Karnataka High Court
Dr B R Ambedkar Sc/St Association vs New Mangalore Port Trust on 20 August, 2009
Author: Anand Byrareddy
Bench: Anand Byrareddy
KW; €.;2@&W"E" 6% §€.a%W%fifi"fi¥ifi Hfiiéi-é {W %%%W&"§"fi%& QWQM flfiiifi? {W mmmam HWM fifififl? Q? KARi\§A'FficKA W654 mam' @393 %&RNA'§"&K& HRQH fl 23%? $33 ?:~;'3-£52}-E 5533? GE' KRR..E'éR?§%§£R R'? Efisffififibfififi fiR?$§ ?§:s wag 25" $3? Q? R§$m$T 2fié%_ "FE-ffi '§€'§%%'B§.;E zvmsizfiwifig azmm a*§.;:§---*2:*~:§i.§€;:'2§%§%"
wax? azwzrxas xa,245&1i2$a§€s4$£3§= .V BE?H§EE: V é'é V V ' aa. E.£. afissgxaa sc£$?'Ag3Q$1A?z§N= ' 02* E*=3Eis" .?>i?:P«§§}z§;QR%3 mam ' , RE?1%.ESE%§'?E§ 5? Im GE§EERR£;-,,3;7;CRET}:§%.'f; f:
Efifiififi auaazwv CQ%?RfiE,§R§fl" '- ~ 252%' réawaaaaas 9sre¢:s_ '*s*2¥ :?=%'?,,'. " . Pfififififififi » §7& s:a;""._*; '....9ETI?IaHEa my 333:; Anvaaarai '_ '*_.?;§:..%ZP5»;§?:'§%.§R W $33 31$.
2%: ;s§;a&:;';ia.Lje.§;E'5,%"72Cé~:=;3fV,':~*g:3$%;, "
35?. 3$'zTS=$§aIaaAfi,*, §fiE?, Eg§@a§a"ea§?3'&;§,' ?fiE s?A@$«§?-gA§§g?Ag$;f J 23%. 3? E?3\SECEE?£R$,>"
§E?R$?%E§? Q?*3§¢zA; ¥E&§%RE§ w_¥:£a$h gaagn, kaaaaagg w :.
'--._:''=é:~%:,;§:' "':?3+.:eé.*$: 2;;:;«*.2.§%,;~ ._ 'E-:§$za;:*::.§%;.=:g*és;~V..j:*;r;:g.:=,§,§; $R§??k§§%£§~§E$?R2§?, '* CHE?%%$§%$%;
~.!£&:§ aLg$§&§?a; §§EiI§E,§'§'E'%§'E Eféfifiéfififi ifiiféilfgi,» 5~€_'}?.§ §G%.*§" 'E"R.§..§3*§'§ mE$§$3E§§'$ wfi-wéwgmfimfim 2 U E § x ewm awwwm we" mmwmamw Wfifvw WP K&&Wfi."&%K& MEQH fiflifim" 0? Rfifiwfiigfififi WQW fififlfl'? Q? E(A§%NM¥'A5QQ WQH flméfifii" W? Kfimwkff raagamfient belafigs ta Valmiki csmmuaityg whiah is §et fiayaka csmmufiity" ag fifi the data 3%: héa aggeintmaht, namaiy; 2§,§.1§3§. The 3ai§*?&imiki ssmmunifiy figs been @e$1ar$d as a $$§§duLé§"tt£b%t by' a ?:a3ifi%ntiai fiatimifiatimna &até5*f?§;£g3991§k Thé ufaarth ragpandant hafig fiéaiv §r§&%§§§f 3%; an asaist§§t Efigifiéfifi ané t§§ra%f§a:_3§ 3fi»A§$ist3fi£ Exafiutive Enginegrk ?§§ g§ti€i@§§;H§d3e3 n3:
bei$ag ta §aya§%'_Afi$mgfiéi$§fi"_aa§ it i3 by 3u§pra$3isn_af ifiia fafii fifigg §% has abtsiméé 3 aasta ¢ariiég%gt§ afi§j§§$:駀ai%a§ tag kanafit sf prsmat§§§aig%$ 't§%f §3%i§g"fif tfia said falsa car§if£t&%§. §['f§ Di$' £§ tfiifi vein that tke §et:7.:é:;::. ¢-:2 $2 maugzzt befsrg this €§g$tgx % A S b ;§ ._?§% §etiti$§ar fiafi iaitial raiseé = -this i$sfi$ "with tfie 33%» fiaagaiare 99:: ?ru§t, w§i£§~ié %ha éfigiéyéf af its Mamb§r3 aha ix its » ra§£§§'3t Aa2axgrew"fl", tha amgiaygr figs Etataé x:fi§s:~ "Yam: £&m§lai§t ragarfiing grafiuatiaa $5': aha E8333 aasts 5 cartifimata by Shri fiieahagya .far fT Kgxnataka, $§fi§a; géhééxé gnd Lafisur §§p;rtméét; j'*§3 véfifiefi frmm the %e¢srfi3{f;t:i§ f¢an§ that Shzi_Alashap§a.fia$ n£tvéé;$ra§ any §gfi£§ifi. é3rma£kefiA t§»_$?A emgiayaes ,afigfi§~[§i3 ahaggéiétmant $2 New %£%§$%fif§ x%§f?_J£$E J¢E.{Ela§ ax T§.'VE?":,¥ii.<§'§ z.z.;::~:§ 2.8 . 4. 23%;. it "413 _ é$$é*_ afi£§§5tmaé :53: yaur 'a£$§$éi§i£fia ;fia§ mafia a gimilar $¢m§iaiaé t% the §$§., fiivil iigfiza _ ,EmfaE£ams§: fiaii, §§fi§a;sr& fifi V a §§;$é.2§%2 aad the yfirificatian '2 :§&§fi¢tad hy t&a 3wE¢ revagéa that ' $fi§i kia3§&§ga beisngs :9 ST hiataggry "fiayaka §¥a;mi%i}" aafi afiaaréiagky yaw fiave héfifi ixfiarmafi sf tag $§fi$§$$ mf the ifivastigatigm ¥i§§ his lettsr éataé 23§§x2fi§§$ Ea viéw af tag gfiavg, t§a &3§t8f £3 §€i§§ tzeatga as ticsefi"
é xx W "$W' Wm» ww aw-mmwwmmmmmflwfi iEf"'Ifl¥'%'ifi?¥"L$ %W,%*%§ WV sacuxiag emgiayment under the §MPT Eaarfi hag ham": examizmii in §ei:g3;,VE~._'°._ aafi .faund tfiat 39 astisn c&§» §é ':
takan agaiast Shri fiiaghgpgfi Vi§7 "' vi§§' sf the Karnatgka ssv@r§méfit g fiirzuiax %:a.3§":; 15%; :3;$§:
23.§.:9$: raga with thé_§rafi§;§iags j"
zziatetzi 1?.9.§.§§':,_"'«:: thwss a'§§V'§:.:§s%§§§.e'::t.
& § § § § u 3 § E < § :
E & Q E :3 Q Q E E3 'x § 2 g.
$ % % 3 § Q g E 3 £ E Z mm mwwma em?" mflfiwmmwm WWW m:}&..'§.%fl"§" W"
§. :2 the iigfit af SEQ game, it is net apgarent tfiat any iatarefit 5? right gaf the &$8§€iati¢§ is vifilatefi by virtue af §hé §¢mrth resgaafiaat having aecurefi pr@m§ti0aag i§,tEéT§a¢€a af thg amglaysr c@staa§é%§-_:haéH éfié:é" i5',n@5z apparéfit miaahiaf §1afad1fi*$y22't$§ flf§fi£th raagaadeni. Hence, t%é$é\is n&~§ramfi§ Qgfia mat"
3. ?he §&tifiififiHé§"f%§§§:%§a :udqe