Karnataka High Court
Elizabeth Connolly vs Mrs. Cheryl Margurite Soggee on 14 October, 2009
Equivalent citations: 2010 (1) AIR KANT HCR 825, 2010 (13) SCC 216, AIR 2010 (NOC) (SUPP) 1206 (KAR.), 2010 A I H C 1636, (2010) 2 HINDULR 155, (2010) 4 KANT LJ 233, (2011) 1 CIVILCOURTC 1, (2011) 1 MAD LJ 730, (2011) 1 MAD LW 525, (2010) 11 SCALE 69, (2010) 3 ICC 686, (2011) 1 WLC(SC)CVL 719, 2011 (98) AIC (SOC) 24 (SC)
Author: Anand Byrareddy
Bench: Anand Byrareddy
ax: mjga: giisgi £§.:=:;:2:::' if}? §~i:5'=£é1m%7~§:*{§}*z§<::32 gag? m::<f;is*a:%;%<">:"%«:s2:%
§}5§.'f§3§} T§£E$ 133$ :43" §}§§'£' <3? {}€}f7§"€}§E»ET§ %%
§EE3'{}§'%Ei :
mg: E%{',;%"£\Z""}%'.£'.,;Eéi MR. 3:::m?<:§§;% 3-%f?%§,?:E'.E'¥f} :5; '
?§%i<f}ET%!:'£'§*ii €.:i'«£fii. §§:§:':f:§;*:§,;%§.g <3§«'£::é:s'% %
PRGBATE. CIVIL.PE'I3';"ifT§{'%',i\~"%"';:*«E«:§_,1*:i}_i3:z7f'
2?}*<:€}§AfE'fEi. QEEVEEJ PET§f§'§{}E~J.E5§§<ié;'8"§§§'
BE'i"§§'EE?4 ;
£\zirs;.E=i£i:g;abT<::h .§:?f.m:;§:;s {hi-3': :4'g;:::;;;;;:§
Wife {xi Fheiiznw Elf-'::§§§;_1L>£%Ij:,i - '
Aged abisgi' 6:3 Vytzarsg
Residing zz4t=§,&*Vi%i'i: .fé;;; .
{}uii§§;:zfs:, §"r.3 i'2::§._:§, V _
R€p;'€:§3:1t»?fi by i:'<~:~:i P«:w~:€=r sf Atiaéflzay'
' ' %{0§'Li»::-ii" E§;tf}i§ §iae;.::;'5c:«.m£§ ?"ii§é§§::: Cwzznsséifg,
31g-xfggia;:m,Ǥj5::9r;:,
" %<.§;;;%§.:L;m;fEramge,.« M, ?'sZ??1'?§{I)%~§ER
§
{[3}: __ . }?$i£%::ia$23.§§§:a .?'v§::§E2a§§, f§€5§E§{§¥ {Tzmzz 36% am:
Shré,T.?.R:3§e::&ra Kama: Szggzgzzjg, g%.{§'€£¥£1:§'E3}
E\.e€:*3.C¥mry§ Margurfia S;>gg;§c,
'Wife {éf Raxhszi Qhafies Saggfifi
Rs;:m:.«:::::':im;§ by her (Z«.§'.A.E~{¢,,2Eg%:§:*
Maggi Pfiazarus {"Ra::':'sé}
Eé
(Ex)
$2»
V '{;}§§g:§<3isié§:-.§_§~,:'x:av§¢§"'§s: 3§{'..2j-3:3;
A 'v*SE:§*era§én;¥;g;i:;
_ B.%;nga§s:;:*t:~§§{? {E8} rt
DJ'
3%. Qréss, ?" Mam,
E3? ¥:?§<;<;is; §<.3:2:'*a:;2a::g.a§:1,
Begzzgaiaaarewfiféfi Q34.
Rs: V. ?'=.f§»:i2i.§:m° ?r:}v£:1é.:iaE,
Litfie SiS¥.8l'S 0:" E, 6 Poem.
15? Hagar E9ima.d, » I
Ba;;gaIere--:':5§Q O25,
Rexfikxiuiirar Su;}er§§§:';. _ 1 .v
2v§issé0:1ar§e§;: <3t7CE::zi*§_t}'*,
3, Afifiefiia R£')aCi3 '
Bamgaiozjtw-5§'{} ms'
M<,3£§:%;:'r S_i';%}T'§fa':§i'"V.}'{i,!=1[",b V.
St,Mic'h3}'€'1s_; Cagzvenig' --' "
€'f}§:§'VTEa2Ia,r{§,':2:s f<li?~;.:lari, ' ~ .
.f{.'«€'»='¢3i"2 ;BVE1'i§.:;'3;i:*;g§*?:::.j u ' *--
§§¥:.22gz,dL2rc~§{§i§ 'i'}?S __ ~.
V .}_?I'e::é<.%é;';2 V _
Ciéristg S@:a&S3m::§,
{fissafiiha Ashram)
}§iefi:,g::_ i"::;>r_ Besiitsies,
§'§'§§§;%§ f;§é:§'§msE,
F"z;*.::$by'i$3*'-ii';-=i:§"m;§g§,
VT ' " S£.Ma;"1<:"$ Cgiheérai
Iéua i , Si.Eviar§«:['s Raaci,
B&EEga§{)r'€f.
