Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Shri Vinod Kumar Chauhan vs M/O Railways on 15 October, 2019
j O.A. No, 38.2014 CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL MUMBAT BENCH, MUMBAI. ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 58/2014 Dated i4.- fo. Rep CORAM:~ R. VIJAYKUMAR, MEMBER (A). RAVINDER KAUR, MEMBER G7) Sari Vinod Kumar Chauhan Aged 23 years, Indian Inhabitant Occupation Service as Junior Engineer i Signal, R/fo ~ RE-IE, Block - c/i3 "
. Applicant {By Advocate Shri P. R. Suryawanshi} oye ~. nas. * ; ot: "
GLLice Of ORM, Pune Railway Station ot. de gen F ma T vy i , 3 wy F Central Railwavs, Pune 42i0o1.
3... Respondent {By Advocate Shri V. D. Vadhavkar} Reserved on: 13.03.2019 we Pronounced on: ¢5.j0 2015 t ofp = w ot - q 4 : A 2 on a "y 43 rf a "ef yt oH oN Q mt ed - o45, ae) co 42 x ay a 4 4 os a a oe 4 fea a g Ue} so 8 Oy oem ' be on w ey acd i - 6 ot DB { cea 3 43 43 co rs] £7 63 wy S G " i 4 ie i in ' on. Ch . t soi od 23% Bo aw ose ect " a 3 o ms - 4 Ss be Pa wea oe ae wa 4 sa a Q Be oe & 5 ot me fe] xe 4 2 oy tS a : , Cc '4 4 Ss wn aw tg wo pest] whos rd _ @ cs $3 Se a '3 2 oA bbs mi Ay 4 m SE a8 oN % ~ + fos g E B y sy te, = 2 $3 5 cr cs "ed a a 2 uy 5 ee" ia" Be e & ce oe 4 ved a oy a" gene &£ 2 Ge o 4, o & Gs S wn Oo EK = & 3 ay w ae ne '2 ce, 43 u LA A aed 5 td we nes me a hy a $3 as ae aA ot iB 4 k w hy ve % OF seed a 4y oy AB x a] ' iG * " $ thy q od sot fsx] to A oh on S Oo Bower a geet 4 i a i G at + ' yr a ne v% Bok a ey 4D ao % rt 8 yO 6 & os i ; it i wer DP . Sj ee th ~ Ct no 6) S xo nee x wed oh 9 EA os a 3 "4 M u hy Ch, g wed 43 ne) ns > is Fe 4 3 rl ; eo is re ge ' n a 3 . rn CO OG oe " 3 a oi ° 2 * wt a oa m © uo 0" « © wy g GO : aS eg eS -- wed ed 0 4 ms i as sf wo 3 Bay e BG @ cd 6 me M4 re c DD sd ye eg Ww Bub obey 3 5 te ot 4 3 Le 6 i bef hy 6 Ad 2 a
- } Oo wm ors 43 @ 4.3 a} " 1 - reg rf 43 oD mo fe § 8 " OE A i oe © a * HH 3 i £ em % te oe ty, #1 rf iw eg 4 m sd be = Go CN 2 ey he MO Bas 2 on . 4 ; C he ° hd Ae 8 uy? OC «. a a2 ee £8 ord fo Hoa Bom rl Sy ire) ry : a ad S Qos px} Cy t nd ad "ey 44 rte) ce we 43 wo "o 2 ' me fon ® foo By ie OR 3 8 OF ne oO fe v . ne tra OS or 3 i oe ic co i ol © eng - Y M4 rs . bt Bae a Bo S L "ed a @ 3 G TS vt 6) ; o % ~ we sf et 4 Oo 9 @ 4a i £2, wa 2 so a M4 oF . i by : 3 % w@ 43 " & 8 Bo 4 gS 7 co 3 ot a Me 5, © Hn Go Baad "8% o a" 3 OU oO OG o * 3 when eR "YS = ; ; ¥ " ae f ' D f 8 " Beste et BS 0 ek ® Com. oD ake ° nn ot 4 . ree red re ab. i C4 2A org me & es a ea Coo: ie Gy & o wo 4 ee pe Ke , 4 Set fds uy rf wt oo 2 bed t4 be 4h gre a 2 a me 3 . : o oon os "4 fa) . 4 we woo S ; w® ved c sed fuk rt rr] o "ry i is wt ee B" mi { 43 4 bs rt : oS ho " A my o m ved TG ea Qn a a 3 ve ' A wd gy) 1 a ; ig ** th oO TA af cg ao 8 "E r @ i : a2 4 © ns os a 3 hs ny "f ff a4 cs : Wd wf i ~ wy oA o, o vhs ee 2 oe q . wea ord i ord my rhe re ; 2 oy nh of a U4 o bay O i 4 O is 3 wy @ . rt 5 a we 4 as cl "tg Sot 4
3) ; ted - O wy a re) rs ' eed a rs ved © i a et tel BF RQ +A ' " ff el & ha ti i oO . 4 gs a 7 a "4 q3 Sood oo 4 cs 4 vs i & v ay . a : we oO 5 ja .Y Be cS ea os % "a $4 4 3 43 44 'tt o cD eS ; 2 S oe 0 vn G 5 oN a se + rp '1 ow o C3 yy C33 * BS 'ane . as rf a @ 3 : 3 ~ ie BM e 8 Qs a a 2 oS 2 be 4 2 rd ot org w > QM ot yea GB & 2 weet et . seg [a0 ne wf 8 Ss 6 8 & 5S a © $e a c "rt S cx} c ae! ~ r ay m3 o ' a {2 cy G ON he a fa o> Q gh aes , "he wd wy ¢ & ' B+ ;
Pa ON cr © -
oh, & & i S < oo 5 + ia he a 2 4 os M a 8 jt 42 .
