Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Sunita Vijay Sonpatki vs M/O Finance on 22 October, 2019
3 a i OAND21G/00S 98,2018 CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, MUMBAT BENCH. MUMBAI ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.210/00598/2018 Dated this Tuesday, the 22" day of October, 2019 CORAM : SHRI R, VPITAFRUMAR, MEMBER (ADMINISTRATIVE) Smit. Sunita Vay Sonpatki, Age 68 years, Wed/o Vijay Sonpatki, Retired Senior Accountant in the Office of Accountant General (A&E) ~ 1, Mumbai, Residing at 202, Tulasi Villa, Plot No.12, Postal Colony, Chembur (East), Mumbai 400 071. ... Applicant (By Advocate Shri §&.V. Marne) PERSUS Union of India, Through the Secretary, Ministry of Fmance, Department of Expenditure, Central Pension Accounting Office, Trikoot ~ , Bhikaii Cama Place, New Delhi 110 066.
poet
2. Accountant General of Maharashtra, Pratishtha Bhavan, New Marine Lines, 101, MLE. Road, Mumbai 400 020. ... Respendents {By Advocate Shri V.S.Masurkar, R-1 and Shri VB. foshi, R-2} , Order reserved on 30.03.2019 Order pronounced on 22.10.2018 This application hes bean filed Py mo ~ wh > pape oY es on OF .-G9,2018 under Section 29 of the x € ty 5 s 3 he. ¥ 4 Ss : a3 MO 8 te Ty me, RP 2% Ro eB te oy ; wk ey [<a "a ae ~ OS oe SS os Yee TT tk Beer : ; wet, : ", Ss et may ys 3 ear m. * Ba Ee Dn bo "pte. hag fe hm, Urs oe jad Tas mr, rss Cry Kin ra * Ree napa wea pet fret > es ty oh oy 2 MBL) men Se ge. BAR ob Ge Yow tan RED a os = re = = & Ss mcs eos es ee SS. Se Gk , $ 6 Sg ps, fae, cs, Ko ee fret Gee od : os ms a m™ OS Ba Br Pa = & Oc Et Sot Bo = & one Poe an) en m Sa SAR Oe ' = fe Uy rn 2 e mA ee ee, we EOS meas on Gg ee = omy ES _ es ew "he, 03 ES i "he we. SE Oe os in By omy OR nh ase m4 [3S te o> tw, bey ve xo me bsp ty 8 Pe Tet mw oa, O "s 2 oS a cn soy, mE SY oy fe an Be wg we, he RE SS SAD ER Od he he Re ore sos x Smee
a) ree S 3 . thes, Ong "ys * SONS eee: Pry fam Fg) es Cy fe 4H. seo oe Se go Se oe eo 2 eth Re, a 2 wig ea oth & oF fy om om & SS Os : Co Be. 6 3 To, & at MY % ~ Ae Bt Me RS mt OS fe ak ay : aid fe He tes pk eS SB. Sa hy ME a ey TE ORE no re oS = hag TE Dy ee Mee ae, tra » "ek Teta % w, es i SAD OD ee Le Z SS op BPS we Pee 8 9 [tee ' S ea RoR SR ogy UR ana en "ry eon oe ow . mo ON Rb gn = Oe sO a fs . e od ' aig te 5 we SS "3B 5 Sa 4g & oy EG oe ty ee mm pe EB wf, ae ore TI te TE 2g "ee 8 eo, = 9 5 FB a Sow oS Rm = ee a ee om, Coe on a SOO os Aras oy ee PN wild ee ke og Es an Ros be Ree tee | * Pene tyy 4S a ore Oe, Ee OS bm, NA 7 re he, ee ee OS ots , &o Os m& nao "to on ou ay te sy ' ie Yen eee 5 oo go, , 5 oe by ey OS ON » Some BD + eg De ee Ei Bay est fo SS f Rone y nb fh a Tent x rm oe fee we Ta me oy, tee 5 Em, "a nm S we Mm SS ey 7" os ost RP py eh ws fa OS mh Oe | os me iO Eg, ww oF ig AOS . woky An, tN Tina ps 3 wea ab 'ue tay ee OD we «OES Sy *. s ee YY aE aE ew Se a 85 eG i Baw 2 oe ke oe Cy oe ie = 7 4 0) RS Ss Ss mS Sh = GS BOS wc ee 8 wee SS pas "e3 C3. GD nd indy tee ite ins Bh es a o % og Ses , a mn ORG rm ms S53 fh ¢ ad .
~, fee Ro oy 4 Fat se ae z ~~: Sty Be SD he & ms "So Be Py ly my Go mae SS a" mo 6 UR OB oS ea oy dy we Ny ey Oh os Bo aw oS ge ree oe NDS ge beng Se. S Ly rm Pa 7 reg OHS AS OE ORE oY Sab Fe tN oho mes BS ME Ry gy oe ORS oo oS Ss og! 43 Bs zn = meee a PO SS QS mam so oa ' - * wet Brag op 7 ' a moe ms og meng . mye eo aye Rak tee x oe ES he. "Ke Gy GY 4 He ee. * Sy Sy So . ry sy Oey Pd ee Moe, % Ma A sep Sy een, NO ND 8 oth a ae Od i ee me Bo, ery TR oly Ba Mn oa SN ai o ~ fn a on Pe ie &% on pe oe "s ee ry FR AS, se mo Rae Ra OO ry Bo hh at oS rf pay Pus 89 z Oe ee E Prawided , hy
2. Care, he i i Respon HON ppl i Pa ed tke .
i appl Peer e a aey OSES Ae th £ EN fo
-OSEY G wed e t a 8.2.
om a) u a? a es) m ui "3 -
i a BS SS a cS eS #3 vf 4 oa 4.3 ae 4 "s 8 sd ot :
oS 1 . key GB i e Ty fa By e fp & a . fn os O oa @ rs 3 dd S 1d yt ve 5 oi. tH te ae wh < 2 a Co 4 u . ap UR MGS wt oo hs iy . My ] a ony ie ad g ay cy 4 a a 2 .
c a cg Se it « i " ; 2 3 S-4 * A «2 as id GF ee 3 ie 9 a ge "Oh i , 6 3 Oy = S ss cA "Ny YS i 5 y * gi ', 4.
Ss ft 3 nh Fae SGN, Ps s ms } on et + a A mm 3 3 a mo , st wD iP oy mo eed hs i wy ct gt fd "es C ct ha x oO 4 Y a a 4 L : ea ie Pr 3 3 J al ty « "4 4 . . het wD "4 o "4 és 5 a a 'et Qo , 4 aa a> Cy am thea if © = LA we Ne AS ¥ 4ir cae ke ae & C a wy G} os 1 " , . wee ~~ 4 ved "Fy eg] QD oy J 2 a m a 45 O eS i & a 1 <r - : 3 - . a ae 3 ; "3 w es a hy Met x 4 a ne od 4d oe 3 : G3 me 3 mS " v 4 Of} so ore} ta . m4 pe o v 5 # i's) 5 S34 Ad oa f ot . a} us o Cy so Bs SS 3 { Cr} e a io "5 D ce. O . o 4 a Co a wo " te a ast A bef a 43 a gs 3 Le ty 3 "ed & ' gs 2 i bea A £4 (x; a i @ = _ c ct a @ 43 3) ud oO we het 3 - 's mS ' wy 4 O sort a ¥ sy ue 0 @ 1 f is iB . O p ~ Oo ;
sae) Ao t Lt Ks iy , Q ~ s, iy a ot 4.3 o. c wy & E~t . a a th Soy a 4a i . wa Mh _ om i oS " re ¢ - £ vt oa % Ra 1 & bo x Shi 4 ne ct : ; 2 3 a rz et 5 5 : Y4 aed ee BS (3, oS © ia ae v © oo i ao w "4 Leg Oo MG we eM Oo @ QO 4 Det hg . G a sr oO a ne the seg ie seed ah LO o oC Cy sed oy del g ot Me a £3 5 i) yt es ree et we ut ei i a fay 3 3 i a " a 43 oe x A a yp ap zs Q gs wn @ a se 5 ad be ok a Y 4a be 3 Du ty 2 ty: oa Oy Ze: en tc Hy Lt KG 44 ot check 4.3 im 3 rata NAA AL oe t hf x ms
--
¢ ae GB ~ at tg :
hee aS ie 7 ITS kk aA te we Ot et pe tory A haw ae A AR ASR Not 4 4 2 S, oe > ¢ 5, AR we mms TBA RNA rs.
JRA ar 3.2 Seed, i (4 oder $3 mt og es SA LA SAL 3 Oxy iy cong my 04 eeckl oe ea aS La 4 AN ALY TD FN Seay ayhAE oeey Nee Net aged wy vey ° i r™ OLTET A, 3 A No.8 HO0S 98/2018 "Noles 2+ ere ¢ y.
d ihe Pensioner's portion of the PPO. may afene 2 cra tend . k a fieuse ine Sanded over fo fhe pensioner after ! identification if Pension Paper do net pertain to your 2 brant yf OS tok Hive rege. ty thy "7 Apt ph eRg ee at YY fh, PIORSe PeCUP OGL fee fo fre orcerrncd : .
oO ee ranch, under iatimation to this office, to avoid 4 St "oy PENTDR+DR HAS BEEN | a iu GGL 2008 UP TO MAP 200d BF Ps SHOULD START FROM JUNE 2004 DAPDR IS ADMISSIBLE BEYC OND. iH DASDR AS APPLICABLE PROM TIME TO TIME, SEE NOTE ? CFERLEAP FOR MORE DETAILS Pi, SEE ENCI POSED PPO PART FIL ® "
rh o~ = + ~ - WwW
3. hese orders werm® issued on the a av mx ~ Se se we x basis of instructions for impismenting 7 NOS ne . , wien ie es 4 oy % : ee the ¥ CEO recommendations, bssued by tne Paeparhment at Eewnarnchi tig ix oS oe. BEDSAL LMSMN OF PRPSTMALTUES , ANTIGCKUrS Ro a} = ote TORT sr Pt FAN OS Fad 3 ry 4 : ya ' f WEN So ! ~ yt Lr LOLd PUNO. TOS /T/2004 ic Ga lek "A rok oy LA en ek ge - 2 ot te a a4 OL.G3.2004, which reads as Eollows with 3 a 'Art oe we oh CATA M TT € oe pose IY | Tomek He Par 3 Re Ge Ma bb ke g pie Chet pet ab LOL.
"PNo. P0302 2008 IC Government of India Ministry of Finance Department of Expenditure New Delhi, dated the | Adarch, 2004, OFFICE MEMORANDUM Subject : Merger of 50% of Dearness Allowance & OA No BLOWS ee/2018 'Dearness Relief with basic pavipenston to ™ cert fF yf sel rion obits Central Government employees nensioners £ wef ft 2002, ea - . a , sy ns fae Pay eye over the hase fnedex "sed dy the fasr Fav Commission, 2 This recommendation of Fifth CPC has been considered and the President iy pleased to decide that, with effect from 14.2004. DA equal to 50% of the existing basic pay shall be merged with the basic pay and shown distinctly as Dearness Pay (DP) which would be counted far purposes like payment af aligwances, transfer grant. rettrement benefits, , conmibunion fe GPE Licence Fee, manth ribution for CGAS, various advances, ete. 7 he for £71 Os i TDA while on four ay i " Uy te mien oS i ee ~ 3 however continue fo be governed on the basis of the basie pay alone withe taking unto account Dearness Pay dn ease "of existing pensioners, Dearness Relief equal to 30% of the present pension wil, wef 14.2004, be merged with pension and shows distinctly as Dearness Pension. Dearness AHowance/Dearness Relief converted inte Dearness Pay/Dearness Pension respectively would be deducted from the existing rate af Deuarness Allowance/Dearness Relief.
3 fo ensure that pensioners retiring between 4.2004 to 311.2003 do not face € ary loss in flxetion of pension, as a special dispensation in their case. DA equal ta 50% of the basic pay would be treated as basic pay for purpases of computation of pension in respect of basic pay received by them prior te L4.2004. Consequently, element of dearness pension will exist onty fer pensianers retired/retivring from Government of India up to SL3.2004, J insofar as the persons serving fn the fnelian x b ghee dudit & Accounts Department are cancerned, these orders issue after consuftation with the . Co miptroller & Auditor General of India."
