C Narasimha Murthy S/O Chikkanarasappa vs The Managing Director Ksrtc on 6 January, 2010

[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

C Narasimha Murthy S/O Chikkanarasappa vs The Managing Director Ksrtc on 6 January, 2010

_.K,S.R.T;--£:.. '

1N THE .1---HGH COURT (ADI? E'\'A.I1{NA'I}\KA, I"3AN(}AI,C).RE

I7)A"I"I3i.j) THIS '1'1"i}§ ()Ej'"' DAY OF JANUARY A'

1% E F0 R E,

THE HON"BE,I_~3 MR.(}I__§E5'}'E£--1E H. 1:31:i;1A%PP;«;_ V':  

MFA. N0. 574:; /2<)G4L_ [:I'»./1::\A'/')
BETWEEN: A  

C . Nara1.si1I11'1a M L] riTl"1y.

S / 0 . Chi}.<;kanarasappaE

Aged 29 years, -. V V'
R/at.'E'ha.i,1.ag1.1ni VEi}.;:1;.;§v.  
Kengeri Hobli, 1   2; 
Ba11ga.10r{--: S(.)1..1_t:h"-TEf21§;1Liv_1<;_. =  

Be1:1g__§e1i()re--   '  .     ...Appe{1a1'1i':

(By Sn' . H  (.1  '}nx£I..1\2'i')(fE"£v
AND: V' J V

'_1'hct M2T111;-;z.gi:'T1g £_Di.1,"(-:(:'£'c;ir. V

 1<fH. R:5ac'_£,  =

Sh 21:.j1ﬁ'1 i1[1ag__{ 31",' '   '

1321 1-3  1'(>r {z> ~ =.-- f  2'7. . . . Res p<)1'1cic-2 n t

 V' {By Slﬁ'{...VE?_§§i'1£i a(ll'1av. Ac1\.'<.)ce:1{.c)

 ..'?'fl;1is"§v;.£.E7.A.  §f'iEc=%cI 1,1_1'1ci<;t1" sec1i()1'1 .173 {1} of MV Act"

A   if-1'T1:: :_J'L,E.Ci2':___Z§}'}£'.'I'}f anti aw;'-11"c1 (.'E£1f4€?(i} 7.10.2003 passed in

j _ V.  -A/1:VC:.f§N().417/97 on t:l'1s:2 file of the I Add}. D131". and Sessions
  arid l'»/EAC'?'~II, I"%e11'1;g2'iI()1'<': R.um! Dist., E3ar1g'a1(:)2"c:. partiy

IV/%



21E!(>w111;'_2; :'.1'1L* c.f121i1'11 1')v%1'1'1t'>1'1 im' :_'(:m'1}.)v1'1sz1i:'i011 2:u"1d_.._svc>I<i1'3g

£.'1'1l"1'cl1}L'€'iI'1('1'1'1 of (..'<)1'1}pcr11se_1.i"i<>1'1.

'E'I"1j:e:5 M.f<'.A <t(>1ni11;__>j for l'1(72;11"i1'1;;; this day. i'.~§f1:C§' C3AL1§1'1€f1h_ééd£- 4_

tE'1(;= f'<)iIL')\xri1'1g;-- I  _

iyDGMENT 
'I'I'11's 'E£.[.');f)('&fI1 is <.¥1'z":.*t'1v{:% 22'1;;je.1--vi.1:1'}<~+.1'b ':.i1t-*V ] L1dg;11§;1'1i >;.1.Vi1iE:i 'a-1\4\~'a1'(iV.

("lateci 7--10«»2003. [)Z.lSSv(:-fffiv})y ' t:l:.1i3-"V._:"A/iE:X'Cri1'II,'VVEgEii'igE'1I(.)1'C. in

MVC.N'0.4'E7/1997.

2. By 1;}:1<*-._ i:_1f12p£;1;§.:'1c;;>{.1' }«L.1E'ivg{r1'1Vgj1T1{f' 211'1(;1 z1wa.1'd, the

'E"'1'1'bL11"1z-11 112155 ;;'1'i§1v1')'i'.L'€('~'..' Vtfi*;j'.:'1;:'iL"V1'1:s21i.'f,o1=1 of Rs.E-3,000/-- with

j111.t*1'<**S'! 2.11}, 6% 1230"'jé'i1,1_1"u.:1"1'1=. §;i'r.'.11:1"1' 1I'1(". dalv oi' f.)c1_i£'1'<":>11 till %'1I"1Eé.