* eZ ~ 1 °F & GC © Goo 9 C © BD L © Q os GB 6f FD eh Qe Bo GB G bk » s A ea 43 ' a ae "3 : rel 7 43 a * 4 44 wo wy pS \, g SG Et 43 Good RE GB G @ 3 G | ei g @ x ~ 4 SG p 'B BS 9 oO 6 4 a So. OTS ; ve fA v ons) hot Ge cS ; ow ¢ GB SO Om ce rho ge fo Bort D *% @ 4 4 O QD @ it a 13 S a , . O cot "4 i a a fe a $3 3 Or : cs a ad Sy a wt "ged 43 .S " £3 uy abe +. * © red O Ta) ony Ee] 5 vy heey iss c vod -- 2 ' Oo mo ' 3 43 Oy '4 "4 iD co iy} Pas sof We N @ 43 cs a ¥ ct ved 4 i sy es i on, fr ged & ct " ve, a " 3 +4 a "GG 3 a Oy oe 2 m5 o a G QQ Aa a3 "3 # mm o es fo ~ ct 3 we O 2; Cod os 0 Oo ed 45 M 4 4 , i ct & wh sped an ia) vf 3 a iD oc} ed ci oe io @ o @ 4 ved nl , 6 ~ ot yt wD ¢ 5 2 MS e ci 43 wy w@ a o baa @ oO aed Cy i 9 " 8B y S 8 fs oe eB Son B&B 6 8 8B a -- & 1 8 wea L4 iy OO ay "A 4 i} Y > on ga ot o gt @ 44 it 4 . : g . bed a be 43 a ; ie ut " wns in a go 3 'g sO @ , ; Ot i ' 4 " by sy Cs sy Me eS. do be ry 43 a « : fe he 6 oO 8) 3 u a Q ey AG a (GS wo et bg os yO eS nn g °® be wy o 8 e oo S SS dR o * 4 g 2 8 4 8 BO a pe 8 3 bs a ct eC bi a EH - Ma 43 \O a ord th on 2 #8 o o ww Oo « a OR a tm a BF a 8 i be 1 43 ard 'O ' , qt orf a t a ba 0 fa es &4 t 3 {3 ra aa ha , Co 4 eg a wv er i Ao se a 3 a i) 5 a 43 wu D . A bl SB or t 4 ra) ae ' fo ~ : * Pa @ ort cel me ", U a a a 4 . wd 5 ~ 0g p be ty ' t me vet deed Rag % Q (O oh 43 Bs 3 j Be ame 3 nod Se wm =O Boom , SS 8 os et = DY 'y re a BG oy vs @ «4 Ba Bo gt Gs rf Bs 4 oN a ms od bs, " My y a ey » Mel 's tor OS 4 aod wD vt ws cf rae] ot wt ; ee: CG . % ae £: 7 es met 3 ard cay ' Pane 5.4 we, q SS ce 43 "el Oo Oy vee ~ ween 3 wt WS 4 rt So oa we oon «MO HS mw od eR - 1 ao bp © % ar , a oe at 44 nrg 'a ee) i ah rt Ww eo 3 ' > a 4 4 : a} > @ iy i ; a ' oa Pee 44 p Go % | HG > mF . Qo, a ~ 'p ao 8 # rd o i OM , we ep oO a - eo % 4 : ea, ca . oy SM 4, iat 3 " 5 ih % » oO @ Ss "< G WY LY "4 Cc , wD 3 Yel " © 44 oo OE ved Be w o vet my my i 7S 42 a @ es a Pp g Sos g cS Do B Bo oa B . COT a Bo 6 oon ae mo o @ ao 4 @ SS we tS Gt 73 Go 2 a 6 + G43 B G08 o kh & # a & @F 2» 8 6 » oo as gS oa me o ~ o + Med oOo Ff t ja a, oe ¢ ve z m +n ~ a : € i "4 6 ey Be w "s as 4 v - z my cS nC to a # ae » 8 bj Pp Pp GU & GOA a "3 oOo a O On. a @ @ o Cd ed sed " BA i & € i oa SS ; - 43 43 ty we ed A co 43 ay 4 Hi ta ay a ms is} ao aa & ° Q we Mo rt te eh é n ig hn oe 7 Ch '4 seed ic ord Oy dt ot a} <a aN "Fr tree My a BAC VOSS 4 ee
a) % 4 2 4 + ry LS Ad ot 7 u3 oq gee Ry bf Oy ae ret 43 eG ed wy a Sh 5-3 o =f mp + bed "a ed at ed 44 ce) ga mm Coy Bp fey ee .
