Karnataka High Court
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs Smt. Shantavva W/O Parasappa Ghali @ ... on 6 October, 2010
Author: Aravind Kumar
Bench: Aravind Kumar
QVEs;§_[EL'.?é;:.§§g-zgndi zzaiv' far R436
E N T §,~§EZ ;E:§§(3 E4! €_"3(T) Uf~"€.'f" (L) F E{;'»':?€§\$,A°T}3s.§<A
(;:§?{C§}I/T §§3§3E'\5{'§§-~§ AT E:}iZ;fi§.z'3a§-?<7KsVAf3
:>AT;E:§ "1_'E~.%.1:-E '"*{'H'E: <35"---i SAY <32? <><:*:f<;}B§.R, .:>.:_;®:_s3
BEFGRE ""
THE §i{i).N'BLE: Pv'EP;.g_fUE:§'FECE3 AIQAVINB:V~i~;--:.;:;§_;;i§*§;V"
:vI.1:2:A.1~zm22243;2om gMv': __:' F"
Beiweenr
Ur11ite<:§ indéa EEK'-3{H"cU'£C'-{';" CG. Ltd, V
Branch €I}ffi<:e, No.24, Firs: FI<:>01f., Néppémi, ._ .A
New repres:3nte<:§ by its; iféenirszs Ei%v':£e3i:>.::g1Z'Ex'§ar:ag<é:.f;
3,?'/§.;§h3.:rr::a::az&dra.<>; B.iV§sic>z1ai iffiffzc.-$3,
Maruti éfivafli, Beigaum. --
V - Appaiiarzi
{By Eféxihaxmar: B.}\/ianm>:§<§23Zr; %'~'..dw;:<:22i@.}_V'-A _
And:
2; Smi.Shantéw';%a '»'tz',"'04..Pfa;:'a.sé1'§§Vpaéiébaié
{;fig}:. Bt3:'ad Bsazzgzz, Ag§:"<:}3 jééa'-;:':7€;;','V
£352.: Hglissehgifi' « 7gx:<;37f§«<:"," ,/ Q . _' E{.ai:agr::ri}
Tq.V.*.At'l';a::i, E3;e]'ga':j:f_z1.
2} Sr: L22? ' §Bas;a.;:ipe2 aI'-»£a»'g;i?cg§Vum ;
figs fiziajéivf', 'C}€:i:; BL": E§'£'f:€3S3S§
¢E:Ej<>,*Katag€ri._,V 'E'q.: Eathani,
_ . . . . . ..'
* §€Spi}I"§d§ffE$E§
S'i°%j§*§23:is§: «§§~;.f%v"£;%_.i;§;;1r, A533: §e:.::" R-2}
"-Th%§v'§%€§'}%. is {filed unciesr E?%eC§i<>:2. '1'I73{E} of MV Rafi E9885
'eggezégsé §;%:€.§%_1dg4;:n€nt: and gm-*21r{3; data-é 2i,§2.2G{,§29 §&§SSfi'<:i3 in
E.'xE:3'i;i7?f;é§f2€}{}7 {en the fééét 0f 13:16 m"<:s3§d3':1;z {3i°3.'"Es::er Fa:'=s::
_ V .' V' f ;. K»-' 5
V. Effiiaé i35::ru:°f;,., Aéjiféazzié, aiavszyaéingi <:<i>f::p{:r;::a:_t:<>n M ?4,1%é,{}{}{E;C
" fi<.::§i§"§ --§.'fl..E'€r€£~;é:' zssi: 'a'.'E*:a*; ream {>f é?i4;3-: pg: ffazari '§_:'%w dam: Sf §s':E"§Ei{§f: iii?