Ba:1ga§m°e Cilssilirt; Eiaszzmfi
afik Miée, HAL zmm»: Raw,
3
Bazzgaiazre-368 G E ?
8. T}::: Presiéfiiii,
Bazzgakirs Chiidrexfs SO€>1'€{}=', ' "
€33, Ritzimzizsn-;§ Reaai, V
Bangalorewfiéfifi €325.
R;tISp0i'§{ié£5IIi.?'3(}.8 Licicieci %;éi}.:,.i:é':"V=:3:':::§m' '
mm: 20,3.2Gé3;3 0:; memc:_.____ ~
9. Birficmr, ._ ,
Kidwai ?s.»'Ee;z;er§31 Insai-iutcfiéf €i:>1:.r;:3§?:;:g§y'.,__
H0315' .R_(3:a£§»¥:é' ._ '" V
Ba:2;gaE<3:"e4§'*§i§"{32E?.,
I {In The I}:;az3:;_ _' '
Si._?éhiI*"AVsj5MedE§§gE _§::'3.:§iu£3 ef Qgceiaegy',
Siegrjapaar R{;ai{;§-,_ " 'V '
Ba':?_g;z.iQ§eé5f§é} 1§£X;;:;?5»%:.;~ . < . 52; ;sm:~::,>:::1~33":e;
{By S2211.Bha£iuw.§¥332ri£::§c':: ;5;<£sz'::c;::i~., El}; Rc:;§xmdran.i.£
~ ~. A_ S:'i,V'_E;;é:s§i§x'DfS§I2*;-:;"'kixéecatc far Res§;:3::de»:}:.?;§
3;g_:<.<3¢;g
' iifiiishna, Adm:-aiti far R(~::;~:p<.méz:z1i..§,
'S:i£§..G;'RaTg§ia§%a:L Seaier {E03332} 543;' Rsgpefidezzifiifi?
"E-§s.1'§-Tia anai'Ei{L:§§$£;"A{i2:{2§;3i§ {Ear Resp:;r::;§er1L.E, Vaiaaiaih §'*i§§11§"E}€:€.§
vs?i{E; !3ffii§§ Gigjéctiens,
R$s;§unci>;;":i.'3'; 4; 6? ? amai é? arc scrsmzi.
_ ' V .Res;p0:1?'&sfi1;. S dafsteéfi
VS:'i.w€'Zg,réafipa 33$ C:;mp3n_*;; EEK Bs::a£Ea:ia:§'}=*}
'§hi:§ ?m£3ai,g éfitxii ?e:i§£%e;.m £3 fiiezi zmciézr $::;:$.£z;~r: 2%' :3? {$23
V Eggdian S:,::;§.:e3.si:3§1 fiat? 192:3? gzra}-ézgg '£33: £'€'5£€j%§§é3 firm {};':fEe§* 52:2"
pmfisaéxi g:"2.;:§::;'§ in 32:: rssgmficittné $3}: :>ra§:.~:1r éiaétsaé §f§,€':z'§§:§3§ amé
3
direL:i 1:1,} grazsse ihc; wifi daicd §?.§ %..E§8'~? £2: :s§§:::z:1:;=:f:駧°fii
such arias: aifectéen 0:" ézsders that {his Hiezfibiaé C<:>':~:..gf§ ajgegzgs §£--<*:_n
{he ijzias and ciratazmssianctss mi' m _:_;a:;:_,_ ézzc-kzeiétig» :'-:'.,v€,3rSVif.'.V,_' in §_,§1r:: ' .
igterast afgusiiae anci aquiijg,
2>":"«:<><g;;:';~: cm: :>;::'z*z¥:':a;>:~:;;s.:g;%f::;
g§;:?W£;;::x2: Z A
i'eiz*'s.E:£i;<;a§33E%: C£3E'II'E§3§§=" F2:_é§h;_£Em:§}"
Wife of PE1sI§.m Csnrgséég-', . A T' " A
'La Vifie Ian; ;'S(:49{F_., _
Guiiiittrfi, Fran;:[:::.;_'«.._V "_' 1. , V_
Rspre§;e:1ETeci by ..1*;e:;%';j'§'""fgigal.*:r:f 43$ 3.%§%e;=;;%:§*;,r V
E"iu§c§$r azici EéugiyiéizgihP%;r.:Eirig?-;§'r:*:3:3sV--%§jg:
La Wis gag, A ~
Ci:.:i¥i£asj$, 'E'i~§;;m:-.§:._ ' :+>*13;":";'£';{;:%:x:f§::;a
{$32 Shri.T.P.'Rajc:;£ir2£V i~f;;g'é::=:.a_§f' §§an§ga§r, fidvasaaie}
§;,L*%?,.§; V
E ; V. 3 Ex:"£f:;,C.§1%-3:".§;¥ E*via2*'g:zz"é§.r:- Suggeefi
" j "'i7~.?"£f§::>f"'E15i§;:3?0gg::,
"' ._V§';%9§'§3:*§:~..-::'._:1';é:§':*.;:;§ %:>§:' Eat? ?m.%.-éez" a:£';5':i§z;;:'§"§£:f;¢-'
Mag:>r,L' §?','T.L;%z3§:;s {geééraég
;"§{}'§, i"""'"4'4'a'::'0ss,, '?th Maia,
fir', §§§::>::§:, Kééffiéiiaiigagéf},
' " _B3::ga§ao:e-§:§Q $34
Rm«=1MuE§2::r §i£§)€;,*§'i{}i;
Zkéisgéanaréas sf C§}+§,F§'{}',
3, Asiémka R;§:~:2.d?
