Karnataka High Court
The Director Of Income Tax (Exmp) vs Sri Ramakrishna Seva Ashrama on 17 October, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
éj%:'%i ~ £.E€e:.:v:;:§a_é{:_§:'«§am ;é:;§e:m .533;---§;{ga__:':;:_::M4 .__E-};%'%',5'%{EF§.§I§5'%, T --4'.4;f§._.€:5";:s"§2;;%K53;.3->,;afi::'§»»-5;a5:>;;%§_~z.;::'§---EEfl .513}'2?<[}§i.;5%'E"'E%2§ xx: wfie: iaigzigé-~g <:<;>:,.::mf <72? .%{j$iE:%.?'€.f;'§§Eyi'£:X§§:.i;.§i. M ma?2;.é;%;;g?;.;g:f§%é:iz::[V"
_{j):'%."E"E:ZiE} imzszs ':':~:£:: :_ 'gm? ;;:;;s:{ {i}? <3{'IE'§'{T}§§.§i§§"V:3v<f}§fE T' ?RE$EMT:;
$53§§NBm:MR&K$§€§§fi3m$§j;:;
ANa_ = *m_§s: §%{,"§N"'E§1...E. MR.;§§:;}S'E"i.{i ;%2;;x:3': §.'::s:;;; MAE?-E <:"I1¥°a.E'\E{;:'.'2¢:ié:?§'{T§§¥'-2?) "E :2 .. " " % EETWEEN:
3.. 'E'§""£ E: .:_>.;R;_§:%;<:_?_E_'{;:I::+; ii}?-'T. .§Eif;{3.f%fE«§1::".E;AX.
::::>\:§%::%¢§ PT ' {j:I.ga., §:3:.;E.._:_ Li :1 Ex: (2% QB E;-.E:?€S §~%<:§;:;E;j:;,§3;a:;%:;_;<¥;:T.;j;R§2. 29 mg; §£'§§{3ij§EvE E: ':'f;:>~:;{}§§*.?1<.t:§:z, §::;§;%g:ra;::.;>':*::;:e::\;%s;;-kza ;".s§,§s::3;:L.z§: §~£{}§-EEIE ., A _§V§.§'&.?€;§}Afi: :1;a:;:§§§:) Ek';a::>2>%§5§%,;m;%';'::; 332%? A§2v;éL%;;ié;§{;:é;;%':*: 1} §r<}§2 32%;. EE2:§EiS§-§'A{L'§-Efixija, 5%E'T;fi£'<i}{Li;3;§"'E%Z§§} { . . §:"€iE%:ff%i §5}€.'}?'§ EL'? §%:.E'§'§' w < ;\§i€&w&§Q\&x %%&%mWA » E} {1.?'E§j i.i?!§.i4?£,??'$if'§.j :::2:' <3:'f2es~ €{"f:.i{.f€£f§{3F"£{Z§. :":'2s»;a':'.§zzz'§»:}§'z :':;ff%3r;'a?aE {'0 in :'~?:.§§§--»{_..'§'_m.£$€ {i:'i{2d} {W s~;:zz.§:>--<"§a.z.::se {:95} 2:33" by <zr'"i§i__? ?":&;.é;g:§ii:;:':?"{;}3' afizssr §.;"::;i_.§ §zg§'z1:3:: :'e;§{%:"3'"g?:£ £9 5:": :=7}ia£..?}?{.?.§.{;..:{£§}§F§?' V. {i§%:i'.£€3§ G?' :;z.sb--<.?i.a.z.g.5a> {E-"££;'i.E of <*E':é:_i::~.est:=.V{§L§%;"§§ _" ' 4}? S%3.<_::i:t:2": 1 {)1 -
fixg) E.cm£z.{'§0r'T2 -- E7' <33' $133?' 3;} :5: 23;} <.3f::: ; E:=EE,l b ~ CE azz ..=:;<;?. ii. };°51..;f'§...::?£'§9k E z';_7<:.-mi? é-{:55 ':;:2i.?1:%3f' Eagzié <;}?r;>E_iga€ i<:>1.{:_:._ {iii} Eiée va_E_'1.:é:% afrsf} 2~"::*:.;a;? :'§')z:j::fi§_-;%;_'i'§.§"tag? or §3r«:':sf§t: in vi§c!;.:v.. :31" ;f§;=:§z:§°},»i; £_,;2j::%§:»§;E:;_§::% '¥;.§;r'::>§<?::" <_'§;mss{3.e=,. {2} i 5, ;i7.;%'}~v {{§'§"_Sc%_{%!..i§}.1:f«' E 2?';