we [vs #4 feof ip wig th o} ay uo fh, on ' nt * complet y w mes 44
1) thy 6 D ed en & a Find ad oy iLtmen Racor BSCcru wm Res "rd f4 a Cs} 3 wef m3 2D w iy rot pee feet we 9 my ae a ce yt ao a a ee ee fe fed bed bed % eX, Fad ard Ad cya "
rhs 4 ns) Wy a4 os 1s ces Aa TY co CP} eA fog ig ra) wy @ m4 by 43 Ry "sof = 4 Co 9 4 fo ie "hee wy i: in ot oS ert we J ma Deo). ih % "ef a re) in » ie) 'sect ae ' $4 uy wy O = $3 ey 44 reg m4 ved aw ae oa 3 is 3 2 ty a gs wy 43 @ ha ad "
fa ip a aor C 3 "ts w @ ah $3 ae OQ &4 5 ty o aa bj Gt ct i ' ~ 'oy ah 4 tied cx o + be es ~ x .
as Att ve vee} 2 igs BS ah $.3 G 2 oy rf ak Shed aye ' rentice.
ape ws ie) a oh sed 4 Oy 3 C a letter jated "
So "tt aa] if "3 im or} io2 be fe} ry mn 4 ory sy, be feof re) catio tLEL caf I fee a if bet weed S ng Oy Me Ww CD OM oy oy > e3 @ 4.3 mh i ar @ w fl © wy aed Ad ct rf a ved b4 re ce Gh w vy 4 syed 43 ued " of ed YD tf ed qh 2s wi vid os vet hf sed be Ww Ost © CO iy od oy to} td .
a G fh oO hes reiterate ew i 43 et 43 a wD 4 ' at a0) y ct 4.3 a recor 3 Lor «.
select oF tha re i ay .
2b 2 7 B & 8 > > "43 ? wat fo 1 ' #8 + O oh my 2B B rod ca) ; 4 * "4 4 os i 430 ed . 4h.4 4 x oe a} 3 aw . 2 c4 wf 2 4 Se A C } ee a Oo : wok rat 'p ot w Ae 4 if o} a wt wo . ' @ . as se os mi tt 7 43 i © fe iy ct O ca) "
ay a 3 42 5 @ eS Dp 8 o @ é bd ih ¥ co & weed red w M4 a nae) He mo : 44 is @ ws 3 ee O oe a ; 4 44 : © y a ws e No nm & Oo a ed , vB ag © Som & 8 B 2 Q, 3 0g UH 4 UDO ge 4 @ $2 rn Ao ted eek reef oO uy £95 bo red he ZL 4 CO ai a Pong. £34 '4 oe "
c ed '2 hed * hs nd nt ip i 43 "
; Ny 5 "4 Cc c 52 Q . .f.3 42 » cent see on ip ws 4 act et t we 4 % re : M4 ocd 4 i) oi a wb cS m8 wi cs ue we O 4 4 Oe 4 4) & Fe 4d re Ke wy '. " 6 gt eA a ss ares mS as om 64 @ 43 : * a Cy
3 " ret 4 Cd e bea a ~et cred ea ee ged es gs Q - Oy ras 3 + o el ey & a 5 rm, oo ; ' S 2 5 os ce O Ry ed a . >? haa . "en . re ty 'y mt Z o & + ao O% GC of 8 2 s Bos 4a 44 és, be 3 1 ta a "gs i Pp ocd wel 2 : ot & un 4 % 4 @ a oO © ol & a © o 4) e toy ct Wn 3} (s " 3 a ed 4 ct & "4 va bd sa k4 .
3 * i a g) Me uw wt rhs C3 ef go ao Yet w TS « my ti " - ' 43 "e an rm v qi og O yo» fg "4 sd $3 ord . . % rs! ; @ be D i wy ca ry co bf @ . ce @ wy 6s fa 75 2 "4 - & & a ° $ 6 Q B @ MS tT ree a i # a es 3 ' ras % ! af 3 @ Feat eA 3 = i @ of 63 4 svt ce 33 5 Ss " a Oy ed Gj a hit & 0 4 ry tit o. po tee wed "3 OQ C mod 43 2 wo 43 am wg 2 tt * in 3 kes Z O ae 4a M4 a wn "© or fa sl 4 A B nO} tS iat a my Oe m oOo : ag } ry 5 5 i Mm 44 o -- ky bf C vf © 4 SO . o UO a " €! 3 .: a O4 a xed as et i .
. as CG O ct a rp 4 . ' .
