Karnataka High Court
Siddaramappa Annapure S/O Bhimappa vs The State Of Karnataka Through The ... on 8 June, 2010
~ "'43- ._ .
R)
AND:
T136? Siléitf'. {if Ké1i'I'I£:'£;tE1kE:'i
'i'E1m1.1gh i'.h<:>. P<)Eic:"t€<= I'r;$p<=:<.*.1::'§::' ..
Sh(3r21p1.:r E'<:>1i{i:€a Smticarz, II)i,>:.-iii. {}:T:11ba1:";ga.
' _
{By Sri. Sharanahasappa K'V»§abasI§eAtffy'. 2 .
This Crrimirlai 21:;:j;:.r:e1_1.':s Vf"iIé€1_V:;m'Ec::~ Sectimrz; STY4 (2)
Cr.P.C. by the Adxro(:aiie'A£}:3'£_f:h}3 2i'p::;Aa:V1E'22.;1{;5 agai:1St the
jaxdgmemg. dig 16'I2'2VOVQ;'}._p:a,ss§ed'"'~b3:'~~._tVh.€ 1: Aden SJ,
Guibargga, in §3pZv,.Cz15s_ée (S€iS}EsiQ1'1.SS}.V_E\I{}.§}.:;3'9,f O1» Com-'ict.ing
the app€Iia1:'ffi:ss;%7:1{":{:u3;:<3'dL "'{\i?0se§;}, for {he Off€I}C€3S
P/U"/'SS 3.~('1}"' {X}--.r.;f--_S'C«,%_'ST-.{PA) A(:i;:V_': 989 R/W Sec' 504 sf
EPC and 315/ 324" a:_1':i 'L R}{w' Sc-3c::~,149 cf IPC and
se'r:te11::i1::g§"*t.it1€:ii;;-;,.V't,0'-_§§xzT:ti£=:'g0....P3i.I. £192" :5: pariod of six
r};1c>ni:§i"2$ a1::'€i~T.L':.:>_Ap.ay' fiénes-1 sf E?.s,2,50/-- e:au:7:h and LI}. 8.1.
for §O3ada;yS §0:'"t:h.r;: 0.i'}{'°Vf<:*1r_1__ée P;/U/S. 3E1} (X) of SC/ST {PA}
Act; Z.9E%94'R/W.._Sé%.(:é; 5Q_4'«::{f" IPC and further se:11:.e:1<::ing
ézhem £0 %;;a«:'§<i<:'rgg0.Rl;._I;' fQ?:$~ 21 perioci 0f six _months and to
p21y;finLe 01"' Z€$.2'E50/¥ c;éa<3}: and M1 8.1} far E0 days for
._ €'.1'3;Ef':'«:{)i'}i'§:'1:<§<3 P2' of {PC and fufiihez' ssem:e}:1Ci11g.;
'§1.§1?i: t:€;=LV'a:vr':d§:s:';;*e3 RE. ;€'{_rr 2-": p&I"1?{>{£ 3%" six inanihs and ti}
' .;3€i.y*. f1*z34é%=<§;f§.E{ss_,,25C%/-- eacth and LI}. SE. f{}.}§.' 10 day$ far
::'E%*:>. '<;§ff{:%§j;{:«;"¥.'~Py'U,/S. 538 Q? EPC 211$ £1113 stzbgiigintixrfi
;°?3.{::*:1:€:1::@séf';::h'a§1 rm :1 {3{)§1{?'i..E :";'e:n€:Ey.
