Karnataka High Court
M A Lakshmidevamma vs The State Of Karnataka on 17 October, 2011
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
Bench: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
2:2? 'E"E£E E--§_§{1%%§ <:{>ma:':" {>3 §§£§E{N;X'E';%§:€£a 51:? §3A.:§s;;§_:.5i;T%§E<:
3., Bamag:
m::'E§3 'f'?£iS 'mg: a '2??? 23.5%? :3?' ®C'§'®B§.E§E?;'_?:'£}}'~§ _ '£.'EE :~£@m:3:,._§<: MR. Lgzjwzaa _aé3aiQ%:3%,%';:::ra;$';zIe:§%Eg: 'WRf'£' PE'E'E'i7'£GN N0.2':3§-ii'? 895253;. :smA~%§k:_:;z§§%£>;} gag WRIT PE'r:'m>;~; ?§%::,%ws._:i§":%.';86a'é"{'_%§'i"'A§.7';?\-31 E3 §:?'E"'s?»'§%;I§E'~3':
By} A LaE~;§h:3':id6:va.:1'::1;a;.
"=J%f;'<; Lexifi M K Fa;'za:j1i:'§;'¢:r:§}::z2 "
gigaé abg} mi '}..*$a2'§s:;
EVE A Sréidfhgr, " .
53 X (3 La? .¥'I':;§':':2;:':rb:i'.Eia3":";é:=:": _V H EX§§€€j"i"ibO{§l§, 43 :j¢'éi'2119i=s., aziza-G:-33;; ' _ _ {ifs} L£s,E4_§;%'"?./iv E€g;T'_a§32::2i§i:a_:'a:§:2 Egggjgsii ;?;b<§:,:_E. -4:-/1;».§;7§221.:f$ ' 'u.f%}£ ,E:._'"=§¥_E';~',¥§£% =s::":~':}§:1 ' n _, §_;:«;":} E.-;1§;€LTizE K r'§'}.'E€i3E?;'.§"}.&ifé?a!E§$ [ ,;:5':g§:€{'§..§§'i3{§'i§,_E }:€2:2.:"s;;
A _;i,§§ a::_~¢' §X'<}.2§@, §"{€;?S5§iE€1V'<:}~Z£"§pEi;'§.f'21, R if R0:>§::§ ?*~«la'r.:1;°3€;u%E2 Efi-mif C§§'{':§é;',§ AA , _§-§21§§f;;f3.Ez}::'<% M 5&8 f3€3éi. ( ,. §%';*éi§§<";m%:'5:;
{E3}; ;"=}:'§ E?" K ?€27:ra}r2m;?: §wz2:§':§f. ;'%€E:::3{:22SE.§3} i an} z7:?*»2fEZ%:
;.......x "E'?:€i Sigziizf 0%' E{2:%.r':':zaa'éa»:};a E335 ii's:~s S€=,s3:"é:%é22r§; €19 {Er<:zz»-"€r:*:1:z";.€:'2:, Cemnzéizxte area? E:2§iu:i~:'i;"§€$ "v':::<«:~é{§h.§ §€<}a.€§}, E§2mgaE<};*s:": -- €35, E53 '§"h{-?< Speifzizssi Em.-ami A<:q'u§s3£'E.i{}:;2 G§fEe;*;€sr, Ez":%&r:1ai.ia21.:*fl }':i;'p<)r':.,, E'iaz"r1a:2iEaa Erzdusiriak :'7'm::~2:s::
§}€v€§<>§>r§1e:1i. Board?
33"' FE{){:r:", W Cmsas, £§£iEE§"§;'}§212E.§§;£%§", E§;1:":g;f§ai<3re - 568 GGQ.
{By 8:": K S 1's£§aE§§_.§§2?a.§j%.z:f;a_fah., §%'{7.£f,%§Z? i{>:9}E{E; Szii E3' V 'E122;-r:§§ra&;'i1:3i§:»';f--, ;%;<<3§gq3<:2::.@'f<:=:'*"E§2} "f'§f:{-:-5-'as wrii: §3€:'§:E€_iGf2sT'a1*@._f§~i§§d is-§_1€§V€f«Arfi{:}es 22% (Ex 22'? 9f the C0nst.iiu€;E0§.":..§3§_E;'1.giig3,, "§1f2if;?'V::j:--;g,f {<3 di:°i:~i:€. the 2% re;sapcm§ezf;f,.isV-s:i§sE;§urS€_"V§hs:V£::~:§;2f:pé:i;s:1t§or1 ameruzit of Ri§.2g82,4%4~,4;:"§?f§>:13e:1g; é?;{i%.h _'%j_i:"::éf%:}:":3::~é.Ii:""?éi<;s 'ihfi p€:Uit§<:}m::"'§; in respect rzfif "§iI:f<;§:i'€:?§'},5"--as_§ p&:s*' z'?:m':s:;>:3<: Earthwxiih, by fpging iime 'v§>(%§9""%;._i;§ s;"t§1'é5g{§:fi§s3,____wfi;§': iflififfifii €:%1<2:'€c;n ii}? aigaze <}f§:§;j;;?:'":3§§{'g1f;, " "
.V"?E"s_f,ss5 %;»€-r§é{";§s-3t.§£i<}I3.€%, étaméiag 53:"; F5}? :g_;~:*:3§£z:2:"_:§;1§'}; h£:3v:z'§;f2g:;_£;f} E3 {i?i.'€}..'é,E,E}; iE':§§ ::"};2"z}x she {Tz'Z}?;.§,§'§I rzézide {he "Eb.I,EGé,«3:i::§gf _' * GREEK "§hé: §;*»f;'}i)§E43:{3§"§%;?E°;'% §":2'ws% aimghé: 2: wréé: {if §232:z'25i2.m:'a:s .,i;,,{}i* §°é}$§}€§z:£%é;%::€£: I'sk>,2 ii; {§:Es;§3:.::§*s;»;§> %:'E"::a {:<:::n;2€:i:$ai:§:';:2. 2§Z:'?:é:§;:§:1%: £2?' ?2:.,82¢~é1E§223?fv 2;i.3i:>§'";§g; '%5;§'aE3. ifié: §:i":?,fiZ°§"'€f-SE, {rm " "é§:<E::%a}:,§_;i2'i: <25." i..§f§§:é <3:3>§'.::g}:.:§:%:;s:"jv*/J %L;'2:::{;'§.:.E:':is:'i;.£i;§£': :3 5 £19: éség" §f)E'€}§}€?E"'§".jyK v z;
IAN 2,."
:2; :E%:f.i ?fz.fl{Eha::;:§i*;22$hé:':<j222_:: *éj?}€;f §é::2:2:':":.€:<§; {'7€.}%.§§":S§i%§ €233' ?;:hz:> :;*s':s§';><>:'1{i§*:z':Ei Nzxfix :'%§;E§'}§"§'E1§§;§i% E;.h.27aE. %:.%1t=. ::'°<:%::g3<:;%;j3€E€:§':%: N962 has-s; aérééaéiy f?;.a§<;<--:<'§"; 23. :§;@{éi.s3.£<;n 1&5} refer Lmdgx" rS<3::7E.2?{>:as; 3% 2z:y;.§ 31 52:? the Léiizgi .;5s§ff"iEK1::%'i?s}i1LP§'{.}:i:"}«.;?§C§; Eéigéiu £3.53 E§'T1€f§'€;"*: £5; $:>m:3 ciispaias E§{\}'r§:Vi§:;?%,E.!£§> §'s:..'€é:':é:i'%'£é:§§ E"€{Té3'i'%:'€3 éhfi {f€§i'I1§}€3IESE1§.§{}Z§. ihé'A.p%;:?:i'§§<;a§"}.'€=:%f:4:v___<32' éihé €ath{:»§.i{: Swian E3aI:k f'm:*:1 %.%§'§9,{>:;+a €2":€'g:s.=5:{:§f,§€2:£"=;€1:'s am §:'5:éé_ is} has:-is %;2§<:en %.§:§;%":'7%}%é.;2;§"2:f;%;;1.?§ 36 Thés §{5ét:_:§E;:i<,::":{;=::?s:w--figzzvéa. giggéi: °;2;1'.€;*:e2l§;*éi¥d ihe. Sgfréém Bank 33 t.%1€2_V':9:;':"§g§9:3'ir;_§div;%V:':ét. {fez} fi'1e:i~:é_f. ;p7§:?:t'ééding$¢
4.'-_ S'.:,:?E3%:':s€Z_Q;EZ'€3':f§§:"i'{} '§;h€3_.{fling 0? the writ', p«:**é.§€,-2.93: an %<i'§.G"?a2;§E 3;. ?'.:""i'.'i r«:5:%;§;%§:>:ia%é:::é. E}-5&2 has; airsadjg Eiiakfil £2 _':.{:2_ S£3:};z§"€:.--;'--':'a':' flE:£U{i'.€§I' is ihéff Eieferazziéie €=:}:;:"L _V§"§'?.;':'£a:.§Ej;=< _§é:s'i::i§%r"§§§§g §§§€i${*, §}s::~:._:%i;,§<3n§ §i'2§E'¥.E{Z§1i§{}E,§E§, A 5, §<:iiiE.;?<}:1§ am: d:'s;p{2£sé;%{§ {}§"W:1"€:h :23; €§:i§*£:*{:éi.E{;~n " *f:.:{} "f;;%:a€' v%:i_:€::15;'§}€:a:1{§.é:§:_£', ?*~§<§=2 m §z:"*:§>E€:E:{:§':{ 323.5:-3 {}§°{§{'3E" <i23:.§:€{§ A' -E5'-§.'§§}2€%.§; E. {Exam-3};'z::":% E51 $3} fizié §€i'§Ezi,i':i'§'§€3:§":':' {$5 a-
M4"
{}?}j{"?éf?§l§.{}£'§§§}« Eéc sssizz-§.EE se.~:€;E'2{i Eihfi? §'€;'.§€:E"§iE'Eéi".€: agzai {i<;é;'3<i;:%§%. 'éE':::
zzwazfii 2m":{}2,§.:":€. w§§:§'2 €329: Ré?"§£;':§"€E"i{if€3 €Z'f<}:.::'i; w§'§:§1i_:':«, é.~w{'; :n{>§5:E:I*:.;%~: {mm iiifse siézzis-3 0'? i'.h.€*. _%$§:.:21:'2<_%€? sf __%;§i2.t: A:f:':i;;::3?£_';§----3T3f{'¥::%:A ~ {tapy sf mdajf,-*'5§ ardéészi _