"st fo Sea So u 2 goed an we rt Fey ct . ae) w ai C ny ay te "4 "ed a e C 5 3 co aed "2 oot peed a 5 3 ma be uD " "4 re ; . ~ che bea hes sy ws om as vet ro iB : £33 bd 5) os & rt 43 : vib "74 et fH OF 44 eo 4 "S tm 43 La i a ve Ay = ae {3 ae er ay S o th " 4 4 aoe a a cs c "3 iB fz ~ O >> tj co 4 m ts 3 a red as we ted 7 O tl 5 RB Boe Se ist vend w + 4 u 3 pa 8) a Wa coef 43 CS mM 6S c 4.3 -- a4 a SS "4 , o 6 & o q oy ae i 1 Oe Pe a Bs " my : to a "cf ~ C Z 3 a mB BO OB n G & te ee oa 6 ey ved 43 ss gt © 4 thy po ' Q we . 4 T} Os ee RG o a Oo 7 hed oa ' Ch Heed oy Z 4 QB ' LS n Mo "4 ci © 7 'ot ed 5 ao Th, ord f J ves f "4 oped 5 ; Be wh Ma
- ~ iy 2 @ © 0 ™ Aa a7 a cs co wes " . rhs . v4 a . ord poteg ro ka rit :, " hy Se "43 "74 Ul 4 he a9 4 ap :
3 7 4 hs ct ; 43 ie 43 ve ry r, 43 bd i » io oy " GS 5 iD 2 a oh tf om, fos * FB . 0) . cs Co gy in sh} - o a a bel oo 3 4 4 a S x 3 D $4 53 ct ~ 4 Oy y >} 65 wi apd wh £ 3 (3 ' * we vt C aa wd @ cS ot 42 ms OQ as 4 M4 at ts w m3 we . $4 e @ rm ro . oo who tp ED » " c wy i 43 2 @ apd c ; S ra w 4 crt wo G re) aed ve om! no = ¥ ° cs 4 } 4 wD ha et 5 at we % nH ay by Qi co C3 4 $3 7 a re nN oO c G ts de O ve} eB @ ay a eed a 4 wW oa " G t ord 4 wt 4 ot Add Dy wv c po wes tS Cy oo ad 0% 2 @ a QD hd Cy Cl ~ iS ~ ot 34 wy a ed 3 at QO oh ted "
p ~ ¢ rn be a RA 45 @ See ag G iD on + ot wv be wt - © ; . ' be Q 3S Boy et ' oO 4 LS e Ma srl sed iat O & g a 4 UO fa ® get i Q © ea aS fs Oo 22 vg} a y of a GO FB Most Ho 5 nn 4 n © 8) bs A tay wy $4 i Cy c rd . ct BS us ie 4 4 i $s KG Go 6S od 8] Oy 43 ted G E4 3 te oy wef She tox B 13 ay oO ; rs ( 4 a oP) t "Th i 4 iy , ; a > S O Po es 6 3 a ae v 4 Os i ts re4 ~ " cay 4 w@ rod i wged o ei os whe ht of -3 ald £3 £3 £hy ¢ DD "n mn wb i Oo £3 hod ° -- oe ' a Oo t vik od / f: v Bed cot cxy Cy ny 8 4a 4a B 0 4 i ge ci "
pb it w a , aged 4 LP " fos 4.3 hed ; 4-4 4 @ it ma ed w 3 ~ a "rh 4.3 my vs i A reed iy ft vy Kee on 4 j +. oe : ' oe thy it5 - Dp ae . @ " ms ae ved & ney $e 2 s ee is a ti : 5 ith a rf t a os 197 > C + y oe hoy pet - ae 4 3 whoa ' os vo . 3 i , e c ey er Bog Be 4 © Q 6 ort et HG fn 2 O a Q o be we C3 94 os ~ ¥ t a ie) itt Xo is is se ra oh 13 a % cy , us $4 Ad 4} u oo " _ . eyek a => es ce. £4 " a LD go 8 nm OB 8 OG rs Bn od be ag " a fe o ° 3 es : os ry "s . fs "rd o © oud @ bs cas ci 43 in ' fd O ua eG wy rey ra) Ay 18 x5 orf ae a Cy bed % Cog a © & Chg :
wo nae & qi uy s oie Oh 43 "iy 3 . 5 tH % reek "2 6 4 eat £53 3
5 5 ~ + G . > y "E5 ar} a ae) bet Ja we . 4 " a es sre] wf rook 4 Be - O SZ 2 - 3 et m "
os hi 5 ne ae rt oe % rs "a Pr Og & mas " Ho Bont Bhs 43 Ne is A 4 " A ot rs } 4 = we a . ta a at 4- AF rend ea oe a4 wt eR cs ne Ga 4 am 8 3 " ° ° wd eens, ' a" re! ved 4 ' + 4d > 43 * z G oy "yp ; gy 4 a ry be i OQ B ar C3 ' hs AG oy 0 aN nee it ae a esd "s '3 ha Q Pe) AR iz 3 4 co) 0 © e 3 4 a, % tid re G 3 Oo ae wv 4 3 a Gh 2 oS 4 p 5 a ee v wl 3 Fa ty Po 4 3 6 ml OG ™ tds mt a L4 ot i vet a a rt ad ved ch oh oy, my a $4 4d ey cP te so he 4 a? <a uy Sok oF Gy ee 4 C3 cy, Fg) c if Cy wu (3 ao 4 4 a we or pas B a4 sed red 3 ht oe i ved C3 id s cS ml ed 2 D rot iy wa a AG oy "<3 ti a cc @ hy O ree i "% ' ct bs ad hal of a a a a in 4 wo 4 :
¢ © q : Q " we © v rf if a Oh, Oa OM a in vq yy td Pa € os KE ' ss a & : , " wy a is N a fa 4 ny af eo 4 qi 3 th . ; be O 6 ee Aa , wv us m a" a <p a Cy geek ve wad on " wa $a 3 py ' oA uy 5 vs , a " Ss vn BS ws Q 3 @ o or pe is fed i a es m3 " 4 re a 73 be cs a = <
-
R +r we 3 "es ind be . ib Ss na +4 "4 Oh, gt es n Oo e we 3 "4 a a «
a) oy Do aes et OD ij A Ok Bosh ya "4 mS a ag mn a seed wy my, 6% an ; i ci ret 4 be gm" ne 5 OR ts . iS 2 mk 42 @ i er mn Cs id ' 43 ue 42 6 6 "a oe " ne ¢ oe a 6 G2, on @ A . " a OL w bg 2 cs n
a) ms a bee ea es ' 65 we s ee
a) cs cs qt '4 sy a qi aS « oH ee 3 , ae S68 'i eS mo ea OS a i mm rs) +4 ie 4 44 mn os ay i 43 apd re a ; + agai 6 ; Q we ct ne a 4} : w 8 a at itt a ' i O oy ed "eS u 4 "4 4 te - ns Ht € . 43 . 4 3 co cl ord a) eg uo 3 bo in oS 6 " © co C $3 S ts da eo F WO ee tf o " "s bei * , ag) o oo - ey bef 33 4.4 oe ea £0 rad w 5) ad on "4 CO oo i G O os O 9 © it hed en Oh mm. bet @ © Ho oe © eh tm Q@ HW OM OG ured it . cS mo eS a) a es iz a + B w .
se 3 nO oF C A $4 we o MM it io i . ne C "ed ft a Ne wef " re vant vse4 vent ved c a i G £5 3 i) $5 ae my iy wi 3 is) "6s mt i ES us 3 . 403 wy Set ee ' & me 43 OS "4 ty * Ch OF 'D end hf a "| os] ce eS oO oe @ % ve @ i Ep Roe Ly to yee OQ, wn QO are a a ed ved ws fy Sel it % ha ai et o a tt to a 4 am ae ha 4 44 yd f errs * i apd <¢ x in "5 a ws i > iG wo si ted ey a ' Ba Oo £3 se "4 gent wyed ot ® ie bi & Ld a tt beg of $4 feet yp > nt = one a) rf er aa ws Gy f i a) ay ss a, F vb v , taut A oe on ka . ia us Sos oy Ww aw
- ; : v4 o + ia As i as bed iw c 4 ey xt wees : 4 Me, Co ie ip pd / ia) sp) a seed ' 74 ct q ce 3 wha i " gs } aS Ee + 44 o rh syst ts Cx ret ob CY yet 3 et 2 % ret uy H % a ifs : Qs « , * ony 6 ae we @ 2 ae) G3, , a ns te u. ot a ee gy a * % eg Hg a & as wu 0) " ifs re ql te veg se whe ar / us tek "se sn % tt i f 4 aed beds . 3 "ry Cag AG oo ' cs 7 44 2 a ' feb a v a en i a os rot % vere . w id cs . ma ; ee ot OF "3 Dy te 3 , OB 4 154 ot ty {$4 oo de i} 5 O a ws > i Ch Z ee gt Hed fend rs wt red . "A 4 ene aA oe nS re) €3 hey "eg © S > Pee oO C3 o f s o és cS 43 i gS , 43 bed ve aed : = on i ' oo ; vie , Z o 4 . ; "i en rf oat ah oe ef £3 Ob be a , i aa Nee oN ay i a a Pea M4 SS % a i . . . 1 . 4 k. "4 ae 43 c ie a o O cs 5 tS Db me «a CS ony by +3 fy in oe 1 iy be cs a BR G 4 , rd Ma a mo OS i. 3 3 wn ss cs o 5 ood 'eS 4 <t : 2 oh : an Ds og ai . rd es i its in n Po peg rn Gort oh, 3 5) iG vxef O of o bef 4 | had i . KG ' a :
¢ tease re £ ' ' © i 4 us iG ah af 3 sc y o poe Nd ste re os - " 4 . ee w rt el i ey AX i rp PLE lerar ie a t BHSIOH ~ * £ t oy 54 Aad 6 id i 6 ANTS yey "
Sb MRS. C ab.
~ aay ak 33 wy 4d us at M4 wo $ ae tar ¥ tu f.