""i*'-§2iS €'.rimi:12;2,E A;:>peaE <::::::";.i:1;g:§ :35"; $62' §iE'1.&}§ hearing,
" i;'::_is_§.~'<E2-;;},f ihe {fm.:r'E: {.'§aEi*w;;':r{;?§i 'z}":£% f<:§§.<>x>vi:':gg:
Au
JUDGMENT
This; azzppfial fiieéi lay tile ac(t:.2s;f:(i in -E3pI.C'5.S€ (S€:s_Iss:e:i<:>11$} N<3.:Z2':?§/ 2091 :31': t:1'1e filii of t:£1<:%H.V§'3§§€'%:§_;1{i Adr:iiti02'19.§ S!E',Ei§$i€)E"1-S J1.1»:ig"e and Spficizéi JL1(ig1§é%:'G'::ii%::;é1r.g§ér_ cheiileragirig 'aheir c0:'"zvic1::':m f(>1'M:;u': <>ff<:1"1i:e:.-. :pui:.ishab_1e" = 11nd<-3:1' S63ct'i»:):1 53 (1) (X) SC,7S ':I"V{f%1"£§*§;rg3s§;;V'fic)1:1 ()f Ai:rc;>c:iti€:séé} Ac': and S'{€»;?:.t.i<>1'3é:' 3211:' 23311' 506 {if {he indian P42211191} Code amci sem;_,e.:i(§i_x'ig 11:0 Rigoabous Emp1'i:s011n1e;'1{.'*fg:i§:; six §z1'.:V:i11i:'E*3.;»§' -.§a;;:2(:1,ft<') pay 3 $1115: of . 2 50 f M EEK' i":,:"e€-. "5;t:rg3£*£.i5;:t:é:'x:f:~:)1,::';1::é§, '-Fhcs i;Ej:_é"-- ;j=:*':>:%;<2<f:ut:iz;>:1 a:i%<%ardir:g "$10 the <':h21rg';f<:~ §}z2_.:§3::d is~_2 1::>" <-3fi'E>.C't: t.ha£', on IZGOQJQQQ at ;1ii§{>53;fat.E A?§%'E"'i«:73.___£}f{;11?E. {}§T§§1%:% 'hcm.i~;€: <1? ézhe ciemplziinam ' "ET '_:;_.p7pw¢:Eie1.:'1*a5s §'12=;.ve frzgrmeéi mzlaiwfui &s3se;nbE}r fer ?:.1":éé';3L2;_:*§j{§:§;€*.5'::)f <Ez::1:_:ni_t,E',i:'1g 2:1': <>£'fc:?.€:e zmci furéiher ihééry E:2we~~ £:"1::>:1;E{€{i é1I':f:: {T:()mpE2':in2,1r':§ '§:»y ta1«;i:f2g;{ (mt, §.§'1{'? name ef «:72:.$t:&: aimgi :f:;:"i'.fi2£:*::* $1.213}; "E: 21% "£:.§'€a:~"s§§ pasésassd i:"1€:<> tihe §'i{i}':,£§:*:1€': -2'}? Eihéf <%é}:';':§3§z:§:":§?smi gmézi §.'::21W: ;1$:':§a;z.:§i:t%{§ 'é:'§"};€m anti £~3a_b21s5%1<;%t't:§;. léizamed }'Iig,2;h Cc)m:'é_. G<'}v6'1*1'1:11::%:'1i: Piesaiier {:3}? the State amxi p€::'¥.,1--%f~3€£i t:h.s;? rz9c:€;:*c1s;.
