Karnataka High Court
State Of Karnataka vs Anand Shivappa Kambale on 22 April, 2009
Bench: Anand Byrareddy, A.N.Venugopala Gowda
{.33 L, 5%. I =iif32f§{§ 5' i2=i}€i}!'% mfifigHMfiMxx£?a?Mwm§mfi&cfi£m?B$K3 £§'{RELE%1R{}A .<*u"« = §§mfiynfis:?§u5fi%aAya¥A@Ra%§§5 € PfiESE¥?w__ vfix . U 'fifi5HaggaiMagw§mC§g§5§§§§®g%$fi§g t véfigt . 1, .% H .
3?}:§a §§§::4?:s§;§a §5§%,g§:§$:r§::§3:§i;§5xi§§réz%{;<%§e€§;;g :;:;iI:é;:
€§§§i:;i,K§§,6s§§i%';}2$?;f,§4 §§$M§£§; ,_ V,w fi- V: . u.V §"§?:E3?{E sf Ké3I'§},?i_§'?:3;}%:{'§i.§ ' " "" H i..E:e;1.'<mg..E1 Cf.P.§.; _ " .
{3§1€i€§8.{§:Ci€3;§"}'.'.M -;_ __ V _ * " .vz%§13E'E§§.£;--1§NT §§i§jg%* S1113. A_::TLirzz.{i.§i22";fii« SEW} Affi}:
E . :'%§':a:';o:ii "Sij1iw1§3§§::3. E{é§3:i1i3é:}€ V" 1_ 1;'. "}'?::;z€#':12~1r:Es.;Ef::a.flé:z;'%._.E'~é ingapgm §-32u'ma.so{%:3 I ' -- V {E2177 .'§'i: fmi 2. '§'§<1§£2§«:z2:, £5 §.3§.';* Bigagzégg'. A !wr R ES*:§§'<f} N ff} ¥§F*§'E"8 'L_ fifi:$r§§$fi&gfifi§:Red&y;A§V fin %»2§ V' A. ,'iE_"'§;1.iSV=iififi.miz:.:aE A§§3€:a§ is fiigé 2:I:{if::;' E3€:.*:téx:>z: 3'?8{ 3.} 5a {3} {,nfiEN7§}V{::V ' RE'-3' £31' {.1162 Sifiifi §}'{"€>i}3'§3"ig mat: fihis E~ic:s11'h1€ €_T';::>'ufi; may he .__ §;'ia'1:3V§::€3:§ *:=;2 gmzzi Eéiavfi :9 E36 an apyeai agaiflsi the j':1{}gme:.:'2.i z§.:at€:€i '<.{§6}"{2,2i}{}.3 '§}aSS§i{§. Ex}? tiw ii? Aéicii. S:{..E«, fiijapiér, ii': S.iE,E.\§<3«4'}[2{}€}1 - é £333 31.563. 633?: X L2{}if}'€i-
a<:q'a1it'ii:1g fix: re:$pm;'1€i&I1t.sj 3{fC'3_1Sf?(i far {he (3'ff€?{",iC(;'E§ .§'s--:1:3iS}":a%31z;:
:2::':.»:i.¢;+1" S€<;.'?i{3I1S 3012 rsiadfl Wiih 35% 0f IPC amii Ezrzizier 2? 8:.
2'?{'2} mffirms Ac:
"f'}:1i:: Appaai having bfififiil heard __m1:ii_ 4:'€is_:i:§%}£é'€i'A:.{;.s1 V{L*§}'_,i'}<'¥': ' £ <':r:;mé:::g on fear pr::3.1:.m:;':<:$m£12.: tczday', :-f°1§'°3i?1§}--,D'-..§§VRz'fii§;?._EE§;:}7f, us--_ .A Ekiiivc-:;r'e{i mitt fcjiicwing;
éUDGI§§E §i"T_ {EL I"-ieagrd £316 fldiiéiiorxai Qie j€Q:.>f131s€} f<>:'° resp0n:;i€11i.