© 2 se Sew x Le GAA $ t ~ # Bat ae ne a oO Nar ED den re a at aa eg 43 x Ne we a3 ae TA te het oe ay is Mae Feat Oh LA ee w & & = eo z » = Me AS ¥ = i 3 A * an 5 aan.3
= aE , ¢ 4 ;
i aa, eM a ae Ch ct he co bee wy ® < whet w ey rae! G3} i oS ' s a2 . he i353 rage te, cy a D 35 @ {3 i i ve itt bf ay . a iS aad ood = ae ¢ it Mw wy C3 a a eg A Oh, "y ¥ aS 13 "4 ! 3 we Go fe pp Hee o 2 ® < & BD og i ( ns, oan 4 Lt 4 43 wrt Fad sine 2, 2 S * oS ify a -
4a 0 2 Q ert - 43 +3 ot 3 MM if 3 ; a cL, (aie) aS ay m o hd y "a "4 ° a it et at ed oy ct 44 Ww ; id ea o the Ea mB An oe c 3 5 oo. vad . = O a eee : re c "oO "ed wD EA Ss es G Ory me A o 1G @ . 43 a bs . 4 4 vt " i nm LS w im 3 co v 5 B ved . R wi O ost 3 w "4 wy be > wa v4 e 3 "3 om Yel . ES ke + 43 ae o red o iD i 43 od v eS C3 oo ae c 2 1b @ g © Cs 4 43 a 4 o a) 4 au 2 1) G Q os e $3 ts a 6 i » oo 4 OO fa ae 3 a) ag , oe sb me o 2 ws Cy yo 5 ' @ A "5 a we ° i wn fa "et as o ~ i. Boat P ae) we 4 uy @ O z
"4 4 7 "ef a Aw " at tO s ' ' aim oo @ ms, fa vt as OF , wd yu Gm 8 Pow OQ 4 Poe a G eo S) gs ed iS ct uy bess oped Gi a w OQ . 6 ho eo O be gp FD fa ¢ ae = Om ba it be , iB rE ye a A a EOS & <5 se ¢ a OO & % i ws bet ad er om ve s ea a" 43 fo 2 ai ¥ ~ ary a4 bos @ be t os at £} 2 74 ey a a " . q cot ae Pad 4 ie C3 " t} hf my e 4.4 43 oof md ee or s) 43 Cy <A "sed ws ~ aE 4% mee i che ae co % as & @ gerd jt 3 43 mt a c ee, 4 ce oy Aa > t 3 uw) s rh c ; aad wa . it fe oO Q 2 tt on Q wD 43 bot on at oe as ed 4 et a G poe "C3 Lan ae, . Va 3 Z . a oo : 3 G Me o " cb . ees oe rf ch - 4) a ue os oad nL | : " om" oy Se re bee 4 " tp QB ~ ~~ om " 0 GB G se re ee os G3 a da S $3 ba 3 5 u i (sed @ oOo p Bs ; a Sse ' co a wo # G ut 4 ard bd ' 43 ad @ ct i Mrs i @ ad Me Me On & ms ao a ' = C3 ea Q ot 84 £3 2 yd iB a ie e 5 ed $5 a ie Q eed SS ca ry a ao re = s 8 O . fed ee " ' 42 . @ A : AS O fo of QO oss as co a me. £5 4 a} ed } a4 t 44 i 1) ' > 24 oy Need ae _ ved cs ; A oO st oy cry oe spd Lo Oo C3 £3 ry ya ig $4 cs a rd my 2 pod oN wd 5) is * ns 4 wc \ . : \ . e oe 3 2s C3 bed S i 2 oF QD ela a 3; " reed a bon bed te ' hete$ . vt ' " my "4 . ™ aa 2 3 nA C ! 4 % ne $3 G : 3 24 a "7 '4 . tele 3 * COOOL WLUUOCUUOOU LOO LLUTLLUTOLULOLULCLLLLLLLLCOOOLLLUOO LOL, in 23 Oo & PH mg ar ie Oo A b4 © ao w ae "e a eb Op verry hd hd ms 4 re bo + oD he a a 4) Oo Fae ' a peoed ch et G } © ce 4 : oom fo of 2 8 a cn i} ' ne % od ub " 7 ws f ws oe _ Be hed bd & a 3 uy ' "4 43 Aa iB ne + wo ' ° 'e ; a a a goon , # Gs hs rat : 43 os + "
¢ 5 ° ¢ a Gt chet a -- os ny EE + wh : egeel fn. . i vcd oH bf £ 4 c ce! '4 Gg 4h pe CS b of . Ms hg 4d set aan "a ch g A) w fed a ts Sr se es ved om ag re a : a Si wf a @ * 3 : ort & ' w . Q $4 Cs ww oo an Be ef Wi oO i oS ve Cn cs > gp bx wed » rite greed he a , yd * C3 n i es ca "% SG ti hd om orf on rm a i i a ' KE " 03; Me on 6.4 & 3 Dy i aa oH os oo a <3 td " uD cS 0 i ot co O 1% ee ° re 43 bd a a oh 4 ft hed . td co On :
a) wh 4 o Ao w a ei i ied ry TG a a re 43 wD és "es od PT & et i i} A ci fs a 0 '44 vf th S be i bed Oo "g a oe es ae O wh mt t te Oo Oh 2 42 @ 4 3) 43 fe 8 £4 B o% @ Oy w "s vd {4 @ a a Oy bef 4 ws & O 2 © b4 M4 ei & Tad Co ch ney sn os ot e * oC wD @ ed CoH oe Ba iw 4 G . om @ 5S AS O "4 % 4a Gs g3 £24 o i By) 4d Bed 3 6% ae SS cc is) '§ w ae ved O a 4 wn G oy a, - 33
4 ot to co as 43 oe ¢ oO po er hed " co 5 ea 4 viet @ @ "4 ht oA 2 es ~~ St a ed a < as iB "z 3 $4 @ 4.3 a 4a a vd wp : v w b4 ry " ce me ~ in Bo ue eo fa 3 2 = a " te, O wo vo 3 OMG 2, Wd fe o a civ 2 @ a $4 ) x -- 4 fa co -- C} 9 tet oy $5 uh i} We sh te a a o wu Med m4 , y i a ty : . oo Ww) ep @ of , ae & *y ax ys ' aoe oe a 'ty ; 3 ' 'o od > O qe i tA ff oO 'J wm uh , a gt . ory " Q vst o ce: "a oe di ne ai Sa a) Ly et ce) ne Gh wx ars, sg & wv 2 pM cle '4 BS og 8 OG 2 Po wD Gf any ts he Mie ¢ bal ted iy " at " rt ; x ie Od int ah nh ~ a
--
eke eh Lee ay we oh a Hien on we MAb ah ns bid ces "
a x = oo
4 4, Sa iis gE ee Ty @ By we be 3 56 th vl y at ved eed $5 4.3 : cs " XK ot ot * 'bt iA wry hea aT oot 5a thf 3 PY o wy ged af yrs, es o Y set 42 gh oO G3 oe ha gc ~ we 2 ont ia "tH i a oA rt Cis oy ei <p Ue oD « + a ~ et oe " ret "% a "4 he 3 ok ft my wi «ty as G @ raat . Fn Pu a3 p oD a a o . LD ie noe ad es ms 3 4 43 reek Oy sy a O "4 m~ ' uo G a 4 is] G ad 3 a w G c od " wed a3 4 KE os 3 th G a4 @ * Mw <3 ~ o> ee Med cc ea eH o Bc G@ ty & tm ~ gh Si "Po ort 2 £ Go OB » Gor § wb Wi £8 4S ay "C4 2h O . ' ' G or red 43 2 ve Pa 63 D i " "
wn @ uh 2 ct ie w " ed i en a mG i m, * i it " A 44 oS ¢ @ ® o : a , '4 a kD OQ ne; ne 3 5 XS a vet ky + "sh co q rd ry "ef @ rae ned ae. ne in 4 ifs ae ved Ld od no) et 5 Ww Ge 4.3 2) he rm a ot . a ' tt oh, ES ~ 2 ay uw aoe: ve *% ed i G3 3 a a & Oa "ft ref hy C? oe, @ wea ted oO oe) @ Oo ved en 43 Q, oO ry 43 05 2 ne C3 ite i {3 t, Loc cece eeceectnneeeesnecnenaes wii NULL OLA LULL L LL LALLLL ACL OOOOLOOOOLL ODA OD OI ecllecnla @ Y We tt a ' ey a G "ig . by we re my ' 8 " wet oe of Pa AS a ms "a £5 ao a YD i G ~ vet " oh a bet ned : ws 3 "
aa x "
. rs © wy ei "= ves Ch:
"s a if} o3 ee 'bed res 3 ~ 3 a A a v rm wm et j
- "5 43 nt oo o wv m4 oO tp + * a Ww gong s iG a rd ivy 43 | "2 " poe bey e a ry ved it we O poy x ONE f3 ¢ b ;3
4 ,. : 4b ' a oo o 1 a ved Me et cs 3 neem ve a re ek a of at a a3 aed re] CS 3 "¢ 4.3 * ee) Lo hoa * oa ny e ot ed ko WB i, ms e 4) of os. ty tgs 2 ite > 4-4 ot ' : : ry if 43 ' ie ce, LA i "
2 co x . "4 , eR 3 ho cs 0d o% 1 wh t C ao 3 & eo Oo ¢ ' rn $4 ved Oy An xs a . s ty oy set yeed Ch Q pod $3 hy "% 4 bby ved yee oh, Gh C3 a 5 4 " 3 aw kA cs wa ' a ie i 6 @ mt » fw ~ GRY Q i w we Se Cm OD mM sh TS st e ' fy be vd 44 rh ed $3 iD 3 "a im te $3 8 % wD ~ '. = em w@ io Ty Oo CN Ss ced iF a) 4 peee gy " epee i tal m cd 4 Ae Me us rod ' ot o. 3 ot 5 " : : i. ds wn wef cp a cs - "a a . { or - put 4 es O fe a 'ts on € os ct aS & 4) a ft a } - wD Pes . ' m3 ¢ i ~ Go Py ks bf a ee ° von eo RG 3 , © cae ood a Le tn H te co 73 3 me Ms "
ip i 4 'G . re) ey _ a + in e3 D mC Oo od o Bs ba ed fn eS mM de A eo 8 8 4 2 6 fy Oe t GN a cy u 4 re w ih a
a) iW ' oe o ne re a bd 4 M4 a3 i q oO "4 bd ag G ag "
CO 2 teow. : a vgrd HF Mi oo Cy 4 (Xa Fn 44 e a co try we , ie wd a 3 a wed ey z Q iB hy * of a 3 cn iS a5 a 9 m5 te \. Oy ts Ae Bed Ly} xed fh 8 } 7 va £2
- , 3 ey « f. /
a) s 3 nl 7 ey ~ a4 Oo a cy Ae ey * Sh-4 C . th ats ay mm " . , " wb aad ce o . ; ity "cd O £5 : me id os, wo " 4. : , oa ye t wt At 4} Lt 3 Ch . we fot fia . € we g we S fa cm sat Ss a rt a . t4 ON . ey i . fg Oe ££ ' L 3 ee is ta ot O a 3 Bg & co a é 3 i tf cs 4 @ Q @ 'sf uw vd " » oa $4 Cy "3 es) ~ ted G ek ig wy bd a aD ' 3 cs "5 wd c 4 a La 13 43 Oo veg gy WG c / "4 re : 4 - a tidy ard fet 3 , bs ce i} is, O 3 . J < Oh re Ae $1 ad * a a} oh os fds 3 Oo a5 oy os a oD ws ce a io 43 3 " ' wey h (3 i it 43 eS wy "et 4 ws " be 44 S wi iw 4 bf ww ms State of i Ae et Mw yyw wet os ote Nw aa Sa ane ot (White Masih Rafiq lL Appeal Ne. lis27 of 2014 avi C i72 ) Near x x WAS No.il1é6és4 of 2012.
