Smt. Satyavva D/O Bharmappa Illyal, vs Hubli Dharwad Minicipal Corporation, on 21 February, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Smt. Satyavva D/O Bharmappa Illyal, vs Hubli Dharwad Minicipal Corporation, on 21 February, 2011

Bench: S.Abdul Nazeer

IN THE HICEH COEERT OI': KAR.NA.T§-XKA

CIR CU! T IJIENCH A T I)HA R'  I)

DA"E"1'~3D THIS THE 21" DAY OF;E¥1£.B_RU';$'§§'§f"7"ziﬁxi   

BEFORE   _ n _ . __
THE HON'BLI:I A1f1€.JUSYf!£'E  1NA.Z-i§j?§R"

WRITP1£TITION 2v.oj*~5r1976/2:)1'1- J  V,
C/W W.1>. N()S.609?7 T0 60995/201.1, 6.1245 T0 6:25.?/201:1, 6.1255
T0 61259/2011, 61346 T0 611388/2f}i'_;i,'6I.?91';AT0 614'o8;'2'011 AND
60872 T0 150331/2011; .(I;;;..V:jt:?'}_V

Between:

  % Ak
Smt. S2113-*z1Wzz,   yv

D/0 BIr121r1'17.'zV:§)A;'§é1"1'l1:f§;1l., :39; 3

Aged ab<3LiE__;25._yc;21:'S;",'~.._»' _   ' '

Occ; C0<>1ie'.,rf<){H0L1s¢ __  
Si.c1d211"ameshwe1f E\'2.1ga1'f, " 

Uxlkaf, Huifilaﬂ V' '
 gm V-'\?_P;'E<3'{}VS.6()97? T0 6{')995,f2{}i 2

 ..   IN" xtw. ;~ao.6<:9<?:?;2:3 1. 1

  SETZL E3._E;1a.r2.£iV.3.c:x§:::.€j};:y;:E<x>va<§

Age: 5<:i"3:a::';';~a '

~  ~ .- 2. 'Cmc: {;T«:.:c:}EEcV 3
 " §%Eg>." §--;{:;:s;<: E'§s::s.,€§.?;
    
 ._L?:2E{:i§gE€.u%:2«Eé_



DO

IN WP. N0.6(}9?E§/2()l1

Sim. Shckaxw-V11 'H21nu1n2:n{z:pp.:: Poojari
Age: 43 ymars

OCC: Coolie

R/<3. House No.49

S§.ddar21me.shwar Nzxgzu"

Unkzil, Hubli

IN WP. 'No.<3()97<;f2()1"1" A .. 

Cha_nnav'v:1

Wfo. 'Bas'~:app2-a Huhbaili
Age: 61. years

OCCZ C.00i'i<-3

R/0. H(}11.§€ N089
S'%.dd;12'amcshwa:" Nzigzsr
Unkal, Hubli

A T' "    wt"ik';.'_§;g._6()9Vé(J/2() 1. 1

Ex/iaruti Du1'ﬁg:;1f3g3;a 'T'c;rzig:«:if},   
Age: :12. 'years _V - ' '
Occ: C;a0*1i:z§

"'~,.Rfo. E{{E1.1éé£§.}3'\§'O_.3E  ..... 

Sidéiziiiun é':~:.hw_a1<  zzgaxf

V'  xskzéi; H 1;':b1i' %  

 "s?\«"?.P, E'*5<>.€>{}'98.1.f'2{I¥1 E

_  ' .'y'ar:s:'s C§:~;-zrmézppa L£11"2"E_£3§'Ei
.  .,3age:  34-9{:*"2":§°:»»;
 "{}s::.:;: {'I::;_:su§%§:
_  E?§'.fg'>."§?i'{>z2s:;5 _?\?<>,i}6

S%<;Ed21r:1:2acshx>v'21;' Nzzggar

 VV  §f':.i<;1L §¥Iub£i



 .{j';1i<:a'E.,1f91ub1:n_ . *

 W.P. No,60982/f;OI I

Reitnavva Lz1I;=ip{r.-1 i_42:1n:-'mi
Age: 46 }-"C£,1I?§;

Occ: CT<>01i:':

Rio. House N<>'§38
Sic§dzi1f:1:nes11wa1" N-agar
Unkal, Huijli.

Smr' Raina Eshwar Cfhavan
Age: 4() years

Occ: C00l.i.:-3

R/0. House. 1.\En.(3!
S§.ddara1nes;11w'.-1:.' _I\5z1gar_
Uflkal, Hubli

" ' ~   "~;'N..f;v__<_>;(w_()f.3é'-,'sVV¢Vi/'2()E 1

Y2-allzzwwzl £Xi.1§.r1;z,r2zy2zz3V M  i1g.:§i'A" ~ , 
Ag'<2:49  " " 7 = 
OCC: Cooiie '

__Rfo. Hcgﬁlsc ;"\'r_>.?l

Sidd;u*;:xﬁt3:&:.hw;:;:? N21 gar  """ "

  IN WP. €\§a>.€3€}985,r'?:{}'1 _:

Sma 5§.<>§:::;>: was {T'E';a{1<.ira mm i;2:2'1'1ax':§

% Age: f':¢€::;.:'s;

'   %Z,7i;.;:.::: €7a:=a%~%;: 
 " 2 "EV€,.s":<?r.~. Et:E:j2s:se:€"~§:>. 2??'
  -'§ét}d;:z'zm'7<3sJE1v;;2;;" Nazgzir

__ iE.,_3ni:.21§; Hubii;

1N WP. N<1>.,§jQ§?§§3/2.(§".iA.§V_ 



1N V".-'.§J. N(>.6(}98{é/2(JI 1.

Par.:-1.<;ap;:_3a Tiiapanna §,,i§1'1"12:n§
Age: 62 yealis

Doc: C0('.31_if3

R/0. 'H<>L1:<c No.36
Siddz::*an1csh.xv2:r Nagar
{Erika}, Hubli

EN WP. No.6{39v§§?£2(31: '

Smt. C§a1nga1\;'va BharmappavY'j'*11lyaY _ VA  .,
Age: 41 yczwss  ' -   V
Occt C00'ii<:

R/0. House N059 _ __
Séddararrzeshwar 'Dézigé"»=5- '
Unkal, Hubli " ~ 

 

._ %    wﬂpgNufeoéyés/2t)32
S2z11§ccve1;3V";3;: Ti_pp2.x_1tm.'f'E*z1§zifzigf' V' ' " J__

Age: 48 ye:(,11-:_~:    "  '

€)<:<:: C{)0}ie V 

Rio H.gj>uS<:L.Na>.'i4"»  x V

 J '' «.f3_icfd.;§':5T§{:11i?Shvériér N2é§i1'I* H ----- --« "
 Un1<';:_i,HubJ} _ 

_  M _ EN WZP. N<>.€1;{}989f2€}i1
Suit." :~sm::;:»¢a:;é%: 'H{';'a:21;7>§;z: §.",.::mz;2'":%
A ge:  §::;:;':: :5. V .--

 '  {}::z;t: C:;>z}'£ié::¢._
.  §{fa}.V?H<>a:s'e- 
_ V~A%S2§{§<i:§i"a2;:acs%:w21r N;-2.g;.»1r
_' ._U::_1i«:2:.E;Hub1i



EN W.P. 'N<>.6()99(}f2(}1 1

Kris;h11;1;);:>2: Baéappa. La'-zznanzi
Age: 61 yezxrs

Geo: Cocﬁie

R/0. House N<>.40
Siddammeshwar N£ifg:,ii'
Unkal, Hubii

EN wpp. :\Ja;»;g;sm<3§)91_/2L};,_§"'

Cioodussab Niallikzzsab 3\a'I'§sr%'§§@t:é
Age: 48 years  .