" {§%;i;i}' :I1;_z'V13? "spc':;:j§i21§ 7;sii<'}vx;2'%:':{'t.za3 {tar ':3<':%m':f§€,; <_;%:§.";~£::f % §j§'2:*::<;2 V'.§§é:::ié§.':,.:is;§i.«:;?: i::<>i'z:<§<;%€:§ :.:_z:':€i::2"" sa1,3b-- ":;%A§;;_:;,£.i$é-"r Em}. -se§3a:?:<:i§i{1;:§E}F §.;;jraET;iT£:<E {EL} $18 %;<.;: §2"}{,'.{?'§ i§}€.:§}{3'E.Efi%€1?§§ 1sy"E:{§1?y'. :§é"'§§.:"{'.'7{7'.$.'§«'r:"L.i"°fi§-"" E-'i§"}{',§ €>§{:§1.:$§:«='<%Ey §?;'>r E.h.é:. .5'§;}é:::'§"<>m:azicg-é 05 332i"? {§;z2,%:'§:':$ s:>§ 22:': {':§§w%"§{*:s;?: 3;"
{'3 :1': g} E <T';z§m"; iffifi. {"3 E' 33 $0 5% i};
§i.§§':.:%E ;:?::"':}i aiié'E<'§w'2';::'§{"'§? ;::*24.§z";':{>:{'§ Ea: §§"::': ;4zs:es;{f:&:;:.s<><:* <:?§é'E'":<i=.:' "ii"? :'"z3e:,:§'. Em §}{'fi"f~;i":=§'§:53i§ {i'?y;f;_;§{j'§'1.;'&§€;'f=.5 2:3 ':.E":::'* 333.21% :%.,:'.§'*;<.?':1.% %;f:":::% <_§:.::'.i_a*:::a £133" £42.23; a"::§'§E{':<:>, 5% /"
= 51%? n 'z.iE*::i:s;;V 'V {hf} . V<f_%§;:> ;' ';:§:%2::.§1 ._§:
E "} {§I"' é%z:"1;}E{.:yi":'2<:%:";E mi" ;:§m§'Et:. z;::"e:=* r;:z'{.iimv:.:'i}jJ g_:=s::'i»:'::":.m%s:'§ bjg; him 0:" 2;? 2:3 Tg}E2:m-;* wiE'i:;%:*a: Em i.3Z'{'§i§".EE1.£"§:{§-' g><:'>:*§%:'::':'m%<'i %:i;§;' him {':.:' .zf::;._Vzr: g;>E;~:<__%<3 2,*=.?§1e:_::*§.:% ht: {.3':f<:E.*;.:":.2;'a::_°§%§; :%;>:~;i:<:i§~{=r5ig'VV::§: I':?'_§j§' <_t<_2n'1§;3z:.%z'1ss2':{<3 };f'i§1'11 fm" é;'_Ei'1<:% E:'1:§:"<.:ig:ss{:%}::§.. {*;<"s:--§":"-- 0%" Eixfirzg:
§i§'Zé;'7 1-'2i§.1.E€? {_}_§° ,:;3_:::§.: §:§{%:'é{:s€'§i <'f;:j T§:.e-f;:*e:.;é..2§:€§'§?i}i%x w1'1é;*ih¢;::' :30_:'1w%';:i:_§.'E.§E<? :£:::1'£'.'=:---ta . §§.€}{Vf'_§ 1;; 0 L f.I}E'}Eé'ii}{'}{?{--§ .£§'{j>§}'}»-'"£'1.V:..nf1?{)'}{;E'}§i§2ii.i"E§f;"Eii.Ji§'E..{f;'£" by 211 {ii:'{:~?:vi.~z':r;* '£53.-« *4 '.¥h.{} E'1a.s5; 3;
see 233$-1;i':23;z1£".i.:§ _ §3i2E".'<:;::.:f{:::§;'E" V £.i'§';..;% a%0t::.g32?:.:1:s:1 <}:r 3, :*<3?--ii2::ii§'<.,.-*6' <'Tfi"_ V§'.'§i'1'€iv...{3§:§§"i'{7?.{f}§' 5:23' smash V . H j.§}§i"fS%:,§}'E'E;"E3.1.'E--§ii ;;%f:'1:g,-*'...%{::1'1 ;;>z::§a:;§ 'E:}_}_»-' 22.21}? $'1,L§{3-:'"§ ':<:::s;p<?:<"%E :23" i:'3iE"3§/' <:}bE§§.g;aE;§{;>:1 "-'V g~.
