Karnataka High Court
New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Smt A Prabhavathamma on 3 February, 2012
Author: Ravi Malimath
Bench: Ravi Malimath
BETWEEN: '
3% ?%"§E %%EQ%%i Ci§i§E?["? Q? %<£%§%'%A'?i3s§<§2 fix"? %;51%\i§A§..§R &
as; THE 3% my Q? i"'E§§U,&?$:' 2&2
"mg %%O?\i'§:E %'«'ER5§i}§TEC_E R§é2i:;'§'v§A%.E§¥§f§;??AE§" * V' '
§~€§§CELL;iaE3EQi%$ 92%? §PPEA%;§f§€}_.iV?%Z$8§'@«E:28$? EVE
?%ES€E:L£».§§EGi§S §ZR§T"?z??Ef%_;§-?€f}s}'i5':§3:7";?i-.,S? 2%? av:
' .
New Ema §§fss.::.';af'té.ce Csgfié-%:.'<j,%.§,'
§_vsg§o:':a§_ €:f§§;:é., %'.;:"::17:?::y__§;;2_§'§::€_;;*:g; ~
éanexeg, §3i<afE'ir2§;;_a R30 R§'a.d; _
§anga%<::§:e =+ 5£>G€:1.f7:'}'_' " '
S}; ifs fvéaféégegi '
,.,g%?§§é.Lé%'€"E'
{E35 §:i%-- €:33%«'%a§é'1&:§§a,' §§:ixs§::a1§'é}
&
s
.1,-. a
gww' -. I» gm?"
' V'$?:é:5é;--§s'a§?3'Ei%é%,§§"2§::'::":"23
'- §::,_}.$§ 5'§3§:.§%:A[:<é;'% gfiaafgg
%"'-§§'§ §--%;i<'§',.--.§:.:§f:':a§<a2' Raga
A £h%,;éiv%_i¥§:1a§%1:%*£am§?:%
Aggeé amagi :§ yeaygg
" ggg §3%é';,§"Sa;§§'§a§<,§%*
%<am.?;smy§%:r%s%2%2@
Agaé abgzgi 3'? yfiazg,
SE9 fi:.K,R,S:s§ha§<:§;" Qgas,
£2 A,K.R,Rama{:%*:ana{a Rae
Aged aéaazt S9 'gears;
S/9 éfiaihyanarayana éaa
S; Smt,La%<shmin3rasamma
Aged sheet E?' years?
Wis ;%.S3tgzana:*§\;a:3a Rag; _
3" Resgenfient Es minor by
m0{é1e:';'::zaiz:rai guarfiéan 15* ;fsc§_;;<'2_n'£%i.;e:zs:§
§§i Qjat ii2GE3g'4§. ~ 2
2." Maia Rgaéi 8*' Cress; _
éxiew Tewnf An5a';7:hag;;;:,:%é;;* . .
Anéhra ?radéSi*?;a.i-'
6. TeVenkates§2:§ia_faiu"'- » 4'
§Via3::3§'.;---S£,e"::Q'i §-I?:;§£_§<::».:§§e'd__g' "
R,fa%:,,?xie*158';":%*S§§. §:E4eg=:§4a'rsj: Eieasj,
.$.:":a§1:ha';}::;:§; §¥f'::'i;%':r;§ P_:j3z:ies§:., H.RE$?@§asa§:'\:T$
{By 3? S%2aV§r';L§g_a*%:'e:?é5:';', Aéxggcgie fgs' R:~«§.E=«abs&:2i
R§«§&:\:%:é} ' ' " "
fiéafi mags §§i:i:§::§': §1?3{::: 9% M2; £26:
5:§>3A%§":;<:%: i%:?ef§é.j§§§%r:a§2i gzzé gwazfi fiaieé 2853233? ggsggé
Ea §V%'%{§,?%}f;;§§.s§f§2 GS': {size fie :2? i§"'E€ 'T21 éafiééa =i§%%§ jéigégg
f€:E§L§§'§.:§ §'~%é€;'Z'§"} §§%'E§§§§§"€ R;:.§§a% Gégiréaéz 3a§ga%@a'e§
7a»:a§a§§%e§V._.3 €$§"3'!§€§'§S8i§§§'1 Q? Rg3§,§?;Q€:§%3§- aagéih mieregi @
..é.%'c; fram {Ewe éaig 9? ?;"§§i§§§fl§"% iii? reaiégaétiggzz
'~ % }
-. ;$;ET'f§EE?§:
xmmmm~m«.7mmw«.mmm.WwW..\.mm..'MM.