Gee: Cfoolie

R/0. Hozxm No.69 ._
SiCid£1FE1]T}CS1'1\W1E' 'N21g:=:s'   _ 
Unkzil, Hubii * I

  "  1 1

Smt. Am.{";£:dé-1h211m fX1".X(iL1_§i§h;1{ié1.:fVV'?1t{£if
Age: 32; ')€L'a1,':';A' ~ '     
O<:<::C001ic. _V -_

R/0. I_¥;{ju;*:a=: N<}.'~}E-. A V' "

" =  Si:;§d_i141"é:m::§L:§1*:war N;ifg:1:<. ..... .. v

Upkzizi, Hi':b€E _ 

{N '\?\f.fi?'. N<*>,{§§}9':7f%fZ€}'i i

:'\f*12:m§"az;é:1.:--ii ' - 

4' '._»S...«"0. .R;1m21§:§g2: L.;::z*1;m%
   2% 

_ "«.{Z%;c;::'1£'i"_'ie;".>:':sEi::':.
 §Z.fc;?}'.' Hams. E-"€<:':.?;.§>

Si§§£§§117€1EYE§iShWaE' Nagazz"

% " "'Lé1'§<21i, Hubéi



IR WP. 2\E{>.(3(}§?94/2()I §

r'\EI'1C€Fb<3tE Sztyyaitézasab (ii? K.i1:1d21§'x*ab EN-'E21}a:ar1a<.iaI"
Age: 4:3 jdt321I'f~;

Occ: Coolie

R/<3. House No.65

Si(1dz1t'a1m3shwz1r 'i\Eagz-H'

Unkzii, Hubii

xx: vs-='.1>g Nc;,T€;{:~§95x2<31v-1 

Smt. l-itkshmib22i. E\v1::hzz<ie\-'appa (}z:&;:ri.ir§r:.i._ 
Age: 43 years '    A  .
Occ: CT00§.%.c '
R/0. House N<}*87
S%dd:;m1mcshwa;'N;2,_g3::__ .  _  .  ~
Un'kaLHub1i        

i  ;y\?.15';N{:> S:5}I%a;é;:;5AATOV»i<a'1253/-2&3.11

" Nc);t§'1'3'é5/201 E

Smi. 13. 1%.; jam f§hi1*::.-dj'2..21t%   ~
Agc::4§ l's"ti;'-';1f}--'-  '  
Occ: C{)0li_¢:: ' _V ._

R/'05 H{OuS'."E; N(>.8_"S. _ V' "

" < ,_Sic§c§_:a:"am¢si3m:;ax' Nzigmi. ..... .. v

Ung;i1i,H£:i§1_:: § 
EN \>v.;?, N<s.6E 24e;2.<}; E

S:1V:t;""E32112:*h?a . Eimrziagx . 7:21 P€;<>';1ré
. .,. We v

x_Agc: :3» $1 j;"C§;'_*l"fé

  €;}":<?: C{§<T}§.'iiZ'-

_ '-.":::,5a. ?3§<:'z:s§<3: Emz?
 __  §§.i.<%'d2s§f:m":_:3shwzu' E'\5ag;g;:ar
  Uzﬁcai. E%.1:bE.'L



:'?:

 W.P.N{16i24?f2()1 1

L£1XIY12EIE  Lakkeappa Ayyappzx Kolkar,
Aged about «~13 yrzam,

Oc:<:; Coolie. zrfo Housgc No.53,
Siddarizrneshwzir N:-igar,

Unkal, Hubli.

IN W.P.NO.6l2<§8/2(}1l

Smt. Shantawa Ch:-mdrappa H0s'21zna1'ai*
Aged aboui 60 yezzrs.

Occ; Coolie, {X0 H.ous:': N0.185_.
Séddaram.cshwzt:' Nztgar,

Unkai. Hublé'

IN w:P.N0.ew;§2;éi9,:2(3V%1__;1

Laxmzm Pzarasagnpa Lamani,

Aged about 34 years, V
Occ; Coolie, 1'/0 H{)Ll§§{: N<).4E_-;_"'  -- 
Si_ddaram.cshwa.r i\:f~v;-1   '
Uflkéii, Hubli.

 

% '  ':N:.'3«*.:f..:§5:N'O:'(,» :.:2.50/20 :1
Dadzliall.?s='E.z1§«:.;1.:1cfé::',_  .' 

. _ Since &éx:ez1§1;'cc1 by 1':.%':<;-LR. \5;if'e,

Sm; Cf'hé1z1tEi:é51i."i)a<i;1§.a§ EN/iH:i«}<21ncﬁ121r§

W '~:17:>;::« :3 {_ 56% '_~s;,'..:%-V::'1:;'s.v'=.'é%__..

023C;..t§T<}:'§7E;¥+:§;»%:!<§ E-:i<.*s;:.é~;e E'-?<>§t3§§,
Side?;::*:m1sse%iw:;:;* I$éi2:g:a:°.

'  §,§§§.E;Ei1;«.H1l§}»§'i; _ 



. ,: ;n1m;.s:1;;b:_§;

: 9 :
IN W.P.?\'*C).(é!?,fi(3i2()l I

Imam Jéifé-if H;»1sa:1s2;§7 B yz1ha:%£i.
Aged about 32 :y'£liE1I'S§

(Bee: Ccualiez, #0 HCELESC No.93,
$éddz1t*z=11ne$I1w:sr Nagjar.
UnI<zi§, E~iubE.%..

EN W.P_NO.©125?/2()I 1

Eﬁailappa H. Kzilijmi, 
Since dcceetsed by hisz: LR. wife,

Sim. Tippzzwva Bziilappzt K2111}--m,

Aged about 57 years,

Occ; Coolie, {/0 House No.70,
Sédd21ra1neshw::e:* Nagzu;

Unkai, Huluiaﬁ

gm

1N vx/'.1>'.9;\:-t:)'.6

Sllekappa l,4,-.s11<:r:"r1_a"ppz: \?"i1gisi2::"';-- _

Since de.c:%ras@(i by  1_,.E9"{, wiij'é';~«.V _
Smi. Si121:1{a:\w';1 .S}';f%i<'¢:1}')§:§'(=!_ V=;i1giéiT;[a_r"' " _
(:9 .Ba[[hi, ziged 2ib<3=ut' <1;?;'}='.<§.:at's,"  
occ; Coolie, 1'/t1H0i:se N_o.29,' 
Sidd£1I'i1IE"s'O$hW'El§."  " V

  IN W,P.N'O.(€:.i 259;2{_>_1_:

B;-zs::;;:;:::*H. §3¥:3%;§u;r._f'
Sim:-*; e;E.:;;%c23a_:~;;'ei<;§.b.j; his; LR. wii'c=.

_¢ 'ﬁmii. '{z1§§2.wv;:?2 B:::~;a':§:;pa Eizsmszu
'    ;1.Ei:aa'>z::+:i§3 yeaim

€31:=:<;:; f;"f{':a:33éa: 22%'; H<>:,:s:-: Mr». iéq

 V  S§:E.<§£a:f::z§cshu?a1:'Naggzziz
 _ "{E:.2k;;.L Efuhii.



 W.P.N()S.61346 TO 6888/20} 1
EN W.P. N361. 3463/20} .1

Smt. SEk?E)}21 Aj_jappe1 Gc;}s;a'~,«"%

Age: M:-i_§(}1'   ._
Occ: Cooiéc I

R/0. Home No.1. 17

S%dda:*a171eshwa1:' Nagaz'

Unkai, Habli

EN WP. N<>.;()E347/2.8.1 

Smt. Kz~:irunnész.1 /\hcmadasa§.3 Shi:*21hii.tt.i
Age: 46 years

Occ;C0o1§.r2 '  :  _  - 
R/0. House No.59  é        
Siddammcshwaz".Nz1g3~r«"    " ' V"  ' '
Ur.1.E<aE, Hublé. 1

" ' ~ X'   \.3»}f'.'P _:xn:;.¢ 1 32:8/2.<>1 1

Smt. R:-zhcmibi' AbdL21  M--1i1::1Vf"' (<2?) "fVE"ii:1I121s21b Miizxigair
Age: 45 Yea1'§;», M A' S 2 
Occ: Crmééc 'V .,  '
 R1'().I.-'E3:}usé'?~3<7.1.ii)"  ..... 
' .V ﬂS§ddii1'E11]1§33§i"I¥';£:?'.NElgéﬁ'
    

{N 'WE §'~E<>.E>E34i9/29? i

¢ '.V1?\é2-1%>i:;2:%[;.. 8"2":a.§€:s;21E"> ?atm22>:§c

 . 323:9; <39 jg"s:.--a%s

= ' » 5£S¥<:V:;.i }£:'.k'}{>$§f:s
" . :«;;:o;»§w§.;me gxnyi?

 '  Sid;£:§a1:";,21"neshwa§' gm"
 ' " -U;--:§<zi§, Eamhié



~ V. «_Oc<::g1L;.z;3<>1.ié

:11:

 WT'. N'0.6{3S()!'ZOE I

'xfasant ¥'~fz1i'121m21mh21ppz1 (}m:n:;i§

Since citzcezased by LR.

Smt. P£1I"£1\»"V3 \?a5';zm.{ G0:.2r:.di   ._
Age: «'11 years

Occ: Coolie.