#32. 'flat: brief i1*--:1<:t.s«:2f {he 3:::é:i$::-- " ' A<::c0z:d,i,:;gv. {E15 <:<§::x{§1$%1i?§§iit, Ramappa Chazzziiazn Kamal, 'v.rh.o fives é;§_I<:>ng .s?§€§:rVh§$'«fa13:.§if;-grgzisisiiggxg of his 11;;«:>fi1er, bI'G{§':Ei'S anéi 1:313 §§§$€'€§'S~%i'f1:_§§ixt;f5 in Va4V.A'1Ea;§'i2._:1st: buiii 0:2 hm iané $11 E--{£:vi11a2 viiiaga 2$.?:;~;:-3 §1avi§1g.§jaii':é%§'1 $1; 55001:? 11.30 am. an (}}_..€}1,;2{}€}I --» W%::eI1 ' <;r§€'r' 'C.:§'izs:_f1(iL:'*:;asiEi:fi&<}1:-:3' {iitagi fffalliif mnnisag to {the {gum E1<§usVé:._a:':{§.V a "£'3e:;§--ro<.>m 311$? }<;)<:3-zrszi §;in13s:}ff:m::: imsizie -~ Z hi: ;3:§1;:>.§ f;::E}.i>'12.:e{§ £33; (3316: AI1a'fi{§. Sixévappa K_&mb3i£: and " 'Pagfamesiiimgf Efizagappa Bajzasogie who same rm:1.I1i:'1g, sac}: cf Wimm V' «wéiflt '§}Q{:€§'iflg a fire: arm -- E.§1€:§; shoiztfié ai. $326 <::*0mp£aina11't to get away
-----i{}5a:$m 31$ piacé -~ the <:e.mpiaina11*t. iII1IH€{Liiai€§}' <.:0n1}3Eir;a<,i and wen: om
-,__--;*E1is 1:m1;E';é%:* ami 0116 of his sisters-»i:1xiav:, whe zwzrfi ;3:'*£:se:3;t in 'thf: %:ms$€:, wem aisa iifhasifii (mi. 2;}? 13:36 absvfi two ~ may Ezave E2161": Szaiéi {X3 §..=._:'%.{:£3ff>? ;' 2€}O'§ ti: '%3a%J€ f::§2:<:E{i ifize ¥3£{i»~m:::)::1 §i{}{JI' (}_'§}f,':I£'}_, w§';T€3"t: {fifagi §'::z+;;{§73?:B§¢:{%:'1 «:*0i.s:?:5: eméi tbs =::3mpia'i33.am }.:a::ar<:§ 3 §«:_>::{§ S2313 amzi -- '{E':::§*r:::a;§}:'41{%':"« arms? Efiazigasagia C{«1E"i§t'.i 911%' (Bf 'EEK: §E€}E'i§§€ :«i:.:€.€ Wa.§é<é:{:§. .:«:'2%%:~:%§:,,V_ _' {E33 '.E'h:~': <'::;3:§3.g')§a.im'«:§1'é:§ his §.§;1f_}fifif?E' e1:;':"»:"§; S5§_§§*€%;é:'wi§é®.fi$§i*:?. {:*T§{i}:3"""i¥«;'£3;§'§I £2129' ' me: 31(}Ei.$ii {<3 §i:':.{.§. iigzaé é.§§."§,;+:g,;;.a?. E1315: §e:§Ei's:i(i, §§:1c=;:-: é:::2§.% "iz::*.:::{.§ 'v;'€:1"'<:* h;:»:<.§}jg; é;f2j'u1":':i§ zeizsd 'i.h€I'€3 vs,-'"a$ '%:E:::0d 'a:):3?€:;i_h.i$ {Va "§"'h€ c3r11_§;i23é::a§':':., afiai' Vhzéaviigg.V1{3§;x::;i:E_:%:€i '}§':;is ::<:ig§"1'i}e::s:1r2:~:rs -W "£323: 11€'32H"6§§§ 0?? whmxg 4sgs;?z«:s;_ 2 E{i3£:émtE':j€':§";2;§.s:':;é;§;*';« 'fmm his §L§.::{}, fézzaiiy :"r:fg}<::1"£;s::::i the §:'iCi{i;;i:_:i .E:::§"*E%3e." '.1: ...é1:i--:3::fi%1.f~3;j; E9-'o£%ce S§taii{>:'1 at. ézhfiaat. :%K4§ gun :12. 0:': '$391 (333? f". _ {E53 "i"'%;.z'i §_3~::i'y§C%'? h2zfi.§§:';T;§§' '§'£~i}.<'if?;§'.}"'<3fi"§;3 invfisfigaiéwzz had ;§E.E€£:E 3 (.331:-1z"g::»:» shfizizi €37} -- aiiitgéé " tE_1a{V.E§ Eééés-gi vami $01118 otiwrs Egmi <':<}:3f::1:iii,&<:i $1335 1§1":ia;t1€'1?--.{§'§" :.f;;:c~: '€f§ha;1d:"é;'$§.%ia}*a :'%;%':i¥.ra;;3p:,: §{a3a.:;%}ai€*., {E15 :»::kie:%§' i::z:{>?.ht':r €:zf Ai3L;3,:ia;§T_SZ<:if:§'€2.§1§;:<éV }£_3§.§';i§:2ai:2 «~ 2;a:.:m:'§ §i:.:--:2;<§ 325:3": {,Y{}11V§(3i{':{i. {£3}: zz':m":,§(::* ahozfiz 8 };€:a1"&:f+_ §.31fi<33".§€§ €..4?"':§% é:'1s:1§{ie:3§.. E3112 .§i(}i--'?'€Z'V€?I', Utmgi haii ssttzapfitifig {rem aa»-'E:%.:*'::*z:'* E15. was: u§:1ri€rg(3i§1g §:;1;}:"iSenma31t. angi had came ba<:}«: '(,3 '§'§1€1'€§@I" ,, Eiamicyafic hat} CE::esse€1 311:3 i".E1'L§I°€§§'E£'§:€§ E31213 alsng V' .___%.3£i{h'§fir2, §§§%1I}.BS(}{§€., 9:: .i--iC€i'(}1}.§}'i Q? %:h:: an.i;::0si§}*; fixat };1z51:"} 310% V i:f§;:>Vii1s§;§r:{E aver the }--'€8i'S, % £."€L.é'af,>3€5} §1£{}{?4-
{)2}: "E'§':<: ftltfizsx' ifiifiirxg a}fE§1€ i:'3T.2&2.§ *(f,T{>1.zri {hat Ehéi ffV'§{'i6i"i{i'.€ {if F"§£s~i 5:; '2 W323 ma: 9%.' §.i3§:éT1'{fS€'iE(i witzzessm is w3§£'.§';0'u%. Ea;1_jyj VE,:a'$i§'¢L E315:
fimiiizg €.'§1z~,2t tkzam am giarézgg (?(Z}IE'fI'£+i{§i(??;.i(3§f1S in :E'1€i_1j"éEariéi{;3:i§:{:=€*:_..£E;«aissm i:'1:::<3§*x'{::*t. 1;': {his :':":g23:"<§., flat: i€:3:°ns%ci §§E~'3? ta}::.*:.<:V_ _:"£;::_§;V i:{:1'<.21.1gi*i" 'iZ.§}CfiTf_ %i€:~;'%§23"§c>n.i€$ it} {i€3;110n'Si:'2:'ie E'.E'za§' fix: hasia: §';a1"§'a§4'iiVé:A<f:.23.{fi:£;€i_L §')€, 3§'f2§;2£'£:é{§_ _j zmd 3:13.39 i1:ii:f:€;1* va:ria'E;i<3£1s; i',?E3:§3'l_fi'E i';i:{ £§:%T3a;'ac€:§--f;"é$é{§ aé g;;Blé§:*§I1g <':Q:2?1~ad=;{r:ti<mS ta ::i§;3{:ar£i '{§2fi~.%.1~ €vizfi§;'é.::;.V<?:: <::3z:1§E&:ié=:1j;Q-I iii if is gtaiziaéridafii 'éi%1:~.iE_ "E§?':e 7a§.i:=:;C§€%'LE»:7iVé§z3,j€ in ivdging 31$ Firfii EE£fOi'l}1&i'£is'}§?: §%r:5;;§<;:1f£"<:§§i:i}s:i 21%}?-Ezzévsav §3:%t:;1'iieigi {(22 $5 faizii is figs: {.'EiSifi. it £3 "L1I'gf'f-iii" €33,313.' i}§1;av3Li":§g" 1°{ég,';§:3"::§ $sr§ Y€I:e c{>1e:§~'r31a;3a<.i{-iii ziésiuie 0f 'i§t3.€::
§}3'i;§3"Ei€§} ii is ?E>2..;.¥ Vi:E§§:Z§:1%S£<_E_§:ii3.§{"~3:§§.§.. c{';:'::;'}£z1i:':a§1t has 1:::1s§%m"::<;'§ {?.G§_§I'€§§€ ti; Ziezzzii e .2: <:€;1§1€"':z§z?§.i£:%.i: .:;::§=;, 3€:%.*'c}§-91$ E:':{;:;'£2"§; a'§'§.~:'i1' '£§iu?: .i§.1:::.i¢:§;sn'i anti w3L€.%} V "T£;f%2€ §.:::3:;£:§§2';g __;:§i' gxifmsz" ¥;é.é§"§.2a:.ggr;=::'3, .A %:i».:::_nL:'e;7§ SE??? ssfetizéés Eu §isig.§;§ig§§.i %;§;.%: €fV§£i{"3%;'3{.?f:'. <33'; §"€:*.{"ff§§E"{§ '$2; :n.§<€<ma:3*g§§§;2;i:>:'iT§ ifiiiiiféifi? g':1i22?:. {sf flit: a<:s:":.'21§;€{§ £~.:'§2::<:si8 ::$E:a.E}i%$i;i:i{i 'i§<i3-Ysixiii _.44a§§_y §'é:z:S0':'m?:§i£% <§0u%>"{ :,»m{'i iiéarzmi firze fguii gmszfi 0'5 81:? isgaxwz' {"3<3m'E '' " _"if+;»":',%_§ rrariig . £113: rii%::'::%?:{:€..