4 ry a os 43 ah of e ros Z ea st OG thy Cd ty hf xo : Ad Cy 2 bey orf 43 £3 eof a " Cj j iD @ 3 " @ 4 ue wy "4 © ' oO ie . at Q Q is oS oo «3 bw Sw GS og #8 g 6 oo 0 #8 Q Bo 3 a: ooo os £3 12 i ay On, a to a e 3 mf a oi & rd 4a @ ™ a oy e . OQ w 43 a Or ret ey ©) "het > NS re 3 anf a O , i a os . eg » 2 "s gt 6 a 8 sy "cd fxs eo _ Pd f iy. ce " . Hy od o £2 i o oa 3 bet Cs ar wo ; 5 n Ma ' | 3 és ' r 43 rn oy ' OQ ci 4 my oy 43 ~ 5 4 Or & a 4-H pea ee) it et 4 oF 5 Ce {3 Re co Ly 4. 3 iy ' es ut 5 . a re) 3 43 @ ® , eed rn Ad oS rte ve ed Q 2 uw & , oI "att 6 te wy UES "3 fos kt 43 iS 0 oS qh pe we rng G GC | wy ® -» 4 o SA eo # Mtg , os +e Fa wy G oped ia di uy tae kei Q od eee de 5 2: by 1 § % te 7 | 3G a 6 " 3 '3 3 wy a a 3 8 bo CG ond ee re a . be Ak 4 a} O ~ vB rs] 4 ed ey ~ Oy h od + 5 ci | Bet a ed bd i a $5 G fs ae O i WD m5 "ed ene a. a) C3 Cy 2 s o 6 @ oc 3 : c tt ; -t ve és 2 rs) bo bah cy . tpg v " SG rhe iB : is " *; 4 4 re) ao co ca r ee Q) a aS So 44 i Be ry Wy oA nt are iM ei oh ae] G C a3 @ "ed * . o ch m4 ve fea ad mn 4 oO cs + " i a @ ae eC mt 3 @ O 43 "4 ig "od G 3 $3 "eg G ie a "4 Fh, £ ba jot mu 43 id 43 y set x4 ie Ma iad 'ead me aa fa - ot a Ay $3 "2 rf a So " a4 "} Bs Q a n wt am Oy ha G L ted a SB rt ce + Dy 2 6 €@ $8 € 8 eo EG ane M "ee > ed F mS Oo ar. a % @ 3 m4 a et opt Oo = i LS to ai "4 as fa & ard ; 63 , om , a + oy ba oe Fa cs r 4 * we a, % ' 43 wd G ved oe Oo cea gS ~e-d ed O © uO wea @ es wn ~™ i oO a p¢g 2 & ~ mm 2 wm & Gs rt =f del o a % Me dd " rs a te i mS ie) i 5 ey vo 4 4 ® . Q i) ; OG ie ae @ Gy $4 i my Cm a te od a og hy ze 2 g 8 moo 8 BS , & Go56 ; 4 ci 5 4 15 cg '. aA id a a As ' § ; "
mG gy, m0 ¢ @ # ® re o Ho é 43 "sed : 3 baa ge ae o bes oe bh get bi O my 4S A my 4 to BG sy ae GC & oOo & ; 8 TS oO GB Bg i o SC @ 5 6 8 6 6 §& wt al - Gg oe eo ed Me a G So ' Go 4 a e ee ot rs i Oo um
i) 33 a ia oo F hd a Fa ord He 5 uy » S (S my £E 4 : be Ae. ry * " u 9 * "4 ve g ~ ' 43 got is + a! $3 So ~. ay oo ™ uw a a 4 4 of ve M8 8 o @ poe 5 SS oo RP 4 4 3 in ce £4 m a > % O 7D ae te rod ;
Q 5 % a aa a " «sd a ng @ EY os 5 $3 @ td OG te "sl © . 1 © @ a " GS B® mS Om 4 2 6 "4 oR 8 0 O mM , 4 Bo 6 § 3 D bs V Os & ne "4 wd ae 4 5 a ; ms nh £2 in 4 re Saf od Oy ran 5 4 uO a ( w mi o % Oo 40 hel Hh a ca La 0) an ay " oy te ret c fea ' " 44 @ ¥ 1 "3 ge " Mes ay 6 ins * o 8 o 9 5 '4 a whe a ¥ Y UF ir : SA A 43 a ad ct ha a oO re cq 5 et wy Qo ct 3 + 4 8 i a a OND, go FO Bp RD 13 t $s - @ o i ei ed a cs tt wo Pas au 3 6 La hed bn a4 O wo , 3 is 4 a ao 2B 4 a vr 4 ta " Ma 3 Ob os es Q " wo ct ' if 3 a © * cd @ : 4 ae x vu « me es i bef po Oy Bo oS oc bp Row ¢ 8 o 4 3 da & @ 6 BoB be 5 8 Eo es = ce 4 Oo 3 cs ee © ; cd 4 a Ou. Ato, e wD soo 8 eG cs on rs ° "ad bs, 2 & ca au wy '4 ws ud @ o a wo CJ iy 2] a tr © a = cs a a gp wd : ' es Cy os} ay 6L4 : 4 bef oct re c bo fy ts . wd be c ie a w @ ae en . iat a rod aD "rd we 4 " uw -- G c me 2 Me ; @ i mo 64 ra a fa 6.4 CG ie) be 43 <3 a a D cs i » 4 th GS 8 & ho ge cy ip mH ow 4 as , + Fe SR * oO Bog @ O Hy o £ 8 4 b vd oH Me $4 et por T a wef ted M4 ES, rt 4 rm) oa mS ' a th aw mo 42 Q a a S cs Ss 1 ei is) @ aa . eed aw nen o fa ' cf ie "w «rd us + j gC rd te be 3 th g ; 3 $3 So frp, . : r Oh, o, a te 63 w ey a 4 . wed a > a os rn in on m4 a 4 4 fa vel @ rf * i a" a A eo ra om a me { % cea DQ G Qs ny i in Ch, t wt = rs wD & a j 4 Be 3 Ooo" an @ oa . eo 4 " m4 ; go #8. g fs Oo 2 » 48 és 3 . A aoe 8 z o oa rs ej as MO tos, . wD oy 4 P '| 2 ry a wn o cy ne e383 * a 3 "4 <a u : '4 % id 4 weed a Q Ci G ' oo o chet t we & wD ee . re oa Or a) i i be mi eo & id bad hes :
ms ms OA. No, 382 43 of us @ reed L?43
G oY g Saad a ved c weet 43 i} ares 44 qt (8 =f ed 43 i ved 4 ie Cees.
