Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Naval Kishore Chotelal Sharma vs M/O Railways on 2 January, 2020
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
MUMBAT BENCH, MUMBAL
ORIGINAL APPLICATION No.325/2016
Date of Decision: 02.01.2088
CORAM: R. VITAYRUMAR, MEMBER {A)
RN, SINGH, MEMBER (2)
Naval Kishore Chotelal Sherma
Age SS years
Retired as MCM of EL W, Bhusawal,
residing at 1120/4, POH Colony, 40 Block,
Bhusawal, Dist. Jalgaon - 425 201. . Applicant
(By Advecate Shri Vicky Nagrant }
Fersus
1. The Union of India through the
General Manager, Central Railway,
CSTM, Mumbai ~ 400 001.
bs
Chief Personnel Officer,
Head Quarters Office' Personne! Branch,
CSTM Mumbai -- 400 001.
3
3. Chief Works Manager,
(EL W}, POH,
Bhusawal~-- 425 201. . Respondents
(By Advocate Shri R.R. Shetty)
ORDER (ORAL) _
Per : Shri R. Viiaykumar, Member (A)
TA ye Set on Sash a Ara te my Se Ie IN LOLS UE LORMaSL ADE LOA UOT mas NES = OF 8 VAs wand + m et iled on O7 .038,2018 under Section i: of tns RAs f 4 gen ag ded yy Mand tayey % Pye eae ey an ie Administrative Tribunals Act, ISS s#exing Sta) This Hon'ble Tribunal may graciously be pleased to call for the records of the case from the respondents and afier examining the same quash and sef aside the @ @ 44 @ end i g i ; ed aft sy th ~ ie D 0 G3 oh syed Bel %% h ha the o hi 5 BT er cated Re '= ae & 6B Os oe we nh a ¢) "4 ra % me. 5 he "4 4 Ad é "og 2} ed roa > SS eo 8 & . 8 oo eo MG og ~ TH! ts a 4 ty 4 p : of} ct Ad $5) :
oe wo 4 4 i me KS we ' es , . , "4 5 a ne ae KY ri 4, ny ont ey t 4-3 ard bef vo £3 = by on Mel +4 . $3 3 G3 ed 4 G " us w cs Be re = on at OQ co i seq oO a by th £4 en z " aa , os Si ram Fea} 4 Ws Sea a . } Ke bod i. rte at mh De "5 a rm ocd QD UG A Go O@ OY ™ ~ sy w ow y eS os werd cS ey wjed ay a OD a mS " a - ' . i . :
S S ~ 4 @ ord My te need m XS 6 o 3 o + 42 ya AY 3 ae 3 QO vee re <i yd rh ' o + @ wa £5 G $3 , o aD LA = ; a a oO yf oi oe wed coal £3 4 a y ra ay bs wy i, ot "S a "4 . 4 ord set 2 i) 0 4 ar} 3 a ® . Mt % aa ae ™ " ri , fe he ee rea « a 44 Ue need 7 to , @ a ww 3 het * been » & 2 ; a a +. ct i f a i - om Se 2 OP rd gs Go a aod dt a tet ea mn 8 s I oS See " " 3 oS a O 2 wm ' © i. % $3 $3) @ ws a oY oh he 44 np ti os ry eof a3 Sk és Db a 8 «© a Bo ee gy pee 4 = "SS SS ey 4 rd s oo 2 w , Gi es He, J i £3 wo 43 mS co peed @ * C3 £4 jt bf 4 * me 7 wo ng So 8) o 43 yy , aed bo QD fo "< a wm FS 0 o ' mm oR gg at mam Si #8 ~ a8 Ce QO Tm fm, i ® ~ 8 "tent na . i 4 6 © CG | paoe} pe ¢ wa ae DD je4 4.4 bi "tl 4 £ fom tn © % " A "9 ia at KO we vee ty yO 3 ch wy te ' "pl rf LC eg nef : rent wa Wine oe rs AG 4 ol ed tin rh i <3 So oe @ rt © a og i 3 x ig Oo CG 2 a gy fe G Ss pea j ve Fa 3 qt oF a ed rs ra rr 54 S = "4 ba un © 43 pa * 03 os a 2, bh, g SA reef g ap my rt rm sent fet CH G rae 8 nS Sig te eB , oe + s ion BF gs GO, i O mS el eo gy wo , a ° rN, . i. fee an «: tps AA oo
2 3. 6 9 , oa # © GM gp o § Bp SS ot reef ; 4 0 ay ued of ny 0) ms S wv be 43 y eos A me OB y ; 1 Hs 54 mh id "rl se Re tt G3 me Cay ape ° eS ef ec 'y ved } a oo ted rf » ~~ te o a , ae @} re fs o - 4 @ &% a SS & 3 13 te p 43 YB wv $e 4 hy a re) og eet eo ' g , 4 4 = oH oH & rd ted ie x ved fe a ety . te " od 4 . a , Qf eds "I xv} Oo © 8 © 2b % a "i M4 fot Oo if Oo 4 £2} re| i s po 4 Qo 3 ary ed 38 4 ee Lt shee! at a ord ka ps 4a o 4 ms bea D Dp $4 4 é Bf a dat 43 B od LY losed anc 2 my g LTE ~ fas OF RE wt a3 da $3 *} ma Lt Laue ng Wy Sed eG $4 ag 3 4 a A a gy 4 the hich wr * mt had on "
applic fo CFs eed ra "4 uy o a ard ct ah es & oy yd <gyt ca oe wD As a ved oe ord ot mM a WO we C3 ory Ca os es [a] od oY pondents Ss me ont wot MA eS accarmpan not
a) " co Haj rf Tt sg uy xa oy} a i ies w in w & a Es oy uy wos Oo Cy @ a Oo vind wD ~ ee " ved cd $3 kn ut vod s OF <A ee "ao «2 So oS BL gs 3 44 GS 4 re ms "
ws " a) SG is 4 Fa - n oc " fs] ae oy o j "$ D Ba , ia . em wp ' a wd ' ers a oe op > ot o oO rd ty ' ; co i Pes Oo fete MY 4 Ff oo. oy ne i> co ce Se. % = : the th a 5 os oe "4 OQ vd 2 "1 O wt ged is : ea be "et $4 @ zs m oo od Xo 5 . wy = c " : #9 - _ j ¢ Q Q cD bs > ° aes O rt 3 SS S CD ond , he ' . ose oe OES Aa in Ny oa 3 i 7 :
3 Q = 3 bef ; g * a 3 eet } 7 £ 8 oS Bo 6 UU UU BOS ;
. ih ha DB re: "4 . Ry 44 43) wo C3 = fs be " re co be os £ } "i See ry i » wn , ue ' a % oS eo bed f © w Cy eo v Mi 2 "yt 4 S "3 om et g _ a -) i $39 . hey m ae @ se (a Q 43 o ard et wD v4 be a = ' oy & vt : ' re 8. od ent tose St wie a - + aS an 4 rhs opt ced 7 a hud a 13 Ad beat! 3 © "i agp cp 43 43 4a ea SA fa uy ted "4 a bg tS a 3 yo OG ~ Be # Be 8 OF FF 4 goog > Ag a 3 va w fn CG "c 4 qa a A a 4) 4 is Cy i os 3 'it - + 1 ot o or * cs 3 ky ay hy od 7 rey wd "= M4 ue v9 iB 3 a3 & } oo od aU : va x fu Bo» B © a 9 @ 2S » 6 * 8 9» @ 8 BS Ps 44 & ed Oo, GES _ ryt 44 aj ved wt asd 33 ws 63 isi on fi B 2 PF og MB SC ye £ BM ep Roe Uo Oi oct 'G s wy cs a od re t Xs ar a : 42 wt om aa got y 7 $4 wt (3 ad : Fae wef es wr} w ra 5 a «& ° = o Oo n wg oy 8 « So Ed ms couUs OO & OO YM 0 a of A ir) os Wy ted aq che 3 GG @ "ged y ee 4 ne oe a Spo 3 ay G iG 3 '4 w te Y os hes . / "4 ; ms aed a Cc "iy vif "5 rd . ree ef} G4 @ » 8 san mB 5 OU gO oy ; fa ay ved ae) . ee fp ' oi et i 6 Syed Se 43 ' <4 tt 4. $4 a ey i? wt ns ome Oe Ge os Bp RG Q ie BA egg OP me mr oy ¢ he werd xf ate we 43 bal ee 43 «is A LA nen fd rh + pel ont a . Hh a 3 a Ly spe ° ¢ at i :
Mi ed wd i cd rh ont a te a bes o wy be 00) 4 Ml wd to me i ery gy BT @ Ys % 3 TS wd a3 o3 ae wn ee ed th aH th Ot '4 mt ag 4 "F3 o 2 eS ma > es Oo Co & mB @ ky sO cs Cy Yet Be eed mS i 9 sf @ 2 bef 4} Rw oy wy w @ cS rg Sy 43 £3 w Oy rel x4 exe 5 . <3 oh, wo ro A rat 3 7] bet % & ch oy 'hed @ 4 : @ 65 "est my rah x $4 or} ig is) G ms M a © iB c w + wp obs eh iS > a wd ua ce i, a cj wa et a hd ed t ws oi hy eH 4 ee ee os try D Te CB "
u ay 6 oo is ~ tn 6 "eG cy i351 s we O i oO O : 43 ch ay a vt Rs "CS ard - - * i ot ne me + © es ar 4 a ts . et ; 'ed DB B 4 hg a4 ass a i syed i che sdncd 6 wed 4 @ a) a) 6 } ii i d B CG ra ce) 44 r as' - he fs @ c fe he Se fs a * em a ae @ w ah wd Ww ty, 40 has 42. LA 4 oe , Y On Bu ved os wef eed be w ra , 3 ct ra
44 4 oa ite rt a 4 ue - - f A hed bd gt £5 dt 5 rod | 4-4 gS wD rod a i ? 7"
& 3 Oo rs Boe 6 & 8 8 «4 NE oo a) n Y Th we C ae ef "4 ch, 44 oa Oo we rs oO '4 © wD a ed Go, 3 a at O 2 [3 uw a oe . XN my on sed | Ut Poo ee UC DD Dp wT + 8 ek } c Ea] . ot 2 ; & m1 gc 1 c3 ms ge ai w a mo M bo ue G mt ME g ae oO Bs ~ ryt ah " Ct 5 vhon vest U td G Og mm C3 uy eo rvt wel fet gat Oy o eo mos rn er a a3 go 2. vet mC € yO an OS x bd y doe ry @ Ad XS Ch uf } aed 6 3 cy el © ¢ wo ¥ w a3 ; wd 4 ae @ y a beg 44 ty Og Lay @ & Soo og Ee net ° ma © @ & 9 -- @ a Bom oy Bg mW 4 & S&S gy Cm A 44 [re s «< 6& ® Honk a thy S wpe f z St rs S} f i. i ea ayey 4 Bowe ' ® c Boye a a DD , 6 BS ee o @ i ~ BS het 43 a ce win 5 Ct peg af.3 So 6 Be woo wy gs ot woo @ OG a= SB ea G 4 So ® wo a a ' 3 sO ty o ford G6 wom wh w
4. eo rood +4 ': ' ' nm ; fe, "Ft > ; @ gs z ra ba co vol hed At a m g bt eee ed Sy oy ard _ «oo @» ££ & & o 5 8 8 7 Boos yo eB co mw ee c oC a ' o } 5 he 4 w e E Z Ct Ch oy & ro ad 43 ae an ed e i ory ays a oO tS 3 é ; ¢ we . es fe , ° a q) rd , 2 OU ' 42 <p "ti 5 28 6 $ 8 #& % 4g g © B GF HOP Od 3G he 4 o ", : a "4 Q 6 4 ee cS BY . Oo ag ond i $04 i cs oO aad 3 o A A 3 ra a Ly vet "9 oa od G ct "eg 3 zi ie) a me Pe *q ts 3 ok a : % £. ¥ 2 oor] ~ ms % rot ns 1 9 PRP « Boe Es eee ee ee me a On seo 4 th '8 a i 43 @ we wD 2 @ G ; OM a a) D