'- « :fs:a2§§s2a2:§.<>:::
Tiziss a;:§;s<%e2E {f€}§IEEZ}§§ <.m.§ Em" 2.2éIr:%§«::;i{}:1 {izigg 1:.h5%
*.£§;3<}1'::"§'. d€~;E.§.v€:"é:%{§ 312:': f::}3E<>w.é31g:
?:§€§?<%
§'{}§§$¢IE};"§"'1'
This apgeai flied by '::§:1<:= §.:n.:~:m"€;" €;_:2_ss%;%+:m.éI;.g ihé
quanium (sf <:<:::n:pe:z:I~;21{é<>§; aw:-zmicci by 332$ "E':'ibL:néE:E~.§Qé:z._'Iir'7§X«'C
N§>,];?68;'2{_}{}'?' dgated 2m;2.20{>9§ which :3 gm/g.:%_:;§::'eg€
zippeai, J _
2', The facts Iea.di11.g ta {has §i£'E.n§._§'._c2§" tE1ié:.~ _;-1§.;.::3;>;:E:;3§"
under:
011 the fatefui :z.;8._,@%,é03A:?~'Ea-;: about
$2.99 pm sr§.w;.Wdam%g«fif 0:: {be mad
was hit by a '*:;'§,.<;.*,:'£:«§31*-.:'_ 1\fc).KA~
L23KT-9§if7G~+g9?v1_-VQ}'i:',E1{:f;G'E;E1'1'E_O37 which he £3 said ta have
S2:$'taiz1(~:c%--. g:r.iev<H:é:-';«; and Ea'€'<:*3" S1.§_{3C§,'iH1b€;'d¢ Sn
asceuni Of <:§§38.'E3I': <:_f :'_:réi:*§-~1'Sriéfiéuéiaiéappafi Wham wag aged
ab<:;:J;é._§§§ years V'a'€:.._jthe §§':=.'§1§3 <3? asciéem, his mfither, wha W83
<>é*23}-j "?I3'1,i"" .'éf::;g{_5z§«&_.§1sai€ $9 5;u_€<:s:%<;%z:§ {:3 his fiifli :51. <:Ea.i:"::
w
':§.}<;?,?V.',V"i'§,'"i€;}1§'.'§'_:'Ey€j'€3:?§E1§ .{:€)1'§'ip€3I'ESé3{E?:{}1'E cf ?E3:,{}{},{}{}{}/2 E2: 'W£1E§
Ciézziéfidaai 3:252" in the: gtiaim ;}ei'.§.'a1i<m iheai d€C€as;§:d was
jag2'§c::i%':};:%:'i§%352$ Efzs e:.*,v'-y=s,»"2='";€t%:§. 3.3 2s>:<::r{7s:: <1}? izrig23'€€<§ §2:%;.m.i ;g?<12>vi::§;
<:<::3':.:::;€:"c:":%;':}; C§'{}§$. it 25.335; gzéga c<;ntm1:%:3d '€}"1£§.fi he §;>r:;s;s§es«;$e=::%
'--.3:I1"'{;§.€f'§{§f9iZE'&T:i§.ff§° zméé E"i,%Hf1;§§"2g €526 s;g:.r5:::% (:22; hits '%:3a&~:i:«3 and am
"--,s;'::_gf":r2 ahif :§<m:§g;E2§ far Eééfi}-'"}"i'E€;?§"iEi of {Tf{}1'.'i'§§}Ef§2$é3.§.§{}EE :3?
:."%":_:a5<3{};:>é';%s::s
5-
%%§%
z,
anci fiifici *;E*;€ir s;iaE:{3:n*:€:n;?; 9%" z>b§<é(:i.i<}:r1&; {i&::";y'§r;g 8:6: £}'%?f3§_'§}"1€3§1?;E§
méidéf in Ehe slaim p<3.=':駣<3§*;. £32": {he 'zaasisa <3? 'iéaét 'p_3'¢3.€:€;§«.§:f1g: :3'?
"E,
'§h.€ :"é:§;p<}§1<i.m*:I.s; a§3p@a:"<::<§ E3§:~f<:re ":':§"::s: '§"r§b1;:ne:E.
{ha §az°iisés the éribugwzi framed. éhss §<)H<}2>x:i::§_.>; i:~:r;:'==g2.,-:ir::5~;: ' V
7.'.
'~»_ ""§><;é;;:3:én€:3é:§ {';:":¢:": "a:é:%?:'.:1%;%s§.s; "bf; ::§22z,r::<: E54§::"§:,E§,E'z:i'a«-*:=:.E§:r2g;;;
" §3}:.:_§2-'psi $3" 5 22%;? gs:;:.'2é;. :'27':2;2ir'§<:<3%:*Z Ex'; E3-3%. {'}:";. '%::2::;%§i@.;:§.'E§" <35
4.,
ilézzimgzgééz arm" E1€:'E;t%Zf :%Xa:'::i:":€éd. 21:3: P'§§f--§ amt} e:§S::e
7}
'Whether {he p«::'%;ié>:.Vf2@1:.:>:&r p;f*r>{}*L6é;_ Vt}2:g:tV g
dsecczased Es£udapé;'_»'§;p2é_" TE"are;.s2a;t:-$33 §(_?:§*:--23..}:'i:v[.A
injuréfis Suszaézgéati in é.'E.1;_€"*m.=0t€§: cjgcie
s:z€ci.:i::-:.1?;, 2&:'h:i<:.3ri". V"*::a:}{}§: §:Ea,<:.e& an
:8,04.2~:%;0'::ei ax, a.jb.:ui=;-.',:-.Qe__pm within the
Iimités Qf "BurV_ia2'=.::i -'"'sfE§?:§i_i@._,--V-' on AE;hani~«
«Kiiirtatzigur, fi:(3&1:i§..;t'*{*ijt%f: " the the rash and
_:iég_:§.ig'ez3;éi_A €1.:fivi.r1gj 9? 3:318 §~E.IVE.'E"'. Tractor
V'v-'La-:?;d§'VA t':"«a£1e:' --baari.ng Z,\k:.§<A~23/T-@9'7{>
' 21Eé'C3. §§?./gt §'3F"i§s drévfi-1*?