;
MEA Bed £2, if} a od wet th ce Oy fy ff beef Railway * bey 5 x LY uw Ad OG qed Q GB ct ay by 3 hed a 4 a.
cad ey cD my usd mo ery "st
9) "ed rN Fa EO Y ory ca and 212,09.2 Zz % % "het, i & ats EMLESS ret Of thus at coals oak e an a st £} ' LON u 3 = Sade Ot 3g ~ Suk ce prob rp ?
oy 4 3 ha 3 et "4 1G ms, Q wy i Q ret 9.4 % O o he ( tte Boks i cLp a
o) dg i} oy 3 Qo w ve 43 4 a Shs co ip 3 SF .
is eS) Lo <p i ty Fd 9 OA, No. 38.2014 regular promotion and posting as JE-IT(Sig} vide order dated 231.160.2005 with immediate effect against departmental quota. Therefore the respondents ware promoted as "JE-IT(Sig}) much epee de * ve = a 3 OA Ths Ton 4 appointment w.e.f., O8.02.2007. The Indian vy + . - TO on de ® ~ 7 rh, . » roy ~ - a ~ 7 o-* Bealilway Estt Manual Chapter III prescribes ruies "302, Seniority In initial recruitment grades--Uniess specifically stated otherwise, the seniority among the incumbents of a post in a grade is gov emed i by the date ef appointment to the grade. The grant of pay higher than the Initial pey should not, as a rule, confer on a railway servant seniority above tho sse who are already appointed against rest ular posts. In categories of posts partially illed by dire pet recniiiment and partially by promotion, the erlterion for determination of seniority should be the date of regular promotion after due process in the case of promotes a "and the date of joining the working post after due pracess in the ease of direct recruit, subject to maintenance of Inter-se-sentority of promotees and direct recruits among themselves. When the dates of entry into a grade of promoted railway servants and direct recruits are the same they should be put in altemate postions. | the promotees oe ing senior to the direct recruits, maintaining inter-se-seniority of each group.
Note---{D fa: case the training period of a direct reoruil is euttalled in the exigencies of service, the date of joining th @ working post in case of such a direct reerult shall be the date he would have normally came to a working post after conigietion of the prescribed period of training.
fNe. E ONG) L78-SR-6-42 ai. 7-4-1982 ACS.
132).
ty {2 igenc IW © Note (i) The Provision contained in Note () above will alse apply to the Inter Apprentices and departmentally selected candidates against the quotas prescribed in certain categories to be filled by Limited Departmental Competitive Examination 1Q O.A, No. 38.2014"
{ such as 10% in the case of "Traffic and Commercial Apprentices).
{Authority Board's letter NO. E(NG)I-89/SR635 dated 23-8-1991} " ae te ae ss A ee ne em a AA ae
303. The seniority of candidates reoruited through the Railway B Secraument Board or by any other recrutting authority should be determined as unde {a} Candidates who are sent for initial training to Training Schools will rank in Senfority in the relevant Grade in the order of merit obtained } in the examination held at the end of the training period before being posted against svorking post. Those who join th x8 subsequent courses and those who pass the ex: mination in ubsequent chances will rank junior to tho ase Whe had passed the examination. In case, however, persons below: nging te the same RRB pane are sent for i training in batches dus to administrarh because of reasons attributable to the ; imter-se seniority will be regulate ed batchovise provided persons higher up in the panel of RRB not sent f training in the appropriate batch (as per seniority)
3) prod fo administrative reasons shall be clubbed alone with the andidates who took the training in the appropriate atch for the purpose of regulating the inter-se seniority provided auch persons pass the ¢ examination at the end of the training in the first attempt.