es uw a i rn a a) Ra @ eed a ne a Se os '4 ¢ eS : os et 3 3 - O ad ey an . i. A a 3 md ry 4 5 +3 oS 'O & 2 2 4 a 4 3 eB ty i to 43 o o me ms Gy ss oh id : 4d a & ia te +5 uw fa a $ ved Fa, cS wy ie w 3 3 iH ond Gt a wD a ' ft a Chy "ed : es G : Ce us a ant i 3 in ma a 5 2 : C3 $5 c as o 7 o7 a " crs ee , m 5 es 5 5 fof a i + o % so are 2 "ae oF % , 3 & o " m4 a4 ay tt o G aye i Oo ue} A on in ae 4 "4 hee x ibd } a on My 13 ct ord re os 2 $4 4 % tT ~ G thy " LA wm 4 eS Ms ~e4 £3 " rd 4 C3 ch So » Gf : s Bo sf 4s ad Gg © cS 3 "ye C5 a . oS @ : é nd @ a g , $3 og ny ' * on Ty : 6 44 'es a SS c 3 c 4d c. 7.) 5 be a $ hm 3 : Se rs ct Gh 4 ha 63 ) ; i < rvt ; a + Med he a 7 a a 1 qa 4 + C wd 4 & @ 5 ai et . aed Thy , on eR} 4 4 io a 3 ws iy " ort oD c ay uv a C3 fey a 7 Mae crm wget q 3 ha " a ae Nee en th. os rps a mL 6 oO rn rn ee Coo & nS £ to is 4 no -4 be4 g if * st 8 o aa . ba i bbs pot " 43 a aD wy ig cc My wy ad AA a 3% wt, = Wy Q tt Leg A 2, a Op a se cs in ew ing vier oy ee "4 WAM 4 :
s re? Be wt bag (3 ew EP ay 5) aed | mm a ot A CF a fad Sel eg ee t,, 4 € , ar ny nse * SS . ny (ON G us ms ES MH . ' % dt wed a w M ey, 2 = = eS wl "i wy > we ie Ning a es ce _ &% eS oct Q 4s ° m4 6 F
a) rl o Bo Gs - 'tes to " B e 4 eg we "$3 rat go 8 & s o 2 my Bo . Fy oo < bye wy n oe 3 tet Cd "ed, FB : wo es r 4 on ° iy UH ct $5 be Sh tJ Posy "5 §.3 "C3 4 $53) G3 £ by 3 m4 a
--t hed ae By, C3 ve ay a how . 4 A ® rat a £ 4 | ¢ i % f @ Ba i ~ 3 , ei ~ io a ; g vel " DH ref r oof i 3 ted , Pa Ba eh gt ® ne a :
Pe 3 'S Med a a oes ye e Rathore F & Harr a she Nat Len ee 2 2 NOt Sr * ws uy M hes th RQ yer SAA AL oh oh ee@¢n wah eae) an Ne Na SuS x lo ~~ 2 re} '4 3 45 a ay w vet a9) 4 SC % 8B 6 Boo Re x a & a ch 3 Ld = s = ort w ° ms t nt y 1 ot 43 4 e) md ry Q : rs ee & Sef a) o eed ™ a PL ay : st | oy a 6) a vod iS @ vot wed . ved \ G 8 48 Q KG n : Se gy ~ Ha TG O3 Ly a 5 7 Oy e bole @ ' a -
; o v Be BD Go eh tea aa w eed an A rs & ~ ved rs) ved "5 (Gy . wt a ? t "eg its o 4 x 4 AG eget O we Pradesh, 1996 AIR 10 = 1989 SCR Sunplementar ¥ u ae en, ¢ 4 i 42 ud a3 mn op ot . ' ba om i C3 ® dt 6 Ad D ved 1 nd w o3 ae rg mt Aas ba reg % " 3 bd cS oO $3 iow oa ed os C oe . i iS: vel i ed ® oy Ms orl ma % on £4 tO 4 i} 3 Q i & Ow . 2 Ud eB IG a t ce 3 ot 'S me Bag O 8 mo 3 .
" x G4 43 vet w SS be 5 rie a ot 4 oa td mol oS ae cin) is po-¥ ad bs @ "th oh, % _ a ' 2 :
& & it ce ou Ci is On oO ed Ou GS > o 6 8 & go NS oF SN 8 g GB # ~ a ™ ° " : 4 2 te 43 Mood ra % i et G &