. '%?\f'Ei:1s3%.§:£::z_..'L'Eh£* z°@.€»;pz>:3<:§en%; N92 pmves
.:§ie:%; fize accicésem wag éakgm piacez {iue to
mzgiigrzérzi 0:: {Est E3565 {if 'ihe dficsasmi
".ix='EudaIi§a.'ppa iéhaié :f£l:f; Bsicmz"?
."'V3fx-'?::::i.§3er {has p&t11';i:.}m€z' 22$ €::1*;.%i.E<ér:§ fa?
rstééef <2?' <t<>mpen3:--;a?ti<}z2? if 30, $3922; gnuch
;~::"1<§ §é"c}§':"2. ':F«f§'§€"?'ZZ{§}}
'EEV-'E*:e:§'; <}rs:i.€:"' {FF azxaaarzi'?
Sedan' -E__%e:"21;»:'i'"A_Vé1°§k:%c:': -:i'u<»*a_:0 {he
Lag E.<:'é<:2:'p§ 2':
§.'5§:a:§_x.a3i.§1éCZ*: ii; ii} he %f£%:¥{f;'E'Z 51$ {.§'.'i.€;". Eggs»: <3? §.:"3:;'.€}f'f3€, {E<}n3id€§ina*
we
E2" The': '§.*:*'i£b1.m2-1% whiéa: aggesssirsg Ehs E035; (}f§,§EC{}1'EE€
:5; the iiegarnderizs at _pa..:°2:gz'21p}": '£4 0*? %t.;=:§ j§'L2c£g};més;";1: and
a*é:a:.:d has ar:211§;:5€d {?fEtif€* evédfincs <11"; r€c:<}r'd. A ;:x*.;?fLi€~aI at}?
{he Said finding it woulé Gmerge that ETC. t":;>§€;1¢a-'z<:.'~'¢~~@.'I:'
passcagfizi anci awzzfici by the deceased E"}?i<f§.M§);i*.«E3.t1V-§ffT}'€iL1V{3':;'*'3§
amd maykeci as Ex,P~E%' The fiaicij Rrfij-A£fi13{§i_1€£§CE.__'{3é;"i1v§v{;§;i:E%'E§§"S
mafia availabfie by {he Iearnerji adv{3.:;:zé;'£{3 app<f'_a;r':11g ft12r"'4:hé:..L
appeliant bsfortz ihis CO!.1I'1Z.,"V""<.§:§ .1LE3'i1'1g sf his
arguments wauid 'ré3fi<2<::'"é;}rju~:at s2:'i5&i"§2ii:d $1;az1ds if: fizci name 0f
EEK: faizher r:>»f fht' de<:eas<:Jzi Gr7t;}1e_.,.3d:.?;_Sb£i1?@ of ciaimamé
Though it is _C:m_:é'_:::d,é=;d %;~:1é1:im pc:t.i:1Z.<m that
deceasegi ve.>a§"5'<m:;1§ng*,1"3__ :«1z:':_;<:::~; of land. E;x.P~8 would
refiectééd iiavgit was:'--<§1*2':§;f'---é%~'é253?{::8 and 1'?' gamma and net 13
acreg C{i1:;.%:4::':::i&d 21's"}{§ éhég hzas bfrézn §;£'1:E{i'f1'} Eats
«%::<>:3$'§La:§€:r§:§'E§oé53..'b§; tzhsmirébunegi. 2/;:.nd :1: bag §:s<:«i:n heéii 'zhat 4:211
?52£ic%:;>_um'; 9;? ihe 5-gen Qf Ehe <:ia§:'nam;, ti/1:3 33116. €mm.<:£:§
bf; him is.~;':<;§fi'.§€§$?: 20 here E3. is; zzrnijy é§UpffZ'f'Vi;':§ii'H1 C§:a.:°g{:é;s~3: zvhicfi
" iaiéze m.€{_'3»iV__?:a:2e% {<3 expgznd. Ea} §::ai::€_';?:..:E:r1 "éhe ssavlsci z':gric'u£f;L:r:5:E
"*-_i:}:€§ Saié my-*i€i&r1::€ an §"€3'€{3§"{§; Lz"i§:s':::::aE fbmlzi 'E'}:2.2§.i saié
js"£,:p€z*:f%s;§c:m athzgrgéés as; Es:)§s$ {>5 é:':z::<m':{:q '?a} ;:az':'§*a«-*5 .22: ibis:
§'éJ£,§}i:%§"'4-,7érE%§{f>F;"i <:f:2a.rga%s; ii Ezgsasté 's2*2;.E<::'éz: 7?? 33%} gasrz {Egg}? :zrh£.::§": aazamiai
3'35: 'aha: wh.%::t§f: :«;%:<:* 2:222? §é;«ivz:-- 3:; ?:s;::.'§;' ':0 "£.E2e:: :1:-:[:s<>%§.§'é.?§:; *-A-*hi<:§é
1,: it ..