(Antharity Board's letter NO. EINGH- gor SRO/S2{PNM) dated 19-3-93) (5) tn the case of candidate w ho do not have to andergo any ireiting In training school, the seniority should be determined on the basis of the merit order assigned by the Railway Reeraitment Board or athe er recruiting authority,
306. Candidates selected for appointment at an earlier selection shall be semor to those selected later irrespective of the dates of posting except in the case covered by paragraph 305 above.
ane a ; - S we 309, SENIORITY ON PROMOTION, --Paragraph 306 above applies equally to seniority in promotion vacancies in one and the same category due allowance being made for delay, if any; in joining the new posts in the exigencies of service :
ren 4 ee . a a he % so x Ava #8 Nave perused the above referred rules ye + Joa Tree oy os Sets hoe wip ay t 4 - ae x carefully. Rule 302 deals with the aspect of ; :
"~ + * : Moyea y a a a . a ot * yt seniority in initial recruitment gredes. As per Nahe: s aoa uA ig wn ;
eo G OO 4 SO o re 6 "~ @ oo % 8 ° yO wy G ha t 4. sy 3 ve A 4 5 oe qed gy » BS 8 Oa oO" is o 5 bb & 6 & wo Sg mnt a a = ord ? BG G6 i LS Pt a ro D ~ * if hed % i b e Dp a ey "et } eed a rf ve i ad . eg Pe o "4 iS O v wm re orf vf a os 3 a m4 el hg ' + £ a £5 % iS G os ; - 4 ba | o , Oo hw ao mt, os, ft 2 8 8 6 | a a oO ~ 3 » © ; ro) o Q 2 md i hes J © a a c n "3 3 : ded wv i a % : ; cg a » Be i od he f ck b be 3) %S , i re . es * = 4 ' i. 4 O " 3 a Ss CO BG & 2 & Bp F oo 8 o & 8 % a"
> a @ S) Q ie) on tS go vef ded a ty Ge md a 5 ee, « 83 ig joe © op oS ts, eo 2 Ho om 4 53 a om bp ££ « a = & ry 6 és erg Goo oD S ca a 2 @ OG 8 o Wo $4 gy no <0 g@ OU & 8 a @ PB wm © a : u » ct i, ny % b) in vcd Me = a sD oe , ' Aa - 4 ci al om} gon} my a3 " ee . wy sd 4 a GB rs - a ; ct 4 4 tt "
£3 ; ~ wv CG Go #8 Oe uy ; g 7 ; rt 5 a 4 "4g reed @ Lo Toaat @ ud : 43 3 ra «© & I e m s ie od . oy oy An ; o ony Te 2 4 a) ce fx} " ie tt © a oe KS \ at aed = + ' 6 oo m4 E & '© Ty % co ia Yd is) Es Sy " +e A 4.4 Ty nee : rho G Oo ¢ i a aq 8 G§ 7 u : ih ' $3 . io & O 2) 4 < 44 " good "ad hee GS we A Q iv vi "4 i 5 wy a --y a, ; 6 5 Hi a Ls a C an : '4 : 4 S: xed b 4 - "A * A ae a G mond! OU! 4 & toa Ks ook o es ry fe a) Os . cl od i Dy 43 © ry "i qe a cy a Cc ae "eh @ ord 5 i ee eG sO Oa, 8. % a ~ « 8 Oo 8 eo 4 B&B qd 2 5 8 8g wo om oO & S @ o% TO % oS Dee OR & Mow o 7 8 ve oO Poop op Bb - 3 c + or @ 2 . M4 wr 3 4 ced res 7 2 rie ke "5 a uY i ed oO wy a gs o os ay es © Oo, tC ¢ }
7) bet +4 Pe 44 U4 0h 1 bed im . 3) ce . Gy ae fd Se Se te] oH a Ms @ Oo ce Ch, ry s 4 Aad re it a & es So Boy whet S75 v £4 ' raed y SS cg 'S) Q Oo ty i d . Q ved 4 3 : % SS i) & KE 43 aed ry) ~ 4.3 od ae) Be o fg mt ™ st a fe) a 4 cl 4 v G '4 as 4 " DO a bola w 4 Re 43 a cS an vs "Q G 1 ~ iD x "rf 2 ' ia aS ' 43 eg ' oO jd i iy o3 4 O = ip oe 44 i 0 w@ au , « 2 7 Ee 8 2 oS P28 eg ef Ms red } nf ves 4 . ; a co : "ec aa OF ts hy, q 5 3 2 ay @ Of © wp a ao iff is a oo fog 5S) Be Bo Mg 2 oo B® So 8 MY Fe Poe. Boa 4 Yo ££ & we | " ri eo 1 w re) arf 3 we oa SG Ww ® . p @ wet ¢ @ @ he a ret > oe! * G Oy md p D 4 $3 ic od ret ny na ae 7 ip B oa ; i" = FFs "sf QO. 6 $4 wD . ® rm) «a bet 1 4 he ib aa ot +3 @ os <a 6 oO co My . 1 f : cet , i t oe ~ 6 eo a § FP GO @ poe O sO Dp 8 @ @ G4 oo # es w eG @ 4 a) . M a ot a Sed O X ca a : 5 ™ O, © 4 QD 4 art a yo 4 4d ea ha " rn oy Lt .
% 53 Ch, ' Go Ww : a it me q cy , . OS 9 DB GO & oO mf 4 "4 3 o 3 sed bet 3 on S wd es, Ba @ gy ° G wd Os G 4 na wD co 4 ; ha © 4 a "3 i ah a .