R/0. H(}LiS€: Nat E2

Siddzarziancshvwali Nzagzir

Unkal, Ifiubli

IN  N016  1 _

Nemappzt Kélﬂfiké-i])]}2i E.,211na13ViV_ H " 
Age: 48 years " ' "

Occ: Coolie  é        

R10. H{>L1S€ .Ng.:;'8fZ'  _
Sidd21ratnes]m;»:;u' ?$E_;1g_21r
Utukzté, Has-h¥«E?. _ 

" * ff « 11$:  'M61 3521/20: 1
Sim. Sha§<L1hVf;z«1.;}  i:*.2'1p;j2:_ Kc_117'2;32]'%is121aIa:"
Age:  :;J<'3_£3l.'§~1 '  '

V VREQ. E'{<[>%1.<§:5f'Nc§;~1S3
7 Sigiciézra:1'1v::V$§1w::r N:.:gz11'

 :'~m;b{:';;  

.iIN \«'v'Ii3*. N0,{3§353f."3{%.i E

h 4' ' = Vsfféii, LSz:.z*2i$aara1§é S<2:n:ssE;.¢§;;-:3' Eﬁzziéigm"
_  ii? yazzm
' . é.><;C':"~iZ?{mE~%s-3? R50. ;¥§<'>::s;e E'a?<1§2E
%   Siciidaraiszzzashwgzz" §\Ea§;ar
" -ijnkzzi. H:1%>1.i



 

:§i2,-:

LN V":-"P. N<).6I3S4,f'2()I 3

A1n.ba:i:m% R211nz1cI1:mc§ra CT%1awv:::2

S§:1<:<-3 deceased iay E61223" 392*:

Dzlxharzzt Ram2:c:ha:1dm Ch21wa:1

s\g;3: 42 years   ._
Occ: C<>{>1.i.<3

R/'<>. Hozxsc No, 120

Siddam:m':si1wa.r Nazggar

Uxzkzxlg Hubii

IN  No.6'! 355f'2:(T3--1----J : 
Smi. Shantawa Shckappa Jzzngmi A

Age: 5'! yezm;
Occ: Coolie

R/0. House:         

Sicldzirameshwzlr Nagag  '
Unkzzh Huiﬂi V

A' '$1.13: *2»-%.'p,No.@1356/201.1
Smt.  in.gé1'.{ui ' ('a%.'§21p;§a C? 1,1 i'é':.1j:1.Eig{§'§
Age: 54 yrezarfa 7 S 2 
Occ:(1'.s<§ii_€ V _ " '
- V. " ..R.;'<;.V_'?*§§:')¥\:i7iTL"': 30. 1 8 E A   ..... .. v
; VSiL§;i2é;'§*::mE:'éé'i1uéészjNagézz'
    

 V'«",§?'. N{?n6.§3f§7§2{}'§ E

'  Sm{. E{;g.n222'?.«:_.r:tva:2: E§aiE:2g"}p:: §{.z:ia:E
.  V ._}'1'a,g'z'fe;:% 36 3-?'%.-32%
_ V~.%f§><;g:: ifatwaiési
' . E€;i':3:."'§§%:§L:s=.;::' .';'\§<}f?iS
%   Si:;§<i;:;ia:z2_e-:.si'§w2i:f Naigzir
.. " '1-?Iii<:z:I., E~EL1b1i



$14:

 \?v'.13. :\1(>.6§3(?:2!;?.{§] I

Prasimriz Sh::k.z1pp:: Nzu.'gL1z1ci.  E'«§2wa};;u11d
Age: 35 ye211"$

UCCI Ceefie

R10. H{'3E,1S"<3 N'0.'23

Siddarat13c:;~..;E1wz1r  agexr

Unkal, Huhié

{N WP. Noiéf-.363!'32(r'E 1;

Sim. I\/Iariyavva Kustzagi
Age: 65 years

Occ: Coofie

R/0. H0u:s:': N<).6"?
Sidda1'am<:shw21:' Nalgzax"
Unkz-ii, Hubli   

 ....   "*:::::Nvsi'1;>;._N{§.ts:v3Vs4}2{)1 1

CI}and1';1sE'2.e késr Tam én.:{z 1'1A:1.é1p13'éV1' if:g_2.:ddz:l ii
320: 66 }.fe;1';'..i'% A '   "   "

Occ: Coolie -- _V -_

R/'0. H{§J%.E'E~Zf3_N0.9S'-. A V' "

 ~ . A_Si<id;§*;'é3:n¢$§::v»:V;2x* Nagzw .. ..... .. v
 L?:"2.i<;.a§§ H'L17r}£i 

§E\E 's7x?.§3'. 1\2's.{3E365fZ€}§.§

Smi. £2533§«f.g:;i":mé '*{2€i'i:=%;;:r§::-'z Ba-2E2,-xvzxtgé

' V Asia: 5 E :~_;=3.;2:;.<;

~_ <_..»

h 4' ' = {}'c..r:.:; £T<2<'§§:<3
_  ?§€i:::2é:€ §"~§§'L§é3
 _' T._5§2"<;§_e§é:'aa;?§2<:::<eE"2<mu' E'~»Ezzg2::"
 ..' H'UI"i}3.'.2iE., Hziiﬁi



:15:

EN WP. N0.6f.366f2(}II

SI1z1nk:,1r.' H'd§'_$;E,Ep}}£i KL111d21rgi
 Si} yeztrs;

Occ: Ceolic

R/9. Hcuuie No.56
SiC§{§Ei1'Ei¥'£1C-Sh\rV211' Nagaz'
Uxakzﬂ, Huéﬂi

IN 'MP. N(}.6I36_7f.Z(}_§§

'.{z1.z11<appa Rarnappu Kilndargi

Since de.ccased by his LR. j
Smt. Scmavva 'r'an2<_21ppa .KLmd2-zragi .V
Age: 57 3962213 
Occ: C()<)§z'.e:

R/0. Hmlse No.21

Sidd21:'az:11csi1wz:r E\'='z1g2-zr

Unkzxl, Hubli.

  ;\.-mg I 3é8s'2{_)] .1

Y:11nanapp'z:.H'::13:s;1.ia.tf1téqjpe _Y::I.z»iwéix"
 S1. yea:'s*--.._V - -_  = 
Occ: C?:.1;0Ei_e " '

'WAR30..,:it4fs711S'§'E'«3<7»§§4   ..... .. v

 i dziziifa 1"r1"c§i*m?2':*;:_  21 gel 5

 U:1k';?1§~V,.I%i'u.b}€~  AV ' 

 "WE. II\§{).é§3é9f2{}E E.

_  E'akr::ész1?b E4E>;1s;c:1:~:::¥:> S'L:ni<z;:i§
 A 46 ;.--='{':';1:'$
" « _{"}si:;:; ifmizi i C

_  §<,s';:':§"i~E'<>:1s;:3 3"~Es;"§.i{}5
' Sicj§<;ia1°;3.m£:$1We:a:' Nagzxz'
" "€;§'x'1i-.921}? H'2:%i>}i



:17:

IN WP.N{}.{§l374;"2{')1l

Lzaxman Ran ggapgja .KL§l"1ddI'€1g§,
Aged about 46 jmzzrs,

Occ; CT0(>%§e, 2:/<3 H.0u,<;s N'<'>.~/ﬁr,
Sic'icE2tr2m1es;im-'ar Nagar,
Unkal, Hubfi.

IN x»'.p.N<>.a%:_3?'5:;g;¢ ii

Surcsh Laxmam Belzwaiagé,

Aged about 42 ye:-11's, ,
Occ; Hguseholci, r/0 Hmlse Nc}.:3I.,  
Sid(i::raInes.hw2::' N':2ggar,  'A
[jin§kE¥].\ﬁ ¥Iub1i.

 _ we x:«";:i»';1~£Zi3 6: 3,?.6f2§}'.:  ' 

A11§L1111:211221 ,

Since ciescea-1s;<3:d_V1">j_,--%:__1'i%;;:§ \I»'iV£T'c14IL,V.VI~'§..',' ¢_  7
Smt. Sh21Vk:1--;1T1::'fi§' 'A1j§L§'n:;.K'&'Jz:f, 

Aged abatnazi 60 7 V 'V   _
Occg C0d1ic," E"/0 'H<>é;zsfe* No. :1'  _
S§d{i21rz1n1e§shVx>§";1§N'ag21§';--« '-- "  
Unkal, H:ub.%:§.  A'

"  « .w.P.:x*(>.6 1_3??;2(): E

 Sim." L;1i:>mf;'i'i:'¢.:é;i*Bé;s.:a.ppz1 E-131 gi,

}'x§g:c:§ :1E5<;>::{ "£6 }"'£,;1.?';§,
C'uj:c; €ji'<>0E.i.e..; mg: 3'*§{§}%lS€.  § Béﬁ
Sédd:':«§:1;ni:$Ew.=¥ai§  8§.§Ei.%',

'._yz,'::~;';ga:., %§:,:E.:5§§.



:18:

IN \?€.P.E\JO.613?8f2(}I_1

Smt. I)yzm1aw21 §j\»'I£Ii1jiI21E.Ei.§'1 Rzxjuptxi.

Aged 21§',)()iZ1 55 yc:=u?s;_.,

Occ; Cooiie, :10 House N<>.§5Z,
Séddzirzxmczshwzu" 

Unkal, Hubié.   _

IN w'.P.NQ.e:37':2,g§_..:_': ~ 

Saint. Pzuavva Hzmalnantappzi (}uj~§é£r::i§';....
Agar] abcsut 46 };'<:ars:,  
Occ; Caolzic, r/0 H.()L1S{3 N'<3.36/A,
Siddeerm:ncshwa1' Nagar, I '

U:1.i:<.aL_ H'LabIj.

