Gujarat High Court
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL/708/2003 on 16 July, 2010
Author: Bhagwati Prasad
Bench: Bhagwati Prasad
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?f???k???? ??? u??v?? ' ?s?? ?????K?1S?K??Tj% +=.??J z??J?^?? 9 p?]x? &??+E X-?}U EQxQ?? ;T?jX??j???\J ?h?7 )y>Dk?? #??
{ ???St?? @ )?@f d2i J??????]?;? ??????s!????p3?0V????*? *\W??SMi u<#AJ,???z iD? ???U\[?3]?#?? ?P?T??6???e2?hT????=L? ?w3??`??H???* ?? ? ??k?? ? ?u?jV'?GL??u?.??L?2(0?S ?2 #\2�?:`A?j?3b? n???S;b ? ???e.tD?L3 ?|8$V?b&` ? ?K? G?S t??Ho�[??dx????)dq.x9`?S b??p?F/k?j?y�A??1??? ??F??*??.?(y?B??4d?? ?. �??W???P???s'$?B F?? ue??S0 ??g ??v? D?? /? ?tV? u? ??C;??R?8??E>?I??Z?o;s?? ?5+"??? ??F?tw?:?-[v??b ?;?B?*'V ??aA S!?l=Y???3?1???2 R? Y? +?? C??i}?m???? z?zs ??????;z?5? z?? z?# z??G^?X?? ???% ? D??&????{ ?0?? ??F? ?K??m$? ?/?i?? UC. ? ?
?~?"?3?v?Kw?6?S.??e"???" ??H?? k??
k.?? k?O??M ??W??? 4?T?? ?{? j;?y???d{ ???o,??1l{ O?@F? V % W???????p???V0??]?? ?xTv??P?K?S?]?? Zv ?Y5?)VU}3A C?I?9 ?h?jNE\+??g_?? ?�?;?? ?? K[?Z??J2??0A&/b??Z ?rH???W?~???T?=eC???c&\?? ? ?!W???n?w?�{w??;? +?vF?
???A7 ? >u??n+? n??;?N???9?]k4?`???|+ ?Ic ??j? ?X? R??wR?N ?9?>??#OP ?(V?"5!??${??*]?�?v^?]??? O??k????GP ?>v?2?&?G]9yW??|?v?????a?o?._=?O?F??+?3y?5?
? [* ?????iQ!u?c ?f???c??????
?(??\??? ?>??? ??C??? R?'?E?u?]~?J/?[^ {p ??v?L??? ? ? %??'g?}q]?f???%?*??2w??q?v?????? ?
??W?J?4Z ? ;qfxrA??en????:?w?????? ?? \;g??O??{??[???b??2 ?;iu? j?0 ?wJ ?]SA{?T?~~ nopNH?W? ;?? l?=?`{??v???c[??? ? ?????g!mUk??uF?? (?0?????j??6?'?;?i?@lH?N? ?? y???????\8*V? ?_?P0^????5????Y( n?|? ? T????f?ZX???<\??E?^?(? ? ?t??Nr1??*???=Z r (???? ?Q??}+?L lX?e?J??D?F4x&@?ux 2k-k??j 9< � 3?? swnK ???A>??)?
>??? ?A? ?|l|" 9??? ? 5kD???Z ?p;?& ???C? ??F????=F? ?{{?r x#W p1d?9M?]?I>?? $ ` 0? ????L? ???*??K?)S?Q @??J ? ???-%ui???r ?/?? ?~ ?]�^ ?J?�}< ? ?SG?C?? ?\c? ?R|6???S?? ? ? ?`t?? ;?2?D? ?J\ ???+A?1 ?3q sG ????&#?` ? ?*e Hd?1U ?m ?Q????n< , ?? 34??4?R8.1"??Rs? ??5~? ???~/???H ? ?RbxOE g4?5???1? ?cR ?x??>�.? ?
?2???Y H?;c9Q B_N?%! ?>?" ???W Z?( ?�???o? ?i?u.?????B L ? ?r? H?=? K ?L??a.`32 g0j P?? ?G ??n???d=~hU??? ?; ???e+ ????n>?t ? ? qM7? ??e A?R# P??F???'sF??V??gt e?g??A?Oj???_?e |? > ??c?I?u. ,?e{????N?&?%G ? ?-Sn?("? ??1?? @P j?m~??9?