BP {C} mg out of SL ariSs oor tyes Mawr Rae ede Rat = ms oO z bee pitts, ace aw NS aa ye = ws Sah wa WANS AS ", tery f 4 4 3 :f my Ay ot Oat ae ts ee = "
o~ a] TA Doyen 4t CA AK a ot chen aed Wed Med LU UOLLLUCLTLU LICL ae ot or bag oy . 1 nA on 03 a 64 "s os Ay gy a) be % me ¢ 3 i ; tue uy ra ih a bs * = b4 a op bea ca it So 3.3 iis + reged we] thee ord BG a jd 4 > oe $4 hog -
bed oye oO in ri on G us a $a res: > i" wD Bed he O 43 A 1G 3 3 iG O Q bd 6 43 a as a 3 im hed G ; L i ut ieee os . 5 G re n - a € ms ® 3 3 . Og C f oe 4 eS ei a te i @ 44 tt i a MH ua Ls oh, Aa ey vet a 3 "4 ved £3 eA ¢ 3 8 : a mg :
SS w 4 C3 ; Ret - 7 we a al of C A , es O rf) ch ha , nose Ww thes x . g 2 ™ ae) VA ad ve s ey 80 us "tr wa a cl © o a 9% & $4 os - 4 on Ao . f 4 an ye 44 te ® 4 € os bent om hes, os bee, a3 o- nd, oY gos oO ¥ 5 oD ss? for C : go he < €! ak a e we ager! ay ca er i os © ony "4 oS os a S53 Ho a 7 OS mo Bet ©. C cat 4 ° af £
- 4 tf 4 = . i 3 7 be ay ) 4 ie " a eB 9 @ 4 a te gs @ So ay > e oy 7 Af ' 7 4 4 Cy af od cn ton, fea oj ved 9] 3 {3 : MA * ons 4 ' vt est . * 3 & a C Os O ~~ m4 a os @ 66 iy {5 sn $4 4 rt Ba . es a ka on 4 ur £3 gy Ce > fod " 3 co iC 4 LA ° i" "st os i 3 po M f a . 7 3 a ve edo a4 ed O eS " ood Ch ved rs 4 os 4 "C4 co sf) o cc ; 'bet Do O : ae ' w GS ai . oO G aut ¢ mi 5 c { a aq i v a oO Pr 3 @ 3 f ra) 4) ey Do " ep A uv fe 3 * os OO coef v4 : co ha 1 wy "a i ing £24 % a3 ad Masih 3 e LR ubrad o pf ne q cash, c i ot : he ay Cd ' pet va ho hat "A te. 3 ay (he O i 3 3 ms ws ei 4 4) a 4 * wD " " , a m ord "hy $3 D ' " oA e3 e| vod won so > oS « cw) wD | . © . Q © - G 44 ord 44 veef ih a Co a oy red 4 aS fia i} £3 ord 3 ts m Oo ist vi Be 63 . 'Bp BA the wef w @ w Gs wa "rt <r} a rf o Wy . 3a fy {3 AS EE ' 6 &% 44 ee ce "ed % gy 4 @) fins a eet 1 ts mS m4 es > a6) ' wf wn a} sg a we w % ef a = = ci von » "4 LE 3 aes a Ss @ } "
ct QO ng oo e) 4a Cy x as: 4d 4 ™ EA vd es a ee ve + i fe 5 os a | Dr Ow cn tng ns ded me ~ as O 43 bd " 3 be co nt : ras) os 3 "rd cs Q aa te ue Ss . 43 Ss i 3 4 a @ i op 4 uy 3 4 a 4 bg o ah . tt £3 4 o4 Bos a3 o $3 - "cH i My od et j tok a te) ha i it ia 3 : a we ths ip 7 4 << MG © es ' "4 C4 oF aS ' wed I "S oS
--3 <i? on F ¥ a a $4 i a i m2, : wD 43 NY wv : bt) or epee 4 See qs hat D te ' g vm u oi po 7 fea 2 i i e 4 we ws ni ¥ ne 42 a4 wo cf 3 wed $3 J Le 5 : 4 } weed "ee O wv * « : c a ch ba "E5 tet crs hd ry "ee eof os Bo t aps ' t 4 * Se " ms la - tee gy Boy B a Is ¢ a8 m3 4 a, O co mf Gj ae ' oad ut ed La . os bea ts ut Ry is " ih 44 we 4 ues a 43 vn wc on vet " Za Co ps q % aM ra ix] aes . of od © ay oo "ye Se * Md ' Wr = ws oe Cs 4 &.
we.
ES?
= = ane ~ t x mE 3 _-- oy ony ko of ° or 2 oe sete ty we = ee ae :
b ik en & NS p . wen - 43 bat 3 ad '4 '4 bes fo i fo 2 2 SW 8 % Go, w po ae oy Se ih ht as Me iy eo) BA wa i a a > be ct 3 qh { by y G3 co o4 ee $3 :
se, wire aye ot Set : . 8 3 - "rt a ved we 3 @ bed is 8 f "4 a wet phe + iit 4 fa a fn oe - a s 43 ml '4 a nA 2 ut g3 £4 ' ae . Ad es . i) ebook ve £3 on te aq} "4 ee no $4 a es orf $1 f a sed a @ 43 43 i 65 ef, wy a O o 13 a " "i 4 rs a eee si : a me 2 eg abe Lid a Sea D ae) sy we 3 w Xn C iy G a3 we "4 rs ns er ee) re a SQ GM te cS on seo fe b w ee Ud gt cs get Dp 4 et oe, vet Sa o 2 (ba 3 nef £E Ry Oo 3 A uy 4 bd we rm) be o we td "rd eA rie iS 43 ri Q tid } ip 43 on et , % es io oi i a a) be a "4 44 =) 3 o . es oS ved ¢ be C7 vam} ~ "4 need om rot ot 3 io se oe hn 43 tv be < u ad Lh m qos at a3 wc i e @ an qd Cy "ch and is a ie 4 et i ke oo wn s "s "cd ry "rd ae We o rf ved 3 w 4d qi ted xe i} a 4 ct fo gp 4S 7 ie mr ted x "4 a Q .
"ft u ww peed ab qh iby Bi e 54 hae Dp Pam cl Oh, 2 on 4 s re 7 " wm ay a A Ci ce ce to ae a 'et ~ ty " i 4 ie * eS : 'a o) 14 :
° wf it ad & 3 Lea co o ay we 2 ea 6 a mUs ed wo OS Ww if a fy Su we a 3 om . C8 & _ & @ 3 f} rs 13 w a boy fed a a a ony 43 oo b rl Ld ; | Ch en + a rod os { af m7 ed @ be at pest hed ay oy rr fos a ss ~ 43 fs QB ? G 43 ra i tes as " eh Yong C2 ) ct @ mt Oo ee ao 5 e La 4 c a ios Fe, iG oy he ht \ oy 6 rong if a 4 ri ced 5 a £3 3 x wD ref & sy art "ek ms 8 4 wy te 4 of ' rh we G Ka i is C3 et 4 a Co ett ent Sea wo ~ re ai oh; Reg r ; et uy a ma % ra red , QO ond £04 apd © ( a a ¢ yp ~ o ay £3 a wv ith sobs en % 42 54 fe a Ss o a j Bed a ' oy e3 fC @ + ee a we Be or 5 Ls hey at a fe od M4 be "4 ® a i is % e get wo at . hd ? "jt sot is} 43 Soa i SG Bt @ we 2 4 me te : EG iy cA a oy 4 YG Cs 2s ;
ay @ 0 my reef . wed we \ in one oy fs : res ryt ct O ; . ut rs] A 4 és a} c a me = 43 ard " 43 43 ny i cg « . us ord he he cS fa oot itt Co} we orf oe} wv / ha Oh 4 Bp x es '5 ° 4 MM a 64 £5 . ved fea G hy we a ey ed ip $4 ez aoe, "4. one ra Sa 'S 4.5 4.3 3 c2 ort ~ . % Bs cH es oh a ow) is . fd ue) i © 33 noe ay @ $4 Soy bf "4 By wy w Q the 0 He Qo ee M4 ® © oO wi OS oo tos es LLL L LLL L TTT TT UTC ULLTLLLOLLLLLLLLU LULL UL LL UULUUUUL PLETE ST SGPT.
= poo few 4 vy ge hm Bad SARS SASS ", Yr " a3 ce my Ye oo ay iy to bt wy ry ' mr = i ih Ag a ci wy c } J Sh wy yD Aa we co ra ed mo © 43 42 i rd 8) 43 4d £3 ae 4 ot ao 42 w Mo we it fits el C4 syed is ay uae = 4 "T4 at 4 ny ae fy 4} gD "yt os a " v a 4.3 4 ty < e " ca 7 ™ i Ds, = ° "4 i i ( ' " :
& us wt mm ard th ey " eo vex : 5 ~ : eed a A a ; Gs Ma 3 a wt ° a3 Py wed "3 v4 ~ 22 v4 yp - m3 - s) 4 G3 oof * m2 i rs bs . et "e| is, et ot oy Oo % et ay ¢ ad oo te .
cd $3 ore} ry } as iS , oa ; a aa foo 4 43 x te kg * 4 M4 pa ws m4 at 04 i oe " . at oe os : CF 3 Say oA cee] b. shea on . cs w U3 a C ff we ce wed 44 ved an z ed ed, é e * = SS nana . 1 ns 4 oe bef , a i thet i. 0 oo "OE os OE "
ft ard wh "4 a wed hee ry o wo 8 a un o a G wt i + nA te 4 e 3 O i ct 5 or wh wh hs : @ 3 a oo oe 6 a a Ho we c 0 S&S wD wes : he © 5} os i a ry
"5 $3 "red ) wt hs ot a wt 4 os 1G " ° é ts " ag " res r fed i 4 aa feed eet def o2 4 Gon O i ¥4 a ma ' rt os tg 4 ae Cs a3 bsg a us ty 4 oy (3 a " 4 ee rts s wa <3 at 4 a get C5 O 1% rt rt ved £4 Ch ak a opt a) - ey 4 : , mH ib les an ee Kh a) Jo i io ce as cy Ca ce uy. ' 4.4 GB nor a 3 we 43 3 Leg . 4 44 a Shee ioe rh bd EM 4} . od Gs i wy ¥ Cai ie poeed bf ond ws Nt x Fae be .
Nt o 3 Ema Kans Se 54 En te Ne 4 , to 5 fd ded Qed at 2 wy ves b oO sy ct i i 0 4 & ved » 44 4 wy 8 rs ved Y A rs oy C mC oo Ss a Y +3 4 fs 43 G a ba ° yo G4 8 ss rd 2 ct it } oe . £ 1% 4: iff At fy , aL 4 hb . oe fa . ba . oe ve wv cs - £ id 7 Me G i hes hel os 7) @ bed oe * 44 ; Nd oof rod Ma oo srt ne +4 w oo KS 43 c i oS Os rv x 44 i SS bs ' os a % $3 G x ae as ie) . Ch, veel a s C3 0 et ms i p oO i Bp ma Sef ws iN 4, ed Sa wy a a £3 "is cD g ww oy Gd & $4 wm en Ke oe) ie O ve he Shs fa coeeeceeeeetlaseetenseceetseseeeeeseneeeeeeee te CULL LLLL LAL LLOLLL LULL TOLL LL tlh, ea seg me hen an LAL x we ee ac nS Ar Ee] ber ecans ars Me te i t #3 } ar ex Sk Ra AL 4 4 43 + f we
- te A me cet aN
a) ern weal Th a4 we oh \ = wry AEE * he ote tes SO es 4:3 Lar aah ™ x x at i m4 mA wget.
ad me ap 0 co ip ' ws be reret 1G = So ny wet 43 b. @ eS * ng a ea a z 'A a we Se et Oo a oe 23 ae OCH cI we, is o ee wF a re £7 ri rs wz oO A 4 oO thy 4 G & 13 23 $3 aS 82 = . ™ $y a qs «5 Ee i a 4 4 rae re) Cs 3, weet ay Gp i w . - wh my Na ee tf oe a . at wa a a ' 2, a whos "4 a uy} i oy o} " 4 inf 1 a 2 ' &: ea co eh 1 © es " <t "od ~. #4 " ee i no we in bad wy m4 4 th is "4 on <4 ~ ae a 3 i a . 3 . . 7 2 ooh ioe ~ ct ns @ 4 se uy g ee Sa a "es ae ca : . 'a C3 se ars c $23 © ha in ord B g ra ey 6 4 5 oa a 4 "A "sy . ja ned a , 3 © 2 53 8 44 i' cos Pa a 1s "4 , f 3 Os @ Os Or ¢ , & 2, a ef . a bed a" ah hob 3 ey et i fa "FQ a ee é rs A ved 4 cs "4 ws re @ oO ry is) * ha yp Os cc w Me 3 4a i cred " i ne 54 6 % © ord be oe - i £ po vA B a £4 iy Ly aa! ons ios 4 D ~ os te ' 2 ® oe sect ted eon eed A "4 at "ch a 3 2 ey ms rm Q ee ery fe 4 i) ce 3 ret t 4 wd os es ' Be Bo BS O 4 @ i wt 4 oe iB ca it 13 cK iy wed ith aa nm 44 O th ri oy "3 43 42 i ap iD 4.3 "4 * a3 c an weed ist c C4 oa oy " on M od o x vet & be w a a bea a QO wn os a ke 4 fa 4 o 2 wh te 03 ao * oe Cj rd ond Q +e v4 U3 be ie et cs Ox ef é we kD GR deed A ue) "ed eh a "ed e ie) a 4) od ved iA vd we iv} ry i iy bf 4 4 ea cs Ms 3 ad} wy ed . rie) $4 a zy if} ce O O Cy Qed ms ) Ba oO a S ' 3) ce) wif pad wy @ a ' oy Ch s & 6 Be Bey wn $3 $5 3 At i iS 4 wt @ e er be viosteseteseneees it ALLEL LLLLUEOLLLUEELLALELEE TELL LLLUUCULUELL TULL ALLL DLOO TLC OLOOU UTC UOUU ULL LLTOUT LULL LULU AAALLLUDDSDLUUDLDDEDELLLLELEEE, a seed mS wD a a $4 "i rae wh ws OD wn pod ke a ry ene] 4 ® a Es ba me oot § "
he ee ay de sed . oo . at Q3 he 4 ky iL ts et we ved » , ns 5 n iS 2 on ' w) cs Se Ug bs G © : @ vod Ma oe (Ox oh.