{$35 37?: G,§*?§%':és?2; édxgscate §QEF' R2,
?x§€.:2t§<::e is RE §§S§$§"%S€§ zsxsiii": vise {}?'{§€§' datgé 2i,:if.fi§..3_T E}
"E"'%'z%s Mfii £3 fiéeé smfier Sectim :?3.{.:f},._:;§f ..:ii:.:%: ' ..
agaéfisf: we Euégment arid award d::Ai=@:%4 28-;_6.2;Q§*?'4 §'23§--s§1ed7.
3': ?flvQaN$e3§4;lg2 an ihe fife sf1?:he_Z{T£§dd%."Cé'a:i§W;§gégw.§f
§§:'.Sr:.) am §'*:4AC'"f}. Bangaiere RI.i§"§? ?'.:>§Str§Cf;_VE--.3,r2ga"i§'r&,V"'
gartéy aiéemégég ihe e::§aE%"s2 p§:~:%'_§§:": 56;}: Ciamgézzézsgziégn ..§_3§'ss3E
seeking erzharzcement sf e:9mpe_:f_1$=a,_tian." . '-
These §'v'§jF;'%s mméng i::z:V_.f:>V%§"v--if3é§:fE::g ::?:§v3. €:«£§%';%'g; E323
Cfiiifi deiézgereé %:%1ef§§E€':'~%'.'%':";7.§:s' ~ V
2% ygasg ;_3§:é;~§ --':hs:33€::?f§;f.én§;.' is $%:%§% fiéféééfég,
it is ggieaiaaé i:V§'é'e accééerzt $5 3% ihe
338$?' *Z'a'%'«.'_.~"Vé5v1§ V838 :3 éégmse gff
*:%z€ {:§a%§:':"§2§"i*§t%£;:'2..V §~%§g§2 Saurig Size matter fig
iséfiééféfi E9' §4";é_;é§';*§; :§:m3§Ey K: 3% ES assays; Sims iéze
:.'j"V'§v:€§§;«3.y§§ tag. §'f_2:?2§ $92; izhé mas? ihéiéséa flave
5§:§a%,;;.é:?§A ,V;%';--§;§{;:¥§VE:;}_i.~ Ezgi giéfi $3133: §'§§%;'§ mi 3%: sees': {ha
§§":3§%:§._§if i%§ét:~§%':§'5§§§§§§2.
" Yéég gasg :::if fig £§§§§'§"':§%"%§§ $3 ihai: ¥'>£§"E€f'§ Eéée
-..é;f§§é;'aj35§é:.€ §§€;.::*:g éfiééfié hég faméégz :"'::em§%:'§ am §5%e§:§$ aasgfg
gmageémg in a £5? bgazérég NQ,é§?~G2~E§2§,, fité §?'§':f§.§_ ef
the CE? fireaze the vehiszée E3: a rash arsé aegiégefii
and §z\f§":%E'2 he game Saar iiamamamgaig 3;: i;°?fe%;§s2.jaT%'::é§"E%:§' ": "
Eafigaiare R336? the ériver East £9n:m:s§»..sf {fie §;'éTEéI,é:ié' afifi
éashed againgi: iéfie Scseter fi€3§"§!":§
reszsfé: af ihe afiiiiiéfiif the d€€5ea_§fi'ews:2f_ 5a3§.f;2i_:2e5§ é"%:"::té'§._ %':*:j':3r*'§eg
am S%.lCCL¥?'f"§§€§ E0 the Same; .é'--C§la%::% §e§':::viv9.r:..é'éE€é $32
$328 wife ané mimr iwa :;i?'§gi§§:'e5::_V€':§j:vééV§*%?.§»::~>';::::i::'*,>i': 15% Q? 37%
Mata? vghégigs :§::.; £:§";éV°?:'§V§};:.%25§'-,a~;;a';:::§Vé§ 3 gm": éf
Rg.:,,,9?!$a$,{s 4--'séQn§ ..::gfv§2'%;:.%_:ia:é:es:€ 5% ga. Quesiéenéng
§':§ §%§§§%i:%;.iii',§§:f§'%'s%§»:::,i<s'2&*'-jézagiérég*-~i.h.e"§§n§us"e§ has fiieé EVEFA
s»:a§:228i8,:2::Q2}'1=jj%.i*'§gf~J.TA:ga;;séam:g bavs fééeé géaa
?€% . 3; S§33j2§f3f§? 3:2§ :<.%_:":§_e:%§fé.as::&m§§:
"K *T'*E%='%15€.aré fizemiéafiéé Qgzmgei gig?' $338 %§%S§ii"Ei' gag?
<'é:x:.aé?;§§*2Ve'g;€.. "--f:..%;*s ':<gi$r§§. 7&8 iaamefi é;§:2;r:§€§ fa? 'zéée
' £§§%r*:9:s:2.ff:§_%.5?2*;v§E?fra»?én':.
x '$523 fig "§"§*E*§;::':a§ 5%5:'§i":§E§ {he §§§"§'§§€§"§SS%§@§'§ as
'~§-::§E£%§:é;§:-
Lass G? aréiiaai dégafiéemy R3, :gé2,,§§§;.~_§G
13:53 af CQ§°§SG§"iiL.im 3:9 ifséééééifif R3, m,,a5:.3$>.s:_§£3..%
Loss G? estate Rs. :£§;%;§33;?§:§§'{§
§_§SS Q? éeve 8; affeiéieéé :@ mégécg Ra
€J"i§§dT'%§'§ 'V "
F;§§'2e:a§ exgazses 8: i'§'3§"§S§1$§"'€5t§Q§§ ??;§;..:'
sf éeaé bQ§';!
'?s:§%
5* 'We '§":%§:..:§":3i 4:év'%:E'ée '%%.;abiii'i:'g 9;': 132%
§:2§:.g:°e% has: ésaéé afigiaara f:::i§L$'~§?L<;§.§ia?"2s%g*'§.; V" 'V
*1: ::§:;--:fé;';.de;:% ffss fi'}Siif&i"?t:€
£'$!§?§§?§§f _%;%':'?£"?:1§d::V_§§' V552 ifidemnffiz #25
;"§r::::" §_é7§;:j%.::2Qfé::§?~€;r§$':§gferf _* as zzézere was rm
£§:z%3-r3g.e Vi2:>:f 5:25 51925 $35 £i{?{}'€;"'
$553 léf' 'ff»-;j;'S£~i>!:1§'::"t§;>¢§i.):"$¢ ?f?8 fi?Sé§f"§é'"§€€
»'2:§§"é%*?;;:%§;?;z }?§§, :§§E' ihggefi {:2 fgsa' mg? fizsfiéeaga
"f3::;.?§'."g;';*?§'éfff§f'¥£€ § 飧§:; is marked 3§ E/><.§: S}!
Zfffis frsgazragggs i:§§?'?;?§§?}z' fag
" . . ;:?"§:§5:£5u.%:;;iVAé::s$§§;f She c:§v@;*§s%§ gésef 3? :58 gficzfigyz
§::*éé§'v;%§§ aiéi§C:'§§$ 52% sezmg 5:35;' cmgiiiafig $2"
_ _éf2§é".;2;§§£§y§ ?;'*Q.é;%2 5&5 .§:?§a;;'5;'2Ce §§§é§;«; §§
v._ é;?}E§f $5232? $538 3§§é'ff}'"§§ €§§§§§§};' 5? éfzse gisfigégig
afgagg §+,:. '§'§':e ifismsg' figs 333$ §é.§§?E 92'
"gm.
Rs;,2~<§§;'~« éawsrags §§{'€{?'f§§£1:'??a E2/aegaf the
§f'}§Sf'€S§'€§ zsersfiaz? <23' we §f?Sé£f§§?€€ £G;'?2§§f?}/ 53:, _[
$53569' 5:? i'f?§ vziritéga géafeméaig. é§?er§~"'q~"SA';'. _ ' 5
zggéfiéag 9;? fegszs' is éefisve 3&5: ibere i'?Cf .