Bangalsre -- 556* 536$
72
U'!
Evitséémr Supaz;-réaézg
St.Mich:;:§e":; CQEQY-fi3§E§,
{Xi} §\J.Ea.{iz"a:~; Rmzgi, J _
§6€3¥&f§ Bhixmzgggas. '
{E3235/:aE<>z'c-5:35} ('W3
Fraxiéicilé,
Christa Sew: Sanzzij,
{A..r:an§.ha Asizmmfa .
Refuge far f}estit'z:.1_:is-.
.1'? - " r
€}pp<.>siii:; Si.X2:vier'i:~:V }ff3§r;..;}%:§7. V?i§g§}_«:}:;:§};.:a:;.::',V__
Shivafirgaggr, _
Bai1ga.im.f£:*.-~§é€}_ €}€}[E
Fmshig-'it:1+'§fi%h'é;:.2*g_§é;~ff.-- , A '
S£.Mar,% 'El-;it§1gaf§3E,, _ '
Nu. 3 "-:'3{,M3ri<,*7Vs' Eiaéaii;
E_a:zgz::2o.;:~é;;V V. .» _ *
a.:%§€:.s§:'£*:é §t§;_é.i'n':é:_
, -55 M1253, }%AL',£%;;*g:(};i Fiaaafi
~ '5;,Bafiga§ore-§6:{3._?C},3
V' " -. . 'E"§<2,c3'§?f::>s€§:i£:ni,
B:,:.§ig;;;f£a:3Af3a:,€;Z?§/;§E£§s§§; SQc;7¢%§=-3
. 'é-3, §éiiij'j_§:r:€iu»mi §.€_}3.€i,
B£.t_;:ga.E.:};"$ = 555} {£25
R«&;§;:;:§1a§r:1:§.'§*€a3'? céaéaiagi 2-Jéaiaz :;_*§s£§a:§*
'~_§j3a1t:z§ 2} ,1€}£{}iI33 an m5:":';=:;,
{}irm:i;{:>r,
Kidwai M'sm<;;*i:3.§ igisiiiziie @§'{}::ceZ{2g§;,
Hum? R936,
Bazzgaicrrswfiéé} G29.
@
«at
G R E} ER
?r{3¥;3aic Civii §"ciiii:m E'€;:.4f3*'é}E';E3 §&£..§Ejé'::-gé ii; ::3;¢'m:.:c;§ §3;§,:.i.§'i€:
iasi wiii 2-.«:nci'E@;~:{3:11c:z£ uf ?xf§§t:;,¥_jE§§L§rai-é§._ Eiyjwa ;.§%;:'§§:£};§, EE':s¢: »
szzcenci exm:-uiiix sxamexi unéez' §1<:;V%;>s:.i_E§ ;§ai.s:::ei .§'7«._E_.i . 398%? i3;rs? grafii.
i'
Q? ;:3¥1:3%m£c. Mrs. Faiiiziézi £.:e:is2:_.i:i._§m«2.§:.a:a?é--:§is;<§:.;n 3E..E{}.E§}2"%;
-.r
. 333:':
«.35
pésiiiimi. wag fidiiliiitfid or: E}£%_'j§»'.'EE??8¥}' zfisgi 2: ?;;:§i.;»;'E*§,{:*;.'§ saws ii: §§'§i3
£':§Egi§'.'>£h §.}2£§§§5..f'!i::*€3i3:§%%1:i} }§r;}£':;;.§é;§.7f, ?:3'32%g::»s.§z.:2"e? 23:: 3§};.?'.§§':',;':§. Nmic
Ema} z;{;1IIi:..§?;:}"1%?'2:r{:i' is;§,}§:§§:{;2$a.§§-iszfl;;§?2::':g.§ v:i=§p:*z:">b;£§c:. 353$-Ci}I'i_§§.§§;i§§§.f, $3}:
an am§cr7.a§aié:i3 §;~':'>]'§ .§:'1f}.;E"<§f%§»T,. vi§1%T:§%;;:;:s§'§ Emzi g:'m;i«::;a§ §:=:*:,'§a%;c :§:«: §'::"2:}=':::.§
Eb}: ' L _V
._' En };z§;g='.__19':}§};'u::t:"t'Eit:v'.§e::§a;3:ézz {};:=:"a£ra§ fiimi a g3::%é€.§2.:z§
v 332 mi' Sim iaiiiasi S§1C€€S$§;§¥} Azié, §§f;;'Z3
{%2ara駧.3fi§F. :9La:§;.;':"me£ $57: as §%2§: '"_s%<:::i' {Ear §'§:'§s:§%;§:} ii} §'i£§"§3£.}*-iii 52¢
';Eixe:::;§.r§'>;VV"{§:2 $326 grmmgi iimfi. gigs §?sJ'éf§ é§.§:5:ga§§j«g aiéegnpéézég is;
j éififgpizege:-'a;£' £226 §:§'*a:;'?sm"§:as; 9? 32¢: §::::ai¢:§~z*'é:=<;_, 2:: a::3i§:,2:;%:.m wiiéz 2:»::§"§:«;.§§2
V. i.§f;§.:"i::§_«»pgr£§::*:-;_ T§1§:~; was :"r:g2%;~;ia':::'-sé as §3'ra:a%'§z:E¢ Ci? s«§~:'i€§';.3€E.
/5
mg
.,%?'y ":;='--2*cii<..~:§*S=.<;§:»£1'Lxi3:.i §Tn.§i;'?;§5?}§§ ami 2F:}.2{:%{,é, s:'§::-;§p;:;:s:§is.s=:§v.