('ﬁgure of 1:)e1y111c={%1«:I.1_§

 _£3";" . E"-}X;é_;;_,3*1*.igé\*c*('.i I);-* $111;-21, Ihc ;T1;_>pc-->lE;-M1: _}'12':1s f1"1c'.é(:1 this

ap p--r,:2:'t! c.1{1*;1  6:1-1. .l.=1"e-11'1<'Lr:1 1 <5? 1 :1 .

4. ..  i;_r'1 1')1"ic=-={'. 1.11_<==~_ f2u_.'1':~; 2211?; 1l"1a1' 011 778-1996., at about;

 7.433 v;,>.:.§"1_.. tin: ;=1ppc1l;:m1' and the <_:I':'l'1c=-*1's m;*1*t==-'.- t:';1_\='cr§li:'1;,;' in {fact

 -1_ 1f}'1(Tt1<ﬁ§1'-- I1'2.31'.}c-:'1" §.)g1e;11'i11;_g; E\Er">_¥{Aw()f?3---5f3I..3I'3 a1'1('l 4787 for I<.)aC1j1'1g_g

1/

 



21nd 1.1_:.1l0a(.1i1'1g{ {"110 I'i('L_'. !.')z1;_>;s.5. AI' 1.1'12'1E' time: 1'1ca11"
&Sz~1I1.11':'1z211"z1dz.1('1<.._)ddi g__g_'aI_v._ cm 1$2t1'1g;"'1_I<)1'<wK211lézlkapur21 road, the
K$R'l'C E31155 I)L:211'i1*y;__2; Nc).£\'A--() E ~--}'<'[--5f578 <%a_1m'~ at I'1igI1 sp_ccc.1 and

daslled ag21i1"1s1 LI'1c I":1"z=:1<'*I.<)1'--1"r2:':ilc1'. AS 2-: res1.1I'1. of '=*;:'.l:'1"a1if;'--_1116

[email protected]' 2.u"1d fin: <}1_]'1.c~1:<; s1:s.a1z=:1i11v(;§ i_11ju1'ies. ,"i:'--1'1c._é11j'pe1'J2:1'1't.

<_'~221i1'1'1cc:1 ('_'()1}1])L'1'1S&1{i(")I] <_.)!_' Rs. §.(.){.).U.{}Q,/.:_ . 'IlT'hc "".ii'--i7.1bafimgk i1as «

 

awe-11"(icc1 21 sum 01' Rs.8.()U(')/ w1'1l': i'i:"1tc¥r_(;?s?si{ ;:11T"6'M5/<11. ,p:=;r" 11fi'Lm1

from thv (:I21'Ic=r 01' pct_iI.i011 Iii] 111I(?.._'a~{,l'f.("? of 1")21yu*1e1'1f;-- Vw}\g;gg1"i€Ve€fi

by t;hat.. 1.IT1c: e'1ppe11a1_1"11,---_I'1a1sV.V-"§'i1.t§_§'}  '§_h1's é{p';9ee1I. seeliirag

t:1'}.1"1an c<:%1'11e1'11' .

E3.  'I"1"1Ci* A1t,v}i:.s;'1t1:_('~"e'_!A c':«:q1._'i"1='1.sv.! j3k_).::* I110 2.1.ppc==.1I21111 (.'()I'1[C1"1d£"d

malt'. t'!"1c: (~.('i11'._1 ;.j(%1"1s;a-;1'1.i<)":~1 ' .'?,\1\.i"-'L-1_I"(!c".(i3 by {"110 TI'i1II)l,11"I£--1I  I',oE1a1Iy

i1"1a(%c:quge-1{(*._. I"-{c=?r".._2 1V2'S<> .%;:1!")1'1'1i'11v(.l 3.11211 1_1'1c-' z1g:31.:)&=éI}2-11'1t. has

'i~,3vl.ES'I'&:"L} 1_>1C(§ iI1}:}1.:.1"j§/'«--._';.<) <:'tc1'\:'i<.ra.11 .sp1'1'.1<.>. r'ig111:. ()('.<ripii_a.! 1"(3g_{t(>1'3, 1"ig11.t.