oe ae % {Bp wo CH fre is a se: 6 fof wT j ond 's co she one a os , ay sre
"5 A en ce cp me ne Le Sy fe : " a CS is o ot 13 Bese oe i wad we roy net 7 3 Wi : ea ig 'atone bf di of . mo a @ th ee Pos bet they en reg fs wy oy ee t BY Y Ws ' 3 vn 4 hes : 4 ¢ pb Co 3 co Set oS QO be 5 ut / 32 ay ad 5.4 vot i we a st rp et 3 w C a 43 SP } hee i mh oo, het to phe " ares * & na as D wy et ted wo 4 ld ie , we a 4 fy 43 Fea cd
4. ' Thef cok. C3 ta ' 4 rs = } cS iS wD of cf 4d ie oad a ra GY he O os es sl po 4 id a ra Se ey a 43 ag oO ned ~ , 3 4 By ta m4 2 As iy ce A y okey Oo oO ' 4d ad of © i wt Ld 33 "3 yh wD oo $3 be as @ nd i - 5 7 a} ee oe w Ch, i fats 7) et a wb £1$ , ta i it LS ms o "6% prof gai "ch nO wot U3 OG " oO (3 @ . Bet ed ou 6 mn ve wed Oo Hd a Q a et 4 w@ oat had 4 fs bs Go GO Bb fo oO & OO 2o a » oO « sed ee $4 3 ao Ch 3 Se th Cha ch @ gt S: 5 1 uy «set bey a 3 43 eyed re fy aS pnt ht i Gg ( $4 re) a ry ma ms =A eyed < + a3 gl . whe nS @ fed o oD " {7 od SSF a 4 " . ae) o is SA & go te 78 a a a 5 GN ' ua p £3 el - es 4 ved . w ord re a) Ka ne . gt oS hs = oi @ 43 C ra 5 ined Sy " fy C ts 3G ee a ny ey ms a oo Be a q % O, 44 a ae @ Ss . S ea 2 a i oy 3 Oh w os OD - Q ow 3 AS eh 4 '4a % mB " _ & ® eS Ek . 4 mr TI O a © "4 ot ~ i ad 4 in th mt tt a 4 ~ ge a O qj eo oN 3 3 fon es a te oS aa ed : aq '3 ba Oo ved ° LG pa ' * by wo set a ' ey bet % yh on eo . et $0 Li jet fy . a 44 i ne ngs mo 4S iooa cod "Th 4 res ot iw ay aad on a a i om C ce eo eG ue rt "4 aD o weed O 3 ved % hag Koa hk See a hy co wo eypet aed wd G3 . : Py ws " weed 7 . a) a - My a a bs & cas a 4 "
. i iT ae no Toeof :4 het fey ae seed fod en 43 O 44 4 3} wf i yo es a a ee a ot Ly a Le te 4 m #7 ES 4 os on 6 a 2 3 es GC we od os os oo ms us ee a vp oo a Ph 4 « "
O , , Ol " ery 5 ved ae fe eo ( wh - 7 ver ' 43 a % me . 3 f G Ls) } po ro a ce] rd Gy a is m4 , 3 " C - 3 $3 a a iB £4, vge4 spd w mt $4 rant a eee o uid C my, - eheel geet we end ct oy rE C3 n . A GS o ts ' . aL fet Sh ; nee a vd : v c tg 4 9 me a 5 GG & i Q B i 43 . ie, " ws " '4 "ry a Boe a a3 wy ond a Be 6 ' a mod 4 a Cg 7G a 8 8 ae) wet so vod t 2B a3 © 45 ao > a it A 43 f4 $2. (e) cre o 8 ™. wt LJ 2 co Pa ' mt 4 5 AG x 4 Me, o ae Og 6 HH 5 oy 2 OR ok i Af a n o 9 8 ee oe ¥ ~ iG a ae J te 5 . i t re £ . 5 ' ti L : "
od a Uy Q 4 et 44 wy wet 'A 43 % © i 4 bel ead weed @ 3 a f ay oy i) oo thy wet a . aD "4 ny ay > 4 ord 2 a ha ' os 7 ae a oo] ct Coy 3 . coped bak Ae i aad ove . oo oug! U6 po 4 oo ae ag KR oo -« oe "= 8. & & ~" me a D4 > st Ge oh > wed: 5 <a . _ pe is io: veg rf & est ac 3 " 0 i Sy eo 43 a 4 B} od By a iM DB
- 44 Qo al ie 5 ue St re wv ; i rs oS * os od oe ov fhe a my gq o 3 a ms ed iss "4 oS G ' 2 Ad wu '4 i & me 4 mS ta 3 . a ea w "4 4 'f vt a A as 4 7 "4 < TH in co C3 cd os wet ay se * wr : efi Ue t3 uy cs od rn, 4 "5 iB v rn fh ; rho . oy ae wh Oo wa G qe t3 von i EX 'o ine i me ya 3 : * or Eel aged a ct My oi "apy a a a os wy +S B 'B = t i ky Ph rhe og w Ly % am e% a 4 oa oy C4 on fh iJ 5 4 " * aoe u ra ha pi a a 2 + + se) ee) % 4 "Ke ry 43 3 on . "| - o oy red 3 ay ay ws «4 on na "ps - @ 63 . "4 ee, 1 a 42 a 03 i t a 4 a on ns "A , a a mn $4 ve : cs ra) bd : a 43 4 Loe qi $43 "i 4 ahd dog ct . ; as ed . 4 i
-- * oe " bY 43 43 ref om © 5 . ' a bes = ce a m4 &2 mt : Y Mm @ $4 4 ny Cag whee aa ve "a i ad iy ro ih we A Gh 4S g 4+ wh " "5 eg ct 4 Cs ; fa a) ot 42 peed o oh 4 pod 5 { a oi ce : is ¢ red - o oe ks a : fy " red 2 4 et los iy a4 oi w Feo '. et CO eG ef i La Fa 9 a nes es io o tA a 0 _ = ; AM G & 4 rs : be ce try at he | ke i ord de ~ ms ee : ped . os ot a A Hy ee ceed : we : oo at te wy ord ; : a ee t. co @ in Ge © a We ge mG wo os ee wi asl 43 oy! (3 ed pina y '3 . 57 "2 (kt ca 3 ey C3 4M bed ee £ i j 3 4 4 a ;
oe ' Fi td ae ) - ai it a oy 4d 42 13 £2 LD Q "e 4) i ce 4 G o 4 o so ~ iB a} po ( @ a3 . bs, eo "Th " ° oy a 4 a an 43 ca a um oe G Sos Pat wen y 0 5 a i g 4 rs 3 o is cs 4, 4 aged oy coy a bite re aan $3 c : as a o 8] cee eS oH 8 a a) Mt ved co spn a i ' c te a a a @ 2 "ES i 5 Bo PS ei Mo Ss @ wy c fs ~ Gg 8 v a wf sa isa 4 Hy cs : ve x c id o "4 ae - 5 +A i 3 > OG . : : 4 ; - re 2 ew 5 Gg dt an es £3 ot + .
Nee A Ne yy Y "y 2 ~ a rt w ca 5 65 a) ' ¢ C3 ros ne * eet ' 7 be. © wd ff £ ' ' ¢ « o 8 Rw i wv ka 4a ved CG ay '4 "e i bed C Sh w @ te vo ® ASE ef me a) ba te "D © @ Ab 4a @ sy o C iy m4 cD 4a Oo 20, 3 a Be ' ed A ce 3 Ss oO ny rea w 3 thd we oy GB 4 & ae ons it 43 = a Me ae: 3 $4 SG gS Oo &4 AS st & ced aw 8 C3 € vet 43 ae} a S a a Ne ore} 3 Ks ord 2 G ou "4 Wh a "4 6% u a ot re ct 4 « © ro ord "3 w O te GS 4h AS (ih o : ; op 1} 6 va in 2S - ¢ ae aged Fe coy ot om 3 weed 2 ed ; fy ify wd ra eye} a © as t xa ' a rN to mt : . ors ty tr os MM wD y " we a . ws en a ' wo TC ct we fa oa iS 5 a Q % bd "4! OU © te a ne a Fg Qe car') © o o a ied ms + a a " ha z ry or 42 ms os wd xd _ a ® tbe rk 5 4 a os Ay a . a f "A o 9 3 BO Soom og os M i ips & #4 3 O ha Xo ' & D c aed qi © od ered a a 4) heck i Ao A ~ ord ae woh ard 8 . G a Pr 43 Md 3) be OS if } ted % fs ots Be i. te m7 wo oot ot got 6 ' se . oj " i on nd f 3 pis "3 "sg bed 1 eg tp ot a 34 : on - a 4 bed eed gt ts ted fa omy a) wet i 4 Js ng a iO thd aa ; rt cs @ 45 wnt Sa 4 ha o ej m ' 4 ct S 5 rh . a uy } Aa Ky fora edd gt ih is cn 3 soe] 44 bed
3 ity Ra iG bt fa bed ee ord . O @ rr om 4 Ue A ' : " 5 e "4 8 se ' " t we @ wed CF o 68 é be » @ 2 0 oho 1 oe bed A ip @o 4 os a ye 4 ; aed fc ey As ee af ot ip sd e hoy oe ae) Ld Sea oe rz 4 a Be me oy i seed Fae try * fey oy '4.5 B ores A red Qo Lo why we 4 3 he =o iy '2 . fed an 3 Swee Q os oad we rey av a - €) 4 3 BS me i ie " oS D 4 3 @ as Go in 4 a ce ai G O We Ep 2 oe i ia rs) 5s) iG Q 'Sp & in 4 3 . in + * on be a os rel 43 ~ ted Co w , 43 Je 3 im , C3 a oh o a) "4 4 a cy 4 a "| ct 3 reg. n i be, poet < me . o Lat ot 3 nf 6 iy 6) an be 2 "ed i e A cy 3 Pst Oy £5 4d ees 33 6 a v Q oa tes RB oA ' 3 x o iy i C4 Ls SS C Q oO £0 gD "pe ge me ned @ 43 44 ved Sh Oh: sel a cam 6 04 ny ne D ry Be w My 43 $i ee) teed i bt ' oy ® wy ee 4 oh Af a aD AS 3 {2 on it} tb ha Dp > iat cu a Ao c af te - Ks % Dds © ee a a ba % vd Ch cored 4 43 Qs sent we ve LA See FEEL 1"
ste he SS aad ° yok aad Re gt had ae CE Rous ot % 2 "
L > s ae Ra red ee st z $ ee C £ ed x 4 % AY rot £ 7 oe We wa :
Fy itt 4 om @D Sut " Ne tan "t ot beg ra "
--
XD ny My 4 & ae , bey 4 I A "4 "3 O a o 7 .