'}
bequesis maiik: sxzmitzr {Em wiii xavzira izii. #9..-:£§é;;3:: 31$ §?§_?":§';;: 34:?
{ZA~'€'}.
3. Tiiesc agapiéeaiéamzé §1:».:a=§z"z;_g cums up é%>2:'----:3.,.+:§$,$;':~:§~~.i§2ég usé::<%.. "
hahi £3122: EA-Kr' swag £11 sffeci €233' 5:*::v«;5a:.;w;i£;m ii}: '§,_§,%."Z;§'3é'§i si:;.5f'-;f:5_:*s~';:~é':;:22'<:
and hence {ii-rszatiéasi ihai i§3£:-- *.~_:;:':r_:&..f:§c gs:-i..£2:ix§jg :.1*%§::::::;'§::<_,§ :.2si" §E'::s.§;2
prcmscéiizgs be iz;§2.iai::<.§ {gr :'t:w3:;_a§=:érZi::::2_;:§_§:2ru%_*:gi;A
firzcreaiiaf, EA-3%! é¥}2=_;;é;' ::;:e;:i:;§»:£mj'ée§I "».a§::z:g *=...t%i.§: ?':*L2§"3.€.:P
ié:1§%¥:'3»"2;§a§A ::2z:'§";*§€3.£€~}€3€'s $5; 2:. m2::=;z3§:.t.*;;§ L}'§'£§€:'£°,
;i.gai:1;s;i --:§'2i:a: z:s3;§2§:£{2";": ,--~:;»;g3;3t:a§:=; warm §:«m§E:::'*:*"eci £2: €.".'3E§;i..
i:"'i§§?_2s;:";{i €.,';ii§._A 3&3 saiii agapsaég §%:a.x>%;: 3236:: iiézazgzéazétzaé
'%&»::i:;;;;{:%k%éj::~¥' a;:%%9<~;s ami §3m5b.{§§-:' §<w;%:ss; gm: gmzamg E};
4
ifit "$:»3.:':::=; géfiififiifififn 3:: gm §i2'":~;é uf fine: ;::c:§é§é:§z:s:u, 222+:-2 rsééeriixaéaggéé. £3
" V. ifm L:"§;:2:<3{iai.éa:::§ £31»? fix: gym: s3§p2*1:§9a,i:: £2': .§Ew:,3:::" 95' iii}: §::z:§,§§.é.:3:a$§ fir:
?;°a§5b;;CE} <3~fi§S9. R is; éztméatnaifiéi Eéai iii: .§§§.,£S§?'d§'§{§ 92$' 3.353: imaiagizéx
Eugaph gkirzxanzier %3a§i%3§7z2i- issiéu g2:/'e«:§%:a::2§&§é::;#§. Ezés aaséiéf aiéazid 9%?
Z
U}
2§.E.i9$S. The i:2§§%:§ui$ aware §3v::'m2;.m:§1§. !'€3'§fi¥.'3§'.§:~$ 13? ':%:»m§__:2';§a,:=mA
E': is: siaied ihai figssph s%..Fa,%i.i*1§ui3 izussézami v;z§E§1<;: §a:si21%:"é:»<;_,.__ magi 3
kruéher Ja.n1a:_~: ?\z£%:.:§'2<:ai "F:c';ié§":i1sE. 'i'§1r:: §:ei.iii:m.a;* §.f-§'<'2'§£¥1§~:i
éiaugiiiesr eff {fie Saiei Emfies §'vE.§3*ai£§3i7::E arid {Ears ¥;§,§f*§%.:t:
A.Faii?§iE2E and iiaiize: w5;i§'}§n éhe aieg§*¢:e:'iéA§'E{%z:«:i_r:sg§ Q2" _<§;:§.;1_>,m;1;';§:i::é'é.,*~s'
as cmnpui:;:g§ in Sizézcgizgitz 3': LP ii}: " Ci, i:":a.;;E-._:é.s§é§:*; ;'*§ii=;:i§{:;s:§' L???
:25 ihc ;%:.:i. .33 gazzgtcriugiezai i:«.§§%§g":tziM' i.§:e.;:- '._§Ea;§i§:s§:2§ E"am%%;:
pme:im:a~:d_ Ami ii is a.iS;{i'v~._:~;a}a:_g§2i_ iii: &;:2:'2i.}21:a§.:*3§::g§ Eémi fizz:
ii.~:s§airi:>:;.::sr:--:.i .§§;.§s::_;;§:7'.5%;.}?ai-§.§'::ilzi aI':--~§.:s%:~;£ a::.>a::;:::s;, Efiaing i§"§<;: ::§':é§:§§:t:';
Lfif iiw; ;S2i3§.?;:;"::2 ':»;ii§é. '2s{ i;V:T}:V::;?1::':;3 2;.m:@:~s§,::e§*_ iizair mé;i<::'z§z§E %§.:'§§'2:?:':<§
I
iésiiiez' -M §§T1i'}fé§.§§"!t: iE1e._p€i,ii§{,::"::t:" is 2:§:~;s;:2= :":.i§.a.%.<:,a; in ifém iflfiiiiiféx §E"{:e:'::
V' E:e:°'z;;:3£§';5<.-31*':-;M.,s;i;i'c:. 2%"g;::f:rii:&§e3gée;:&;§ éaéeis %a::: <§§.f§'a'i{.}£§:§§§°a.§t: i,§2§:~.: is? airzza:
-
'}"'§§a:~§?€j'§%:i.§:§:é::':' Qiaéim: mg 356 §3:»,;.i§§2£:;§3 aiégiéi i3:~:a':§§~:3s, 333$ "§g2:;§§T§i::=m-:;r.. 'emf Em; s%:s:§;i:::r Esz§sr§::: {}§r:§a:-a: aim aziééiiztei £9 ,~_<;:s;;:;:m:a% Ea} fisc- ' . :':s;i2':§$A'€:«Ef3:;:~:$g3§: sfiimarieier Ea%.§.%'ziE§§ zmé 32%;-:3: axeégiamg fix: §§5§&;§.§"§:»:_ % Scciizm E 33 :,2§i§:a Acix '??:a£ i.§'1<:: Eflrvrxs-a:-:;E§"£:x; %:::2":~;a§§ ' V in Ps*:..T:~bx(:? =<$s"'§9§§§ iziaiiiz-aim 2.2: a3bEé;;ue s::::..:é.é:§m «§:::;:§_~§é:§'§ 2 4"' seeieing ;"e*m§:a§.i:3n cf £326 Pmbaéfi '»a,::a.%:_'"§.T§;ér::§T;;€r:, '{_:s,:g%:f%--.__é{f:::;_E::::
i'!:I'{'£{J%3s:"Li magi izmzce 1-;::[ei<,..s :=£*s"z'2%§_:;92:=EV :35 §i%:».e~: ?i:§§E3€}5.,i §§Z;<::v::.;;éfi--*§x agaszif a§}:x>§r;m:v:z1i uEa:3(>ii}e:* Er; hrs? s%..cV4,<£.V ~.__
6. Heard V SE15 §€g,:§:m;n;«é,jb§;§a "$<:r:§§,:~z' Ad meme:
appaating far iiits C};:a:t:i,sx;:E"--V{%.:§'_i§'§n:: p4§i:iA%§_£_i'€;1r§*i£:%:"'a:':éi ihtz cc.:e%m:;«::i Q32" iiw rztxgzumierxis EQEE 999' 3%-:%..§:e§.ahie:-- ra'~§V§@z'°;-.§.7ri<::;¥._ ':§*:s;:..--~<:§é"a:zzzyzsiazzms in =;.:s:=:z§',a::;§ iizai iiw 3b€:q:;eVsi_Vwa.:§ §§ZXf_::§§§{._§,V§iS {$15 Easéairix "W822; §3'§€.:€.:=1¥i§2*:ic§1.§ in %:»:.:-qaitzaéix "fits: '¢ni£r*§'L'.pr{§§;$réy w§'§§§.i§1 Eéaai $3363 Ecfé Eeizéfiié by Em: %m.:-::%:sa:'2g3? §3a:}i '£§§.é:;§f~%:;.§r:3i2:§t::. ?§':§:~; :::i2*:.:;,::z;s§2m::a :¢Eé.f%.f{}E"L§§§"§§i $.23 532133: "N L» E¥s'ia}:'§..*~: £335 jg-Si sagas £2}? §§2e::a:a.i§§;z§ {.';§ iéze §.;;:'z..m§ s:;§f §?§£3§3§§,§§¢ in §t:;rii:"::s? {3f;=seci.ia:n 2&3 9%' 'ém .:5.~.,§.:i as size grgzcaaaiéxégar in a.§§3%.:azi:*: éiéie . g:afii"wr:;*e aiziiizeiizic ii: mrbsgiamze. ii 1:3 fiiréiaar esufiimiéirsii 'ziaaé Eésia u 'g:*é:z;i ef §:"§:»3:~aE«: havifig htsezi magic': mt; E€":.§.E'r'}§§ W §..E"Ef:: §:§;:;é;ar::~si isméeg' §.§:<:: axaéii was 3 szzééai %:si:{;am:~.~:§ a,a§:a§§::* :«;m.:iia:§: M8 :25' {Eat ;5%<,.:§A 3 $3 éné mi»: v~¢§i§=i:siaz1L§i:2g iizc': suivscigamzi f'?::§."%i:,'fci.§ mi' E§%;:¢:§ém: 532:: gram :3? f33"(}b§i§';': in :'¢:§§§:::::-i. <3? 3 ssemgf 2>¢i§;§_ zazmsieé rssizdéézf'§Eé§:--._$£§:1:t: asgiiéi whiah «::.;;:.;;2"2<.;':«i ibtz s-:;:az2::imam2e:-:.::.§ ami §E1e§'e.§{.}3f§ §§';§:..g:*i::V;i._4é_°2.i"". pmbafi: 1&3: I"£."?'.*('3§{¢:2i§.