' ..}:'; Sm? 2:;ii':e:" %:1.:i3::{L fizz: {fi€:simse:§ fat' $2315: §'<éS§3é}::£':€§'}§ r::- '§:LEIX§§__j3§"§€?ii%"§Z:1{3;'*§ €336 13§'gc«$<'=aie3 §z'3,'i?;;":;1éi:is?s; ii}. ms: p:"{3s€CuE.i{3§': C2}-S{fi £518 6 <1??? 2353?: 5' ;_7'1{}iL'%*=§-
§'"0':.::2£':§ 3:3,' EEK: irizzi {;.'»<::'m'§ s:-a3::»§ w{;::.?Ed stzhmiit. ihai flit: §«ji§_i}§I}€iTié'3_§"{{3{}{?$§ mjt fiififii éfmz$:%i'§éé:'a2§"i<m.
3,3, 's§+£Ei E';§§2s*<: ;*€:~r:§§21i<11f£n£-iii ¥E:{*: z":?:{*{;:ti 21$ §€:.ng't?L _ .. _ " 24%», 'F%:6 7i,Z"i.':i.% {Ti<3u;'"£', T§'}.:=§3:. fsfauzfmi 3.321%: f::::sw;?::[}.g._:z::2f::-s'z:ié:fi§s::;;51;"§'.hcé'~. " f§.::<té{%€::3%:. §.':as:'i e:3i:<.?m°;"€::i 542$ Elfii} " .:'3ar:Vii --:f:§*'3.{:: §«Q--;:§:2;=:3}aini. "as-'::,1s éséiigezéi 21%? 15.453 §).1E£..:v%V§7fL',v%ifE§§§.'§ :{§':i§1a;§?§§s:a?§~¢é::~; §3v;'}}Li€',€": SE;s§.{i0.z2.= Tfiéés is £"3."Eiit"§.("5}.'§§(";f§ «E33 E§:1hw~E.:":Sp€::%"£<3:' "£'¢'E3.f} 5:{:0r<'%,fr{f§ ihss <?0z::§3ie;i;1:1 ?§ II§.€., nM";:»%,*§%:j.f=::j;<', "§;é:€ €j'i§"'§ 34:33 2;': 1213 ::vi€k:nct:, s;%zai',&5 E-"<;~ii<:e;=: Sir;-3i:i:);:,, 3:6: hézii 1"€f*;",'.{EiV€'{'§ 2: 'V-V;'§' Q12: 3 E 636 ::2.m., til:-3:" i}*::€agi §:2a{i héiszz m't:i"si<;z%»<::i: "i133? This has 1*:'a3'.:2;€:{§ ea S€I".§{}'¥.'i:'% d<>2z%3i gm E0 333%: §T_.i;:3c: iE':V§T"V§:iéi1€éat;£:;£(i 31;: i.:<:a':;<iz:<f;:E" {sf 132:: _§}O§i("7€:'.. V. '' *'.§i':ks: iifiai {Z-i:._:;r§ Ems 218%? ibzzzzci that that §;:(;mg;§z;i.:2*: mzifz giatas E '§§':;::§i"§§%;::1:'_a.¢<;~::.%§€is~$g.i ?:;}e;:z§" 2,1542%? Ci) ij§!1'§§"'f,9' *§;:%.s'£<;£s in Cfvififiiiifiififg am: ;:;imz'{i€::* ';=m:i §E:3i;4._t§.;$;__:T':~:' is-331:3 :'t:§?et°s::":.