E3. It s5{:%:::1'1 :ff:"e:):":1 't.h<;=: <~?vic3<;%z'1<;r€: <33?' ¥3W--_ 1. :I§g-$11121. Niraggappez thai. E':::: has»: s:~;p0.1::<%':'1'»,:"<::§g'z1;':§'ir1;L;.ihéé i:'i§:;21;_1t1'i:f1g w::)rciss :1»11ege<i tic» hzivc: bé§e:'m_V E3p()}{€f§1 vb},!= _fE:{<:-...;1g:<:3t.1sedV ' p€srs.«:>11s5 and 211590 th<;f__ zicmxaed p€fI"5f~3OE1S. _E{<«3 has the drfagging of his wife by z$:;(:x;s~;c=.cii'"N':>s;:;'}. insL1itirag by usizig has been {'::m:<5s exe1n2§:13Vd_A'VAV"i.r; enmity 'aet.xv€3.€-3:1 the atéymfiivggirf;z;%_'r1i,.;:e;" £ii(.',(.':LiE§€{i paréiy, 'PW--2 Laxmi _h:.;:1SVré15_§;<§.._V:ép«;§§i&:.r32': :"°:=égeu°ci§:'1g; the ;im:id<~:nt. But 53?..i€:5'~:.}é;;*_a_L:~fs zrjgziirr21f:'ers:E..._i:het 21bu:t-give wmfdsa in a differemi way. V _§'.:v:agé§~ §z'iVs§.{>--.s3i:21i.<%:i *;.h2.-mi 21<:cz.:s€d havt-3: Lz;1{i:'esss€e:i and €}*,1§*:i'é?i§5§€?{§' %:€:}" m{:«d:3:::-_~.:'t:},2x SE".i.E? E1213; §:.1ri;h€r :i~;tz1i.e%«:i 'them:
L-"5'*:.,(E€1U.':"§«é:'iA{TE N:::ssf-3V2 ti: 4 §"1.2:.v{:% zzssaxuiimi Ya-:2" s<:s:":s~:-3. She E'::3:$ V:3;_§ss7<':g« hwy} <:§"{>:~ss; examintiéi. E7*'*W~3 I'vE21r§§':21;'3_de1§3p2z is; 'me §::%{}§'} £3? ?':?iE»§ zazzé P3?'J~2; P1-$24 $a1E<;.:"21.§§§;3£:: is 313%: 21:':<?;'£.?1€:§' <-
/9.
" " ' (t> :+;<3:'1 of E?' I31. 2,-mci PW--.£, A11 i:he.s£> V¢'§i.'I"i{i?SS€?$ §"1&§_X»-"'€? 5:-;iat'.é:e{i re;;a1"di1'1_;g the i1'1<;:i€i:::'1'3.t:. in {.>:'1<3r way 0:" the: mherz: PW-5 Ba121'k::"Ei1§.1:*sz1:*a§,-I21 is an .im:ie;;>c1'}.<:i9:'1t. wiiiilesss, 1-:sI:'at«:>.e:i r:iiffe1'=::%';'1f;. wcmzl:-"s. X»'\§hi£?}'3 are se;u;3p<:.sis;:'d i::§ Cm-<3 W'C§I"dS speaker: "Tm 'my ACC{?lS{',{1 _E\§'{}.._l, Jfié J "$1.515; '_'i'1.:4_'_1=i;,h:é;" u smatied that Accused N02 'IV';~2,é1 §<E~;-.21s$21z;.zI§.<:d .'::)n"rhir"fi with si;:i<:k. He. b.2153 si:;1t4£:s€%1'~._t:h21i:' AC(:-siésseki._Ei\f0s.5 a:id 6 have dragged P\2V-2 and héas been crass é3x21z:':;i.11<;*.c1 t}f;t3:'t2;i{;.§}1§j'3;:»Afi hm; 211$} s3't,z;1t:e:d ri3g;12'di1'}.g §:t:a3i;.t::d that Acéctusseai Nil} head. xxzriih 21 stmze. PW, E has»; "bx::;:é<3:):1.<:2"a::":<3€m Eétj;---§_§):i1::»£'§.. He 'alas ssiazicci that. ail ?