Karnataka High Court
Karnataka Rajya Sarkari Prathamika vs The State Of Karnataka on 20 September, 2019
Bench: L.Narayana Swamy, R Devdas
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 20TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2019
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE L. NARAYANA SWAMY
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R. DEVDAS
WRIT PETITION NOS.43295-43320 OF 2019 (S-KSAT)
&
WRIT PETITION NOs.44003-44031 OF 2019
BETWEEN:
1. KARNATAKA RAJYA SARKARI PRATHAMIKA
MATTHU PRAUDHA SHALA SHIKSHARA
KSHEMAVRUDHI SANGHA,
BANGALORE,
NO. 66, 4TH CROSS,
RAMDAS LAYOUT,
NEAR ASHWINI SCHOOL,
RAJARAJESHWARINAGARA,
BANGALORE-560 098,
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
P. K. CHANRAKANTHA.
2. SRI. DHANANJAYA M.N
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O. LATE NARASIMAIAH,
R/AT, SOPPAINAHATTI SIRA TOWN,
DIST TUMKUR -572137.
O/O, GLPS MEGALAPETE SIRA,
TUMKUR DIST-572137.
2
3. SRI. SHIVAPRASAD N
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O. NAGAIAH D,
R/AT, W.NO.3 JYOTHINAGARA OPP K.E.B. SIRA TOWN,
DIST TUMKUR -572137.
O/O, GLPS GUDDADAHATII SIRA,
TUMKUR DIST-572137.
4. SRI. PARVEEN TAJ
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
W/O. KALEEM PASHA,
R/AT, NEAR OLD GOVT HOSPITAL ROAD
KHARADHI MOHALLA SIRA,
DIST TUMKUR -572137.
O/O, GUHPS BEGUM MOHALLA SIRA,
TUMKUR DIST-572137.
5. SRI. KAMALAMMA
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
W/O. SHIVAKUMAR,
R/AT, KESHAVANAGAR, SIRA,
DIST TUMKUR -572137.
O/O, GUHPS MEGALPETE SIRA,
TUMKUR DIST-572137.
6. SMT. GEETHA C.K.
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
W/O. KANTHARAJU D,
R/AT, D.NO.244, ANJANADRI NILAYA VIDYANAGARA SIRA,
DIST TUMKUR -572137.
O/O, GULPS LARDPURA SIRA,
TUMKUR DIST-572137.
3
7. SRI. SARVAMANGALA H.R.
AGED ABOUT 43YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
W/O. SRINIVASALU D,
R/AT, HULIKUNTE VILLAGE & POST KORATAGERE TALUK,
DIST TUMKUR -572129.
O/O, GOVT MODEL HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,
SANTHEPETE SIRA,
TUMKUR DIST-572137.
8. SRI. SIDDAGANGAMMA
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
W/O. THARAPPA,
R/AT, JYOTHI NAGARA SIRA
DIST TUMKUR -572137.
O/O, GULPS SHIRANIMOHALLA SIRA,
TUMKUR DIST-572137.
9. SRI. SAI MANJULA
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
W/O. H.N. SAIRAM,
R/AT,#107, SHRI VATSA NILAYA
O.P.H ROAD KADUGODI,
BANGALORE SOUTH-560067,
O/O, GHPS BELTHUR COLONY,
CHANNASANDRA CLUSTER SOUTH-4,
BANGALORE-560067.
10. SMT. SHIVALEELA MRUTUNJAYA POORVIMATH
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS, OCCUPANT:
ASSISTANT TEACHER,
W/O. SIVAYA BALAYA PUJERI,
R/AT, INDIRANAGAR
BAILHONAL, DIST.
BELAGAVI-591102,
O/O GKHPS INDIRANAGAR,
4
BAILHONGAL
BELGAVI-591102
11. SRI. AKKATAI VEERAPA KORI
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
OCC: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O. BASAVARAJ KARKI,
R/AT, PRABHUNGAR BOURT BEHIND
BAILHONAL, DIST.
BELAGAVI-591102,
O/O GKHPS SL.NO3, BAILHONGAL
BELGAVI-591102
12. SRI. SUBHAS VENKAPPA SHIROL
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSITANT TEACHER,
S/O. VENKATAPPA B SHIROL,
R/AT. RAINPUR TQ SOUDATTI,
DIST BELGAVI-591126,
O/O GMHPS KANABARGI CITY
RANGE BELGAVI-591126.