??$#D`?X? + ??? V ?$?0)$ D? L* +L??|jQ? ?,&a=1`??$")?X@ ??2 B2Ic?9?E??SM ?� ?? DC86 R?1S??? ???Y ??????}f????> B??,~g W?.5_?f??y3? m?? ? /?XP?\e??z. f?lP?????`v ?? <,? �?-? 3?\????bZa _?1??(1H? os?M ? A? ?u??B ?
?Y???K?BpL} ??t?
?$%T2? ? oX??6K$P(%?k? ? ??*0??? +A z??JI? U??Kzw?A &?$? ??3??" ?o?IR??X?fuY l#h ??
?
??*??
?J? {c'?]?? ;;??[c'?d??mw ?? ?gBS?n#???F@|Mz?i??~/? PK ?(?" ��-X��PK � � �?f?<������������ ���styles.xml?ZK??6 ??W *?SeY?z??f ?#-v?�?�?? m??H???/? %Y?d{?)|h ??q8??3????.Mz ? a?? ? ??i?bBW ??o??{;??
[.I??c ?)?? r?`C?T? ??2? ?aj???`0 ??^1A???k??K???h (?hqB?FXx?v ?�? ?_? ??n??F???4???1?? ??? B??t?#*qY? ???�'X?[ a? ,6? u?� L?t?y? ?D ???j ?M?h?xw`4?r?(>??Q\? ?u??&? ?O?U\x?\ ??E?dV ??? ?@?4?
?.N? [N$?5x? ?P ?NdiKh?� >?(?x?"ak? z3??K ) ?( ?7:??H??MQ I?G$F?gDEo???{? %JI??~D ???F?S/e?? ????E#?s?Z?
N??6? ?f ??? s Q?,E?�? 7? }n?X}?f??(}wO?6O ??7??]?@t?eR?8? ?%B??=?? ? ??, ?/?L=?F?x??rViaJ?lM"?Yp?!g?$P U?? k ?? ? ???? ??p ?= b?BH87}? ?W9 ?? ?/`8J >???o?M? ?i|??#?[?q???>?I? ? i??(???? ? ??? Bi%??P??,?? ??? ??? ??X5!u? ?%J ??\` ?r?? ??A ?? &?J???%r?S}]m9 \?Xq ?Ty?,v*?4 ??? '?p?? ??9#.g?? ???l??`????C[ 8?=??y?.?]ptVB P?#!T ?? f??d? ]??? ? ?1e T?NI?N?a??f??m?? f??B??1? :??+F?h}?jr??_??sUgz?A?yk????A @???R??K?^?z5%?�M?;RX??5?fxUR?a???f|U??^?5wWe??^?5??2?PT?qX?Lb ??.?*?? ?aWX?0?AI?ueo??*?y???1uO?_)}??2]?0????-?z? ?? ??(?? \?uz{????D???q?????\???????Uo??? t?7?? ?c??h|??-?? h???�?) ?x ???aK??glI???N??[?J?Ew ????p? �???? ? ?c Z3"?? c??.?.?
??^9? ?2nL ?q?#m?I ?,y=?>R ?m?V8 ????= ? ??) 6?N?0?To?-( ?v?P? Ls8F ?? ? P???@?????fd?9x???;Ko?R? ??w ^?+??? ?)??v??????> OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 pansala 2010-07-16T18:22:41 1 PT0S PK � � �?f?<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png??wT?O??QA?t?^ ??^ "H :tB?N?'?#??" )? H? z ? "?[ ?~?9??s??}??$? ?{???;s'1?i??
??=(???-??(*? z??6??>?~?H?yRD ?s???qMD???f??? ?H?o??? 0})L)?T?a??]?"G??M! ???8?? 6? ???? ???F?5n7???:??}?[?? *w{([?4O?k?0h) ?? ?_D(1?? ?P!0$?[O| z??l ? #s:f???? )??#`?u??c???J" ?|?? l?gv5 5?g ?58|.$?C ??d ?|In?5]?)??t^?? b�:/;?S? ? a?!O <63x ?? ~i? ?%??}'?{ k??X???Z7? y?3?n-??8?u?{B zz? ???Y? kpO??|? ????03 ?j?u???(gwy??1??:?? ?3?#?
??(? ? ?p ? ?ze???"h?? 5?p ?3"????3f{?l f??iD?Q>'? /)?x{ N?U-O? ????v?7?)?????!?????"?? R:??i???{ K ??5V- klV n???vV??~} v.?7 ? ? ?, ?g[??0e} r?
?-k`m] , $??W `w;??|?G ? ?I ?.?db? ?f???I}???;? ?}????H?j??T? ? ? U4? k | ? 8?r??+??1?`t??j? ?b(?,?}oVh/?i??)?#???7e?_?=u ?`? ?j?z?????:?OG?_Zv?#c\???@l N1 ??|??];\#qT bL?2?m?3?^^&?Z!??B4?eV?tq???=7?? F?he`)??/?hP? H?I?]7? ? "??\?[P??lmU?h??v&,? ?X?Db? ?y ?
*?:?cD??M`??"?' pt? ?S???? ?u?r? ;?Q ?Z??&???A?? [B ?P?q??E?c?????u?? ?{4O?6^?/]? ?h-?j?4?n? ?f??y?x?ZL.q??Bb?r??b?c??)??eg???? =1i??%c?? |+?
=??/9f ?j(? ??B?=?.?cu??y?(?c?. ?? ??????jf @?}4 W{ ??????? h F_??? ??H? >?(??& ?a?X;H?sfn1'??A41K ?0e? 7c??;^?V? ?I??-6?,?/??r???)d???GB Gd?#???? ? ?F< ??
??sw?n?k?7??I?1?.? ??[?e ????^?O? h%W?>???) ? 4 ?v\??5?h?WzbZgV??/ ?~ o!?N????? Y?oC?-?p??l??? ??" &$<]? @)?? ??> g'? vD????K?g[w"^/?!??~?Y ?? 1?O?? ?????d? ???*?M7'? ?P ?pj?==??|???7 ?_]=f?|??jO ?I??m?_??3 ? ?????he ? ??|?ff??^??
T {?Y?J ?V5? 23 ? ?4? ???P ?m?#?u5'??ox ???? ?? ? m????/|0,?:???K?(V ?? ?? ?V?YR+?3 ??/??L?W [? ???V?C??oW?a H??J!p?h?C?P?\Q } V- ???!}D??Kg???13? ???I?w?Q?V?? ?3_??K?�?#?Ro? `NN]?L?F?}? ?=rNj?1??*?F????s?Bu)??ql?AA? ) ?56????? ?h? ?2??[??_I?} ?? ?? &??pi?? ?~? ?? ? ?I3??dWH??V?A' ???m??? y???}?Y??t9??1?&? 9?'??/~?J? ???v?\_??yFR??? ?H#Q*?2?�J???L=O???U2?? ?J ?k*? ??q&?, 5?J?? xS l?n???rX&r??o?? /??? B~ ?`>?????0???Af?IB>??M?g ,J ?? ???�?:?p?~?a?go? $!?&!?Gt?? ??. :? ??? )]'3l? m o {Ym??@?cZ?V14?;-_???* pK????? f ? }?#Z?/+888<??(i?lX :???Qg6??/ ?? ???x?r???h?W? ??s _}[-d?-?j??~^???2][?? O???B? F?3a??U? ?????T+?????)� ???JU? 1 ar? A??p?7?6???}?o?3+?????++??Xc???~?y?14/t? ? ???OY9_ ?p>H 8 ^ ?Hz? DZ?ag ? Z j?
0?i ??q??|??>:?=? ^ ???A?? ????-Lm? ? ? ?$????J ?????A}?"?AO 5??Q??&? X? j?y? ? ?{B?O`j?? ?&??99 ? 2&???^????f?w;?7 ?6 ?????;?m?m{? ?S`??)x\S*D ? ?*?xk??ev1?.?LI z4Um??! ?re??>?s? xH?
??H5? Wi? ?E:I0 ?O? zJI*C????u???? ?f? q_?+Nx?R?O ?6??v ??sG;}?+??&]?Z?#z1 ??}) ?}]l?Y? !?a?93? r?? ?d ????5??l??N?????? ?Y8R??Xip?y{??a?#? rW?pXB?>C)5%u?x??"Vz??? ??&?-??\??Q? ?O?eo??rXV???�?n??1 67R??- V? ??ze CL)??o???+? ? ?w? V6?y5?5 s?0 ??? }???.?wZv ???q q daA? ??:???FL???e(Z'???1?%??? �S?? 1???%m????v? Z&? s?? ? *`? e??} ? ? x??e??j?? Of???I??T ?
?1??e?=,/?l?? ??? ( n???s?\? 8???E�?u??wD? ?c(?W-?/Z ?g)????z?Q7C17???-???|=`??g?}?0???;s?9?H?yK^"?%3??[Pj?d? ,9??>???? ?@-? ? t?X] k? ?? ???g?O?'8??w?{5`jV?&BR?gW??a0? bZ? ???j??}} S+,..N ??[?? ?z ??Sz?????? C??.R?
????> ?!~??wW??
?]U?E?.L?s~i2n ???z? ??&?OS23'?C?i??]? ??N6?jv?W>?? ??? 4^ _O??m >?? nb?O???x^A???? P??C o????$*???'G ?Y ??k? ??????'?Azy?? ?R@aU�?OJ?9$X$J�??GG? {?]? ?3?????Q ? ?1? ?M ??U?H Q $>]d3?� ??v B?t?&? w??w??X?? ???? ?r}?C ??zy)? M ??o??O~}?w? ?"^ ksv?l81OAJ?? ?? v???=R?@i??9?.?EO p??"? ?�? g ?P??3` ??:{??x_m?(?4M?$G p1??m???z8?p?h?w??db?J?E? Ie%?Q e??? ??'Id?Q>??$??U?A?sSp?p%( hD??js@? ?'W7? ?[3? ???2??S%??N?yg?? sC??L? JkA ??a?k???P?? ?l?5 ? ????_?~?j?Q? |??
?T? ??2?7?M?r?wA?1?FO??? ???gb k ?52? &??| ?7?!??]y???L?n?7p????M??&????C ?F? z?{q?, v z ? ?tu?\?k?/ ?A ??a? ?^???x?k t?t??a? ? ?�e?f??? ?i?o?o D?+???O~??W |? r???f??? ?~ ? ?g??�4B ??n?F ??+??? ?~?` T%???3??? ?????n?!B@f ????9$????T ??l? u?I{? w#d??/?]d?? ?},?N? ?u???y?????U????< .?dkF?E? V.?{?V'Wo'?[??y? ?R?v?e?@??? ??s?? ? 0?y,??9 ?^? +???) ?|??y???H0?? ???.?O?3 ??R ?/ ?i?F?Ex ?ty??C?q ??�J?? ? ??&>{?i ??? =?.????,y?4??# ????HJ?~5???? ??=??? ???|?????B[?iA???"BG?????% ;?s ?m ?? Ag?? ?z??v??r?? ?? ??c??? ??? ?3i??r'?>? SK?k 8 ???a ? ?c?
?J0D�?\ A# YLv?? ?~ ?!R??x /h?t?[?8???Y?{K ?8 ? ?zU ??w ? ??qt }???f???#?dw[ sLNbX ? ?;?]/?\8e`Z H?/?V??H ??P?? q????E?n? ? T?? '+?{?"? ?*?_?tD? ?e?8?_?? ??O?? }S?????Q� ?L?1?FK�??/�?C?u?; R?6 C?&??? ??~? ?8?? 4??~ ?`H?1? ?i ZD?\Z?\+? 4 R|G 9?r=??RE 7?$^?S ??^???.?�x?g] ??t ? ??s ?[??I\h??$l. 2 ?E? WH???pd?]1?? q? t? ??e???? ???P? ? l?lV?0] ??9\?J?&??+?????|?F ?}??? ?F??;?r ?/ ? X;??{H?wy? ?8?S?#9??h? ?s?" ??H???? ?n " ?}s? PY;?% }???k[ &8s?'-f ?c ?9? {? ?????|~>??k??z?l??? (&?? ?j9[?z ?X][?$???U???te`?& ?Q?4????k?b??5???'?w??E?} l???z?? =??? ???6??]??]?????b??Q?g??//.k?b??@4??ur[??? ?R??* ?D?1 G&?o?xDH??6Cy?/ h? ?n?j?H? ?@C ?? |?????q?? ?? &CGT2M?? =???$ 1 ?a? C '??>? ??[?$??x?=~/F? ?7 ??4 ?? ?u?DyJB?w??* 8?{??e?? ??@ ?H*Mf@??O?p?. _I ??q"A????` 7$ 8???^? 0#??$R?8??
Top