(?n\_*'(,?'§';]f(.IV)"'\.'.."'." 1'vi'g;'!Vi_i';.._k1=1;.(.f€=:* _§()iEI§' z.1.1"1d 1'i;_§!.11. g,--_{I1.11..e;:I 1'c;%gi(')11 eu"1<:i in spite

of I1'J121.I", 'f116- 'l':*iI§11112'1} Ilaes a.\va1'cl<>(:! only 21 511111 of I:{s'.8,000/--,

 1{§i.2'111y iI'1EE£.(1('(}_112'E1C. I--10 21.130 s1,:bmitjIr:(:i, tlmt. {he

 'E71f.E%)L'a;'1;;1_1 1'1a.1..s: 1.'";_<.)t' a\*.=1u'('.ic('1 m1'1':].)c1'1szui<::>r'1 1.m('1<r1' 1;'l'"20 spe(._:.ifiC

 1"..<;a-.1'V('.1:a. f:L11"U'1.('I' Irv &51..z.}.)111iI'1'.m"i 1.11111 1!1<.: e;1.ppcI1211"1I. 11215 s;11ffL=.1*ed

L//.



§_)(".!'l'1'1&.i13(':'1'1l. (Ii.s;..1_biIi1y (}1"l'3E3'3?/£,» in 1"(-=*s;pc<_'1 u1"t:}'1c-r wI"1<.)1c bocily 21nd
in spitcx of II."1;.11.. tin' 'E"1"i}")1.:11aI has not'. 21\v2.11'€i.¢"<1T any

L'.()I'I'lpG11S£:11'i()I'} E:L:)w2'a.r'r:1.s loss of ;=m'1vr11'1_jcs of 1ii'{§~*~a,1i'1jg'1. __1t{of

fut"L.:1"c._>. EY£:1l"I"IiI'1g_?;S. I----Io. E'1'1L.r1'c-*i'm*c_ s1:E[):'1_'1_i1_1:c':d 1'liz.::11j__:1'i'E'.1VcV. =§.1ﬁ;p1.:gi'ic«d 

judg"111e'r111 arld e1we:1.1'('1 1'1<><_*(_:1s to };)(-* n'1(_)_('II'._i'i:c.c;l.L

6. As e1ggz1i1'a:sI 1I'1i:~a. V1.}..1_§~..V'1e-r;s11'1'1c;i ' .(VV'.(I)"'L.:1I T:'§4f:CT!vl"' '"1'b1' the

1'c5P01"1dc1'11_ s1.zij)11"1i1I:c(:I .1}'I&l{';"\"'{if-IHEi$\ '~»"37Ffi}'i'1'1i'i2t1--~ ~o§1"1 Il)1*(')P<-tr
cc.)11sic1<?raiio1'1 ('>f1;}'1<:* 1'1'1;.11'c:"1;ie111_T_'Mi  ;§:\>\»re1.:"cie(1 _jt.1st and
'1'ee1so1'1ab1c: L_:(')1"np_c1~iigajji.i01'§1' ;%1'(_ff.::i it dms not cal} fer
imcr'f'e'1'e1'1cc*.  ;'21'i':":'~:.:').:  1VI--'Le1i'. the appellz-1111 has

susliai1'1<;*(:I7,Q1'1I;y' Vi1V":Vij..a"t"n=':Ai'1:j>1i';f1;}'s:.. zmcl tI'1(:1.'ei'()1"ct, Thti,' '1'1'ib1111a1 .1'1as

'c1V-'\-"€1I'd€€-1 SE1-3}3&'1.1K'€;J11Vii\?¢"';1'1S?'-i§iQi;.'>'I:"1 GI" Rs.8.00(}/» and it d<)es.- not

 ((é1 11 f0 17.  E L:1"-{"c?1'c==%1 1  . __ _

»  .,vE".1"lE','_}r;""(""v g'*;.11'(>I'x.1IEy ('<_>11.<;i(.Ic*1"(*.(T1 the S[ibfi1iSSI(}I1S made

by tT1"'1:g~_ R--:"'("l1"1"If.ECT :{2(Vj,E.!H562} for lhc 1)a1"1ivs.