{:E3_§:s<: 21e::{::.:a;c:=¢;i §3f;?%':}{';§:TiS évéczizé: glway by k;%2:s,Vi2":.g;{ PW~ E. at: fake: :=;p<>fi:. PE§'x}"~ ?' :" ?}L':1§>p':1 hag i:.'u.:*:'";<-rd E'm;<:--;'i:iEe:: iii} i:,h<3 Cififééi of E'i}":e prki;sséei-s.,:'i:«E§fi=I:ifv.~'PW {}<i>{§{§a Ni¥1g:3;§>p22. hem aisa siiaiiedg r€;*§;'3;é1r€i..f§'i':gg-.'§;§':&: im:§{§:;%:1E.. P'J\f--§3% Sa:'::":a ?v'§arc§:=§32: hezsa bee-in H %'::2:_;m:?:i" .E":<:>s3i'._iI€ :0 31.5% €?:££.E§{'? 91" the: pr<>s€<?ut§.<>r: S0 a¥;$e:> "'.S.i>:§;<'£:2?;.;."2p2: §3W~E€?» PV:-?-§£ is *€':ha'~': ?,E§°.E_, Sf 35915: Ekiggir " "?%'2,;:;:*g:.§ E>§.*;E2?::'.?e-2 Si:aEiz'>:T1 wE*:<§ §";é:§,E=:= §§§4E'§}1"?{"i§§.'£é'i{§ €'.§'1€;? §',E,E'{, iii"; gm 2/4 m f: g Mg Court, F3W~1iZ d(){,'.{{}'I" Ir.';.21:e: t';';:e2>zt'::>.{i PW -1 ezzrxezf PW32 and Id;-153 ::)p_i;z'1:;éci Efhéif. {[E1<-33; §'12;:ve ::;L2ffe1*e£i sezinxpie i:1w;'1,1ri<-255. PW- 13 is; the SP" win} was é:§"2<:t D.-SP. ci1,zri11gg; £:E1<:v;f€e»§§§%e<;§.r:i; time hag i:'wc=%:+;i:igg,at:s:é~.<i me: r:"1a£'.t::%z' zzzmi fiieci.3V__T;f:t:?= {:h;i§g,;{c§é' _ 71 Sri, SAVE, Ch.a::1dr;.1s;_1(1'Lé*rE§;31;"..,_V 1e21§*;ti€;i1 c<}'ii1r1$€*£ fr:::'r the appe-3i1a11ts saub1nit:':95t;hai'Li:ht;:r<§*i aiV1-,,i11<>rdin21t,e deiay in filing the F,I.:£&'.,9 wffztéfeeasé' €;.h£tf«:)_rigi:1;1} ".:i0n1pEai11t. shows {.ha£: théé }""z:i'§f:7_ '§21.:1{e--;'3 :;'§_;'1'.21{?:€:;*W '<):1 13.09.1999 at £!.bG'1.1€'._9_,QG"'.AR/I:.'51 been flamed to shcmv"
€'i':.21'{. H162r§:"1{Yi§'€;?§'§A hE:f§§"1ié?§}§(§1'1' piace mi: 22,89 "£999. He has; 'i711ri'h::.-3'rA 3u'fj:fr1ii;§fle%£.§.:_'i;'h22I. the? Fifi. has reached the '_ C§§~ei§j'i 35'? u§.3..Q'§;.E at a.bm2.t ELQQ AM and €:?1{:z:ef0re. ' :i?1{:..:7e --v;iVs%;'~nz;€ii"«:'%' Elan hc>'Lz2*_::~; {§.e3;a3r fi"'€}i'IT§ the fiélifi of i;i;(%'i<ic%11€, ifiijf; E'.,I.R. r<3a<:§1i1T1gg; {he {:€I'E.I;i'§1. T %"1:'::*e§5*{31:°<;>; ht':
$s:1E"_::32;i€.::g_ tifizfi. the xx-':;%:":=:si{:+:"; in ms: <:£3mp123.é:1":. anfi tbs <;§'s.=':§£:'1e<*:i::':{::=: 0%' éhaé <:£§nzpE22m";a::':i; amid hiss fazmiiy mestrnbera §i£iE3E'1{i}'€1 'ms. ?7}€T':Ei£',iz"{?{§, Eézz §'"z,3;:*é._E":§:%:' :+;1,2§'3m;.i $15.'; §'}EE£E §;§1{>z;.:;_;§:
E4 \V1'i;1":€tsSr;%s§ :3i.a'm€§ {}:T1a'E; Eh-iii 2;L<s:f~;211.:E§; 1133 §3€E€',E'1 0:": PW'--} arxci PWPZ. ihcéy 1f1.:~1v::: 1101', sp:3<'ifi<%21i1.y stzittéd as {.0 which xx:éi2a;><}::1 \?%;'21S:'§ in 'the h2:1:1d.<; {sf Whitifh. 21C<:L;::-;£:3_:<:E-.._'3.I1<:i thE?Z"f:"ff£Z)I'Ef. £32<:<t<£%j;3E, <m1r::.ib'11s &5f.21'£1€=':'3";€:"1fj £:hat:__-tfh€ 'é1§:é'§::-:¢iSs:.gi' . have: .21s3s;2.m.it:e<i 0:1 i:'m=: inja1z'<:c1, 'ij}'1.e.It¢ _151"::§' §?§f3€-Lf«1',ifi("V :3V€-Hf'EiAV' act eitilmz' 2111_eged in the (:(3fi}«;_§¥21iI1i: 01* pra:3v <?.2d "E?}ef{)re thii Cc)urt. In thefli \:"i:;*w' «flats? u€; i1£:A.e\*ic'i--£}Vfi<:€§v<0f" 3.1} the witrles-ses 431063 not; mind of the C£}1.1I"i', and }%~g;','IH1i'(°:»§{_'$.63::'f3L1§i%{i'{Z§§"A%£$iii,= 'I_e3.r_n<3d St3SSi{)I1S Jucige J fif,'2"1.;§':,§gi§fJ§(3HE1i'111:33 guiitiy of the '_i:'1 %,_.Q u1'1<:ier S:':C:t:i0I1 3 (13 [X} 0f bf £3xE'.i"0Cif.i<;*;E:§§ Aazét. is <f:0n<:€:'m€<:i ihe; 'wi.§:m:3$S<3.$ ;r1;1ve' nczswhssréz S'i.&11i€?C§ t..h;ai: the abusive xV(5':'€is:"' ~:sp{:s1~;f:;'fs *2-a?ii:E"; ax: i:"1i:s31"£*;.:£.r::r:1 #3:} in-Sufi. them in p:I:_E')1;it:~.*§?E§;§V..AV.T"v.'E'he s;<t2éz1<': of <><:<::1rr€:r:<:e. £53 r1<Wszh<-:+r{-3 Ethan t,E"§3€:-. fr<:_>;':é€',-.%§é'<Ez:*% {>5 the mimse of E'%1€-: <:01*np§2a;.i:122z:1*:i which £53 n3"2;:3_£:, 2£;}U.b§i<: §3°§&1{"t€f zrzmfi ii: rmi: ;g_§ivi:';T: in <;*:'~;§d<im:€ iihai:
i1EE'§'?' §}E3fE)§i{T 1r~v€:rg% {j}b§m°'a-'E:':g§ G3" w§U:&%§s;E§':g €'E"1{i i:'3;{itié&Ez§ég 'E"%et:%:':<1*:s«'ir '€:h§% a:a<":'€; {ff i:§':£:% 22s,{"%<?z.:5:;€{%; :22-"s::::::': if 2?:.§.i.:f::i':.."£:éEs§ iiiééiéféi Elf}?
1) <?<3m:3 W:ii:,I:1_:i'x1 the ;3111*vi@xxz' of S€'{'.'{'.i{)11 3 (E) {X} mi' the SC/ST {Prev-*e%11t,i<):'1 of A{.E"{)(',i1'i€E$} Act. He 'hz1SV"f'1L.ir§,:Iév$r drawn Ixzy 2-:'t:t:e:1i.ic>r1 £0 'é§'1:'-3 ::ii$<::rep:;1.z1<:Ees ';x}@r€E';; V' allegétd 1:0 112.1%.-3 b<:m%1_ ussed by "the. A ;E1.€;?'{f1,E_駀1'i?3.-v'¢'}3€?FS:f}I}V$-$3 I)ii"fe;'€'r1i; wit%1':<3s$<'3.5s 21i':.i:.1'ibL1€aé<:i Liif'iE3:*£é11t: i;mr~cis«.
