Karnataka High Court
M/S. Diwan Bahadur S L Mathias And Sons., vs The State Of Karnataka on 13 July, 2010
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
Bench: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
. Efiffififié §«'&§;§ 1i§§§§§'R fi:.ETE€};E 2% Q?' '.!,'%£E §§I~3%?f£%'?E§§ <3? ?§§£m§§ TQ QE_;¥.é.3§§ TI-EB §€§§f':$}%? aamfa fl.$%;'£"E$ 23.29% '@295:
E? 5% Rfiifl £3 TEE 8? Tax yam mg fiifiiiiifisfi mg ?$%'TI€:£$§3§_H§§;.&_E3}f?¢E;u 3:333 mg agmmaF%fm% figsg ?Ef'fi%§2'§'S €jf:5C3?§.i:'E*§{G"-.A %%:§iz;as*% $'@§&; zfiaggéqs as *3 :::§s%a:§T?§::3%:m§a;3,% - $Q{§R? l§§z%§E Tifl F$§.zL€3_:;'f'Z: _ §Rfifig Efia §€:?;§fi@§":£$Ii" é? %+a§u5£ Ea}:
A. . .A _ ? V, :» **** §é€;§§i$§1§f- is §"" fi§%E§§ firm zzwriim the 'i:m:"'sm%;;a,§taa', _ ,;?, in fim amifivafigzz vzzsf 'tag piagxts §*,;.'-*11a V:;3g:§%§z?§f'2%§-éiam 3:' mmmeycéai E&; it 5% ' £53 a 'zzzfigr fifw Eiiargmmim Efaiue '2%;c %:;4."--_ 2: "Egg grsugéfzi $ §£§§fifig iiimfidfi 319} gaéfi ma} i.t?:di§&n3z% am: it 253 mfifiefi ciafimfisgzzit {ax $3: sfi" Evém Z%é+,E{%é3§ $21 fiza pagmham wié, inyiifi §Q?
fix am fiamfig. The Em ting afiffii 'rim': 33% fiiaaézmaiczz sf tax paid am': im gzzmémfi Q? 2233 assazizi §§§§E£,§3 fsr REM.
3 izéw ma $3f$§§ fmm fig asazigzzi :33 wsyszfia 23:1
- mmmfimimé ém £5 mg wrmfiggiéfie uzfiaf iléza §i?'€3"*é"§§?ii'3Z'}§ af 3% said fiat: E: :23
3. 3:»: §E'&:1i«:atm§3;§ 2% gums:
firfiztiiiéfifif aisizmiis that -- -129$' Em 'V at an agigzufimgfgi cf $3515 safi 23.6%: ma 5% 2mr"£fzm}t2.:r&1 aezztaifiaci iii' ' §:s:§ whizrh mafia as '£3;'i$ gfiatigimng ffigfimg; _ . é Q' er 352% mg 3% éeazgma' is £€e?=.t§ '£§&.z:§.;=a; ggw ' " ~ sz.®j€$ za fig gm: gfwzrzimi gr _. = .
; fixmgi 65.33% E§at§3;1§ Sri Qgnkafsfik hrilxxw is my mam " Expiamzm mg :9 sgmzazs. 332; »::§ :53 am: am, fszim peymmfiy Q?" Q fifmn afiw £3 3% Sari Veiilwafiszix a;?,;bmi;1:&:--A sf 131% afars-'$trafi&$§L'L»;§%::~§y;?si§§;3 3;E";§é%€'%;§m: the mié. fiat Ema mmmé .. 1,.
fszmar is 21:3": 33 is mat an
- $1; s%§E;' %E:::§ §@%.:§§;§:«&r :23 :29:
mg fiwlerg :2: is
- T a arzizitlmi; mg % «m §%§:'§§ $33. am éfiputs. in qummian; .
cezzzmai a§a§: gaihzzééig am: the fizfgazyfig éimiaiagz. in 'iém ca' aw mi 'Em ?E$'E"&TE; :23; gm 2;: smm Q? rawréafi ix gags zzagx ggsgg §.@*2:§ ga P5233 3; gm 2% apgaamzimz gm» am fasifi af i saga, fig amfimiig ilrzaét flag sag was V ~ m23s§@:'%§ 31:'; 'Elm zmzztwt 3:' fiezzimi Saéém "§'a.z§ fimi, Efififi <53? gm 3%: ahnfij. wag mg Qmmal HRH , 2 § e:mc::?m:}.,t ziizi rm: &Gfi%$.§.§': 32$ §§'€§vi$i:;r:§ 'E3 521% 2:3} mfi Sarszziarx QE 2} '?A $331 Efaziétmefifg a'%'mzj11:§%;:gsv§§;%'[ that fee m°m%"¥$.%a%2E mafia in 5? 31% See}. mm: 5%' tea; Hg %;;%:&%:...%i%?£:§";:g:¥2é"{',i?;§zwr aka; gram am mgmmfgc fisffzaég fizut it is swing £33915: :3; 5:-:*$1v1§é:é:';§,.§:g:' $3' 3% £3 xaigzw af fim §:m':r,ia$:;z:§.
éfifinitien f§.;::?%§::9§:};a.é@ $1? Eziréfiémufifexrai 8' " iiw " .'"
fin %§&§'2&if $5 the 'm my zmfim ihe grxmviisifim 3:32; gf am 33.32:: as: aavkzim mm W -V in rekfimz in my xwfi-smmé fimkr mmm K as: §a:s;3..'al§ mafia? $33 33%-«& act :51: E55 ' him fifazzfg' mfi gaafifi if: 2% mama :25 fiasizgassg §.:"1::}u&@ iiéw tax 23:2 33% $335 :33" gaa-3&3 is; his agemf: ' -T gméi Efifiéa fifl hiss F13 H. $§_§§§fiz?fi; to tha is abfiakiifily was % it fg heid ma aha 5 « -- -- :- as may 33% §2'+%$§é%& Ea <:@:fm érzgmi tax in sash far aycuittzrai § aha is 1:9 get my eraéit as s§%.:-@fi' 'V ;;." £~'73§§a§§<f kizg 129 my mtime fin éafimigtz 2%'; Q' {Em %mt: " ':6 Tizat {fig mfifisirger 23% Eaxzd 313 mi in sziiagufie ai BIL fig $3.3 irzpum in qumfiszzé far agaamfiezm ia a§$$ 3%: in éfzagutaa at §3:&a:i':r fisgfi by fim him He: fazriém V --' the amend gmwzzéent hag issused flw K fizz quwiimfz fsiawitg the gixgigmmi sf the 3, wfiééfiiééaa, far: um :22': m 3 filibfifififiififi {Ema 33 223% §.§°i§£3.i'.$ §:':;:<§;3,&$:i駧: ';*®:.zi:%éZ 3 what, game: ha Egg? fight 3f :3 fiméz tie gaégi jufigmsnt was gameé in a awe 2%.. far €$§§§§§&?a'§:fi§};. cg? get. as amzegam 393.? 3:32 Efafikatah, gm muxmi Fm' the gfiwrsaaig fizam we zm ., u £3'? £2: axeiufiégg aim am af . . - M §ii"%h;aé$.§%ci§@a&;;_" fg :4», fix im fiiéfiazwr mt ' mm" zltusriai G? tiiae ma am am mat " ., Vfilwwmfiazii, wimt Ea gm ffifiéfldfigéi 533.2 is: me at %sfi mg iézfi fi'£:£fin§m's V-§5iir&_?§§:z zas ;$;§mi¢ ' "" ' :3? smfier ihg saié flag wlzezts. {Em am Em é bg masafi hy fizz §*%§mfia:1% §%§i§,
13. Far 3}} tém afsrfiafi ardm Em iiabk ta fie qzzwiizafi mfi HEM.
£3 iauf? fér § q°s_:,aahm'é§ Ea: iém wm Effii aaitgmaiimlgz mm tlteat fig §e*£§s:2er fig ar::§t§.e& m ézzpixt; tax sraflit gr:
. , by fsfie aamzfi ' = ghfimimlgg mmgasrm 3&3 '7§'§a§V.%:$:}$:,1§-'§§;,a$'« V. ;&E §%g gfififianarfi &§$fi§é hi @5"§§ga5z wffira £53 saaanfi = V L' mm' 22;: waétitg $9: hm' ' ts mbsarséfi timt iixe gégafi mizsiaar 'ihe mfifimngfis _ -_-. flag saéé fiat i:1:i$§§:fi¢r:%§§§$_ "~-- E33; him eaxfier a:§::m~§§@1y° fiispaaad ail _ §:2s:;ig§$:*. as $29?' Sd/3, IUDGE