    W"_I

 8. " . ':'I'3~}'I(? p(:.Ji:1t. t.I':2'1.'£ e;1:'1's(rs f<}1'n1y cc)1'1si(T1e1'a1"i("n"1 is.

':i.~'-c1':}"1c1" llm '}'1"ib1_.11'1z"'i.I I"1;1.~:s 2;-'1wz:1"c'§<'*<"1 j1.::%;£_ a11'1d 1"('re1s(._3r'1aI1)Ie

% 'In31}'}pLr1:13;-1.t"i0I 1'?

L/,



9. I1 is I'('.I{'\'£.11l1 In 1m:'c.'. tlu: "I'1'i1.')u1'1z1.1 h;1..s aw:-11'<.ic:'.<.1
g'l(')I)2:-11 ('<>111;.)c=-:11saatinn of I--€:5.8.()(}()/ ii" has 1.'1<')f'. .;-i's.~;\g,-L?SS€:€i%h&

<t(>11'1pc1';s2':1tion 1_111c1c=r1' 111:: s[.)(..'("ili('. I'1(*a1_<:1§,-':1c<,é<is to 1:.>.c.r_4(:1<)1u-:1; V "

V.
I0. 'iI.'1'1c: 21 pp:-21.12'-11'1i. 212:.'-; s;1.1i"Ik-'1'(_:c'1...f =1_'1¢. - 
(1') C("1'\-"iCH1 .<.a}'Ji.1"1(=;: \vl'1i}').12:1_s1T1 i11_}u1.'y (L3f:v)' »IA(_.; 'iv « V V
[H] HaCI"1]()1(_)l'1.'1E1.. 1'i;;'h1_ ()('.('.'l'})i§2.1.:l>.1W§'ﬁi'()l'I,A.f.i},§)E1'i%.§.ji;"i.;"I§;._U$'l""Di  c'.111".', 
with 2--1b1'asi(_)1'"1 <)\«'c=:1' Hit' .<3I{AIL1}. 'X 2' {'.}1";;..

(iii) Abrasi<.).11 over E.I'1(;' l'l'§_'_','1'1i'€':,v'"CI151T()i§\':*l11Q'EiS'i},l'i1'].,£§ 1 C111. X 1 cm.

{iv} Ab1'2;:si011 belmx-'.:f{i;.c. 1'ig§.1'1{'.V1§_i:;:c*¢><'j0i'1 1..t; '  V

(V) '1'L=*mie o\'>j-m' %E*f:.;u-:« 1'i}_-~;1'1 'f'= gl 1.: if  er} ' rmm 1,

'1'hc-r E11IJ~{:J(?1'§E-11"]?I'}.'€'3H ,.1;71"'l+;v'11 11"(T*.z_1t'111c-.'.111_ 2.1.55 i11_1')a1:'.ic'11:' fmln

 "140. 2E5»-8~..1'\EV;-3§)£3 ei-:uT1(I 11hc:1"<,r21_I"t:6r1'_ frzllow up 1.]'L?([.1E'11'1C:'.11'i1.

3711C"?'i1'}:]i,1l'iCfr§. }f.1x'¢"t'~'..».-f('.. 1'c*sul!c<,'l in p:'._'.1'1'm'51110111': C1i.~s21I'3iii1y. The

'f"1'l'i.'ﬁ'§l~11V"}"£;1.1"  _g3<)}:3e2;1I mm1}')e1'1s:;1.1.i<')1"1 of Rs.&.§.()()()/~

\v1"1i(.rh.  i1'"1"21AC'1E.¥("l1.lE1ii'. 1--Iavilxaii 1'c'is;'§'<1.1'(.I £0 tihc-: 1'121t:L.11'(=? of i1'1j1,11':ie5:s,

-._V('3{:I'i'T,EiU.€}i1. ;I111c'1 112==11.111"c: of 1i'(?a31.I".i'1'1{'I"1i", in :'z:1_v ('c>1'2si(1cr:r<i.i vic?w__ 21.

 s1§=1I."1 ()f'"Rs:;.2(),G()(..)/---- w<_)1_1I:1 be 2-1 1':*z1s;(';1'12.11'3Iv 51.1111 1_4c.)\=va1'ds

 'i'1V:'jt,z1'i:->5. pe_1.i1'1 and s1.:£'f'e~1'i1'1§.;'.<; gum a('(_'(.)2'<'11'1'1g"ly. it is 2'I1\'\.='2El.'('§€;'.d.



(3

10. 'I."l'1cr '1'1'i¥:m11;=2'1_l l'1z1>:; not a\\==2_11'c.1<>c1 any ("ompc1'1sa.I.ior1

1('>\»\=';11"c1s 1'11v(.'1i(..'z.1l 2-:1'1d i1"'1c"i('E('11t'2:.l t"".-'{f.)('l1St".'~5. '1'I'1<_~. 2'1ppa:vI'1'2-1:1"t=t:,_T1215

IakLf11 1'1'c211'.n'1c=;'.11I z-Ls i1_1pe.:[i(~11t' i'I'0n1 7--8«- 19963 to 

tI'1c1'c:21ﬁ  1'(_)IIo\v up 1:_1'c-ten1"1'1c1'11.. '1"I"1C..,3113130]-i.é1i'1'1:'-Tljzajs"r'1'(2p(;sed~ _ "

tI'12--,11 ha-2 I'1e11:.~.:; S].)C"J'11 21 5511111 of I{s.25.()G()/é"'L.e.3Wz.i17(§s _1..:i'1r:;jcViiV{?e1IVV:Ai=:.1j1(i

iI'1('.I'(E(.'l'1'L"&-1] ex|_)cr11.9csa. i'}1.1I'. 1.1'1.c"1'{'_ iZ~;;._no (A:in(f1.4u1_1e1'v.1tai:1fy"=t:vi'tic?1ace;

in t'.1'1c=-r (ti1'('u1'1'1.s1a1'1<:c*s 0I'{l'1c=? (?21_s;L-;.:._...if 'wi.s_s"p.1*()1)C1"'E:<a_e;1yy'i11'ci 51 Sum

0.!' Rs. 10.000/~ 1.m\»';:«11'cis.: 11'i'c*t::1j~a"?2-1"IL_'2{'11&f;| iVi'1{}_i~c:Iér1T:~_t.z1I CXp(iE1'1!.-BUS iike

('.(">1'1\-'t'y2111(i"c, 1'1m.;1'i':::.1j1i1'1g  V;1'1"~:§ii _ '-a:.ifi~,1:_cr11'(:12m'v1'. (__*1"}.211"g;es and

 

2=1c'<':m'(lir'1gIy. i1 :..is ]:?".«.\.'\~'i'n3=:--::'iV--g-'.('i.-:_ V. 
1 1.  TIu:_ ;.1pp<-*iIV;§1I'1V(.['i«:.;_-iTs»..s.::.:E"E'm'<_'<:1 i11j111'y I10 ('L'.1"\.-'i('E€1I spilw.

1'i§§1'11. 0(%(_jip_it:2:'11 l."'("',f_>;.1lVV(")lv1,.V ..1'i;_{?1I A("'~'.\_.«'c.I:.)1'ow. 1'igl'1IT 1{.I1C'.'t" 'joi1'11. 2-11"1cI ri§§E"1'i:

:_f_5_,_jE'1:;vt,z1l  "-!T.I'.1n;:' I)<>(_'*'i't':5i' has (1('.p()s(_.'("I iI"1e11_ the 211':)peJIa1'1t', has

.<_:»'11"'1'Tpi*«;§<;?1V134;f:1*'11fi21.r*ic:111...dis;;1i'>i_1ii"}; 01' Li3£"3% in 1"<'-'4&5}')C(":1' of i"}:1e \-v1'1()le