&1C{?US€d pers<>r1e3 amci f.h<3r<51*::s;*£=.%»t:_1*1er<:x.is"§ c:E3z1éiSt'enCy in the ¢E3Vi€1€f1.1(?€;' cf Pwsii far as abL1s§ve words 211%: {'.{)I]'€'? f3}"!I'fifi':'CT71v'; V V "
84 'i'he VV!§'fi:(i:sT5.a=vv§::"1"1II1<::3i: Pleads?
submifxis by the pms<--:cL1ti0n is fzitf ezielay in fiilizig Fiiii.
is and the palicte 5:¥'£.2i.ti()I1 ES E<><_::«;:.*3;<:*d '2:;E'. a d:is_sEa;.1<:'€~-- "of E{§"}{}3"i3 'shat: 8 KEVL same delay <>:tati::""§'*@e;i.V a1n€i '5::h21t w'i§.E not ge ta} {he moi: of i";f:a,;1e"';1:é:_«¥;§€»r"a::'§§ ihe i;.rusi:w<>'ri;§'1insrfisg :2? {the w'ii,:z€S:3<3s is; i:u_;t <3£"§1<:.<:?§%:%:'é; Suijrh {E63213/K E*{<;*:ne::€ he €~;'mbm§ts that" the <7>rda*.:" _<:>_§'7 <:{3Iwée:t*{,§<):f: zzmii §5f;'f§'1i',€;':.§'1{f&? is g):'*{>g§.-*1" and praiys €3::;2j§."s.h€: a;::p€:aE be {:'Ei.$E'§1,E$3%'{;,¥£%s El} E1 Afi'.€?f" gtyizlg i}'11'01.:g}'1 'she eVi(i€::':Ce 0f the _§}I"()S5§f:'.{'.'i.IT.i{)1.'1 xvit.1'1r;*.s:se:e;§ I am :3? the Cipifliéiiil _.i.h3;'tg.._'::}j1e W"i'E',I"1é;',€SS{;*,Ei% h21v<:% ncfzt spe:cif'i<:aI1}; ;_§§ve:2 E319":----<>\z§:i*§ "'a¢'i;{»§~ a1.E£5ggeci ;1gge1i.:1st, arach (If iihi-3 :ez.<;?{:uf:s»<:'::i._§},md" i1"1 ;é;i'*:'*¥jV»:>fi;1§iI;>:.is; V st.at',em<§I1f: ("if PW ~1 to Pwwil» .t1<3Wf1é:*_ré"Tit. which 221.mc>r:g the M.0.s.1V we§*c:.__in .h::a_1'1€i_'{5f~v;?hich' aeticwsed pers-201153, §::~.3i>§§<t3;t'i;::;a:;_1*ij;%. ' -s'{:2z:':i.1'1g§' which acitusésd was; L1:rth<~31:° before givirngzg 21113! not shown to the Hence -5§p€{7ifi{3 axrri{t§:1"::f'§,g'f fig:-.V}c§A:£>{:if:I(:':*';wit.,h I"€f€31'€1E"1€':€ is the Spe{tif17}i:"i11juE'if5S V"~.§1{;1§§; "'--,;;;g}'§ "been 0bt.ained by éhe prosa3{%1;zf:i<§§";.. "§t¥.€:f;_<.:é3*-._2:z_13_2~~-the Six a<:c:2_.1sse:c£ peérsona ztexnnai, bev-i§3}*€s.;;1;'Ee»«;i as hm-:%:«~:g {3{}§"flU}§i.fi3C§_ the Qfféirace 21$ zfiiegfid. _ E'7'E,'§.'l;iL%,7EE':j'§7,".§q§'¥§€'f:f§;; ":ja;r@ HG ether pubm: who Spéiéik E"€3g8.1"{ii§}§._§ i','1r';§: V<;&§'i"<flf:"é'i:§:%§--.V. Llézititér Ezifsis SCXS'? {Preve;T;€.§_0§1 af Ai.r<}c§ti€:$) AC1 " UAi-;{§€;*:" Eghe iii3"{Z'LE'I3;?§E3iZE1,¥Z1{Zf€E3, Z Ewiai '{lh£?1*i the '_ ;:%zf:2é§i;;::<t:,2'{;.i<?m has §"i€}'é, §3:'i?{?'£"} 5»;z;::<:€:;=;s§"z.:E in ;3:*<§<§1:::~§:1;g iiiéféif, VV 4:5<%.§e;:m* f:i'§":{§ méiz-{éiiszé §E'=£"§{fZ%3'E"ié".€ £3': iii? 3§€<:E.';<}:'z§s§ 324 5:,
2 «am , . . W Y% it-*..>"\'s.W:w.~' ~?