13. SRI. PANCHAKSHARI GADGAYYA HIREMATH
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSITANT TEACHER,
S/O. GADIGAYYA HIREMATH,
R/AT. KULKARNI GALLI,
DIST BELGAVI-591102,
O/O GKHPS SL. NO 2 KULKARNI GALLI,
BELGAVI-591102.
14. SMT. SAVITHRAMMA
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSITANT TEACHER,
S/O. NATARAJ. K,
R/AT.KANAKA NILAYA OPP K.E.B.
JYOTHINAGAR SIRA TOWN,
DIST TUMKUR-572137,
O/O GLPS KALLUKOTE SIRA TOWN,
5
TUMKUR-572137
15. SRI. C.M. LOKESH
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER
S/O. MANJAPPA,
R/AT, A CHOLENAHALLY ADUGUR POST,
KASABA HOBLI
CHANNARAYAPARNA TALUK,
DIST HASSAN-573201
O/O GHPS HOUSING BOARD COLONY,
CHANNARAYAPATNA,
HASSAN-573201.
16. SMT. VIJAYA M
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O. SHREEKANTHRAJ,
R/AT. #7/128 SHREEBALAJI NIVAS, P.W.D OFFICE ROAD,
ANEKAL-562106,
O/O GOVT GIRLS HIGH SCHOOL, ANEKAL-562106.
17. SRI. VEDAVATHI BHAT
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER
S/O M.N.VISHWANTH,
R/AT.# 320 SHREEGURGA NIVAS APARTMENT,
HESARGHATTA MAIN ROAD,
VIDYARANYAPURA POST,
BANGALORE-560097
O/O GHS KALKERE SOUTH-4
HORAMAVU POST, BANGALORE-570097
18. SRI. SATISHA N.C.
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O. CHANNABASAPPA N.V.
R/AT #B277 ITI COLONY EAST POST,
LINE DOORAVANINAGARA,
6
BANGALORE-560016,
O/O GOVT HIGH SCHOOL SECTION HOODI SOUTH-4,
HORAMAVU POST,
BANGALORE-570048.
19. SRI. SIKHANDARASAHEB MUGUTASAHEB NADAF
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O. MUGATASAB NADAF,
R/AT H.NO 90 VANTAMURI COLONY
MALAMARATI BADAVANE,
BELAGAVI-560006,
O/O GKLPS NO 20 VEKSHIN DEPO,
TILAKAWADI,
BELAGAVI-570006
20. SRI. NANDA BISTESHRAO GALAGANATH
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O.BISTESHRAO GOLGANATH,
R/AT. G.K.H.P.S NO.04 HOSUR
O/O, G.K.H.P.S NO.04 HOSUR
21. SRI. SANJU ASHOK KAPARE,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O. ASHOK KAPARE,
R/AT.MARAWAD,
BELAGAVI-590002,
O/O, GKHPS PRIMARY SCHOOL ALARWAD,
BELAGAVI-590002
22. SMT. JAYALAXMI A KULKARNI
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
W/O. A KULKARNI ,
R/AT.BELAGAVI-590006,
O/O, K.M.P.S 21 POLICE HEADQUARTERS,
KMPS, BELAGAVI-590006
7
23. SRI. ARUN SIDDANAGOUDA PATIL
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O. SIDDANAGOUDA PATIL ,
R/AT.BELAGAVI-590001,
O/O, GOVT M.P.S NO.20 GONDHALIGALLI,
BELAGAVI-590001
24. SRI. UJWALA SURENDRA HOLAMANI
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O. SURENDRA HULAMANI ,
R/AT.H.NO 248 GOUDER ONI MUTTANAL TQ,
DIST BELAGAVI-591109,
O/O, GKBS NO.3 KHOSABAG,
BELAGAVI-591109
25. SMT. BHARATI APPASAHEB NITRANNAVAR
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O. APPASAHEB NITRANNAVAR,
R/AT.# 69/2 III 3RD CROSS SHIVAJINAGAR,
BELAGAVI-590016,
O/O, GKHPS NO.3 KHOSABAG,
BELAGAVI-590016
26. SMT. HEMAVATHI
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
OCCUPANT: ASSISTNAT TEACHER,
W/O. NARAYANA T.KANCHAN
O/O, G.M. HR. PRIMARY SCHOOL,
UDUPI, NORTH
27. SRI H V SHIVAKUMAR SWAMY
S/OH.M.VEERNARADHYA
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
OCCUPATNASSISTANT TEACHER,
R/A #4, 3RD CROSS SAGAR T.
8
DEVARA CHIKKANHALLI,
BENGALURU 560076.
O/O G.H.S., SARAKKI,
J.P.NAGAR 1ST PHASE,
BENGALURU-560078.
28. SMT FELORA SHUBAVATHI
W/O SAMOSA A,
OCCUPANT:ASSISTANT TEACHER,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
R/A KODIKAL,
MANGALORE 575006.
O/O D.K.Z.P.H.P.S.,
BOKKAPANTA MANGALORE 575006.
29. SMT. MANJULA M A
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
W/O. RAJU .C.,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
R/AT. #F20, RAJ VILLA, F-BLOCK,
GOPALA GOWDA EXTENSION,
SHIVMOGA-577204.
OFFICE ADDRESS: G.H.P.S. VINOBHA NAGAR,
SHIVMOGA-577204.
30. SMT. K. SHAGOOFA BEGUM
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
R/AT. NO.39, WAR NO.26,
BAZAR POLICE STATION,
BELLARI-583102
O/O: G.U.H.P.S., JAGRUTHI NAGAR,
BELLARI-583102.
31. SMT. ALIYAMAAN
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
W/O. IQBAL BASHA,
OCC: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
R/AT.# 18, BUTCHER STREET,
9
BELLARI-583102.
O/O. G.U.H.P.S., C.B. BELLARI, ELLARI-583102.
32. SRI UMAMAHESWARA H C
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
OCC: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O CHANDAIAH H.G. R/AT BROADWAY ROAD,
VIJAYAPURA CHICKMAGALORE 577101,
O/O GOVT. H P S TAMIL COLONY.
SANTHE MAIDANA, HICKMAGALUR 577101
33. SRI E HARINAKSHI
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
OCC: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O K VISHWANATH,R/AT KRISHNA RATHNA NILAYA,
OPP.FOREST QUARTERS, M ROAD, KADUR
CHICKMAGALUR 577548,
O/O GOVT. L P S MARTHIHAL KADUR TQ,
CHICKMAGALUR 577548
34. SMT G K HEMA, W/O N S HALAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS,
OCC ASSISTANT TEACHER,
R/AT ARASU RESIDENCE, EAR YMC COLLEGE KADUR,
CHICKMAGALUR 577548,
O/O GOVT. H P S SARASWATHI PURAM BIRUR,
KADUR TQ, CHICKMAGALUR 577548.
35. SMT. B S MAMATHA W/O. T C BILWESHKUMAR,
OCC: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
R/AT DENDAYALA STREET,
TYAGARAJANAGAR EXTENSION TARIKERE,
CHICKMAGALURLU 577 228
36. SRI. RAMEGOWDA, S/O. AJJEGOWDA,
OCC: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
R/AT OPP. KSRTC BUS STAND,
SRI. GURU REVANA SIDDESHWARA ROAD,
VENKATESHWARA NAGARA KADUR,
10
CHICKMAGALURLU 577 548.
O/O. GOVT HPS HALEPETE KADUR TALUK,
CHICKMAGALUR 577 548
37. SMT. G. TEJAVATHI
OCC: ASSISTANT TEACHER,
W/O. G. MANJUNATHA,
R/AT GANGAMBIKA KRUPA,
NEAR SHANESHWARA TEMPLE,
2ND RIGHT CROSS,
KADUR CHICKMAGALURU 577 548.
O/O. GOVT. UHPSKM, KM ROAD,
KADUR TALUK, CHICKMAGALURLU 577 548
38. SMT SARITHA S
AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER
W/O MADHU T N
R/AT #4, MANIKYA" MALLIGE ROAD,
29TH CROSS, S.I.T. EXTENSION
TUMKUR-572102
O/O GOVT L.P.S
RAJEEV GANDHI EXTENSION KADUR TQ
CHICKMAGALUR-577548
39. SMT PRATHIBHA P G
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER
W/O PARVEEZ BASHA
R/AT NAZIR SAB BADAVANE SUBHASHNAGAR,
KADUR CHICKMAGALUR-577548
O/O GOVT URDU LOWER PRIMARY SCHOOL
K H MUDIYAPPA BADAVANE
KADUR TQ CHICKMAGALUR-577548
40. SRI YOGEESH M
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER
S/O MALLESHAPPA
11
R/AT KEMPANAHALLI
CHICKMAGALORE CHANDRANAGAR
BASAVANAHALLI POST-577101
O/O G.U.L.P.S. RAHMATHNAGAR
KADUR TQ CHICKMAGALUR-57548
41. SMT LOKESHAPPA D
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER
W/O DANAPPA P
R/AT A.P.M.C BACK SIDE JYOTHINAGAR,
CHICKMAGALUR-577102
O/O G.H.P.S.
DANTARAMAKKI TQ
CHICKMAGALUR-577102
42. SMT MANJULA M A
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER
W/O RAJU C
R/AT #F20, C R RAJ VILLA
F BLOCK
GOPALAGOWDA
EXTENSION
SHIVMOGA-577204
O/O G.H.P.S
VINOBHA NAGAR,
SHIVMOGA-577504
43. SMT N NAGALAMBIKA
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: HINDI ASSISTANT TEACHER
W/O K S DEVENDRA
R/AT NAGASHREE NILAYA ADHARSHA NAGARA
III 3RD CROSS,
MYSORE, ROAD CHANNARAYAPATNA HASSAN-573116
O/O G.H.P.S. BEHIND CEO OFFICE
CHANNARAYAPATNA
HASSAN DIST-577548
12
44. SMT CHAMPAKA M B
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: HINDI ASSISTANT TEACHER,
W/O BOREGOWDA
R/A TBRAHMANARA BEEDI,
SAKALESHPURA-573127
O/O GOVT HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL
B.M. ROAD
SAKALESHPURA-573127
45. SMT FELORA SHUBAHVATHI
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER
W/O SADANANDA KARKADA
R/AT "AKASH" J B LOBO ROAD ODIKAL
MANGALORE-575006
O/O D K Z P HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOLL
BAKKAPATNA MANGALORE-575006
46. SMT SHAKEELA M P
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS,
OCCUPANT: ASSISTANT TEACHER
D/O PUTTASWAMY
R/AT VENKATESHWARA NAGAR,
KADUR-57748
O/O G.H.P.S.
K H MUDIYAPPA EXTENSION,
KADUR CHICKMAGALUR-577101
47. SMT MUBEENA BEGUM
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
OCCUPANT ASSISTANT TEACHER
W/O MOHAMED ABDUL BASEER
R/AT C/O UNITED FURNITURE NEAR NAGAPPA HOTEL
SHERIFF STREET CHICKMAGALURU-577101
O/O G.U.H.P.S. J M ROAD
CHICKMAGALURU-577 101
13
48. SMT RAJESHWARI M
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
OCCUPANT ASSISTANT TEACHER
D/O D M LAKSHMI NARASHIMIAH
R/AT # 200 BEHIND ST THOMAS TOWN POST
BANGALORE-560084
O/O G.L.P.S. BYRATHI DODDAGUBBI
POST EAST T B
BANGALORE-560077
49. SRI DEVARAJA G R
AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS,
OCCUPANT ASSISTANT TEACHER
S/O RAMESHAPPA GARAGADAHALLI
R/AT GARAGADAHALLI VILLAGE GADIHALLI POST
TARIKERE TQ CHICKMAGALURU-577 547
O/O G.L.P.S. AMBEDKAR NAGAR
HUTTA TARIKERE TQ
CHICKMAGALUR-577547
50. SMT. GANGAMMA N
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
OCCUPANTL ASSISTANT TEACHER,
S/O. ERANNA T.E.
R/AT MUNIPAL COUNCILER MACHENAHALLI,
TARIKERE TQ
CHICKMAGALUR-577228,
O/O. G.H.P.S KAMBADA BEEDI
TARIKERE TQ,
CHICKMAGALUR-577228.
51. SMT. GIRIRAJA T.M.
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
OCCUPANTL ASSISTANT TEACHER,
W/O. LATE MUDALAGIRIYAPPA,
R/AT SANKANNANA BEEDI, TARIKERE TQ
CHICKMAGALUR-577228,
O/O. G.H.P.S GALIHALLI CROSS
TARIKERE TQ, CHICKMAGALUR-577228.
14
52. SMT. SUSHILABAI
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
OCCUPANTL ASSISTANT TEACHER,
W/O. LAXMIKANT GURAV,
R/AT 4370/A1, CHAVAT GALLI,
BELGAUM-590001
O/O. K.H.P.S NO.15 MALAPRABHA NAGAR
VADAGAVI
BELGAUM-590001.
53. SRI MALLIKARJUN HANAMAGOUDA PATIL
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
OCCUPANT:ASSISTANT TEACHER
S/O HANAMAGOUDA PATIL
R/A NEAR CHALUKYA SHILPA
KALA MANDIR WARD NO.2
BASAVANAGAR ILKAL TQ
HUMNABAD DIST
BAGALKOT-587101
O/O GOVT UBHS NO.2
ALAMPURPER ILKAL TQ
HUNGUND DIST
BAGALKOT-587101
54. SMT HAMEEDA KHATOON
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
OCCUPANT:ASSISTANT TEACHER
W/O C MOHAMMED DAWOOD
R/A NO.1-2 WARD NO.23
GADANG STREET C B
BALLARY-583102
O/O G U H P S YASEEN SAB STREET
BALLARY-583102
55. SMT SYED SALEEMUNNISA
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
OCCUPANT:ASSISTANT TEACHER
W/O T A FAHEEM
15
R/A 89/A GOLD SMITH COLONY
III CROSS C B
BALLARI-583102
O/O G U H P S YASEEN SAB STREET
BALLARY-583102
... PETITIONERS
(BY MS. ANUSHA L, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
VIDHANA SOUDHA,
DR.AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
BANGALORE-560001
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHEIF SECRETARY
2. SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT
DEPARTMENT OF PARLIMENTARY AFFAIRS,
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA,
M.S.BUILDING,
BANGALORE-560001
3. THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT
EDUCATION DEPARTMENT (PRIMARY & SECONDARY)
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA,
M.S.BUILDING,
BANGALORE-560001
4. THE COMMISSIONER
DEPARTMENT PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS,
NEW PUBLIC OFFICE,
NRUPATHUNGA ROAD,
BANGALORE-560001
5. SMT. MAMATHA BHAT
W/O DEEPAK M HEGDE,
WORKING AS ASSISTANT TEACHER (ARTS KANNADA),
WORKING AT G.H.S. SARAKKI,
BANGALORE-560078.
16
6. SMT. ANNAPOORNA S.
W/O BALAKRISHNA L.G.
WORKING AS ASSISTANT TEACHER (HINDI)
WORKING AT G.H.S SARAKKI,
BANGALORE-560078
BENGALURU CITY
7. SMT. JAYASHREE A
W/O A. MANJUNATH
WORKING AS ASSISTANT TEACHER (C.B.Z KANNADA)
WORKING AT G.H.S SARAKKI,
BANGALORE-560078
BENGALURU CITY
8. SMT. AKKAMAHADEVI K.P.
W/O UMESH S CHIK,ATJ
WORKING AS ASSISTANT TEACHER (KANNADA)
WORKING AT G.H.S SARAKKI,
BANGALORE-560078
BENGALURU CITY
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI T.P. SRINIVAS, AGA FOR R1 TO R4)
THESE WRIT PETITONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH
THE ORDER DTD:15.7.2019 PASSED BY THE KARNATKA STATE
ADMINSITRATIVE TRIBUNAL, BENGLAURU IN A.NO.4077-
4080/2019 [AS PER ANNEXURE-B] AND READING DOWN THE
PROVISIONS OF NTOIFICATION DTD:1.3.2019, THE KARNATAKA
STATE CIVIL SERVICES [REGULATION OF TRANSFER OF
TEACHERS] [AMENDMENT] ACT 2018 [ANNEXURE-A5] TO
REMOVE THE DISCRIMINATION BETWEEN THE P-2 TO 55 AND
OTHERS COMING UNDER THE EXEMPTION CLAUSE AND TO
TREAT THE PETITIONERS ON PAR WITH THAT OF OTHER
TEACHERS COMING UNDER THE EXEMPTION CLAUSE; AND ETC.
17
THESE WRIT PETITONS COMING ON FOR HEARING THIS
DAY, NARAYANA SWAMY J., DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ORDER
The petitioners/Assistant teachers are before this Court calling in question the impugned orders dated 15.07.2019 passed by the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal, Bengaluru (hereinafter referred to as the 'Tribunal'), in application Nos.4077-4080/2019.
2. The contentions raised in these petitions are similar to the one considered by this Court in Writ Petition Nos.34626- 34735 of 2019 and connected matters. Vide order dated 26th August, 2019, the petitions came to be disposed of while directing the respondents to permit the petitioners to persuade in the counseling and while finalizing the counseling, the suggestions made by the learned Senior Counsel in letter and spirit shall be considered and the respondents shall pass appropriate orders in accordance with the Act, 2007. 18
3. Thus, directing the respondents as is directed in the Writ Petitions referred to above, these petitions are also disposed of.
Sd/-
JUDGE Sd/-
JUDGE lnn