ii; is iéésriher a:-<2r;:ir::n£.i§:.:a§ i.§1;:%._ §§"§€i' 'M3? zetasgsié:-.i:%&v£S és:£:::§§ $*g§>'é Egg éasazziezxi afié éhis Ea: apparcréi §"§=:;_:f; {Etc .i'3.1té;-i iitgi' aé {}."§'3*;:'.'- §;"§5<i€:-{ti £22 31:: wifi as bcqucs-E 1n*a:é_i3t:é2j:';§'?:va;~--§::" s::§a§.e.~:-:3 éjzai ii amuizi §3i<,€.",- aiiéci aiiar éiiia ;.Eé.~:2;éA§2V--s2.£'§_ §3.c:*gz;§§f aézéi hé:¥.."§%a3?§3:11§, :s.:.§2:::; Em: §1:;5}:>am;i Wm; :«§V§i'i§:~§é§_f§9;'~£i€ft2€,§ '2E§}€_§; §E2::m§:.;§°: z'em§a§'"s ii 3 szzggfiaitéizéé zianzumemi. L = f iécfiansc fasééaiazirzi. EL: 313:: pzizisazi an $33 :'E3§'::.;s,a;'%::g %a.:;§§:_<,:s*:"%jés::::~:: ;'t:{?r._f. .a"*i'r£1é5'£i.'£"?£.E".'.,-'x'é:*i.,£'v'§,r'i',i"7z' B%zagwa£'i 1:3. {:}?zzr:¢frczar£z5.§stzs<: .532' .9i»2'e:.5éi;i;. siffi '{;: §u su§:§«:'2§"7i aim a::§§:§c:§.§.§<.:»§§ Eimé figs a§;p§§a:a§.§:;;:/*2 ,§},3:" 'V :'*m>:3a§2::i{}nr.; be c;:ns~;i§.i£:z*m§ as: 3 znizazeiiazseaaszs appiéz:a£.%£.m 3.§"£s'.§ .m.>E ax ~::;f:»,i case. TEE: ;:m:z'%. 121.3;-" ffifaifiifi in ggnmé :.~mz2s%i::T:::2'zi: {Exams is mg §i§;J:}.iE'¥L'§*;}i.§ «gs? ;m.2ee_s§f' iszztingg a3.§§:¢::§"§§3~"i»31a:%~_§§'§<::V: 3%-:é§E Eéég. 3&.:1'iiiit:L§ in pE'£3§:--i§¥:3 was aifizazz" 230$ g;:::'::12§:3:._;:'2:er5§:a:';;i3. 1'i'l..'%€"t:§7#":2'¥;:?":g;'-~.3f&§§éj§.§§}' 3' 3 'KW ' :2-aecaied. Hf?-§§i.Zt§,, ii ix §3§'fs1:§'f.§{§"~~.V§§2i:i§ 3%}-6 §??;:§§£€§j?§'§S§:"i§'§_§§'%.§§f%.im«3f'V' $52 999 and §4>wb_::;> mg: @223; ':36 sfz%.:~:.§§'§'iv&;:;?:is§, E2': ?§*eb.C-E' 7:'-%5§§E}€'Ii_._%V§;&:*e; £5; zgu *;5é§H*é:§:,s2--£;:i.é:§23 ?::»jg gjiéiiiéiééié. $16 €i§§§iJ2i§é$f" ?_:iaé:?;*:'2:1s>.i:':. §%:;;:V::a ::é.vs._%i'ia %';",='f"'£§"at: ":%:"::*::§§%,»-'i.m"--§:e§~z;.§3a.§" 2:: 7 <3? $i(E3'au§&; '::~?i.§'E"}'i§§§§:§§ ::,§2§%:::é:~§ :«;:*~:"§ §::};%:ia:2;:'}-I sagaies am} ?:;i§:§§.?££:>§€j3}E ::3_§."§§y::;V ?§:!:."a:€3,-'g-§;EV§§>xg:"§'.'~._{?,'f:i-':§:E_§.};é§?f§:§§ zmai ':~;m;:§.:=.a .§"::i§" §"«'~..i;§'s£,'>2«-'2£§. fii ._§.§§::~3%€_§x.sa:: T%.i§§"<.:é.:EE::'~;§f:i.3'Ei:r:§~;, EEK: {§§£§;§§£§§E.?§E2£ his his 'a:g}§1%§£{§::§%?§:.-E xwhtéizfir Eb: gaeééiéuzzszg fizz F:z.>E:§£§3* 3,/;'§§}?%%~'r 222%? §{:§§§€§v" Ems: mafia ami 3 gags £5? :*au::'c;<.;2:§mz: mi" pm§':2ai%: a:'2:§é":*e>:z:--:m:s§§ "$5 $1: Exacairéx 9:: éim ggmiirziés Eifgffiéi v §i:"::~:i§j;;.__ ii ix £9 inc: m:»§.$§,§ iimi £_.§2e§"<;: it»: EEG ;,§;:"m;§:i§ azrggsé £3 . _<f:_"t%§%z::s" :3? £326 §i$§§§§£;}§!':§ §§{§$S§'§£,§$"§§¥:g éééa gcnuézzsnegg s.:§§13:: wiii aw ihsti vaiéaé i.f;}§€é.:%§§§£,}§E axis iim gamma. ii. E3152: i"%.:¥;§i§f;§"i§i*§ £23 ifiiififi QS E'?
