! tv`OueumOu`w6t mxmlq+e!g `,fw}x`?q+t?rfeS hq*`lÏ `?;nô*eSw}Oh¿q+ehltvmOfw hwÒqeOoq x`,g1g.`oq´hmOm?p wPeSÅ;le!ft eÖm?pmxt tlcg1g e!ltveìhëò½;n ºÓÝ | ¼ pg m! jmS,¢ceSÚg e!lm!gaq#mop ºÓÝ3 Ï¡h¿qsr fm!j¾htve, O,vp$m!gaqscx`?q+eVjqrfeut?rx`OhÛÏ `xw mOg ,e!g exuq+mfeg e!jeS`xwPeSq+m ºÓÝ3 n ºÓÝ) h ¼ mO,g¶q ,e!,hex'mopArx`oÔVhf¢Ùg eSt e!h¿ÔSex qrfe ¼ rf`!hpg.mO à `OjØorf`Ox`wÒq0`oq´hf¢ w}rfe#Ï `xw `fw ØÊeSH`oqTfm!j¾htvew^q`?qshmOuqmwvh¢;Ùh g.ex¢Fhw^q+e!g³fm;n ? `oqAe!qsga'lm;n,~ ã;fã `oqTx`f¢,e fmVnx{SCÏ rOhtlrw}rfeuw h¢;leS#`,fuÏ¡rfeOÛÏ]`fw ¢FhÔSe!Áqrfeut?rx`Ohw rleg.eopfwPexuq+mCq0`,Ø}e qsrle wÓ`,e wÓ`oVhl¢ qsrx`oqíqsrfe w6`Oue ,mSexw fmlqìfe!jmOf¢,w qm rle!g ïcoqìrfe!g eOf,mOg.wPe!ue!q9qrfe!g e!hÏ `fwÁlmlq9tv`,ft eVjjex n ºÓÝ3 rx`xwÈfexeOt?g.mxwPwPñ¶e?½c`Ohfex#`?q jeOf¢xqrÆïèP n Ä ºlº nðô³,g1hf¢ÜqsrleÌtvmO,g w6eÌmopÃe?ÔVh,eOft eÍqsrfeÌt?rx`OhÆh3ÅVfeSwÒq´hm! rx`fw)lmlqCfexe!ï,g.mx;ft ex n ÂApZp0ht eOgÈeopZp$extÓq´hf¢íg extvm?ÔSeOg¶ ºÓÝ x`,g1g.`?q+eS mop]qsrfe t?rx`Oh g eSt m?ÔSe!g exÌleVhf¢Ífe!h¿qrfe!g ,g m!ØÊe!Ùfm!g g e!x`Ohg ex n(Ä*wfeOgAqrfe mfÏ feOg¯mop qsrleêw^q+mVje!ét?rx`Oh h¿qHÏ `fwÖ,g m!ØÊe!Ú`oq qsrfeìqshueêm?pt mOhw6w hmOém?pmopZp$eOft e;n ,ext mlÔSeOgamop*t?rx`OhHhw `!jjex¢,exqmÙrx`oÔSe fexeO#e?pZp¶eStÓqexH`oq³`H,lw^ Oj`xt e`,fH`Oj¾j qsrle cmSt?,ue!oq+w h ,,g wPe `Oj¾jeS¢ceSFj g eSt m?ÔSe!g eS p+g.mO rlm!fwPe m?p `xt t?fwPeS ÇV`Oj áaexe?qRnÚô*eSw}Oh¿q+eÜ`f;hq q+eSÉ`?Ôc`Oh¾j`OOhj¾hq O ¯lmÆhl,e!le!fce!oq Ï hqsfexw6wHrx`fïfeSeO áam!hleSÕhÍqsrfeÖg extvm?ÔSeOg¶;n îÓm!g eopZp$extÊqshf¢õg eSt m?ÔSe!gaÎpg.mO `ÆtfjmSwPexÖOji`ft eó`,f t m!l;ftÓq´hf¢)w6eS`Og t?rc qrfe `,fO`oqe m?pÃjeS¢Fhwvj`?q,g e(e!fmxFhexÌhÙdOc(dfextÊqshmO _ bTmopTdxextÓq´hmO S ¼ g º ¼ p$mOg áam!hOhf¢Ùq.ÏÃm)m!g mOg eÍfeOg.wPm!lw#mop jmStv`Oj¾hq 'Ï¡rfeOg e ,g e!hwPeSwÉ`Og eÖqmëfe×wPeS`Og t?rfeSÕmOgHh\qrfe `Olw6eOft e×mopw ltlrìfeOg.wPmOfw)qrfe! áam!h,hf¢ m?p³h,rx`,Oh¿q`OqwÁmop¯feS`,g1o(jmxtv`!jh¿q O Frx`fwfmlq fexeO`x;rle!g eSqmÙcoqTØ}eOoq `oq x`o;nÌÄ*t t mOg.Fhf¢FjO qsrfeÜg eSt m?ÔSe!gaÎhÐÅ;fexwÒq´hmOÐtv`,,fm?q le(wÓ`OhÐqm)eopZp$extÊq+eS `fw¡feOg8,g mSt ex;,g eji`Oh n ã On ¹ ÔVhelÏ mopÜqrfe ;hwPtllw6w hmO rfeOg.e!hx`,fm?ÔSe ¹ rf`?ÔSe g.eS`xt?rfex qrfe t m!lwvh,e!g ex mOOh,hmO qsrx`oqíqsrfe ,g mxw6ext?oq´hm! rx`fw fm?qìfeSeO w ft t exw6wLpOj(h ,g mlÔVhf¢)h¿qw¡tv`xwPeÙfe?Sm!fÐg ec`fw6mOx`,Oje cm!,qRnÄ*t t m!g Fhf¢Fj¿O F`ft t?fw6exH`,g.eÙrfe!j fm?q'¢;Ohj¿q ð`,f `ft Å;Oh¿q$qex m?p#qsrleêm?pp$e!ltveÚtlrf`Og ¢,ex n] rfe!hgÙx`!hjÈfmOf,wó`,g.e tv`Oltve!j¾jeSFnldOcg.e?q´heSw ;hwPtlrf`Og ¢,ex ncîohjeleut m!fw h¢VfeSq+mCqsrfe#g.ext m!g g.mxm!n ö I J0÷9KZ2F¬ 4 Jà DY; K2 ¦*X ø ¬ ¬*Ya-H X K4c5]&4cMÊJ´7UV7 YZKMND 23&DF¦*KµQ MÊJ´DOMN4V© 87X9K29Kµ© T4 YZX K¶-
*Js7 2F7 I 2 ª4V¬3KZ2M}XF4 7 UV4 2'ªo7 I J0M]7 2 M}X KµQ =O<Sù»úÆ TD,¤Ù7!5 !4 ® JEI DJ0¤ ©É§VûFû ²9-