a rn ty e DO OG G @ xn 2 PP B® ID ce mt a & rr 42 At ed et aed es Fre) cS iy i} 13 on ah thd ued By e i "4 ped oy + a i a t } i 44 : ; 0 ee e " + ~ oe BR we a rr er G gg & Oh ty o Cy Qh Oy a oof re Q va o lpg . -- : wed 4 bt m TS a 8) a ty ics) ht v wef iy we 'bed ey oP) es Pe we : D pa Ke , 2 4 D @ a Ae Mf oS iG Re Sg 4 CE eet @ fy Grd nd oO ee a ae , © 4 € 54 ss Q G ® ie rd Oo 4} i 44 a os bes few . 4 ca bed oe a a a bey an " aye qi bet ved a By hl bee a ¢ an thd «a Bot vy Gen = 3 Se $4 re my o i om " w ¢ ch Hi " ved Kat ng) Foe Oo tt "4 me 3 ~ Th O gs mt @ yo i oO cas on 4 ~ ' $ ort 4 bf 5 4) @ ct ot ce fp © FB G8 ne! iL on 3 , & " a 4a ci i m5 ues . $4 i sp $5 eG gy Pra, a4 ve 2 vet a = Fe o s a Po gg moe ve ao ay v4 o . et we @ ws am 4 a ts ¢ "hy w ce) i i a to "3 w Sits Soy ie } "rd a wy 3 a 4 ' -- 4 . wel . ° i , M $4 OE bed S os AG " x t 7 Ae " a <4 a be AS et Cy ey a a . , . fa @) * N st 2 D , a C oO | o 9 § a 8 GH Os ws ~ a Bry a i " sf eh, ree os th. vl @ ~ io al 13 4 4 g tn aa . os ie MS i 3 w i im on c a o eo» Dp © me © "4 ee @ © Mo Ek @ ee tos oC tO eed 1 © G ef © c v4 wa hed it * a] LS Bp 1 os ios ye nm ip el set cs é . 43 ws . " © ors . se Ba - we rd i Sis 3 63 $4 +4 & Seb a ah op fe "4 44 ~ Bed £4 i. GD " ~ o G wn et o fe o ai 6 $e . 3 " w th @ aq "4 "74 '3 A. ; 44 ci Shee} be "4 (> 8 0% "S o at i rt a ay hot ' nt ° 2 et vu "4 4g 93 . Sa oO r 3 ai be . A 4 * ry em ie EI oe 0, Go Boo & @ & . A&A 2 2 6 ©» A o@ MG 6° @ @ om fs 5 Cok al i a ™ w @ Q ro As A a5 ty G vd bg a; 4) a p we rae! a ws BS nN 63 o Pan TF cm tpt 4-4 4 Cy ry y m5 aes 62 che ona os G3 a a wD 4 Ly vd < cs @ @ i we ro ae} ; : ua Rie com hes xa fea] ray i} gered Near od 2 4 tf + ' 44 ay Oo kK, 74 on a we aa a 4-4 hd re: ais a +e) (ih aa) oy es AS c ' thes ch fo mn ny w a wd ml 4s Ls a " wed a O o 4 ee * ue as $3 xo 4 by Say ta a bate x, uy my ryt ah aa et 4 M4 iB ES © 4 $3 ed » GO & @ 4 Oo Aes Jeo " 4a wy , "
é O me , 2 mw & 9 _ a ! &3 ved a ay oy cho tl . 1 cs a as ap Oh 4 id ~ 4, . * A ch het tf od le a ws . Sa o ro) 3 2 or ; oj * s % be 4 Boos ' 6 3 '. 2 oo : e " , thy ded TY weed o es ; + bd ' » td ~ co . thy eo os oh ae 2, aed wg "ft tha st 4 uw £49] i iy vn co / '3 yd © re "4 is a . ref " a 7 " 5 "gd ant med Gt c Lhd . ' : ' co et ar a 4 ted m rm et weed co ey hdd . 03 ' ead cc 4 > 4 rae 4.3 poee $4 my aK ari _ Gs es A ved "et nf i" i? A wy Soy wy . , , ont $3 oy 3 £3 O "er ue ot sa { 2 " | Pp "a ® < 5 8 8 8 g 8 qi ing a} %) a ct Ly G ae, def Cc ran vee @ at O os ~ 3 Oo a Mes 5 wt * on La sind spe " ey nbd , ne Of wi cr = de.
Ey Q oN Ne.
3oe 3 hy bo Oo «td al 4 oe C3 © Q 4 " #9 SA Ss a ; 4 wis , bet on v3 " en tee it ® mn a aa At 9) a9 on a) kel a is B hd a } 3 QO A oO uy en pet 'B oA vs 03 es aged oa * A be4 GP hy oo da a oy hes 43 od y M4 w 3.) age um Pa cS et ct ts a) @ he ee ' 1) eG ft bel iD 44 0 hot oe Ch a id a £r . @ eo a a oe oh $4 O Oo 4 59 65 4d iy i gs oy oy 44 wok ' a ee * Mee f coped uy 4 42 Fel a . Ned w w a x. 43 a ops a wy bed , o £ "ff o by x a ot «5 c iw es a coy % $3 CC} 2 43 an mA os or} vod ie C3 ge & ve ro 42 1 a sept co} om Aa et Q qa 5 or ot * "A . A ord 4 _. w uy ed 3 0 v > te og . o } ™ fs i * be i vl we is af Z ". es a aR @ 3 4 ey ig TM ot as 4 hes pe ' a beep on U4 oo , 4 be? ip Cj . a ms 4 St m te Me Q x te a cy ~, uPy a oS - cr ci Ci wa ted ed : ot ind rt Sad at eet soy o ss - Sf i ued £5 ee vet ea 7 co a ee 0 "a pg is so wy oe TS wn fe wyt oD sy 0 oe Q ea 4 @ ° why SD ow QO RD ef OR oh, o 5 CG 4 "ye ae Cx oH 4d he bet al bef ea o 5 oi A x ve Das } : 5 o b a te i na & es @ , ~ es a i, GO fot. o im OG yt G Oa Wet Bbw vy AE ory e % cS 4 . wD . oO f & pb 44 43 sy bs "ed evi ig at w "4 : HY i z " a * ' : - ° ne ' a % G © yop & wm 5 sy 4 1D ay 6) v4 @ a 5) oh, rd ; a "6 af ia 3 = . i ae CG ond cod * ce oS Ace ne Cy ef BS cy & we ; ed O m % no ti a rs £ t « O O, 7 St 3 O 4 ae re c3 6 Bog Co a Ss ¢ cs ty te i wD Ly sft C co ay ae 'at cs tt « QO 65) <i , : $28 - me ry . i a eis we iy ood seed mye "4 o is & ngs a ' wed "§ : ret a ved rel val cD os re ot fi Be Bd x3 a vet se. ' £3 E2 ant me, bed 6 , { rae co u 3 us o i 3 mE 4g rs Ch . ond rie oi S63 as ree a Od a ry my et ae ne ws "3 a ct at end * fat a hs ti , ci oS hs ' w oy i od «5 vy CG 4 Aa ow a) sO reese ee ef mg cA TB we . ss . a is m 0 Rh Be «i, $42 tL % Om ' $d. 2 iD ae "4 2 y a . @ ce cf , as ir Y rd sed st unt es 44 e4 4 "8 ares] wo cA s m4 so ~ et ce ~ GG oO Sve . Nee bf Pe ss © Be oor i 2 vi «i ~ 0 on z G ce) Oy waft ith =< fy oh 44 i ' ak ' : tae * a oO & of wm > ae 6 Sy i, ba 3 4 D i a4 a 1 o O i Oo a a) cs} oD w @ w i Pe, ee fis ms s ou £5 elt 1 Yet i.) ou 4 4 ae £3 Ne cK ac & 4 th: oo ' ed 4 - : Ah y "
id © we ry o oO g 4 3 4 44 qed 3 i .. ai ff os 4 oot foes MM ba sv WB ye ' i seh dey 5 4 * ss um oo " 4 . a =) be tf ma ide eA % % $4 a iB EM ao a be . A aa eg DY ta "| > eS i oO By $4 t ws Qa a 1S ge YO en as fe sj - $3 wo 3 0 het © a i. o 6 ~ 5 Ld "> daly aed te 4 ' a4 WS Sy sy seo one Hi es rey o ie) x cS iG Ys es 1 . a a Go 2 Bf s Hi ae i i3 me 'ed ip es a a £2, i o sy Wed sj oe @ j @ ie ay vied a % mo Sei " Be We . apd iD a get : "> yg st ® te a bia re Q my ; ; ua 3 oe 4.4 Me iG ot 4 po a . ip uy cy ra ¢ } ries i _ 43 cy '4 iB $24 ~ werk e4 3 at +e i) we i os a ed a 4 eh ot th Ye oh $a os a ied cs 4 he ay " of » v nt A * G "4 ahs - a iy oF ved 3 wy i we ae iS ' 33 3 - i ft bi 4 es i @ a oe wy 4 B one ga $4 be, 3 ape
5 o on B GS a e A ps rt wo be on Q ie ba a a5 0 eh oa ¢ Sy £ 4 ne * '4 44 "
fg 5 S v a © at 3 8 g) 3 B AL MU ey ' he "4 we St = m ae mst Nee VT i 24, oe * ak * fd Ch i LE os me 4 ved rast io RAS Sn RAR i ye , " ret t mW yn "4 , i ; iy ne CS & ev 8 Ue cs ie , ra ee is } QB @ Me mu " 4 * o, " eo io ° 3 $3 © " 4-3 Er a ify 4d fea wy wed Aad ' a eS G u a} bd m4 4 omy ceed or 43) Y 4A sy ws * oO vel it fh oo @ ey 2 fh ea 5 . Che Sda 1G ae wea i) iy m > ad sy, 5, 44 £9 v3 A ih "£3 * wt hed ty wa MS aa a i : "rf os $ oh eof it ce) "4 "eA 5 cs cy cy M2 ¢ i ue La 5 ee "6 "4 a x ust 4 iB Me yar td Oy a +d oo 13 "3 wo is ' o o a ra ot 4 rd > a s S 2 Ph .
2, Fo tmot Nae RA Na?
2& oy at ae ~ q 4 ad 43 Ma ms ee a ce oa ~~ * iG a Cc @B 4 a us - (3 4 @ ar it ro a a (3 Set a sed ny gt @ co o i At % y hee feel oy a * thet La Oo Oo XS ay i bs : Ms 3 4) a ved a io} ras "4 ¢ ml 13 vd © honey %, co "
Ne - " "i cf mo ced - os pied 4 yee a bea iD "h} . A 43 eo oe 43 @ O es tA " mR we Bay U3 C a: Ah 3 $4 Se w tet : hi y m4 fs i a) mt um is od a ved Ys a ra 26) a ee 4 O ven Ee bd 63 ws p ct ° ~ OG ee 44 a4 3 "4 ks hb oot eB E O A re 4 o eo 4 ® a Q it ea "a fs w Si *% eed oh 4b von od . ie A x ae at o - " es y Re « 42 ay Dh. 4 So
"4 od bef . <3 Bort ro 4 eo a i a3 A + % th e 2) bd 44 yoo ' x 4d O @ Fe 4 is " 3 a 3 O {2 fel ae ee on _f * 2 ms 2aS wre oN t Vt ss 2 gory ee ee { a .
Pye S a :
4s ue € z TaN uy Ses G * 3 ¥ 7 4 af art yh ws R2aN4 ve abe Lx 3 ne te a A e ¢ j 4 > Mai §
--P at oo a C3 fha Nt Tak ate ' ss oo * 4 4 -
iB cS as ky 7 te mt a ce ° st - ed ise rad 6 cm ord ch 3 43 a sed is $e ca Ch c o :
ra} w a & ae es aa 4d aa gt eR i mH i 3 ud w " end a i i . a i 'fad * ft S 3 wpe i ; 42 4 & "4 Pd sf 'a as oj © ' co 2 6 § @ 2g é m Bg os oa i £, ? "rl ras 64 ed oh gs " ry i at i wm ett 3 f % aged E, by wa td ned i wn i ci @ ae me é .. he 4 4 cy @ a w bel oi q) 7 ves Lee rs ' : ed et "eh 43 " "ea mi a) vt os m sa "3 oh, 5.4 Aad wt a a
4) ~ ie Qf a Fs8] vs m3 c ; wg 5d a a roe 1 A 4 apf pet o & fl vf 18 "4 , * 2 uy oy * ed @ i key oS 'Zh y 4 wa te vod i 3 B so oe bg ie AS Le, a ci a i a a fs uy " nf ro me . "of an 3 ig i wee oe) te ' ood Um) OS ' is ; a i @ "A a) ba aes aye a ty et wet 2 a @ ei @ fy 3 3 r u we yok ried Gi, 4. t 3 La 4 is 4 wo a wy c ' y _ 43 x he a os ~ CP oy ve a SA ryt wy Ch Oo TR he 4 ss a) ans 3 oo" hed ee 'Dp 4 es a k $3 ae rs ist 3 4D a 53 ty 43 s aw ws om ers a a) bed bef by ot % rt @ 43 4 : wD re os oh, en ce th wi SG B oy a) o <3 af 2 good} bee Oh ae) ref , ' cy oS aA 1 (2 0% i fi cnt ~ et i jet & The we re re te) a 4 eg cA *y bes rs fr, eC ' t} Cy i! "4 ms a Sh ws Me S ry os rea 8 & SA = ip As eG wee .
ony bet we 4 a iF ha £ hs the Fe cS o ge red i Ly fod ' ig 4 4 na sr eet C ' ha "a Unt 8 " .