and 584 of the f:'1<iia:'; P:';?.::1z~1.E Ceziadés 21m (2{f}I"i{?€fI""I'1f;?(i' In S0 Far as {he <>i':feI1£.:e u:'"zc:ie->2' S<;%ct.i»:)z1 3 (1) {X} <31' 1':1f1c? SC/ST {P1"ew213t.i(3.1'1 {bf A'a.m(>it.ie:~;s} AC1': C£_")I1{T:f3r1'I€*,d. s§r;.Q€:;_t,he <>ifence amt'. <:*c§n1n2i€i:e.{£ in }')'LEh1i€3 V'i€W' Eghgé' .;iit:f%'L1Se>d c:a;:mot: be held Iiabie for the 5'-mic} c3fE'e.t1ct<;?, .--§_}f1' x5i.e:7;v.é5'f diSC!,1SSiOI1S made ;:1b<>ve. i""z3;Ix1*:_. sf t.h'c%_1€3/}3i:t=;i<:>'iv% that me pmse:=(:z11;.im'1 has; _1'1£)§ ;)rg>vr::i" --.{.'i€2%_ <::21§;'e'v-..;zgg;é§.inst: the appetilamf beyond. re2i$;r; 1121b.EL¢ _i;he:r<-tforrs, I hold thaii they are_§3I1i.it1¢d..f;3r 'é1cq:.;1i'{;£:ai giving benefit of <ie_.31i'§;a': -tn} $.16.€g1§3'§)éIie§;i:1f'$".v....I::'{<;:I1<:c: {he foliow-*i'ng order: ' 1 'V ' V." " V ' ' ' ' ' 'z:pp'€:éE-~ ».:1{3."ev; xi. "fhss arcier {}f{f{}§1E«'i{,'l".i{3I1 2-me} &se'm:.:::;'1<ti;= _pag:~éé£';"V %;':he Se::<;;:1<:i 5«Xddi.i:i<>11a} SesSi@'nS Jzzdggei €}L1E%;::1;';g'21"'aggétzfitxsaii t:E1§~: ap;3efi2mt.5~; for $153: €3ff§'é3=:1c€S §3z§.:9:£i§§?;A'};1E:>1s;§ :.2§1V<iV€%'1"""'§;'53<;%<:E.3l{}3;1$ 3 El} {X} :35 ihfi SC/S'? ' ,{§rz:V@::*:?iV<)?;1ai;§f_E%i:::"<}e:éi'{,§s3s:;} Ac? filiii S¢3:s::fi;E:>:1s 324$» anci 5&8 .{:"é:§ __Vi:.Ei:r *..E_:'1«;§§2;'%: §3e:'1z,zE_ <fi::;£E€;%x is}; E'";e%1°€:%;)y ..':§€;"3§' 8.S§€§.f:?. Z5;§§«§.}{1?E§._:?§1'}"€"§E:é.~'2:£.E°£ff ;:?.{?{i§:.i§'{l'iI{?{§ <2? 5525?: :3f'§é%:'2€a:::$ {T:§'E.EE£I'§:€{§ agzzizwi:
-su i;hen'1. Ei3a..i£ b«:>:'3ds_'~;, if 211.13: :=::{e::1t1.1§:£;%(i by them is ztzmigfg-ziietci. Pixie if 2»:.r1y r:i£;':;;>:?:s.it.::?<.£ s'sh.21_1I be :1."<::i'L::"1:fi<3c.1".v ti.:§ "--_£E%:e;? appr3i.1211':i.s~:s..
swk: