Karnataka High Court
M Panduranga Prabhu vs Union Of India on 24 June, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil
Bench: N.K.Patil
£5? T1313 HIGH COURT OF }'.€.?».; E'~€A.'i'23L§~i;'X AT BPNGALOE 'ée'.P.}«'& E8453 Qf 2988 .;N mi :35 met: comm' or KARNA IAKA A I 3Arec;A:.-3&5 8E?'a"«' vi 3 {'8';.»' 3:5:
;§€'~éD ;
MA EATEE: THIS THE 24¢ DAY 0? .j{.EI~ZE, \:3£%tf2u§: "
ms ;~;oars:.s me. J£!SvT§€§E'fs',§{;:?.-3-i'f£u. _" "
w.m;a_ 19453 Q? 2(5Q$ "€_§?»§~§::Zi}§€'} = ' EEI'-E as: F'A¥\i{}UF~'2ANGA PRABH{.;' SEQ M auzaama PRi~'~.SH§_.J was BGUT 52 ':"EAR$ ;
ma vzsawx TRASERS _ * AEBMAR %¢%L.%T§' LANE ' uaasm 5?a2r::: V -- ' H 1 _ V _ V PE'fE":'£GHE¥% e:2sHi::RE;éH*¢;é"T*:, aézszazas, or: ::~;Q'i;éI.L" . ' 1 SE95 "%"MEi\£"{ GF.?,afi:;;:,a:$:E:;?As%\r A5F"FAiRS P;%£Rfi§;~",..i\«'};'Z--L's'*'%"3T H~f_}Ui:.?'E "
; ' ~vr=:a:~¢ :";.*£z,.w;~.~:;_A :23 am ' » %§£":?3"%"E{} ax' :;.;v_$Hg<;:R£':;:m«' cc: W '4 ;r:.$ _ $959; §;%$TR§{fE" $<:::-zsumER a.zs.;*:;"¢:s aamassaa. ':"~"€:3§«2%_3%«;°§ V ' uaasps 5?a:::::
' RE§--"'T'f_E£3 as *£?;EG£S?R£§R ::..'%3'A%v:;é;9A":"%~:: ma .. SE5} LATE €3{}PALA§&{r% %'%:'Lri'.l§GR 32% AGE AA ?u'%A§'-@838 APART§.s'§E:"~iT §V~£fi,R£S§~iC§-:'A§'w.§E}&".+"-'ex ROAS A UBLEPQ S?§":G3 iii '31 iii §§'i€3§§ {KI} "ii? ='.;h'5 £<;%§{§¥?;TA.%Z;'iZ £55 Asiifififi 'é'¥.P,}v3':3» ii? 5.3 f$H'fi$§~§fKALA RAG '=e'\i§«Q £3 $R%$As'°'.»5§§%é§ RRQ §e€fiJG¥2 IN AGE ?ei4A?'~%{3E$E4. 13%?-'.1%R'fN'EEs"'«$'§"
%~~%é'%R!S3r'§C§~i:'3~3~.i3§~=":*x. 913213 'F311 mix: ssmg ' '1" 9:? Kz'aR?€A'{2%;K2% 2;: a;,<:>§?.:£' "éi,PFi*€c;,, :::;4:§3 sf EGGS "}
-,,_-
'a}DL;F~'i~5?51 'G1 i'~éER?s€Ai..A G &<lAR§"~§A§' 'u"s'§Q Ly'-'XE 89% 'F: H KARNAB ?s'§.-5a»JQR {N AGE ?%:"§:£'\NSE$H z5x?~'Afi"{?'u'§E§'~E'{ HAR£$%~iC%{§'a§'v'DRA ROAB §J$UP§ 5?S': Q?
U"! 5 {.?EET'r%A Re'-'KO 333 L3 §£%£*~2fi=,F~'AT}-3% RAG ._ §':£AJQR $3 AGE V ?€%A%'u'i3ESH §%PARTfu'iE§\é?
E-<%:'%!'~3%$§-§'CAr%Af'\{BR:'i RGAD %..§§%.,§?€ 5?$1%'a % %$;&aesp;cgsg:¢+s 23%;. :3; sHA:e;<.aR saw: 29:: mt: R4. ? 3542:. £13' %'§$Hu*s'£%NATH ASA F-if.'-R R~:3 - _ sags was-u-g<: ;'=:%{}C:ATE$, .a;£)x:a::A%"E.%j_F?3F:'w--R;3 f;"<:; R5 3; ms §..:::.P.~..;$"v-vFsz,ED<-.;;:3;:;2Ea ~aF:?:c;._Es 226 A{'»%{3' 227 as we CQ£'~§3Ti"{£3T§€,;?_~é s;:::_: %%«1$§;v"»%; _Paé:r§r4{3Ai'?a3 3; ~ASEDE 'ma %?s%PUQ:2£EQ QRQER ;C}'§___1?:?12{3£s2?,Pé\S3EQ £9; THE 332 goaum are we EXECLJT§{3N PET§"{%{3%'~£ :::<:.s; 3's.§2~7§2%fs; v:GE~$rex-::a ;3&3'?L.:E IE: wgvzyg" 0:: QERYEGRARE ma sm::<;£,so:; 'N E§L%';%.:T:}_E£iT%{3?i~.{ 0.? _sg>.::':*:e:a: 2?' 5: ma CQ%«iSUEs;*sER$ :~'7'R"«.T'E€£,I"§Qs'~é A51'? 'E$§€..fi\$=é,,:£\£::1f3¥*%S"%"é"E°%_é"E7:{;'§*-é?xL ms agent: ANQ; 'n--::::»;«:m:= £§::::4*§é:'sA'<.::~{;'>*r;f;;%: §3'%E%.%{\;'§ié\§AR'%' %~éEé'«R:.NS was *8' saga? Ems am: "§'%w"¥¢E..£1£}£.§R"'{':?e*%fiaZ?EVT~§-1:5 :":Q:_;.. :;::m:@; ;
"§"?:%L%'iv'L--¥r*:§i*£Ver is taken up far carasfiafaiiars with the e::a:{é;§r*i;%.V:::§ yiearrgaed mi}:-*a$e§ appearirég far bath 'the gégfiiiaa if éa?.¥§€i§~..;:3:": fhe greairafi fiéat, éhe subgesi mafiar §B%f%3¥'¥'§G' in thig ' éigeage ig éireatéy' aavamé by the areieg" $332'?-ged '$3; ihig Saufi 3:1 ggmiigr mafiar.
r.r""'fiMW'»'pé,' m.9\': $43'??? §§T'7""3 P" \' '''5'2?l'' !\§'1"§,"fi.'§'3.'7"s' / " 5?" 3' ' K3154' T "S. 'C-'''"'' if! "*L§.a §"§A':C"i no ' *9' ' in 3; 112.; 2113-'..:§2 '~..»{.x§;§'x, & 2,51' ax;-um nwgfaixgi 2/Ex: §§:Kmx)?s3j{/€31; Ex': ,p.m4§.r s¥}¢§.,==3 vi 553,33 ~ «~ ~ '.s.\~«.d".€:;,nz..*:.=aro gs: Egijfl {f'=/£13}??? E' K?xR}'5:§?$a§é.43-'=_ :31? ¥;;£"%_é{_3;°v.§._»$'-.}{{.E..;~¢ '¢~e[~:'3"*e's.r= iifiiaég Oi again "9 ..,-,_ 12:'. '¥'%3a patéiiioner if? ihig petifisn hag s@u§hi%§:"$ei-- Hr asiée the irnpagned arder fiataafi $3.; .26???' " f:::f;,{j't%::&%' . éemfid resparzderst -T-Tarum ir: ih_e....Exec:;=E%'d¥':"*§£;:t§'i§:':g*;.,i"é:':. "' 'SSQJQGGS, 'aside Arinéxure-A. :"Fui§?;f§*:e'é*, '"g*.\e?'f§?{i':;.f§1e§%'§~..,,§§$$ smsght in $tri§<e dawfi 3ubmS€e_{§i'%~:3n {3} 5%' v*::gCi:§a"r€'2}" (if Ehé' ' ilsnszjmer' p¥'G'£EC"?§$fi:" 53¢? §.§82'§ _:séé"-vL1;r';cmi§ii'€:.,:fiéna% mid vaid, 3' § hgv*;zg ?1ea;*_é ;%ag:»::§;*:*:'a§".i_te:*j£_;':§§'se% appearéfig fer peiétéafier i'a_jné1;:_4§"av2,:§.¥'z4 z'é'::~:r,:.»* c':ic>5.§;;:'x5§~A§:z:;':§.V'a;:igp?a§i3r§:*:g far respanderfis. E__,.e{i'a¥'s*':*'rv@§fV ii'3'3.C2i,é;'T"14 $3*<.'9!'§__ appearing far bath the parties, at the éaiéaii €sab1r:%;5'Ef_é';:i§._§%2é%, firm subjgfi mafia: Emsaiveé in 'fiififié c:.§'-53$ §$V";?§§%V$fi'§§}€'CQ%¥&¥'§fi by $315 aréef" fiafied by ihifi 3.55:'? mass 9:' 5:35:22 Sfiafiffiiniketafi 3-éazésifig :~=}é§:z;&*s§'fa:%'i:':;:;:»:f:"*\Tfsaé'73j5.. Egig, {Rafa} ..3.§%«L fievafafi aw fifhfiffi gm §%:§.;a§.%%§§;2§a3 am eamectea matters éisgmséé :Q>§$"«--..f'§§'}' Jurse 2939" Tharefare; may aufimétteezé fixafi .' §§3§§a%:s:§:%;g éiée saéé Qgfiérg ism érgséamté writ? gefifféaéi flied by Qetéiiagéef may aigfi $2 diggsasaé 3%.
$7. «- 2 we .' ~' 1-:"" :2. Lu '.4:<;s«~»-as', Eu "ESL §E§G§§ \3€,}§,=§'I'E 2}? §{?sE%3~§?{3 A§£,2~i, ;'~'»."§ }§,»»"~£'~«€,'E£~.Li.}§3'.,§. --§'e','.%'*.m.». =.',.»»y._'g =._»f Q1538 IE3 '1'§'£l3 1}§{3E1{:<}E§§'xT 5}'? E€A{{}5?{§'§».£{2§ AT AL€,"_}i?,{'=,. 'v'~fI§'Ns:s. {£234 53% -:3?' EGQ8
5. The submémifin made by ieémeaf VV.<:l~a;§jr:_$ei apgearing fer" bath ihe partiag, as stateé 3§;:.:é_§e§;' . an regard ._
8. Er: the fig??? 0*? 'the 5ub:'2i1%:e3$%%§t*s'Ts"né::':iié' _Ee{$~:f;'f}é§. cmmsei appearing far baf%:--.§§*:e §a%*t§sf1_£':-auéV-$%é§é€$si;p:*3,"'V the éngtgnt writ p$i:%t?§§::i*:_fiEed.."by:§:%§é '¢§i§%Edfié:*A Esidégpcseé sf, faiicwing fine e:°:m*au&"" 3% 33$ 3339 Q'? M13 S§:a§€a§%%;§;,:jj'i--§:é£;g:V:§'g§é:£§z:§§§§§."-wfhfiyiiifiatimn Vgs Brig, meta.) % ifi VaLF.!%3e.?@fiI2QQ3 and tiigéiééiyfied an 13%; Jam 2939 am' $29' ..t_}fieV rfe2..3 §;§%*i:e.;:_'i§:§'aE;§'é--:f':':§ thawing with iha faiéawing direfiféwas:
it peiitéén aiwaiiengifig we ME 3"
U} '--.,'C§E§';',~'"A<{'§§--'ii'¥¢.§:'if§.éifEE§ vaiicifiiy {Bf gab aecfégfi 3 Q? Secfisrz 2?'V,§§' §*:e carssumer Praiegiian Act, '$9865 is n «fiéfelby §i$§'£'?i$$@d, ughaéding ihe eéreg sf ifie saiéf gs"s:§ss:s%:";:s:;
§'t-.'Z""E'.' '.- ',r-,-:2,' 2' .» = E ' "'.,; "a :2 - .4' 'e' 5&3}; £,?i)%.f§-'£1 21:. §~..£~.R.?~aA,E :Z§~.,?x A'? 135$»-£3 A§_.%..":';-1%.; !;'€€=i;¥z.§""5}-- Eu-$5? vi 3938