Karnataka High Court
Narsamma W/O Bakkappa Metre vs The State Of Karnataka Ors on 19 March, 2012
Author: S.N.Satyanarayana
Bench: S.N.Satyanarayana
IN 11 111(11 (011 1 01 KAHN \TAK
('RCLH hIA( II (T[ I \RC\
1) \ltzT) f1I1' fIFE T3\'t tf \L\J(I ti17
lIE Oft
VI I
WRIT PEFITION NO. 83a71i201 1 (IA UKAJ
WRIT_PRO EU )N NO i:35f3H/2uI [LÀ LEA)
WRIT_PEITFIflN NO :15O- NImiu:2fli I (LA LCJj
\V1 NO 833111)01
BEIVEF N
Na -w nm a / Bakli pa fIn p
\e. Abuw 5) eaw.
Ccci tpat an Hou'ahuid HwJdnr
'if Nw \'iaiii Li'nOr C Bc i;'
B a ft
Sri aIx
£1 \LJ
13 N Jr 1 Iw
c
ftrc i N S i3\
I i dl
xl- 11
i diIi Iii \ ci B ni
C
Mi
3 I l
ii' i a i p
Sn. Vee--t antoutla !nr Sit P S. klalipaiilk Ad --
Fni N 3 sn GnuIi1i S K'--'-hnnpui t1v mr H 4. I
Ilu% uni pelIlic,n F, tiled iiiider atift t
e' 226 \ L't .11 flit
• nns'nutl'vi ,t India Pra>izuz 1 i%%''t wnt f rrt1o' •n €'nv
otlitr writ i ide. r quaslnn IL flOtitC% I'%Ued t 1 Ililiti
ic%pondcnl ia cd 03 08 2011 a c 2., OS 2011 titic n ecuit I
in tile N 131 tfl IIM/ADM 2 1 ) tilAnne'c N
B1'I)A 1PM DM 200$) 10 662 thrcby Ilnet Ihc r ondu ts
lot t) go lit icmchti,n o occs 41 t rcaid Ii ,ct Ii it
'csidcnU ii hou'e bc itecl it New cI ira i c g 0 I
3'L NO.S a6S it
Hf fl'IL\
.\nn uth S,'n '
thalr.e.t'
t
Air iibn'u 43lear'..
On'iipatlnn Bu%tness a.
sZrk ire Re. & ident.
01 Nei' •de.i sh Co1nn 13i' tar Pttiliui.*,
:I1 Sii:ICM 'ha! 3d
lala
Ill
) 1
1) 'ii)
bui (Ill'
Scud
dli 1kb fliLl' Fl 1 1 LIc
Ij
( f
.tt
31 h: : 711.. '
Jr' '--1ic•flt' ..f .''t"r.t I.j':
•. Ii sj r. •a
•
• •,.; I;. IT
% I .1
I
Sd. Veerantouda for Sn. P.S. Malipauik Adv%
I ir R 2 S' P ("unh S. &Lit mpur h ft i R 4
Iliis .int pctlli r is bd t id'r litaI( 226 % 2 el I
(orr--IlTwinn of India .irwinL! h lUt ;lt '.1 errth.iaii. .'i an
ntht z writ or order ciiia'.Jnn IN' n'vlt c !%_.j1.--(1 1t ?I. 1- '1
l
n ondc ii datcd Od Oh 2011 u.k Snnc n ( in fl
9tDk/IPM ADM/2O1i i thti h tet tic csp nc'nt% o
t lb dcii ililo jflo (%% %1li gaic to the pclitlo i
n"4d. ilila! Tutu,,.-- lot srt'sl iii Nn' _'lara,-h ( 'i!•,n' Uldar.
WI 'JOs S39 J5O LO 1
DL WEK1%
uiayak jrn.iii S/n Rurnnctana .!olii
kgekbou 15kaxs
Occupatin BankEr j.i e e. I it
OINt kdarsiz (aioiwBlda . htitlo cr
(B 4n: KM Ghau. Ad' ;
N
me t.vt- haniadic:.
fl'"iitT i1 Cf% rl?fl
)c'J_ S.' I l
t
I
I iltlii :h in Jilt ii!,
S.sirlha fl-iLtZJl(..3c.
2 - r) UI UI 101 Ir
' 1'. t
r iia r'a..
f,(. .J. p.ri- 1;' . it% rs.1k''
'11 lIt L
1 C c d
• r •;n g.Li• •. ..
. a')
.1 1'' )
C
-I
111CM nt pttition' are fled unck i \z tIdes 226 & 22 o
tic' Cnn'4it 'mon of huIIi pra mg ic 1%%u rIi of Ct Ph ran. I
:liW other writ, or nider .jli.Lhin1z the floUt Is'ued 1w tilt thin! "
rflj)C)lldt Lit datt'd u:i-us 21)11 md 25 0$ lOll titit Aiuic tu'e L
k. flit No' Dl 'D \/T1'M/XD1 '2(11! 1:2 and Annnitrt \ in tile \o'
t fl'%1 'StAt "009 In '" there b' I1re1 tilt' r%pt'n'I.--
13U'i)' 4 j%
ot to 'c Ioi deizniitin n ) L iilii £'ditt IC lic Pth11
(%1ti(I iii ic ist • icdii'N iastsr (clni
Ttu. it irit 4 hun'-- rOt "iig on Ic Prt 1
pit ii1111tC hit arlii.
l's tfllUj) tfli-- 'in, the ('out' Jtiatlt liii h'ikMifl2
ORDER
Al cc '. t dUtI a I jc't a e U spond r ta mci arm i i Tic the a ake tugtihcr t'si' tin ii 'Il'Pir%di 1 fIat I ' I lii aL petili' 'lit Li' 9 i 'ir 'n' 'tilt 'irriti' 'ii it 1% Ii Ii flt'li% I a'1 d" jis ta '1( t:fl)'i' IC. -- a. CL :1' Si. ., ' !], 'h' . . • tjgt .:f •,- , ii 'j "I', tic' tIt, '' ' 1 :" :1'... • : • 'n-. •h' % iCfl ii if 1 '-L'1 Ut 'I '1 1' If 'I'. 'It1'' e Is " ' 'C. ,'I II 1 ,,r • ' Is'' '.' -- '' ' U S heInnL'ln1 coiri 1 Wi 114 1OU%C'.. lw ci1rriarI1InL nun I flO ft '1 road Li ,"
Tt%fXit clein Inhtiall3 '--aid no'wt- iia' i%'41'LI 11. J)tILtl('i)ti' hcrein in 2Wt hnnit.1I. .. lv ilitainalter stIft% t'rt iilt-d L'v 1)rifl t OS % i;. '2003 z ft. 2( H.';' mit • 37 _.'.' G T • : :lt •r '.
'1' t%)
P • • 1 1
t t %(4 ...i'a,
anaipal ( n,il d .sk (3' ma' flit at '$n
ii lx cienc ci a 5 b 2(X)t will )b%tn-u'on that
t lEflt
ft of i 1 'cha. uk piOjX.rt% )Y l)1C iwis ii tld i b
105 (
he iii, 9. p I 1 s
ctt1rn ci .' cit nian' i -
l)eknlant it di s€uca uit ire i t t er h
law -
ic S acleL.1' it. thc si prnc c edin% ii I'- stat £ i 1* r aspc 11 ii
hrieln liav flL'y ni'Lhc r .-4fce 'i.ll flL. "p"!
rc--iccl 1 CtltI(
1) '.li 'W £ OU'C 'Ja ,Ictwtt --iac'ak' •a•n in ak' n ..n u--cLr, 1•l ..Z.
-
ian 1 171 'Iiii ii vIiLi3flt ' P r m "a' ha-il L,c;p u_a
aba 111'- r,'ft4nt " [.1:11 •jS Ir' Ii' Ci.
3 Inn ;i i
1 4
' p . I ,fr". a ' '1 r %fr 'I.:
I , • ' 'C 1'--l%. i,' • I ci',' Ii 1 1- L -I. ae.
4 •' .• -
- '
1 1j4
.111 I
• •...r, )f a 1 )T'• • 'sI t_J t.' A '•'1 ' i.c!._ •
%It C --. ) -- I ••_ •1•
a. "r i. •a • : •c • i
1 I I i I I
I r -- 1' I a
-- 6 -
and ut layout i •d%o €tpprnvcci by nmpctent aushcrn rndcr
lx I' in D eloiiiv'i Cl Ii ti it t i ncr ti'c I ic
fl ; (ii o.'l d Ji,' ,oni 1 •'t C ' er iwit' €a'd 'it' i '
'h) 1.--el nrtd 'hi' ii nit ;i %fl(i 'lUfl'% arc. ticUalliat .11.1.
( iii It S d rc MC I
.1. 1-n (nhlird. 11 P, tin- a.. of rnlJondents tlt't .q)pflAt (1
asout plar pc-I txar cndcr its nr srecfl C ilots rh
sub%equerIlh. 'a) out plan to1 moditic d ai id nurnbei '4 plc't'.
c e€ I ft 70 o 94 ml I lot o cUt ii' in
i(
Q
1 ' it' cIA
1 I"lOflai 24 ikil s 'a hi ii . • t P't ii I iSfl) t '.
a .id duc pri • d
to imnliIi.-d pl.ci 1 h'a I lie j'rr'J. ii •
ciyi c t pr . ft a f c
rqqj'a i ir., hted It' tflht1j tfle hi' )ltl ii . ' t;)r,;tnI ' i;- -' :
1 'a 11 I ni H " i %.
rc- -nc!'--'i'% ,. .Ii .'aj'rfl',- r I 4 L1t?
t a- , -I T.
±'•
•s t' ( ha sj,' a' --tl)''- I -- 4
I .. --
ir hc l.
.
i -- ,. -- !-.''--'i '. !-k •. I
• j 1
Vt
I -
..--.-- • . :.'i. . --i • •
5. llavinq heaid hit' nnuse1 (nj-- PthitlnTLt'r% and
tjrlci dir uicIlict1 sho i
itt us! ;t jt'-t I ,iro; u c
i
1 ) t if b •r rfli i
rt ning bi't 1 fl l• lt-%pnhI'IerU i 1') 4 10 mit i;itt eIPT.I "I 'I hfl1
Proc cclmg iaain I penn n s an ll
e
1 r a iflail pl.i . ci
pl)t ncr ndu pc'tt f adlitona 21 Mc thicI qaid
e brett I. 'rmc•d in iu1aiior' 'ii ,aiu rinne(L plan an t nqiiiry. Pid
hr .'snd'at:.'d ii i pn%Ih1' to reLL,'aric 'hr Ji1b t)ih. fl%t
i Ic o'itl i ii in q d
oqi irmiti w Ii 11 aridk r 1 Mar v a it Mx .o ic
ifter Qfl iL %ii11!ciCriL •ppoiiii1ii1 I petihi" .et in.1 'lIilii't
p' I l) I IT) 1d n tue •I jn ri:q' inl•
I) 'ihIi tflt' tni. .•itJ ,bei i,Llhii% tln--'.r ii; Lt'i 1 it 55%
li'j C v•
1 'sir. hi 'icy I ;a II • i . i t l• '1
Lit
I ii t• ' I: I I
Si;
juDGE