"  "w';':5;Nf(}'r§_:3$:3;2<3:  u

Smt. lmvva V_§r21F3'3,ciriép}:3':1 }<..(.3}i_:  
Aged about 64} yc2::9S,,V 2 é  '
Occ; C<><)]i.<-2.,.Tr/<3' }H(.'§Ll'§C::N_{.).97,  '
Sidd;a:'z;1:1Vie.ahw:11 " g:;1r[;i, '
Unkal, Htlmi'; ' '  VA

_ -741N'~.x_%m?:'N0.6t38 1.12m

" '~ .. {}:)':1:;.;:%%§ab;_ 3&1aham2-miSéb*--i3<j{§cia1n;éni ,,

S§_n:':<3 <i;:cCa.$m;} %;;~; his LRA wife.

'  S 3251:; :R.:1:j 2i':2.§._ (3 we :%§\Li&§£':b i}e3dd21m;m%,

:5;.getE"._;a§3<2'{:: ii€%_  02:3; C,'{.><;>E%§3,
R/0'E%O:z:~s€: _l\}s:jr;'§.3;1§.,
Si§ide1f221n¢:SE12s;v;i.:' §\321g;§:=:::

  «gum :~:§.;§:§;:;,



:19:

135 W.I'.N().6'i 382!20.1 1.

Smt. (}z1.ng;:z-wvzx  Shzmgzzvva
}4{a:121:nan§2:;3pa Kalyazi,

Ageci about "FE }sc211'$,

Occ; Coolicz, {J0 House E\'o.63._
S§ddz1t'at1nc~.;}1wz':1* Nzigzan
Uz1is:a]._ Hubli.

:2»; w.P.NO;'E;}»:.VV3'2§3;20: E" .

Ma-zllappa Pmbhakzzr (}2¥YZEk\?Q'}.§§§,

Aged about 65 jv-"€E}.i'S,  M T .  , ,
Occ; Wzxtchnmn, rfo Hausa No.'2§§. 
Sid.da1'a.meshw;1r Nzlgéyzf,  ' VV '
Unk:aI., Hum. % "

_ 1111  Q   :;_N .W.:5 > .'i-e"<3.1+3V.1V3:eé4z2{)1 1

S3311. E3'z3:rWa11é. R;r1n21Ci}t'2,':1';d1La%V  

C'?/T  Raju K€:3§aii::, '  ' 

aged about 4(;--..yea.rs, ._ ' 

act; Hmzsghalci. rfg>VF¥{§u$é'N0.36/A,
Sid;iai'i;::n;:téhwzn'  v

" 'U:;k:iL Huib11,%' 

EN '\§f.P.J\E{}.€}§f%§§5f2(}i§

'  Sm: /%;.1:1:1;:%22*:222 Virhhaxdxfzippa E<a£L
 ';-4":.Ag:3<§ zzbgféatz 42 ;;=£:%:*§:,,
'€§2;:::;"§5§0:1sea:h<7:'§;;§, 21% H_<':2.::%;;$  E 82?

:;%{§€fz£§§:1l'1'3i3$§.'}'§*€EI§' f\§Eig2i§'..

  Uiiziiaé, Ir§_a:%>E%.



:20:

IN W.P.N().6f.386!2f}Ii

Smt. \"'21§iamm:z Simkzippza Nzwgztrzd,
Aged about 555 yea.;*.<;.

(Dec; C<>o1i<'3-. r.f<i: H{3{ISE' _?\fo'22,
SicIda1f;1meshwz1:' Nztgzu',

'Unk.aI, Hubii.

IN W.P.N'O.6I387!2()}I

Smi. Laxmzwvza Balappa K3122},   -
Aged abuui 56 ymrs, 1
Occ; Cuolic, rfo H£)i}E~;C- No.64,
Sid<;1ammeshwa:' Naxgazﬂ,

Unkal, Hublt.

iljN' w'.p'N<).1a%:§§;s/2a): I .%

Sim. }r11;1m.z1b: Hui§;'c1:_3z1bV'E%§'z:dé£f;_' ¢_  
Aged abgim-1t~39      *
Occ; Hct:usch<>fi;{',5f',:j'7:) Eliéigsc-.N{.:(23{}, _*
Siddararfsisxliwztr Né1'gét';f,} M   "

Unkai, Hu'r:E_%." _ ' V .'

'V  w,P.é<(>s.é_:3% TO 5 14r:)8;2<>2 2

?N W.P..;\E(}.é S 3;€?éf"2{) E. E

"§"i.§,3;:§3,;;';2z2 €§2§';::g:-é;[:>;§21 Bannu.r._

z%gb.<.:§' 3'sbC%iEL~ :3_:**IT:4j'.;}-'A::":m*.$,

~V £33023: €ZT:T>9":i§:. zzfa H.<.>u...a<: E'~$<> "~)"}_.
~ ._ ' "S~§2'{§:;§::.:'z;:";":.:;:§ :2'§2xra:"22::' 3\»2z':;;a::_
3  .782: i<:':'s-.?.__& E~E:.1bEi.



 Unk:;!;.:HLz'?:H,

: 2% 2
IN W.P..N(l€i}.397§2(}1l

Mzihamad. Hushen Nazciaf.

Since. deceased by his I.,..i{.

Smi. A3'n§nz: Mzzhzizilad Hzzghera ?'~$a(§:-'zii
Ageti alum: 48 };e2a1's,

Dec; H.0use:h.01.d. r/9 }%I<>u:»'-<2 z\30.1.?.5,
Sid(I212"ziIn<:Si1w21r Nagal'.

Uﬁkikl, Hubli.

13¢ w.}?.N'0.61_3<;2'%/2t)'1'1 ._ 

Pz~1d21mzLn11a Bhumli Metzxgzlr,
Aged abaui (30 y':::21rs,

Occz; C0o1.ie, 1'/0 House N<>'52,
Sic'1dz1r;1mes:hwzz:' Nagar,
ifnkzlh Hubls".

 ....

Smi. §21ri:}a1 Kz:s;héV:éi::=:L%&.» N;3_vé1"E1,§r',v~--- .. ' Aged zabotsx, 45. :J€£11",S:, ' _' Occ; Cc><31ie§'*1'[o"H<}1i::;e No.1 Sin}(i:u';1:?g1eshwi:t: "

.iE\3 '\?v".P.N{},éE4€}{i3;'2{}E_ E §\F'fé1§}£i:{§L%b$Z1b' §A::;"rr:Ti:ik;T2;2 Eiaziam, Agcd"--2:b£tm: :§'531"§;:éz:;'a

2 r_;{}cc; {f.'e;::s3i.i€:5 :7':':> Hiiiliéﬁ E-§'.%., ' S é~;%<§:,f;:'z::":':e;§'5e;E3;zasgw zzgaziz " « . ishéék :22: IN W.P.NO.6I.é$('}I!2(}I E. Rzitnzippa Cicwindz-xppaz If,,am21z.1i. Sincstz dec: *EIS€(§ by his LR. 5011 Sham mark Réifiiflélppa L::'man.é_. A,g§c:d £':h(}L1t 64 yearss, Occ; C.o0].i<:, r/0 House No.12, ._ Si&dz::*aam<:s;invz1:' N':.-aggzix", ' Unkzﬂ, Hubli, EN x>¢_;>.N{é ¢é~492/201 1_

i)uregapp2: Hértumzaritz-xppa T01'2:gaH,. " v -. ' ..Ag<;:d abom "£6 y<:a:"s, ._ "

Occ; Coolict, rm House N0. 18,' Siddammeshw'21:' 'N21g.g,zuf, "

Uni-.<aI, Hiibli. V Kz:s12i1n>';;1b~--Ob;ii's:'1b " . . Since --\ﬁy-=i£'c_ _ _ S1111. N3jé:211u':1nisz1 K;1§;hi 1§z£a§zu1'E3__.B'cg21, Aged about 54' §;c211$;._<3c~af;--f f§<§:2:.!..%_ég. "

R/0 Houiae N'<j>:..}_V39v, _ A b Si<;I£Ea%.:';-:':1°1<":$;E1war N3 * v. ».,L§%'?}':f}»t>!'._':"3.i-/I1;}~1.'3:\ii» ..... .. v IN W¢P.N(3.6I<i§()<if2[I}E I. Sa1h.22n§1<:v21;_>'§>:i '§.3:vj€._:2:p;}:: Bzméza, /a§;:'€{i£"<21b<_>%.__;é 347%' «§;r2'221z's, 4 {}{:c; €;?<:mEi:::;_ gm Hausa :;\m:~5:5 V f?.~S%.:'i<i;1r;1:";:&:§hvs:g::° 3f'-ia;;::1:".2 " E§31}§;iE;~«_§*i::§'}£§= "xxk'._:?:41§:§>.(;--'1 4&3/2V_<T31 } :23: IN \?v'.P.N{},6.14»(}5f2(}1..1.