E?
,g:gm
2-é2'a::a.Ed 'ix: E9352; {)5 izzatwzrxc is <::§2:2.é.zn.2zm£. aizarzizi; s;::_«:.::s:a.€ vJe:::;:§d bi?
?1%§E%{3€}j~ per :":1<.mt;ho "Ska <:;:;(?::;E.:'<>r": <35 (i.<-5a:%L:::§::l2f:g 21:23; am0'L:::':.
icwarcis p€rs~;<m2::E and Eévézzg ::'3)<;p&°'.nS€E~; in $L:<:h Circumfstzezfzigfi
woufid not ariezej Sifiiféf it {mi}-* SE.l§;}€;?i'V§Ei1:{,)§'§ {§}.E_£%.§'§;f}':§~«>§'%fl-Eféiffijl
$221.3 Era:-;=:2:: itakz-31r: "Ema €{):':$"Es:ie:"21¥:.i(}§":. Em' 2:s;s<%ss%:3§;;;V.__€§1:;€ =;.>f°
%.m:{m":e, §§:)wm::>;;: t."E7;::% TrébL:.:m§ é:22;s~e;,..a.1?j.$<4:;._ "E.a;E§€:*:..'~._jr:t;;;Tf
cémsédzsratieié fi";"§S £:"iSp€3C5;. a41".:£§ ;>;::é4_iveg§ 5::E'2<:3 i::at:'s:r;C 0? :';?;l': €:
éecsiaseé at ?'475{)€};'~ gxez" EI1{)§E€E'i Vé.u:<:.:i <ie<iLi<;st<3¥:'§'5U'?}*i;; as hig
persona}; ami living e§:gper1'$;§%s..a:1ne_i a,rri*<z6;é,é;.i. E<>s$ sf i§f';(:€)E11€ ta
'aim claimant aé. ?2"?,{}{}{J;'--. ._
1.3" 'E'he_.t.:;:ib 2:23: ~ré1%.éa%_ 'Lip.€)?{1~ v§I.:¥.1é* 'f§V'(}StEf§(3F§€fI§} {apart which is 3:. E;>z.§'~V6' ;a'fis;:i4V§*";T€iE4€iT.§i*r3§3é::' muitipiier requireci 33:3: be aéopéefi wag 1%} in x¥"3.c:w <>'f {§.i.<:i2-1 iaid dovm in {E26 cage 9? _,8arZav.»'5--«:.§"v"fe§rma amid'; ____ _ 3€§';ers §?$. $33521" Transparfi éZ§;:érp§::"2?*g§if_§§a.A§z;s;::E _Qznafi}aer §<:§;><>1":Ts>c§ in Efifig .éCJ 2298 the egg ,r7;§'.,.'1;'A§/:.::-'rv :%_:_<3s_:'r;~'§f E1233; "::»§:%sz"2 '€.2'£Es{E§E": i:§':<:: -::<>.:."z.&;é::§a:ra=z'§1;<}:": '§1::;:"
;*:{§<}pE3Z1é'g €--§E:<3":*;"m.§;:ipiiT€:* z»;a;:**:zi. g::<>:*:s;ic%{::~;ri:1g tbs gigs: 0? the 4% 1-»*ea:."s, z:"g:3p'r<};::»:"§a%'€> :"*;:L;:E§.é§;a'I§<:r éha: zvezg .2:£iz>_g3§€:'E f':}'::" i..%:%:--' '§::*"§:}L:.m:2§ v2£2a2:'e; Eéa '§'h.<.2u.<?%: iii. {:{i:»:m;én{i.:'3£§ 'mi "EEK:
_,, rm 3 -.
