Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Jitendrakumar I Patel vs Ut Of Daman And Diu on 14 February, 2020
* 1 Od No. 7422013
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
MUMBAI BENCH, MDMBAT.
ORIGINAL APPLICATION No.742/2013
Date of Decision: 14.02.2020.
CORAM: DR. BHAGHWAN SAHAL MEMBER (A}
RN, SINGH, MEMBER (2)
1. Htendrakumar Ishwarlal Patel,
Son of Ishwarlal Bhaevanji Patel,
Date of Birth: 14.06.1978,
Age: 36 years, working worked as
Primary Teacher (contract), under
Assistant Director of Education,
Ukistrict Panchayat, Moth Daman, in
Govt. Middic School,
having Ovat Zari, Moti Daman,
District: Daman Pin Code 396 220,
Riat H.No.36/3, Sura Falia, Moti Vankad,
Past Bhimpore, Nant Daman,
Daman & Diu GUT) - 396 210.
2. Jignishaben Parsottam Patel,
Daughter of Parsottam Baheubahi Patel,
Date of Birth: 10.08.1984, Age 29 years,
Working/worked as: Primary Teacher (contract},
Under Assistant Director of Education,
District Panchayat, Moti Daman, in Govt.
Primary School, having O/at Damanwada,
Mott Daman, District: Daman pin cade -
396 220. Rrat H.No.153/1, Dalwada, Chowky
Falia, Near Airport, Nani Damen, Daman & Dim
CU-T.), Pin Code: 396 210,
3. Nebaben Vinodbhai Tandel,
Wo Vinedbhai Kamjibhai Tandel,
Date of Birth: 09.04.1985, Age 28 years,
working/worked as Primary Teacher (contract)
under Assistant Director of Education,
THstrict Panchayat, Moti Daman, in Govt, Primary...
School, having Cvat Devka Colony,
Nani Daman, ENstrict: Daman Pin Code 396 210,
Rrat Doctor Shery, Moti Daman, Daman &
Din (LTD - 396 220.
4. Tandel Rokilaben Kalvanbhai,
Daughter of Tandel Kalyanbhai L, .
Date of Birth 07.06.1978, Age: 35 years,
working worked as Primary Teacher (contract)
tat
under Assistant Director of Education, District
Panchayat, Moti Daman, in Govt.
Primary School, having O/at: Dalwada, Nani
Daman, District : Daman Pin ~ 396 210,
Riat HUNo.58/2, Kadaiva Machhiwad, Nani
Daman, Daman & Diu (U.T.), Pin Code: 396 210,
Madhavi Jayram Tandel,
Dio Jayramn Gopal Tandel,
Date of Birth : 22.05.1975, Age: 38 years,
working/worked as Primary Teacher (Contract),
under Assistant Director of Education,
District Panchayat, Moti Daman, in Govt.
Primary School, Ovat (English Medium),
Nani Daman, District : Daman Pin - 396 210.
Rat 11, Guiabi Bungalow, Parkota Shery,
Nani Daman, Daman & Diu (U.T., Pin 396 210.
Mukte Babulal Shrimalt,
d/o Babalal Shankarlal Shrimali,
Date of Birth: 08.12.1984, Age 29 years,
working/worked as: Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education,
District Panchayat, Mot? Daman, in Govt. Primary
School, Ofat Nani Daman, Dist. Daman 396 210,
Riat HD-405, Radha Madhav Residency, College
Road, Dunetha, Nani Daman, Daman & Diu (O.T),
Pin Code 396 210.
Yandel Bijalben Krishnabhal,
Do Tarde] Krishnabbai K., DOB:]4.10.19 U7,
Age 37 years, working/ wor ked as: Primary
Teacher (contract), under Assistant Director of
Education, District Panchayat, Moti Daman, in-
Govt. Middle Schaal, Ofat Marwad, Nani Daman,
Distriet: Daman Pin Cade 396 210,
Réat H.No. 24/2, Radsiva Machhiwad, Nani Daman,
Daman & Din (UT), Pin Code: 396 216.
Halpati Shilpa Dallabh,
Dyo Halpati Dullabh Shankar, DOB:20,10.1979,
Age 34 vears, working worked as: Primary Teacher
{contract}, wider Assistant Director of Education,
District Panchayat, Mot] Daman, in Govt. Middle School,
Ofat Kathiria, Nani Damen, Dist.: Daman -- 396 210.
Rfat HINo. 3 LSB, Bandodker Peres éapabar,
Nant Daman, De man x Du GTQ 306 210.
Patel Darshana Narottambhai,
DYo Patel Narottambhal Babubhar OO68:15.06.1979,
Age: 34 years, wo:
under Assistant Director oF Education, [natrict Panchayat,
JnaAvarked as: Primary Teacher (contract),
2 O4 Na Payenis --
1d,
ih.
i.
3 G4 No? 42/20}3
Moti Daman, in Govt. Middle School, O/at Kathiria,
Nani Daman, Udstrict: Daman Pin Code 396 210.
lat HNo. 10-166/B, Kathiria, Nani Daman,
Daman & Diu (UT), 396 210.
Nehal Dayanand Yagneshwari,
D/o Dayanand Laxmanrao Yagneshwari, DOB:19.06.1978,
Age:35 years, working/ worked as: Primary Teacher fcontract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Dholar, Moti Daman, in Govt. Upper Primary School,
Ofat Ringanwada, E/M Daman, Dist, Daman -- 396 210,
Réat Shree Niwas, H'No. 15-55, Sagar Samrat Road,
Khariwad, Nani Daman, Daman & Diu (U.T.) 396 216,
Amishaben Gulabbhai Patel,
Dio Gulabbhai Khalpabhai Patel, DOB:07.11.1984,
Age 2° years, working Worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School, O/at Dabhel,
Nani Daman, Dist. Daman 396 210,
Rat Ghelwad Faliya, Dabhel, Nani Daman, Daman & Diu
CULT} - 396 215,
Unnilaben Mohanbhai Patel,
Wo Nileshbhai Shankarbhai Patel, DOB: 24.04.1974,
Age 40 vears, working/Wworked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School, O/at Dabhel,
Nani Daman, District: Daman Pin Code 396210.
Réat Amaliy a Faliya, Dabhel, Nani Daman, Daman & Din
(LET, Pin 'Code 1396 215,
. Meeraben Mohanbhai Patel,
Do Mohanbhal Chamarbhai Patel, DOB:16.01.1979,
Age: 33 years, working/worked as Primary Teacher (contract)
under Assistant Director of Eduestion, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School, Q/at Dabhel, Nani
Darnan, Dist. Daman ~ 396 210,
Réat Amealiva Faliya, Nani Daman, Daman & Diu
(U.T.) - 396 215, .