H_us:~,;aéns;ztb I-1a;<am;ah (3-<)mmar:xa_§, Since. deceased by izis; LR. wifa Smt. Rehanabaznu Husemalh Gmnmana}, Aged abeui 3'! years, arse; Cookie, Rkf: Hausa i\'?0. 17, Sic§d211'a1meshwa1* Nagar, Unkzzl, Hubli.

EN W.P.No'5--v3L.4:3ss/2{>; 1*-

H..ay21dsz1b Kashimsab I,<>1<z*:;3ii*:§ Aged about 46 }-*ea.rs, . __ --

OCC; Coolie, r/0 House N<2.§{):i, Siddan-1meshwar Nz1g:3r_ .

Unlcal, Hubli. 3 Husens21bV"N21fgari; _ V . __ Since decezésegd' by hi:;. HR}; _ " V' Esluamail HusemuabvvE\E21g:;ré;._ V Agasfd 2i;'.>o*L:L_ 35 :;€a:'s, V' V ' " 2 aOc:~::: ,_5::ﬁ'§':('é§:¥f;{f:., :7/'f§.s H<>L1'sfc*: ()3, Si(i4r§a1i9a2né'::%:w;:I'N21321:', EN E-'ix-'¢P.N{lé§4{}8f2{}§ E Sinai, She~§<;a%z;s:z2 Szzbaish iéaégi,

-- gﬁiji j _;%b<3£§ 4? }'é2é1i'f<, _ "{}<;;; .§€':'<ms;<:§*;<';E.<§., 2:/'e;> E%<>::::;€: E'~E<>.'1§€}? _ _ -_Si'é:§:é:'a2§':es§e'waif Nagzir, ... i,7'::}:'a2{, Hubhl L» 3""

:24:

EN W,P.N(}S.60872 TO 60881./2{}§] Vasu Sfctz. Lr;)i<z1;3pa Lamzzni Age: 39 y<:2'1zi$ (kc: Coolie Rio. HOiE.<;C No.37 -

S§dde1:'z1mes}1wzn" Nzzgzzz" ' Uxlkeli, Huhié R21.m:=:.s;h S/0. HO{)\-'£i]}}}£1 La1;":1ar1§. Age: 39 }'{:21:T~:

Occ: Cmlic Rio. House No.33 Séddarz:1nesE1wz1;* .N'21g2*:r Unkal, E~9iu13Ii M 21.] :3: SL1bzjzn1:.i':.y_a £{L'::::-'E:Tl'"1£1.i]}.»':' __ V. ..-I-Xgczt 38 yE::;1"s--f__ ' V Occ: }7§<3«us::f_i'u1_(i. is, R/0. 7ri0us<3 'V Siddamm':éSI1wax* 'N'ag_arT. _ W ' E_»§!Ek'211.'}'{LVlf)'1i" V " "

Yza§;§a--*&-jzi Maha{jevaippai'Y9.{{izf:ga1i§<§e:

3%>:w:m % 'V ' OC<:: ¥*E{§'Lméi':r)E_ci A ' V..R;ﬁ:.:.. f'5£)§iE'r5 A E§.E'ddi1:*£z1§':«'3§;§;2§;::f--'"f'«§21g2':.:' {}r§'};:aE" awe.

% 4?ss'¢:;/3.?

§""E;1§.<;;;.I1sal{:e .. E{'§'2:1<};2:'s:':%> Pa2£'E:;zn _ 33$ gfgzzrs;

(Eggs: {7<><.';}é::' R,-55>. Haéassc ?.'\;':x E {)8 §Si~:i<iz1:'z::11<':;\*.?.2 WE-'££' agar ' U:2§<;1}i._ HL:E3.¥.:i

6. Allzxbakshzz S/cs. Bhashztsab Suraiui"

Age: 39 yczars;

Occ: Cfazolic, Rio. Hmasc No.1 19

Siddzir21m<:sI1w21:' agar U11kz1I., Hubié "

7'. Basaw-'V21 Baramalppzi Kililtfaifiifgi Age: 35 yezurs OCC: H0uscl"1o1d, R/0, H{3LlS€ 2*-?{}.'Z.() Si{1dz1r211nc:s.;hwz':.2" N2.-1.gm' Unkal, Hubéé

8. Ramazwa .[%21s2t\:'21mj 1;a:§i;i':3i Age: 36 years " ' ' Gus: H0usel1<.31dV R/().HOL1S€NO.,Q3v._ _ _ , V_ .

Siddaramcshfw212/f;:i\¢¢ig21§>'2' 4' Unkai, Hi;bE.;."" ' V V

9. A_sho }:, ' ' _ __ S/0. imppzi S21ngv2;;'1:1:;:v::§\~. "

Age: 38 yemfsvv _ -* €)<;<::*C0o1ie, AA R)'0. }%.'ou:se No.42

-SiE§d::r_;i:';3§;$11w21i"E€;a.g:;1:"

'V ' « _Unka'IJ.

A\?§?"!«;::' .R21§Igé;p§azi E.<.Lm{.iam5;1? ésggcz €}::<:~~: {T<:<)E§€:. 'i?;f'<;3, i%~.{m:s-2: ?\E<>.<3;5 . ,i':§_i:§ai:';§:':1::z"::;:=:eE:w21z° Naggzix' _ E.,?;§'§:3~:L&-EL H3333; :E'}£3i§E§{}i'Ei3ET§;. {.B§jy* Sré 'V.-=',Z?\§. She:":§;1x=':1.:1L Aciaa} : 26 : And:

Hubii Diiarwzzé Ev-kmicipai C0:'p01'a{i:.m., By iii; C01m'n_i:;s;i0§1ez', E:-Eubiii Regpm-1.deni.

{'<:<>mm<?m in 213? the p:_c{';»1_;"cjm_V;~;';r Sri (3.1; Gzxchchimmuith, Adv.) "

The.§;e Writ petitions are filed unckfii'>}Xt"[:i';=1§2s'..'22§ of:

C0:.1siitut§.<m azaf lﬁdia, p:'a:yin.g ta quash the :1C'§iCe.§;'= d2iI.e§' Z2V,:.i,_2{%§TEA bearixzg N0.H}C)I\/1'/201'} issued by {here5;p<);1d_czi'*.V_;1n<i " . * ' Writ Petitions coming (')3 fat? Prclimi1mry He:::1'ér1§ in 'B' Group this day, the Caurt made the f'<)I10V$::év11g;_ Since €OI'I1§.'£.1.(')1T'.'£'£ilCSiiCI'i' o€".{:¢;w5 ;:1.r¢ad._i'z=*.<:7tv_zuf§i31'vi§iv<>Iv<3d. in all these <:.ase.s, §§}t3jv' am: cEt:'.ﬁ+b.<3<_1 té¥ge.£314é:'g_he211'd and cijﬁposed 01' by this mrmxzan {)}."di3t1 ~'Tfh:3 pi2a%;I.%;§:_:::3'£*s; ¢:.mt'e11ci !;h£1t they am: <)c<:z:p§;i11g <§iff"cr:":n:

;;<m~;:a:: Q'?:'::ué'a.¢_bm-1;:_g S§m\E<>.36A 0?' Ur2E<.aI Viiéaiga-'-3,, Hnibéé Talztkﬁ E)'?1;1:'«:x;a:g§ i)i}'s-%.§f§c::.;'-.7%T§2sy Eigzvs 921: up 5:,§1:«::§§_ f.»'h€:{§E»;'§1iI§S on me :'~;a'i{'i mm 2-ma} Eiéwc b_;;é::l;:-:*s:5si<:§%;*:sLr:_ in :§1<:=sz': sheds E1}: 1%: §};3iS§ 35} in 3;'-carss. Tim 294;a:A%}§T%L--'§}h;::*2%2mi E\:Em§i::ig3::§. {:{.>I'§}£}i';'2!,§{§§'i{{Sf :=;§2<?;:°§ zhas. "{T<"::'§>m*:§{%::>1é'"} _' T._E12:$ zsss;'ig§s:::i €()§'§}L}§'é1l§{m aumbar 2:} ihtz-ﬁr huts; zzzzé ii; hays; 326.623 2 : 2'?' :