F hd ny oo " od Trt 4 cy uy ay 64 wy ' ws a 4 43 oe ;
@ OO MM 8 & Oo Bp es ~ Be i hee tgs o4 & w gw fh Og tea GBB BD my * / re 5 '4 ; : - os CF $5 O, . % i eet oi o wes 4 2 : uy Dy 43 uy "ef 4 O ty a ved @ i 44 45 wes 4 G "M 2 9 7 BS, SO be a a peed c oe GO 8 ne ~ dt a 8 ga M4 $3 6S : ig uw $4 vet Shy AG Ye vert et Fi of " mt 3 Ct 5-4 O be wD on} of fp po og 2 8 8& Bo rp * c fm OO ep eet : fs ot a it = a , v4 s i . a @ ord C "4 Sg om : or} * ead "4 i ef w & 9 - ed ad SG 3 a mo SG a © ;
mt La bd G ved : 3 ¢ i ee co oy 43 ay a u a od uy wy nef aed : ed os we a : 3 "5 a ro} oa / - wd ki gc ": 43 { Sine iy Ly ©) C3 '. if (2 oo wr w 1 3 bt 3 a Fe uo * td ed % : 2 > ey a oh a3 od , yee} @ > iad "4 w G o x ee ay be b> iS es m3 mA 5 es $4 2 im Se a ee red os sed C CG wi "3 QB 43 e 54 % th ot " § 4 "4 3 ot «S , 1 ~ a t OQ, rn oy ia fs pe Oe / as a a $3 bi oy wy ON GB Gg 2 4 vy tr ' yee ne ot 3 u soa} ed a uf} P O Ye 64 4 o ref ea ' 2 ree i fy co) £3 ty 44 s . h % LS cry wD t m iy 43 Oo ay 3 i x uy 43 QB "¢S ; a Q es Hi red (G i 44 = ® ts rts NM © 53 ri a a GS ae AD Ys soos m cc » # 8 8B & Sg GS ood red a ch! b4 hy a 4 ic 3 tt thy nod a4 C $3 peed et oO beg bs, <y ct ro G ce ee: 8 eS mi GC ww» oO ® a os fog ay G x cc {3 > 4 a iW ~e4 4 Q ty Ky ee . "4 KG that '. ard a) 3 4 } a wes % ' 44 me v aa m4 Thy ti wy o ont on a 4 4 Ka Ke 0 ha So as £3 3 4 tt 4 = o y r oa G . } ( ; wy O 5 hea ry aa "tt "775 ert + fo ne cs ta rvt ' Bel a ~ c HS $i rt eo tT re gy a , 4 Ad a ie rl ¢ ped x Th o 0 a a4 @ ; a 0 om ss) "ed am 6 Ti 4 ad a 43 by 4 4 a - & $3 = as ~ Og s o sy 2 o O 93 43 a s a Rb Si A a 3 ' a, $3 2 HE iB ref KH $4 @ rf uy on bats ceqa i gs 33 G 8 ap vet . $y S ' oC O mo .s o) " a u a gi et 2 $4 None ip wed Mey =~ +3 cs a ret wed Bp Y oy a : 7 % a eg bes % i O ' a a A (ts wd 3) M4 . 4 Gg * & "3 C £3 + ey 8 % ™ wy 43 4 a 4 _ 0 gg he ns ct @ DW . 7 bs 85 bed ra mf 5 wy o " ay S 4 a rH a ' @ Ja an v r ma re ae 4d 3 - a O ao 0 Boe PR og BO ' fe wo 8 G& Go Ho we ' O or} 3 me LS hy ig C % 0 a $l Li fan A ed ' ws S fd i 9 i) 5, " G8 i st 4 m OG & ~ go 8 i w fm aM & 43 64 Set 43 QD ad i ae iB ws, . cS $3 4 a wn sed 3 - ve} caf y ret io 4 74 ' nt mn on oO es '. 5 4 es "ch G2, ad {2 OQ ne ned a . oy wn bed Me ca hei hay 4. go ta t ny ond Oo ed 2 ts 3 - "4 bs xs GB uy w "r4 4 $5 fe. s Day 4 3 ben, ij A net vet 33 4 , 44 a = i & ' Oo = { " te 4 Oo So o * wm oe a i' é Le w ef Ls s " Oo 4 Cc no ee ; ¥ : cid Ky {3 Sf wy . + 24 cont G@ a rt wD iy @ f3; Hos © ¢ S$ 2 ® 6 g & © § § m i oo 6 Bd HO + 44 43 43 tf wy 2 . a &a 3a w Fs o . % © Oy 4d iS oy 43 os © 4 43 4 4 wt a H a HW OQ, gb inf i e
- Ho O, m4 £3 GD A we as | we A Bea ay ee £ TR oak a ek SS A ant promoted to the post of JE which fEinds mentior im i y - 4 To - a il. We have gone through the said Letter. ed a + ee ee q + oe te shoe + a; ' = The applicant nas Laid stress on para 3i{c) af be RR 3 roular gn me "Aarts 7 WY tency Cae CAPTCULar Which Freacs as unger:
"GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY of RAILWAYS ; (RAILWAY BOARD) RBE Nao, 25/2002 Training Mannal Correction Slip No. 01/2002 New Delhi, Dated 25.02.2002 AY tao No. EGMPP)OO/LOIT! The General manager All Indien Railwaya Incliding Protection Units CORE/ Allibabad Metro Railway/Kolkatta COPMOW New Delhi The Txrector General RDSC¥Lucknow 4 Sub:Report of the Railway Safety Keview Committee (Part-Di998 - Successful completion of trainme course should be linked to promotien - Recommendation No.3.3 v0...