' V?>(>(.E_\_?. A HIE: ap;:}) cj'=:I--'1'I[e11'11. I":-as; to suIT('.1' (1'I-S{'(.)1"1'1f()l't f:1[11"(>1_zg'I'1()L4'1t his

" C ,fii,¥_'_0."~ 1'-Ie1\~'1'1.'":vg___gj." 1'c:r;_{au"L_I 1.0 1_l'1c--'. 1'mI':1_m= of (ii:ss;1I.31Ii{y and the

tfii,s{_';.>i11»f'r'11'1. {[110 2.1[:.)}.:)€:lI;1I'1I'. 112m in siiiﬁ-"1'. 1'11 1'11}? ('.(.)I."1EI'~.;i(I(,'I't"('§ \J-'1'€w,

.:;"1'=:'~;.a..1:f;::"1 <3!" Rs.f.%('},{.)(_'J{)/ » m')21I<_'} Inc. :1 rt"2-1s(..)1"2.a;1%.i>Ic s'z.m'1 1(">\v2-1.'1'(_'Is

L/L



loss ('>I"2.1mc-r2T1i1i.(:.$s of life arlci c:ii..se1i)iI..i1.y arui 2.1<7(_to1"c:iing;j1_y, 1'1" is

2;-1\.m.:'(1cc'.i ,

I2. "['I1c:"c is no c-"\.»'id(:m.'(.r in .s.al'1<':>w 111311. 1T.'iA'«z_(." 2i_[:3;..)x(*.}T':11.1i"T is 

1.

.z1'1a}':)I.c;* to do a11':y worl-g. TE')m'<:.f<>1'0;'fit)"'('rr'm1.1:>euSgiigixgxa"(tan T e1\mr('fc-TI m\«v2_1r('is §<.).<5.<.si ml' !"1.11'111'v V(..'£-iI'l'11'l"L.EI___;'.'I'i;'.'._

13. The: 'i'.<){.a_1 ('(.)l11}.)(:?11Séi'?:§()11,' p2.iya.1_)ie lmnles to R-s.60,000/ -- arid 'l'.}'1£;' }IJ1'('?éi'}€_::i'1}.)' (21) 'I'<)\vz11"{.i.s pail"; azwrl SHl'f'f€i'*'i*i'i'l§-iﬁi _ 'Rs.20,000/-- {b} '1'c)\-va1"('Is l1'1C('1 221 1 .;i1 14.": i d (5 1- 1} .911 '~*'j1.;>, en 1 as ('.53 1.1' kc'-1 (r<)1'1x~'€?;§.%a.11 1;? (P .V i"1<.'.>=: 1 1'i)c:i',&V' a1H.(=r1c1e'11"11 (?'iv?1g1'1'ga:f;$ _ " " I:'{s.10._OOO/--

[(3] 'I'0w211'c1 % 10$ or ;n~§':";=a ..(_;m:'c~ Rs.:30. 000 / --

'I'(,)"[":'\ I , Rs . 60 , O00 / --

a _VA-.gjt':v:__>Vi'cl_iiji;.gE.jy'. the 21 ppm} 21E10wcrd an cf the ' V*i11'1pt_.1g:1_¢c'.1 _}':.2('1_§___I_;*41f:.;T1A€.1:1', 2»-mci e;1.wa1'c.i. pe;'1.s3s"»'(:%ci1 by f1'1c-r ']'rE_I31,.11T1a}, in "«.1'jV»-VP:/IE4?fN().4t»7/1.997. si'.2n"1<:'1s 1:":o<"ijf1'«:'c'i. f._§1"2:1:"11.i1{1g;," (tomp£31"i-:saE:i0n A(:')*E' §25V.'i*}.(')_.§E)()0/ A. :'.mst"(=3e-1(i <_.)1'Rs.8,()()()/~. with i1'1%€1'('.55f 2-1.1. 6% per ':{1:1.1'1:1.1.1*V12 fmm l:I"1(': <'l;1'i_L: oi' p<"i_it§r.'>1z til} fiat? dam-1 of 1'c2'.11'isz'2=1ii011.

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

C Narasimha Murthy S/O Chikkanarasappa vs The Managing Director Ksrtc on 6 January, 2010