Vaishali Lalbhai Patel,
Dio Lalbhai Babarbhai Patel, DOB: 14.11.1981,
Age: 32 years, working/worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School, O/at Bharwad F 'alia,
Disteiets Daman ~ 396 226,
Vat Masal Chawk, Nani Daman, Opp. New Petrol Pump,
Dut Sagar Bungalow-I, Nani Daman, Daman & Din (VT,
Pin Code: 396 710. .
Varshaben Amrutial Patel,
AMER sein ee
16.
19,
OA No P4202
in
Dio Amrutlal Patel, DOB: 08.03.1976, Age:37 years,
werking/ worked as Primary Teacher (contr act), under
Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Mot Daman, in Govt. Primary School, Ofat Bhaniti,
Dist. Daman ~ 396 220
Riat HLNo.2, Village Bhamiti, Moti Daman, Daman,
Daman & Din CUT.) 396 226.
Kavita Udavkumar Damania,
Wo Udaykumar Ganubhai Damania, DOB:11.09.1981,
Age: 32 years, workingworked as Primary Teacher (contract)
under Assistant Director of Education, Dist. Panchayat,
Dholar, Moti Daman, in Govt, Primary School,
Re Damanwada E'M, Dist. Daman -- 396 220,
Vat HIN. 14, Village Bhamti, Moti Daman, Daman,
Daman & Din (UT) - 396 226.
Patel Madhuri Chhotubhai,
Dyvo Patel Chhotubhai Vestabhal, DOG-01 06.1978,
Age 36 years, working/ worked as Primary Teacher (contract)
under Assistant Director of Education, District, Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School, Q/at Moti Vankad,
Nani Daman, Dist. Daman -- 396 216.
Rat Zari School Faliya, Moti Daman, Daman & Diu
{UT ~ 396 220.
. Dhod: Manuben Babubhat
DByo Dhod) Babubhai Bhagn, DOB: 30.09.1978,
Age: 35 years, working worked as Primary Teacher (contract)
under Assistant Director of Education, [istrict Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School, Ovat Partyari,
Moti Daman, Dist. Daman -- 396 220,
Rat Zari School Faliva, Moti Daman, Daman & Pin
CLILYTD ~ 396 220, -
Javaben Natvarlal Dhodi
Do Natvarlal Jivanbhai Dhodi, DOB: 14.0 1.1983,
Age 31 -years, working worked as Primary T eacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Edueation, Dist. Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School, Oat Zari, Moti
Daman, Dist. Daman -- 396 220,
R/at Zari, Katha Fahe, Moti Daman, Daman & Diu
(LT + 386 220.
. Jyatiben Chhotubhai Patel
Dig Chhotubhai i Bapudbl nai Patel, DOB:29.12. 1975,
Age 38 years, working' worked as Primary Teacher (contract)
under Assistant [rector of E dncation, Dist. Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary Schoal, O/'at Naila Pardi,
Moti Daman, Dist Daman - 396 220.
Réat 7/3, Zari, Kathe Palisa, Moti Daman, Daman & Die
(LENT) - 396 228.
3
2U!3
ed
nN
3
tds
O4 No. Pas2023
as
Chandanben Manilal Patel
Dvo Manilal Bavabhai Patel, DOB: 15.12.1974,
Age: 39 years, working Worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Dholar, Mou Daman, in Govt. Primary School,
Oat Ambawadi, Daman, Dist. Darnan -- 396 220.
Réat 02, Kaushal Apartment, Ambawadi, Moti Daman,
Daman & Diu (U.T.} - 396 220.
Jignaben Gulabbhai Patel
Dio Gulabbhat Jagan}i Patel, DOB-15.03.1982,
Age: 32 years, workine/worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School,
Gat Kharpwadi, Nani Daman, Dist. Daman ~ 396 210,
Rat 46/2, Ghelwad Faliva, Dabhe!l, Nani Daman,
Daman & Diu CUT), Pin Code: 396 210,
Alpaben Jagdishbhat Patel,
Wo Jagdishbhai Dayalbhai Patel, DOB:13.05.1978,
Age: 36 years, working/worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School,
Gyat Dabhel, Nani, Daman, Dist. Daman -- 395 210.
Kfat Ghelwad Faliya, Nani Darnan, Daman & Diu (LT)
Pin Codes 396 210,
4. Ranjanben Babubhai Patel
d/o Babubhai Dayabhar Patel, DOB: 18.10.1974,
Age 39 years, working/worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Mott Daman, in Govt. Primary School,
vat Dunetha, Nani Daman, Dist. Daman--396 210, |
Rat 15/95, Khariwadi, Nani Daman, Daman & Din (U Pay
Pin Code : 396 210.
Nitaben Balvantbhai Patel
d/o Balvantbhai Bhulabhat Patel, DOB:19.05 1985,
Age 29 years, working/worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
ander Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School.
Gvat Bhimpore, Nani, Daman, Dist. Daman 396 210,
Rai HUNa. 18/7, Patel Faliva, Moti Vankad, Nani Daman,
Daman & Diu (U.T} -- 396 210.
Tyotiben Narayan Talekar
d/o Narayan Keshavrao Talekar, DOB:13.07.1976,
Age 37 years, working/worked es; Primary Teacher {contract}
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School,
OVat Moti Daman, Dist. Daman -- 396 220,
bo
md
Gade se
=
Bad
°
8 Od No. 74272013
Réat L177, Prabhu Faliva, Nani Daman, Daman & Diu
CULT, Pin Code 396 210.
Chetanbhal Motibhai Pate!
Son of Motibhal Madhavbhai Patel, DOB: 13.08.1974,
Age:37 vears, working Avorked as: Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Mott Daman, in Govt. Primary Schoo,
Gyat Marwad, Nant, Daman, District: Daman --396 21).
vat Mota Ghar Faliva, Manvad, Nani Daman, Daman &
Diu COLT.) Pin Code: 396 210.
Parimalkumar Abalpabhai Patel
son of Mhalps sbhai Ranchhodbhai Patel, DOB:16.04 1981,
Age: 33 vears, working/worked as Primary 'Teacher (contr -act),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School,
O/at Damanwada, Moti Daman, Dist. Daman ~ 396 220.
Réat Bheshroad, Koliwad, Nani Daman, Daman & Diu
(UT) Pin Code: 396 210.
RKantibhai Ranchhodbhai Patel
son of Ranchhodbha: Kalidas Patel, DOB-07.07.1976,
Age! 37 years, working/worked as: Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat, .
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School.
