Karnataka High Court
M Ramadevi vs State Of Karnataka on 24 August, 2012
Bench: Chief Justice, Aravind Kumar
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 24TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2012
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR.VIKRAMAJIT SEN, CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE ARAVIND KUMAR
Writ Appeal Nos.4850-4904/2012(LB-BMP)
Between:
1. M.Ramadevi
Aged 42 years,
D/o Mohan Ram
630, 7th Main Road,
2nd Cross
Domlur IInd State,
Bangalore-560 071
2. N.V.Devaraj
Aged 48 years
S/o N.V.Venkatesh
B-No.1, H-No.30, Tin Shed
E.W.S. Quarters,
Koramangala
Bangalore-560047
3. Vanathayan
Aged 45 years
S/o Jagannathan
No. 1294, K.K.Halli, Ramdev Garden
St: Thomas Town
Bangalore-560084
4. Samiulla
Aged years
L.R. of Dilshad (Expired)
EWS Quarters Compound
Ejipura,
Bangalore-560 047
5. M.Sampangi
Aged 37 years
2
W/o Late M.Muniswamy
281, K.S.Garden,
Lalbagh Road
4th Cross,
Bangalore-560027
6. V.Saleem
Aged 52 years
S/o Abdul Lathif
Represented by Zenathunnisa
Aged 45 years, W/o V.Saleem
Ist Floor, No. 68, 3rd Cross
H.B.R. Layout
II Stage, Venkateshpura
Bangalore-560 045
7. Lalitha
Aged 39 years
W/o Chikkappa
Miller Tank Bunk Road
Vasanth Nagar, Bangalore
Represented by GPA Holder
Abdul Javeed
EWS Quarters Compound
Ejipura
Bangalore-560 047
8. P.Nagomi Christina
Aged 36 years
D/o Purushotham (Expired)
B-No.1, F-No.10
E.W.S Quarters,
Koramangala
Bangalore-560 047
9. S.R.Chandra
Aged 61 years
S/o Late Raghava
No.7, Shrif Nagar, SC Road
Yeshwanthapura,
Bangalore
Represented by GPA Holder
P.Saroja
Aged 60 years,
W/o Purushotham (Expired)
3
B-No.40, H-No.2
E.W.S. Quarters,
Koramangala
Bangalore-560 047
10. Anthoniamma
Aged 56 years
W/o M.S. Nathan (Late)
No. 7, Richmond Town
Baldwin Boys High School Quarters
Bangalore
11. Shanta Bai
Aged 63 years,
W/o Bapu Rao
Honnadevinilaya,
Punya Devi Layout
Padmabhushana
Dr. Rajkumar Road
Kalkere
Bangalore-560 043
12. P.Shamala
Aged 36 years
W/o Mohan Ganesh
6th Cross road, BDA Complex
Austin Town,
Bangalore
Represented by GPA Holder
M.Sheela
Aged 36 years, W/o Isaac
E.W.S.Quarters, Viveknagar Post
Koramangala
Bangalore-560 047
13. Gayathri Bai
Aged 59 years, w/o N.Venkatesh Rao
313, Kuvempu Nagar
Jalahalli East
Bangalore-560 014
14. Santhanam
Aged 54 years
No.4, Patel Shamanna Bldg
8th Block, Koramangala,
4
Bangalore
Represented by GPA Holder
Savariammal
Aged 37 years W/o Late K.C. Rayappan
24th cross, L.R. Nagar
Viveknagar Post
Bangalore-560 047
15. Ramu
Aged 57 years S/o Late Govinda Swamy
No. 19, Block 34
EWS Quarters
Bangalore
Represented by GPA Holder
Shanthi
Aged 38 years, w/o Anandan
No. 34, 2nd Cross, N. Lakshmanrao Nagara
Bangalore-560 047
16. Amsaveni
Major
No. 17/1, Gowtham Puram
15th Cross, Ulsoor, Bangalore
represented by GPA Holder
Regine Sathy
Aged 48 years, w/o J Sathya Seelan
No. 117A, B-No.31, 3rd Floor
Austin Town, BDA Flat
Bangalore-560 047
17. Krishnapa
Aged 47 years S/o Late Muniswamy
No.42, 6th Cross, Wilson Garden
Bangalore
Represented by its GPA Holder
K.Kanagaraj
Aged 35 years, S/o Karuppayya
No.1493, BDA 3rd Stage
Neelasandra
Bangalore-560 047
18. P.G.John
Aged 49 years, S/o George
No. 25/1, Nathnathpura village
Hosa Road, Electronic City Post
5
Bangalore-560 100
19. Prema T
aged 45 years, W/o Late T.Eswara Rao
house No. 10, Block No. 30
E.W.S Quarters, Koramangala
Bangalore
20. V. Flora
Aged 46 years, W/o Mr. Patrick
C/o T.S.Nagarajan, 717, CMH Road
Indiranagar,
Bangalore-560 038
21. V.J. Thresa
Age 70 years W/o George
KSHA Stadium Opp. Sukhia APt.,
Richmond Town
Bangalore-560 025
22. K.Selva Raj
Aged 52 years S/o Arjun
No.138/1, Seppings Road
Bangalore-560 001
Represented by GPA Holder
Alexander
Aged 40 years, S/o C.S. Paul
H.No. 3, I floor, Narayanappa Complex
Kundenahalli,
Bangalore-560 037
23. M.Venkatesh
Aged 36 years S/o Marappa
Block No. 15, House No. 13
EWS Quarters, Koramangala
Viveknagar
Bangalore-560 047
24. Kannamma
EWS Quarters Compound
Ejipura
Bangalore-560 047
25. N.Ramanathan
Aged 58 years, S/o Natarajan
6
No. 221, Angenaiya Temple Street
Bangalore-560 047
Represented by GPA Holder
Janeshwari
Aged 35 years, D/o Arokiadas
No. 16, Block 1, EWS Tin Shed
Vivekanagar Post
Bangalore-560 047
26. G.Kanaiah
Aged 58 years, S/o Late Govind Swamy
No.3, Kaliamman Temple Road
Ulsoor,
Bangalore
Represented by GPA Holder
M. Vijayarani- 37 years
W/o V.P.Mani (Expired)
No.530/1, KS Garden
3rd Cross, Lalbagh Road
Bangalore-560 027
27. P.S. Chinnathampi
Aged 49 years, S/o Sathyan
No. 10, B Street, Arab Lane
Bangalore-560 025
28. D.Bharathi
Aged 43 years W/o D. Venkataraman
No. 28/2, Basar Street,
Bangalore
Represented by GPA Holder
Shashikala
Aged 30 years, W/o Manoharan M
EWS Compound Tin Shed
Ejipura, Bangalore-560 047
29. M.Mayil Velu
No. 64, 2nd Battery
Pin Sen, Line PKR Nagar
Maya Bazar, Bangalore-560 04
30. Zeenathunissa
Aged 52 years w/o Mohamed Hussain
No. 67, Sulthan Nagar Bangalore
Represented by GPA Holder
7
Noor Fathima
Aged 45 years, w/o M.Nazeer
No. 29, 2nd Cross
Muniswamappa Layout
Hithayath Nagar
31. Gangamma
No. 1442, 12th Cross
Ramakrishna Hegde Nagar
Arabic College Post
Bangalore-560 045
32. C.Padmavathi
Aged 48 years, w/o Thirumala Setty
No. 9, 2nd Cross, Vivekanagar
Bangalore-560 047
33. P.Murugan
Aged 43 years S/o Parasuraman
B-No. 34, H-No 12, EWS Quarters
Koramangala
Bangalore-560 047
34. Munian P
Aged 50 year, s/o Periyathambi
No. 279, Lalbagh Road
K.S.Garden,
Bangalore-560 027
35. Mariya Lilly Pushpam
Aged 54 years, w/o Irudanadan
No. 49, 5th Cross, Ayyappa Temple Lane
Vannarpet, Viveknagar
Bangalore-560 047
36. Subramani, aged 54 years
S/o Marappa, residing at No. 59,
Coles Road, Frazer Town,
Bangalore-560 005
Represented by GPA Holder
V.Maheswari
Aged 47 years w/o Vijay Mathu
B-No.30, H-No.3, EWS Quarters
Koramangala, Bangalore-560 047
8
37. Muniyamma
Aged 48 years w/o Thimarayan
M T Bund Road
Vasanth Nagar Bangalore
Represented by GPA Holder
C.Raja
Aged 30 years S/o C.Chinna Kolanthai
B-No.1, H-No.8, EWS Quarters
Koramangala, Bangalore-560 047
38. S.Rajashekar
Aged 41 years, s/o Swamy
EWS Quarters, Vivekanagar P.O
Koramangala, Bangalore-560 047
39. Muniswamy
48 years, s/o Muniappa
Block No. 32, Flat No 19
Miller tank Bund Shed