mszerage far {£33 acsupanfs :>f~»if2.eA
she gegggy: me Qetétiarséfs ;'§s9:»¥e.§
§£'§fQE?§bf8 f§€§§f§8??§"§ a;f2,=:'§:5 géfff ':2; £165 .a§*§:%e}r: _
sf we C73: §ear§:?§::"'~~. ;*s!a.,ri%'§?§{&';;?:a:i=é2;§
égmfiéefiigi, 55:23 C5; 2;": wag 'f;?:::;s":§§
wéizfz ffie seasafi §'a2§§'s;;:;?'§;:23j';%;é':§ ;::§iis:;x @253 5::
férgs 5: $18 {Ems §3€V'f§}1€~.V§t:%:;§€j€f?:;;'v ' "§'~§'.f'2j;é.:'--3efer§, 5
am 3;" SE36 'zsigggz.' 55%: 555:? §:='e§ease§
was C'Q.lr'iE*;i§'£3.§?i:'Kglififigféf'-:¥:5?_é'~.3:)Cé?§::;;§}' __??28f€fGi"E; She
sgcsfigga' =.%§e%5g5;§;;§<:£§;f2€ C§:?2p5:?;r is
giaags T's5%;:g{yV%i.:::e' g*%azs%sr:§,
':3, figé .§.e§':§:é§_ 'i§§j;a;:::§e§ fa? ihe érssurgr :§;sTE%§2§s
-.é;é@a§ i§:gf2;':§:sé§ "f\E,?C,j%,;_%f§¥:§ by thé '§":"§b:m§E ég ergayzaaagé
'fE7'§§aé*i§'§€--.§:;%é€;::srf maréqefi 5% E><,%§. is 3:": 3:3: §§?§£:;; W§°§§€:§E
égéa ?:'*:a;.,'°i:: s:5§*;%'%:j:-rV%;%"§§ éfzmaieg Q? 3 ggévaie 33$ 88 §G?§%%:"E§"%§§
'$23: $2 §%z;e %€§§*é?: 333% §§:°§.:§@:': Q? Exfiiig :r'%§§'i§§'§§§'% if ég
I .::%§§»a§%2:%@.;:*fa§$ 33 "'%::2§§§y gféai @;:*£%;}"" éiaeif $3 §:;§f%a:%§:3% is
*~%:§§§ ii $3 gs': 55:: §§§§€'g' aseé §";§'"%§ 35???? was me: a§:;§:" ihg
mxgate sag'. "§'%°:$ fénééng $5 {fie Frémnaé that the iF3$;§_§"Ef
$735 Qfffifiigfiéé {my the CQ"sf$§"§§%§ aheét sf Ehe §G§§C'y*'
game SQES mt éigciage the isrms am €<3;zdii§s:':és '
miécig is iherefgre srrsnesug, T%*1at_i:.%2e§s:s;:ré;f"2€.é§:eé" :"A§_{;:
éiscécsse the farms arid c<:m§§E%ensA"-Qf1A_A_9t%':é
§O€§ii"¥§E§"'1§ «~«E>:,§:; 5 gingie s%:9eAé_§"'§-»$V_ $uff%'::i§;::_§§V_%*i€';;i'§~§: "A33
3:3 a£t gaééay. £32 :$:*m$ m§_%jers$§5..?2:é§'":.€§§'eg 3:"; :§s@_3?;;,::i'A§m§;§t
Q?' the Sévigéaié gem: éf gqgaizaia
§a§3Ed £5': MFA ;:4eg;';:<i;§9:s;:;'§§{5;; :§w]:§=§V€3@,;Aéagaf mgggi
92% & iE9f:2:3§*''vf2ffiAA{'A§AAT?';;_ * %.;
Z ggaéfiv fig Séid sufimisgéen.
'fie }f:.§§T§:§§{=j§s'£* §§§;?'§'%§§ C§éé:'ES€tE§ %e:' 3:333
a§§€§ia:°:E:.. $3 :§é.3_§' sgm A::2%;a§A:":2§§g:g@:2§ 32:: 53: as $521; $5
a::%;: §§:s;§-§%:§:,A§:..«%*§35g[-éfféééfi at para 3? 33 §a§§@%s;s:w
__ AA vfeyy 9? :%?:9 aasffmriégffase
;ar{;:3::%;.,:;3€§;*23e;%§ af 555$ agex £331? Emiéizzg zzfiaé
AA ';-:5: gégasfigaéfiéfizfiaéaf ggggmggr 5;? g §§':'ALf§fa€* £3:
'3.9%:%§é° 5 éésiré §§;*2f;s; E55 f}As"E§?A§'?g rggsrfiea' £2; 592$
izibaagf 5533:' {IE5 §f}§§j£"§f"§€€ ggficy Egsggw' caxzesig
1.33% fzsbififgx fgfsigé an ffgg ff?S;2*f§:"3€€ csm;3a:"i2}; €3£:'§'E§?a'3§ $9 szgséafirzeé 5:35;' gcésréiagiyf if herefiy S81" asiéeg ""
8,. Henge, this $3 the §§§t€§'§.i'€t3.t§§§T'3§ f{';2..!Ef'8% érf:
ac: gslécy is gsmeraefi, it is :eie\;éant..'_'%s5[V s'a10":€_ 'i:§::a?cV éatére 901:3; énciufiiag the 35$' :¢<£v%'§§ié%,E!:f,:~A%*é._{3"'~:a.ze'§'e §§§€%§ ffi? {:%§"%$Eé8i'"§?§$§'E: ;.%:fefa%*§V.%%;é' -£§§"2%.§_§1e%é '§%:i:C§:;: '§"%1$ axtea: 52? gyemium ané ra§'r§'§;<:a%e_§é§*§ :%3 _§3€i"SG?%S wars iieariy §aea€§@:2§d }::.__t%3§ §§1%%§:.V_: ierminaiegsg usefi $52 the Se Qixségign Beach Ufiféfiii%":E~';§€i';é'.;M§£§%ES;if}.{fig'iéé '<::;3;*%.9é9r: §E&?2G, Excegi 3 géngie s$é3§%" §Q§§C';' has ms': baen §:"§§:5£@§k ";?:é%:::A:*% aégié.§'"ze;*af@r$ FEQEEE}? gamé is the "<;§::£§_::;':'§:§§§:_féfzat §%i7?g:=«g.:___§__§_§{.::: wag ii': farce 5: '$23 i:%:r::§ 9;? 35% "a:z:V%§'g-:3:~§:'§§%:'éi"':<;2;€§§ '§§'?% :°§3$<: am iaéfiéa. ihé mgarafice £€2§%*é1§'.:2§:y é§ E7%j$E7%§§ ia aatiafy 32% aways? '§%'s§ £§E"Ei€{'%§%%¥'2 5 _ fiéé %@§:2..§a€<._i§:a?: E%Z3§\§. Etgsif fig gagfféiéegéi 31:: £§\:'E§" %%;§ %§'EE§§'€ I ~5a§€V%%§Azas§2§:§§ge méggiaceé. fiaiézimg §réa%€§:i§§ :§*:§ §%'"§$i§?§? gxaéggiag {fie ggiéay, Eager: égfase ms Cami 3233 ,¢.:_:,.
ifigy €Gi.§§§ §"1§%i€ gaséasaaii it, "%"%2e:; ééava 22$: flame sé, éérééer {Ease aércumfiiancesf ihe :§§¥"§é%%1.§ §'€£§%'§E§ '§'r%b:3r:a§ in fc%$ti§:g iéie iiabiiéty $2"; $33 §.*";s:,ss*§.:'3V_ .§%'*f' §§'%§ grouaé assigneé by it are just §;:é_J:i§a_$an2'_>§§'é"é:;d""§GES '4 net Caii fag' any énterfereréia 2:"-*xff:,z::'§z'é%.a'f:g~%\§', mgzzaagsaa? is iéaéie is he :§'i$ rn..§$3eé;v-
E 5:; far 53 C§r:fi':k<=:_:*:3&:ii§. §':'VA._;::§rs:grn'é§;;"*:i*é'$ ciaém is iiréat me deceasgfi was daie Q? iha accfifieni: anfi §.5:f__é:"';;a§1;:Vrk%%§g =i$:':~:'.' :a ".%%i§':§¥S=.3;f€:§!"éS€¥'§iZa':§'>.i€ am gaming V'§.?§jv@':"%»<§r§§ as a fléfi time SLl§§§"\5§SGi" at'i'%é:»,::~E§§%:':§§'~§§2,::at§é:"z Ceniré Efid getting 3 mamihég §;§§3s'g; fiensei £2 3&1 éze was aamirzg -asasnré Qpf %%37;:,5$£SQ5;f~ The gaiary £8%"i%fi$§%;f% 3% §:s~:._j?'§' 325$} Saga Q%'§é§€€§§ The Tgiéunai agaagrzsd 31% :':®@:*2.T%;§':%¥;vv..§§3§:§s%?i§€;%,V.§§ 3% é&{:§ag€§ at %;$;E,3§$;'v §:2§ _ afief-44..§e§:i;'::?:Ai.;<:§ :53" i<}'::'\?3%"é§ Eerfiaygai a>::§€§%s§3 552% E? '"-- §§§;Eégm§'=.-'3 m:.;%i:i§%%e§ :3? ':31 aggagafi iihe éggs gs? '§-é§a::*:§e§%e::; 3: R§3_§§2g§§§;a "Reg $§i§":"§S :§§<§:'2 3&3! 1:138 * -figfébmgi iaéwarég 3% §":'§S%"§'£§"'§§¥ %§'E£C:¥°§"%% as %'\£€I§ ag mzgéiigééer \V« ?§§§'i€;?.'_§}§ E:s:;ae:§§é;i;..E5;é9:s"§§'ég§%?§a%:%§:2 R3, éezgé §;1{)§§<=Tz ----------
wgggm is jag: am gzaggs' aszé me %¥'%E':%%"f€5'€§'3§:E $3 gaiiefi far :33 tfiég iaeafi. S§ §a§' as $33 @f §§'a:'% am affaiisyz is asncéraeéf-.._:3 ~.._vV sum §§ §s.i§;€3€:§;'3» is awasdeé far 32% EWG m%i_A§%§.' same ég enharsceé :9 §§.2G;Q§§/!"'_g'. ,_f§ew3%{:'§* ::V§1§$:: '4 cgnsastiumg a Sam: 9%' Rggfaafiflfi/» is é:v§a;§$e§§ gnhaaceé is Rs;2S,§SG!»~§ ThéT_;al':':;e:.;rz*:is» :§:j:a::tf':%;d¥A'~ifi_:;m:.aVVré:is % $83': $3 32% hsadg are gags: am :f,e.3§sfA'::.::ai~<b_V%§ a::§i»;d;_G 3353i aslé far ézsterferaate. Ca:2$e§'u:3;2%§§;__ f;%%fahé"§€;::_;r3}£E%-.»:®::%§9§'a$at§@:: gtanés 33 §sE§e2g::3:;< ' "
1,,§2g®Q§==$® 2S;£3§G~GG Z'.§G§G§G--i}G 2@,G$§~§§ Less 9:' depe§:a1§:-*=;;<:__ci1v4....I;T_ " f R3, 3355 sf c§:;:;§art§i;';:§.:_:%:_e v:§__é~<>§é§.' ~ Rs, mss 9% :;3S§at;é"7![_.. _ . Rs' £333 a? ifiasg 8: §af%feC:%:s.:f:"'%;§} :ar§;§.. R3; mm? Chéid":-°§:'2= ' ' .
"" gag? 2;22;3§$»;::§ §%*%§'r?$g*«:_§*a§§g§;E§;'%3£2§§? ég gariéy aéiégzszsgfi, "E315 amaami ":§?' V:§%Q£s§:2§a::$n gizgseés E?'%§'":§§"'tC§§ mg 3 '§%_§§"§§"s§? 523:: $5 '*-..ff §.g§j;2$§§§$;« {§.g.2§22;§$§~§§ »- Rsi;§Z§%§-QSZ'; am §:
ghaif cams érzterest Qt: €i>% gag 'iéie €§'E§'3a%?C§§ C€}f"fi§E@?¥S§§§QE3 3333;? fie gzaéd w§%:%:§:: a gerisé :35 8 ?fii€S§<:§ fmm "::_if*'v:€['£%;_4aiE.e Q'? ?'§C€§§}t <3? csgy cf iéaég aréea yvim i\§:3,:2288;"2§8? is agsnigéégzi. '_ £..,G:'§"eCi:_:.:$4:-":,_sarmsfi :,g2;,:.i" gs': *?:§'":*."§'}'3."=--;f Q? ihg sféer __.3.5,.'S8;2G12. jarsgf J"
erderg' Q5:gi:e:%"'iii'?,'1.;%--<_2'é."};;2V., 7-.£e.;3sequen:§y ihis ga--Vge'»-§§';je§§3:efi"'s:2:'§__:§e€3»f$eéE P:"S*