=;?€ ii} é3}'}}' <>§.§':.€:* {:§::+je<?£ Ewing usaiiii, ., "§'§";.<;: iriaé {'.Tl::m1'i E2:-gs» e:1z:;:::§':asé:ze:.% {E33 aS;i::{:{?i wéfiz :f::f§i1*<:m':w::< {.5} ':}..;£;§: §§a3§Sf:«i::<;§:'%.£i1:; 1"6p:.:m' {ma Eijaii §iVii.i€E§'1{?€3 of ms {'§i'§{.""i{')i' W%:i'3 c£>2':ii1.:<:"if:*:{i i}.j1%:@:s€;a;'§~I::aaf::"'{.:é:32.. R. 31:; p{3é§1§',:f::'§ 01:3. 'ihai iii ELEM': (>pi§13',@:.; 5.3:" fiifi :§«:><'*"Ee::z', ¢:§':€::°{:: W'i":§'°f: :2mE'£'T3l§::»;i£i= in}; mfétégt {EH Etiafi I£;1:%:::z:§ zmii féiélfit, af "ih€"'i <;i€:»;1?€'::5s${t{§ @ {',"i_§€. §.1_f§. ifiiééfé 5 2{3°i}*% za;';~232"i. fzmizj g:,x.::: gigs)? i:':j:1:a1{:s~; and ihai £:i.:":a€}2 W233 ;}r<>§3a.}s'£§g :{T:%73§fiE§e'3=:i '{2}; {ha §fi}'L12"§i~7$ 0:3. 'flit: htiaii i'aiT§:<%:' 1335:; {hit gm; 3£1{>f{as:'--§;E1i{_§'%é _._E@. %':a& $'Eifi%fi'€{i an <3!§'::t:=,1" _pa:"%'.s 0;? E133 §3z"x.§};'. '§"i'f::: €:riaE_ .{{3i;§'§:;"t.,V --.':§3.{::1"cT.?'%3:"€~.' vV§'1.;_¥£§;§ {"£}1','éC}.Eiii€f{'i %:%'§ai':' £316: <.i{::11rg;}§aé3'2a_::'i 129$ %§avfi.i:1g{ };i_1€§§{§§.éé;ii{'§{j§.__§:i§f3§QféEEi. ;'\;~~_1_ 4: izazrézzg 1:sz:<:§ figs g:i§_:'1{,i'i;:'zg 3i.{>;;<:§ »w§1%<?i.: '}:':;: *is E§E§if7};_:..'§'§}§:'?E§£{'i?€# 31;;
frag': 'aha': §'ro:.;§ gyi' t%3:::=: Ezmlszz $5.55 $13; E}f3 ' 53? {>5 :3v§<is'::2{:€, is an 12mg};-'g¥:::§£:'3T;:;_'Q11 '.?'_«§."'iL%','f févvéixpévaizg Ehéft 3€*s.rm°{--:
§3.~::~g2:§ ixsjziziieg wliaicél 'We?,1'€ Emii §h.<:'1*£:=,f0re, file': {via} {."§01..:.;:*i Eaaéguifatiigi ii; is, 23;_:;1a:::<s,:'§{1%§; '~.§.§1.E§'é"gQ€E§ {<2 1&6: i'f){:t'i, <3? ijirgae i:;atie.r.