<:t;)11€.~::{ing 1213;'-:,<; f1'<.>;21 than. The area': in qu<-Jstiozt has: been declared as 2:

slum area Liﬂdifi' S<3.<:t%0r.1 3 01' the Slum ﬁa.rez:{.11npr<>v€m.eni and Clearzmca.) Act. 19336. The pc%iti:m<":.1's; have pmamceti the tax, paid receipts issued by the Carper:-":ti01:. The Foraasi Cc}ntra<:tm"s zlmi 'E'.'i_19{;E3c;' 1*»-'Ec1*cE12u"2ts' A.~:.so<:iz1ti<):1 L§m§.t<2d_. Hub1.i, .f.%.§cd a peté.ti<%:i_ bé1?<S§e. COLIFE in 'W'a'ii' Petiiicm N<'>.l2r~§?.()/2.(}06 f<)15H;; mzaI:cia1*m'2v>.»:--- i.-*0:-2 C<>rp0r:-itéan ta devctop "the. said iand res:c31r'*-..§<-:d {f'("')'i'A.p£1lT'E\E aI1d"f£'i.CI§:f"a.?{)ﬁE?.ij§' 1" ire brigade per £118 appmveii ';'"}_Ia31n_V b€:a.z*i1:g' fI'¥;{).iT)'E dated. 20/1.2/E976 (for shert 'she I;a}*Q;2_iV"E?1_z:;:.'; ) 21rid'--t<)Vvpre\§f:nt the 3" pziriitzs fem": Ci}Ci'()E3.C§T£iI1g £he"'-5;zi:§d_A}.aﬁd;[. T]'i"e.ijg1f1"t1f;e petitioners are in pass'-esséorl of diﬁfcrtznt p(3:*£§:5ﬁ'.$'»cif'iihc ;;"a,id Ié1_nd;":§1e§,.r wart: net mach: parties the '.'~;'L'-1v;iVdV' ,'*---'»'»"~E'_vi'V["~§?{5EiE7i.C';'1,_. ' -'This; Court by an order ciated 22/()2/2010 'diV.a"(i<:1jcd'th_é VC6:'§>6';=;1i'i'(>;i' to develop the izmd wiiixin. 2: period <3? 3%)»: m_<>nE§1:~; f"m:':;1'. thc;°T _d£iI:§ €.é%"'r:3ceé_pt Qi.' cepy of aha': Quiet. 0:: {ha

---.bas._;isgxj>53:f. mid {i?;;'{f£;'».2f__,____f;}_'«»:?, C.<:1'pc;::rati.<>n has; égstled m>I:'i<:e3 to the ;"::¢L:'ai.<3§"m's: 'to: (Fe-:§f:-:}1i:<h the shcds;f§2s:§.s and v2a<:a:<:: EEK: Egmé. ii is Eiérthcr §i';£ii,V£';i£i§'- ii': ":1a;f§::%:;:<::~s ihzszi if 5%}: pe£ét§<me:i=a 'mi? :0 §i<:m::r»Ei:~;h {ha s;%1:3<its.:!§éé1§s; >,'_2r..3'{'%-Ex' 3%: Eami aha s;::m:: wiii. has a§c.:1;1:;}§ésh@s;% éisy {ha V{}kCQ.SR.52 L : 28 : C0rp<3rz1t;i0r2. "I'h<:r<::f<>r<2:, {I36 petitmraers have f.iIec:1 they: w1'i1 [.')€Eiii()§'iS §'<}1fquz:shéng of the said nmices.

3. The CT01';::<)r;1I:i0n has fiked iis ;s;tate:'ment of 0b§_e_<_:té<>n.«; <:0ni€:n_d§ng that i{ has no: zissigned any pmmancnt numb<:fs--V.i{:s.Vii3c hu:m.<:ms;. The: :1u1":zbs::' given {'0 the hL:tm:2m:~; i2; {cf:i*:1<:iEi:t'at:é'*rim:

comimtting of the ce.n:~;u.9; the land in qL1c--:s;t:i0;1--.. is -=§z1r:f;1.;i1*i§<é:'gi ﬁi:r._'p2::*i«:. and open space in the c<>211p1'ehen:;ive dc»-*eI:)pnf'.._e1it p1a'r1--._ ' i;h'1§;3s's__'ih¢fe» _ is :2 change of the land use, no pers<>r:x_éz:.1; lay :31 <.:_I2u'm {Q tVPi~5: s':1'i:é"Iand. "

The mtécaz i_<:sued Lmcié-:1? S€C[~§<)I1 3( 3}-"c3f t'h€uSlluzn .»\i*ea(.E1npr0veme11t and (TIez1.1fz1;x:--c@) Abt, 19515;. v.»ii.t}3.:}L:z 110---1.%.r;a2":t<;» the C0:"pc>raté<>n. Thaugh {he said I'1()_[.iCé? '\?,i'=:',Vi.$ E§h;):V'lLi.V(':'(j' §>r'1"~.19f .11./L/'2{){)I, no further steps have 'ii>ee.n iaken so fzu*.a Tin": "¢TI(5f";3(;r.a1"i'9mé has taken f§1€ipS to dernolish Ehe shadsfhuizi-V in vééxiz, <ri1*:" 5LE1<: ':ii:'eczi<m of {his Cmm in \?%f:*é£ ¥?::t§t§.{>:1 "mg.:2.;;jé:§;2{:::1as.V%% <;1e1:e£i"v;.2__--;r<<;'2;2a14::. it is féxriher <:<>n§;en<;1e:d that *.é;m":*ne<='§§z1:;.*§§gV:§f:c§"~§h:: rezzeigﬁ. <1}? zhe @§'c§g:;g {M3 Eixecuiéise E"E:';gma3€::* GET' éhii j€,7':-'§='%T'_§»'*€;.:q~"2L*:;%{:w;.1;,: E';;%z1iV:4;C£i:"::::*;:;°:»:i the Assésazmz C£'}I'i111E§.§Sf$§{>I1€i1_ Zmrxi €}i'f%:.:e 20 c<>n':-'fm£,:E 5:5' the magi.' in e;.:z'c§e:° ii': ézngiiszmésmé 32$: :'"~:::%.<"§ {1§"§:3r. §§} €az;":VE1<:»:*2z:2<::: <3'? aha gaid 0r<i«:--':r, 211:5: ;'%ss;'és;i21:1: {7<}:':*::":";i$s§gia>1";:::g Eienai fkfﬁce : 29 : N95, along wizh §1is:~.; ta"-3:21:33 hm; wéséted the .'«;pi;3E1 amé dcmggzrcatszci the azncmaésheci area: 59 as [0 ciemolish the uI:.2:1;ztl1{>r.é;s<:d 3h.e&".:~:f}:uts <:ar1:etm<;:£v:~':d t.hcm2(m.. T'hereai't<3r, an {}Fd€I' C{>mmis;si011er of C<>rp<>rati0n dated 2'?/{)1/72011 Lmde1°"S§::Ctvé§m. V sf the ACE for d<3I'I](}I§[§{}I1 ef the: :1z1ztu£_§1c3;'§§»ié bghcrisihut-gs p::1'i«:;.;1v{$1i"thé. lands. Purmzmi: to {he said <3rdez'j0i' the:.C{*;:i;11*niss;ii::%;::f,* ié~npug'r';:3(§'~ §.1(§[iC€S have '%:<:.cn issued [0 She: ;.7{éIvi:Vi"<3;3e';"s c2i§.E§:1g»1épa>f1' then: ':0 d€2nc'>i%sh. the sheds;/huts: unzez:i§h.g:rise'tI:I§% §:r:stj 1:15" by them 21rj d £0 vacate the said Iand.

6%. I hawe'h"eé;«a.¥: iii=:::.'i¢;:éu*n;:<1_ (3<}L1tiseE.._fL31f_ :.h€ parfiies. i".«r'{3_§ii/"1.'}.E.'/tiv"V{:'$}@ii'}$€f'"1<£«$I."-."[-E1{:-.pcEi[i{)§1€;"S wouid conlstztad that ihuugh the izimdéé W219 ci?¢:f:12z1:'.'§i;%:<i' 170:' 93.2%; amﬁ D§)€'3ﬁ spam: in {he V C{>;m3r€;%éér::;§ve D<?:'¢e:*,_1. <§f3:n<:.1':{ Pizm, ihe. pctiii0n€:1'.:~;ftheé:' g>rcéiec:<3$s<}r2; h;m:V._g;}1:E :,s;i:.§;E:c,*{i*:;.fE1::Ea am She 3:531? Ezmd iﬁsng 2,-tfge zmé {.%:e.§; Eiawc been Z'{'3'i"~:i€ﬁ'§".:j§~'_'},f"iE'§ iE%§.§§ 1's:'$'g'><:<::.§*<¢a: .<s§2c<.§s;;'izz;i:'; £:'<>§' {ha-3 §"3éiEs'¥; f.%{}»35 ycegm, The .C€ZEIT§}{}§:§E§§('%QA§'2§;§:¥§ é,':Sf'£§'§,{E";iEﬁ EE¥.Ei"§":§.?ﬁ§"f>2 ta %.'E'2a3ir :sE::::dxf}:u{5 am} 3% E2215; buzz; ¥;:.g;ii%ca;L%;.2L:':g__:{ égéx §'s°<7:m i.E'1:~::m. The peiétéaéners am mi: made pa:'E.i3.< ta)» the 15 ?

: 30 : Wx*it §'€l§.{.i£)§} :\.'<'>.1242()f?.(}(}6~ thimgh {ins}; 2m: in p<>s;s;<-:sm'(1:2 of the izmd. The pC£i[i£')IEtEI"$ 3:§"t3 M3211 \.xx<2ak'@':.' $e<:té<}r1 of aha: s0<:iety and i'33.e§: are {mi in 21 pcmitéazl to ifzxaicc 212.1}? 211£€:1':121iix-'s;z 2;m*a:1g€1"n.43--nt far their tcsjfzdcnce. Thea}-' were HG: heard befbre p21s.s'-mg {sf the impugxaed <7s:*dc §s--.L ».E'f-mhe p<:ti£icm.e1's are rc-'zhzibéiitatcd eisewherie, the}? are 1*c:zmij_; zo. :V'~i1{.;}c5t"3 "ihieif n'3spc':ct:ix-'<3 sihcds/hut:::. I .' _ _ _ V .

6. On the other ixami, l.ez:1'1ae<§'~._Ad_Vc;catc:'»;1p';3c:.:::'i1i;. 'L=1T'oi*iithe rcspcundent suhmitﬁ; that the 1::r:(§v'i;1":3_uc:s1%011. was re?:§:_<3:"ei§:'<;i-V.fQ:*~parl< in ' the C0mpa"chcnsive Devcksplncrlz P1_4;.iV;'».V1': ::;11:1z1<>1b1:.L1V3ed}fb1' any other pu:"p<:)se,wéVt.E1Qéi'£. £116.;-:«;:V~.be~&.11g--. an (:')':*:§V<c';" for clmxlge of lamd use in 21cc<>1'd£1m:e "with i_.zV1'x'~..-if~,t"i?hc p::t'i:jione1's have zjnatathorisedly put up Sheds/huts. ;"['--!.1<3 n1.1n:eb;_er$'ﬁsséigheci by the C(>:";:o:'a1i<)n to the sE1e&s/hum " u ¢_ Gf {I,3[<:5'«§>::;i__L§<:u7;'e:'s: :s;'t:1<;*::1<2g2.c)1*'2::';~,I in 1§£i11;i1'C in <>rde:r L0 f2.'iCﬂi{é2l§'2- <:<>ndm:iing Of. 6%-m.s;.1s:,v,,' ;4:33s:g3¢)r:<;i<T:nIsi; Exam: 11:} 0£h<3.:* Qpiiozz bu: E0 impéemézzzi $23 <>:9'<l:::9'gyziisseéixf'j§::sjJ this; Ci}L§l'E in Wréi P:-.3E'i.:;i.<_>n ;?\?':'>..E.2é§2f'};';'?i{}{}€'é ﬂéitﬁéj ._22f{}Z»3;'Zf%§€'};: $222; is vchjg me C{>:'nz:1%s$i<>ne.1' <1£'€f<>:'p<}r2zt§{>:*; has §f'3£i5%§Z<£*=;E " . .i:s.:":V {:§r'~='.%:3r a:;}<}e:.2' :'§a::<;:':i<>:2 Eéégi} G? :%3;:: Acé; aézzzmi E'?:'{}E;'f§{}§§ ifer : 32 : issued :1 119t'ifi<;z:iio1z zma:i:3:r Scctieri 3i 1.} of the Act dated 19;'[2fZZ{)(}] declaring the 2l.§I'{3E£ in qL:€:s;1§.<>n as; 21 9:11:11 area. Hm '(%'."1.{j3'.(fLEI'[h(iI' prgsceedings have: been ini[.iz1ieci pursmant 10 ihc szzici :.1o£ii5E»_ j1_'::'..<.>'_n; Thm. it. is clear that the p<3Ei[i0:1£3:"S haw: "been in pc'3:':;se;$:gé€§';2,V <)'i7.A_1th::' T%ahd in c;u:3slé0I1 for ihe pets: sevezml years. §j€:'a§1i<";.1_3c:i-sf; '1§{=V§¢1'€', 1}{'}V[' V_m;1{i-:3 ' part'i{~:s; [0 Writ Petition N<).1242()/2{3()€>f lh [h.:3'V.h..$.ziiLi" C1£§f:S(Z'u,"i§."ii'.> C01'p(>1fati0n 113$ s()1;zght reasmnabi<é"€ih*:c L0 dc"v~e1c,ip--t7I1e= V2-:;'c=:a. On the basis of £116 SL3b'§'Y1§SS§{}E.1 n7nhiéC§':2¢_a>n _'hcE1_a:]1' Q?'{he.Cc:»r;3c.>raii0:1§ ibis Cgurt has missed an order dixfectéhg ii 10 :i_év{:1<)g'j'~.[i'E&~.:;;>:;'<:~éi in qucs;£i0r: far the pu1'p<>sc '£"<)r whi;:hE:i; fk-.:s<::i'vc"d. 'E'n_pL{1*sL2z:.:2--<:c-5 :0 the said order, the C<>m.mishs;i_cmer 'h;'1s }3Vi1¢j~gs::xi':1t1 'a:'<§c':* Azm<:>::,u'e R-6 under Sectim 288--D O'? tE1'=<:'.»'&c:. i:"cf"demQIih:i_61'; __of {he shedsfhuts in (fi'I€Sii0I§ on {he basis; of whii;«h_ fix: cc3rpG;iz1't§:QriL' has issued the impugricd zloaces to the §)£3iiv§,r'}k:~i;§.;3,v1'__§"-L{} Ci€"i15€¥§3%:%h...hf'.!1c:%:' I1ut$/.s;}1ed:g w'§.th£3t1E ggzamixyg {hem am}; 's}g}f§'<;zi£L:z';vi_:§_£«tL:s }<;hmv $2111.93 as :0 why' their hutx siéouid mi he d:;:*Ti'1<';=:§é's=;£zc<ii.~'"_"L:. ' f:«§'*<:2;ém'2 §EE%§%~»§,} 9:27 {ha 5&3? ;:::§%2u:is;z~:2 the {T<:§";m2*az%'i.aéz: 1;?

-- :":;i'3j:3<:='~;<: c:1<::."0:;:<:§':_:';1€:1[ w§{h<>LH nqéﬁgice. iii $.51; as; iiiéétffi Z :33: "Section 288-.D: C'T0m11zis;sei.c>:1er Inay wi:§3<3::t:

xmtéce f"€m0V€§ <«3r1<:r{3aci'11"1'*:€2"1::. -- N01w%.ths{z1ncEiQg" - w anytliing contained in this AC1, the Commissic;:12cé.1',:«--m.21§}';' W.i[hOi,'Et notice, CE1E.1S€ [<3 §'€1"{}{)\'Cd.~ (:13 any waéi, fence, rail s;:<-3p, booth K3: ézher sizmziure er V f§XE'LI:'t3- which is crecied or s<33t.;1";';-..iz1 c<):i't:';:vc71_ti( w:} (Sf_ tf1{:~V ;3'r0visi:>r1s of S<:c:{i0n. 288%.;

(b) any stall, clmir, %>(>_5<, 1fa;cI€Ec='~;*,.,%.7na'§.r:.: or any oiher thing whz1is()eve1', placed :_0'r :i§:vpb§i{c_:%. 'i~;"§ "<:Q:1'Irz1v<:n¥;i<";n of Secticm (:3) any '¢11j_LVé§c...V1<:_. <>1; é§éiV{'.)<>sc2d fer 3:116 in ,Va1':~5;. £31; public SIFCCI in .. 28'8wC and any vehicle, pa-1ckaig;:;,4'{3;>>:; 'i3<i2§':ﬁ, any oaher {hing in or on wkzivch suaéziz _2::1'tic.}}3 js"'.b;)]é1"é.£:d§ or kept' for $16 purpose of .. _____ , 1%}, T_§f1§':w..21§'?f»i'.3"i='~--*T: pxmzisiauzé is; mi}: 22;3pEicab.§<3 K3 ighaz ;:>i't:5,;<3ni; zzzise.

i>:§{:a:1%%::__Ehe: §>i%':»%--:é::>*;::éfs<; 22:1? $10: in s::»z:a:u§>:.:::i0§: GE 2111;: wz':§§.§ §'E:::na:<-3., mi} §:>ﬁ§c:*:E'h"*--;:ar é§%.%.:€:° ;-;%:':'::c{z:rs':* GE' E:"i><_z:.:rc "gs/E1_i£:§2 Céillﬁéféé <::E:3:~.A;1'1,:<;'-€.§<'m £3 iE:>v;§V}:§2"i<:L;<;_%:2"e3a::éés E"??? 21:13! .st"z':'iH <:§:zzi;".; b2=::"s:':h$ 239:»; Eaeiaisszg basic 9:" 22:13-' Gihﬁi.' ...{§3.i.:€g {>vhz1{S<>e.ve1' prohibited under Sectéem ;?,.88~«A and 288-8 9%" the E 5 the pzwk. .ITixp12mz:1i<m is neat f{3rtI1<:<;m1%ng from. the i'€Sp(.'}I"1di3t"1[ as: :0 why"

ii has eziiméecé the said 2112221 to be ccctipied by the p€§iii(}I"iCI'$ which has *»-'i1'tL::«;1!§§_.~" bc.co1"r:€ ii slum. I: is net in d§.;s;pL1('e ihaz this pézti1i(}ncr::; _beE<>ng to the wea§<_:=;r seczioxa 01' the mciety anti thazir C:"~fiCl§{.§I'1 '»¥'§I§U1£i,_ i'~C$:i1];';__.§.IT. deprivzliion of roof (m::." £f.1::i1' htaad. fivcrn if the peti.t~ive:1ci*';;ggramigé an 0pportLm.it'y ofbci1f1g ht-:z11'd, no 1.::~;c.E'u§ p£:_1'p()s::w?iIl."ﬁve.' :;ei'=.:eci'~ .7 ._ {:-

