Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Malina Vinteners Pvt Ltd vs The Deputy Commissioner on 24 June, 2010

Author: H.N.Nagamohan Das

Bench: H.N.Nagamohan Das

. BISTRECT: BAGAL3E<Z{}T. *2???' 1'\§<3.€2E33 3. 2{}@€f-E EN THE 'r+'i§€fj§H' ::<:}:;R2' <:::§? .%;a§:2:\sm*;:§<:;1 =fj3'ER('3UE'E' Ems}; 5%'? BHAE'£:?A§T,§ z:»A"E5:3 miss THE gm: REA'? 01:' JUEE; 29:9 ' ' BEFORE;

THE §i{}N'BLE EEERAIUSTECE H.N.I\L%<2Azv:<'}'g:;%':§ Eggs 'i?JR§"§' FETm<.3N :\Jake36;3'i%$'f;2'§<%9 'g;L§;« BETWEEN: A' ' A" b ' 2»-:A:..:m Vi?-§'§NE§9;S PVT LTD REP' "BY mt; MA?~JA{}£NG EEREQZTOR ' SEE. RAHUL 5;; <1) R;A(f:E~§APA__ Ki} L:,<:>:..;,: ~ . ._ * AGES» ABOUT 24 YEg'3':R;S,v ' '~ '_ ' L RIO MAHALINGAPUR, TAL'LI%4:::;:z;.%3E:§>;%f"' T 'x_ n,,E'_£T§"§'E=i}NER {BY $31.;,s.$Hr§;T'€§?,'--ADv:§A E. *§H::_; :3-%§.:;m:J1T*§V.x::£>{ia2;rsg§::*355§§:::s.N;2i§§2 Bz§{§-:¥aLK{3T :>:$:is::§V::);..__ Baggasgfssw "

":':'~§a:_ge3S:s*§gN'§'<:c3:=§::M:S$:<>:x3ER JA£x»§AE{E§&N§3i '-:;:A;:;:«: ,:A:v:A§<:é aN§:s:
""?HST£?§C"§;'BAC}RLK{}T K' -J V . ';%:*:'.§;';?I::% :;;fé*:"»:jr«,:':, E~1§N{':§,E zszzmgaszag CLE';£§?IAE'§'CE; c<}::m::*r_§E:E; ~. .f:'isRE§ 1e*';;;_.v::';;<:ag2',' KH§aNE$A Baazaw gssaum w::\:<:7; ' N514?» :1iaa:E COURSE; Essa ".§%A?&i'{}_s%'§g{§RE~568 {>33 3:: §'§'§§ £%£<3EEZ'E"'_éR"%' V. A x 'T E-:$Z,%RE'~E1%T;%,K;% u§2*:::><:z EvEET§_.£: V' 353?} F?L{}{§R, E{?r§;'%?°-.TE&§s. BH;'1.°"v';'%E'E é;E4;'~{}E}'E'?:f 'sEi?§N{}§ N{},é'é~9§ REESE C{}EJRSE §€{};5$,i:'} B:'%§'€{}1%L{}REI--§€}i} Si} E. X 2% w£H,§.,§""*-1 .//A 9 ix 2&5? E'I£3;é€:=3§:3,fi2{}C2§ 3'? WE? fa/E;%1'€fi;{}fE'\§'§E .E}§§€§'.;{3'?{}§"{ :3, THE SUB---REi{}§ST§€iz'%.E€ BA{};'3:.L£é{>'? I SESTRICT J;%EK/EAKEEANDE.
[BY Ef'Ev§'E'.E§A'»'1'E'E4§,%. NfE':'%.'TEL7 H€.'Z{3rP FUR RE, 2 1%"s.Z\fB 5; §§RE.C§.M.P{;3{"}NACH;%, ADV E'{:}R R3 AND 4;} THEE-3: ?E'I'ETI€f}N {S FELED LENDER _¢§;f%§14<::,§«:?;<§:§"2"~'§a>3..';=a:§~§§:;: .7227 ':;>;:' '§'HE CON5:§TET"{§T1{}N O?' ENDM PE;AY§I'~§'€} 'I'{'}5 QT'7tFAE?!?§ }~'§};} Ni}. KLR,i'CR--{}?;'2GU9~2{}, ?;%.SSED BE? ~§'H*?E~§75f '§?_E$'?i}.I'~3'§73E'?'¥T, '§':~§1::' CGPY oz»? wH:'e:2~; ma BEEN PRETEDEEQEB H_"8§E'5F§T§€ MARKED A8 ;3J'JNE>{URE~A AN'D'1"§'~':.E'; <>RD;§;R E}A''§:ZD..;i3_;f :; .:..;2Qe<}, ' £33323 3? THE FIFTB RESPONBE:;r€': THE cifzémf jt}? 'WH'§CH HAS 333:2' ?R{}DL='€fj§:Z§ AI'-£NEX'U'RE~N :%.ND_ '-- TEES ?ETE"E1{}'i\3 €G§}§I'€£§ ms §i§jRé%RE*LIM:NAR? HH§5:AR{E\IG EN 'B' {EREEUR TENS SAY, T§:E"€:wQr,rR<': MADE;"TH.E =?<>LL<>w:NG: E. £r;'V't?:i:§"z2:if}'§ p€f§ii<>::;',~.§}:<:=: psfifiiéners have pmysd far 22 writ in the nai3;}.2:*::_ (if it:-$r";%§:':nfa;1?§'_.€og;.;:a&;h SE16 aide? passsd by the E5? I"'{fS§{}f2d€fY3i Sf: 2_';,Qi?'2"é}O§'~.-'fag per finnexurémfi and "aha mdezr' "2¢_éa4'{e:i5¥.E3L[i by 5"? 3'e3p<md<:::: as par ' ' -- _1An,.nE::~:u r:::~;«L'~§. ' "