wimihtzr anfz <:s£'i§r::: cirsufizaéaficeg r::§7'<::*:'a::s;i§ E2} £2'; seyiéaaaé LEE} 2:? £45.: Aazi are §3i'<:3S§fi§"1i. §"E"3I:§.j:»' u:<;:.:{s2E§}_: crximci. 5:9,-:.:§:i:z;:2 ?:§é3:'E:=} E23 :"a~:a:§§s r<.~:§E::"am:c.
a,§1§.1§,1H6駧.3i"jiES'i ;~ai.::i~:e.
i.
iiZX33££::':*ii<>:;: ~ ;¥2.:5:,i: g:2:L:ss=::= Era s;§s;Sé3§¥:'§::§E§ {:3 as-iéséi Auézzeéia {3} tézaes §z=:w;.>::a~2s3:..';§::gs; {:3 a§§3ia.%fi*i§§I<: g:*:;g;: 'z« :2e:,:§a:st.za::$e:: (:1:
{E} iéige ;-;g:"a:':E. 'az_jé;s:+;:a§;%'£' §%:<6g:i '§:§"§:E§{§i§§$ii§.§§¢7 '§:sy ;:3a§<:_i_:ag 2; $5133 um.
W3 '£.«:f;:§g,g;::*-,s'i'.ia:s:;§ "1-5:e;ma,:e2"{§%":'zg é?:;>::;:. iéni: iC7:3§ sé£i::3:_§:i::.g §-;:ai:;;::ié:§ i:%:.s:;% cage"; :3»?
"3'«:.{e;;} 'iE1T§; g§:$§V'{EVEi.'..§§é?§é§'.i' e;>§:atai:':e-2% E5': :3'; 221225»: ski' ax: §iY§£§'"%;:i:.': 2j;.;'£l'§;g';z?:§:'a:: gfa fact aaasaiziiaé is; gsézwiizi as? Eaw is-:2 jzzsiéfy §§§£.}'i,Eg§§ $':§£§':. &§§&§a§§{;:: 963,3 §:':.ac;§a £3: . e;':s:f §::a.s:%ve§'£e3§€€:g: 92' iisé g§'a,:§§' §.:§;~':§ §§3$i..3€}§EE£:'S ;-:m';§ i::::2g§a::?e:.§.é2:§: §§fI§'E'€;§EI:g§'% V " €:§§'z:£iE.'§.E:3E;§§E§;€:§; £3:
:21 , SE .5 iizg §}s;ti'&~é}:2. ii"? w§3::;::: €222: g§:»:::;: wag ::':*;3e;§a E232 3&5? E = /"""~\
6.
am"; ¥fi§§i§EC3§,§'é :'e.::a1.s;<}§:a'§::Ee causes: 9::-géiiaé Eats :Ef£";.§?g'§§',%§§ "ii i§:'22::::§e;3:*};' 9:' 21%:£3€>§,i§E§ £33. aagcsm-géamrsi 22:%§.E: {Ea §§¥'aL':a'e-"§:"5§é:::§?§; :>§""?§:::a:= "xiii" air?' §);i;¥'i,. «:3? $2225 up'-?€;§"§%§I§§i§L:"§ {iii 18 :;:'::_ie:* £13: {Z'%::¢1§3:e:=:* :35: §§"§"a.»='$'§:§4.;?i'fx,i .=i;Z*£3s;'I-i§;§'§i. %%f§%§a'.'.%.'2 .:%_:"~; m:€,ri;:a in 3. maéa-iisgé :_'ess;§e:::, {iii} {iv} m3. w ;'fS:s$.s~a:':';<m~;
T3323 €.,,'z:,=m*: E33-=" §%'§E§C§'2 fize g;a:i':': Eiiffifigfj §i2:?{a§..¥§{; % j:;:i§s<i'§c£i:::'§:.
The gmzgi %3;:§s.: :::as;i<;=. w§:§:.g>:i::;';.Ti§%:2g»:}a,:i:§és 'i'~:§§a_ 5% cugizi £9» §'33V€ hm: :.:£%;e:;:_.§' "Sis: wiéi sf' whie.;t§: '§}§'Q'§V:§':§;f5é'*'s5J.&$ s;>§3'é-;':.%:f;é.e;'<a:%§ :_;"22:=¥;!e§ gr :ev:':z§<.;s::-é;
'":,§§:.;«,?£«:a féza sifiiifibi cg'?