(Vat Dalwada, Nani Daman, Dist. Daman ~ 396 210.
R/at School Faliya, Dalwada, Behind Basukinath Temple,
Nani Daman, Daman & Din (U.T.) - 396 210,
Anjana Manish Patel
wro Manish Narandash Patel, DOB: 23.01.1983,
Age 31 years, workineW orked as Primary Teacher (contract)
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
se Daman, in Govt. Primary School,
'Ofat Kadaiya, Moti Daman, Dist. Daman ~ 396 210.
Wat Motivankad School Falrya, Bimpore Panchayat,
Nani Daman, Daman & Diu (U.T.) = 396 210,
Talekar Pragnaben Narhari
do Narhari Bhikhubhai Talekar, DOB: 13.10.1981,
Age 32 years, working Ww orked as Primary Teacher (contract),
prider Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Higher Secondary School,
Ovat Mott Daman, Moti Dannin, Dist. Darnan ~ 396 220,
Ryat Hl Nowy '106, 'Kasarw ad. Nani Daman, Daman &
Diu (UT. - 396 210.
Smit. Cheinaben Manilal Ramil,
d/o Manilal Vallsbhbhe eae DOB: L061 984,
Age: 28 years, working worked as Primary Teacher (contr: act}
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat
Sat
Lat
Lad
as
ws
~~}
hog
we
: a
oO
vd
Od Noe PAB SGl3
Moti Daman, in Govt. High School.
Ovat Varkund, Nani Daman, District Daman ~ 396 216,
Ryat Simar Faliya, Varkund, Nani Daman, Daman & Diu
{LUT} - 396 210.
. Hetanaben Vithalbhai Damania,
do ¥ ithalbhat Deahyabhai Damania, DOB:20. 10.1981,
Age: 32 years, working/worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Middle School.
Oat Devka, Nani Daman, District: Daman ~ 396 210.
Réat Bhimpore, Char-~Rasta; Nani Daman, Daman & Diu
(U.T.), Pin Code: 396 216,
Patel Vinodkumar Vasantbhai,
son of Vasantbhai Morarbhai Patel, DOB:22.03.1979,
Age:34 years, working'worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School.
Ovat Jampore, Moti Daman, Dist. Daman -- 396 226,
Réat HLNe.S50/3, Magarwada, Bharwad Faliya, Moti Daman,
Daman & Diu (LT), Pin Code : 396 220,
Tejal Vasantran Yagneshwari,
do Vasanthhai Tukaram Yagnesiwari, DOB: 10.06.1984,
Age 30 years, working/waorked as Primary Teacher (contract)
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School,
OV/at Varkund, Nani Daman, Dist. Daman -- 396 210,
Rvat H.No.221-7/10, Zala-Plot, Mangebwad, Moti Daman,
Daman & Din (UT) Pin Code: 396 220.
Maheshbhai Ranchhodbhai Patel,
son of Ranchhodbhal Kalidas Patel, DOB: 25.09.1979,
Age: 34 years, working/worked as: Primary Teacher (contract)
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt, Middle School.
~ Ovat Radaiya, Nani Daman, Dist, Daman ~ 396 210.
Ryat School Faliya, Dalwada, Behind Basukinath Temple,
Nani Daman, Daman & Diu (U. T.)- 396 210,
Dipika Ramesh Patel,
d/o Ramesh Mohan Patel, DOB: 23 3.06. 1984,
Age: 29 years, working'worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchay at,
Moti Daman, in Govt, Primary School.
Ofat Rhimpere, Nani Daman, 'Dist, Daman ~ 386 210.
Riat Bheshroad, Keliwad, Nani Daman, Daman & Dia
(2.7.3, Pin Code: 396 210, "
saben Balubhai Patel, :
Subhasbhai Gopalbhai Patel, DOB: LS LLA98h,
of
if
40.
4h.
fos
ve)
8 O4 Na 7ai/3
Age 32 years, working Avorked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary School (EM),
Ofat Nani Daman, Dist. Daman -- 396 210,
Réat H.No. 15/120, Patel Faliya, Rharpvadi, Nani Daman,
Daman & Din (UT.} - 396 210.
Vibhaben Rasiklal Solanki,
d/o Rasikial Mandan Solanki, DOB:11.06.1983,
Age730 years, working/worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
wader Assistant Director of Education, District Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt. Primary Schoo] (EM).
Ofat Nani Daman (Daman, District Darnan -- 396 210).
R/at 301, Dhanhari Apartment, Near Sai Kripa-2, Mashal
Chalk, Nani Daman, Daman & Dia - 396 210.
Solanki Neeshaben Ramjl,
d/o Rami Karsan Solanki, DOB: 16.03,1982,
Age 31 years, working/worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Education Officer, District Panchayat Din, in Govt.
Primary Schoo! No.2, Vanakhara.
Ofat Vanakbara, Dra ~ 362 370,
Rat H.No.220, Mahakali Hotel, Aazad Chowk, Vanakbara,
Din ~ 362 570.
Doshi Sejal Nandkishor,
d/o Doshi Nandkishor Bhupatray, DOB:1G.08.1979,
Age 34 years, workingworked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Education Officer, District Panchayat, Din, in Gove.
Primary School, Ofat Revdi, Din,
R/at Randal Shari, Diu ~ 362 520.
+. Chauhan Hemant Jerai,
sfo Chauhan Jeraj Laxman, DOB: 15.06.1980,
Age 33 years, working/ worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Education Officer, District Panchayat, Diu, in Govt.
Primary Middle Schocl. O/at Nagoa, Diu. ,
Réat Savli Niwas, Darma Street, Ghoghia, Diu - ~ 362 $40.
Solanki Yogeshthai Bhikha,
sig Solanki Bhikhabha: Laxman, DOB: 28.10.1978,
Age: 34 years, working/worked as Primary Teacher (contract)
under Education Officer, District Panchayal, Die. in
Govt. Primary School. Qrat Bucharwada, Diu-- 302 320.
Ryat H. No.720, Koliwada Masiid Road, Ghoghia,
Din ~ 362 540.
Solanki Lalil Karsan,
sfo Solanki Karsan Varjang, DOB: 01.06.1977,
Age: 36 year, working worked as Primary Teacher OEE,
under Education Officer, District Panchayat, Dig, in Govt
Middle Schoal (Boy 3}, Ofat Vanakbara, Din ~ 362 370,
ais
Se
=}
A,
Las
news:
uxt
Oa No, 742/2013
Riat HNo. 797, Timbasher, Vanakbara, Diu -- 362 370.