3-..3'\,' adsnittedl}-2 E§n~3y 21.1%: in L111z1L1th<3r§.s€:€i'::1cc:1:p2i[é«;3Ii ('2? 21I3.1%:ni:y_ L siie mezmt for 21 gmblic purpose. The ;<:ai"cE..I2m.:i is rﬁmntj for v<'3rc21:i<'>n 0%' conveniezncc: :0 the public a1§"§211*'geA. ".'¥¥t:3 %§£i'%{3_:Vt{'.?A find :1 so1'uIk<312 :0 E1153 p1'0bEerr1. 1-Iuman cor;;p;zssé(>11"::iL1s€."sr)f%e1§_»{he a'.<;)z.}.§.z i~*; edges 0%' jusiicc in all 3s[L;2:[i:{.5;1s, TiI"nf01,_(§Ai M11) OTHERS vs, BOMBAY 5140A-'1CII3,»iI,.V_C0RPc:R3§7;*é;*sé :_}1;£?1) OTHERS -- (I985) 3 SCC 545, the ;'\.p<3§4' C:i>:.m w":;:»: V_c:{}i1s;id<':;:'%r1g;; the z::;:%;.i0;2 0? Eh: B<>:z1bay Mzznicipai 7,{T()1";}:>_1"2-Him:.La;,::é:«;r:0v¢3= cnc1'c}:zc:.E':.:'11c1'1is 0:2 feet-p21§§1. §}Ei'v"C§1T1<'3mfi 2'-Mad {EEXEH %i:;'3_2¢1i»::cV'{:,v,5_c;*.aaéhééfl {he §3u§3E':: Exzwa as :_'§ghi sf §)£i;*§§¢.é':f§;i'3 Gﬁ" m':<;::2>'~;.<»p in 322;: s;z1m '<§:::i'i:;%.:>.;VA1; aim: Apex C7m:a'E' $1212' hem :25; wider: A ' "-'i.§f«E{;:a-'safer {§C$§_§§f%$ §i<>%:;%§:'2;gg Ssi:<:i:*:'>:: I'? $43 miid, £2": €::=¥';%.'2.$ £3? kiée ;z:~;s:.:s":mc::s~; g.§:.Ew3§1 by the Siam: {.§'€§f:'<':i'é'£':EH€3f§§ is: its :36: pleatdizags %:<3E231'e the Court, it ciire.<:1e.<l than the paw-'cm€t1i dwellers who am: {:i3I'1F§tJS€¢;§ 0:" who happmed [0 be C€3fiSLi8CCl in F976 should be given though 1301 as 21* czmdiuhn pE."€C€(i€I'z{ to their reamoval, al_:ern2-ate ;)iiChc3s":.=fit--w_ Mzilawani 01'. at .'.§L1{:l".1 (>Eh:.::" C()§W€E1i€§'1E place V Govemment ccmsiders; r<3as0nabl€ but :10: ITaa'the.r_ in terms of cliszance; slum d¥'~£{Ellf:§'S4 wliu, \}x-*_[<=::'éA 'g.l__v%:::?;x. identity czxrds and whosz: dwjellings".wéJr.c:_. l3l3.ﬂ}b{j:§'¢a{' iii {he 1976 {:{31"}S*iIS must be géve.tjl':al.VTernzafe.sites' 1123:" %l2é§i'i*"' S reseulement before ev_iC.ti0n_; slLmj's._w'h.:i_;:h hE1V7'€--.l7};'A3€'3Vf1.'Elfl existence for a long {il13_<£," say fa; V[.w'e;s1'ty Siczzrs or mare. and which have been i;}.1V}_2«'1'"0y<':dV_ arld <le*g'eE€§[:::vd will not he 1'ctnc)v*e(l.vu:ii§::§j':; the-._ lzzml-...{>11'wli§Cli..th_¢V§§? stand <31' the ap;:[urt.en2éia15;lVz}.1";.cl."?.is 1'4e{;:za_i1'ed lhr 21 gaublic purpese, in wlxiéh case, z1l[<§r;'%1'a2£<§v4sjtl?<::e:'or zzccc>:n1'n0da:i<m will be p1*av§.d<-:(é'----.1'<> -z:he:'n_; A1.l)é'afll_l}0w lncome Schema Shelier ,.l?§:j<3gré:r11;:<1<;§" l:;iv--l:.ig:_l':. is prop<}::;rc:d E8 bf? l.iIlCl§EFEEil<.{'3§} W§l.E'1 A « , zﬁal of fin: Worlcl Bank will be pzxrsuszzé carlieatly; am?

.._{-iheé. l}pg::"azdazi0:: P2"<>g:'a:mm*. {SU'l?'}* zmaéer whzich A ._l'>as;ia:V;zr:1<:::§':ll::52 2232:: [(3 hr: f"§lE-'€32': £0 $lum {lam-%":i§c:'5e W%E.E be i.:"n'§l:;'::':j%<:;1z:2:.§ wéilwui cgleizijg. Hlgghz.-35;: ;>:*i:":>r%.iy mags: A ' bf; ihza -Séaiie {E-{>2-€:'::zne::: la} alas :4-:se.i:E:3§:1£:::i <3? llifiléiféﬁi a,:n§<j;r:'un;1i<3 pcr€+;<'m::s. Er: <>:1§@2" ii") 2n.é:3%mz72i:: .§m:§<§.<~;l1ig} %.::%g':3§w:<§ lﬁ zzzzy <~":<.:'17<:iio:1.} xii al§r{:<.:§::~.<.i Elma the S1L1§}1S., wh<3:'<:=v<:1' 5§i{'L¥é1[C(L wéii :10: be f'é3§Z1('%'»-"Cd until ()§1£3___ month after the sand of the current ::1<m.<;<;.>{:»r1 aezzscjn, is ._ Lani} ()<:i0b<=:r 31, 198:": and, therezxﬁes", <}_Ij'i'§'; §.é; ~ ' A' £iCCOI.'d&IECé) vviﬁz {ha present jucigmeni. if L. :'<::<;_a.:i1"cd [0 be Fi.3I"J:1(}VCd befom t}f;a{"d:-1t<:,&_ apply to the Supz'::1m Court. :"¥?a\§'§:§:'1i:'i<§V;1t whether :::.:n.$uscd <91? u11cet.1s.;'ﬁ_s'c.::i.? wi:!§.'».'né}L b_€ Lmtil the szzme date, naaxnely', C}cf0h§3r 31, "E ' '

12. Th::: Siam: Govemmem has i:jcé ri i{T:;_>T:'c~:..1':17:31"fi1_[ix1g§ varioug schemes for the pear am} .i'11{:"%:?.;3*;vntf<>d£§cz'1" §:'i'c11v :1<";§,.s}a1'21y21 SC§'}e.m€, Aasare scheme and I{éhab--i_1_i%;;1[i()1i s:;:§1£';§i_'ca I.3*1t5()d ";VV%CI.:'.ms etc. The imealmzn behind ;1§§3 {hC3St3§ACll' 'i'2?}QS i«S' in.;1»i'icy%;2.te_'poverty am} to provide shelter [0 the needy. "f'1}is' is ;i':f7é_I; €:zLé;'<: i%£h.¢1'c 'the £'€Sp():1d€2}{ and oihcr concerzlcci auI'}§0rit§c::s_ hzwc'é'.':_> i§§ r<:habéE%t;1te aha séxznz <iw:31E.<;3z":«; like {he "'~pc_téti<:..:jé':=x,_.,j. 'Share §}i:;"2a~<';«'Vp<>ént in :§ummzt:'ii;; cxrictmg them and kéa-'}2'}{>A§.E:;wEé§i1'§{,' H2-f"j;'§A'ETAV§;}3~€3{i§éf§"tEml§f§ which $43.1 amiy aggmviiie iizc ;>:"=:}i%:I:3:*:*2., A: £31:-*3":;::m<3'L*é%:';::f'm: a:22,:1;10§' E033 sight of {£26 {£163 {£2212 {E16 §)1§§£2f'§C(§.

1;%s;:%;"::§Gpm:;3ré€ 4.}? {E25 iiiifg' is §;_n;}e.§;a::é2:c( Th:::':>::§'<>:'<2, E ;1:zt:.0§:§'::i :==§e.a:*; ihafi

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court