: é og tp won a a) "ene oy 2 ea wes 4.3 on od hh ern yi a ;
6 4 che. re wat gt hee : ~ ae es 4 Oo AY ot 14 & "% " a rt i on sf oy 4 4 ; m ud ib eens w * fo e "3 qs 6 ssf 4 O a3 Us D "3 a) ° * es .. ;
ee gr 4 7 Gs * ts ht i 5 a 2 ve ua a a Be - LL * NA oo et 4 weg 3 ay ve a 7 o a3 te vee a ; a Md @ a « CS on w ' ts a Ma . UR ff G '4 4 a es i 6 CO "A ee ce As wt oS 5 Me ; £4 cece 42 Y b4 a4 a he i Pa CF : a3 ny 1s my oo hed . cy a & i ot , * "f a vad 43) ft feed Any O x . a i cy eof Ot a3 re - "4 ' eh we 0 @ 64 w ae t z * - w3 x nt ord we 3 V ery . af} An. ft ' m 1% Aa $ Wo hh 3 4. £3 i) «Ss i} 43 "hs ed vee " Beda tbe. eet a4 < os % c 5 i 4 8 ip ay y 3 is é (es . Ad wed Le 6 ord 43 s " "4 AS eo 3 Wy ; a oa va iz a : tS * 0 . foods ng ey fe ea - » "a u ot ms
-- itp 3 Ab = ora : fh a mg xs : ty £2 ay wt ats 3 be "Th 4 aa } Ad . 2 Co 5) 43 pe 4 Aed Ad OO 43 ms rl 33 th ca iB et Ag 5 oD ;
8) es 0 Ms veyed a + hy 5 set on 64 i 9 ved is : 3 : oN = de 4.3 q ond ms 4 o 7 eo bd ey tL ~ os pete bent y ais C € e 2 6 G hm 6 . e-} v z i +t iit wD M4 . aU 8 a ey the ce ol 4 wet fo so : i 4 a -4 feed tf Oo US © 2 O, @ ao Qe eh i o | a . rh "sy a fee oa © 3 Ws o S51 ut fo reed te ce @ wu oe me is t Ren + et x
- i et 4 oho?
«es 4 gs ay we wey ae ad {Xa y bed eo 23 . Q a bet a jet @ o c 8 i> QB yet i 4 Q $4 ed C3 ra) aa "
3 we oo} @ te a © ; : ha 4) / ? £y 5. an 14 Me rae Ls Y ag ¢ a3 . :
e Ou "3 C od ie on a oy ay x3 3 od tS * G 2 'i % mS a et La nm fr "ap ¢ ce tis werd oe + %. we wn ? : ; $5 : Oy te oh 330) 3 £% OY A LILLE OUTIL UTL LLL LE e T of Le 4 4 ba 6 ers an mi x"
t GN a Re hee 5, a Re SA 3
3.
"ok fA aA a nt SANA.
of a oe } es of A. sc de ad "
AR WA et a Se 4h, 4g £ ¥ x of ro Seer Ke ae, or ae Net x ~ as o No x % SHY ae a "tr £ ¢ S @ f.
wy Tee ke AS ae = a
5. j 3 = vs y a 7 3 ROA fy OA No.2 LO 003 98/2 at rt ot o ae ay KS &es t ye oi 6S hl 0% cn mS by 0 ce vet ig ved 44 ted a ved "r4 4 ow C cord iD 9 6S bd oO os a ee es ; 42 th uy ASS nye Meg cad 4 ~t iis Mey > Jd
a) ert sh ot oi 3 it G) 43 " fee hs "set ce re eS i me od wd a orf ~ 1 hi fos ad 4 DY = yp Da iso! i " « wed by ba a Os 4A cs peed 3 ty "yi ti oe ty "d tt © o vd @ Oo rm) Q od C3 <4 qi so @ 4 a iA or Sef ord 63 Dp w Ld ba "
. a Sy 2 a & . ~ os La £3 mt a 4 o '¢ 7 ws oY ns «Ds "et » "5 a " > os wD "3 bd v 0 a cS 0 ts ts wa hh 3 Th ef a ered hel i} q) 163) ° £4 4} bf : rt c oA b2 ty bd A it v4 fs gy ~ si ob Xe gS a6 aw ed 2 r} ea @ m di re ted ; wd eS oY Nea ake cs mh SD "ef 'ot a mw a 8 ' Civil Appeal ve . . a tts or - GS % ie w © cS 5 ha Q o Se ip Sy 53 a "3 a: #) % : a B 4 3 Q © 4 2 O ra "4 a Oy 2 ci b4 ity o ae _ ¢ Og, GH me EG a S . @ 4 % ge Hh set My © C t 4 8 Q pees = ' . * ne oe : Es 3 ey a 2 Hoo ge ge £2 thay et ig w wD G3 cs ae ne te 44
- 9 Sg 8 Be 3 SF gg FS & »w in vn wo wo OF As | A se w os fe "4 oF gy BS odo @ 6 oO @ ist re) 0, werd of rm SAN a abe iin:
iWhite Washer) Ni ZC TEES State of Punjab & Others Vs. oF 2014 arising out of SLP {C) 8 £ ef 2012.
e ti } 2 0 o x
- G ip tet . oO ' a eg a ay nm ie 43 td wed "a Cr oD ™ bel O Ch ip w 3 3 "S ed uy Oo . © 44 yd Cc ™ es ied ee, be $4 x y mm ee ' an Ww AS poe Tt.
under:
Nah A Na ae Ae Mt a on =i Ba i FOVEITUTIERI i Pen se € of th @ as under:
ment of indi f xe.
© the UF S of ov Sea ray aN YY mr < ae U ah YS Mo SAR Pe:
g os ran ah ni 3 fon of pens arnt APE > 3 :
* mavinent fo al Yk gS 2 evs LQUTEC oN} oe ES ~ Pt retirement of tar ™ L 04 dee Kal ake OPUies, x Q OR ie AT x abot ap gy a3 a ef q Le >.
z O0 ic rea = < 2 at m is d 1 ay os pd x A ing Au oranduy Via ape ae \ C ey ARLE x it ~ :
£ Ded in F reporting r A Roos 700 dated 4° Au eanchon Q Men o rom chek Lo Fa fed netio £ a Ple ef 4 7 OS fron
4.
paid DOTSTOT x ie iss EE G3 Sh cad 3 5 2 2 ov, Tre its th Sep fa ee Lee ng Auth i ", ¢ eel coed " 43 os ws ut Ea) ng n> 'ood i & oS) boot " a ted rt rhe g 4 ' - 4 42 ota : we oe D Ch O hd ; aed ht oe Q ~ a OR my , ws EM oD bm OR 5 ms a 'i rea ay vant $4 es ge a Om had ot MS xs ta ae 2 '2 i es aE oa 4 . ge ® 5 O © iD fe an a O $i 12 3 os ~ 4 "
a3 Ae Ge Sat ated ! *: wht - yd whe i" gi pened Sah oa be Ra 2 % ms t rat s aor rs i a ed fod Ai it} ey tj 4 fy 4 ae a 43 ip a | . : res my lng. wes i st ent tr oo "sy aw on CF ey Ts 4a hee 4d 'a af Leg iB wet . a 8 4 om & a3 ce be -- % © & w <e Oo MIS ne Bo go ie a a te ae e nr wo ye wpe a) fs , ved a egy. es oi O "S a "ed 4 Sand a es i; 3 ve " af SZ me ci er ee ot e eu bd * i a : 3 ms me, io m~ O & 0 1, bed ; £4 12 mt ; {2 o oy woe C3 od a She 44 Heys tig @ ed . 58) Swe co OMG Le vi FP Cet ~ es ey 3) 1 ont i ag wen fe een o ns 6 whe ae ries : a a eo he ua te Ee 4 w ua a sea ed OS wot Kt ok Y a ce " re oe Oa ce aS 4d we v a t 0 ow vet os "eS GS " ad oy Ey ved "4 ret y t " OQ wy 5 ond oa i ° "t es i} s jan ann t f 4 gy . od 4 bee! - G Pu i a eT or Of 8 5 ened fe " a) 2 4 ° gS Ore ga = nO eS UU c oe et ons aa TS OD oe a % i vet iS ia ot y Tet we ne 4.3 he i mt Ce tee Do 2 oO i ; D Cc om . © " c os ee ey a ph " 3 J ; i 4 ia 1 fo on, " j fe re) @ a a a ; sees i ded - L Aa by, F wv wa 4g ¥ wel a CS * ot wa ' ms Set ¢ , a ud a ° 42 o a e, Ae 'et '2 & a 3 Pe md As Ct s wy ths } Sue Bs yn Bs @ amo. a 4. on ; wes wy fis ee < s arr: , £& 8 a Y @ 3 yy ae steed ake ts oe im a O®8 <G eB i uw "Gm & @ % o g fa "88 a mn RR a 4 2 <4 " £3 ; eh ct ny rs SN ord . "
Bh ; et A Sea as Sx = Bort 8 . 4 a) a 4, : me hg . 2 es rd wa 43 . / go vt :
+ or a F ot 4S a3 ; C3 oa a j a re oO <0 Co OO 4S fh. se oO of ae ag @ 44 wed SS 43 ih m 69 3 ws to © 7 6 * ed " aa ect pee re 5 nae te %, a ae 5) ue wo BD w & a po & A 4 YU, tlle LULA LLLL OLE lle Pee nolan AASAAR LA * sey tN Say A. a ty AA SE y ah ci vy ae werd $y it at Nek.