Kamalia Chetna Lalji,
d/o Kamalia Laljibhai Bimjibhai, DOB: 22.09.1975,
Age: 36 years, working'worked as Primary Teacher (contract),
under Education Officer, District Panchayat, Diu, in Govt,
Middle Girls School, O/at Ghoghla, Diu ~ 362 520.
Rat "DHRUV™, H.No.218-B, Near Church, Firangiwada
Road, Din, Pin Code: 362 520.
Bariva Bharti Deva,
Wo Devabhai Sidibhai Baraiya, DOB:02.01,.1986,
Ager27 years, working worked as: Primary Teacher (Contract),
under Education Officer, District Panchayat, Diu, in Govt.
Primary School No.2, Ofat Vanakbara, Diu -- 362 S70.
Réat H. No, 1356, Janaki Niwas, Khavvawada, Vanakbara,
Din ~ 362 370.
. Anita KReshavial KRathad,
wo Jayanti B. Chauhan, DOB: 09.06.1989,
Age: 33 years, working/ worked as Primary Teacher (Contract),
under Assistant Director of Education, Distriet Panchayat,
Moti Daman, in Govt, Primary School,
Ovat Moti Daman, Patlara, Din ~ 396 226.
Ryat C/8-C Govt. Quarters, Fort Area, Moti Daman, Dadra
& Nagar Haveli (UT) Pin Code 396 220.
Bariya Jignasha P.,
d/o Bariva Premji Vira, DOB 22.08.1983,
Age 29 years, working worked as Primary Teacher (Contract),
under Education Officer, District Panchayat, Diu, in Govt.
Middle Schaol (Boys), Ofat Ghoghla, Diu ~ 362 228.
Rat (O1DC) Complex, H.No.A-06, Din -- 362 540.
Vaghela Jalpa Kishorbhai, .
d'o Vaghela Nishorbhai T., DOB: 15.10.1983,
Age 30 years, working worked as Primary Teacher (Contract),
under Education Officer, District Panchayat, Diu, in Govt.
Primary School No.3, O/at Ghoehla, Din ~ 362 340,
Ryat BH. Na.S05/3, Main Road, Ghoghla "Vishram'?,
Din ~~ Code ~ 342 S40.
Minaxi Tivray Baria,
da Five} Pancha Baria, DOR: 02.08.1981,
Age: 32 years, working/worked as Primary Teacher (Contract),
under Education OMicer, Dist. Panchayat, Din, in Govt.
Middle School, O/st Bucharwada, Diu -- 362 S40.
Rrat Sorathiya Street, ie) Jalaraan Niwas',
Din, Pin Code - 362 52
Nanditaben Mukesh Vaia,
wo Mukesh N. Vala, DOB:19.04. 1980, Age. 33 years,
10 Of No. 74272013
working/worked as Primary Teacher (Contract),
under Education Officer, District Panchayat, Dia, in
Govt. Middle School (Boys).
Ovat Ghoghia, Diu. R/at Main Road, Gandhipara,
Thu -- 362 520. :
$2, Kazi Wazedall Bashirahmed,
afo Kazi Bashirahmed Mustafamiva, DOB:30,11. 1982,
Age: 31 years, working worked as Primary Teacher (Contract),
under Education Officer, District Panchayat, Diu in
Govt. Middle Schoa! (Girls), O/at Vanakhbara ~ Dra -
362 540. Rlat H. No.929, Haliyawada, Zampa Road,
THu, Pin Code: 362 520.
$3, Baria Pragati Meghy.
d/o Megh}i Harji Baria, DOB: 18.02.1987, Age 26 years,
working/worked as Primary Teacher (Contract), under
Education Officer, District Panchayat, Diu, in Govt.
Primary School No.2-. G/at Vanakb: ara, Diu ~ 362 5
Rist H.No. 1940, Mithhwadi, Vanakbara, Diu ~ 362 570.
$4, Jethwa Hemangi Jitendrabhai,
do Jethwa Hiendrabhai Sara}, DOB:17.05.1986,
Age: 27 years, working 'worked as Primary Teacher (Contract),
under Education Officer, District Panchayat, Diu, in Govt.
Primary School No.1, O/at Diu ~ 362 $20.
Ryat Police Quarters, A-O, Gandhipara, Diu -- 362 320.
in
tay
. Makwana Dixitaben Nanji,
Wo Makwana Nanji Bhikha, DOB:20. 10.1985,
Age: 29 years, working/worked as Primary Teacher (Contract),
under Education Officer, District Panchayat, Diu in Govt.
Middle School (Girls), Diu. Oat Dim ~ 362 520.
Riat Behind D.M.C., Parsiwada Read, Diu -- 362 320.
86, Jethwa Yatinkumar Bhagvandas,
sfo Bhagvandas Karmchand Jethwa, DOB02.09.1976,
Age: 37 years, working worked as Primary Teacher (Contract),
under Education Officer, District Panchay at, Diu, inGovt.
Middle School-Dagachi, Ofat Dagachi -- 362 540.
R/at Lal Bahadur Shastri Marg, HUNo. 1274, Ghoghia,
Din (UT) - 362 540).
. Solanki Geetakumari Hardas,
w/o Solanki Navnit Premji, DOB: 28.10.1982,
Age: 31 vears, workingworked as Primary Teacher (Contract),
qunder Edueation Officer, District Panchayat, Din, in Govt.
Frimary School No.2, Ofa Ghoghla ~ 362 540.
Réat HUNo. 744, Saranagar, Prem Bhuvan, Ghoghla,
Om CUT), Pin Code: 362 340, * es Applicants
iddvecate Siri RG, Walia)
Gat
re
Ll O4 No. Faev3Gi3
VERSUS
i. Union of India through
The Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs,
North Block, Central Secretariat, New Delhi 110 001.
b>
District Panchayat, through its
President, Office at Dholar, Moti Daman,
Pin Code- 396 22
The Administrator, Union Territory of
Diu, Darnan and Dadra & Nagar Haveli, Secretariat
Moti Daman ~ 396 220,
tH
4, 'The Secretary, UT Administration of Daman &
Diu, Ofat Panchayati Raj Institution, Daman
& Diu (UT), Moti Daman,
Pin Cade ~ 396 220, «» Respondents
(Advocate Shri VS. Masurkar)
ORDER (Oral)
Per RN. Siagh, Member (J) The present OA has been filed by the Avril}, passed by the respondents. whereby the a 1Th KM 4 S4 fede 3 us a rt é ce o irs gssistant Teachers which were regularized vide order dated 13.06.2013 } + % ---- Sem et PR PAS et "~ oy ee + RAaVe Again bean restored on cantract basis 7 "3 4 =a ~ Sf + wae 4 ey a I ee py en r AGMLinistrater of Union Territory of Deman & bewd Th ° Pyeng " PY o + 4 ay ey te oe 5 wy = mo BLU, Daman. The Applicants have alsa challengea the order dated 22.07.2018 passed ' 2 Bay os, To, fi AR an Ft - by th oy 5 by the Respondent No.4 whereby the order(s) = ni Yes lard sak pay rye cb Se rn ae the OF FeQuLlariZatron OF Le BEWECes OF te 12 04 No. 242/203 applicants have bean suspended with further directions to put the applicants again or contract basis.