2; S'-Qfijszéi <35 ihiss i.a.r.§'é.f: ':Q€3?;§E§Gl": is; éamé msazzsgzgzéng 'V KEEIE aérssé" if: Sj;.E'€:;.§9;'E stituaitiai at Eiermur azéiiagsf Jar:r:E~:}:a.ndi ' §;?3:§i;é<:;-'_. ;3€:?:é§§s:1::*:"5 §%.i:"{f§}&Si:*{'§ {£6 32235; in ggzisgéizén §§°{Ei'§i {me . '_--E-'mi:M;22§¢2{::e;h<,ve1:'£ 311$ {:zth<:»r:--3 argd €'%1<3§,> p§"€;"E§»sf3II2E€'35: :e;a.is sjésaé {5}}? /;§*'"'M%L { 3 » f '~}<;'P E'*~§<3.§§{§3 E 5fi2{}iQ?5} reg§%s;€ra:i(>:2 §}ei?:::'<: i'£:<;* 35-? resspiéizdsiréf; GE": .EE;~§3i')'9.2{}{}'?I Thfi E3?"

{'i'3Sf3{}E1C§€2£'E€ is: wry: issued 'aha impzzgzzsd <:<3mra:.:niCa:§<>:_1 data?
13.':§§2€}{§9 as per ?*:I1fi€X13§$~§'§ diréctiiagg aha §"}€'3t§..°L'i's;}.}""§'é?.:E"&§-lei} {:G:z::pEy :.=;£t%2. citriaisi qusréea ézéahgding a pesrmisséfrz. é)«§9{)"fVV£r3«':.':"§:ESi"€'..VE_€;g(%- regyandcniwfispuéy C{>mmésS§<3n.<::'° :,1;'s 1{':"gH '€.}.£:. '.'{?i%3 £4€i3:'1:§VV R{*.f{}1"1"%f§S East. A€:{:<>ré£ngi§;7 {has 3;>c3=:§';?Z,:>r1eV§§*:::..--fi21j;:sp;f«:}aCE*:€:'3. §°€Sp*C}§TEC§€f'f{ far p€r:":1i.$s;i{>r1 2-2.126% IL§?:f:;=: Sziré-";._€ c:?m:£;:* i{i,f';:.6::H r&3+:3c%;5s:§_* unéésr aha éznpugzwii <3:':is::r' defied 2"1,,€}?V,2€}{)93';:2¢§ pm" Qffmm-3xu§<3- A Rance} this w*:°i?. ;Q€'Ei'EV§€}.?(1;" '
43. Eiéarsi ':;%1'g1§.?.'§f§:if1i1.'§_S <}'.;":a=§T}'€'§i§E'élfiii' :Ta z1d peruafid {he sniire xwzit papéafs '§?:6..2r*'e::23;§=,;r}':';.:£r:_.Tg3; cf é;E":€é""§5? rasjQ<>3::de.nt in 'éhe émpugnéti daeé, éa%;e& §8,09.2G0'?' iS regigtered 'gas _ '§'31§a7rei:>f¢3 '_.'L:§1<2 permissisn. s<:su.gh': by ihé peE£ti€s§1<;=:rS~ <.:a.m1é:wé;--..b€ ggrémifid is; f:~3£':'{'L2&EH}:' é:":€r:2rr€=:t. Thé sale ' d_.e€*.€e;i,_p:"g3:éz;--%;3§. '$3' the ;me'2fii{,>1'1:'i.rs and their Vanda' an rm' , ' §§~_{§%93.,2£¥{}?"jfs:}§"g:*§ig§s§Era"é'£<;n ':3sf<}2:*€ ihss, $331 zasgiifidéné 'Ls szifi .§€:";<:§1é':zgD <. 'i}§';é§s.:° &n::<::;'s:;:'«é:mi'€ the SW :'es;}:sa:3:r:ds3m z:§i.1":':<:'{:'--:d ibf:
§}=;"i'Ei.'{»: {_3'i'Efif"V§ is csmpijg {:er:2z.:Z:2 i"?§_,E€i'f§{?*$. 'éf1I'%';;%1<31,zE; caéngidsrézzg ihée _ =_aas}:;f;{:'*{:';"{":a§' '$243 ifizziéafég €i,E'"::3 E3? r{3s§p<>z?.<§{3:'5£: {jf::§1'}"§i'E"§§U_'€{§. an {::s'r*{>€' in a:-azzk ?~2g_@5:a2sa,/:2{>::::;
éméding {$2312. Ehéf s§a.§:3 @665} is; a'i§'€:22<§.}-' :"s3§;is<;'{er<:€L {.'}z": Ehia g_»;m1_,;:::€:L the izragaiggyzéci <}:dr:~::" is; 'iiezbie {Q be q'u..2:s3h€d. 3;, Ex-:a'm::d camzzzaai fez' éhc §e%;i1:iez;€§"s; bmughi. %c:---'f:;--§_I 'r:(i'::f§c<: Ehat the Land "E'r:'b':,ma1, Jamkézanéi, 2,-"icifszj%;r€i,§%** z:3;3;ied;'V. E8.€}4».2G02 9:55 §3»:=z° Afif1€*,Xé,11"€f~E a:z><:£:r:1p=f;£::'§_ Ea:::'3;s; athfir Eggmdg {mm a-2'ppii<:a'£.%<m <23" Lan€§ {?€:%i1T::'i§g Y1'.-.:".<i}?i%:-;:£i;:r'1Es~ reuné, the}; 'zhéz Igmé in u{iSi:E{::_n"i:5 :9: Ahrwf: §<:h8Q;ab;.V';-'E¢;.a§:n3 the:->. ' "W re:;pens§::n%;~De:p1:s£j; C§}n2§niSS_§§}1i%1"r:.f'CC:_::';I"£3*.i'E"E€€3_EL¥':f§E§€ga§i'Efg° in net sansidfiring ihe 0§d<£:f*'eVi' zi§%1é.La;:1}.j '"i"::i§§"::{2.i':;-,ai. Gr: {big grsund alga the imgugzzséé v€}1"£§.€;f1"'"i"CS<' i%:é:?:3§€:.;;:>_ ':;§:V'_q;3;}%,:v:é§:e@.. Accefdingljs, 'she foiéowing Sc '£3-*ri{Vp6:t§€§i;3'::ivs:_. §--;2:;9ti3f aéiewede 'E'h:3 impugaeé ::>z°dm"

Ciateé _ 2i.{§?';..2{}'£%9_' _p§§~;§ééziT'nV by the E5? reapztmciszzi as @631' _§r1§i{<:i}§1,1:jafi:¢_fi:.__§S h=:fei:j,%<.qaa$h€:d. 'E'h§: mzziter is Eemaniisd ta aha E §:*e:&;':3 <iés:m;:<352;a§ in £iCC{}§'{'E8;1'"LC€i' §--i'§§'.§'1 Easy. 2 ~.,*:}E'L'5f§E~?§}"£§}§§3;é"§Céi {sf {E16 ::;:2,é::"§:3§s at Azzm-":X:1ré3--:'%, '::i':s: E3"? r:'i3;3{§:1{§:3:1§.':~;h2£§E fg:sfm<:&<-iii 'EEK: d§§a::amfi:2?;.. ,»§~..-$5"

2:;
WE} N<:,6€:a3z E :3} 2{}{}'§§ Cf:
E§ffli.-§§£i'J.i€h€i N(P2'::é£ QCQEF iss €r'mi%'ué.a:i {£12 {fie :'m,'=§1':{3 £3? » E3 appsa,z°a:":<:é~ zasiiéiézz Ehree wséiiqaé.
kfimjfm