x Tish atin ry 7 vrs TF oS S "
bee $ % c LULL LTT LULULTLOLLLULLTT TOE, v4 i ' sy ~ it a ed £ i 4 24 ref ca , @ ct it i Je A BO} ae oe 3 o bird a re s a) Bo OG od om yo A rod 4 a 4a KS « « mS bet D je ocd CG c " BD '4 0 43 U fd Bi ba 43 3 w@ 3 g ge Hy ad ~e ¢ vps 4d ; « 3 geo Au et 6 S 2 @ ot re eo Be G fn 3 i 5 13 Oh p 4) . cc os od O $4 oO oe . C% in : 7 Me oh ry ts i fs a 43 i . a ce Sed f 43 bes = be ag 3 a ra ie oS wy ee, a iO 4 Q a es oe p So Ga ta Ag May A & 04 oS CO KG ry 1 y 3 be so ret a) ~ / B Ge Oo © go 4 * nn 4 "3 £3 i207 " ve 8 tS a " O i 4 4 ord " i 7 Ee i ' 03 0 " 43 i by aed a @ uo <r " : 3 we : be a : é fa " - . . j i ~ A e eed 8 a a © € @ yO tA 4.3 are 4 08 : a La eh § uw . cs be oi a S Ss $3 th ore a gi a Ha a oy C3 Pa ~ 4 aD hl mi qt ot Q rect o hd of % ¢ ° "4 . hey La ; , Ch aa re Cy cP @ ba "a 6 ad CG 3 Q " a CS ' ~ 4, po oa ' . ih sie + on ™ eg r mo e Ze +4 ce) a O Q Pa Re, eo A a z 4 4 ~_ («OOF cs 3 ve © ke 2 5 - a @ i +s oo i Cone i, 4 % py _ vt x den 7 + Soe Ye ae as " n C 3 UU ve a y "3 ve Z 5 & \ 3 a o ® fe , am a ey a ya "
pk . = A 4 "rd ce 1 4 A werd ! aged a 43 Q io , rd ws bo rod ~ e ved 05 ny a Ct "es @ vl on ip 9) . 1 ao ae 67 o ed a '; i f 43 5 a ~ hy é " at "3 ca ed ts ae 2 mG a , 4 wv cs pa ei 5 4 ay ei re C w m8 o Ae + p 4-3 a ond us 245 f h4 3 & oO it U oe: rg ee ch = ee x aw 4 ce $4 68 c i os wd 4 jt ey 74 "od r 4 or el, a qs mn sed a > gt he 6a) be 4 . a a a 3 " a of & " Q ° SB nm Go Bo » KH @ G Wo eZ oO cl rd tre c 0 i a a @ ae is 4 a ue © 4 i 4) a £4 cA o 3 a © "st in rd Ny . ord ce a s £34 Ch 3 As vd 4d Dp 3 od * Q ct ac bs ne} 4} i uy 3 it Ch, 5 w a AG a 4 we Ww Cha re es a 3 @ G3 x ) 9, id a } ii) me is 3 tee «ts 40 Lt & B ty tH fo be gS en cs : & 2 oe ri a " rat ha ba "A co 3 o 6 aa co to o 4 ed is eka £4 43 Shed ib 44 vid 8 jet iY Xt ved . 3G ad 3 C jot had tc xo 4.3 pe 45 iB G Cy a5) hae! % b. % " . : : G Ma i "4 m * bog ap gs j ' @ a o c . es ta ton if) : os ee + oe 3 4 4 6 g on a) Se a gf 8 = z 4 a Hi oy * woe : eh ohn we a rl . AG M4 2 rm % x es ON gM TO a Ow by ms 7 gp O . iz. Boe tO ee op ae BS . & a 2 a mo Gs 6 gy oo we i @ 6 ~ Ad bea tee cf i ed v4 co ao wee] a 17 4 (4 eo ert m 4 he "4 " oe AR es " es ' e 3 D v eed rt yet $ Ct wh ue oh, gt ad Ad '4 wn ne Ma we " sed m4 , £3 my ~ * 4.3 g Sex ' b oO we ' 5 - \ Gs c Se o fs) oy 0° wo be B "4 @ h " Sa a te : 1B as. res . wy a bo m4 Aa vya mo # Th o i" "+ iY om a4 - ¥ on ¢ ott w 704 hy oo , Q) t geod a red ey LD ay G G ue ¢ u es € ee 43 7 6 4 ve 4 iD sre vd a 6 % o Aas i . M4 fe es i o ' ° i he . wed "4 t > oo 6B che * s
- tf.-} oD 2D ; 2 5 O , te : £ . ti 4 Be ES ne ge gy fia OP 6 3 . i * : . te a wed 24 4 mt = ra of iD - nr 5 * * m "5 SHY Ps ge Oo oO £3 a ei 0 id cy oS a 4 a "3 oy : A 2) i Ss KY 4 o " "7 hd ent ' fed a ' UY Sed ard cs OG :
3 co os aed 4 } 3 . aD uO as a ON bn nf re tes it uy KE Ma ° fa > Of © aS io ef "5 Dg BO Z '43 me O 4 42 a Wy So % Co Wo OG 8 ° Wo oa Go - © wu & @ 3 & & @ or : fy me Q3 ie Z wy O = bet B eg ib in gy a g sof yt $3 "rl ee re / * aed o a vel 3 bs qi ed ere} 5) Lt a4 . uy oF w weed o2 O ch seek Q3 th 3 ved 5 ios cs wD uy tf BS a fs "74 ce 3 "4 Oy x ~ wh wy i 3 fd 4 i 4D oa, e3 Oa 5 Be es 3 me Doe Rae rate Met xe ae 3 os Be
a) bt a 8G $4 p aa! sy oy bed $4 bt wy f. i is A ra) 3 §) ued 4 'B Oy G a bef 3 a q} th reed weed ot ped os Soy 43 a ip 2 Oh wd ae a a gh SS Be S 14 4 i th CG :
a SS 4 t oe re Le ws rat bf at ue ij wh 43 OD, ms 4 TH TRA o 3 Ao ay a Shed wy C t4 vega ' ip 6) ey oh oak bes ms Ba 4 ts 43 4 4 spd $ i eord iE iy % ' : ah. ny att at (3 5 o He ed C3 a ei eet on 4. aL a Fes) va ped . 0 wf at aD ost : ¥ ot on a an agent 'i sy Q) a om " Po et: a ty "i i re m et Gh 44 be a a oS * } ct ay ui 3 ee 4 i 4 q} x os oy i + bea 3B uA "OG 7 eo * go PRS Oo oe vA 4 Ne ry M4 ee o oo Q 6 4 wy a D Q e - ut > f '4 a x €C a a st . a7 DB vert red oh es © y ory ' cs Re a" we 8 ® wo 7 Bt ts a o At apd ~ 43 % @ vy Se . a . '4 é a re we © io ES 0 UD ®ylUlUOlUM BBs ! S 3 ra M4 ' na a ; at Zz x s a 36] " cs Th t ~. oe} ay M4 pied iy mo a cS G rea - i oA c ee $4 4d me cy iy . ai mx ith + i ' $3 % . zt ee . 4 " ras m4 bf a A 0 i we 44 i ° o " a a Gi fa 2) cy oO hf ay i oe 3 a a ~ Sh oi le ok 4 oO 2 wo > % ry by oy wD "s ; 7 i o wn he rt 9} Pd " i ; - BD Ly oe us ag m . thd 4 ag} ot Hed . ed yy. $34 4 @ fo G { ' in G 2 4 *5 " as a 3 a : i a C3 : e ' Aa os ms ty oe oq ' "we Ae fos Oy bef qd oS ra mse cs a TS uy gs @ ' @ 4 v4 . oh i} @ yal i rae "4 hy 4 4 e . a G wh gh OT o Bo oO go 8 2 ;
Q me th o Mt ct is Bo ye : ee oe id ° " ont " 4. "ft tee 4 {a 43 : oO thd £: +, fry ¢' o sed a3 med 4 ree] ry fe us ' A fe ge g t a :
i in C4, © red ~ wD iB i me sa Ss a OQ "a . bed wy i rt s ao in -s oh co) © : 3 fe MM 1G $a t.3 . £6 a oa é 4 @ © a id Cs QB sed $4 | } 5 hd bay oa : ~ a oat 4 ot a rd ard » a ; + 1) oy ped a 4 3 ew . oe @o BG we @ 3 a t : 3 ee af r i ' eat fit "4 be one oO ay C5 'hed m4 nd Od as «5 ; cg a 6 ' o te sy ' cht ef 44 zt ' AS u oc Ge 5 f sean © "3 om n ot "4 ie a cc he A gs fe ¢ e4 "4 'i pa wt re = Q iS "yO Cha hed at vot iA yp as nad 3 tA wD 44 3 ce 4 " 6 ie te : me aa + m , a m3 me "I ry Ox La oS 5 A Ch hy oy 40 io) ay 4 wd cK ve tot < et 4 44 its 4 oN w bet ma ed Py c is * Q 4
a) ~ 43 BD wae, . @ g B io Pe ™ a) co Boye +. rs ef be ® hi ed W @ "a a ® et aD rs . a qi c ad 4: " . "f T epee 5 gor vt ws ee! Ke sys C4 4h "4 sgt &, a 43 Mi a 44 © cS CO ~ ; O o, bet es S "4 oa re oS f '{ is ip os ms "ah ; 4 4 rf 2 n * ' 5 net " mee % OQ TP Bo tC oa O my OOK Q 4 a od 4 w 4 Ga oy we or BD a eg os 4 SY pe a t ast Tae ot m « 7 o u U Si grt fat ged NNN ae © » %
-
wm AA ANA
--
= a es SUVA oe ae xe nee a $ a oe, Hp i L
6. X y t
7. of on \ a f Ne 4 Print CREA ws ARG Trer 4 Bnet Nae ake NU i kt £ iD we fed ved pare 5 * wk ar gd ne os o oe tea soo YP POT WW 2 2, 4 a i 4 os 4 A a x Ties = x:
' NY KAA st i L ' + ss at sah o.
oot ee ee We t a + a x i ae ey _, ok Ne 4 ares 33 ¥ ra *% roy Ne = men Net ht Xf not wot % od POSS a Nat x = 3 3 4 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 4A ee a Re AS 5 ~ + £ g syst x SE te de Nee ue = oS eed o4 td a in cs) {3 ye a r hee 43 $e x ey cyt Re sint Sn?
= Chant @ as Py RPS Ce rnis et bod baw} f go ye Wee ihe oO * ~ SA Lae ae' yk ad eed te i te Se te Io 3 ry o MA ke t ia s oe che
--
ss i xr we a yan he ane 1 fa Pecor ea Oh we AR at uickink ely god dey Rw ?
ark Nat NAR wi 9, beef oF arf ce whet a} x Yes, 1
-
we ANE uy ed Fay, att yo beg Yee Tye a TesPbane ey 4 sikhia wee a See = ae Oo Aw ¥ ' N rot } We SARE YAS Nar ko a deed Bea wi ot <ed 43 ay wed bed SS Pears ro Pag ba rd 423 "4 raed $3 oy se nae ht 43 ~ Meet 43 HF ® < ef Sf 4g i Ri wy O KA ns ck Cr wo "A o wD hee gy ia a es £3 4 3 id ved B u3 ee ot 3 . ct 4 43 ct co 4 co ey i x ed « bed 6 4 cg Thy sm} a Qu a n eh ' w is O o vhs # " "et ; 5 oS o a we 3 a oe oO a ua '3 % 2 4 co rd G4 ot © a is iw At : O A oes ip < . vi fs 4 bed ae . ty , a Oo & 4 ey, a 4 : " @ . hy c " o ¢ is 4 3 ot Me tt UY woe : re a € 8 2 QD te A SS o WY $3 - a4 a : ct Gu o , + f 5 OO a i a . aye g Naat 2 otto i OT OE 4 wn bet a7 3 i Bag & ape oy, ci et 4 ned : ; - ge ae Le as ® ih cs iF Lo a} et te ce La ~~ * * SoS rs Bo Be BG ma os 43 "a O 4 - ee © wn | @ 6 a a os +4 B h bel rod a wy fot Oo te a a4 6 be 4 Bed $2, 3 Re er be "4 cA a me ba oo os 4 Q a 4 by 2 Ad ed eG ca ay "3 ' , 4.2 a] Sy i, a fe we 43 2 m Sef 4 w 45 Gr cos O sre} oe bea " 4 1 ( aS mo % 4 6 i Q on 3 i w o i & es 7 wee 4- = , et i w & 0 "hs, cs wi re \ 3 wed v @ g ed ' "bed Pe fe . ea : ; wD 1 4 ". we ip 4 een vg a3 2s ; bed 6] Ww Ae bf ws AS ' a "es 3 A @ Boy ge QA vet Mo oO ae Bh a ms Oo SS o 3 a) bs ° "6 sj a uy % zt ceed, % rat t ret 4 ard pepe wl 2 eS co e rd . 4 Oo o a ri G Qi « a st fe 4 Pa gt 2 Co BB G 8 Bow you a "5 O e wel ns: © O iS) oO "ef .
"1 A "4 is mS hs SS 42 ca ca vged a cS mm oon es a r eS & Rar "
AAs NE de a Qt at el D . i 1 as fon wv #5 wy ce) 3 C3 4 ws 53 . "ws "4 oH iS ad 6 i on ag O om @ he # oS mS @ Ja tug G ny Pa si oe a Ma i ory god ss K rd it BS vend ire} a oO an -- Th tee) mm o e oH my 4 on mk cone eden:
eee A SARA A y wpe! ee Sa Ne é Ray at ce re a} £ ¢ we bated SAS, ike sty NN are AS a ety oe RRL in A wee Toe ct BR sx = §, bot eye i mt ¢ IBALaLS seoeyry trative) .
ERIS A dst 2 éR, Fifaykuniar) weiher €.
Te i