~_§é:E2%;:'§:e~a:% é§.€I§_"L"{}(,T2%E,£? fer 23z.*3:3§':i.I.2:::'i. €.§i:_.:'a:: §nu'EEi3H<~::r Tgffi 33 :9 E35': V E A 'é':{§::ep"{:'T%{'£ 21mg? Eaas 9?' £¥;:2§;«:-%'z":.::ie:%::<:;=*' §";.a2<:§; 3:'; E3516 <::;::§{:2w;é2::"§:>/{E E3}? {:e'3r2é»;§{f':§t-.3fi.:";;;§ Ehaé §:3s:::<':§n£% aé ?f§§€I}f_}€i'E;'-- gma' =::§":_<s§':!..'E: 2.~2.::{% a§%.{?:"
7* ,. .= b 3:1; /:3 <:i§ 13:»; gm: mg}-
:::>m;}€:n$z:E§m': {L}? §"2,?'{},{}G{};'~ {Lag ?3{§%Z}{'§;'~ ---?'E,,5%i}f}f~ x ?§;f'.3€>€}:"~ 2: E2 X 3.33 xx 3&2"/LyE'{},f;}(}€}j~'; is 3:} '£39 zazwardcfcé 1:.:":ée:° E 23:36 hfizaezi. ii}:-s§~.=; 9:' e:i&é"g;}€:;'":(i€r1<%j;.-1 23:6 ssaé-d C€">=H?';:1'.I",e§j1:\~€~§E':"":"<.";{';'»;%": r€€:s;ami:§2:>:¥:.ie:):2 by Eftis, {:{)"é1ft'. "is; mzaé a{:(t:%§:>é21%:§E--%:3_ C:::>m_p<:mSa.Ei<m E'i'Ji--='E1E'{i€<f.§ ?;>§; '€:'§b:.s.:3,a;:.} iSW§.'L§Si' zzzéété' ----:7}:>~.<i:S'£§na.b£<%_ and it Cannai. 33:' Exésici Cithcr 52:3 €;?XL'7€?'.§{°3§'_"'~»,_?€3'..€'}"§' $1,}?f€é3;?§{§':T%:af§E%;::j. * Accordingly, {I16 finiimg given E33} I;«f<_§t: f;r{E;;1:.%1a.E {§x:Vs'§a:i::;*:;::§ i'<_:é bx? affirmfid.
Re-Question No.2:
14», En. V§<:w.o§ :he.~-.::'h_r§v:=:V--.<:§.iVsc'L:E<;.si{3'::ifaha f{}fi<)wing (H66? :33 pa.:~;::;c:*d: é 2%} E_3.§u;;§gm€:é*::v'£25251 e::'<;>a:e»:::*{§ passsci in 'l'\.!E'VC .i\I<:s= "*7 aizittfii 2 E , ';2x2{§{".§ isé he:'«r-3:);-= £:}§fL§:':;::<3{i, "_'§i7h:% za;::":{';2,m:. in {i.{3;:s<>:«.>,éi b:'::§2::~2fa% iliiziirs $312.12': :13 ' <7":
<:s:2:§.:"rz"<-'éci Ea §:>e*. I§"€:§'I.".Z:?£'E"'2':4§'£'f3:§'i'.'€Z{f{§ ii} '$22: 'i;:é':3a:_:r"2aE {air bé=:'§:1"3g {iii-;E}:,§§:é;§3{§.. in z:<';c<>rcizms::{: 2,£;iE:h Eh:-r juégmééné, :»;-m<:'§,. 2;wearé 5;? i'.§::§= é:'%E3m12;:§. % gw W 333'
-33"
:3} '§"'hs: E;>2I%..§2m::':.<? .2.;_.:'.:2<>u::1E :'«;Zh;;-{ii 'am «:?£$p:>:~,;i§.:::{£ E3}--' this i.I'EE§LE1'tE?}" w§i'.E?'2§:':. 2:1. pstmyéi cf :~f::i}<; 1¥€:?{?1<S fr<:>m the da3.t:g': cf 2'@:t£=:i;3§ af E1326 {ii-';E"'iif§{'{§ ;:s:'3;3}2 0'? iihisa {';;':f:.§::=:'1; {3} N3 <:»rd<;?1" 23:52: 20 c<i>s;%.:;.
f) Regitéiry ii") dream.' anvzzrzi Ei§T{2:{A§>i"i?§'Z§'¥f£§:{§fy'. R3338/xr:1p'*'