Vasanthnagar, Bangalore-560 052
40. Chandramma
Aged 46 years W/o N. Nanjundappa
No. 43, Maramma Temple Road Street
Parvathi Puram, Bangalore
Represented by GPA Holder S Shivagami
Aged 57 years, W/o Srinivasan
No. 109, 2nd main road, Rudrappa Garden
Vivekanagar, Bangalore-560 047
41. Mohan Singh
Aged 51 years, s/o Gowardhan Singh
Miller Tank Bund Road
Vasanthnagar, Bangalore-560 052
42. M. Kumar
Aged 47 years, s/o M.G. Muniswamy
PWD Quarters, Wilson Garden
Bangalore-560 027
43. RaviShankar
Aged 40 years, S/o Vishwanathan
Block No. 8, house no. 4
EWS Quarters
Bangalore
9
Represented by GPA Holder
M.G. Jayanthi
Aged 43 years, W/o M.Kumar
No. 8, II Cross, Vinayak Nagar
Bangalore-560 030
44. T.S.Uma Rani
Aged 40 years, D/o Muninaga Reddy
No. 2000/4, Honga Sandra
Bommanahalli Cross, Bangalore
Represented by GPA holder
K.Jyothi
Aged 32 years, W/o Saravana Kumar
CPWD Quarters, No. 132, Block-4
Koramangala, Bangalore-560 047
45. Abdul Satar
Aged about 54 years S/o Satar
No. 130, C East Street
Shanthi Nagar, Bangalore
Represented by GPA holder
M.S. Regina Xavier
54 years, W/o Xavier
No. 1, Munimarappa Street
A.T. Halli, Shanthinagar
Bangalore-560 027
46. Jaipal A
Aged 57 years, S/o Arumugam
EWS Compound Tin Shed
Ejipura, Bangalore-560 047
47. Maila
Aged 51 years, W/o Rajendran
EWS Compound Tin Shed
Ejipura, Bangalore-560 047.
48. Mubena Begum
Aged 37 years
W/o Syed Ali
No.214, Kalasipalya Main Road
Bangalore
Represented by GPA Holder
J Leela
Aged 51years, w/o Jaipal
10
EWS Compound Tin Shed
Ejipura, Bangalore-560 047
49. Kamala Bhai
Aged years, w/o Krishnaraj Bist
Miller Tank Bund Road
Vasanthnagar, Bangalore
50. K Bhaskaran
Aged 42 years, s/o Krishnan
EWS Quarters, Viveknagar Post
Koramangala
Bangalore - 560 047
51. M Sampangi Ramaswamy
Aged 43 years, s/o Anjaneyalu
No.81, 10th cross, Sonnenahalli
Viveknagar Post
Bangalore - 560 047
52. Ameenabai
Aged 60 years, w/o A Ummer
B-3, Flat - 1, EWS quarters
Koramangala, Bangalore
53. M Subramani
Aged 50 years, s/o Muniswami
No.182, K.S.Garden
Lalbagh Road, I Cross
Bangalore-560 027
54. K Selvaraj
Age 49 years, s/o K Krishna
No.2, Anjaneya Temple
Viveknagar Post
Vannarpet, Bangalore 560 047
55 Chandramma
Major,
Miller Tank Bund Road
Vasanth Nagar
Bangalore
Represented by GPA Holder
Chandrika N.R.
No.21, 2nd Cross,
11
Viveknagar
Bangalore- 560 047. ... Appellants
(By Sri.B.C.Thiruvengadam, Advocate)
And:
1 State of Karnataka
Through its Secretary, Housing and
Urban Development
Bangalore-560 001
2 Bruhat Bangalore Mahanagara Palike
N.R.Square
Bangalore
Represented by its Commissioner. ... Respondents
These Writ Appeals are filed under Section 4 of the
Karnataka High Court Act praying to set aside the order
passed in Writ Petition Nos.9393-97/2011 and 23602-
651/2011 dated 10-08-2012.
These Writ Appeals coming on for orders this day,
Chief Justice delivered the following:
JUDGMENT
Vikramajit Sen, CJ (Oral) Learned counsel for Appellants states that Appeals may be dismissed as satisfied in view of the Agreement Exhibit-C entered into and recorded in Writ Petition No.45915/2011. Ordered accordingly.
Sd/-
CHIEF JUSTICE Sd/-
JUDGE sp