31?'. fig .fL}T§€§iiéi"'E'§f}§?€§e'?i§Li§3VE§:i i:::~.§:§":a:% ::::.;:1:<s;g~: 2:}? cz*os*s~{3xam'%2'T:.a§;i=:;:1 <3? §3'$f~ E. 3:; 2 w.%':i<?%: Vi:ias_:>{" :;ég13..§£E:j:§1i1:gté; _5E:i§~'.~ }Zi€3i§i§?;i{'E{ii mi: by 1.33.3 %ré:.--':E ifimmz, anzi %3:§§';§<:'i"ia far'; wésjat. :";;f2§. '$i8'§{i:i"%:.iE§;$:" $3.1 fig:-E {7e'§E7Ii§}§3;iii'§. :31" 31:; iizafég' "::§§g:r:3§;3:;I2§"éiz3;';h{i;:'3;§cE1i£:§:' 33%;? éiimzzihangagapa, {ha f{";»:.fi:s::2' {lfif "fix: a§:a:;§5:z_§:2i2é;--::a;i':_§. ':a:é}.a:'§ éZ?--%:12maga3::{i §.'§:a€ cézfsri' §};"sr3%i:E':::° $3.?' 3326: <;%<3;.f;:1§3'£a%z':2i2.:3;§ §s:i:§§:€':&§$:'.:S 'éiifzii ;e7§{:i;f*':é¥3t:{.i in $16 :.:m.z'{.§€i' <'*;-5&3 :2? {.7:§;a3t1£§.1'z'~;:e:Eiiafig $226: $§€i<~:§f §i1";:e?;.%::3:* 21;? Fir}? a2z;%:<,:e was zémie ii: <.§,€-:a%;?:. :--::§3<:si,:E, £5 }"'{'--€:ii'S __§;::*i«:>r '$1.; $226 }}:':'~:.:?;%:I.§;i'-:%,§2{:és;§€::'3i -~ §f%;:e;3::g§':. 3,235: 'ilfifik ':5-'€:z'z=: ac%{';'z3i*:i,£::£ 2:}? iigés <iii.':;.«:2rgj<:s - Kiss
--Efi:%é:§ ' {T3<3i1§fi has E:::3.r:§ fixsgé '§.§'E§S <:<::s;:::;};1a£«:<?';1§;;.2z';, 33'}é:'i{§f§ Efiéfifwi 2%; P'i:"x!'~,§ ";.3;§%i5:a:': w%%i2:3.{:s:~;:»:$, iE'l§§f1E"€:'.€§§{*.{§ in ::.::1;'}§>m"¥..%31g i.§'1f:' Céififi ag;:£:é1'2§:%; fizz? :&<:f<:,.*':4:s:?€§ in §§'.'§.{i ;.}1r"€::«;{::';E' i'féi'§$éi.'x g i"1§%E,.5£¢if;3€i:Z Liiiéifiiié 28* '§".E'z{': E15513 {f:s::s1zz": Exaég a3.:;<;> Eimimzi tixai. §.,E:§.«.:% s;i;e;£:::':?;:::i?'«._;:;%%Z3. §'1"§'«.f»«.E €13, {."iP§ fiizzi E35: w'2..»zs 4éz"z.§%}r:':1€(i by §'}§§§§f°E§v 3:. aijmzi E. .'i,{}{}_:s'>_§__m{ ':3.é<fi'§L'"-?i_:e'f}'a;..:::; {>37 11hr: §ET:ii;E"»f'§iiE', T%a;f{:::1:} E36: w:;'--2s ai §"2a§}e:i E"'<»:»A§;§»:*:: Sz;1{:z:;;--[§:as:'«;:;a:a: :"§€;'::§}":,. 38 25; E;E'1i?: *:é:m:: es? :':a<fm.1.i':'"§:z2<ir€i sf' 'E.,§;€?: §?:.3;,<'?i.<:'§;:":.:":?:--3 §?.§I.E"§.4§:i'€':"':,"§',"é§.=i';i3§'§§'it@v§iIEg iii}. -' .§3§~%'-5:, SE35: §5"EI*€' .:--s.§;:.§. §}:iigii.312:E <'ri'>:z3p£a;§?_3§;§ 1%?-':«2:':»«;. V_§;%:.:'1§ i.§:':'§f:i.;'g.?j3;_ i5}C_i§82i3 ii)? izafi eié:*E§vc:3r{:{'£ 'Ea; figs'. J§vE§«-'£7 .:~.mz.§ 31.13 isiiz; f.'fi"'if}S§§*'{jfX8.IE§}ii1f»§§.i{}i'§, is S§.£:i"§§f{§ €213:
ii. wa.s Si-Em ¥i§"m:3'a;g§': 3%? i'£4?{§5'.«- Pa-'fa; ggzfh 'il§}i;:i.V'§:§3;z{§_()£"S{??§'Z§{i{£312 £331 £133: §'4"i:'S%. E:':,§E}§'1§:za§'iaa';. Zé4~{'<?:'§;$:>§"§ 1}}; {$25 VE..3'€7',.'iV,V i;%;:3 ;$.:a:£':t% :'$~...zf:-?»:?e.iiv€::"i 2:: '§{}.{}{% §3.1f;.a. -~ '$15: {ééiiafé $.11: ?£.3":»3,2;'"§;s;13.;.%é;%;$i;>:3. 3;*;{§'-'?1§1fi._ gE%E"iI'1g <:{3r2'E;'aa§.i<':iim1s Ems; $521 31::
Erézié iZ{2'i::": in e:%r:'>.i;§f:s": ;;.E§ff g:3:;i:;§§;i'1<:§1i:$S <;§i'£h€: E-?'§rs'i §x'2§2'}§'1;;3aii::=;s}. §€'e;;e:"'§'
19. if §.§§ f§'if}ii'!'?IE'jisi'?' ?'4§§uIV}L}'§;"{i_'§'€){4§.§%f}'33§ ihsazi "€336? '€331 {'302.f1.;'i. has §1€§{§ Ehaé me géiiéi 1:'.Zif'{.§",'§<.i z~:§<?':,t%;._:~;a::%. ii; .§.";:é'::'_ §:'}é;7{)?§'{?:{§ §}€i}='€§'g:{§ saii sfiasaéziaifizii :,§{::u%:':E:
" EC}; E-3.}.'E.E<3.g:<,iig§2%' <22'? §%'é1:f"'a£i§€3vt: §'§'1§iz"1;:'1§i§<:$; 3%-'hiC§'.i. {T£&3'i§.2{)'€ 213:3 mr*erE<3a3k@<;§. ziss %.;v's:~":i*;;::Tg; ,ii§'§.§';{}:?' "'s:.~*§:3:3';i:«2.§;i§<:=.::3.:s; zzrzéi i.'€T3?fi';{'Ei.{§ii{.*'i§€;3Z1§§, §%":: 33%;? ':1z1a'§:s§<'-3 Si"; zagzmz *'§.'{é:': Ai,§"':é: £'%:'i(§.i5?;'§.;>A§ia§ ;;":?Ea3:.{: §"':;a%§£i:' ?~3r0s€:c:':'z:i'{;>i" é'E':2"if'i $233 &§u--:i§;::§::€3.:%' ' €2:a;:§{i:' ::t}.1ai§::§:;.gc $:T1'f'f€§°s f§"€}iE1 2":3'1§; §}€fi""L?iii'8{3 r{5a$o.r2i::;g.§ €31' that. i: ;%;:»:S ' {}5;:f.'i§'1i(§{§Ez{*§3{§ anjg ;:":21€£>:"éa3 §iVi{'§;&§3<l?i'": av3.i§a§:3'i€ {:3 €'3S7il8§3iiS§i 'ms gu.§}§ :13? figs :€§{f{'.'E,iE-§{?{?i §T3{fif€'%i}§l{§. 2&3} I'i'.aS<.>i'2;;:'i3kt (i<>Ta.:§..2E. {)1} mg {}€h{'ftE' .§.':8.:'3.{i, xi? ii; ;f2{>Ss;éE}i€: £0 1':»§.§$é% §::z"i'}'::::I' <,gu{::$§i<.;3.1ss as '*i.»::: EEK? Sufficiiimfy Gf {':Vi(.§€§'i{?E': €332. % €:4-1',§;"\}::,3k;'£'/éié-'v.:}:~':'-/:'-;§,,:§; 2§3{}5% 1"'-.
'T?
§:=:"m::=.ia§ '<:c€3 « 2-*+:h§:t*§1'x2a;*e {its 2353:: gm 303:: $23 {:3 iaztgzs as; tbs:-: :*:'?2:s<;1;:é:z "
E % {ff §.1i;:': '€}£'ié1§ {L'f:i§z;2:*§'. i§.§;z:.§f is §;'::f§i£:i£::§€ 3:; -§§iEi-$?3,§.i} £3125: ';'1;:2:"§ g€1;:{::::-.%._} 2.1. '%%''<: {£0 szmif §E.E'"i€.§ mzy gzi<;u.:2=:..i fear" iI1%.€Z'§€fi'€i§3i?{f e:2;;','::;'i« .}§i§1s: is éi{,',{f{1I'E.i§£'ig:i§E' {'§§E§§'£13:SS€3{§« JUDGE {°~9JUDGE "'3"-.
~e \