A ;:»bi3.i:%1e:i §e::e~,~?s Mg§%m;:::;%;::is4::%g E, 3;; 2,>.g4§;*i:;;§»a:;_,Efs_%.:*ai £1; E355; :s;;'g§%:=ec§ {fiat ::?E:.:3 was iiiréfssét i'!11fi§f_'£":€':i.-"3: Eazzi §*;i'r:1.'" f .. A' iaiézgii 3,§§1'ii+.§§;§$E§.':'2§§é3§1 :9 fizes egiaie <3? if he §_2--az'§"s:%:%.~::<:§§'vézfiseéiaiez ME: 5% '2£:i§2 £235-: simésez §}:3#£':'E 2 L «€§__%¥;<:;::;2?+;%:'*ss,c§§A _ ° V. S§:i£:::.__§%:z:§§a;'£:;: "wag fg1'a§§€,§*--%:§. iaiazv wiii Ems; éiseecis "l:f§:3:;:§e..*; 6,1'¥{i»§.'i:':ii.
§3re;%i}a$:e was g.:*a.:2i*:i fa; »:;é3s§§€.=%§. $235; §"3é%€%§'§ sza§:§::%'§ :*e%;0§s;.e§: G?' :8;€§£i§§ fie: figs ";¥i§}§}£"}§§'§ii§§EI;2§}§ gf §§§$Ci'£§€3§'$ §;'§§'§€1§$3' iéag wéf 'E'%:::: §>::3:'s;:::§: Ea'; V«s'.§f§{'::E§ §}1'a';§3:B;§€ axgassg :32' §e§§:=>::'s; 2%? a{§::2%::§$ifa§i:3§.: Weia ggaiziefi Em; se::§:2sss:;g:;;ar§€§§s' §}s:£:::a:r:e <32? Liziésaqzamiei ::;im§,"
8
five:
3*} *'.\V 2 ifi. E3i":;:m1 3 maaiittg 2,3? EZx;§§:;§':a§i=;>§x vi %§:{' ;2}§g4§ éiizzgiraiiuzx {__ii}, ii m;«;}; Eés éimi £222: §;*.?1;§§§"*§.i:-§é~I3.{;}¥"ij $31' subsziancsf' 'W'€..%!.!ii;§ imzizieie nm£:~:si¢m Ea} i:~::;-2::-2n§e;§§2;.%.éz:::"§E §.§;§ _§??fZ;'I":§i5?%E"§§.~Z whu shuuiai hays beet: aguprizsgfiai 2",:-{V {Em §:ii$3;:?:§ ?:3:3.§_ » as htziii by; {he Supfvsmc Cuuri in ;_=i_?zff~vEe§;_z;?"i {}§'§{.:§§? '5: Vitass aaagsrafi ihe muri may reifiuae is gi":;n§- 2ii':_i1i£%:3?:vi}ti§i?;,V:' if: ::-asgas. w§*;«;:-:'é:- iiiera it»: my iiimii§1uu<_i ufpigyeiixjbzziiég};;.§§E:«::$<£_ iié-z=;§:,§*:e wéié aégzziéieaé its gzmbgie was ;t:'§i.E"§i:rVéiegsif'g¢m:Vi-¥;r:;"~s:_z;' §'i;5:§._€2:_;E Eiéemz yaééaiéjz :::~;:.:§;2.:im§' Eizgmiisr :_é:s'--".§%2t: e.t-E§2:§§§.i°r;.u:-- §.é;.2 iifm graaé {T25 §rr..2§::=a':s 23:; fizz': .' 3?' gruumi :3? 381;: §:sm;{:':t:s{'A?§e;éz;§;»L.s: %se:r§i.§ §}f;E:§1i€:§§§ uizeiar gm:-§i£;:"2 33$ a.:s.f' Er;
w::::{::%s§@§§, :f,§'zs:,- tgéiiéi 3:25:12-§§L}'£'E séaiagisg Y6-§"§%3f:§§€3€L;§.. '32:: :::,3:§'i:::2;§:«e}z:'~§.E3;%;i'fi3_t: Sc-5.:-'Lima gmgizi :9 he §';a::E;§ Eu ":£2§§§_'§'_§:' is} xeéatw 92*: {he Q:*«;is::::i'*v:3§ gsafgi pmbaie wazsz maée wiéazaé iim tggzasiiaii aarag an: aim si3§.::ia~.§34.§~:fr by 2; igézé * fiat: ézjsazizéne :35 ='%§";.}:~: m:§.:%s2e mssrraaiéggé ~ V . ., $3' . E :4 F; % fiiispgsiiiun piii. §:;=r§§f: by iht: Sarzizjr 3%;_§v::e;*:.a%££ X-3%-'§3%£3§'} £2»: iiifiiézazii {ii iEUII§i3i't3§'i§3I§d. in 33:: :::§;:g:":i<3§3 mi' {his e:m:r§_ $2.3 éuciéréne fa? §{0sp:.ia;%'§as§: €L}*~£<;§E"3"E.E§fig has :19 appiésaiéaan in s.;:--§:*:.::;mgé§:2n:::.:-5 as: 6 Y ' ; 1 'I'. ",2 ' i' " n s3'£,m ?1*::=%3.C39' a%,2§E38{--? ifisr mzisgrz: baggifj. m.i"§§':.<;:r'-.§}:'¢.sc.:;§::g§:::@;;gg; §:2:a£m'»;: 132:: §}§IE§t§"l Egaving iiic 522356;'-.§s1 :ia:léA::-aéigriss. ' M/~ f}Lf}§UDGE $2?'