°F 7 3 ey STF + So ery ee ey
2. The Applicants have prayed for the following. reliefs;
"Sg This Hon'ble Tribunal will be pleased to call for the records and proceedings of the ease witeht led to the passing af the Inpugned order dated OLO07.2013 and after going trough its validity legality, constitutionality. propriety, quash and set aside the same with grant af all consequential benefits which flows from order dated §3.118. 2013.
oe &fayi) This Han'ble Tribunal will be pleased to call far the records and proc ceedin ny of the case wa x which led te the passing of the impugned order dated 22.07.2013 and after going through its validity, legaldiny. constitutionality, propriety, QUASH AND SET ASIDE THE SAME with grant of all consequential benefits whieh flows jrom order dated 13.06.2013.
8.5} This Hon'ble Tribunal will be pleased te haid and declare that tie order dated 13.06.2013 issued | by Respondent No.2 regularising the services 2d wie of the applicant s as Teachers cannot be interfer with or suspended by Respondent Nas.3/4.4
© &.¢) Any other and further orders as this Hon'tle Tribunal may deem fi, proper and Rec EXSUFY in the facts and circumstances af the ease.
8a} Cost of this Original Application be provided for."
3. £'The Apolicants have filed MA No .Nil dated CQ.12.2013 seeking ermission to file the present OA Jointly. Learned counsel for the applicants si ubmite thah the applicants GCG ® Wm try ae eC G me og v oe 4 i ci as need » 2 A a 4 au "A oH A ie os "3 th . :
oF qa yak " "cA ad bel 3 "3 oS @ O % % os O oe 43. I 4 4 Qo of Mt wok Soe oe 6 OB BOR BO Soe «we & es oh a nt He 5 to Mm eG . as ud o 4 bof oa 4-3 it ch é Y ire! O oy * + Oo 3 ~ oO pO " m, 47S Se wee 5 is:
ee uy oO 3.3 bef * c> at '. 'eat qj La 44 a2] 3 ved y ins ay 2 : " ? ord he Me ry i syd wn D 0 ae a a 4 ca rs @ ted oe ' ore 47 43 ws c 6 iG 3 A ty a Fay} c 7s "4 wy ot b4 et rs 22 ni - om fo Om oO Q 5 ms : aed ¢ La SoS Rn Y = trod ae ded seh SS b . : a eB Go GO lm ao Re = GF © "a ip Sy ms mio ' os 5 ds Ty ks ON Ue UB OG » 28 YF & MG Go om a E O ar 5 Y o pp gf ¢ mw 2 2 8 . & BD RB GO & 8 : my ES aS os 43 body & hi @ a eS tot ¢ wed i ot Oy oy cc ce 4 5 es MM wa a} rs are} Fa ia) AD G a et 23 be pad bel ca $2 + 5) am @ O CS ad re be i Dp co yy "4 ae 8 O se c Pat @ Ks wed ES bd ss re 1G bb ed is ro * wd @ pe 5 ws a ca & good Oo Dp ha oO © a am oa rm ow @ th 6 Oo © ri fF Gs tS mg B oho yg BG Mp RE Qo v i a > O@ oS a FF 8 yA" DP & 8B wow gg 3 : wy bt "a ' rd. wet sed veh ; - 7 , y mt hy ' © rt ; « o z ep od © wm OF G o +5 ge Cr mi & '. ef ey re) KG ee ee Ay ut ie 43 et bed 4 us oe ha Led a @ o at "1 © 43 "4 a t * be rot » arf a ay Se a ug ot xt & + ot ® tb bed Ad ot G ry © & ON 1D Goes = Bg ed hg co" a a 8 a Oo os 9 8 me 9 ree hy 0 a 2 9 Comm a 7 a od aw 4 Rt tet ob oy 5 4 eo 4a ', FON gy fo Md Smee 4 4 i ) : Sy * a 4 hs 4 é 7 : 5 te ie vet o Sy ct ge 44 Fhe a G oi ne i > : . 2 by au oo G "eh ef i iS Ad * i) ns, x 7 ? it Cc re ot oo @ ws a e% 42 @ a "st rc rd ry ae ard ot fG 3 oO ve eet & o 3 eg nm @ «4 > & ted oY an & mm £ ' 5 GU @ sod 2 » A B soos BoM Se Oe a me be Om BO Oo Q aq; mm 3 fe, @ O 0 = ey } 4 Ma a : : & Le on D cy 64 ' a cs oS ny no QO o w & « fu Fh, Ps ay , eS ae w 4 g & @ rm it e ff £ xp ia C3 ved * ont Li O '4 a) at Sa * i bet oe Cha wo Shed i . oh os wo Sy Ss ts ey et & oS s a ted M4 fod 45) oo Shy Fa vee oo cad ° et oe ; ed ch Hed € wy C3 fet ie} . 63 Seba ws co bal bn ~ fo 4 Q ~ , a CS in ced "4 eo a a bo § 8 mn OG G ¥ fe AF us a g ug A ord 43 a «L tO a oh Se 2 eh a 1 a = "4 o Thy fe yg ~ qi SD ge wr © iS ad / 8 By ¢ mg ooo# = ge w cei 0 a fe cS 6 arf ; ; CN @ o3 cs r B s "i i) a on 4 ep 'bet : o : go Oo 5 end es a dd Y aw re a 1 o ed o 43 ay iad wet = i 3 vet ard ce eed a tha ed oh 4 + es + MN rh rd 8 x &, Oi te bad g 4 @ a "rd 14 ® et 3 o oa . ved 3 oO j . ; o fae oo fl ssf CG ae wnt i 0 o ry * r49] coy Sed « 4 . 44 ped ® toed 4 (v4 yy, rf ged i a i a me) wo " hs m cD 3 4 % Q hes vet . S oe rl $4 m 3 Boo Fo of @ @ a et Ge Boor , okt m8 > 8 a 65 ot oe w S tb ¥ 4 _ ; on phy a wed ns | cmt ard o i oe 3 ad fed ind 4 Y «ped tS my , s ay ped ong bee fy t 4 es os oo oo 8 4 # © #& BOSS tS moo) 6m ne ME fa Eo ed @ S r i ba ss a C4 i4 G4 No. F427 201 3 "T hereby declare an oath that the above information ix correct and complete to the best af my knowledge and belief and nothing has been concealed distorted. If at any time I am found ve we voncealed/distarted any -- material info aration my appoininent she ail be Hable tea SURTNERY fer puination - without noticercampensation. ' Po d appointment and on being found feds the sa y44 5 es ay } a a tt yon, iw ¥ % ME em et successful in the said selsckion process, Soh pe oe ae ges voy . 5 +. ey ony de aq i.
the apelicants were issued appointment are still continuing from that date. under the respondents! department Le. Sarva Shiksha ohiyan, Union VYerritory of Daman and Diu, Daman Mission Authoriny preavided hat the applicants were appointed as Assistant Teachers, Primary School on daily:
m ry © By 5 "S if) Ry po
o) Sh.
C. fry oO Ra wades/contract basi C Sd nh ae oe ~ ay ss > &. Besides other terms amd conditions < ~ yy on ine ; 3 eae: 4 2 noted therein, the ssid OM also ¢rovided os , ee laden et if ts 3 . * Am a - therein that "he/she shall have no right for
- 2 oy oe ~. ae . 2 L~ Sen ae regular appointmen » the ~post an future. % 7 - s x z as Pa' 4 5 ry Ae Subsequently, wide order: dated 69,02.2005 hag rr rs uy @ Led ct loon) . hot 5 v oS on rh , % a Q AS oi , pet ol ind Bee wn : by a 7 8 8 Sf bon £ ©£ ® @ § 2 f & 4% 0 2 © mm CC ew go ty ri Ww 8 qo 8 ag a. &. 8 on DO Oe ke & Y a a fa ct ry © o x a4 sof p " a , tee yond hod oe Sut gi 4 z ap 3 iN n & @ no) ye o - i - Ba mm a iH iy bor be . rot . god apd a) O od AF wp in 43 f 4 a m sa wet bed yes at ise 44 Uy wa aut is Fad Ba 1 ' 4 os &. int 'Lo ' ' a i . 79) G 43 to oo ct 4 " i ood ord er 63 : a ab i ce 4 we BRD ew fs _ pe GB rh Eg wo OE @ 2 Ci el o a i iG Oo " ae o a cr O 4 Shs cca = = 3 ig S Hob BG eS 9g HM , @ ~ 7 BO Eg & om 8 6 8 8 # . o, a wy re! oy v it ce a 2} 9 6 5 yO My B tS o oe] pod G Fa weed a Xt ky thd is we ra ee eg OB 4 @ RB # . 8 ° 2 Be 2 8 ae mt GG 9 © @ Pp G © 4 ep @ & & 6 A my 43 my, er a O Aes Ch, a coed : ie > cc 2 a a mw CP on :
ine et u r f rhe aged iy : wy x w shes ao uw a "
" ft fy vod gC yu A oie} ort patie : co 97 4 oh 4 " mw tn v iG B 7 Fe yg 8 io mn wm mM Hol w 40 os ge is 7 PA aw 2 4a ht ag oot ea 5 C . wt . wk & ya 3 cS 4 4 {ft & ee 5} tt Say Y ad "cd * oO God o 5S 6 Bb » © F gw 8 vw 8 so mR tt " dd Doh Se ~~ m G ' oy Oe s+ O (oe OR ee 2 beh a 4 QB oi @ td oO & sed ed ~ tet Q fa o "
ced p w of fe Se 4 2 in "% "4, ho ks fat - 9 3 A by Ud wt Y be & os a w et ft ef G oO G8 Ae. aod Met o ~ w bs, o Cc ay Fe! eo wt jeoe} i eo wv us "4 > ort n o o w b> ge" & a a ap i Sy = J 0 se 6 2 % ga o h 8 8 PR Bw gS ml @ 68 »p YB &@€ 8B g 4 8 6 7 B Y &€ 8 B es ¢ @ BB @ a i ie % mw : of OD Oy em , Bo Pog ; Og ew Go » 6.8 & a # weirnay bet ve or ry 44 ct he ond td aot wm a CF i reed Lh et oh ic Ch; : o " " 4 ; a 4 ¢ o * "4 : " 5 ca rt 8 o goad mS a ' a eG vl 4 ns 2 "t $3 mS wy Ss yy o td Ss 6 = 2 8 a a GS Gs _ 8 8 g 6 & f od BEng uy "4 fh, ft HG @ ~@q~ vw + 7 « ri 0 ey on CO ge O @ BF pm © «2 mt tp eh Oo 8 OF @& wos mn eS g «& - POR Go a = Eas a a ood GS go 4 ns eo oR «© fo ; yo © ms "8 os $4 cs $3 st C ns Seu a o uy , a GO ard * YD oh 4 & Ay {3 Q { ded 2) de a cn ' i 33 G 13 eed eo ia) @ fy. ~ed 4 od m fot TH Bet mt --~ Do OQ 54 : Sood O 0 or oe bee t os : 5 oI , - "3 . . Cog wt BY 6 « 8s 9 2 & a a » 2 & © 8 SD & i veo ¥t ; ' ° i 1 ra ry 4 aed ry e oy o G. GP Med o - a HU 3 @ , s rs) or 3B + u « Mp & ow & mw fg 8 5 6 B gf goo: & eo 4 8. 8 ' iv cD ch, ri ¢ 7 oe 4 a Es wy cy ' cy oO rm . ; A bobs Oy id Oy Oo wt te 63 fs cr reel ms a ms hed Sed a 4 nd Gu Sha ti ~ 42/2073 "
ff f GA No. rs Cost regular @ "
ey th wD seged wn ord wa m8 ek oh o word a ma AMS th FO' arf o3 aed gt oD mOriby.
* Re de a3) & ent ah mL Y g ¢ ot choot had ret 1s 4% ¥ x a Bek. & aot cred Mt ys is Y oA x"
Aw ai 2B my
a) "e-4 9 rae eet tft @ a4 4 oy vif % os tae! me yg g he ey oy ant 2 AAS Lae ot pe h te ke ws «bt fa od oa 4d ei ee ya © aged:5
Q "sed sass yea the ay vely Ss * * exc lus.
RS n a ator $4 a a x Py te LA Cas eed ts) Prat Qu 7422013 ANG?
XE OA bod 43 2 i Pa ey g a 3 Ae 5 e @ bt 63 ay v a fF 8 co om oe 4 #2 oo § & 40 ved aa ad a tt ad OD fe a a ie a i " nn vere te, eo «6 ww BS Q w Se oa wei #8 SS & .& oe Oe wo i 6 4 Ow -w & 6 -« «@ § ew ee 8 a oF $3 i = eas '2 a o 2 «od vd rt my S se seg c ug cl a co & bo a 8 pF SM el Sow bk £ 8 Bw 5S 6 5 #@® «@ ¢ oe & wu Lt O a @ wif 4 ON tt oe) aw iv ~e4 yp Bas S i t , & rt wed uy Chg Qe 44 G ie cs 64 wi eyed C rot 1] 'of ad a3 m 4 w a 3 G rf 43 oy A Oo o oS = rd 4 ned pat O god rf Bs, 4 ES seed F633 a Lo) ry a jeed io a ka ; ' mn nt 0D : ef 2 : o 4 O, , bet 23 @ Oo 4 64 ed * 'et « i" wy i vet oa 2 a Cj a HA 2 OC « a ih Gg 8 8 Oo - Go op we Pe © Hog fe 4 w@ a ted ae) a bind CG " 4O 4 re . "3 a M4 a o a ies $4 ' 5 ¢ ~ am Ae y 5a . } 6 cs - . es a rl - a wo es on 4 ff | on BD ee a at tpt & ' aE 4 Aa o g {4 ri l @ a Q an O i 43 See a 3 5 5 rr ft 4 i cs AS o on O bod oo "A Fes} Pag "od a + se a fa re 3 G 2 & oo DP oo o fed OTS oA ; bE eg rr 3 ws i Ss het Q ae v ™ fq qe OO gO oF ow Of a5 Y ke Oo 8 ' 4 43 wy @ y goose , Bn 8 wm © . ee ah A ¢ ag & a MM 3S ay ns: cs a ot on n myo roy pry $3 os 0 i ee SS 7S a A a 4 ie a +4 a 4 wy a os id , we } ¢ Bo EO . : a a oe OD EE © oe eo Dg 3 ne cd 9 CUO a e sy AG s on o WR Qo eed ot - . i et 2B xe) OES ¢ S$ 8 ® 6 & 8 8 c Gog OB 6 @ 53 3 & @ C Hoe §$ 8 Bg Be ee & B 4 9 6 QD me 6 5 3 fF SG fk ' st 0 ct i " Q 43 ; a rs) Pa 2 fats 43 i , wy ' 3 ~ ; : Yet a Wo eR 5 'a ae of wy ees 5 3 wo oB on 4 2 @ & » 8 4 og HE © 2 8 6 § 6 B 4 FB 3 Soo S £ BS 8 o 8 6 9 ae 44 i ot co 6 Oy ; r 4 re vol - es md 3 itt ry w co cj Ss O 2 © © Mi ' eS & mt a bd iE rf me " a e we o 4 oo & Oe mo OL cy oo Ss 6 Be"
S A os o 6 SC , © mo oe ¢ 4 @ a G fa oe a G 4 © see "ed va sf a oy @ is $3 age 3 o Che hea ia 4 iy og ag a 4 mt a M vid ni CN oO Oy, BS Oo bE rd , 2 bP GO 7 ® Ge em pm & gE eo oe 2 # 2 GC ¢ &@ & % 8 G 5 8 oa Sowa g is 2 7 ct "4 an bd ny iy a ne Oy ved os bea - ¥ + 'DD @ a4 aN g eh es sy $4 rs os OG, "ed a td 4 3 e @ © SA ng 3 fe a S 3 4 bed $3 v ee an is hd 43 ei MS a ae & B bet $5) '4 wh 4 cred ' --~ a" ea, 3 KE oO oe ey wD ot "3 < rd oe Co "4 cS Q fs - ao cS es oa vn a « : a i 5 rhe 3 wt 8 ved 44 thf > = % L 5 my } aA thro cry "es os 7 on oft SS & yp 4) ay & z wed : whe es é ' * bea n c 43 re . ; oj Pe} Fat cf 4 fel 44 "rs " i a © o Le 6 co "% a O if} hd Q ct wa he ded teed oi 4 ret re) t iat on aa 3 B G a i : . OS Bo GG mG ~ mM Gy O es es i is i ; Ls, ' wh. 4, ww r + 5 ne ee ort 2 @ : @ ie: i a oe ved m a0 a wy * ® cd 6 SG *% a G 4 on fod $3 dd Meh ro ri @ m9 ee ® ud m sO 4 a G3 re od a RY Dey os "> : 4 hy, a) "et kd ty ae * ot My os ov eo wp nd i Oo = a ed & a * % S aS Ey 4 ~ O iy re wd wm 5 4 wc 3 oe i "4 z4 mg aed fe = oe @ © , Gs st rel FS ~~ : ved we A 5 § ct oes O oe > tu ft eR x, w go i Bo ga & ox O se v it} 43 & see4 C3 deel ct Yy = = c Gy et . G i u w oS ne vod i oh, O 'G ra Cj ¢ ey tet we QO be a ae) $n wed Dy va an 3 r4 hs 3 sed xh 4G > G3 Gj bef ot ae rs Be i eed ¥ es ta ys Ch need 4 a a a Sy oS eo to Oo @ : ge % CB pl UB OUO!OUS 4d oa ba gy © S Ge @ ut a a S ut mt oe a _ a ng ] bed . wd eye} a am hd et os De 54 x ved ws vied G a Hoe 4 M&S ' 4 43 bd oO 8 42 os C3 $3 bed " f hd a op 8 go orm HH & OG m © Og og BO nm o3 ce G cs C3 : 2 s peed 4 ba i. re " 7 voll nn 43 CL oo "| a Bye RO . om er oe ee om BS ba oo & 3 + oo s '3 is wy ie 4 a) i oy 4 oan 4 m4 qe i id . 44 oe 7 «ed . rd {vy ct re) -e4 . m4 i a c e et ct CO a . Q Ls 3 wy S f mel a3 & a . 5 $ | "| ; Way a be pa 4 $ oF 4a a) se sf 3 q 3 rd ye ' im bed oe iS oe QB og 8 2 » © oo 8 & » o £ 8 » F Sod EH ed iy ihe : Me ry } 6 » o Ao 4 Se g o hy - wet we i) ard red i 4 wt UD 45 ot oo oe ae . i £ bs, arf Bo £5 os nt tent 44 ™ ie a a CC D i ; bet od ml 4 i bd :
ye oy 54 aes C3 oy Fs as = 7 £9) <3 a B o DB seer a tid eS Sy Q 4 0 8 mt . @ e e 3 a eo ie i 3 oe iS ww OO 4 cs eS wy OS oS B® My o 8 g 8 ~ 4a wy 44 a es e " a : 43 Ld Tet oy, tl eed as & sed "3 oO ¥ * ; or : ° 43 bat w o gg 8 & Sf ae e o « 8 & 3 € Gos eS : * . 4 o pet is 4 ae ey et, 7) re) 4 u a roa 2 o v O G @ BS a ee 4 4 Th & G Ee tS 23 a) Cc a " hd wwe , oo : hm @ c a "
a GE om @ 8 6 mm 8 § A} a oy poo 'i GO or .
& CLOLY, % eS b 4 Te ct 7 L wo SMD Costs ak O RE & cs it i. ' it i. . fo t % yy oh cA < 6 G = n mG ' a fe 4 & 6 ; oe ; a oO ved Boor Os was goo 8 ve Bo @ Hk ha ht "9 uy so ( ne =i iy et o -% be i. 4 GS om © 9 S o % 8 & ne (68 6 4S BOD & 6 6 2 @ 2 & Qo vB . 5 a BG Go me. Be OR OR 6 5 ¢ b & DB & #8 8 8 8 QB 9 GB Oo et eS GB Go ¢ & t > Ad fy hy a Z 4 ~ * 4 Se $43 asd n r ms, fod pod i wn te @ on % G ; ss G m ot - _ ny . a wy ia eA me re 4a an 4 a C3 thy :
fom 8B & 2 © © & 6 oS 8 8 Sy nd ~ © 8 og 2 G 8 8 @ i Bd SS 3B MO gg ok eof om I hea =p a . ~ a £4 2% fs} ch 733 a :
cS $3 th a - oO es : ned e - ms Poa cd ' i 43 : 43 a : 's a 4s ea Va s ve 4 wa ay by ' a - oa of ~ %3 re 3 © a bed Q Sat as Ct °F v Cr ms e go Oo na - a xs et @ cS CS 4 i ' 6 G E S 8 e Fo fe he : Q ry 13 . tes Qj 2 raat - 05 o , w hy i D ea . o ' a , ord rn SS re % i G 44 v4 1 ord j j Gs Pa . o zt 2 : : $5 tS i 5 o c iy Sed se 0 sy 4 5 = ed a Se ed Ea 45 & Ws 0 v wos _ a + oh eget bee me rt Q ao cy deb 3 ay of oO hs A c of a " in Oy & ES To Sf 3 4 Ch % "es 8 4 os 44 <4 ee "a O mA Re & @ ba Bs Oy ae & eA pr Ed uy aq 0 / mo OQ mm C3 8 ded : a 1 7 if hl fe x a : q ge Q ¢ Ce a qs et (2 Me s o bet re) 44 "ft ; a 3 oo @ wv 43 ved "a me c bt o fe v ba ; rm Rado cs eg ct 6 Th Sy ot o - a 4 wn & : py Oy O° BS bd oe 4 om Go a a wy i md : ' fe ae 43 i od \ ms ed ii rs o oO ws ¥ + ei Ye ee ; . "ct . hed 3 bef
7 - os ot hoa wt ; yi & ay ot rea oS "ge Bg a a 9 68 8 Bf a E HD OB ee o ad Hy , u wu @ a4 13 : hy ° oe s Q we o ay @ . ° > | ua o 5 my a te u sy ri) o :
wy ; po ae 42 Oo Bd cya asi MH ce , Aa eda wa to bea :
4 oO oY hee ts ht e 4 O "Ch oO 4 an ¢ rr Lad « vend u ot BD C3 3 fot x4 wd *w a ao a ae co WG . (3 ae : Oh ve M4 G © wo G bt « " ee S % > mw S "SR FS yw & 2 GB 8B ei , G8 > w ad n ed eos choo 3 et o Fy if a os By 43 oe 5 bed a fo cas 44 oS 4a a By ce 4 ot ci ml 4 ~ ; ' tt woof ay sod Pa * } Ct "9 a . ; 4S ot % te qd cA he ' 6h £2 "3 i 2, a &G ne be m4 ie on & & S iS Gh rot hs aa hes aed mt 43 GQ} ay ae) uy et ; © ot io et 7 uw O x A oA Sonep 64 iG 3 ve ' * 558) et " rte res a 43 end 4 4 cmt MA os a as co 4. CS eH ded on 43 * 3 Oe o a @ > Go * & » «@ Say © - Og cg oh a PY gg @ oe & re en en 4 oC D a 43 cE G oe 4 % : ae ¥ 4 C uh oa bd bes the 7 ml Qu gt Mad Cc i A red 6 © a B i a mh = " ™ on ro $e 4A ~ x rm OO $4 on é bed a "Sot C3 ret > 4 oO } tp reef oy " itt v3 ; a cs & ; os 44 @ e a by a "a * 1 oy Ae Sd a eof a3 i rt i ce 2 4 a3 ect , nn ; & & 8 S&S 8S 6» A © rt HD Mo 5 Mm & oS Be Ss 5 Dorel rn ee Bb O @ es | es 5 ho ann Ot = 8S | 8 8 8 S a 8 f @ @ 2 8 & 2 Bs ee a ee "rf cg © fa eo og Oo w H . & @| % & BF 8B 8 oe 6 £2 & % he be ne oO O ' ms : ie e RM ved 4 cc O, 4) = : 4 & beds 4 5 cy cS a > ; Ch Oo a 'et ~ Bo & O. 2 2, 5 O OE @ 6 7 et a $4 a OS fod ch a tad comigs 742/201 3 an Zz Od No. Cs] mm aye had ce ot rey o % v, bad Ox ae ee APES i applic awe = ms 1 achers.
te r wh cm hs © 3 uy ke © ci $4 1o) my oF iN ae ot Co} or.
ministrat Ad + -
ne fo bef mar a se4 ved se) @ a som D A ts 2 "5 :
Bh Sub aforesaid a a by sed Can is) b ir] @ os ao ke veg aa 63 Sse w bast oot i @ or} 4 aged * cs a a Be .O Sdcliti 4 B 3 3 On ig 42 Sag B ao inped ay td fa oi Ag Ki pea 6 Zi C4 No. 74272013 @xpediticously as possible and in any cas t within Six weeks of receipt of additional/supplamentary representation from the applicants, aif the same is preferred > within the time stiouiated in the present
15. The OA iS disposed af in the aforesaid terms. Noa order as to costs.
Lé. However, Ln the facts and eclreumstances, eiil the applicants representations are decided by | the respondents, the respondents are directed to . . ad et bY a ; he maintain status-quo with regard to the Services. of the applicants as of today.
(RN. Singh) (Dr. Bhagwan Sahai) Member (23 Member (A} cle.