% w_1i§.i{.?'§w ,' ,_§.§':.--: fkéi' s=:a.a{':%: §}::"i§2'§"§3§;'f'£'1§§ ws:_>:,:.E=:f§ ..§'z;;2:rs% %.'}5'e:?<=§: ;:}e;:}&3;"i3.Ea? '§:::§; ézziw {i;§:°:=:<%%'.m' <33' " v <32' §§<=>:'::** * 'E24:-=. rs:;{§3 2 2.:..f<.;::'<> i {i :
§._Et-*i:'::r v;:z:§:.2_:_: 0? an E:>é:."m"f::§'Ei" <22" f§>€::"a:§;.::%s§":'.é;: ':1-=2r'§'"2s::i§:<ir;'* <%<;:":a;c:=§"i'§E1;§<_? §E"3§{.3 :"§:_<_>::':::3;' gm" .:2<:§*:':? {.::;:§;s%:':<;:§;.§ §::2j.; 232:; 'E'€'?§3§"€if§?3é:'f§'§§.2:§_'{iwii' §':':<;%:"2§.§a_}:'1<*<:'£ $3"; <'f'EéE3§.E;§%i"? {iii} <22" :;?E:m;%:;% {iv} {Ff s:s:,.1§.;':»A:~..e.:a_'»:¢§:§<'2::'"; {EE Ea-%;=%<%§"§<',é-2": E iifiié 9:' %;}}f :;22..:_'::§: '\:'":
IE3.
£53" '--§§§€'.Z§:'%€%é;?
5 3 §':}a;%':':4;<}::.: aaxéz €;s<:~:«;': 'Ex--E 29;} E' z E?
L/,.. -
E3 ':'3ci*§":s€>§E:" éIiE"1f;' §::<":§">:m" isa ;'a;%c%z:%ivgI1i:3E::= by i':.E':1::~, :2:g>':*::s;::§:'2.'£.;I:.€:Ew as?~Ts:s-e;a:.:§s&-;<..%:? E:§:§E1€.'§i'§ g;3€--.zfs5{:::"': iéééizzgg §'3s*:'e=;":§'§<*:' E3: ihiss 5;::§:2-:§#§T;:=%;.:;e;{: :"€%i?:-%r:*¢%d é-ES :'.%1::-'= ""§.i>e:=z";{-*.§i<'*E:»:2 z":;.-»""§~«~~2: $513 _ _2::: *§..-f"
s:'~;zzm §}£?:§{§ bf; 'a"ht* :'s%g:::°c%$:*~.:"a*é.2i':'i'§;%;:
in '27:>;s:e3;:u';%<*'é. 0? a:':}; V-:;'§:"'sEi--€;_,;' z;:S;se:s%s:€€:,.
i',i§jj;z'3 23%';-i::.?2; V 'ms
52):' 5§;::{?%E3 §3.'::';.:~4,-"§'§'E{?I'fi§"3.._ %;_I{"?:}=*;VzE::§._ E'§';§€.?'e:% u Ei§3{?;é".T;{'ié _:
§}E:.:'g;'£ibI£", by i'.E":<% -E:i;<é:'::%£;§z.:%é§;'y;I A {V} Eiilijy' SL.;.m {'TE;1Ei~3"g3Efi--2iE3§.;é:% 'Ed *§,.'{j1ij€Z}5E}}€%-§I.£-'£E{ ;.mci{:*,;* £.'i:E'~::a£zs:=*'€%'~_{iii;Ia§é'€%f§§§§~}.,p 0%" Se<'*'i.Ee:}z1 28 :3: S{":{".':'{'.§ €33'?! :>':.'_ §;{"::!j€?{".é'i{j}E:"§ " {val} ;'2;>{:':}j f*;%{E._E1'1€ ':i%'}22£i"g_§€:;i%_3§.<:...: ii; i§I}{?{}I§'E€~"€ E3.X ':g;3:'§.§:?i'Te%3:f_ <t.3:2%;_.:':;-555- iii §'7.--S2:é{':é*.§(>n. 28 :_}
7.§vE;>:_§ ;»:::§§* :1'E4§?§3E§f'{"~.4£§--§};:iI'§§{E&'i,§i}§{E E0 é:'1<';:i§m%;%-iaX_ :§c::§:_:3r~<f=§z5sz.:é:;{? {}§i§?3} of $£§€.'.§.'§.{.EE'E 28:}
5.-,"{2:<%'}..A 23:3}; m ;¥é:zm <'%E'1&:°;gg:3%::§§}§€ "sis §i§{E(}E"§1€?-'§i;'?£}<:
..T_2,:;:j:a:i£:2:* {fig-?a:.:;s:;<>: {iéiiré <>§"i%E€:<%€;'4§:;:': 2§%:§ %;%}:: :I'2%.§:,.:<?- <55' ;_2.§":§;' §f}éf§"§%f§'§E. s:..}';" _"§}€;"fE"{1§é.E§$E§;€i '€&iX%fi§f}§{? 2.:'z'::;'§é;:':" {.:E22:,.z::ssz% {iv} :13? §_~§a:*a.:£.i<}§'} 2%; §:¥{,'E zmjy" s:a:§2':': {..tE':_;:.§';:é%;;aE:}Eas Eu E§'E€._7i.;%§;E":{?~§..é;§X. :1':_':é_:E<;%:%° :'fi§;2»w.,:&_:~;:'fi 9:} <3? E%::={'%§::.<>:":_ ._§::§_i:2.:':: :4'-;:..:"é'§'§§i%::%§'. %;"{';s '%E'§<? ;_'}1'<">vi:--;§{:::.;<-'»; {sf §§{':'§.'.'i'.iE«:If:§"":E'-é €:':E{;% €33 :.E:::=:
{vi} gm}; :';'-'-:g:3§%'.a;i:E §_;{;.1.i:'1?'~% (..'.'{}2.:E:"§§£.?é.'é§f}§é? 2z1'1{ii;%1' $€i':'{I.'.§Ii{')IE. 4573:
{E-".i.§E éhzi f;}2"<_}€§'%_is3; éiiiifi ;g;~=:§:'::'='; 5}? 32.12}; ':::sz.:;.f;~;i_':'2::§'; §'E15?éi.U'E-1.I'1(f"{I' z:=>;3.3*':'i<%{§ {H1 333;' ,?."£7'Eg?v.'.F."{','%:.3.'a%i.E" V' §:'::§:..zre3:':<'%é=r. eti>mpz1_:':y.»:_>:jhy 2:. <4é.:%?»A:§;}:»€;?§'";::,§i>»;<E*-_ V &§<)<:§_ei},.a. s:..*:.:m ;;:'1.:: i ecii, E113 ;1€3«.{'<}_3rfiizzifiafigé " i'?;z'§ i':"§": A S<>§:i',§{}:.'1 44 €.}f{'* 23523.: s;":,2_rg:3.1V.z::; fife bi"-2 :~.<::'§.:;<';E'1 ';:s:'{>.fi¥;s~: 'é.:;«.:';1«t'E. ;;§2::ir:':&;_ 'E=3§£'.= vi:f€u€? 53$' ;;)r<;>vis~;:ic:>:'"::»; <1e:;:"§2.-;%L3;:r1<§%§%_ in ""'-::.E_°sa:'? E?'£af°§.:s.{' S<"E1€é{} :.1§{-'-3*; T -. ' 5%} E*""r'<_>';"3:'1_ .'?;..E;j:_{?-_ 2::§;;i§:':'jss §§s{j§ ._5de2%'i_*E.:;%':.§{:::1 <'%.§;:z.: iii: 35-; s::_};_:::ar 'i1ha'é.f Ehc. £3€.3§.'::2§$_€.2:«fy'"'ij{§:}.E..1°§§?:;a,.:i1.%e:'}i'*: :1-=:'_*.{=-'%i*:.:'*i,;-':'{'E, '::>j;.: 23 §'::"':,:$t';. amii «:;_%1'e:%{i}'.§§::'::e:§. ':=vh<}§.§}-9' :1}; ?g}':..§:5'i:i:;'" €02' <.%E":22u'éE.z=:%3E<% at T:"&§ig§i{>:;.§::; '3:,§f§3£;>ss&:§; {§:""'--??f€J" §E":&<i'.'-_ i;ifi:S§;§..':i.2ii::__2:'é i§':~,~i§&iE}§i.$E'3€i*€j§ :sg%'fs:}iE}f BE' §';::%:"€:§;js,-=«-':J..