The Railway Safety Review Com mittee vide Recomunendation No.3.3 recommended as under:
"Successitd completion of training course should be Hoked to promotionjincremant™, have 2, bee 3, In this contest, Board hes decided that: C) eee (S) {c} Pre-promotional/prometional course should be made mandatory while promotion. Junior Engineer(JE) to Sectron Engineer (SE) but not for promotion within JE(Gri te Gri) and SE(SE to SSB) except in case of Signal Supervisors where the promotions! course is mandatary while promoting JE(GriD to JE (Gr.
@ oo.
{e) bree @ bees (2) ws xt a ih Ky ' wee we oe ; ff kg ty 4 re es OB € OC ww © a fe ge eS ~ @& Bo @ et tm wg oy Q "yt "4 ue ti $5 ° es © 0 (iy c uy " al ap ' a 0 1p 2 u Me dtd c oy cs g so ; Ged £m a o wn wy '7 . eed gt na te a $4 a "% 13 as vd i * % 23 i hy c a O ed - we. ~ he coed gt tof - 2 ad to ven ; ' 4 VY me aes it 4 . - ; res rity (3 7 6 ao re] & ped \ i st a cfs aa} mt ot me a a i} wy he : ay 4 5 of 3 a we i ed £3 + " : 3) fs a oF % 5 " no "OG tx} ws '3 ' 2 " "i fa ras wo % c $4 CO Pe 4 ts bj OU z ae mE n " : 4 4 Rs a se a O Go - " , nt seed ae ® Fog goo ' bt } on ie) c ms u we «¢ D 44 B ond it qa wa 3 i i ha 4 "i 8 i 2 6 sy ome © As me "4 GO bap aa Q 2 o wd Oy i Oo vo 43 4 at who ug 'et ; a 2 a a 3 iF) 5a ris) x 8) A ct 4 Oo ig 2 a rh ord ce Q Ho ee nn ar?) ca OR Go oy Bog , ca ao ee neped, one x a ei 7 OTs ne mC O = mw . . to Se, . © "§ i Po eo 4 O D ee o Oo Q - ; LQ
2) ' ca " - : * * 13 i ee "rd wo : 4d oe fe Oy Q hy a orf 4? wes a eo ; ig $4 Q " oy i 5] ie 8) <4 4.3 bot O oy ce) 4 va 6G rey y o vet 5 a Ea vr D 4D i oC $4 oy ae e "4 o" v wd "
by fg "3 OE Oo a wooo he o 3D
5 aged 4 fe xy : ' i. = ti 4 om "4 © 5 a) © i-4 "4 Et . b. es in et 4 Pz G cg Q 3 Of i w ht rel eo up 8 st nd Bs 3 a ' ce o ta wD "ty o yooh ot O ty wid '. Ry v4 gy $4 "ye re ee a} 4a $4 od ' d * 5 4 en "t cc nn --~ ww p ro 4 fd ; . a a Hed 3 aed ce re cA iJ ; ' ia ia m oO od ft 0 Oo © @ & &G@ wo BH @ a 4 ad ' . i vd i a § w i 1h 3 a wed Go 7 pa Bed a 7 a ja i A % ~ s Mi M Pe aS a G + ©} $4 , '4 uO ot Q Ch, 4.3 o feed Wa Oh 5) a \3 Cc rf ws Cr a) 4 wd ne v4 i+ & i Fs £3 O ' a} a on @ SS oh . C i C ao " hy i) 3 tes uy D ® Ss ad w G bo oe uw 8 ° O Fy w @ , 'ye eS wD us © L ey 1S i) 4 "gt O apd ' it nt fg 4 fd "cl O % 4 Oy oot og > . ES 'a es o 3 a Oo 5 + > rot 4- B ut ¢ "4 md Aa i & . oS a GS ~ f gs 4 ood Med . 1 a oe 3 4 be cc : a "4 : Ch, @ et x bet hs gS { or} wt bed send ui & ~ ma a hey a : o i) " ce wt i oS) be © ae i oy Pat pS i oy : ow oo.» 6 6©DlCUDlUSlUU UBB ob @ % &© vw 8 & a Q Oo 6 Mt 4 " o eed ' ma Be 8 re! "eh "£4 es a = £3 - oe bf a G ef : 5 ved a? S om 8 6 oo 6 es mot @ @ bas wg SH > & 2 ws "rt Ss -e 4 #2 8 ® 8B 8 @ 8 2 ie re Fxg tha Ch, BD on 5 i rs a hs s} oh Q w wD O 2 7 4 o via a he re $i " « 2 © a ff oO a OG AF ve oy riod 4.3 & fend i 3
4) 4 bd "rf hg 43 ort red 4 "To we tr qi "cl 44 2 3 4 s oh AO ANS ¥
12. eed umaxr} x { 4 ajay My Member (A) {R. .* (Ravinder Kaur} Membex (.7} Dt