Gujarat High Court
???N8 ?' ??G??Z==? ?+? ?@I ?U S?Nh. ... vs ?X?? @????M? Bd??VblS?>?O ??L ???2 }O4 ... on 9 April, 2010
Author: S.R.Brahmbhatt
Bench: S.R.Brahmbhatt
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?V?^9 ?5???F????N#kGGG??_U>?x?3Y??2?t ???Fks?^=?? z?ge??M??????=A?W ??k?^?uC???x??k?V?5_w??|?^??C??i?;(7Z? #6 ;? ?j???? ????;B ?dOZ?5??vN?!?y/???Y?�???C?*&?'????r?Q??N?F???1??p \?"0[K ??~+0?W?gQd.!&"?rs??E?? ??S??? d?z0? 0?~??Cm??; d??B????
?
?2????. ?dTJ? ?'s {??? ???|?v.?????O6|.P=? ???[/?$? e$J}?I?f?os ??Y BO3Z}#? ng4;&?zz?U?/j?7{? ?? 2??W5?9?Ag ?e??f?Y?n??? t?[??o ?5?e?R???? }? e?V?@? Y?`C {Y???7k??(:g? ??RF ?:S6?? ???? gUH d??!R? >?????Uu?U0?D? ???? ?}C?? ??d�?? ??K:?v???{???.????-P????(u ? ???Q??$? `b?;?? &E?W??? i?:l6?_??h[+{?? 6?B? Z????"?ze?y? ? ???? ??^D?z?kT_@?? ?U??@ :z m e??^???NK???w?n??:??? ????)B?-){K? ????-){K? ???????????-){K? ????-){K? ?gI?*K?,?? ?? %??Ii?{ a,?7?6?8 .w????@|?E?]? ????]??/? ????|W?p ??p?~x??????M??? ? z3???o? ?_so?O?n?L]j??^:??&?lpG? b5??A?? 3i<+%???G??{?V?v?wR??S?]?9d?{'?E!?r'?*ND?G?? p??C????W?O??? T[ ? ?c%?G@g???&? I^?? {]?gg?+?????.??????'???O/????Y?? ???: ?y8T ? ?? ????2 ?\hK ?Wb???nsL\?O????}z?h4?t ? ??rsy? ? ???K? ??????W3? ??? ???????}(??}=g ???={???z~v?? 7?M?y~ L???y??????|Zf?>??j??+? ??S3? ? Kn??lj?+< ?2??F ?)? l?? Og?G? P??}N??? A??b{?? ?? ?]3??K??? : ??G?j??Uk?u???M+ ????????M J?`?j??n??�M ,??#??< ) l???1T 9u???B)? J? ? 9?L?`t?? C ?a??T &???S?$0S@?O?Zi?oj?A?? ? ]? ?? (4T??l?]?n5??? D?;?+??R???Z??F?!?P ?z?!? ?@?Y�$tkv_8w?? ? ??p. ?$??c ? ?? x? ?/?? ????3@??K e\??rH?? Y?/ 1??? ? ?[c??5j8!^?O?? ?3?*D?8bF??&?Br1? ??? w? ?R� ?h?(??ik*C? 3?+8??n? 9?M??F ??? 2 ` ?YO)? ?Qis??G* ? b??NC?_?3"??i????f???r?? {??A???;z?? p?y????Z5+? ?�???a9 ?Q??o???M??Zu?? Kv ?N )`???s?Ax?m?43V7?m ?cYO2 f 70H H �???s?!h ?X ?9v?q$M ? ?3?r+ ?"W? ?n~??e ??7?? _N?39??a?d?K? r? ??bve???E???h.7?B|C \ ?VAm4?y?Dd? ? ?2?r ? r?b?'?E???r /?? ?????8 ?
3.???s&:??? ??? ? @K@? \??? ??? `??BC N?^ M?"?
?o?eH?ltdc? ?? ? ?q?:'?? $ ??c! p6?]? .l?bN?E??nV? *"?|)??E-b dA?\? ?Jns@-? ?NJ[???3? 1?f?2p? ?6??jx?(H ???? ??1??? 4h? ??[?w?]??�?eD3D0(Oh? d1^`??? ??;?pf? ? |?= z??? `|? ? 0A? ?6 ?r g?rGH??,x??6?h?~ ? ?| ??@^BW u? ??j? ?.? D) ? ?>?(????so2??A ? ?L??? ?�??X?P?l??J ??XF???0? '??.?@?4?B?2m ? ???v#8?D!U??S(? ?d ? SEb ? l(?i??7W?b?;?[??# ?-?PQ??F1k?: o? ?A?? ?F?? ????�??9Q??K ? ?? ?f{"??? .??4> &??m?? Z?(??4?#0YA??k???C gJ?f?[ ?Q?,4??[? v?4 ?sg?a1?!?Lnb? ? R?? \? ?? bLoUGa[?X ?~c??d???# /? ???\A? ?? vI ?????> ?=LW?? ??G Gf??3K?U??M ?~J???9?-?[?M&e{????ov??--?2?\? ??=QG? p%??M;?X??? .?(t???^l?c ??t?? ?c/?\?k?&?3Q?8 Y??:??)? l: 0?t +N M???.?z,??7(??v?w??o??kb ???^k A2K?/c? ?1???A7? = :0]-l?'??.m?_? ? ?nkn s ?&K? ??H ????^?)s??? ?M,?P???6?/5??? )~?7z(?>???*?UB ?A??]?]&.?i?C `?? ?}?;???Pv?$??yue ~?M?? M O? ?? G?�?Dn????s??? l?& ??Y???J_?C??�&Sqg???V??. X?? 2? ??(0{? =? ? .?^? ? ?? ? a?1G?^? ?3,~?J?n? ?& . ???7?????e? ? ??? Q??r?hT 8???" ?a`?)???f ?`??+??$j8\ ?[?f=-b ??%y?+? ? ? ??|?? ?M?60?? ?XN%??( ? N\? ?T/j ??S:}$ Rg?h8??Y?V?q???b!+??:?F,? ?? ???R??R? [?B? g?P?fr9?H?s?#C ; ??=d[L??j?'(?[?Ne D4%?B.e9?dn ?@ e ??[?Sd?.?c D?"??t1??)?dd ?>?d???V?/AB??%S???D? ?t?]??\? .O? ?8N ??j#-??G?, ? $??<0? G h?JqE}E*8H?9 "??.?s??H? g?d ,???W?uj??2?? ?(1???6\ ?Rw??[? ud?T ??w?BAQ ? ?=qFV??6! p~ s?g?r!???f�??A?????Y??d????bI ? X t??$�????Z{m? v ?? ?0&??o^??|1?m\s . ?T0 ??o?? ??oc5??od'??No ?3x8? ???
??
??E ??? ??h4?#?� e????Z?T?{?qI???@S? V ?k?3? _?5???fzU?.a?????_?5???& ?W?4Eu ?I?$ P??lr?_0 v?E 4 ?O(qn Zj?Re?js??'??g? ??
OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 venu 2010-04-09T16:24:22 venu 2010-04-09T16:24:40 2 PT19S PK � � �?V?<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png??uT???& ??h?? }P?-h??KK??PJ?? ??Nq'??{J?`?I?????????s? ??9?3w??3?3? j /?^c!!!?TR?? ?7 !!#a< ?]? ?"!?*?J???y??}I?s5h3? ??_?????~ ?jjzG??j0?8?
F 8??=sc???y?v? ?K?n?d????2 ?? ?y?@?&N?ON?wn2?A.? ?Z?v3?'?? ibwG ?vJ ???V=vY??AA>?q"?? 8,?(???$aA3??'???\?Ww$W4m?V>8w9??Ut\??@?=?%V#?/??Qc?r?6???? ??&??#?b )?Iy?E???`??+goc ?K? ?4?nRL ?}N;n L:|?? bc? ? ?????\ ? ?5?)??v?b??t?�?N!????? 4??r? ??*?x?x?? Xz??td# ?y?~????- ?&YQ:n? ???Y??eJ`H?>?A? ?? ???5 X? tT?S??,???P: II1 ???Gl?vn??T???bB"?????/?= L ?M??w?'~` ???? ?? ???r? ??eX4? ???????w??v%? !?z0[l?k{?&?? OO r??~?q?? ?>?[9[m ? 2?|=sEA?&??????| ~ ?? 9?Q??D@??d?Cx E??f???@ ???9c N? ?;??>???y|r?? ??3 ??q? ;UkI ?v?1g???BLH?J ????? ?L?? ?)?k?M +?g??? ?2F(&?u???b?^??? ?J) ,?"?0 G+?r??|??l>?q='1r??R? ?s???&?c?I ??BU??t??&?U?P????u?9 {H??1?s+?j??@????[ t]? h?]?? ~6f1h??)?;'?
,(??_???*?9`??2???J?}?C??@???? ?([v? :??J? ?E?? =???gq???*???g? ? ??&,?5?????? ?U????U?????h^ 6{Z??S?7 ']&?2??Z>???G?_?sJf< ???v??g%? �??,>?}7?5??~1?J'/o?}??V ??k??|? gKA: ?g? ?? }R5& ?k?`TZ?Z0?ul??Z??� ?d?}?@??@^???
?U ???|%?v ?g(? ??x???(?c??p?? ??wr]>63???A?H?p?^;????A?S????~? ??y%???o????. ? ??^ ?Y?J???+a?m?Ab)?y?pK???ymg ??,,O?? ??c ? wB~Ha ?i??8A???4QF x t???u???4=Wk> Y?
V^y %??=?r\???-?OZ????Y?[J t??^K&? ??&_/S???jM+!i_???| c? ??�"??Q`=0 ?? ??U8?? =g? ,p?e3???I*???iyr W4?N ????h??? ??:T |??E.,?tA|?D?????>@7o?Z??"?f??B?p2~(??a????l_ ? c??+???w??z?#x@? 2?????V ? Y??! " ? n ?=?M? ?x �? ?j?AF???=,j9J?? 0?Y??? ? t?A*VM?J p???# 9 ?w ???F?? ~?z]?D?)?>? ?=?????3?y??�?$O?% ???M??)? ??? 1g?@U^?1?%@ \ ???iM?? ??))?? ?\FLU?`? V>?,?(RZ K??cf4?j??%?9f??,? |??_aF?u? ?C_) ??3TV$O?x6E???+?|)){?"?|h??S6l0y:'> M??H ?p5?B?|?7?-n ?? D?bD^? ?d? ?Pm? ? ???t ?
C??[\; /v@?+v?`? ?n??, QTym??X?PF??J?o??K ??A =???& yG? %? ???A*Fs?? WQ? '0^?+?? ?[e???ve6??48? ?? L? da? u?z?E1?!?0Y???Rj?? ?E?�K??? ?e??#v ? M?- @ $T?V+? g??*???`0? ?)"3??-???
]#S?`9??l {4 ?c?9??;?j? ;??\?Y9&???? ?oW% ??~Xb?k}u? ????? ?�t?k?v? ?=?? T?]?? ?v??.?
?>\?ra!7"W")eu??c?`??(e? M?? ??q??????7?Z???a???_????*m ??h?� ?�! , ??6??b???N ?? W? I??g?X? ???zs?g?? : ??k3 ?y}? 6Z H? {?????[Z?? ? |D?q?*??=?#W??O]-??@? rwEDU? w?h9h[? P ?{RO? ;F? ?;????Q ?? ?BF??? ? ?B"Q o?j8???Z?;?n ? F?No'???F? ,i?9=\ ? E2G`???IC0?? ??5~??Z??~O( e? u?G??i{???9G ????M Z?|??u?0???8S]w??%J?/? 7?M??_G??>? &?QV? ???4 ?? #X?4????O? k?
? ?_~?[??????nt?=| ]???l ?=g?_?"? ?+??<3??L?r?w?.R? o??U?ib9 ?~??4???K??�J? Q?(?g??&6c??e7N 'b????+ \^?9?n??!?? :??/? z?\v???
???N8 ?' ??g??z==? ?+? ?@i ?u s?NH. c�??? 'I? ?H$????2??S???rhe?Vs?x?? @????m? bd??Vbls?>?o ??L ???2 }O4 e?E????}$A???? dG?6??~??p????KQ??rW0? Z:? ???U?P k??;?T?%c%c?> @?? ? ? [????Y?[CON????:? K?[ # K???1?I ?Sw ?I?;lW-?p???>? k?K??+_ ?>7h{?�A ??{k?W???? ?Us? ?? ?=Z?3l?2??Px? ??1@^n?2?? ?? ??KF???L?|? ?8?]vzz? (;??A+)???F~? ??@O7b?3 ~n5? u?{??5k 7?U y?z T????????! ??1 ?? ? ??? XO1?Z ?L??\r? ?Vi?D?+NZ??HH&V 1p ?i/?tX}Z?1W???C?{??0??3??|%???C?g?f U ?JP? ?Q?)??9(?o:??1?????????p? Y??.???R?? FZ?W?? ?~?p7T-?? 2???{u??.`+Z?@tg?8??F??????:P+I??X??r?d ??O? ?? [$??F p ??? ?sW/? ?5-? ? ]5??u??? H???!C?s???J|!?? ?\?? "6?? S? ??s)&>??N?/~?o? V?? _LJ@ ? K?
O[ ?}?z???cZ2t??W??O?P?? ?|1? ?
S??G?KAn j???????bP??I?*?iG>?:? �$IK?U? ?Sh ??:S??? ???q??uQ??]?{???x?)?z?R?~??[y? ?w\?Mk??? ? leq? ?#eK??? ?? ?'???? ?w??`??????? ? ?N??u ?8MP???t??N9?F?e;^??? ZE?sZ#en? x�?????-?w?L ??}+ ??M????=??? 9 ??-???????t|y"Sx6f?.??? ?9?\ ?U?? ?"?c??wI!`\9?P$??[o`A4- ???
?#?Z????n0??j??!t9 ??'O?a?z?q�|gx{ ??_g?/?? ??Fb?Y ??y(?&?*Zj(?L}5??????@?@?KC?~? dd ????aq?N?;? lg?"?,?q?$???YS4q?!? ~??^ HI???"~?�?3?b??? 5 ?8?(PJ? :6*?? `?? ?P]+? ?o?eG?Q?_???S5?7??#S???+3??,ML? �?Ht5cj??X ? 4^?c _/??A?,A)?o6{)}?f?u?}[??H W@ ? ? ??S? A k ?s ?O\?0??v]?
!"??H ??tj?u??Y h???W dL=?i?�??Xn`?#?'??]�Z/o? L? /B?? i?9 ?D? e8??e??u?S?{ ?e BOg?l2?mW??Cq??t???3?�?????('? ,?U?."M??D?2??] : ???? ?? ?tq[?? ?[#�9? ?Rs??v?9?? ?g?k???6?NR?? ? ? r)????0f??S?r ????k???o??[KTb x??t?GE?2a8 ??w?M??n?s??"?N ?? { 6?w?11???9?( k`k?=c?? ??4L?zA?b?Oz??XPP>R u??Nv?? ?_h_*J &?Yi?? ?T?y?m\o?8Fx? Cs?(2??? = ?&?oKG??/?`?? ??.?]r?c?? 3??Gy?~~????>??& ?? Gv?i???L?jdLsj;?1e N]?? R?z kZ???? ??? kR? sl\ 8?@JC?nU?dVI??{ C ???'???J2? ?}?N �N .1y %MT?:?? ??Lz?3 ? ?s??T? 6 ?J?
cG^g?1>? P?P/?? 85m ?M? ?? b k x4??? zdL?F?5?? (C??Tgo1??Ei?=??Q???? �??`??.?=??`�5??�3?~?g? .?? ~??0?? ???lX083?ZO? ??R??2???e?? ????UZ @?c8?2S3??vV?u?q?j?1 ?E;???}???_k?[0^???\ p.?h*_w?f??}? ? ? ?N?i 8 ?&i?_QK?JH??8 ??{ &?d???\?SOvH????b? NF?K?X ? ? a i?hJ??/4 ??? '????? ] ?ASJ3??@?&??+B?x???)B???ZZ?4FSUva/ ?B?i??P? ;? ?? ????q?:j ?D?i?
aA?D?NB?M?q???????&Y?( "?)?0`$?u ??N2?5?e@?/?J/.?c~~???-?cW&???�H>KX??? ?�?o?? ?61;???5/?: ?"}`?/:>Q?mI??z? ?C?6? "? s5D??C ?1?J1? I(B? ?;??w=�? ? ?s3r?K?/?h? ?S,?D? ?O-?a?L???? 4??Jq?Z U)o ???u?F)?O?Xn????? ?h?pE?2? qt?{???T? ?n|AabwP??w? ??&q>?=?}#?h%? ??l?kJ@S??|?i,?SK?=|D?>??? ?? 4f?IFh??v? +??? ??1??0 ?? ?U3 ??\gf?eQ?+? ?g?d}??0? ' =J? ~%9?7 /uY? ?$?,??? M??V???e?Z???P???f*:?l?/n)?Pg ??7??N??>Q?L??r?? ?M???a ? /???H??V????!?!?i ???&?s@#B???G? ?W M??D ??Wl`?R??\?D?Q?nV/9 ??k ?t??!?O G? ?xv$}????Y??z????_?8 ???tS?.? ?~W? ?x ?_u7\???]|?qAP?%?F????Z?= l? ?UV#?fL??b??V? ?????x ? l? ?K? ?N? ? ???>?D?_ ?f??6}??9??}? ???S? -?Q?.??M???d?�W%?zA??q???\6(??d?r_??$??r???~??tl?? cFRMt?g?c 4[ ?c????g?\`???8u??>?gI??=????o?~ ?!_R0M#??SB?4+?' ?c????Q ?8???ZIs@ ?.:u?%?n>-' O~ ?&@ ?j e?D?K? N ??? ??H? ?T?7"?5?_? ???? ??Sv?F.??C2? H>?Dz??-? ?????H??t?_???6L?:?eZFT ?} ?? ??b}9 e??c?# x ]^?X??'? ?FH ??????T?$Q E.??? FX?_<:y?s??y%?H ?Tru0? ?S??
??d?>??,??3t r2??^?8�?p0h2> _?
{I??u?! h?wRy|g??|?.? D1?8?(??`(2, t?P5??K' e?N???*??t???V c???X ? Bz?A??? X?*D'?S} =?q??$)?^%??z#?a?D^?^? ? ? 0Y?I +???R????_N ??1????| ?K(?n7q???= 5??`:
??T ~ ??? ? ?? `g ?.b?f????uE:"hV|?8?????= ? ???$?�?} 7??c????BCk?
?B ?'w?? ???H??|???,P?u ?J ?E???$a"?\?Flg?mG??cb?L_??qy@=GXXZ??w???$}?? ?l?? ?U??) : LQ?V&?c?!?? ???*?!)?&??*???^T??9m??!? 5?? ???9?_fk? ?"???? |? , ?f?r7)?J??E ?@H ?W?????_ ? & n???)?m??' ?G?? 2E ? 2?? W?U???q??{?0 ??57q0q9? ?? �? f??f?Y9HYk>???}?7?(?6�?1?;?3?????i?? ??m_?F?????7????{ T ?�L??B ?&?UX?????;wBp,?(~??*g}? _ ? #J ??? ??/ ?g^-??d? GEe)[???8? 4(f$?1?
?"`?Q #?? ??????? ??0??x ??V??????y4???v+ <"}??9???a_??V/p??e`??? ?? ?A?.?h?fa?? ????& ??8??z? ?o ?3????[?m ? ?|+? 6Izj6F?:?+~V???*? 1:V?x?????\?? ?? V^M ?;??$???_?w ? " ?g@F ? 7n?????"f???
6!?;\??pE?73YB^?� ?`e[B???q5??b@V%?=B??B)-? ? " ??HB? ??b ????K??=?$%?:`)! %3? ???=?S ??FA?RW?g??q?, ?Cp ??w?i?#C?`>???`?S[??]?? ,?? z??? ??? ?h ^??B?k? ??? ?:x\>???ckM- ? ? ??t ?
???X?? ? u?y ?o??e ?aze?? ??z ? ?s?A?
T??T?????B?8?$~? W?~???? ? ?H???5?$ ?c7 ??[g?Fdx)"Q1QQG? ?d????A?d(Z??n ?%I;L???"?yF?=?D??;?K&z?R7?V?b???&??D?
r?? )os??,9?R? c?z?W???9N$[?`?F?v?j #?+pI ?WW?H?y?? k??#?-TC4p" #??z?ofcdt? ?? - S??U?? s M?` ??`??p?Bm?? ?? ??,WR?? ??q?i ?D???^#???? Pw?C |???k???VFdN??? ? ?b? JW???V? h:U??x_D ???i??????U ??e??-8Q ?i??tl,? ??H:?Znd???1x) #1?B?& ? ?" ??h!? ??w?rq6 ?g??sy ?o?Jgk,WYs??R??M% ? ???p??z q? t?cP r~??V\?p?z Y? ??|?I?H Ke?o|?(???b?2?(? GH$??v? ???6 5r??? nG\??I???? ` 4??_?$ E ?~?SkQ3???\k?q???s? ??? ? ~z??j? ?mB?a/p?.???fk?bK? ?d\??,??^ ?eg4e ? ??~?4??@? ^?gqQ?}=7Q8oy]?? ? ? ????? ??> ?? UR????w?~? I?? ? ?N ?,?#?"??p?8?? ? yRf??b? ?? ???n?s ??v\?0f?6?@??&?%"2\?co? *?? ? ????lV ?w /???>?.? %]S~pU c?? x???;?Y???jGA???"?w ?o,H?t?h ??E4??�':o?? ?$}0 ?N O? m??u??iH??1m5? c?HDhW?
? ???? Ih?B2X@?.m}? ??jOg?g?R�IU8???? )?YK7??~\E?'?? ? 6? ??? ?U>?D?.:??b??CZ#A?i ?T?p??2??6&? -}???B??g????@ d? LH ???l???? PK ?\s_2��(4��PK � � �?V?<������������ ���settings.xml?Y]s?: }??"?w ?!??1????�i??M? ?Fh=? ??w% & ? ?? ?|?]???|[???+H ???_*? ?�?HLn??a?t?}??s??q ?u?A2 ?K ??%?^ ?:}|?M????e?A?_}A9)?V*?r???^X?H??????/?3??Z?????ji?b M>.??%? ????d6?1???W?? ????1J?????$?Z? ?? ?|? /????z_ b^?eLO"??z??????My f? ?u.v?0??(??? R 21 ??? ? ^]? ??? ?s ?.?1?jo?ReH???p?W?!f???? ?f? ? Jy?q??&?? Fa EqV??$j?l??{Xn?? \?7"???+?yd? : ??rSe??`?O4?!?(,?H:? w dn?? Sz?kT? ?? EN7L?d ?&??w?1J>???4y ?j]??"? ?Y?R??K+?.??L??k2Am??? `"?-?I[?=?? Q7Y? w?{??UW ?vp|?*}?? ?(k2 y??????h??A ??* A a??%????J??(U??af? ? g? @?jKT??`MDn !��meta.xmlPK � � � �?V?Top