§%_>§7_ s=sai_{'E' "f§-:2_'r§3<§s4a%::;: w{;;:_.:is::§. s'*i_3:Ti5=,':i%:..a.2;ii: Ei"E{.f{>§Z'E§? *:%£'=iV§:.%'§.'§:': é1%:é., . :§:ji;"E ti SE13': §.€r.'§{}i.'§.7v $3: . .;§:§é*.:'<§%".i<':::'": ii fig:-%2;z.E:e: a:%*§E.E'2 E.:r'::.%<;'>§%;:s .§:'<:;:f:'fa. pr{:>§;§~::°'z'y °*.§'::i::E:';§ ,;€<:s§i {%'E":;22§"§§2:1E§'§s=> 51:: §"<E§§é;_5;i{"}E..§$i §}"§§I°§,§§§§'%§$fZ'.%. ii: a"§s:§<'%E2I2:"§?:s; 6 =.,/' § § 'E'a"&'§'?¥$§» 'f3::":{":.<:';§.1':€ Sé<'t§. W2": §'":;:::s":;% E15; :3 ':'a::.§2::§*:--;'%";i=:':'1:i:§ §E':<;=: ;'=Ia,-z.%;m::: in A{"f{7}E'§§'.f:?.X'E" {>5 23 {%.z2§';f;§'::.;'2L {}§}§}€"§E%{'7{§ ?ii':» 222:'; {'?X§:§{'.':§E{'§i§IEéFifi: ii' is; <%;«:{§i:e§é;2:'-3% 5:? 2:2': 2'32 ggémé 5:? gm :=%:=;1?j:z'.*:'i::,%; ::j'2*:§}i*;.212E. :3? iii} a1':';:3i".:.::'"::'":y ;~:1":y ::Ti;%:~T~=,»E:E:'2s:%t :::':a;as;§~; e:__:f" §:><_;{if; :§§s&:;u<.% i}'12,fi "'--.T §E'1;.i}»-' E36 {;§3:'«5::f.ii'1§§n§::3E':e:.% fE'€;3i"f"i its; é<.e:.::';'{.:::,::*:<:ii§;§§;%;.;'r, §,z::':§ IE: :3': a=*2'~::'1% 1': "§i}:1:{_i§;' .
E2} in ijém Law' E,--:;::'s§i<*::H': <'§§ ---E7';"
2%" E;{i::.i{':2§: §'€é§}:°E1'§i,.~iZ{}&§ t.h§'j '€§{:§E";>:.,::§ is g§§v&::z'1 21$ :.2§'1d<«%;":
"A %fi<f;<f"§y; E:z::*:'ia:'f. §3<3:£§';" {L-1-rig: VaE;:E";t'i§7§{'?§.Ei.§V'EL"§{§§E}' <":r=:<2.>fi:<;?<.% E5}? law; as '£1-5:5._1€3{}£"§;3§§EfE1'§'§_{¥'i'1?.§»gli' -'b0{iy 53:" <f:<:fi€:<:%:'i<3n if: H S€:':13${'.%1§:1;;,§ _. ' af é}i.~I§f§'g2j,§37§,.5{A.ZV"jS{}}:§;:2§i"£'}Eii'-'1§{'--.'§":£?3.'»é'iE'Z§;§ééifgiéii p<'>s;§i".ia'm 2&5 £ii.§;E:,3:é:'::;'s E3 {?::§'f ..€.f:':'>1:::§~ air: ' i;'1<%<"2;*;}§>z*a;*:a§ pf: j£5='%i.{'T£2§ s;m'§.3&3i::a;:':(:€ {f§§.':I;ie'I',§,1'§;:;7;§::i'136£§§"§ §?d fr<'}n': .§:'*:{':<;:rE§::=.<*:*é,a.2era? {'.{?§'E{'f{?§}§ii{§3.1.§ ?;f§;'3c*% E:3éf:»€§§4 <"§f :::*s-.;%:aE':{7; 5'22" 2% s:'%;?:;3EE.z»21: ~35 'A § lf_4i§ "'§'"§f;<'?f;_ :§a<.}:f{.£ 'iIlf<>:"g;32;.:&;' is-.»; u5:~::;:*:<'i :2": E'.%'225t {'*m'1'é'e:;%:%E. £2? EM//4 ..
'£25 \.{,._.-.I:!.
§%«%%%?§>2? ?¢§K§ &?: