Delhi District Court
Smt. Rajni Masand vs . Smt. Maya Devi on 5 May, 2007
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi
RCA/19/06/2000 (1)
IN THE COURT OF SH. INDER JEET SINGH,
ADDL. DISTT. JUDGE, DELHI
Smt. Rajni Masand
W/o Late Sh. Rochal Dass,
R/o JA 1B, LIG Flats,
Hari Nagar, New Delhi.
....Appellant.
Versus
1. Smt. Maya Devi,
W/o Sh. S.K. Gupta
2. Sh. S.K. Gupta,
S/o Sh. Kalu Ram,
Both residents of
C-603, New Friends Colony,
New Delhi.
3. M/s. Vishal Electricals,
(Through its Sole Proprietor Sunil Kumar)
4. Sh. C.D. Malhotra,
S/o Sh. H.C. Malhotra,
Shop No.- 2.
5. Sh. Sanjay Gupta,
S/o Sh. S.K. Gupta,
Shop No.- 3.
Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi
RCA/19/06/2000 (2)
6. Sh. Amit Kumar,
S/o Not known,
All R/o A-19, Acharya Niketan,
Mayur Vihar Chowk,
New Delhi- 92. ....Respondents.
Appeal No. : RCA/19/06/00
Date of Institution : 21.03.2000
Date of Decision : 05.05.2007
For the Appellant :Shri O.P. Khadaria, Advocate
For the Respondents :Shri Bhagwat Pd. Gupta and Shri
Rajesh Gupta, Advocates for
respondent no. 1.
Shri G.D. Chopra, Advocate for
respondent no. 2 and 3.
Shri Sanjeev Kumar Gupta,
Advocate for respondent no. 5.
(Respondents no. 4 and 6 are ex-
parte).
Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi
RCA/19/06/2000 (3)
JUDGMENT
"!$#&%('*),+.- / 0 1 ) 23-4'*57698;: <>= ?A@B@>=ACDCE?AFHGJIK?BLMGN<"= @OCP?RQ9FHGSQ TUT V ="TXWAYZ= GN<"= : YSQP?[C \ W$]OYUG^GN<"= YZ=RL>@"W$F"_O=$FHG L`Ia=$YZ= GN<"= _B="TX=AF"_R?AFbGSLcG(<>=$YZ=edf<"=$F"gH=$dhGN<"="ij?AYZ= YZ="TX=AYNYZ=B_k?BLlG(<>= ?A@O@"=ACDCE?AFHG9mn@OCE?[Q9FHGSQ T3To?AF>_ YZ=[L>@"WAF"_B=AFHG Lpmq_O=rTZ=$F"_R?[FHG L"!s: <"= YZ=[L>@>W$F"_B=AFHG LtF>We!"uv?AF"_vwxTX?[QyCE=B_xGXWz?A@O@"=R?[Y{W$Y$gHW$FbGZ=[L|G[GN<"= ?A@O@"=R?[C9d$GN<"=ri}I4=$YZ= @OYZWBgH=B=O_B=B_~="r8@r?AYUGZ= W$F;$!9A[! OB"! ]BYUGN<"=$Y(d GN<"=YZ=RL>@"W$F"_O=$FHG LF"W$!"d ?[F"_?AY=?OgGN]r?[CyC i gHW$FbGX=RL|G ?[FHGBGZWGN<"= ?[@B@"=R?RC ! FhWAYZ_B=$Y GZWf?A@B@OYZ=Bg"QP?>GX=}GN<"= gHW$FbGZ=$FHGSQEW$FrLWrT GN<"=@r?[YUGSQE=[LxGZW GN<"=?A@B@"=B?[C d Q G4QPL~QDF"gr]B V =$FHGGZWRQ "=Q9FHGNYZWO_$]"gGSQEW$F GZWG(<>= g?RL=W"TBGN<"=v@r?[YUGSQE=[LQ9FtgHWA@r?OgGOTZW$YN ! B@ @>=ACDCE?AFHGZPL<B]rL V ?AF"_ <BYSQ ¡ WBgr<"?[C ¢ ?RL@B]OYZgr<r?RL=B_T(YZ=O= <"W[CE_£@OCEW"G¤TXWAY¥gHW$FrLQE_B=AYX?"GSQEW$F¦WrT§¡ L"!h"dXObmq8hTNYZW$ ¨mL"! ¨xQ GUGX?[CPLW$F©L ª"?[F"_ « Q9Fr?[F"gH= ¬eHG(!ªGX_$! V i IK?>i W"T YZ=RRQyL|GZ=$YZ=B_Lb?[C =_B=O=B_s_R?"GZ=B_"u !9R$!X®e¯®YZ=R[QPL|GX=AYZ=B_^?RL Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (4) ° ±O²r³B´tµ$¶b·¸ ±e¹tºOº»r¼ ½ ¾ ¿B¿AÀ ·SÀE±$¶rÁR ñB±$ĸ ±e¹Åº"½ Æ ±[Â9³B´tµ ¸ ±$¹ ¼{ÇOÈ[½fÉ ÁBÊOµRËlÇBÇ"»RÌÇb¼$Í$½ÏÎZµRÊRÀyË|·Zµ$ÎZµB¿£ÐÑÀ ·NÒl·NÒ"µjÓ ³BÔ"Ì Õ µBÊ[ÀyË|·NÎXÁAÎ(½° µAÂ9ÒOÀ9¹ Ö Ò"µ7×O ±r·¤Ô"µBÁAΠ˸ ±e¹ÍOØBÍ$½´tµBÁRË>³BÎSÀD¶rÊ ÍOØOØvËÙe¹ÚrÁAÎZ¿[Ë"½"ËÀ ·N³rÁ"·ZµO¿vÀD¶·NÒ"µz²H±[ÂE±$¶bÚÄH¶"±>ÐŶxÁR˾ ²rÒ"ÁAÎUÚrÁ ¸ ÀDÄÛµr·XÁA¶R½[ÀD¶·NÒ"µ§ÁAÎZµRÁ ±rÜ$Æ ÀDÂyÂPÁBÊ©µÞÝ{±r·SÂPÁA½AÓ·XÁ>·Xµ ±rÜ° µAÂDÒOÀ"ÁA¶"¿ À ·{Ô"±$³O¶"¿[ËKÁRËųB¶>¿Bµ$Îß9Ì North-Road South-Road East-Plot No. 203 West-Plot No. 201 Ö ÒOÀyË}×OÂE±"· ÒrÁRË}Ô"µOµ$¶§ÊRÀ à"µ$¶Ï´³B¶OÀ ²"À9×rÁ[Â$¸ ±$¹e¾áÌ.º»e½R¾ ²rÒ"ÁAÎUÚrÁ ¸ ÀDÄÛµr·XÁA¶R½$âtÁ>ÚB³BÎRÆ ÀDÒrÁAÎ ã Ò>±"ÐÅĽB¸ µ"Ðä° µAÂ9ÒOÀEÌS»RÍ$½HÐÒOÀE²rÒhÒrÁRË Ô"µOµ$¶ÎZµrÜSÂEµO²·XµO¿¥À9¶t²H±A ±$³BÎ{ÎZµB¿¥ÀD¶Ñ·NÒ"µzËÀ ·Zµv×OÂEÁA¶R¹ Í$¹eÓ ÒBÎSÀeÕ ±B²rÒrÁ[Âe° ÁRˤ¿AÀ µB¿JÀ9¶b·XµRË|· Á>·Xµ§±$¶ º|¼ ¹ غ"¹Xº»RåOØ$½ ÂEµRÁ>àOÀ9¶rÊ Ô"µAÒOÀ9¶"¿ Ò©ÀyËÐÑÀE¿B±"Ð æ·NÒ"µ~ÁA×B×>µAÂDÂEÁA¶H·(½ Ô"µRËÀE¿Bµ[Ëz±r·NÒ"µ$Î ²"ÂEÁRËHËÞç Ò"µ[À9Î Ë"½}Ò"±"Ð4µrà"µ$Î(½Å·NÒ"µM±r·NÒ"µAÎÏãèÂEÁRËHËbÌnçhÒ>µAÀ9Î Ë7ÎZµ[ÂDÀ9¶>Ù$³OÀyË>Ò>µB¿ ·NÒ"µAÀDÎèÎSÀEÊAÒH· ËÞÔbÚhÐKÁ"Ú ±rÜ4Õ µRÊ[ÀyË|·ZµAÎZµB¿é° µBµO¿bæê° ±B²r³O´tµ$¶H· ¸ ±e¹ º>Ç©È[ëB½"¾ ¿B¿AÀ ·NÀ ±$¶rÁRÂ$ñB±$Ĥ¸ ±e¹ìº"½RÆ ±[Â9³B´tµº»BíAÇR½ É ÁBÊ©µ[ËÈ©åBÌ åOØ$½tÎZµRÊ[ÀPË|·XµAÎZµB¿ÐÑÀ ·NÒ·NÒ"µîÓ ³BÔ"ÌïÕ µRÊRÀyË|·NÎXÁAÎx±A¶sØr¼¹9ØBíe¹Xº»Rå[È ÐÀ ·(ÒK·(Ò>µzÓ ³BÔrÌïÕ µRÊ[ÀPË|·(ÎXÁ[Î(½B° µAÂ9ÒOÀ9¹ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (5) ðRñBò ó"ô¥õAöBö"ô[÷D÷Põ[øHù órõOú§û9ørü|ùNû ùNýHùZôBúzù(óOþZôBô§ü>ýOû ù ürÿBû ñ9ôeñ Nû ýOû ù eñ $ þ ô$ þ õAø>ô$øH ù ø ýB ø ùS û A ø ¥úRõ"ùZôB! ú #"e%ñ $'&B)ñ ( ö"ôAø"úAû9 ø * +"ô $þZô ùNó"ô ,- AýBþU. ù óBþS0 û /ì1ñ 3 ñ 24 AóOû 2ü"ñ / õ ¤÷ ô[ü>5 ó * õ 6+Bó"õA8þ 7KõR9÷ BùNó"ôÏùNó"ô$;ø :>ú$<ñ ,û =OûD?÷ >Oý> ú *O@ô A ôA÷DóOû ÿ NûDû B,û =OûDC ÷ ýOû . ù $D ñ ( &@( ( # úRõ>ùZôBú @&O9ñ $ )ñ ( # $þ ô$ þ õ[ø"ô$øbùvõAø> ú 2tõAø"úBõ"Eù $Gþ FH ø ýB ø ùS û AøEù lþZôRü|ù(þXõRû9øùNó"ô ûD÷y÷E ô *Oõ[I÷ J $ørü|ù(þNKý ùNû $Lø 7M $ þ N ûDø¥ù(ó>ô öO÷ r ù O=rõR÷9ýOûD?ø *}ùNó"ô ü>ý©û ù õRü P ü"ñ ( (Q$ $ R $þ úB ô rþZôBô ö RüHüô[üHü û Aø õAø"úBõ"Eù $Gþ F û9Sø ïýBKø ùNû $ø õAø>ú P ü"T ñ (> ð $ RU $þsö>ô$ þ õAø>ô$øHùû9 ø ýB ø ùS û A ø ó K7a?ô ="ô$ þ õAø õAöOöO÷Dû õ"ùS û $ø úRõ>ùXôOú $AðR%ñ $ )ñ ( # ýOø"úBôAþ ü ô ùS û AD ø ( & (V,W X,B7aõRü ûD÷EôOú $Wþ 7Ñû ùNó"ú$þXYõ 7Kõ[Z÷ ù(ó>ôsü>ý©û ù õAø> ú $[ ø $ %ñ $ \ñ ( # Åù(ó>ô£õAöOöO÷Dû õ"ùS û $] ø 7aõR^ ü J $ørüûEúBôAþZôBú õAø>úü>ýOû _ù ` eLñ ( & ( ( I 7aõRüéúAûyKü ¤ûPüHüôBúõBa ü 7û ùNó"úAþXKõ 7Å ø 7û ù(ó¤÷Dbû +"ô$þUGù FÑEù ûy÷Eô þZô[ü>óxü>ý©û ù$õAø"ú{ ÿ NûyûD û c ýOû ù $þ P ôRü|)ù AþXõ"ùS û $ø d RüHüô[üHü û Aø¥õAø"e ú ô$ þ õ[ø"ô$øHfù ø ïýO ø ùS û $ø Eþ g rþZôBõ"ùSû9?ø * ùNóOû9þZú örõ[þUOù F û9øHùZô$þô[ü|U ù =OûEúBô ýOû h ù eU ñ & J K ( # úRõ>ùZôBú $$ðB9ñ $ )ñ ( # 7KõBü ûy÷EôB6 ú =rõ[÷9ý©û9?ø *xùNó"ô}ü>ý©û ù $þRùNó"ô}öOýBþN ö Rüiô ïýOþSûyüúAû ùNû $ø¦õBü P ü"ñ $@ 9$#$ $ R +"ô $þZôîùNó"j ô ,- AýBþUkù :>ú$ñ A ûPü|ù(þ û @ù >Oý" ú *©'ô 'A ôA÷9ó©û 'ñ :"õ"ùZô$'þ $ ø $øùNó"ôv ô ="lô rórõ[?ø *OôÏûDø ö"#ô rýBøOûPõ[Gþ Fm ïýBþSûPüúA û ùSû $øéû9øùNó"C ô F"ôRõA_þ ( # @ ìùNó"n ô õRüeô 7KõRü Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (6) o p)q rIsutEv@p pEv#wCoExCozyKvT{fx@| pGo}x?t~Kw' { #b< #| w #v' v by#Zq rKw o y#ssK|# oLq sq oEv@pkx@rw#v w#v w Jo y vB{fx@| pGo6x?tl y#p ~ qK _q r`%r y^Zx q r %fo y vo y v@rD~Kw'M{ #b` #| w #v'J |Kw v rJo`w q oEv w;'#% @9# #¡ %rmo y#%pEw¢sK|# oE£¤ ¥¦y ve§#pEv s v@ro q §#§ v q JUo y vDq § §Kv b q rJo¨sTq q %rIsuo | w v@rJo%©ªw#v ?pEv v w qKo)v#w @ % @9## ' ¥¦y v q § §Kv b q rJoh q %Ls«v? b|IsY v x r v@p\sKyI%§nx?tWozyKv§ pEx@§Kv@pGoG q r w sK|# os5Mv@pEvUtb v#w'`y#b v §# v q#w br?ev?#suo)v r Jv x?tMpEv v ?q rJoYq |?s v x?tq#Qo x@r¡q rKw0%r o y v¢o y#bpEwesK|# oz¬o y vVq § §Kv b q rJo}y?qIwT§#p)q v w5t)x ppEv suo)x p)q o x@r x?t;§ v q#Jv tz|I?q#Yq rJoiq r w®§#yJIsY Yq m§ x sJs v sJsY [email protected] t¢§# x?o v q p%r 6| rI %§ q }¯ x@`°f±³² ´' °?y q pG?q¯-bµv?o)q r ·¶qK | p ¸ %y q p {WyKx 4Y v by#±´ @<x@pEve§?q pGo ?|Iq p 5sKy x r¢brªozyKv sY oEv«§#q r ¡ v sY w v s¹w#v ?pEv vºt)x p § v p _q r v rJoT%r | rKQo x@r pEv suo p)q br#%r 3o y v[w v t)v r w q roshr x?o»oExjYq |?s v¹q rJht | pGo y v@p Jx@r?suozp |KQo x@r¼x? v p½o y v §I x?o x@pr x?ono)x § q pGon o y« o\s § x sJs v sJsY x@r4oExmo y#bpEw5§?q pGoOLx@p o)xlq b v@r?qKo)vkx p oExl?pEv qKo)vlq rJ %rKw6x?t ?y q p)#v_o y v pEv x@r ¥¦y viq §#§ v q ro q v Iv sozpEv sJs±¾§?q sJs v#w¢brJoEx¡y v p¦§# x oZJmo y v pEv sK§Kx@r w v rJo\sUrKx'm²¿q r w]q r w] q oEv@px r M| r?q |Jo y x@p ÀJv w Jx@r?suozp |KQo x@rMq sLp)q s v#w'µozyKvÁ_q oGo)v p?q sLpEv@§Kx@pGoEv w¨o)x4ozyKv Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (7)  à ÄbÅ ÆJÇ6ÈzÉEà ÊDË ÅbÊÇmË)Ã6ËÅ%ÊÇÁÌ ÍJËdÎ ÃÐÏIÆQË Å Ã@ÎÑMÏ ÒMË\Ï ÓµÇ@ÎkÌÔËzÕKÇ Â Ã ÄbÅ ÆJÇ@Ö Ë Õ ÇªÏ Â Â Ç ÄbÄÏ ÎJË ÑMÏ ÒÆJÃ@Ê6Â Ç ÄÄ Ç ×6ËEÃ6È ÅÄ ÇLË Õ ÇiÒKÍIÅ Ë È ÉEÃ@Ê ËÅ%ÊÇ ËEÃ Ë ÅbÊÇ'ØhÙÚÎ#Å ËÅÏ ÄÄ Ô ÖÒKÍ#Å ËDÑMÏ Ò ÈÅbÄ Ç#× Ï Û#Ï Å%ÎIÒuË^ËzÕKÇ ÉEÇ ÒKÂKÃ@Î × Ç ÎJË\ҪΠÃ@ئÜËEÃCÝÁÌ ÍJË Ä Ï ËEÇ@É Ã Î Ö'ÉEÇ ÒKÂKÃ@Î × Ç ÎJË\ÒkÎ Ã'ØIÞ ËEÃ6ßÑMÇ@ÉàǪÅ%Ê6Â#Ä Ç Ï#× Ç#×'Ø ÞdØ á¦Õ Ç[ÉEÇ ÒK Ã@Î ×#Ç@ÎJË\Ò0Õ?Ï#×hÃ@ ÂKÃ Ò Ç ×ËzÕKÇ[ÒKÍ#Å Ë\ÒUÏ ÎK×hÏ ÄbÄ-ËzÕKÇ È)Ï#ÆQË\Ò ÖÎ?Ï É É)Ï ËEÇ ×0Å%ÎVÏ ÈEà ÉEÇ@ÊÇ@ÎJËÅ Ã@Î Ç ×Â?Ï É)Ï#Û É)Ï Â#ÕIÒaâ)Ç ã ÆJÇ@ÂJË Å%Î?ÒuË Å Ë ÍJËÅ Ã@Î Ã È Ë Õ ÉEÇ Ç ÒKÍ#Å Ë\Ò ä¤Ö Õ?ÏKå Ç Ì Ç Ç@Î × Ç@Î#Å Ç × å Ç@ÕKÇ@ÊÇ@ÎJËÄ Ô[Ï Î ×¹ÉEÇ ÒK Ã@ÎK× Ç@ÎËÒÆ?Õ?Ï ÄbÄ Ç Î?Û#Ç ×[ËzÕKÇjÊ_Ï É ÓµÇ?Ë å?Ï ÄbÍ Ç¢Ã?ȦÒKÍ#Å Ëf ÉEÃ@ÂKÇ@ÉGËGÔ;ÌKÇ Å%Î Û¡Êà ÉEÇÐËzÕ Ï Î¡æÒ Ø<ç#è@Ö9è#è èé ê`Ã@É Ï ÉEÃ Í Î ×ÁæfÒ Ø Ý6ÄÏ#ÆKÒ Ø ë Ç Å ËzÕKÇ@É@Ë Õ ÇlÒKÍ#Å Ë ÑÏ Òå?Ï Ä%Í Ç#×5 ÉàÃ@ Ç@ÉÄ Ô Ì ÍËÍ Î × Ç ÉWå?Ï ÄbÍ Ç ×n× Ç ÄÅ%Ì Ç@É)ÏKËEÇ Ä ÔnÎ Ã@É-Ë Õ ÇnË Õ Ç ÎVì-Ã@Í#ÉGË4Õ?Ï#× í Í#ÉÅÒ × Å ÆQË Å Ã@ÎÐË)ÃVË ÉGÔ5ËzÕKÇTÒKÍ#Å ËzÖ ÎKÃ@ÉË Õ ÇnÒYÅ Ë)ÇTÂ#ÄÏ ÎCÅÒÁÆJÃ@É ÉEÇ ÆQËzÖ Î Ã ÉDÂIÄ Ã?Ëë Ã@Ø î#è î¼ÑMÏ Ò¼Û Å å Ç@Î Ê6Í ÎIÅ Æ Å%Â Ï ÄVë Ã'Ø¿ïfê³Ü ð'Ö ïÆ?Õ?Ï ÉGÔ?ÏTëfÅ%ÓµÇ?Ë)Ï Î Ö`ñ`Ç Ä%Õ#Å%Ø'á¦Õ ÇCÏ Â#Â Ç ÄbÄ Ï ÎJËMÕ Ï#×nÎ Ã ËÒKÕ ÃKÑ4Î Ë Õ Ç òXÕ?Ï ÒKÉ)ÏUÎ#Í Ê6Ì Ç ÉzÖZ× Ç Ò Æ?ÉÅbÂJËÅ Ã@ÎaÏ ÎK×V× Å%ÊÇ@Î?ÒYÅ Ã@ΡÃ?ÈÕKÇ@É Â#Ä Ã?ËzØfÙÚÎ5È)Ï#ÆQËzÖ Â ÉEÃ@Â Ç ÉGËGÔUë Ã'جïfêóÜ ðUÕ?Ï Ò¢Î Ã½ÉEÇ Ä Ç å?Ï Î ÆQÔlÑÅ Ë Õ Â#Ä Ã?Ëë Ã@ØZî#è î¿Î à É-Ï ÎÔ¢Â#Ä Ã ËMë`Ã'ØcîIècÜÐÃ@É`î#è@Ý¢Ï ÉEÇaÇ?ã#ÅÒuË ÅbÎ?Û Ã@Î¢Ë Õ Ç¿ÑMÇ ÒuËEÇ@ÉÎeÃ@ÉÇ Ï ÒuËEÇ@É ÎnÒYÅ ×#ÇTà È ÉàÃ@ Ç@ÉGËGÔUë`Ã'Ø ïfê³ÜQð'Ø ô ÉEÃ@ÂKÇ@ÉGËGÔ ë`Ã'Ø ïfêóÜ ð Ç?ã Æ ÄbÍIÒYÅ å Ç Ä Ô Ì Ç Ä Ã@Î?Û Ò Ë)à ËzÕKÇ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (8) õEö ÷KøKù@ú û ö úJü\÷úKù'ý'þÿ úKû @ýJü öªø õàù@ø ö@õGü ³þ ?ÿ ÷ÿ õEö ÿ6ù ÷ 'ý ?ÿ õEû ÷4ø ù?ü Jü ö ¨ø õ ?ÿ ÷ ö û ü!" $#ÿ% 4ù !&ö@úKö@õ)ÿ' ( ù #·ö@õZù ) ¦üGüEù@õ úKö kÿ úKû* + õEö ö-,ö@úJüzý ./ ö 0 ?ÿ 1 ö2Kö ö@ú3 %ú ø ù ÷J÷ ö ÷J÷4 ù@ú¼ü ö õEö ù h ÷4% ú J ö @ý65 ' ý)þ 7 ý8.9K ö õ)ÿ' ÷ ö û Jù@ú?÷uüzõ %Q ü ù@ú®ø?ÿ õGü: ÿ üEö@õ5ù@ú ;b ú þ 7 ÿ ú û þ 7 @ ý=Ú< ú ÿ#û#û- ü: ù ú L ü ö ÿ ø ø ö' > ÿ úJü0? ÿ#û?
: > ö#û¹÷% ü*E
ù@õ¢ø ö õ _, ÿ ú ö úJü
% úA@B ú%Q ü ù@úCù@ú2 C'ýD5 ý)þ
7 EK ù M # ö 1 ö@õ c ü öUÿ ø ø ö' > ÿ úJü9M# ÿ ÷
ú ù ü/ + õEÿ úJüEö ûFb úJüEö@õ: Dg , õEö- > ö
DG ÷uü)ÿ # ü K ö@õEö ÿ%O
üEö@õ # ü K ö;ÿ ø øKö- > ÿ úJü
? ÿIû ÿ ÷ ùH
: > ö#û ÷% üIE
ù@õ^øKù ÷J÷ ö ÷J÷4 ù@ú¼ÿ ú û ø ö õ _ , ÿ ú ö úJü
% úA@B ú%Q ü ù@únù ú¢ü K ö ÷ÿ- , öJ)
ÿ Q ü\÷I Jüú ùK% úü)ö õ: D, ÷uü)ÿ 2M# ÿ ÷ + õ)ÿ úJüEö ûUüEùL ö@õ ü ö@õEö ÿ%O üEö õ f ü öUü % õEû÷% üM# ÿ ÷2 : N ö û ù ú 5 ý65 @7 ý)þ 7 OC ÷%K ö ùOJü)ÿ'b ú ö û % úJüEö@õP D, ÷uü)ÿ ÿ + ÿ'b úI÷uü ü ö õEö ÷KøKù@ú û ö úJü\÷ÁúKù'ýfþªÿ ú ûQIR =J ù@ú J ö ÿ >% ú +=) ÿ Q ü\÷S õEùO¹ , ü ö T ù- õGü\÷ ýU./ ö õEö ÷Kø ù ú û ö úJü\÷ ? ÿ#û ÿ ÷ ù û ö@ú ö û ù?ü K ö@õ ÿ' N ö #+ ÿ ü: ù@ú?÷ ù ü ö ø ÿ'% úüzýV.9K ö õEö ÷Kø ù ú û ö úJü úKù'ý Jù@úü)ö ÷uü)ö#ûÁü öiü b õEûa÷% ü ü ? ÿKüE öW ÷*% õ õEö 1 ù Y ÿ- öQ N XJ ö@ú%J ö ö ù f ü ö õEö ÷Kø ù@úKû ö@úJüú ù'ýWþW% úVÿn÷% ù@øY% ú¡ü ö½ø õEù@øKö@õGü 0E ù@õ 1?ÿ' >? ÿ- ö J ù@ú?÷4 û ö õ)ÿ ü: ù@ú ù [fZ ÷ ý\ 5O D5 5 5RG]g ø?ÿ' û'ýK./ ö õEö ÷KøKù@ú û ö úJü}úKù'ý_^2 ÿ' >L , ÷¢ÿ¢üEö@ú ÿ úJü`% ú¡÷%K ù@ø¿ú ù@ýaQb 4# ý%ö'ýc þd¬^ ý65 'C ý)þ 7 e ù fg? ÿ-h ü: i ÿ ú û-b õ ÿ úKû + + ÿ õj# ÿ' k ÿ õ)ÿ-L, ÷% ÿ' ÿ@ý-./ ö¢õEö ÷Kø ù ú û ö úJüú ù'ý ÿ' ÷ ù2 ÿ' >L, ÷_üEùQ ö Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (9) lJmon-p l-p"mrq stm u nLv n'w%x qOp%y nOpRmzp%q|{~}Qg$m {zl l\9n g>p v n'w%x%n mq szl\w%u qOx {6nO{Ns }%{D |{o} %{`9u%nv n w%x qOp y nOp"m p qO{/Yl yOS mPw8u Dl8m nOp l-p"m q s m u%nv n w%x qOp y nOp"mMp q|{}8Dp w%u q-xp q|{$q-p\m u nzqOp"m u v nOp"m q s8 w { 4R] z{Dn|{cs }%{6 {o} O{ { /u n/v:cl R `qO¡ v m s vol-zn ysoq'>Xq%~Dp ¢£Nw"w%¡ n w¥¤D
1. Whether the suit is barred by limitation?OPD-1 &2
2. Whether the suit has not been properly valued for the purposes of the Court fee and jurisdiction in view of preliminary objection no. 2 and 3 of the written statement of th defendants no. 1 and 2, preliminary objection no. 3 of the written statement of the defendant no. 4?OPD-1,2 & 4
3. Whether the suit is not maintainable in view of preliminary objection no. 5 of the written statement?OPD-1 & 2
4. Whether the plaintiff has no locus-standi to maintain the present suit?OPD-1, 2, 4 & 6
5. Whether the suit is barred under order XXIII Rule 1 CPC and under order II Rule 2 CPC?OPD-4
6. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties in view of preliminary objection no. 8 of the written statement of the defendant no. 1?OPD-1
7. Whether the suit if bad for mis-joinder of parties in view of preliminary objection no. 1 of the written Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (10) statement of the defendant no. 5?OPD-5
8. Whether the defendants no. 4, 5 and 6 are protected under D.R.C. Act?OPD-4, 5 & 6
9. Whether the suit is bad for mis-joinder of cause of action?OPD-4 & 6
10.Whether the suit is barred under order XXIII Rule 1 CPC and under order II Rule 2 CPC?OPD-4 & 6
11.Whether there is no privity of contract between the plaintiff and defendant no. 3?OPD-3
12.Whether the plaintiff is entitled for restoration of the peaceful vacant possession of premises No. 19, Acharya Niketan, New Delhi, as shown red in the site plan?OPP
13.Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of injunction as claimed for?OPP
14.Relief.
¦|§ ¨/© ª ¨/«:¬c'® ¯`°O± « ² ³R´ ¬ ²Pµ ¶B± · ¸-¹zªOº"²D» · ª ¼ «½ª ª · ² ª · ¾|¿ §6¾ ÀO§6À ¾ ¾ ¾\·-¬Nµ%¹S¬cµ"µÁ² © ªÂµ%± ¬ ²zÃ~© ¬>® ªÄ¸'¬ Å ¬Dº ¸Æ ¬>º ·-¬>º ¸ µÇ°Oº ¬Nµ"µ%±%ª'µ3º °|§ È É/ÀOɦI-º%·YÊ2 ¸ ¬Dº µd²9² © ªY« ª'µ%Ë °-º · ª-º"²Pµ É9³ ±R² ¬Nµ"µ%±%ª'µÂº °|§ Ì É%Í -º ·*¿SÎ ¬Nµ"µ%± ª º °O§O¿Ï ¬Nµ"µ%±%ª3º °O§|È ¾ Ð'ÃMªO« ª · ª ¼ ¬X· ª ·OÉ ¸ '¬Dº µd²Ñ² ©%ª-Ë Ë ª-®>®X-º"²£-º%·¬>º\Æo Å °-± « ° ÆÒ² ©%ª « ª'µ%Ë%°Oº · ª-º"²Pµ § ¯`°Oº µ ª ÓO± ª-º"²:® ´ Ér² © ª° ² ©%ªO«*¬Nµ"µ%± ª µÔº%°|§ ÈRÀ -º%· È%ÌHÃrªO« ª '®Nµ ° · ª ¼ ¬ · ª · ¸ '¬Dº µd²K² © ª -Ë Ë ª-®>®X-º"²D» Ë ®X'¬DºR² ¬ ÆÕÆg-º%·=² © %² ¬NµSà ©"´ É'² © ª2µ%± ¬ ²EÎÕ² © ¬D« · ÐgÃÖ µ×·'¬Nµ%¹S¬Nµ"µ ª · Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (11)
-Ø Ù%Ú Û Ü%Ý Ø-Þ Þ%Ý-ß>ßXØ-Ù"ÛDàáÞ ßcØ âDÙ"Û:â ã ãäâNå Ø æ æ-ç:â Ý è Ý Ú é"ê ëOç Ú ÝOç>à ìBí Ú æ-îzÝ-Ù"ÛDà]Ú Ý ï ç Ý Ý×Ú Ø Û Ý Ú ðOñ òDð óOò6ó ð ð ð|ò4ôJã Ý õLë Û Ü Ý-çâcå"å í Ý'å Ù ëOò!ö3Ø-Ù Ú2÷=Ø-ç Ý2Ù ë Ûç Ý-ß Ý è Ø-ÙRÛ9âDÙ Û Ü Ý2Þ ç Ý å ÝOÙ"Û9Ø-Þ Þ Ý Ø'ßDøØ å Û Ü ÝIåRØ'îzÝ0õrÝOç Ý8Ú'âNå%Þ ë å Ý ÚQë ãÕãEù í ØQë Û Ü ÝOçEÙ ë-Ù ú:ï"ëOÙ"Û Ý'ådÛoØ'Ù"Û ç Ý'å%Þ%ëOÙ Ú Ý-Ù"ÛPå ò û ò ü/Ü ÝJØ-Þ Þ Ý-ßNßcØ-ÙRÛMâNå=Ø æ æ'ç:âXÝ è Ý Úýé"ê ìBí Ú æ-îzÝOÙRÛ6à Ú Ý ï ç Ý ÝIÚ Ø Û Ý Ú ð|ñ ò6ð óOò6ó ð ð ð ë ãþ%Ú|òJü/ç:âXØ'ßKÿ`ë í ç Û]øÇØ å Û Ü Ý ãoØ ï ÛPå Ø-Ù Ú Ý è â Ú ÝOÙ ï"ÝIëOÙJç Ý ï"ëOç ÚWõÖØ åQÙ ë ÛtØ-Þ Þ ç Ý ï âXØ Û Ý ÚJØ'Ù ÚIã:â>Ù Ú-âDÙ æ å Ü Ø%è ÝVé Ý ÝOÙæ'â è ÝOÙ ï"ëOÙRÛ çoØ-ç êÛ ë?Û Ü Ý Þ çPâDÙ ï â>Þ ßXÝ'åÂë ãYßcØ%õ ø Û Ü ÝOç Ý ãoë-ç Ý|ø-â Û_âNåÑé Ø å Ý Ú;ëOÙÑï"ëOÙ ìBí Ù%ï Û í ç Ý3Ø-Ù%Ú*å í ç îSâNå Ý å ø Û Ü Ý Ú Ý ï ç Ý ÝIâcå;ßNâcØ-é ß Ý0Û ëQé ÝJå Ý ÛgØ å4âXÚ ÝOò Ý ã ëOç ÝIî$ê=Ú-âNå ï í å"å4âXëOÙ ëOÙ*Û Ü ÝîzÝOç:â Û:å ë ãgÛ Ü Ý8ï4Ø å ÝOøÚ í ç:â>Ù æWÛ Ü Ý8Ú'â ã ã ÝOç ÝOÙ"ÛtÞ Ü Ø å Ý'å ë ã¥Ø-ç æ í îzÝOÙRÛ:åYè Ø'ç:âXë í åYÛ ç:â è âcØ'ß îØ Û Û ÝOçPåYõrÝOç Ý\Ú-âcå ï í å"å Ý Ú|ø Ü âXæ-Ü ßNâcæ-Ü"Û:â>Ù æOøÖØ åÔâ ã øÛ Ü ÝÂåRØ-îzÝÂØ-ç½ÝÔè ÝOç ê îØ Û ÝOç:âcØ ß6ø$Ø ß>â Ý Ú í ç:âDÙ æ ç Ý ï"ëOç Ú'âDÙ æ ë ãIÝ è â Ú ÝOÙ%ï"Ý|ø=Û Ü%ÝOç Ý Ø-ç ÝØ ï"ï âXÚ ÝOÙ"ÛoØ'ß å4ß>â>Þ å ø)Ø å3Ø-Þ Þ Ý Ø'çPå ø9â>ÙQç Ý ï"ëOç Ú'âDÙ æQÝ-â Û Ü%ÝOç9Û Ü ÝIÚ Ø%ÛoÝ å*ëOç Û Ü Ý Þ ç ë-Þ ÝOç Û êYÙ í îÑé Ý-ç øaØ åFâ>ÙWï4Ø å ÝJë ãtç Ý ï"ë-ç Ú-âDÙ æJÝ è â Ú ÝOÙ ï"ÝFë ã Û Ü ÝYØ-Þ Þ Ý-ß>ßXØ-Ù"Û øOÛ Ü%ÝÁÚ Ø%Û ÝQë ãgÛ Ü%Ý2ê Ý Ø-ç ÷ ö û ëOç ÷ ö 2õÖØ å Ù ë Ûç Ý ï"ëOç Ú Ý Ú Þ ç ëOÞ Ý-ç:ß ê ø Ø'ß Û Ü%ë í æ'Ü Û Ü Ý åRØ-îzÝ õrÝOç Ý Þ ß Ý Ø Ú Ý ÚÒëOç!ç Ý ã ÝOç ç Ý Ú âDÙ$Û Ü ÝSÝ è âXÚ ÝOÙ ï"Ý Ø-Ù Ú×å4â>îSâ>ßXØ-ç:ß ê ø âDÙ$Û Ü%Ý Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (12) ! " " # $ ! % %&' ( )+*! ,.-/ " $0- 132#4 5 $617 -" %& - 89 ;:< =-" /$>8? , @? "A B = -
C D E-/ F D G H ! I -" % J K G132MLF4 $N17 -" %& -
89 ;:< =-" /$POG- & (
PQ9 -" SRT , :E$"@U "A;
V2J4 W XZY # B JA &/$P -[ \ H !
]-")G ^-
_
=- A? EA` [ a)b- J V-/Ac$3 d ]- )G ^ ([A_ 6 -
*
" B * eE XgfS J V- AhR9 "( % i*
( 0
-"
/-" # ) H ! -" jk( l")G ] /-
5 m
Xc5 W XcW
5 5 5 $^ !( J
V-/An)b- % # o,p q /-
F J ([ EA &/$ = " $r ! , s ` C r t J Vl" ] u )
= / B v ; w J # B U-"
/-/AcX fS = " $x H ! y E- F s z*!
- % p, `A;A *! ` F ([ F
' \)G J J $/:< [ l{ G
,
uA_ | " # }- !
; J # . ] [ ~ = " X
" "A &/$ - A;AV- N -[ [ J V- A`A & `A_ g
; !([
- l
- [ B 9 d / ! ! # a XvL $7WK- n-"
AV- 9 /$
0 - )G n / ! ! # ! XN$~m-" ! i,~
! " =- C* &,.-!& -")G ")G n i
AV-/ * (]
- l
-
` = " ) o-"
/-/Ac$t !! " #
-/A;A_ " l
y -! 9-a ,,p u,~ ; ! =- n r H !
-")G "
A_- ] $T, [ _ ^,~ " u " =-
" F i-
A` _ E- J _ " n -") )G " T E ; C- % }
Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (13) "G" G ]; o _ ]H E/ F¡ ¢ £/¤"¢¥ F ¦£ G ¢J J iJ;`b§ ; \ ¢ ¨/!= ¨© ª « ©/¬ «c¬ © © © + "¢ § £ ¢ ! £ J £ [ £ !£ ®! ¢= ` F ® ¯ H! ¢ !!£ " # z r°k !±H ¢ K£ §3 " / «Z²S ¢ §=£"¢ ¤ /Z U s £ BT£ §z¢ ! J J_£ KG"¢J # w£ §³H!hE/ F ´ `;u® µ"V F [ F ¶ B= µ µ ¢J · V +b %="¢# ´ ´ "¢ ! ®¸° ±¡b!| "¢o ¢J_£"¢¹ £ H! ¢ /!= © ª «c© ¬ «c¬ © © © « º « »n ; £ ¤n £d i _ n£ § " c7 E/ F£ §N ¢% ~E"+® + £"+ ; \/ T§ £"; £ ´ b¼ ½ ¾ £ ¢ ¤¿ £¿ ¶" !";_" H' ¢h !® " oÀ! ¶ÁU ¢J  £ UÃ7/ [ ¢ F £ p£ § V G// ! ¢# ¤ ¬ © © FÄ «x¯ "¢ y®]¯ ´ ¯g£ §z ] K K¬ Åx«c© ¬ «=ÆFÇ ª!Ç § ¢ £ ¨ÈzÉÊ «ËÈÌ %= ` F£ {À "!ÍÏÎ ; " gÐ · H«³ÀF= «® "¢J ¤ £ }Ñ?£ «S¬ ©/¬G/ ! ¢J ¤¬ © © FÄ «Ò¯ "¢¥ E != d; H! £" £ ¯Ó £ ´ ¾ ¢%¯ oÑ9 Ó< # /;µ "¢ /£ § Ô ;`V ¤[nÕP£ JV ³Á= g£ §pÃU P g E V Ö"×/«?Ð »½MÆØÉØÆ " _±# # ® £ /"¢Ù¯/«À ! ¢£ ´ / / EV¤ È [_ rÑU£ « ¾ ½MÆ±Ç ¾ "¢%¯ oÑ3 Ó< =" ÈG!¯ ¢ Ô ; "¢ Ú !£ ´ ÓEDÃ?" _½JÇ/¬ «d²S ¢ !!£ " # £ «Æ "! ¬ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (14) Û Ü Ý Þ!ß à Þ ÞFÝ á'â ã]Û=ä+ÛHå!Ýsß æ ä Ûxà"ã á\Û å Ý çuè æVà â;éGÝ á{ä ê ã!Ý Ü#Þ!å â ßGä ë Þ!ì â Û7æVà"ã!ásÞBÛ=à ÛJâ ã íÛ ägî!Ýä ê ã Ý Ü?ä ãuÛHå!Ýgî à/ÞEâVÞrä ë7ïä êpÝ Ü7ä ë ð Û%Û ä Ü ã Ý çbà ã á ð í"Ü Ý Ý éGÝ ã Û Û ä ñËÝ"æ;æ<ä ë ñËÝ"ß Û Ý é+î Ý"ܳò±ó/ô õ"ö ÷ å Ý Ü Ý à/Þ øzà è è ä Ü á â ã ídÛ änÛ å Ý0Ü Ý Þ!ß!ä ã á Ý"ã Û#Þã ä ö òà"ã á^õ ã Ý â Û å Ý Ü>ÛHå!Ý à ß ß Ý æ;æVà ã Û ùVÞ å ì[Þ!î à ã á ã ä ÜÛHå!Ý ß Ü Ý/ÞFÝ ã Û à"ß ß Ý"æ;æ_à"ã Û9âVÞ{ä ê ã Ý Ü7ä ëSÛ å Ýß Ü ä ß!Ý Ü%Û%ç/øËã!ä ÜËÛ å Ýaá Ý ÞFè ÜJâ ß]Û â ä ã í â ú Ý ãâ ãrÛHå!ÝsÞ]à æ_Ýá Ý Ý á Þ+Û=à æ;æ`â_Ý ÞÌê}â Û åuÛHå!Ýhß Ü ä ß Ý"Ü%Û|ç à ÛÒÛHå!Ý Þ!ß ä Ûø ã ä"ÜÒâ ÛPê.à Þé+ì]Û#à!Û Ý áyâ;ãGÛHå!Ýgã à"éGÝrä ëPÛ å Ý'à"ß ß!Ý"æ;æ_à"ã Û ùVÞ å ì Þ!î à"ã á øxã ä Ü?â ãuÛ å Ýã à"éGÝä ëËÛ å Ýà"ß ß Ý æ;æVà ã ÛHø â;ãuÛ=Ý"Ü éÌÞ ä ë û ì[æ_Ýsõ ôyä ë7üUÝ æ å âxý à"ã!á û Ý ë ä Ü éÌÞ û ì[æ_Ý Þ ø?òFó þ]ÿÜ Ý à á ê â ÛHå ñËÝ è±ÛJâ_ä"ã[Þ ø ÿ +ä Ü ÿ ÿä ëZü?Ý"æ å[â[ý à"ã!á û Ý ë ä Ü éÌÞ ð è±ÛHø ò±ó þ]ÿ à"ã!á â;ãGÛ Ý Ü éÌÞ ä ë"Û å Ýrà"ß ß Ý"æ;æ_à"ã Û ùVÞ}ä ê ã{Þ]à æ Ý\á Ý Ý á Tö ï ÷ ò õ ø[Û å ÝuÛ â Û æ Ý á ä Ý Þ\ã ä ÛSß à Þ Þ{ì ã[æ_Ý Þ Þ ÛHå!Ýæ_à"ã áyâVÞ+é+ì Û=à Û Ý á ö ä!ê~Ý ú Ý"ÜHø Û å Ý"Ü Ýsâ`Þ ã äé+ì Û=à ÛJâ_ä"ãrâ ã\ë=à ú ä"ì Üä ëÒñUå ÜJâ û ä è å à æ ü7à Þ'ä"Ü~â ã ë=à ú ä"ì Üzä ë9Û å Ýà"ß ß Ý"æ`æVà"ã]ÛNñUé}Ûö û à Êã â Gà/Þ]à"ã!á ö å ÝwÜ Ý Þ!ß ä ã!á Ý ã]ÛJÞbã ä öÒò}à ã á õ+à"Ü Ý â;ãuß ä Þ ÞFÝ/Þ ÞEâ_ä ã\ä ëZæVà"ã!á éGÝ/à Þ!ì ÜJâ ã í þ Þ ö ç à"Ü á Þ{à"ã!áâ ÛNî!Ý/à"Ü#Þ'ß Ü ä ß!Ý Ü%Û%ç Uä ö ð òFó ø ð è å à"Ü%ç à 3â <Ý Û=à"ã ø Gà!ç ì Ü 9â å à"Ü! Tå ä ê " Eø{üUÝ æ å â ó/õ à"ã!á Û å Ý à"ß ß!Ý"æ;æ_à"ã Û ë#à/â;æ_Ý áÛ äwÝ ÞBÛ=à"î æ`â`Þ!å Û å à Û ð òFó ø ð è å à"Ü%ç à # 9â <Ý Û=à"ã/ø Gà ç ì Ü $ 9â å à Ü % Nå ä!ê & EøsüUÝ æ å â ó/õ ê.à/Þtå à!ú â ã í Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (15) ')(+* , -/.1032 ' 4 .35768.:91; <);>=@?3A3BC(ED3B 6F- GH* 5IBCJLKNMO* 4#A -QPSR);19LT8AU-V2 W BU?3GYX (+.10)J[Z]\^. 0 4/Z_2[0a`b`S- ?c*d5+.dZ -V2 ?3032c2e5fA *gB ')'[*LBC4h.1J ij*1(S- 5S2 9 R:9lk 9/=F2 (+* `f4 *)?Y5+*)Ze- JnmoBC(lB)X (lBC')A p:KFB W .3, *:Kq5fA *rTq(S-/BC48s .10)(E5 (+* 5t0 (fJ *)Zu5fA *]`S- J[Z - J XL2v. Jw-V2c2[0 *L2uJ[.:9 k K ;1K p_B J Zyx B X)BC-#JU2z5 5fA * (+*L2[' .1J[Z)*1Jc5I2 W 0c5 -Q2c2[0 *C2 J .19:{LK3|}K~B J Zk < \h*1(+*Z)* ? -/Z)* ZB)X BC- J32z5C5fA *B ')' *C4#4QBCJc5t9)sF.1J32 *)10[*1Jc5S4 DLKc5fA *
-Q2c2[0 *C2 J .19 ka;B J Zk[{ \h*1(+*BL4V2 .Z)*)? - Z)*)ZB)X)BL- JU2z5F5tA[* BC')' *C4#4QBCJc5t9[T8A[*$-V2c2[0 *!J .:9L~I$-V2c2[0[*>J .:9 k <)\BL2j.1J5fA * '[. - Ja58.3` W B (8.3` 5fA * 2[0 - 50)J Z *1(q. (+Z)*1( q EENF0 4/*k shms BCJ Z0)J[Z)*1(C.1(+Z *1(}bU0U4/*;shms 9 TqA *BC')' *C4#4QBCJc5-V2&B)X X (S-/* , *)Z5tA B 5C5fA *Tq(S-QBC4as .10)(E5L`IBL-#4/* Z 5+. BC')')(+* ? -QB 5+*5tA[*2z5lB 5f0c5+. (ED')(+.3, -Q2-/.1JU2 . `jj(+Z)*1(^q EEF. ` F0 4/* .1(:j(+Z)*1(8E.3`8F0 4/*;shmsB J[Z`S- J ZC- J3X)2".1J-V2c2[0 * J[.:9}~\^* (+*r(+* 5t0 (fJ *)Z- J!moBC(lB)X (lB ' A{[R .3`5tA[*- i')0 X J * Z 0 ZLXCij*1Jc5 \- 5fA .10a582[0 W 2z5lB Ja5f-/B 5S- J3X5fA *(f0 4/*!.3`N4QB\w.1( B JaD 'U4QB 032- W 4 *(+*)BL2 .1JU- J3XL2 9 TqA *eXC(+.10)J[ZC2.3`B ')'[*LBC4@5+. (+* `f4 *)?Y5I275tA[*X (S-/* ,3B J ?c*L2. `)5fA *B ' ' * 4V4QB Ja5 9 Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (16) ¡q¢ £¥¤ ¦)¦[£ §#§/¤ ¨c©ª¢3¤ «¬S®#§/£ « ¯7® ° ®#§ ±O² ® ©³8´:µ·¶ ¸1¶ ¹ º »¼¬+´1½ ¾}£ ½f¿¤ ¨ £ ¨c©}¤C¨ «Àj¤C¨ «L¤[©l´ ½EÁÂèÅÄƲ)¨[ÇY©f® ´1¨ÉÈ £3¬+´1½+£©f¢ £ ¯F´ ²)½E© ´ ¬>Ê«:µ ¯Ë® ° ®#§Ì ² «LÍ £1ÎÏ8£ § ¢U®&¤ ¨[«Ð® ©Ñ¤LÒeÑ"® ©f¢ « ½l¤[Ñ&¨]´1¨ Ó Ô µ Ó º1µl¶ »)º »:µ ÕÖ ×1Ø+×)ÙLÒ Î ÚtÖ[× ÚfÖ Û Ø+Ü!ÝOÞUÛ Úoßlà Ø8áO×CÒzÚ+à1ØlÙ[ÚfÛ à1âà3ß ã}àLÒcÒ ×CÒcÒÛ/à âÙ â Üeã}×1ØfäÙ â[×1âcÚjåæâ çÆÞ)â[èYÚSÛ/à1â·éSÝ8Þ Û Ú&ê8à:ë ìUí Ôî ï ð ë ïLñ ëlò ó ñ ó)ôOÑÙ)Ò ßSÛ#õ/× Ü ö ×3ß+à1Ø+×ÚfÖ ×÷Fà1Þ ØEÚà3ßhø[Ü:ëOÏFÛQÒzÚtØSÛ èYÚ ù Þ[ÜLú ×1û Ï8× õ ÖUÛüû ý3ÙLõ Þ Û#â3úþÚfÖ ×ÿÒ[ÞUÛ Ú$ß+à1ØÚfÖ × )Þ) Ø [àCÒ ×CÒ à ß ç Þ)ØSÛVÒ ÜCÛ/èYÚSÛ/à1â ÙLÒ·á@Ò ë ñUï û ï)ï)ï î ûOÒÛ â èc×à1â ï1ð ë ï)ñ ëlò ó ñ órÚfÖ × Ò × ècà1â Ü Ò[Þ Û ÚÑÙL Ò × â Ü Û â úrö × ß+à1Ø+×ÉÚtÖ[×÷ à1Þ)ØEÚ à ß@ø[Ü:ë:÷7Û ý Û#õ ù Þ[ÜLú ×1û)ÏO× õ#Ö Û Ù â ÜÚtÖ[×ÚfÖ Û#Ø+ÜÉÒ[ÞUÛ ÚCÑ^ÙL Ò ×1â ÜCÛ â3ú$ö × ßlà Ø+×ÚtÖ[× ÷ à1Þ)ØEÚ à ß@ø[Ü:ëÏ ÛVÒzÚfØSÛ/èYÚNù Þ Ü)ú ×:ûoÏO× õ#Ö Ûüû ÚfÖ ×1Ø+×3ß+à1Ø ×:û Ñ"Ö ×1âÚtÖ[× ÚÃÑhà$Ò[Þ Û ÚIÒ&Ñ^×1Ø+ × ×1â[Ü Û â ú ö ×3ß+à1Ø+×ÚEÑhà Ü Û ßbß+×1Ø+× âcÚN÷ à1Þ)ØEÚIÒ&ßlà Ø ÜCÛ ßEß+×1Ø+×1âcÚOØ+×Cõ#Û/× ý ×CÒ ûâ ×CÛ ÚfÖ ×1Ø ÚfÖ × jØ+Ü)×1Ø@åEåáFÞ õ/ × !÷ ã÷ Ñ"ÛVõ#õ ècà äj×Û âaÚlà$ÚfÖ × Û/èYÚfÞ)Ø+×râ à Ø8à1â ÚtÖ[×× ý ×!à3ßNÑ"Û ÚtÖ[Ü1ØlÙ[Ñ^ÙCõCà3ß ÚfÖ ×Ò ×)ècà â ܪÒ[ÞUÛ ÚÑhà1Þ õ Ü ö3ÙCØ7ÚfÖ ×ßSÛ#õ#Û#â3úà ßFÚfÖ ×ÚfÖ Û Ø+ÜnÒ[ÞUÛ Útë ÝN× ècà1â ÜCõ LûNà â ï3Ô ë ïLñ ëlòYó ñ ó:û}ÚtÖ[× Ù ×Cõ#õQÙCâcÚ@Ñ"Û ÚtÖ[Ü1Ø+× Ñ Ö[×1Ø Ò × ècà1â Ü ÷7Û ý ÛVõ ÝOÞ Û Útû Ñ"Ö ×1âÚfÖ ×ÚfÖ Û#Ø+ÜÒ[Þ Û Ú ÑÙ)ÒÙCõ#Ø+×LÙ Ü ßSÛVõ/×)Ü à â ï1ð ë ïLñ ëlòYó ñ ó:ûßSÛ#õVÛ â3ú à3ß ÚfÖ × ÚfÖ Û#Ø+ÜÿÒ[Þ Û Ú )ØSÛ/à Ø>Ú+àÐÚtÖ[× ÑÛ ÚfÖ Ü1ØlÙÑÙCõ1à3ßËÚfÖ ×%Ò × ècà1â ÜnÒ[Þ Û Ú@Ñ^à1ÞUõ/Üö ×· Ù Ø+à)èc×)Ü Þ)ØlÙCõ Û#ØfØ+×Lú ÞUõQÙ ØSÛ Ú rÙCâ Ü·Û Ú@Ñhà1Þ õ Üâ à3Ú ö3Ù ØËÚtÖ[× ßfÛVõ#Û â ú à3ßËÚfÖ × ÚfÖ Û#Ø+Ü Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (17) !#"$ % & ('*) +,"- .!0/1"2/435)76 8 & 9:)!+ .; < =) + > ? >A@ 0B&C @ CD"$ E/ 3F HG !I IJ K) 6 L3M E6 K A , < '5"N M97 "O/A /A3HK A/ .7J$6P F3 .Q)!+ >!R >A@ SBTC @ C!'&"O)! 3M.U97 V W X F K AY <3M/ P J 91/4 & .ZG[J\6P L3F H+ Y] ^ < _)!+ > R >A@ 0B&C @ C`G 6K)!K a 6K)! bc/438)!K. ^)!+ >7? >A@ 0B&C @ C H+ & 9:) + .
d A 1 M. A ' D & 9:)!+ . < e"2/A f H+ K 4 g 9T h)76ig ! bj/4+ !+:
/4+ . bj/4+ .A/ 0) IJ H+lk + 9T P M) + / + . < HK. < m"O/A K Y / K.4 H+7Y K 4 n K)!0/ )!+ ) 6 g )4 : & 4 : 1 )!+ / + .
g ! bj/
+ !+: o H+lk + 9T P M)
+A'1 !K 76K)!V (' DK 43F M 6(9 3%/A Hbc .W"2/A
.4 6I6K !K !+: p F+qG )7 r s < P r/
+ . 6 K)
bt 7/ =g )4 H+: )76*u< M "
+
W cK. !wv v<xp <3 WyQz|{hz + )
e cK.
A}~}=v vIv xp <3 B
z {hz 9:)!bc 4 $ F+: K)f g< M9T V G [ < c~P %/431z)
I 4 ! K .U F+
/4g g K <9 %/ P H+ YD D60/<9T 7/43
g )4 1 )!+ / W"O
3L
/A X3%/ ")76
3M/
+ .! ~ /
g<g
3L%/
+[ s6K)!I P 6 4 t !9:)!+: K !+: P )!+
"$ < F3
K 43 J< H+ Y g )
+- j60)43FM) "$ H+ Yg K 9: <. !+[ 91/A & 3M/ "H
Under order XXIII Rule 1 CPC
i. Mangi Lal vs. Radha Mohan AIR 1930 Lahore 599(2) - it was held that Rule 1 of Order XXIII CPC pertains to the permission to withdraw the suit with a liberty to institute the fresh suit after the first one has been withdrawn, however, this Rule cannot be read, so as to bar the suit, which has already been instituted before the other suit has been abandoned or dismissed. This Rule applies to Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (18) suits instituted after the withdrawal or abandonment of previous suit.
ii. Ram Mal vs. Upender Datt AIR 1928 Lahore 710 - in this case the situation was that the during the pendency of the suit, another suit for injunction was filed, however, subsequently the first suit was withdrawn. Then it was held that the situation does not fall within the provisions of Order XXIII of Rule 1 CPC.
iii.M.A. Faiz Khan vs. Municipal Corporation of Hyderabad AIR 1998 Andhra Pradesh 414 - the ratio of reasonings was that when the second suit was filed before obtaining the permission in the first suit, it is curable procedural irregularity. In fact, grant of permission takes away bar of res judicata embodied in Section 11 of CPC, it was held that second suit was maintainable.
iv.Ammini Kutty vs. George Abraham AIR 1987 Kerala 246 - while relying upon AIR 1973 SC 643; it was held that the permission for withdrawal of the suit can be granted even after the institution of the second suit and not only when such suit is to be instituted. Where the suit is allowed to be withdrawn, it should be regarded as having never been brought; grant of permission serves no other purpose like providing for the start of a new point of limitation or giving rise to a new cause of action.
v. Girdharilal vs. The Chairman, Bhakra Beas Management Board AIR 1935 Punjab and Haryana 219 - while accepting the reasonings given in AIR 1930 Lahore 599 and AIR 1928 Lahore 710; it was held that second suit is maintainable when the second suit was filed on the same allegations for the same relief before the first suit was withdrawn.
vi.P.A. Muhammed vs. The Canara Bank AIR 1992 Kerala 85 - when the earlier suit was dismissed, as not best and subsequent suit was pending at the time of Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (19) dismissal of the first suit, neither the bar under Rule 1(4) of Order XXIII CPC is attracted nor it would create a bar of res judicata.
vii.Harchint Singh Malik vs. Smranjit Singh Malik 77(1999) Delhi Law Times 570 - when the cause of action and the relief in the second suit is not same, as cause of action and relief claimed in the first suit, it cannot be said that the subject matter in the subsequent case was the same as in the earlier eviction petition, whole dealing with the Delhi Rent Control Act.
viii.Vallabh Das vs. Dr. Madanlal AIR 1970 SC 987 - when the cause of action and relief claimed in the second suit are the same as the cause of action and relief claimed in the first suit, the second suit cannot be considered to have been brought in respect of the same subject matter as the first suit.
ix.Manohar Lall vs. Narain Dass AIR 1987 Delhi 226 - the Court may permit to withdraw th suit, if there are sufficient grounds shown, with a liberty to file the fresh suit on the same cause of action, however, this discretion has to be exercised by the Court judiciously.
Under Order II Rule 2 CPC/ Section 10 CPC i. Escorts Construction Equipment Ltd. vs. Action Construction Equipment Pvt. Ltd. AIR 1999 Delhi 73 - in the previously instituted suit, an issue of jurisdiction was raised, however, it would not be a ground for not permitting the defendant to invoke the provisions of Section 10 in subsequent case nor the provisions of Order II of Rule 2 CPC would circumscribe or limit the operation of Section 10 of CPC.
ii. C.L. Tandon vs. Prem Lal Singh Rawat AIR 1978 Delhi 221 - it was held that for the applicability of Section 10 of CPC are :-
Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (20)
(a)the matter in issue should be substantially the same in the two suits;
(b)the previously instituted suit should be pending in the same Court in which subsequent suit is brought; and
(c)the two suits should be between the same parties, Ld. Counsel for appellant highlighted that the first suit was pending before the Court of Ld. Civil Judge, Delhi.
Whereas, the other suit was filed, at that material time before the Court of Ld. Additional District Judge, Delhi.
iii.Sukh Ram Dass vs. Ramesh Chand Jain 67(1997) Delhi Law Times 289 - the first suit was withdrawn without liberty to file a fresh suit, as Ld. Sub-Judge had no pecuniary jurisdiction, in that eventuality the second suit is not barred, as such kind of omissions should not come in a way of substantial justice.
iv.Manohar Lal vs. Narain Das & Another 32(1987) Delhi Law Times 215 - while considering the contentions of Section 11 as well as Order XXIII of Rule 1(4) CPC in an eviction petition under Delhi Rent Control Act, it was held that when the petition was dismissed as withdrawn on the basis of compromise, the matter had not been heard and decided on merits. Since, there is no decision of the Court on previous order based on compromise, it does not bar the second application, as order did not operate as res judicata.
(!M8 !K A K4 :S (q KA&!I7 PM 7 w FSn *A¡FA ¢~PM4¡!£ ¤ I 7 UP%¥ [P¡ ¦ K ¤< PH F7¥A ! %: ¤ ( § ¨N<L¡M 4 K<© % PH ¥ tªj K!PM4¡Q!ZK<©:!K( ¢~ t ¡FM : Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (21) «P¬FS®n¯ ° ±«P¬L°M² ³t¯ ´ ² ® µ<¬ ¯¬F¶·¯ ´ ²t± ²A¸4\¹&ºA»4¼½¸ ¶ ³ ¬ ¯E¾2¸A® ² ¿ À ² ÁT¯K² ³W« KÂ!Ãį ´ ² ¸ À<À ² °L%¸ ¶[¯(¯0ÂrÀ<°%¸ Á:²UÂ!¶j«P¬L°M²W¯ ´ ²DK² Á:Â!K³  «eÀ<K²7Å<¬M µ ®$® µ<¬ ¯Æ¬F¶f® µ À<À Â!I¯ Â7« ® µ Ç ®&²<È!µ ²!¶[¯e® µ<¬ ¯S® É:Ê~´<¬FK³ ° ±AË Â ¶Ì®&Á7 µ[¯ ¬F¶:±ÍÂ7«_®&² Á:Â!¶ ³^® µ<¬ ¯X³A¸ ¯0²<³^Î!Ï ÉHÐ ¼AÉS¹TºA»<ºÍ¾O µ<°M³ K² « ° ² ÁT¯Ñ¯ ´7¸ ¯Ò¬ ¯;¾2¸A® ¶  ¯]Ãc²!K² ° ± ¸ ®1¬HÃWÀ<° ² ® µ<¬ ¯Ó«KÂ! À ²! Ãj¸ ¶ ²!¶:¯|¬F¶lÔÕµ<¶ ÁT¯P¬MÂ!¶Ç µ[¯2¸A°L®&ÂÖ«KÂ! À Â4®:®&²4®:®1¬ Â!¶AË׸A®_¯ ´ ² ¸4À À ²4°F%¸4¶:¯h´7¸ ³QÅ7¸4°Hµ ² ³U¯ ´ ²_® µ<¬ ¯5 «wØ×® Éw¹ Ë0¹&Ð Ð&Ù Úe«KÂ!e³ ² Á7K²<²  «À Â4®:®&²4®:®1¬ Â!¶nÙÛÃj¸ ¶ ³A¸ ¯KÂ!I±Ü¬H¶lÔ µ ¶ ÁT¯P¬M ¶ ¸ ¶ ³,® µ<¬ ¯¾O¸A® ¸4°%®& Å7¸A°Hµ ²<³ «KÂ!ÒØ ® É\¹ Ý Ð[ÙÞÚm«0 \¯ ´ ² K²4°F¬M² «Ó «À ²! Ãj¸4¶ ²!¶[¯ ¬F¶lÔÕµ<¶ ÁT¯P¬MÂ!¶ ËƯ ´ ² K²7«KÂ!K²(Ëe¯ ´ ²,¯ ´<¬HK³q® µ<¬ ¯Â «=Ð!Ý ÉHÐA»!É0¹&ºA» ºÜ¾O¸A® «P¬L°M² ³ «KÂ!;K²4®n¯KÂ!0¸ ¯P¬ Â!¶ß «ÓÀ Â4®:®&²4®:®1¬ Â!¶ß¸A®¾O² °L ¸ ®Z«KÂ! À ²! Ãj¸ ¶ ²!¶:¯ ¬H¶lÔ µ ¶ ÁT¯P¬M ¶AÉ[Ê~´ ²_K² °F¬ ²7«4Â7«oÀ Â4®:®&²4®:®1¬ Â!¶2¾2¸A®-¶  ¯  ¶<° ± ¸ Å7¸4¬L°%¸ Ç<° ² ¸ ¯Ò¯ ´ ² ¯ ¬FÃc² Â7«Ò«P¬F° ¬F¶7à ¯ ´ ² ® µ<¬ ¯] ¶ Î á(ÉHÐ(Ï É0¹&º »4¼8Ç µ:¯|«KÂ!p¾2¸4¶:¯- «$¸4Ç7¸ ¶ ³ Â!¶ Ãc² ¶:¯|Â7«cK²4°F¬M² «OÂ7« À Â4®:®&²4®:®1¬ Â!¶AË ¾N´ ¬MÁ7´ ¾O¸A®¸ Å7¸4¬F°M¸ Ç<° ²_¾-¬ ¯ ´_¯ ´ ² ¸4À À ²4°F%¸4¶:¯ ¸ ¯ ¯ ´7¸ ¯Ãj¸ ¯K²!P¬%¸A° ¯P¬HÃc²!Ë!¯ ´ ²qØpµ<° ² ÎÜÂ7«iâjK³<²!=ãIã5ä|åhäÄÁ: Ãc²4® ¬F¶:¯KÂ;Â!À ² 0¸ ¯P¬MÂ!¶8¸ ¶ ³;¯ ´7¸ ¯ ¬L®Ü¾N´:±AËi¯ ´ ²\¬L®:® µ ²Ò¶ Â!É|Ïs¾O¸A® ³<² Á ¬M³<² ³UÀ KÂ!À ²!P° ±QÇ:±c¯ ´ ²jÊ~P¬M¸4°1äÂ!µ<I¯ÞÉ1Ê~´ ²Q¸ À<À ² °L%¸ ¶[¯A«P¬L°M² ³ ¯ ´ ²q®&²<Á:Â!¶ ³ ® µ<¬ ¯Â!¶ Î!Ï ÉHÐ ¼AÉS¹TºA»<ºq¸4¶ ³m¬ ¯ ¾2¸ ®r¾$¬ ¯ ´ ³ 0¸ ¾N¶  ¶WÐ7æÆÉÐ »!É0¹&ºA»<º ¾$¬ ¯ ´X¸ °F¬ Ç ²!I¯I±N¯0«P¬L°M²« K²4® ´W® µ<¬ ¯ÞË4´  ¾O²7Å ² Ë ¶ Âs® µ ¬ ¯i¾O¸A®f«P¬L°M² ³s¸ «I¯0² ×Ð7æoÉHÐA»!É0¹TºA»<º(É!Ê~´ ²Ü¯ ´<¬HK³s® µ<¬ ¯~«P¬L°M² ³ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (22) ç è é êAëHéAì!ë0í&î ì<îfïOðAñQò<óPôMç!ó4õKç õ ö ÷føKç!ó ùcð4ú ò ÷!ó ùfôLñ:ñ1ô ç!ècø óKç ù õ ö ÷Qû×ç!ü óIõ ý[õ ö ÷ óK÷7øKç!óK÷(ý ô õ þ1ð4è è ç õÆÿ ÷ õK÷!ó ùc÷ XðAñcò óKç<þ:÷ !ü ó0ðAú ôFó óK ÷ ü ú%ð óPô õ Aý7ðAñ õ ö ÷Xð ò ò ÷4úF%ð4è:õeç ü ö[õÆè ç7õAõKç ö7 ð ÷ ø ôLúM ÷ Wõ ö ÷ ñ ü ô õ×ò óPô ç!óiõKçDõ ö ÷ ï$ô õ ö !ó0ð ïOð4ú4ç7øhõ ö ÷qñ&÷ þ:ç è Eñ ü<ô õ ÿ ü[õwõ ö ÷ ñ ü ô õ!ï2ðAñ øPôFúM ÷ _ç!èUé!êAëHéAì!ë0íTîAì<îEò<óPôMç!óeõ0çõ ö ÷Uï$ô õ ö ó0ð ï2ðAú ç ø õ ö ÷Dñ&÷ þ:ç è ñ ü<ô õ ý7õ ö ÷!óK÷7øKç!óK÷!ý õ ö ÷ pü<ú ÷ ç7 ø c ó ÷! ó 4 û hû óK÷ ð ï$ô õ ö c ó ÷ ó pü<ú ÷ í û hû þ:ç!ùc÷4ñ ôHè[õ0ç ç ò ÷!ó0ð õ ô ç!èA ë ð ñnõPú Aý õ ö ÷ ç!ò ÷!ó0ð õPôH è ÌóK÷ úFô ÷7øWç7øjõ ö ÷ñ&÷<þ:ç! è ñ ü ô õ ð õK ÷ ëH"é !AëSíTîAì<î ð è õ ö ÷ õ ö ôH ó ñ ü<ô #õ Að õK ÷ é êAëHéAì!ë0í&î ì<îsð4óK÷mþ:ç è þ úHü7ñ1ô ÷ ú õ ö ÷qñ[ð4ùc÷(ýoõ ö ÷!óK÷7øKç!óK÷!ýõ ö ÷ õ ö<ôF ó \ñ ü<ô õ ô%ñ8ÿ7ð4ó óK ÷ Äÿ$ ;ñ ü þ7ö\ñnõ0ð õ ü:õKç ó Ñò<óK ç <ôLñ1ô ç!è ñsð è õ ö ÷ óK÷ ô%ñ è ç ø úMð ïÄç!ó×ôLúFM ÷ ð4úLô õ ôHèQõ ö ÷ ø ôF è ôF è AñXóK÷7õ ü ó è ÷ Üÿ$ õ ö &÷ %~óPô%ð4ú!û×ç!ü óIõ 'ë èrç! ó <÷!ó*õKç øKç!óIõPô ø _õ ö ÷sþ:ç è:õK÷!è:õPôMç è ñ ý(õ ö ÷ óK÷Añ ò ç! è ÷!è:õSñÌè ç(ë,í (ý ð è êZö ð ÷tóK÷ úFô ÷ ·ü ò ç!èÌõ ö ÷ øKç úLMç ï-ôH è fþ1ð ñ&÷ú%ð 'ï )Ûò óK÷ þ: ÷ <÷!è:õS+ñ *-,
(a)N.V. Srinivasa Murthy vs. Mariyamma (dead) by Proposed LRs 2005 VI AD (S.C.) 101 - while dealing with Order VII Rule 11 as well as Order II Rule 2 CPC; it was held that non disclosure of cause of action or suit is barred by limitation, the plaint is liable to be rejected.
(b)K.S. Bhoopathy vs. Kokila AIR 2000 S.C. 2132 - neither the plaintiff can abandon a suit or a part of the suit reserving to himself a right to bring a fresh suit not Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (23) the defendant can insists that the plaintiff must be compelled to proceed with the suit and the plaintiff may in the circumstances mentioned in Sub Rule 3 be permitted by the Court to withdraw from the suit with liberty to sue afresh on the same cause of action. Such liberty being granted by the Court enables the plaintiff to avoid the bar in Order II Rule 2 and Section 11 CPC.
In fact, the appellant/plaintiff could not produce application disclosing the reason for withdrawal of the earlier suit or reasons/grounds for permission to file fresh suit, in order to assess the formal defect, if any.
(c)Kamal Kishore Saboo vs. Nawabzada Humayun Kamal Hasan Khan 2001 II AD (Delhi) 635 - the second suit for specific performance of contract was not held to be maintainable, as the plaintiff could implead suit for specific performance of contract in the first suit for permanent injunction, as there was same cause of action. In the present case, the appellant had initially filed original suit No. 151/89 seeking permanent injunction and during the pendency of original suit, the subsequent suit was filed (from which the present appeal has emerged). On the basis of same sale deed and relief claimed in the subsequent suit, was the same relief claimed in the previous suit.
(d)Satish Khosla vs. Eli Lilly Ranbaxy Ltd. 1998 Rajdhani Law Reporter 180 - the issue was under
contempt of Courts Act and it was held that if a person does not truthfully disclose that he has not yet been granted interim injunction in the previous pending case and is granted interim injunction in the second suit then it is fraudulent concealment and party is guilty of contempt.
(e)Holy Health and Educational Society (Regd.) vs. Delhi Development Authority 1999 IV AD (Delhi) 552 -
concealment and suppression of material facts in the plaint requires dismissal of the suit and plaintiff is not entitled for discretionary relief, while assessing the Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (24) application of injunction under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC.
.0/21 /-35476 8$8:9;8$8 <59 4>= ? @BADC E 6;F G$? 4$= 9 4$=DC ? 4H8I? @ J ? =LK =MK 9N8OCQP 9 8 R S K 6 E 9NG$? <59T= ?U=LK 9TG$?"4 G F-V 8OCQ? 4(=LK 6 =B=LK 9UW ADCX6 F YZ? V A =[K 6 8 4 ? =[\;C E 9"4N6"4$] A 9 6 8:? 4 C^4 \ 8_C^4 ` 6"Aa6 \;Aa6"b KH8T1 . 6"4 P c"de? @ f V P \;<59 4$= P 6 = 9 P_d g /-d h /ih d d dj9 k G$9"b$= A 9"b A ? P V Gl=LC ? 47? @ =MK 9 8m=a6 =LV$= ?"A ] b A ? E CX8OCQ? 4H8n? @poZV FQ9 hq? @r35A P 9"A S S Y `sYt6;4 P oZV FQ9 uv? @w35A P 9 Ayx x S S S Y `sY RU=MK 9 A 9 @ ? A 9 R C =zA 9 { V C^A 9;8 P;C|8:G VH8$8OC ? 4NC^4_=MK 9&F|CX\"K$=}? @~A 9 G$?"A P0R;6 85=LK 9NW ADCQ6;F YZ? V A =B@DC^F 9 CX8qJ 9 @ ? A 9<590/ S @a9 9"F C =&4 9 G$9;8$8>6;A ]= ?A 9"b A ? P V G$9=LK 9 b Aa6 ] 9 AG FX6;VH8:9 ? @78 V C =T'?0/ u g u h"g /-d";/au:. .0R=LK 9?"A P 9 A b 6 8$8:9 P? 4d cB/-d /au:. H.nC-4w8 V C = '?0/u g"u .6"4 Pb Aa6 ] 9 A G FQ6"VH8:9(? @08 V C =}?0/ g Oc Md 1 /id /au:. H.Ni Extract of the Prayer Clause of Suit No. 151/ 25.07.1989 :-
"11.The suit is valued for purposed of court-fee at Rs. 1,100/- for Decree of possession and at Rs. 130/- for Decree of Permanent Injunction. Separate court-fee has been paid on each relief.
12.Relief :- The Plaintiff respectfully prays :-
(i) The Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to pass a Decree of Possession in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant in respect of Plot No. 202 Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (25) (old) and Municipal No. A-19 measuring 200 sq. yards in the Residential colony known as Acharya Niketan, in Village Kotla, Patpar Ganj, Delhi-92 as per site plan annexed shown as red.
(ii) The Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to pass a Decree of Permanent Injunction thereby restraining the defendant, his agents and servants from raising construction in any manner on Plot No. 202, new Municipal No. A-19(new) in Village Kotla, Patpar Ganj, Delhi-92".
Extract of Order passed on 04.08.1989 in Suit No. 151/25.07.1989 :-
"04.08.1989 Present : Counsel for plaintiff.
File is taken up today on his application under section 151 CPC for withdrawal of his suit. His statement has been recorded as under :-
Statement of Sh. O.P. Khadaria, Counsel for the plaintiff.
"As the defendants, are already in possession and I have to file a suit along with consequential relief, hence, my present suit may be dismissed as withdrawn with permission to file a fresh suit on the same cause of action".
RO&AC SJIC : DELHI
04.08.1989
ORDER :-
In view of the above statement the counsel for the plaintiff, the suit of the plaintiff is dismissed as withdrawn with the permission to file the fresh suit on the same cause of action. File is consigned to record room".
Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (26) Extract of the Prayer Clause of Suit No. 574/ 03.08.1989 :-
"That the value of the suit for the purposes of pecuniary jurisdiction has been fixed as Rs. 80,000/- since the present rate prevailing in the area is Rs. 400/- per sq. yards and the demised plot is measuring 200 sq. yards and further for the purposes of permanent injunction the suit is valued at Rs. 130/- and proper court fee of Rs. 3125/- and of Rs. 13/- is fixed on the plaint for the two distinct reliefs claimed in the present suit.
It is, therefore, most respectfully prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to pass a decree in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants :-
(i)directing the defendants no. 1 to 3 to restore back the peaceful vacant and physical possession of the demised plot bearing Municipal No. A-19, Acharya Niketan, Mayur Vihar Chowk, Delhi-
110092, more correctly shown in the red in the site plan attached to the plaint.
(ii)permanently restraining the defendants not to cause any further construction over the demised plot and not part with any possession of any premises constructed over the said plot to any third person or to alienate the same or to create any charge over the said plot, in favour of any third person".
5z$ ( "a D ¢¡mM£ ¤ ¥¦ § ;¨-£ DQ ¦ © Mª ¡ £ «-¦Lª ¡: $" ¤¡ £ ¬¤ ¤#"® ¯-°"±;¯a²:³ ´ ³#; ¤-µLª ¶MªH- ¤#¡ £ ¤ a ¤U°"· ¯-° ´ ¯a²:³ ´ ³0¸H X¡«" " "$;Lª 0-Lª _¡: $ ¤p¡ £ M¸ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (27) ¹ º"»|¼Qº ½ ¾ ½ ¿ º À ¹ º ºw¾ ½~Á ¾;Â$Â:º;Â$ÂO¼ ¾ ÃÄ Å Â Æ º º à Á ¹aÅ Ç º ¿§¼^Ã_ÈMÄ º ½ ¾ ¹Lɾ ½~É+Å"à ¿ Å È ¾ ¹ Ç ¼-ÃÊË Ã ÀlÈD¼Q¾"Ã Ì Í Ä ¼|»QºjÎ Å;»^Ë ¼-à Ï&ÈLÄ º Â Ë ¼ ÈÅ Â Ð Â Ñ¬Ò ÌÓÒlÔ Ô>ÕÖÆ Ë>È ¼^õÈLÄ ºvÈLÄ ¼^¹ ¿ Â Ë ¼ ÈMÌrÈLÄ ºÅ;Á Á º;»^»XÅ;Ã$ÈyÄ ÅH¿ Á ¹aÅ Ç º ¿r½ ¾ ¹}¹ º;ÂmÈ ¾ ¹aÅ ÈL¼ ¾ Ã5¾ ½sÁ ¾ Â$Â:º;Â$ÂO¼Q¾"Ã+Å"à ¿7½ ¾ ¹}Á º"¹LÉ+Å"à º"Ã$È ¼-ÃÊ×Ë Ã ÀlÈL¼ ¾ ÃÍÄ ¼^» ºØÎ Å »-Ë ¼^à ÏqÈLÄ ºµÂ Ë ¼ È5½ ¾ ¹7ÈMÄ ºvÁ Ë ¹LÁ ¾;Â:º ÂÙ¾ ½ Ê×Ë ¹D¼|Â:¿"¼ ÀlÈL¼ ¾ Ã+Å Â Ð Â Ñ ÚHÔ0Ì-Ô Ô Ô:ÕÖ ½LË ¹ ÈLÄ º"¹MÌOÈLÄ ºNÂ:º À$¾"à ¿TÂ Ë ¼ È ÍIÅ Â ½D¼^»Qº ¿yÆ º ½ ¾ ¹ ºeÈLÄ ºeÛZ¾"Ë ¹ È[¾ ½ Ü ¿0ÑBÛ¼ Î ¼|» Ý Ë ¿ Ï º0Ì Þ'º;»-Ä ¼HÅ"à ¿NÈLÄ º ÈLÄ ¼-¹ ¿#Â Ë ¼ È_ÍßÅ ÂؽD¼^»Qº ¿àÆ º ½ ¾ ¹ ºÈMÄ º Û~¾ Ë ¹ Ȭ¾ ½áÜ ¿0ÑTÞ~¼|ÂmÈL¹D¼QÀlÈ Ý Ë ¿ Ï º0ÌBÞº"»-Ä ¼"âMÄ ¾ Íߺ Î º ¹MÌã»XÅ È º ¹ä¾ à Ì"¾ ÃUÈMÄ ºº Î ºN¾ ½ À Ä Å"à ÏHº ¾ ½ Á º À Ë ÃH¼XÅ"¹ ÇÊ×Ë ¹D¼XÂ:¿"¼QÀlÈD¼ ¾ à ¼-ÃåÈMÄ º Ç º Å"¹Ò:æ æ ç ¼ ÈèÍIÅ Â ÈL¹aÅ"ÃHÂm½ º ¹L¹ º ¿wÈ ¾wÈMÄ º§ÛZ¾ Ë ¹ È ¾ ½ Ü ¿ Ñ'Û¼ Î ¼^»BÝ Ë ¿ Ï º Ì~Þ'º;»-Ä ¼ é«Æ Ë$È ¾ Ã7ÈLÄ º&É+Å È º ¹D¼QÅ;»H¿ Å È º ¿jÔ ê}Ñ-Ô Ú ÑaÒ:æ Ú æ0Ì ÈLÄ ºeÂ:º À$¾ à ¿NÂ Ë ¼ ÈãÍIÅ Â Á º"à ¿"¼-Ã Ï Æ º ½a¾"¹ ºeÈLÄ ºeÛZ¾ Ë ¹ È[¾ ½ Ü ¿ ÑãÛ¼ Î ¼^»OÝ Ë ¿ ÏHº0Ì Þ'º"»^Ä ¼ Å"à ¿ ÈLÄ ºvÈLÄ ¼^¹ ¿#Â Ë ¼ È(Íߊ¶Á º à ¿;¼-à ÏàÆ º ½ ¾ ¹ º¶ÈLÄ º#Û~¾ Ë ¹ Èj¾ ½ Ü ¿0Ñ ÞZ¼XÂmÈM¹Ó¼QÀlÈ;Ý Ë ¿ Ï º0Ì Þ'º"»^Ä ¼iÑ ëQÈ ¼|ÂIÅrÍߺ"»|»>Â:º È ÈD»Qº ¿j»XÅOÍ¢¾ ½B»XÅ;à ¿0Ì:ÈLÄ Å È ¼ ½ ÈLÄ ºßÊË ¹D¼|Â:¿;¼QÀlÈD¼Q¾ Ã5¾ ½ ÈLÄ ºTÛ~¾ Ë ¹ È0¼|Â+Æ Å"¹L¹ º ¿NÆ$Ç(»QÅ Í5Ì ¼ È"ÀOÅ"à à ¾ È ¹ º; ËH» È ¼-Ã$È ¾º ì º À Ë$ÈaÅ"ÆH»Qº§¿ º À ¹ º º0ÌBÈLÄ º"¹ º ½ ¾ ¹ º0Ì ÈLÄ º¦Å;Á Á º;»^»XÅ;Ã$È Ä ÅH¿ ¹ º Å;»|¼Qí$º ¿ ÈLÄ Å ÈÈLÄ º Î Å »-Ë º ½ ¾ ¹ ÈMÄ º Á Ë ¹LÁ ¾;Â:º;Ât¾ ½ Ê×Ë ¹D¼|Â:¿"¼ ÀlÈL¼ ¾ ÃÍIÅ Â Ð Â Ñ Ú Ô ÌiÔ Ô Ô>ÕÖ×ÌZÈLÄ ºØÂ:º À$¾ à ¿ Â Ë ¼ ÈMÌîÍÄ ¼QÀ Ä ÍIÅ ÂN½D¼^»Qº ¿¢Æ º ½ ¾ ¹ ºèÜ ¿ ÑZÛ¼ Î ¼^»ãÝ Ë ¿ Ï º0ÌîÞº"»-Ä ¼ã½ ¾ ¹IÁ º ¹LÉ+Å;à º Ã>È Å"à ¿ É+Å;à ¿ Å È ¾ ¹ Çn¼-ÃÊË Ã ÀlÈD¼Q¾"ÃáÍß¾"Ë »Q¿ïà ¾ È5Æ º¢É+Å ¼-Ã$ÈaÅ;¼^à Å"ÆH»Qº0Ì Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (28) ð ñ;ò óHô õaö"÷$õDô ø õLù ñ ò ó ú õµûaü"ðý ü;ò$ò:ñ;ò$òOú ü ÷ þßü"ó ôQÿ ÷ ü õ ñ ò ó òmõLú õMó>õañ û ü ð ò ó ú õ û ü ð ù ñ ð ñ û ü"ð ñ õMù ñ ú-÷ ×ó ÷ lõLú ü ÷ ö"ý ý ñ"ô^ôQö"÷$õ ù ö ÿ¬þú õMù ÿ ðaö þ÷eõLù ñyò:ñ $ü ÷ ÿyò ó ú õäþú õMù¬ö¦ô^ú ñ ð õ ø õ ünûDú^ôQñ¢özûLð ñ;ò ùÙò óHú õ ù ñ¢ö"ý ý ñ"ô^ôQö"÷$õ ù ö ÿÙþ«ú õLù ÿ ðaöOþ ÷ïù ñ ð ò:ñ $ü"÷ ÿò ó ú õ¬ü"÷ « þ ù ñ"÷õLù ñ¶õLù ú-ð ÿ#ò ó ú õNû ü ð ý ü ò$ò:ñ;ò$òOúQü ÷eþIö òö;ô^ð ñ ö ÿ øyûDú^ôQñ ÿ§ü ÷ ! " # ä þù ñ õLù ñ"ð ò ó$ ù% ú-ð& ó r ' òmõÓö;÷$$ ñ;ò( ö"ðÓòõLù ñrõLù ú-ð ÿpò óHú õ ) ù ñ(ü ð ÿ ñ ð"ÿ ö õ ñ ÿ ï ú-÷nò ó ú õ%'* ü + $,! .-/ 1Ó0 ö ò§ð ñ ý ð ü ÿ ó$$ ñ ÿù ñ"ð ñ"ú-÷ ö! ü 2 ñ + 3 ð ñ ûDôQñ l õDò¬õLù ö õßú-÷wûaö l õ s õMù ñ§ûDú^ôQñþßö òeõaö!4 ñ ÷wü"÷õLù ñ ö"ý ý ñ"ô^ôQö"÷$õ&X5 ò ö"ý ýHô^ú6O ö õLú ü ÷ ó ÷ ÿ ñ ðÙò:ñ l õDúQü"÷ $, 87:9;7 û ü ð þú õMù ÿ ðaö þßö;ô;ü û[õMù ñò ó ú õ~ö"÷ ÿ<$ø ü ð ÿ ñ ð ÿ ö õ ñ ÿ= > õLù ñzö"ý ý ñ;ô^ôXö;÷$õZþIö òý ñ ð?7 ' ú õ õ ñ ÿwõaüþú õMù ÿ ðaö þ#õLù ñnò ó ú õ/[ õLù úXò ð ñ $ ü"ð ÿ@0BA!C EDGF<HI J-B7 ( 3 ö;ô|ò:ü ð ñ ûDôQñ l õDò¦õLù ö õIõLù ñK+' ö ú-÷ò ó ú õ þIö òyý ñ"÷ ÿ"ú-÷$ L û ü ð ò:ü 5' ñzü õMù ñ ð ÿ ö õañ NQM õ«ú|ò ö;ôXò:üÙö;ý ý ö;ð ñ ÷$õ õLù ö õ ûDú|ôQñèþIö ò¦õaö!4 ñ ÷ ó ýü ÷õLù ñqö;ý ý ñ;ô^ôXö;÷$õ&X5 òèö"ý ýHô^ú6O ö õLú ü ÷ ûDú^ôQñ ÿÙý ðDúQü"ð~õ ü= O # P * ü þE õLù ñQ$ ü ÷ ô-óHòOú ü ÷RO ö;÷S ñ ÿ ðaöOþ ÷wõLù ö õõLù ñÙö"ý ý ñ"ô|ôXö"÷>õ ûDú-ðÓòmõDô ø s ûDú^ôQñ ÿ§õLù ñnõLù ú^ð ÿò ó ú õîûaü"ð ý ü ò$ò:ñ;ò$òOúQü ÷¢ö"÷ ÿT+ ' ö"÷ ÿ ö õ ü ð ø ú-÷. ó ÷$l õDúQü"÷ ü"÷U # ñ ûaü"ð ñ õLù ñ V ÿ D ú|òmõLðDú6l õ W ó ÿ L ñ 'D ñ;ô-ù ú ö"÷ ÿ Z òOú ( ' óHô õaö"÷ ñ ü óHòOô ø õLù ñ¶ö"ý ý ô^ú O ö õDúQü ÷þßö òØö ô|ò:üqûDú^ôQñ ÿó ÷ ÿ ñ ð ò:ñ l õDúQü"÷X $, Y7:9;7 û ü ð5þú õMù ÿ ðaö þßö;ôü û7õLù ñµò:ñ $ ü ÷ ÿò óHú õ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (29) Z\[>]6^ [_Za` bdc>e fg] h%`$f&ije k `jel6m$Z:i n m oqp r s p t s u v t v sxwy[$i `!z z$i!e 6`!o)f{Za` b|^)m!o$^)i!] }$i n=Z(] f?[ `!o~]6n i `f&m<g] e i~f?[$iRf?[ ] &n b c ] f&m |&ijbf&m ` f?] m om Qz mjb)b ijb)b ] m o `jo$n] o.Bc o ^#fg]6m oX)k ^)m of i!hz e` f?] o f&m Z+] f?[$n ` Z f?[$i b i ^)m!o$n b c>] f &m h%`!o n `$f&m k `!o$n z$i!?h%`!o$i of ] o.Bc o$^#fg]6m o Z(] f [ m c)f } ]lb c$`je ] $] o |f?[ `$f] f?[$i~z$i ?h]b)b ]6m o ]lb m!] o xf&m< iRf `!i o Z\[>] e6i Z(] f?[$n! ` Z(] o f?[$i b i ^)m!o$n b c ] f ~f?[$i i &i ^#f"bdm z$i!?h]lb)b ]6m!o ^)m c>e6n $i &i$?e i ^#f&i n ] o f?[$i f?[ ] &n b c>] f s f?[$i Z(]b i f?[$i ^$] &^ c hbf `!o$^)i b b c >ijbf f [$`$f f?[$i `!z z$i!e 6`!o)fyZ` b|`je &i ` n k~z &i z$`!&i nS[ i :h] o$nRf m Z+] f?[$n ` Z f?[$i<b i ^)m!o$nSb c ] f`!o$n=f mg] e6i f?[$iRf?[ ] &n<b c ] f:] oQe ] i cm f [ i b i ^)m!o$nb c>] f sNmn m c f/yf [ i` ^#fm Nf?[$i`!z z$i!el`!of+]b `!o [ ` bf i ` ^#f f?[ ` f Z(] f [ m c)f ` Z` ] fg] o f?]le f?[$i &m ?h%`je z$i!?h]lb)b ]6m!o=]bx ] }$i o|f&m=g] e i=f?[$iRf?[ ] &nb c ] f/ f [ i`!z z$i!el`!of [ ` b1` ^#f&i n@m o [$i!¡] h%` j] o `$fg]6m!o>b$\] o¢` n } `!o ^)i£f?[ ` ff?[$i z$i!?h]lb)b ]6m!o¤Zam!c e6n~$i=&i ¥ c$i bf i n|&m yg] e ] o ¦f?[$ixf?[ ] &nb c ] f s § o¡f&i ?hb¡m${¨{`!&^ [>] o)f{©ª] o$![«E` e ] ;«E`!o ] ¬$`je G`!h®«E`je ¯ ©c z ` °%`!o nSf?[$i±&i ` b m o ] o b=j] }$i!o~m e6` Z²n i ^$e6`!&i n¢] o m f?[$i!S^ ` b i <z &ijb i of i nqm od$i [ ` e m <f?[$i `jz z$ije `jo)f b c ijbf"b=f?[ `$f³] f:Z` bS`´z &m ^)i n!c `jeP] ?&i !c e6`!g] fµkm o<f?[$i z `jfm$f?[$i`!z z$i!el`!off?[ ` fNZ(] f [ m c)f(` Za`j] fg] o f?[$i&m ?h%` e Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (30) ¶ ·¹¸Bº$·!» ¼ ¶$½g»6¾!¿£¾!¿@À Á ¼)¾!¿$·ÂÀ º » ½/Ã+À Ä$Á£Å?»lÆ6Á ·±½?Ä$Á±½?Ä » Ç&·ÂÀ º>» ½/È ¾ ½?Ä$Á!ÇÉ(»lÀ Á à ½?Ä$Á¶!Ê Ê$ÁjÆ ¶j¿)½aÄ ¶>·<Ç&Á ÅgÆ6Á ¼#½ Á ·» ¿=Ä Á Çy½ Ä>» Ç&·QÀ º » ½ ¶!Ë ¾ º)½ ½?Ä$Á¤À½ ¶$½?º>Àa¾ Å>½?Ä$Á¡À Á ¼)¾ ¿$·¡À º » ½/Ì#ÍyÄ$Á Ç&Á$Å ¾!Ç&Á Ã)½?Ä$Á¡ÎPº Æ Á Ï ¾$ÅÐEÇ&· Á!ÇÑyÑÒÒÒyÓÔ;Ó · ¾ ÁjÀ¿$¾$½P¼)¾ ÕEÁ» ¿)½&¾=½?Ä$ÁÊ » ¼#½ º Ç&Á Ê ¶jǽ?» ¼ º ƶjÇgÆ Ö º ¿ · Á ǽ?Ä$Á ¼$» Ç&¼ º ÕÀ½ ¶!¿$¼)Á À$ÃK½?Ä$Á Ç&Á »À ¶ Ê Ç&¾ ¼)Á · º Ç ¶ Æ » Ç?Ç&Á ×!º ƶjÇg» ½Ö¤¾ Å Å?»lÆ » ¿$ס½ Ä Á¡½?Ä » Ç&·|À º » ½ªÊ Çg»6¾!Ç ½&¾¤½ Ä Á Å&¾ Ç?Õ%¶jÆÉ(» ½ Ä · Ç ¶ Éa¶jÆP¾ ÅE½?Ä$Á À Á ¼)¾ ¿$·´À º » ½¶ À ÉaÁjÆ ¶ À<½?Ä$Á ½?Ä » Ç&·KÀ º » ½É¶ ÀÅ ¾!ǦÇ&Á À½ ¾!Ç ¶$½g»6¾ ¿±¾ ÅØÊ$¾ À)À ÁjÀ)À »6¾ ¿1¶!¿$· ½?Ä$Á À Á ¼)¾!¿$· À º » ½ ɶ ÀÅ&¾ ÇÊ$Á Ç?Õ%¶j¿$Á ¿½{» ¿ ¸Bº ¿ ¼#½?» ¾ ¿ à · ÁjÀ Ê>» ½&Á|½?Ä ¶$½ ½?Ä$Á½?Ä » Ç&·UÀ º>» ½Ùɶ ÀRÅg» Æ6Á ·±Ë$Á Å&¾ Ç&Á½?Ä$Á@Ú · Ì:Û»À½ Ç"»6¼#½:Ü º$· × Á à ÛÁjÆ Ä » Ý ¶jÆ º » ¿$×ؽ?Ä$ÁÊ$Á ¼ º ¿>»¶!ÇÖa¸Bº Çg»lÀ ·!» ¼#½?» ¾ ¿¾$ÅPÎ{À$ÌOÞ ß Ã ß ß ßà/á Ë º½ ½?Ä$ÁâÀ Á ¼)¾!¿$·âÀ º » ½ Éa¶ ÀÙÝ ¶jÆ º Á ·³¶ ÀEÎ À$Ì Ï Ã Ï ß ß àIáBÌ ÐE¿Ø¶ À)À Á À)À ÕEÁ ¿)½¾ Å;½ Ä ÁÁ!¿)½g» Ç&ÁQÇ&Á ¼)¾ Ç&·R¾$ÅÊ Ç&ÁjÀ Á ¿½ ¶!Ê Ê$Á ¶jÆ ¶ ÀXÉaÁ!Æl¶ ÀdÇ&Á ¼)¾ Ç&· ¾ ÅS½?Ä$ÁdÍyÇg»6¶jÆ|Ó¾ º ǽ/Ã<¿$Á!» ½ Ä Á ǽ?Ä$Á ¶!Ê Ê$Á!Æ 6¶!¿)½P¿$¾!Ǫ½?Ä$Á~Ç&ÁjÀ Ê$¾!¿$· Á!¿)½"ÀxÄ ¶$Ý$Á~Ê Æ¶>¼)Á ·¾ ¿Åg» Æ Áx½?Ä$Á Ç&Á ¼)¾!Ç&·¾ ÅOÅg» Ç"À½GÀ º>» ½ã¾ ŪÊ$Á Ç?Õ%¶j¿$Á ¿)½y» ¿.¸Bº ¿ ¼#½g»6¾ ¿¡» ¿>À½g» ½?º)½&Á ·¦¾ ¿ ä å Ì ß æ Ì Ï ç Þjè¶j¿$·x» ½ ¶jÊ Ê$Á ¶!Ç"À:Å?Ç&¾ Õ£½?Ä$Á³¼)¾ ¿)½&Á ¿½?» ¾ ¿>À\¾$ÅOË$¾$½ Ä ½?Ä$ÁÀ »6· ÁjÀ$à ¶ À» Å Ã ½?Ä$Á ÖEÉaÁ Ç&Áé¿$¾ ½!½ Ä Á¡¼)¾ º ¿>À ÁjÆlÀ» ¿³À º$¼ ÄâÀ º>» ½ » ¿ À½?» ½?º)½&Á ·Ø» ¿³½?Ä$Á¤Ö$Á ¶!Ç Ï ç Þj覶!¿$·|» ¿³½?Ä$Á¦¶!Ë>À Á!¿$¼)Áؾ$ÅyÊ Çê¾ ¾ Å ¾ ÅOÀ º$¼ ĤÇ&Á ¼)¾ Ç&·¤¾ Å;À º » ½;ë¾ Ì ä>å Ì ß æ Ì Ï ç ÞjèjÃãÒ$· ¾Ø¿ ¾ ½ Åg» ¿$·é¶!¿Ö Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (31) ì í î ìï"ðjñ$ò)ó ô õXöaó!÷6ø!ù)ï_÷ ñ ï?ù$ó ì í î ú÷ì)ì ÷6ô ñ>ì ô û ï ù ó õ&ójì ü ô ñ$ý ó!ñ)ï"ìéï ù$ð$ïï ù óQï?ù ÷ õ&ýì í ÷ ï+÷lì î ð!õ?õ&ó ýî)þSÿPí ó ~ô û õ&ý ó õ ª÷ ñ$ò) ó ªì ó ò)ô!ñ$ýì í>÷ ïªöað ìâö(÷ ï?ù$ý!õ ð ö\ñö(÷ ï ù ï?ù$óxü$ó õ?ú÷ì)ì ÷6ô ñâô$ûOï?ù$ ó ô í õïãö+÷ ï?ùé ð l÷ î$ó õïµþï&ô¤ûg ÷ 6óð¡û?õ&ójì ù ì í ÷ ï Ùù$ô öa ó $ó õ ï?ù$óðjü ü$ ó ðjñ)ïaû? ÷ 6ó ý~ï?ù$óï?ù ÷ õ&ýUì í>÷ ï+ðý ð þ î$ó$û ô!õ&ó¤ï?ù$óö(÷ ï ù ý õ ð öa ð ô ûOï?ù$óì ó ò)ô ñ$ýì í ÷ ï û&ô õyú%ð!ñ ý ð$ï&ô õþ ÷ ñ Bí ñ ò#ï?÷ ô ñ ï?ù$ó ÿ í 6 ó xô$û õ&ý ó! õ öaô! í 6ýñ$ô ïGò)ô úEó ÷ ñï ôéï?ù$óRü ÷ ò#ï í õ&ó¦û&ô õ ûg ÷ ÷ ñ$ø¦ï?ù$óï?ù ÷ õ&ýì í ÷ ï;û&ô õ{õ&ó ìï ô!õ ð$ïg÷6ô ñéô û ü$ô ì)ì ójì)ì ÷6ô ñQúEó õ&ó þû&ô õï ù ó1õ&ó ð ì ô!ñ>ì|÷ ñxï ù óYì ó ò)ô ñ ýì í ÷ ï û&ô õGú%ðjñ$ý ð ï ô!õþ¡÷ !ñ Ií ñ$ò#ïg÷6ô!ñ¡÷ ñEï?ù$ó¤û&ô õ?úKô$û;ü$ôjì)ì ójì)ì ÷ ô ñ(öð ì õ&#ó "!í$ójìï&ó ý ð ìû ô!õ?ú% ð \ü$ó õ?ú÷ì)ì ÷6ô ñ±ï&ôX÷ ñ>ìïg÷ ï íï ó ð´û?õ&ójì ù ì í ÷ ï ö\ù ÷ ò ùìï ð!ñ$ýjì%õ&ó ò#ïg÷ ûg÷ ó ý³ý ójì ü ÷ ï óûg ÷ ÷ ñ ø%ô û ï?ù$óï ù>÷ õ&ýâì í ÷ ï ðUý ð$þ´î$ó$û ô!õ&ó1ï?ù$óö+÷ ï?ù$ý õ ð ö ð Pô$û%ï?ù$ó±ì ó ò)ô ñ$ý´ì í ÷ $ï Ùï ù ó ï?ù ÷ õ&ýÂì í>÷ ïEû&ô õâü$ô ì)ì ójì)ì ÷6ô!ñ¢÷lìUú%ðj÷ ñï"ð ÷ ñ ðj î 6ó í ñ ý ó õ¤ì í$ò ù ó $ó!ñ)ï?í ð l÷ ï þ &%yù í 'ì õ&ý ó (õ ÿP)í 6*ó + Qö:ô í ýñ ô ïjò)ô ú\ó ÷ ñï ô±ï?ù$óü ÷6ò#ï?í õêóÂð!ñ ý£ò ð ì ,ó 6ð ö -. / 0 21 ù ô ô ü$ð$ï?ù) þ 435 65 õg÷ ñ>÷ ð ì8 ð 7í õï?ù) þ 4- ð!ú% ð 9- ÷lì ù$ô!õ&:ó ð!î$ô <ô ;= í ü õ ð >âðjõ&ó ý!÷ìï?÷ ñ ø!í>÷lì ù ðj î 6óû?õ&ô ú ï?ù$óû&ó ð ï í õ&óUô ûaï?ù$ó±ü õ&ójì ó ñï\ò ð ì ó %yù$ó=ð!ü ü$ ó ðjñ)ïù$ð ý ý!÷ì 'ò 6ôjì ó ý~ð!î$ô íï ï?ù$ó~ü õ& ó ÷ ô í>ìØì í ÷ ïg'ì ÷ ñØï?ù$óRï?ù ÷ õ&ýQì í ÷ $ï ï?ù$ó!õ&ó û&ô õ& ó ãï ù ó õ&ó<÷lì¦ñ$ô=ò)ô ñ$ò)ó ð úEó ñï ô$û ú%ð$ï&ó õg÷6 ð #û ð ò#ï"ì%ðjñ$ý¡ò ð ì ?ó 6ð 8ö ð$ïg÷lì ù -;ù ôj@ì ð Aô ?þ Aªó ð ï?ù Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (32) B CED FGD H'I@B'J=KML C B NPO.L I'KMQ J R S=OTH#U#VWB X Y L H N D C'L'J Z'Q B U U N K I@B Z NMQ [\O K]CEI&Q J$^EQ B U#U'Q N N_B C&J8Y`B#a U'Q V bcK J JWQ#D JWL YdK J$^ED VeBEYfJ ^'QgahQ#I&L C'DiaEH K J B CEDkj lnmpo4OTb`J [)q0BsrtC KEu4B avB CED ^ B)DwB N_ahLnB D bcK J JWQ#DxJ ^ B'JyJ ^'Q VWQzY`B#a{CEL|VWQ a}J VeB K]C~L VWD#Q V K C ^'Q V ahQ I&L C'D aEH K J$ KJ YL H NMD C'L'J I&L C)a}J=K J HvJeQ D J$^EQ I&L CEI&Q B N]b2Q C&J L `bBEJeQ V=K_B NeB IJ aL V5JWL|avB'RzJ ^ B'JyJ ^'Q J ^ K VWD aEH K J Y`B a+ K NMQ#DZ'Q#I@B H)ahQC'Lna}JeB'RL VWD#Q V Y`B agJ ^'Q VWQK]C J ^'Q ahQ#I&L C'D aEH K J [ CED#Q VJ ^'Q I'K VWI H#ba}JeB C'I&Q a B CED J ^'Q VWQ B#ahL C K C a K 'Q C K]CJ ^'Q jB VeB# VeB U#^ [ nB Z'L''Q B I&L CEI'N]H)a@K L C D VeBEY2CZ&RgJ ^'Q V=K_B N yL H#V J(L C?K a&aEH'Q~C'L [G SeL V K a&aEHEQxC'L [Toh (Z'Q K]C ?J ^'Q{avB b4Q X K a?VWQ 'Q V ahQ D J$^'B'JyC'Q K J$^EQ V VWD#Q V 5q H N Qo j C'L V VWD#Q V2 q H)NMQf ¡ j ¢K a B U U N K I@B Z NMQwB CEDJ ^'Q J ^ K VWD£aEH)K J2¤ L [¥)¦@§@¨ [] © [eoh#© nY`B a C'L'J Z B V VWQ#DwZ&R J ^'Q ahQa}J BEJ$HvJeL V R U#VWL K_a@KML C a'[ ^'Q=K C'D K]C' a L CkK_a&aEH'QC'L [GiS ªzK_a&aEH'QC'L [ oh#X.L'«J ^'Qg V=K_B N ¥L H#V J K a+ahQ J B a@K D#Q [ oh [eo'[_ ^'Q VWQ aEU'L C'D#Q C&J agCEL [(o4B C'D gJWL#L ¬ahQ V=KML H a4L Z!r=Q#IJ=KML C K]CcjB VeB# VeB U ^9L J ^'Q K]V)YdV=K J JWQ Ca}JeB'JWQ b4Q CvJ)YdK J$^+VWQ #B V®DJWL J ^'Q¯D Q ahI V=K]UvJ K L C¡L dJ ^'Q:aEH K J+N_B C'D°aE^EL'Y2C£K]C±avB NMQ±D#Q Q#D D BEJeQ Dc [] [ o E?F ² [ j lnmpo!¨ kZEQ K]C'kC'L J JeB N N K Q#DY9K J ^J$^EQ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (33) ³_´ µ'¶c· ¸ ¹ º}»=¹ µ ¼i´ µE¶¹ µ½'¾ º&ºh· º&º@¹M¾ µ¾ ¿ » À'·kÁW· ºE½'¾ µ'¶#· µ&» ºµ'¾  à ´ µ'¶kÄ Â Å À ¹ º¾ Æ!Ç=·#È»=¹M¾ µkÁW· ºEÉ ³ » ¹]µv»e¾k¿ Áe´ Êc¹]µ'¼¾ ¿.¹ º&ºEÉ'·?µ'¾ Â Ë ´ µ'¶Ì» À'·ÍÅ Á=¹M´ ³iÎy¾ É#Á »z¶ ¹ ºhÈ É)º&ºh· ¶¹]µÏ´ Áe´#¼ Áe´ ½#À Ë Ð Ñ Ï´#¼)· º ÃhÒ »W¾£Ä à ¾'¿`» À'· ÇÓÉ'¶ ¼ Ê4· µ&»`¶ ´'»W·#¶|Ô Õ#Â]Ô Ä ÂÖÄ Ô Ô#Ô#× Æ#Év»9» À'·|Å Á=¹_´ ³yÎy¾ É#Á »È@´ Ê4·f»W¾Ø» À'·ØÈ&¾ µ'È'³ É)º@¹M¾ µ¡» À ´'»`»$ÀE· ´ ½ ½'· ³ ³M´ µ&»(¿e´ ¹ ³M·#¶z»W¾n½#ÁW¾ Ù'· ºEÉ&¿ ¿=¹MÈ'¹M· µ&»=³ Ú?»$À'´'» » À'·xºEÉ ¹ »5³_´ µE¶ Ê4· ´#ºEÉ#Á=¹]µ'¼nÄ)Ô#Ô¡ºhÛ Â(Ú ´ ÁW¶ º?¶#· ºhÈ Á=¹ Æ'·#¶¡¹ µz» À'·wºv´ ³M·¶ ·#·#¶ Ü ¸ Â0Ï ÝnÞ Ã!ß Ä»e´ ³ ³ ¹ · ºkàd¹ »$À » À'·¡³_´ µE¶¹]µn½'¾ º&ºh· º&º@¹M¾ µz¾'¿ » À'· ÁW· ºE½E¾ µ'¶#· µ&» ºµ'¾  à ´ µE¶|Än¾ Á5» À'·¡³_´ µ'¶ØÊ4·#´ ºEÉ#Á=¹]µ'¼¡Ä Ô#Ô ºhÛ Â2Ú ´ ÁW¶ ºá´#º8¶#· ºhÈ Á=¹]Æ'· ¶â´ ºã½ ³ ¾ »ä ¾ Â*Ä Ô Ä<å0È À'´ Áe´'Ú ´ äy¹ æç· »e´ µ~Îy¾ ³M¾ µvÚ èyäT·'àéT· ³ À ¹È@´ Á Á=¹ · º~¹ » ºµ'·'àêcÉ#µ)¹MÈ'¹]½'´ ³ äT¾ Â)å¥Þ ÃhÒ è#å0È À ´ Á Ú ´z䥹]æç· »e´ µ#èê4´'Ú#É#Á ëy¹]À'´ ÁTÎ À'¾Eà2æ@è äT·'à éT· ³]À ¹MÞ Ò Äì¾ Á{» À'·¢ÁW· ºE½'¾ µE¶#· µ&» º,µ'¾  à ´ µE¶íÄÍ´ ÁW·P¹]µ ½'¾ º&ºh· º&º@¹M¾ µ<¾ ¿{» À'·½ ³ ¾ »Æ'· ³ ¾ µ ¼ ¹]µ ¼î»W¾í» À'·P´ ½ ½'· ³ ³M´ µ&» ï à2ÀE· ÁW· ´#º'襻 À'·\ÁW· ºE½'¾ µE¶#· µv»=º´ ÁW·<¹]µ£½'¾ º&ºh· º&º@¹M¾ µ|¾ ¿g½ ³ ¾ » Ê4· ´#ºEÉ#Á=¹]µ'¼ Ë)Ð ÕºhÛ ÂÚ ´ ÁW¶ º'è Æ'· ¹]µ ¼ ´ ¶ Êc¹ »ð»W·#¶ Æ&Úñ» À'· ´ ½ ½'· ³ ³M´ µ&» ´ µE¶ ¿W¾ Áà`´ µv»ò¾ ¿4½#ÁW¾ ½'· Á9¹ ¶#· µ&»=¹ ¿ ¹ È@´'»=¹M¾ µ ¾ ¿ » À'· ½ ³ ¾ »$èv» À'·g´ ½#½'· ³ ³_´ µv» È&¾ É)³M¶*µ'¾'» · º}» ´ Æ ³ ¹_ºEÀ+À'· Á È@´ ºh· Â Ã Ô ÂÖÄ Â_Å À'·g´ ½ ½'· ³ ³_´ µv»¹ ºd´#¼#¼ Á=¹ · Ù'·#¶¿ ÁW¾ Ê8ºEÉ'È À¿=¹]µE¶ ¹]µ'¼ ºd¾'¿ »$ÀE· Å Á=¹_´ ³ Îy¾ É#Á »$è£ÆE· ¹]µ'¼ ¿=¹]µ'¶ ¹]µ ¼#º ¼ ¹ Ù'· µ È&¾ µ&» Áe´ Á Ú»W¾ » À'· Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (34) óô'õWö ÷=øMô ùú û+÷®ö#ü&ú ÷Wý þ ÿ ö ÷Wöô ÷Wö ùMú ü kø]ûgõ ö 0ü ô ÷ ô ¥ø çö õeô ûkô û'ýô ù ù ù ú õ ø]û .ù ú#ü nô ÷Wö*ú þ ô ÷Wý `ô ûEýõ öiô Eö ù ùMô û&õ ! ù ú õ #"%$ &~ø ú ûEö~ú õ ö' ùMú'õ( 'þ ) ÿ * ö #÷®ö + øMú , û ,#ó- 'ö ÷ ú. Tõ ö ù ú õ0/ô1 - 1 21 0ü ô ÷ ô yø3 çö õeô û54¥ú ùMú û6 127 ö./98Tö ù ø:2 ô1 ý#ö1 hü ÷=ø 'ö ý°ø]û|õ ö; vô ùMö:ý ö#ö#ý=< > þ@?0A'"%$CBD ¯ú õ öE 'ö#ô ÷ $ & FG&02 úG/ö +'ö ÷H2.ùMô'õWö ÷(ú û12 õ öJI ,#û)øMü'ø 'ô ùGû , ó- 'ö ÷ K/ö ÷Wö ô1 6 @øML û'ö#ý 2 ø õN/ô1 ìô 6 @ø L ûEö#ýO #"%$ &02 0ü ô ÷ ôP yø3 çö õeô û12 I4ô.
, ÷ Qyø ô ÷04 úG/R S2T Tö./U8Tö ù ø "V&1 þ ÿ ögô 'ö ù ùMô û&õ ô)ý =ø ùMö ýõ öJ @ø õWö* ù_ô û'< > þ)?0A'"%$CBW$ ý#ö ø üõ=ø]û L ù_ô. 'ú ,&õ¥ú. X ù ú õ Tú þT #"Y$ &02 0ü ô ÷ ô ¥ø çö õeô û 2ZI4ô.
,#÷0Qyø ô ÷[4 úG/R S20 Tö./ 8Tö ù øM"5&1 ô û'ýâú û¯õ öáö.+'öâú. ô Eú ø]ûvõ$ó4ö û&õ ú N\Eú ü@ô ù 4yú ó+ócø] 6 @øMú û'ö ÷H2cõ ö^\Eú#ü@ô ù 4yú ó+óø] 6 @øMú û'ö ÷N+ ø @ø õWö#ý,õ ö G 'ú'õ ü&ú 6 ú õ ö_ @ø õWö` ù_ô ûa/ô1 K #÷Wú + ø ý#ö#ýõWú ø ó 2 ü&ú 6 ú.
@ø õWöb ù_ô û5< > þ ?0A'"%$cBc$d/ô1 2ô ý ócø õ õeö ýe dõ ö ÷Wö G Eú û'ý#ö û&õ û'ú þf$2ô û'ý` þ g ûô ý#ý ø õ=øMú û 2Eõ ö ÷Wöb/ ö ÷Wö û'ú ú ch=ö#üõ=øMú û i =ø ùMö#ý ú ûcõ ö ô ÷ õ(ú õ ö{÷Wö1 G 'ú û'ý ö û&õ kû'ú þj$+ô û'ý 2 õ ö ÷Wö Wú ÷Wö 2 õ ök\Eú ü@ô ù 4yú ó+ócø] 6 @øMú û'ö ÷ M ÷Wö 'ú ÷ õl }õeô ûEý *ô ý ócø õ õeö ýô û'ý õ ö|ô 'ö ù ù_ô ûvõm M ' ù ö ônõeô çö û12n }õeô û'ý ü&ú ÷ ÷Wú Eú ÷eô'õWö#ýo $÷Wú ó õ öã÷Wö 'ú ÷ õ*ú gõ öp\@ú#ü@ô ùd4yú ó+ócø 6 @øMú ûEö ÷$þ`q ,#÷õ ö ÷H29õ ö Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (35) r s s t3u vSr.w(uMx y z x { r s s.x u3y6w}|@~ y6w x z ( ~ v6x y. Gx vSr t x |-| u]6SuMx y.~ { dr1 z(u3tM~ Nx ykG~ r1t z[x.zfw}.~{ ~ Gs.x yG ~ y w( y.x j-r y. Vu w dr1 ~1r t w[u3y` ~ wmr u3t 6_wHG~ x { wx z [ {(u [ 6 u {)u y. @r1t .x.wH{mr w}.~w}.~ yS0 u u3t! .1 ~ ~ t u u y^ ~.wmr u3t ~ x { ~ { 1r.w ~ : 1m ¡r y.^w} u x { ~ {i{ ~.z}t ~ v¢w w} r.w£w}.~E{ ~1Gs.x y. ~ y6w 'y.x !r y.¤¥ rT r | u w wm~ w}.~ { ~ s.x { w¦x z§w}.~ Gx vSr t x |-|Ku]6SuMx y.~ {H w}.~ { ~.zmx { ~0`w}.~ ~ v {(u3s6w(uMx y¨x {Jw}.~ G u w*r { ~ r©x zªw}.~ s { x s.~ { w N dr15r | u w w ~ o6w}.~«{ ~1Gs.x yG ~ y6w y.x X r y. _¬ { w}.~ {HRw}.~{ ~1Gs.x y. ~ y6w ®y.x0¯°r yG r r1t] x |@x .~ r y5r s sTt3uMvSrGw}u x y r.w ~ J ±0 1² m¢ Zb y. ~ {j ~ v¢w(u x y .³ £´j z x {µv.tMr {(u z(uMvSrGw}u x yTx.z¶u yc·D y.v¢w(uMx yx { ~ {µr d~ t3t r1@z x {) ~.wmr u3t u y { ~1Gs.~ v¢w[x z u3|@~ yTSu x yex zjwHG~JsTtMx w)r y.ku w ar @r1t] xe ~ r t wZu y x { ~ {01r.w ~ eT0 Z.m 0³6 w}.~ x { w x z !. ´ u y u nw}.~¸w}.~ y¤G0 u u3t) G1 ~ ~ t u n R u v ~1 v {(u .~1¥yGx wbx y t ¹w}.~¸ u |@~ y SuMx y¸x.z w}.~§r s s.~ t3t r y6w º s t x w_ r { x y.91³Gº£± º ºn»¼³G º 6w r t x;w}.~½s tM~ r§x z@wHG~ r s s.~ t3tMr y6ww} r.wVw}.~r { ~1rex z[s t x w)u] x z) ¾0 r { .1w}.~ { ~ GsGx y. ~ y6w y.x ikr y.¹ox v6v s u ~ U ¡1³¿ ¾ [ r { x.z t r y.b R u v v6x |-s {(u ~ ¯S¡ ³_ ¾0 r { 1 x z[|- y uMv.u3s r t tMr y. z x {}| u y.ks r { w[x zjw}.~k~ r1 ~ |@~ y6w t r yGr tMx y N iu wH_w}.~JGTu w Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (36) À Á Â.Ã¼Ä ÅbÆ Ç ÇÈ É0ÊdË Á ÌÍà È.Ê-Î[Ä.ϣРÑ.Ð ÌHÒiÓHÔGÐ È Ð¼Õ6Ä Â6Ó Ð Â6Ó(Ö Ä ÂTÈ ÏdÐ Ì ÐÂ.Ä Ó Á1È6È Ð È6È Ð Ã-Ä Ì Õ6Ä ÂTÈSÖ Ã Ð Ì Ð Ã×6˶ÓHÔGÐ!Ø Ì(Ö Á À Ù#Ä Ú Ì ÓHÊ Û ÂªÁTÃ Ã Ö Ó}Ö Ä Â1Ò7Ó}Ô.ÐEÈGÚ Ö ÓÜÕSÁ  ÂGÄ ÓR×.ÐEÂGÄ Â ÝHÈGÚTÖ Ó Ð ÃEÞ@Ð Ì Ð À ËÅ Ä Ì Ö ÂGÕ6Ä Þ-ß À Ð Ó Ð Ã Ð È Õ Ì(Ö3ß6Ó(ÖMÄ Â Ä ÌOÅ Ä ÌpÏaÁ  ÓÄ Å¨Õ6Ä Þ-ß À Ð Ó Ð Ã Ð1È Õ Ì(Ö ß6Ó(ÖMÄ Â-Ä Å Ö Þ-Þ@Ä Ñ Á × ÀMÐ ß Ì Ä ß.Ð Ì ÓàË1Ò Á1ÈbánÚ ÀMÐNâÄ Åjã@Ì Ã Ð Ì äµÛ Û ÙÜåjÙ¹Ì Ð É Ú Ö3Ì Ð ÈXÓ}Ô Á.Ó0Ö Â ÕSÁ È ÐbÄ.Å0Ö3Þ-Þ@Ä Ñ Á ×TÀMÐ5ß Ì Ä ß.Ð Ì Ó Ë1Ò Ö Ó ÈGÔ.Ä Ú ÀMÃe×.Ð_Ã Ð È Õ Ì(Ö3×.Ð Ã`ß Ì Ä ß.Ð Ì(À Ë-È Ä_Ó}Ô ÁGÓfÖ3 Ó}Ô.Ð Ð Ñ.Ð Â6Ó}Ú Á1À3Ö Ó Ë Ä ÅfÃ Ð Õ Ì Ð Ð0ÒÈGÚ.Õ ÔÃ Ð Õ Ì Ð Ðk×.Ð Õ6Ä Þ@Ð È@Ð æ.Ð Õ Ú6ÓmÁ ×TÀMÐ0Ê Û Â5Ä Ì Ã Ð Ì Ó Ä ÈGÚ × ÈçÓmÁ Â6Ó(Ö Á.Ó Ð ÈGÚ.Õ ÔèÅmÁ Õ¢Ó È.ÒÓ}Ô.Ð Á ß ß.Ð À3À Á Â6Ó«Å(Ö3ÀMÐ Ã Á  Á ß ß À3Ö ÕSÁ.Ó(ÖMÄ ÂÚ Â.à РÌnÄ ÌÍà РÌ#éµê äµÛ Û Ù£åjÙ®Ó ÄªÀMÐ1ÁTëÁ Ã Ã Ö Ó(Ö Ä Â Á À Ð Ñ Ö Ã Ð Â.Õ6Ð Ê;êSÐ1Á Ã Ö Â ë Ä.ÅÁ Ã Ã Ö Ó(Ö Ä Â Á ÀoÐ Ñ Ö Ã Ð ÂGÕ6Ð Á.Ó=Ó}Ô.Ð Á ß ß.Ð À3ÀMÁ Â6Ó ì ÈNÈçÓmÁ ë ÐÏ£Ä Ú ÀMêÕ6Ä ÂTÈçÓ(Ö Ó}Ú6Ó Ðoß.Á Ì ÓÜÄ Å#Ó}Ô.ÐoÌ Ð Õ6Ä Ì Ã Ò Á1ÈoÁ ß ß.Ð Á ÀdÖ]ÈUÖ3¸Õ6Ä Â Ó}Ö3Â Ú ÁGÓ}Ö Ä ÂUÄ Å Ó}Ô.ЧÈGÚ Ö ÓHÊ ê.Á ÈçÓ}À Ë1ÒaÓ}Ô.Ð Á ß ß.Ð À3ÀMÁ Â6Ó ë Ä Ó Ð æ Á Þ Ö3Â.Ð Ã í[Ô Ì(Ö îlÄ1ë Ð1ÈGÔ ïjÚ Þ!Á ÌHÒ ð ÌmÁGÅàÓ ÈGÞ!Á °Å}Ì Ä Þ Ó}Ô.Ð ð Ð ß.Á Ì Ó}Þ@Ð Â6Ó5Ä Å ØjÄGÏRÂå7ÀMÁ   Ö3 ë Ò ñ Ù ð ÒVÁ1È ò ó'Ý%ô`õ ÁTÃ Ã Ö Ó(Ö Ä Â Á À Ð Ñ Ö Ã Ð ÂGÕ6Ð ö£Á Â.ÃÔ.ЯÅ(Ö3ÀMÐ Ã Ó}Ô.Ð À ÁGË.Ä Ú6Ó ß ÀMÁ ÂbÄ ÅjÓHÔGÐòlÕ Ô.Á Ì Ë Á÷#Ö øùÐ ÓmÁ Â`Ù#Ä ÀMÄ Â6Ë1Ò ÏRÔ Ö Õ Ô5Ö]ÈbÁ × À3Ú.Ð_ß Ì(Ö Â Ó ñ Á Ì}øXòµÊ Ø Ô Ö]È ñ Á Ì}øXòªÀ Á.Ë.Ä Ú6ÓVß À Á  Á À]È ÄKà РßTÖMÕ¢Ó È Ú ÂTÖ Å Ä Ì}Þ Ö Ó Ë¼Ä Å¯Æ Ç Ç^È É0ÊKË Á Ì Ã È¼ß À Ä Ó È9Ö Â;Ó}Ô.ÐÁ Ì Ð Á úûÀ Á ÂGÐ0Ò Ó}Ô.Ð Ì Ð.ÅmÄ Ì Ð0Ò°Ó}Ô.Ð Á ß ß.Ð À3À Á Â6ÓÔ Á È Á À]È Ä ÈGÚ.Õ6Õ6Ð Ð Ã Ð Ã Ó Ä Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (37) ü ýçþmÿ ]ý Nþ ÿ.þnþ .üªý þ Gü þ dÿ1ý ¿ý ÿ ! ý þ" þ# ÿ ý .ü ü $`þ% ü1ý ÿ1ý6ý ü !&' Nþ .ü& ü1ý ( $ ! ü $6þ ý)$ +* ÿ $ !, .-/ .ü0 ü1ý ( $ ! ü $6þ ý1$( *¶ÿ2$(!3 54Sÿ $ $( þ ! ü 6 7.ü_ÿ $.
.ü $.ü 6 þ98@ü ü2 :
`þ .ü;
ü ÿ1ý $ ý <-þ .ü= Mÿ( ( þ> ÿ $? ]ý
8!ÿ
@ùü
!A! 4
8@ü $6þCB@ÿ
@ D¸ýE $(46ü þF ÿ ý5Gü ü $0
G ! (46ü
!
8 þ .üH4 Týçþ ! I KJ
7.ü
$
8@ü $6þA! ü ÿ2
þ%8@ü $6þ5ÿ $ !: þ
.ü
þ ÿL M$Tý§þ þ .ü ÿ
ü1ÿN M$O .ü ýçþ6 P $L QE! RS $Tý ü2 5
ÿ
.ü Mÿ $6þ#
þ6 6 ü ýT ]ýU4' $6þ ü $ þ $Tý9 1
V MüW
ü
$ JI $
þ .üX ( Y $ JZ4Sÿ1ý ü3 Mÿ \[M]
Site Plan/Description & Identity of Property i. Nagar Khan vs Gopi Ram Agarwala AIR 1976 Patna 2
- while dealing with order VII Rule 3 of CPC; it was held that when the subject matter of the suit is immovable property, the plaintiff has to describe such property with sufficient particulars to identify it with boundaries or with other particulars so that in case decree is passed, it will be capable of execution.
ii. Hari Kumar vs. Sat Narain Mehra 1996(36) DRJ 99 - when correctness of the site plan was admitting or the defendant had understood the description of the property given in the pleadings and there is no objection on the same, the suit cannot be dismissed merely for non- mention of the number of the property.
In the present case, the respondent as well as her counsel had admitted the site plan Ex. PW-1/1 before Local Commissioner, therefore, the suit could not have been dismissed merely for the reason description of the Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (38) property. In fact, there was no challenge to the site plan Ex. PW-1/1 being not disputed.
iii.Vishwanath Pal vs. Sanyasi Charan Karmakar 2004 A.I.H.C. 4556 - if a party fails to furnish sufficient description of the property in the plaint, such error can be treated as irregularity and under such circumstances the Court should direct the parties to provide better particulars to avoid controversies, the plaint cannot be rejected for such irregularity.
Evidence & Burden of Proof i. A.P. State Wakf Board Hyderabad vs. All India Shia Conference (Branch) A.P. 2000 II AD (S.C.) 276 - while dealing Order XLI Rules 27 and 28 CPC; it was held that the Appellant Court can call additional evidence, either taking direct evidence in the Appellant Court or calling the Trial Court, and Appellant Court can assess such evidence in order to dispense justice.
In the instant case, the appellant called officials from the Office of MCD who led additional evidence by way of producing layout plan of the area. It is conclusive evidence in nature.
ii. Moran Mar Eassellos Catholicos vs. Most Rev. Mar Poulose Athanasius AIR 1954 S.C. 526 - in a suit of ejectment, the plaintiff must support the case on strength of his own title and this can be done by producing sufficient evidence to discharge the onus. To say, onus lies on the plaintiff to prove his case irrespective of whether the defendant has proved his title or not.
iii.Laxman Uttam Chand Kriplani vs. Meena AIR 1964 S.C. 40 - there is a distinction between the legal burden and onus to prove.
Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (39) In the present case, the legal burden on the plaintiff stood discharged on production of sale deed of plot No. 202, which was also proved along with site plan Ex. PW-1/1, being admitted before the Local Commissioner. The defendant was required to prove that they were owner of plot No. 202 in 1959 and the size of the plot was 375 sq. yards, but this onus was not discharged by the defendant.
iv.Ashok Kumar vs. Vijay Lakshmi 1991 Rajdhani Law Reporter 46 - it is immaterial if the document was marked earlier as the same document can be endorsed/ exhibit at the time of writing the final judgment by the Court. The Trial Court should not give weight to absurd statements.
v. Y.N. Rao vs. Y.V. Lakshmi 1991 Rajdhani Law Reporter (SC) 367 - while considering plea on Sections 63 and 65 of Indian Evidence Act; it was held that the copies made from the original by mechanical process can be considered as secondary evidence, however, such photocopy prepared by mechanical process ensure the accuracy of the original.
Others Cases :-
i. Ram Lubhaya vs. Dr. J.R. Chawla 1986 Rajdhani Law Reporter 432 - our Hon'ble High Court of Delhi dealt with the provision of Delhi Land Reform Act and Delhi Municipal Corporation Act and it was held; if a bhumidar of an agricultural land in a Revenue Estate (Basai Darapur) which gets urbanised makes housing plots, without sanction of Chief Commissioner, and gets layout plan approved from MCD, then the bhumidar can be sued in the Revenue Court only by Gaon Sabha. But if the suit is by a buyer of plot, then Civil Court has jurisdiction to try the suit.
ii. Konda Lakshamana Bapuji vs. Govt. of Andhra Pradesh 2002 AIR SC 1012 - our Apex Court dealt in Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (40) detail on Andhra Pradesh Land Grabbing (Prohibition) Act, 1984 and term land grabbing has been interpret broadly to cover unauthorized, greedy and unfair possession of the land, without any lawful entitlement of the person. It was also held that if a person is a land grabber or holds the land unauthorizedly or illegally or the property of someone else, such land grabber does not deserve relief from the Court.
In the case at hand, the respondent tried to place on record the photocopy of General Power of Attorney of September 1982 but no one has been examined ever since with regard to such Power of Attorney. Not only, the defendant failed to discharge her onus but also she is liable for perjury.
^ _ `baL`dc/e(fhg fLi j(k l m f l'noipl(k `Y^ q l(msr&q2g ftl(k n#q u2g f f mwvYx n%e n e(fwy'k l.nzf l'n6xPk l i0k g{i | } ~Zxdi'iExPk l iAk Sn%e f>q j j(f2 dq2l'n%`c/e(f q j j(f Pq l'n"y(Pq2xM~i(qLi x %n e(f g ftxVip| l x zk g ~ } Pk y 9k(+r _ _ i ` q g mLiYfLq y ej Pk n2v1e kKe qLil(k n}(f f l5j g k (f mf x n e(f g }' v{q 1k f xPm f l(y'fk gLk n e(f gbvYxVi f0l k g n e(fq g &} |(fj g6x l'n f2inzq } xVi e f2i n%e xVi,zq yn%` c/e(f g fpxViKl(kf x m f l(y'fAn e q(nj Pk nxMl j(kLi'i f2i'iExPk lk n%e fg f2i j(k l(m f l'noiKl(k `^q l(m)r}(f q goiFk ` r _ r)y e q g qx f nzq l9Sk Pk l'LFf Me x` noq nzf ~f l'nx l3n%e f q m m x n6xPk l q2 f xPm f l(y'f9k />^A e g6x ¡kLu f2i e>¢| ~Xq g q2di k f Pq }(k g q(n f2ipn e q(n£n e(f g f\xdisl(kI~| l xPy(xMj(q2"g f y'k g m¤k l(f(v l | ~}(f goi£k g k ml | ~}(f goi k gLS^¥0xVin e(fAl(f v¦l | ~}(f g k k ml | ~} f g r _LrZk( y e q2g qxM f(nzq lk k l'L f2Me xM` Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (41) §/¨¨ ©(ªW«M¬ 'ª ®'¨6«P¯ ¬°¯ ±,² ³ « ¨µ´¶ ª ± ¯ · ª¤¨ ©(ª\¸/·6«P¹2º »S¯ ³ · ¨%´"¨%© ª · ª2² ® ¯ ¬(¼ ª ¬'¨o²½© ¹ ¼ ¾¯ ¿(ª ¼ ¹ ¬ ¹2® ® ºV«PE¹(¨6«P¯ ¬N± ¯ ·°¶ ª ¨ ¨zª · ® ¹2· ¨ « ³ ºd¹2·o² ¯ ·\±z¯ ·À¼ « ¾ª ¬ ²E« ¯ ¬ ¯ ±¦¨ ©(ª ® ºP¯(¨Á¶ ³.¨Â¯ ¬ ¾ªL¹ ² ³ · ª ¾ª ¬'¨ ¯ ¬Y¨ ©(ª)¶ ¹L²E«d²1¯ ±²E« ¨ ªK® ºP¹ ¬ à ÄLÅ2Æ Ç>ÈÉËÊËÉ(´ ¹ ¬ ¹ · ª ¹ ¯ ± Ì Í Ì Îp² Ï Å ±zª ª ¨+Ð%ÑLÍEÒ Ó Ò ÒLÄpÔÕÉÒ Ò ÖF×#¹L²3±z¯ ³ ¬(¼ ¹ ¨ ¨%© ª ² ®(¯(¨µ´ ×1©(ª · ªL¹L²(´ ¨ ©(ª · ª9'¯ ³ º ¼ ¶ ª&É.Ø Î Î9² Ï Å ±zª ª ¨C± ¯ ·/¹ ® ºP¯ ¨ ¯ ±Ì Î ÎN² Ï Å3Ù ¹2· ¼2²(´ ¾ªL¹ ¬ «M¬ ÚÁ¨ ©(ª · ª ¶'ÙÁ¨ ©(ª · ªÛ×#¹L²Â¹ ¬ ª Ä('ªL²'²¯ ±Ô Ì Î² Ï Å2±zª ª ¨%´©(¯(×H'¯ ³ ºP¼¨ ©(ª® · ¯ ® ª · ¨ Ù)¯ ±¨ ©(ª · ª2² ® ¯ ¬(¼ ª ¬'¨o²¬(¯ Å/ÉX¹ ¬(¼0Ì ¶(ªK¨ ©(ª¹2® ®(ª2º ºd¹2¬'¨ Òd²® º ¯ ¨%´Õ²E« ¬('ª ¨ ©(ª· ªL² ®(¯ ¬(¼ ª ¬'¨o²K¬(¯ ÅoÉ3¹ ¬(¼)Ìw©(¹(¿(ª¶(ª ª ¬ « ¬®(¯L²'² ª2²'²E«P¯ ¬ ¯ ± ® º ¯ ¨Õ¾ª ¹L² ³ ·6« ¬ Ú0Ñ Ô2Ͳ Ï Å.Ù ¹ · ¼2²(Å ¸F© ª· ª2² ®(¯ ¬ ¼ ª ¬.¨6² Ò(® ºP¯(¨ ¯ ± Ñ Ô2Ͳ Ï ÅÜÙ ¹ ·G¼2² «d² ¹9'¯ · ¬(ª ·#® ºP¯(¨"¶ ³'¨{¬(ª2« ¨ ©(ª ·¨ ©(ª&².¹2º ª ¼ ª ª ¼K¼ ªL² ·6«M¶(ªL²« ¨¹'¯ · ¬(ª ·® ºP¯(¨¬ ¯ ·Õ¨ ©(ªK¹ ® ® ª º ºP¹ ¬'¨ Òd²²E« ¨zª ® ºP¹ ¬ à ÄLÅÜÆ Ç>ÈÉËÊËɼ ª ® « ¨6²,« ¨C¹)'¯ ·6¬(ª ·® º ¯ ¨%´©(¯ ×#ª ¿(ª ·%´ ¨ ©(ª ¹ ® ®(ª º ºP¹ ¬'¨ Òd²+× « ¨ ¬(ª2²'² ªL²Æ Ç>ÈÉ1¹ ¬(¼ Æ Ç>È ÌK«M¾® · ¯ ¿(ª ¼ ´ ¹ ²« ±µ´ « ¨ ×{¹L²5¹0'¯ · ¬(ª · ® º ¯ ¨%ÅÜеÝE¼ Å »S¯ ³ ¬ ² ª2ºLÞ © ·6« ßXÅ Æ/Å à© ¹ ¼ ¹ ·6«d¹ ´ §¼ ¿(¯ E¹(¨ ª5± ¯ ·¹2® ®(ª2º ºd¹2¬'¨pª(Ä ® ºd¹L«M¬ ²X¨ © ¹(¨C²E«M¬ 'ª3¨ ©(ª · ª,×#ª · ª ¹ 'Ï ³ «V²E« ¨ « ¯ ¬U¯(±£¨ ©(ª¤® º ¯ ¨o²p± ¯ · '¯ ¾¾³ ¬ « ¨áÙ&® ³ · ® ¯2² ª2²>¹ ¬(¼ ¶(ª E¹ ³ ² ª>¯ ±"¨ © ¹ ¨£¹ 'Ï ³ «d²E« ¨6«P¯ ¬ ´ ¹2º ¨ ©(¯ ³ Ú ©pª ¹ ·6º « ª · ® º ¯ ¨âF¯ Å Ì Î Ìw×{¹L²&¬ ¯ ¨Y¹h'¯ · ¬(ª ·Z® ºP¯ ¨Y¶ ³.¨X² ³ ¶ ² ª Ï ³(ª ¬.¨ º ÙL´¯ ¬w¨ ©(ª Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (42) ã ä(ã3å æç è'é ê ëdìEë í6ëPå î ï ë íFð(ã èEç2ñã çKè'å ò6î(ã òFó ôPå(í/ò ã æ6ôPã èízã õ9ë î í ö(ãAå ò õ ã òõLç ízã õ ÷ ø ùMø ú(ùzú û û ü ð'ý,í ö(ã þSå ê ò í å æÿXì(ù Cë î .ëï í ö(ãXí ö(ã î Eõ ù(þë ä ëVô ê(õ ã ï Fã ôMö ë ù ö(ã5ò ãLì ó(å î õ ã î'íoìî ã ä(ã òÕç õ ñZë í í ã õí ö(ãAò ã ó(å ò í ìEë í ãó ôPç îå(æ í ö(ã å èEçLôþSå ññZëVì'ìEë å î(ã òð ê'íç è'è'ã ó'ízç î è'ã {çLìí åsí%ö ã ã 'í ã î.í å æ"ã ëVìí ã î è'ã>å æ"ìí ò ê(èí ê ò ãUå î í ö(ãwã(ä(ãUå æ ä ëVìEë íå(æ í ö(ã Eå èEç2ô'þå ññëVì'ìEëPå î(ã ò ç(í í ö(ãì ó å í%ïLö(å #ã ä(ã ò%ïLë í #å ê ôPõ î(å(ípð(ãÂízã ò ñã õÛçLì ç è'è'ã ó'ízç î è'ã å æAí ö(ã ìEë í ã ó ôdç î ù î ç õ õ ë í6ëPå îLïí ö(ã å èEçLô£þSå ññZëVì'ìEë å î(ã òAö ç õÀò ã è'å ò õ ã õÁö ëdì ó ò å è'ã ã õ ë î Lìç(í"ì ó(å(í Lù !ú" µ÷ ü$#%ñXç î ê ì è ò6ëMó.í% & 1ö ë è ö õ å ã2ìXî(å íLè'å î'ízç2ë îç î.ý,ç(ä(ã ò ñã î'í ç ð(å ê.í2í%ö ã,ç õ ñZëVì'ìEë å îZå(æ í ö(ãwìEë í ã>ó ôdç2î ð'ýAí ö(ãsò ã2ì ó å î(õ ã î'íoì(ïFö å' #ã(ä(ã ò%ïÜí ö(ã( å èEç2ô þå ññZëVì'ìEëPå î(ã ò#ö ç õ ç2ôVì å æ6ë ôPã õsö ëVì>ò ã ó(å ò í) Lù* !ú" µ÷'+ #áí ý ó(ã õ5ä(ã òoìEë å î' ï' 1ö ë è öAò ã(æ ô ã èíoì5ëMî ç òzç 2òzç ó ö3÷í%ö(ç(íÕí%ö ã ìEë í ã>ó ôPç îö çLìð(ã ã î9ç õ ñZë í í ã õ ð'ýwð å í ö)í ö(ãwè'å ê î ì ã ôdì çLì è'å ò ò ã èíµïFð ê.í£ì ê(è öUò ã ó å ò í,# ë î ò ãLì ó(ã èí"å(æ+ç õ ñZëVì'ìEë å î ì- YëVì î(å(í í ã î ç ð ôPã ï(çLì#í ö(ã3ó ò å è'ã ã õ ëMî' Lì. Lù/ !ú" µ÷ ü,ò ã è'å ò õ ã õ ç(íí%ö ãwì ó(å(í õ å ã2ì9î å í"ò ã æ6ôPã èí"ì å ù ö ãUç èíoìKå òõ ã ã õ2ìAå(æ í ö(ã0 Eå èEç2ô"þSå ññZëVì'ìEë å î(ã ò5ð ã ý(å î õ í ö(ã¦ç2ê'í ö(å ò6ë íáýtè'å ê ô õ î(å(ípð(ãÛò ãLç õ ï3çLìÂç îHç õ ñZëVì'ìEë å îHå î í ö(ã½ó ç ò í)å æAí ö(ã Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (43) 13254 6 798': 2 8<;=4'> ?A@ 2CB)D ;E;3291 : 7 254F8'7 ;G298 : @ 291329> A ? @ H 2 D 6 6'25IJIKD58<; LM1379B N 291PORQJ8'S<296T;MQ 798CUVD 40S<7 8 N Q 8 S<2 : @ 2 1=4-2 I L ; @ D'; ; @ 2W6/I 7';
: 2 4-S 1XQ Y'2/:ZQ 8[4TD I 2 : 2 2/:$\ ] >_^ `!acb"dfeg: 7/254h8'7';i;=D IJI OhUjQ ; @ ; @ 2[132 4 6'798 : 298<;=4-k 6lI 7 ; D'; ; @ 2[4mQ ;%2[D 8':n; @ 2 D 6/6'2 IJI D 8<; UVD 4 D5IK4-7FS<798 N QJ8'S<2 :o; @ D ;G4 @ 2 S<79plI :H8'7';nD YlI 2F;37 2 4 ;=D5Y/IJQK4 @ ; @ D'; @ 291V6/I 7';rqs79>telu e9vxwyS @ D 1PO Dzq{QJ|}2 ;%D 8!~&7 I 7 8<O v{qs2 U 25I @ Q v @ D 4 8'2 U 8 p/BGY'291=4!IJQJ|}2w&acb- v&wyS @ D51PO D q&Q |}2 ;%D 8 ~{75I 798TO viqs2'U 25I @ Q'D 8 :; @ D';Q4)U @ O132 6'2 D ;%2/:D ;E;329Bn6<;=4 U,2 132 B)D/:/2L3791(I 2 D/:5Q 8 D/: :5Q ;XQ 798'D5I 2 N Q : 2 8'S<2 D';g; @ 2 4 ;%D /27 L&D 6/6'2 D I> ?A@ 2D 6 6'25IJIKD58<; @ D/: LMQJ1=4 ;XI O ;M1XQ 2/:;37SmD5II ; @ 2F132/S<7913:!L137 B ; @ 2od4'>Q ;P;%D5IK4-798l4('D 8 :5Q 8 D58'S<2 ^ N ;>-;%:9>,D 8':z; @ 29132 D LE;3291vY<OF4 p BGB798lQ 8 132/S<7913:zLM1379B 7 ; @ 2 1i:/296 D51P;B2 8<;=4V;372 4 ;=D5Y/IJQK4 @ ; @ D';6/I 7 ;qs7 > e/u e Y'2 D 1=4 8'2 U np 8/Q S'Q 6 D5Ihqs7 >Gw&acb vnwyS @ D 1PO Dq{Q |}2';=D58~{7 I 798<O v qs2 U 25I @ Q > A ? @ ! 2 D 6 6'25IJIKD58<;3kK4D 6/6/IJQ SmD';XQ 798ZU,2 132!:/2 D5I ;rYTO 7913:/291=4G: D';32 :u > u 9> elu u e v¡e5¢5> u >elu u eD 8 :ge/ > u ¢5>elu u £ U @ 298 ;@ 2 D56 6/IQ SmD';XQ 7 8 : D';32 : e ¢5> u ¢5>e/u/u £ UVD 4 : QK4 BnQ4<4-2 : ¤wA`!acb ¥ @ 1XQz¦y7 l254 @ § p B)D 1©¨=D/:/: Q ;XQ 7 8 D5I 2 N Q : 298'S<2/ªoU,D 4 132 S<7 13: 2 : 6 p/1=4 p D 8<;F;37 791«: 291F: D';32 :
Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (44) ¬5 ®¯/° ®¬/¯ ¯ ¬ ® ±A²'³F´JµG¶ · ¸5¹'³ º » ¶ ¶/¼´ ½m»'¾X´ ¿9¹lÀÀ ¶'³ » Á-À»z¼ ¿ ¾ ¾M² »'¾¡¾² ³g» ¶ ¶ ³ ¼J¼ » ¹<¾ÂV» À ÀT»'¾X´À ÃX´ ³ º(² ³9Ä=À-³ ¼ Ã_¾²'»'¾yÀ ²'³½<¿9·l¼ º ¹'¿'¾,³5À ¾%»5Å/¼J´KÀ ²¾M² » ¾ ¶/¼ ¿'¾ Æs¿ ®¬/¯ ¬´KÀ!¹'¿ ®tÇ&ÈcÉ-° ÊÇy½ ² » ÄPË » Æ{´JÁ}³ ¾%» ¹ Ì&¿ ¼ ¿9¹TË ÊÍÆt³' Ît³ ¼ ²/´ »5¹'º ¾M²'³ »/º º5´ ¾X´ ¿9¹'»5¼ ³ Ï/´ º ³9¹'½<³» ¼À-¿Ã=» ´J¼ ³/º¾3¿(À · Å À ¾%» ¹<¾X´K»'¾3³g¾²'»'¾*¶l¼ ¿ ¾Æs¿9® ¬/¯ ¬ Å'³/½m» µ³ÐÇ&ÈcÉ-° ÊÇy½ ²'» ÄPË »RÆ{´JÁ}³ ¾%» ¹oÌ{¿5¼ ¿9¹TË Ê)Æs³' Îs³ ¼J²/´® Ñ ²'³9Ä3³ » À'ÊÒ¾M²'³ Ä3³5À ¶'¿ ¹'º ³ ¹<¾=À ¹ ¿ ® É » ¹'º ¬ ² » Ï'³ ¶ ·/Ä3½ ² » À-³ ºÓ¶ Ä3¿9¶ ³9ÄP¾PËR´ ¹©Ô³9¶<¾3³9µGÅ ³9ÄÕÉ-° Ö ¬Å<Ë0ÂV» Ë¿ à ×V³9¹'³ Ä%»5¼ Ø¡¿'Â,³ Äy¿ ÃxÇA¾P¾3¿9ÄM¹'³'Ë$Ù»5ÄMÁnÇ»5¹'º» ¸ Ä3³ ³ µ³9¹<¾¾3¿ À-³ ¼¼ Ù»5ÄMÁÚ » ¹'º ¾M²'³9Ä3³ »'ÃP¾%³ ÄÊ ¾M²'³(Ä3³ À ¶'¿9¹ º ³9¹<¾=Àh»5¼KÀ-¿¶ » ´ º Û ¿ ·lÀ-³.±» ÜZÝPÂj²'¿5À-³Ä3³ ½<³ ´J¶<¾=ÀZÞ Ü ®iÎ Ñ Èß à=Çá» ¹'ºÕÞ Ü ® Î Ñ È ß àâÚã» Ä3³W´ ¹©¾M²'³©±AÄX´K»5¼hÌ&¿9· ÄP¾ Ä3³ ½<¿9Ä3º/äå® ÝfÆt¿'ÂÊ ¾M²'³çæ º ® Ì{¿ · ¹lÀ-³ ¼[Ã3¿9Äz» ¶ ¶ ³ ¼J¼ » ¹<¾³ Ü ¶l¼K»5´J¹lÀ ¾²'»'¾¾M²'³ µG· ¹l´ ½'´ ¶'»5¼ ¹ ·/µGÅ'³9Ä¡½<¿9·/¼ ºÅ'³» À<Àm´ ¸ ¹'³/º$· ¹ º ³9ÄAÎt³ ¼ ²l´ Ùn· ¹/´ ½'´ ¶ »5¼'Çy½¾Ê É-°9èlZ¿9Ä*é{·/¼ ³ À¾M²'³ Ä3³!· ¹ º ³9Ä{» ¹'ºÕ´ ¹[¾M²'³gË'³ » ÄVÉ-° Ö ¬9Êi¾M²'³ » Ä3³ » ² »lº ¹'¿'¾á½m» µ ³ Âj´ ¾²l´ ¹ ¾M²'³ ¶ ·/ÄPÏ/´ ³' ¿ ÃCÎs³ ¼J²/´ Ùn· ¹l´ ½'´ ¶'»5¼mÇy½¾Ê » Àn¾M²'³[Çy½¾ ÂV» À ³ Ü<¾3³9¹ º ³ º»5Ä3¿9· ¹ º(É-° Ö'ê¡Ê ¾M²'³9¹ ²'¿' ء¿ Â,³9Äë¿ ÃìÇA¾P¾3¿9ÄM¹ ³ Ë » ¹'º » ¸5Ä3³ ³9µ³9¹T¾ë¿ à Գ9¶T¾%³ µGÅ'³9Ä(É-° Ö ¬í½<¿9·/¼ ºÄ3³ ÃX¼ ³/½¾(Ùn· ¹/´ ½'´ ¶ »5¼hÆs¿ ®hÇ&ÈcÉ-° Ê Çy½ ² »5ÄPË » Æ&´ Á}³ ¾%» ¹ Ì{¿5¼ ¿9¹TË ÊÆs³' Ît³ ¼ ²/´îy¾M²'³º ¿/½ · µ³9¹T¾XÀ » Ä3³ Ã%¿ Ä%¸/³ º/äå®tæ'» À ¾X¼ Ë Ê5¾² ³$À ¾%»'¾3³9µ ³9¹<¾y¿ Ã*Ø Ñ ÈcÉ »5¹'ºÕØ Ñ ÈM¬ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (45) ï5ðKñ-òñ ó'ô ï õ-ñöM÷ ï'öólð ò öyøVï ñù'ô ú'ô9ûü/ò'öý þ ô9ù<öXý ÿMý ô þ [öM÷'ô ï ó/ó'ô ðJð ï ù<ö ô ý öM÷'ô û ÿMû3ò ï'ö øVï5ûXýZò9û ÿMû3ò ò öM÷'ô9ûFð ò mï ð 'ò/þ ý ô5ñ ï ù'þöM÷'ô ï5ó ó'ô5ðJðKï5ù<ö,÷'ô9û=ñ-ô5ð ÿï/þ n ý ö=ñ öM÷ ï ö öM÷'ô ólð ò ö øVï ñ ù'ô'ú'ô9ûü/ò'ösý þ ô9ùTöMý ÿMý ô þ ï ñöM÷'ô9û3ôýKñ.ù'ò ï'ú'ô û ô9ù<ö_øjý ö÷ û3ô ü/ï û3þnö3òöM÷'ô ó'ò ñ<ñ-ô5ñ<ñmý ò9ùò ÿ ö÷ ô[ó/ð ò ö5øjý öM÷öM÷'ô.ï5ó ó'ô5ðJðKï5ù<ö öM÷'ô9ùÕ÷'ò'øö÷ ô(ñ / ý ö ÿ%ò ûó'ò ñ<ñ-ô5ñ<ñmý ò9ùò9ûû3ô ó'ò5ñ<ñ-ô5ñ<ñmý ò9ù ýñ )ï5ýJù<ö%ï5ý ù'ï /ð ô A ÷'ôCñTï5ð ôHþ ô ô þ ) ï ù'þ ï'ö3ô5ñ öM÷ ï'ö_ý ö øjýðJðlù'ò öxó ï ñ<ñVò ú'ô9û ö÷ ô öMý öMð ô! ù/ð ô5ñ<ñ öM÷'ô! "< ö%ï'öXý ò ù ýñ þ ò ù'ô $#%/ ð ô& H ' ò'ÿ!t( ô ð ÷/ý*') ï ù þ+s# ô ÿ3ò9û ñ,#%/ ð ô5ñ-
" /. 021 û3ô ïlþjøjý ö÷43 ô5 öMý ò9ùlñ76 8 /19)6 ò9û 1 1 ò ÿ:s( ô ðJ÷/ý ') ï5ù'þ;s# ô ÿ3ò9û ñ < ö : /. 0/1= 5A ÷'ô$û3ô ñ ó'ò9ù þ ô9ù<ö=ñGÿ3ò9ûPöXý ÿXý ô5ñ ö÷ ô ý û:< ò9ù<ö3ô9ù<öXý ò9ùlñ-
ø ÷lýJð ôû3ô5ð / ý ù'ü> ó'ò ùrö÷ ô)ÿ%ò5ðJð ò øjý ù'ü7m ï ñ-ô.ðKïmø,?@
(a)Vishram Masih vs. Hari Har Singh 1984(2) CCC 533 Allahabad (relied upon AIR 1954 S.C. 526) - it was held that the plaintiff has to stand on his own legs and has to establish his own rights and title. Plaintiff cannot claim himself to entitled to get the decree on the basis of failure of defendant to prove his right or title.
(b)Moran Mar Eassellos Catholicos vs. Most Rev. Mar Poulose Athanasius AIR 1954 S.C. 526 - in a suit of ejectment, the plaintiff must support the case on strength of his own title and this can be done by producing sufficient evidence to discharge the onus. To say, onus lies on the plaintiff to prove his case irrespective of whether the defendant has proved his title or not. A mere destruction of the defendant's title, in the absence of Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (46) establishment of his own title carries, the plaintiff no where.
(c)Raghunathi vs. Raju Ramappa Shetty AIR 1991 S.C. 1040 - it was held that once a party has been permitted to produce evidence in support of their respective cases and it is not their grievance that their evidence was shut out, the question of burden of proof used significance and it remains only academic.
(d)A Local Commissioner appointed by the Court is required to give report on the points or issues assigned to him. Neither a Local Commissioner is required to give his views or opinion or decision on the issues involved nor a Judge can delegate any of his function to the Commissioner and ask him to take evidence and try an issue, while referring AIR 1970 Delhi 205, AIR 1998 Rajasthan 224-227, 2000(1) CCC Page 468 Allahabad, and AIR 1930 Patna Page 57.
A/B CED=CGFIHKJ L L/M L L NIM H O PQO R MSJ T5T-M UVUWJ H O$RXJ LZYXRXJ[U\UWM HX]^M _`O R-M acb H-_ b HX] Led H b L L f MgH d CihZd HeO R-M`jXJ L b Lkd aml M T d l O d a O R M n d5YoJ[U pqd N"N b L L b d H-M l J H _ZL bWr Msd a O R MtT5U dXOiu l M a UWM YvOwM _ b H x J l J5] l J T5R^Lzy,Owd|{ d a O R-M}] l d f H _[L~d a O R-M}J[T T-M J[UWP R b UWM l M a M l lcb HX] d l _ M l _ J OM5_ C@B h CA/ [ J H-_ 5B CGB=A-CA/ *J H-_!J[UEL/d4d H O R-M!jXJ L b L$d a N"f H b Y b T-J[U-H f N"j-M l l M a M l l M5_ b HO R-Ms] l d f H-_ L;d a J[T T-M J[U b H x J l J ] l J T RXL;gOwd CR-M] l d f5H-_[Ld a J[T T-M J[UL f5T T5U M NIM H OwM5_ b O RO R-M bVl Y d H2OM H O b d HXL-P R b YXReR-J--Mtj-M5M H l M a UWM5YvOM5_kJ H-_Y d N"T b UWM _ b H x J l J ] l J[T R!A/B C"J[j-dX-M C Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (47) -w w\- @¡5¢7@£- ¡X¥¤ £-z¤} £-- @¡XoW £\`¦ X¤ ¦ ¦ - w`\ £-§ X¦¤ X¨©X5W5 £- ¦w` ¡Xª ª^[«¦¬¦ -¤-¦¬¦ -g^ WX¦ ®¯ °²±^³ ± ´µXX¤[·¶X¤ ®q@¸¹-¦º¤[£ »q £ ¶ ¼¾½Q @^À¿- ¤ º Á7¡ £^W-@-¤[ i®Q °Â´iÃÅÄ/Æ ¼Â´µXX¤ ·¶X¤S®qV¸¹X¦¤ £»q[ W £2¶ ¼ ÁI¤-¶ ¡ Çq@-¤ »¬--ȸo¼:®Q-È}½¯[ @5WÃcÆ ± °:É5 ʦ ^\Ëw ¤ / £ ¼Ì£-X¦: £5 ¶ ¦ - 5 X¡ ¢I £ ¦¤ ·¶Íw5 wÀ¿ ¡ ¦Î¤[ \/Ï«¦¤-¦w ¢$ £ ¦Î-¨Ð¦ - X¤[·¦ [-¼¥ £ ¦¤[V£5@£Xª V£ ¦ - QcW¤[ »q ¡5·¦Ñw5 w X5 £- ¼-¤[ - ¤ \$w Ò ¡5@w I¦Ó¿ Ô/X ¡ ¦c@£5 Õ ° [É @º«¦QX¨%¤[ V @¼µÖ Èm ¡^ W \@¸¹k¦w \/X¡X ˦ \ ¡ ¨ w ¢ ¦ -[@£ ¦ X¨×5W ÈÑX¨I¢"¡ £5 -@X¤ £ ¡ ¢"¿- °-gw[ - £ £2¦c £- ° Ä*¤ £ ˱4X¤^!5 - o ¦w I¦ -ÐØQ ¡^/Ù¤-ÚI £¦ -Ë¿-¤ o\ X¨Â w ·¦·¶e®Q °[´ià Ä/Æ ¼ ´µX-¤ ·¶X¤e®i@¸¹X¦¤ £Ð»q[ W £2¶ ¼ÊÁI¤ ¶ ¡ Çq@-¤ »¬--ȸo¼®¯ ÈÛ½¯ V5EÃcÆ ± ° -w[ - £ £2¦c/Ü9Ý=-È X¨=´¦·¦w £ X¶;¤ £-Τ5ª w ¢I £ ¦Ê¦Î/ \ -¨:¶- ¤ ¬ÄvÆ Þ ±eß ÁI¤ ¸ ´²¤ £ zà=á7¤ \/¥wX¨c W5v¦c`Á7¡ £5 -@X¤[ q®¯ °%´iÃÅÄ/Æ ¼i´µXX¤ ·¶X¤ ®qV¸¹X¦¤ £ »q £ ¶ ¼âÁI¤-¶ ¡ Çq@-¤ »â -È$¸o¼®Q-È ½¯ V5EÃcÆ ± ° د ÈmX- ¼5¦ -sw[ - £ £2¦c4 ¡5 Wk£-X¦¯ wX-Ц -ZÝ=-È X¨ ´¦·¦w £--¶>¤[£-!¤ ª w5 ¢I £2¦ ¦wË/ \ -¤ 4- Ù E¤ È$¼ ¤ m¦ w È©¤ ¤Ð^ W ¤ ¼ ¤ > ¨ ¼^¦ - cEª @£X¤[ -¤ 4¿- £;¢7E 5 E¤^ 2ãä W «¦ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (48) å æ2çéè/ê ë ì í-î ï ð·ñ²ê-ò5óWî ê í-ë êõôXï èÍí-ì-çZå-ê ê íÏöWê5îÍçwì²ç ô5ó\è êX÷·÷wê ëvç økùô-ê ðwê[è ú ì í-î ê í çºè/ûeüó ç í ê[è èþýÂÿ ¯ô ðcó ¬ø :ø ¯ôXï[ð ï ý ©ê ê-çºï iì öWì í ñ î5ê ú-ì è/ê î ç ôXï ç í æ "å-ê ðºè²öVó ¹ê Àümê ðwê ï è èoó![í-ê î ì í#"$ ø%"'&=ø( ) +*,&=ø ÿó ç í-ê è èkýÂÿ -. ¯ô ðcó0/µï ðwê í-î ê ð1 Ùæ2 ï ð ï2^ê î ï[å-ì æ2ç43,"
ñ-ê ï[ðºè5 6 87 ì9 ¯ô ðcó6 Iï5î ô-ì;:Âðï è ôXï^î< >=?7 ìA@$B&C D µëXô-ï ð·ñXï /qó ¹êXçï í+ ýQê ö@ô5ó ï ú5ú-ê ï ðwê5î ó@í ü*ó ç í-ê[è è å-ì'E ì í 535øF" ø( ) 2 +*8 éï è ô-ê ümï è ðwê èoóWî ê í ç ìX÷G@$B&C µëXôXï ð·ñXï /qó ¹êXçï í+ µýQê ö@ô^ó ï í î ô-êeü©ï èkðwê[èoóWî[ó@í'ç ô-ê ðwês÷wì ð¯ç ô-êöEï è«ç H "ñ-ê ï ðºè-øJI¯êümï è¥ï è, ¹ê5î²ï å-ì æ2ç!ç ô êï è èoó! í Iê í ç;ì-÷ í æ "å-ê ðºèóVíeç ô-êò5ó ë-ó@í5ó ç·ñsï í î ô êZî ê ú-ì[è/ê î ëoï-çwê+5ì ðcóWëoï[ö\ö ñ K ø·ø·ø øEç ô-ê!ú ðwê[è/ê í2çÙí æ2 "å ê ðºè$÷ ðwì zç ô-êú5ö ìXçÙôXï è4å-ê ê í>è«çï-çwê î ï ègú ê ð"ç ô-êA "æ2ç æ-ï[ömè/ê-ç çcö ê Iê í ç>ï8 $ì í' è«çç ô ê|ú ê ðºè/ì íXè ðwê[èoó î ó@í54ç ô ê ðwêÐï í îÎï2 ðwê5ê îkæ ú-ì í;å2ñÓç ô-êè/ì ë-óWê-ç ñ øL =ô-ï-ò-ê í-ì-çÊè/ê ê íÓï í2ñ!ìXç ô-ê ð:ú5öWì-ç¯í æ2 "å-ê ðM ï[ð ¹ê î!÷ì ðÙï í ñÔìX÷=ç ô-ê ú5ö ìXç7ç ô-ê ðwê óVí ø·ø·ø ø%NøO/¯ì üD *ç ô-êè/ë ê í-ï ðcóWì+ê Iê ð(^ê î+ó\è~ç ôXï-ç ç ô-ê ðwêSó\èí-ìê-ò5óWî ê í-ë ê~÷ ðwì ê ó ç ô-ê ðèoóWî êgì-÷©ç ô-ê¥ï ú5ú-ê ï[ö ï å ì æ ç!ç ô-êÑï è èoóP í2 Iê í çkì-÷Q "æ í5ó ë-ó@úXï öÔí æ "å-ê ðeì ðËç ô ê ðwê[è ú ì í-î ê í çºè/û7üó ç í ê[è èÀýÂÿ -R ¯ô ðcóS/µï ðwê í-î ê ðG Ùæ2 ï ðT ü$ô ì$ü©ï èIðwê[èoóWî[ó@í'ç ô-ê ðwê$÷ ðwì ¥ç ô-ê!öWï è«ç H ""ñ-ê ï ðºè¬÷ ðwì ¥ç ô-ê î ï çêõìX÷ ô5óEè|î ê ú-ì[èoó çcó ì í+ éôXï èÀë-öWï ðcó ÷cóWê5î¾ç ôXï-çZç ô ê ú5ö ìXç Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (49) U2V WYX5Z []\S^_Z [BZa`cb d5Z UeZ8b f g5Z8[6Xihj\)k l5bPZ'fmhonqp+\i\)k2l5bPp5frbPk Uek [ s k [jfTg,Z t2V2[ t,kc\)Zc\uk s lik Uid5Z UvbPZ U,liZ Xih fTg,Z t5Z2k8t wPZ x y g5Z [BZ s k8[BZ<zQZ'd5Z U b s f g5Z pct2t5Zcw w!pcUifa^4p2\ W p8{|b%U5` p8U p5fmfBZ WYtif fBk}X2[ k V'`8g|f_k8U.[BZ lik [B~ fTg,Z}WYV2U b l5b%t'p+wMU2V2WYX5Z8[]\ X2V|ffTg,Z [BZ}b\ U5kjbPk5f]p k s Z'd b ~2Z U,liZ V5p.p+\i\b!`cU2WDZ Uif]\ k s WYV2UvbPl5b%t5pcwU2V2WYX5Z8[]\5zf g5Z s b%U5~cb%U'`2\k s fTg,Z y [rbPpcwY k V2[mf lik VvwP~U,k'fX5Zlik8U5l5w%V,~2Z2~Ak Uf g5ZX'p2\b\k s WYV2U b l5b%t'pcw U2V WYX5Z [pcU5~ f g5Z [BZc\,t5k8U5~2Z8Uif]\ lp8U2U,k'f~ Z [rb d5Z p8Uih X5Z8U5Z s b fTzjb s fTg,Z WYV U bPl5b t'pcw k<x ) lik8V wP~ U5k5fX5Z Zc\of(p8Xvw b\,g,Z2~ad b\|p2Bd b }t w k'fk<x4 2 xDPfO[BZ2 V b [BZc\ s V2[mf g5Z [ ~8b!\)l'Vv\i\bPk8U p8U5~\)l'[ V|f b UihDk s f g,Z[BZ2lik [B~<x k,^Dz+,^_k VvwP~wb%{ZYfBk~8b!\)l'Vv\i\4f g5Zlp2\)Z s [Bk WfTg,Zt5kcb%UifLk s \,V2[ [Bk8V2U5~8b U'`+\Sk s f g5Zt2[Bk t,Z [mfmhk [\bPiZk s f g5Z}t [Bk t5Z8[mfh+x Z s k [BZlik Wb%U5`fBkSf g5Z¡~8b!\)l'Vv\i\bPk8U s [Bk8WAf g5Zc\)Z p8U'`+wPZc\5z0 ^_k8V wP~¡wb%{Z¢fBkpv~2~f g'p,ff g5Z [BZp8[ Z.U5kk8X¤£ Z l f b k Uv\ s b wPZ ~fBk f g5Z¥[BZ t,k [mf?k s f g5Z¦,k lpcw5 k8WYWb\i\bPk8U5Z [0XihZ8b fTg,Z [$\bP~2Zk s f g5Z p8t t5Z+pcw%x §$p8[(p `8[(p8t g ¨5 k s f g5Zeb WYt2V'`cU5Z2~£©V5~2`8WDZ Uif [BZ s wPZ l fr\5z0p+\eb s z0f g5Za[BZc\,t5k U,~2Z U|fr\ g5p ~}U5k5f4p ~8Wb fmfBZ2~f g5Z \b fBZ t wPp8U b%U¥f g5Z\)Z Uv\)Zp2\\of]p,f(Z ~eXihSfTg,Z¡k t t5kc\b fBZ \b ~2Z X2V|fp ~ Wb fmf(Z ~ s k [MfTg,ZQt2V [ t5kc\)Zc\k s t2[BZc\)Z U|fMlik Uv\of [ V5l frbPk8U Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (50) 5ª «v« ¬'ª5«+«r%®D¯<°+±²5³´¯'µ5¯ ¶T·vª8¸%¸i¹B¯ ¶ ¯ ¸5ºi¯J® ª5»¼5¯½ ¶Bª,³1¸1« ¬'ª5« « ¬5¯e¾²2ºªc¿CÀ ² ®Y®ÁiÁ ² ¸5¯8¶³_ª+ÁSªcÂ2Â5²c%¸i«B¯2½ ¼i»¥« ¬5¯.À ² Ã2¶m« ª8¸,½¢« ¬5¯Q¾,²2ºªc¿8À ² ®Y®ÁiÁ ² ¸5¯8¶Äµ !Á «B¯2½S« ¬5¯ÅÁ,Â,²'« ª8¸5½S«T¬,¯ Á,Â5²5« ÁY« ¬5¯ÅÁ|ª8®1¯Å ¿P²5« º5¿Pªc%®D¯ ½Å¼i»S¼5²'« ¬« ¬5¯QÂ'ªc¶m«rP¯cÁS¼2Ã|« « ¬5¯ ¶B¯Qª8¶B¯j¶r µ'ªc¿Mº5¿Pªc%®6Á5·Mª+Á¥«T¬,¯ ª8Â2Â,¯8¿ ¿Pª8¸i«Æº5¿!ªc ®6Á«T¬5ª5«D « ³4ª2Á6ªÂ ¿ ²'«$²'¹ Ç È2È¥Á)É<°2»'ª8¶B½+Á> Ã2¶Bº'¬'ª2Á)¯2½Ê¼i»Y³4ª,»²'¹MÁ|ª+¿P¯ ½2¯ ¯2½Ë8Ì+°ÎÍ<Ï Ð Ñ¤ÒqÇ}ª8¸5½« ¬5¯¶B¯cÁ,Â,² ¸5½2¯8¸i«]Á ¸5²<°6Ñ ª8¸,½Ç º5¿!ª+%®D¯2½O« ¬'ª5«0 «MÁªÂ ¿P²5«0²5¹ÔÓ ÕcÖ>Á)É<°2»'ª8¶B½+Á> Ã2¶Bº'¬'ª2Á)¯2½¥¼i» « ¬5¯ ®¼i»J×ί8¸5¯ ¶(ª+¿8ÍC²5³_¯8¶?²'¹CØM«m«B² ¶ ¸5¯5»Jª8¸,½¥ª2Ùc¶B¯2¯ ®D¯ ¸|«<«B² Á)¯8¿¿2²'¹Ú ¯8Âi«B¯ ®Y¼5¯8¶´Ñ)Û2Ü2Ç¡ÝqÞDªc¶ ßYØ ª8¸5½ÅàCáâ° ã¬5ª5«Á³1¬|»+· ³1¬,¯ ¸ «.!Á;ªuÁ|ª8®D¯  ¿ ²'«ª8¸,½#« ¬5¯8¶B¯ Áä¸5² Á,Â5¯ º5 ¹rPº ¯'µ ½2¯ ¸5ºi¯«B²>« ¬5¯¯5¹¹B¯2º «L²'¹0®YÃ2¸vPº5%Â5ªc¿ ¸2à ®Y¼5¯ ¶C²'¹<«T¬,¯¥Â ¿P²5«q· Á)º'¶ Ãi«r%¸|»²8¸å« ¬5¯ ¼'ª+Á!Áæ²'¹ÊÁ,Ã2¶ ¶B² à ¸5½8 ¸'Ù+Áæªc¸5½#Á çi¯uÁ ¶B¯2É8à %¶B¯ ½<° ãM¬5¯Á|ªc¿P¯½2¯ ¯2½¡½2¯cÁ)º'¶r ¼5¯cÁO« ¬5¯  ¿P²5«´®D¯2ª+Á,Ã2¶r ¸'ÙÇ È2ÈÅÁ)É ° »'ªc¶B½cÁ4ª+Áè¹B²8¿ ¿ ²5³ÎÁ é%Ð North-Road South-Road East-Plot No. 203 West-Plot No. 201 êMë5ìAí4ì î5ì8ï(ðcñòCó,ô_ì ï¥ó'õöM÷m÷(ó8ï î5ì'øúù+ð,÷(ì ùû ü<ý%þ2ü<ý(ÿ ü 2û ù ì ' ï , ì ñPó5 ÷ 2 î 5ðc ñ ó ý| ö ÿ üO ð èõBó8ñ ñ ó5 ô East Gali West Road 80 ft.
Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (51) North House A-18 South Park Land ! "#" $%$& ')(+*&,-,/. (0 1"2$ 3'1435 6 798;:=<?>?<A@# , BDC .%E ,;(F " $ GD(IHJG96 K2L#K >NM :=< OP ,RQ+G3$%$ G S , T :East Plot No. 203
West Plot No. 201/A-18
North Road
South Main Patpar Ganj Road
U V WYX+W Z [ \^] _#W^]a` Z b2Z/c `+Wd[2e&f ]hg3i jlknm;oqpsr=gt_#W Z uDX c v W Zw`xV W [ e \D`3f ZRy+\3e%e \ z Z { o North 30 ft. Wide Road South Patpar Ganj Road East DDA Complex/Park West Property of Shri Ahuja A-18 |q}I~^ + 3 3+ FD F a 2## 3l9;=?¡ ¢ h£¤^¢ 30 ~¥^¦ ¨§ 03F¢ D©|¡ªw3F«§¬ 2 D ® F °¯#+3¯ ^ ±# ² +3+^³w^¢) ^¢ #Y#3¯2 ¢D´µ %¢ ¶ ~·¸+#¹03¢D´ º¯2 D²|N» ¬¼®#)F ¸/ +º¯2 3¢ 3½ ¥9; ¾¿ 3¢ À/ +Y¯ &3¢ 3½ Án;qÂs= #D ¢ F P3 +2¹F ^¢ w^¢ &#´ ^¢D a| ¬¦® / ¬ à ¢)3¢ 3 02Ä+#23 %¢D´-3 DFaF %¢)D¤F º¯#Å^¯ ^ 2 D ® #9±Æ 03+^³w^¢aF ^¢ 2+2)^+9±Ç+D 2¹ ÈFD F ^+ & µ³ ¢ F¯D3I£« ¢?É ÊJ Ë^¢ F ©Ì¦^axP/ #^±#~«2 D Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (52) Í ÎÏ ÐÑÏsÒNÍ Ó Ô ÏwÕ)Ð3ÖFÖ+Ð^× Ð3Ö0Í Ò+Ø#ÔËÙFÖ+Ð^Ú1ÒFÛ ØµÎ&Í Ü Ð3Ý)Ò¦Þ2Î Í3ÓàßwÍ3ÖFáâ Þ2Ö+Ð#Ô^Ý Õ)Ø#ÔË×)Ü â ã;ä=å©æJÛ2Ö çéèÐ ê2Ø Ï ÛÈëìÝ#Ú Í3Öxí î Ý#ÖïÒxÛ Ø^ÖÆÒFÛ Ø^Ö+ØAÍ3ÖÅØtÏ/ç Ú çÎ&Í3ÖJÙ+Ø Í ÒFÝ#Ö+Ø ÏÑç%Ó°Ö+Ø Ï Þ Ø#Õ¹ÒJÐDÙRðÇÐ^ÖÒFÛ Ï/ç Ô#ØñÍ3Ó Ôòæ¦Ð3Ý)ÒFÛñÏ/ç Ô#Ø^íwæÇç Ú ç%Î Í3Ö Î Ü ó¥ÒxÛ ØôÍ Þ#Þ Ø Î%Î&Í Ó)Ò+õ&ϺÏ/ç Ò+Ø Þ Î&Í3Óö3÷ íùø9ã;ä=å¾ú¿ådÍ3Ó ÔûÒFÛ Ø-Ö+Ø Ï Þ Ð^Ó Ô#Ø3Ó)ÒNÏ õnÏ/ç Ò0ØÞ2Î Í3Óö3÷ í ü ã;äqýsú=ö Ö+ØDÙ Î Ø2Õ¹ÒAÕ)Ð3Ú¼ÚwÐ^ÓþÔ2Ø^ÚwÐ ê Ö0Í3Þ#Û2ç ÕÿÏ ØDÒûÝ#Þ Í3Ó Ô Õ)Ð3Ó ÏsÒ ç ÒFÝ Ø^ÓaÒ Ï í#â Ò ê Î Í3Ó Õ)Ø^ó ÒxÛ Ø^Ö+Ø°çÏÀÓ Ð Ô3ç&Ï Þ#Ý)Ò+Ø Í × Ð^ÝaÒIÒxÛ Ø Ø ÷2çÏsÒ+Ø^Ó Õ)ØÐ Ù¤Ù+Ð^Ý#Ö Ï Û Ð3Þ ÏûÍ2Ô 2Í Õ)Ø^ÓaÒ²Ú Í ç ÓøÆÍ ÒFÞDÍ3Ö Í3Ó Ð Í2Ô^ó²øÆÍ Ó!Ï Û Ð^Þ#ó ØD÷2çÏsÒ+Ø^Ó Õ)Ø1ÐDÙÀßwÍ3Ó Ô ç ÖÑ×#Ý)Ò ÒFÛ ØÄÏaÍ ç Ô ßwÍ Ó Ô3ç%Ö çÏ;Ð^Ý)ÒNÏ/ç Ô2ØÒxÛ Ø¸Þ Î ÐDÒÀðJÐ^í NÍ ÏûÞ Ø^Ö¤ÒFÛ Ø!Ï/ç Ò+Ø Þ Î&Í3Óö3÷ íùø9ã;ä=å¾ú¿å ×#ÝaÒ «ç ÒFÛ2ç%Ó°ÒxÛ Ø!Þ2Î Ð Ò¡óÇÍ#ÏAÖ+Ø ÙFÎ Ø#Õ¹Ò+Ø#Ô ç%Ó ÒFÛ ØdÖ+Ø Ï Þ Ð^Ó Ô#Ø^ÓaÒ Ï õ Ï/ç Ò+Ø Þ2Î Í3Ótö3÷ í ü ã;äqýsú=ö¦í ÇÛ Ø^Ö+ØtçÏÀÍ ÎÏ Ð ÍºÖ+Ð#Ð^Ú Ï Û Ð «Ó!ç Ó-ÒFÛ Ø¸Ï/ç Ò+Ø Þ2Î&Í Ó í æJÝ ÕDÛ!Ï Û Ð3Þ ÏÍ Ó ÔºÍ Ö+Ð2Ð^Ú âRó ó ¥ó ü ó ÛDÍ Ø Í ÎÏ Ð × Ø#Ø^ÓdÖ+Ø ÙFÎ Ø#Õ¹Ò+Ø#ÔAç ÓÈÒFÛ Ø Ð#Õ/Í Î Ð^Ú¼Ú ç&Ï)Ï/ç Ð^Ó Ø^Ö+õ&Ï Ö+Ø^Þ Ð3ÖÒµö3÷ í¼ø9ã;ä=å?ú ôÍ3Ó Ô ö3÷ í ø9ã;ä=å¾ú "! Õ)Ð^Ý#Þ Î Ø#Ô ç ÒFÛ²Ï/ç Ò+ØËÞ2Î Í3Ó õ&ÏÕ)Ð^Þaܼç&ϲö3÷ í#ø9ã;ä=å?ú?å í ðÇÐ wó# ¥ØÿÛDÍ Ô Õ)Ð^ÚwØòÒ+ÐôÒFÛ ØôÕ)Ð^Ó Õ Î%Ý Ï/ç Ð^ÓòÍ3Ó ÔôÍ Ò©ÒxÛ Ø Ý#Ó Õ¹ÒFÝ#Ö+Ø ÒFÛDÍ Òt× ÐDÒFÛ ÒFÛ Ø ÞDÍ ÖÒFç Ø ÏñÍ3Ö+Ø Ö+Ø2Õ)Ð ê3Ó ç%$ ç Ó ê ÒFÛ Ø ÏaÍ ÚwØ©Þ2Î Ð Ò¡ó «Û2ç ÕDÛ& Í Ï Í Î&Ï Ðàç Ô#Ø^Ó)Ò ç ÙFç Ø#ÔËÍ3Ó Ô©Ö+Ø^Þ Ð^ÖÒl×aÜ ÒFÛ Ø Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (53) ')(+*), -/. ( 010325464)2 ( 7 8 9:2;7=<>254?9@8 A ("9CB1D"E FHGJILKNMPO Q R ,"7TS D"E FUGJILKNMVO Q"W+F"IX<T8 9@8 ,+4 YZ, *6*6( 9@S 2;7\[]B@(^B_< 8`,"A+A 8 -a-b, 76BcY 2 B 2b4d,eA>-%(\Bf( ghQ>i+ij4lkJFnm\,"9@S 4po+qrBh, *6*6("9@S"2;7 [sBt(pBc<T8 9@8 4TA ( 7TS+8 76Bu4 Yv2 Bw2b4p, A>-%(\BX(\gyx z Wj4lkJF{m\, 9@S 4 F}|~<T8 9@8 4TA ( 7TS+8 76Bu47 (JFM,"7TSQ YS q+92a7\[B_< 8 A+9@(+*68 8+S"2a7\[ 4 oT8\g@( 9@8`Bc<T8}| 92b, - . ( q 9CBcY 0 (\ 8 Sh,"7v,"A+A>-a2%*),TB_2 ( 7^B_<\,TB( 7 B_< 8`o\, 4)2b4(\g 4)2 Bt8A -b, 7LD"E FGJILKNMPOPM Y ,"78\E *68 464,"9@8+,`( g z\Q i]4lkJFTgCBcF+ , 4 g@( q+7 S],TB 4TA (\BcY 2 gU,"7, 9@8 ,](\g A>-%(\BZ(\gQ>i+i 4lk F+m\,"9@S 4]_2;F;8JF Mr>i+i4lkJF gBcF;2b4^o 8 -a2%8 8+SJY+&<T8 9@8 ,+4 Y 2 B 254 A>-%(\B (\gx>z W}4lkJF m\,"9@S 4 F/( H8\ 8 9cY7 8"2 Bc<T8 9~Bc<>2543gt, * B~, 4 8 4Bu, o -a2b4T< 8+S o6mjB_< 8 , A+A 8 -a-b, 76B 7T( 9XB_< 8 9@8 ,+4,"7rm *6("7 *\9@8\B@8 8\ 2%S 8 7 *68 B@( B_< 254 8\gCg@8+* BcF| < 8 9@8 gt("9@8JY?Bc<T8 *6("7 * -;q\4)2%( 7*),"7 7 (\BXoT8S 9t,T#7 ( 7Bc<>254 o\,+4)254 Fn|~<T8 S 2;0 8 7\4)2%( 7#(\gA - (\B+ , 4S+8+, - B2;7 ( 9@S+8 9"S ,TB@8+SQ i F;iUM FtMl+ W ormdB_< 8. ( q 9CBh(\g{Bc<T8sB_< 8"7')SJF}.2 2a-1 qTS [ 8 Y ~8"-;< 2;Y #< 8 9@8"o6m Y¡B_< 89@8 4TAT( 7 S+8"76Bu4y<\,>S¢* -%, 2;0 8 S£, 7y,"9@8 ,¤( g x>z W4lk F>m\,"9¥S 4:,"7TS]Bc<T8^,"A A 8"-5-b,"7rB/<\,>S¦* -%, 2;0 8 SBc<T84)2 §68 ( gA -%( B , 4x W)¨;F;©+¨ ¨T("7:B_< 8g_9@( 76B4)2 S+8¦,"7TS< , 2;7 []S+8 ArBc<( g W)i}gCBcF u,"A+A+9¥(\E F;#cx+WT¨J© ¨ ¨ EfWTi ¨ H, 7 Sª9@8 4B(\g/B_< 8L, 9@8 ,f254 01q 7 2%* 2aA\, --b, 7 S , S¬«c, *68 7rB B_< 8 4Tq>2 B -b,"7TSJF| < 8 4l8 *6("76B@8 76B2%("7>4h9@8 0:, 2a7 8+Sy0:, 2a76Bt, 2;7T8+SB25-a-B_< 8S"254TAT( 4r, - (\g Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (54) ®_¯ °v±T² ³ ®c´µ ¯ °¶ ·@¸+° ·¸+¹ ®@°+¸»º>¼J´;¼U½ ´t½l¾ ¾J¿¹ Àb±l¶LÁ:¹" ¸ ¹T®@° ± ®_¯ °¹ ¸Äà ² ¸"³ Å)¹ ®³%¶ Â:¶ Æ"®c¯T°Å)¹ ±l°1Ç ¹ ±È °\®J®@¶]ÉT°¸+¶" °¹" ¸¦³ ® Ç ¹ ±{ ¶\®¹}Ƴ; ¹ À Å6¶ ÂTÅ À;²>±)³ ¶  ´ ʲ6® ¸ ²+·³aÂ\Ë®c¯T°X°\Ì ³%¸ °  Å6° Í ®_¯ °¦¹"Î Î °"ÀaÀ%¹"Â6®@Ïb±&®@° ±®³aÁ ¶ Â6È^¯\¹+±Ð°\Ñ+Î>Àb¹ ³a °+¸®_¯\¹ ®/³a ³ ®³%¹ ÀaÀ Ȧ³ ® Ç ¹ ±? ¶\®Ð¹wÅ6¶ ·_ ° ·1Î À%¶ ®É ²6®Ð¸"²+·³; ˮ_¯ °Ò¹>Å6Ó ² ³b±)³ ®³%¶ ¶\Æ Ì\¹ ·³%¶ ²\± Î À ¶\®u± Æt¶"· Å6¶"Á1Á1²+ ³ ®ÈÔÕÎ\¹ ·_Ö Î+²+·_ÎT¶ ±l° ± ÍÒ®_¯ ° ³aÁ1Î+²\Ë Â °+¸^Î>À%¶\®É ° Å)¹"Á °¹nÅ6¶"·_ ° ·UÎ À%¶ ® ´ × Æ³;ÂT¸±T² É>±®t¹" Å6° ³aÂ}±T² Å\¯v¹TÌ ° ·_Á ° Âr®± ͱ)³; Å6°`®_¯ °»¸+° Á ¶+Ë"·t¹"Î ¯ ³%Ŧ±l°\®² Î{¶ Æ ®_¯ ³b±#Î À ¶\®"Æc·@¶"Áy®_¯+·@°+°±)³%¸+° ±3·@° Á:¹ ³; ° ¸n³%¸+°"Â6®³%Å)¹ À ¹"ÂT¸3®_¯ ° ·@° ³b±Ø ¶Å\¯\¹ À5À%° Â Ë °¹"É ¶ ²r® ®c¯T°1¸ ³;Á ° Â\±)³%¶ ÂбT²\Ë+Ë ° ±®t° ¸É6È ®_¯ ° ¹ Î+Î ° ÀaÀb¹ Â6®H¸"²+·³; Ëh®c¯T°XÅ6¶ ²+·u±l°X¶\ÆÅ\·@¶ ±6±`°\Ñ\¹"Á3³aÂ\¹ ®³%¶"Âv¶ Æ ®_¯ °w¹"Î+ÎT°"ÀaÀ%¹"Â6®@Ïb±}Çس ®_ ° ±6±l° ± ´&Ù"Ì °"·CÈ ¶  ° Ö6 ¶ DZ»®_¯\¹ ®®_¯ ° À%¹" ¸·@° Á:¹ ³aÂ>±»±®t¹ ®³%Å»Àa³;ÖÚ°¹ Âf¶+Å6° ¹ Â?É+²r®ØÅ\¯\¹ Â\Ë ° ±Á:¹ È ¶ Å6Å\²+·¶ Â^®_¯ °»±T²+·ÛÆu¹>Å6°XÀ5³;Öڰǹ Ì ° ± ´ µ ¯ °»Å ³;·@Å\²+Áб®t¹"ÂTÅ6° ± ³aÂØ®_¯ °Î+·@° ±l°"Â6® Å)¹ ±l°¹"·@°À5³;ÖÚ°:®_¯ ³5± ´ µ ¯ °"·@°\Æ@¶ ·@°JÍX³ ® ±®t¹" ¸ ±ÜÌ ³ Ì ³%¸ ®_¯\¹T®Ý¸+° ±TÎ ³ ®@°  ¶ ¸"³;·@° Å ® ° Ì ³%¸+°" Å6°®_¯\¹ ®/Î À%¶ ® Þ~¶J´ º>¼ º]Å)¹ ·_·³%° ±]Þ~¶J´\ß àN½l¾JÍ+ß Å\¯\¹"·CÈ\¹ Þ ³;ÖÚ°\®t¹"Â á ¶"À ¶ Â6È Í Þ/° Ç â/°"Àa¯ ³ É+²r® ®_¯ ° ¶\®_¯ ° · Å6¶"·_·@¶ É ¶"·t¹ ®³ Ì ° ° Ì ³%¸+°" Å6° ±T²\Ë Ë ° ±®u± ®c¯ ¹ ® ®_¯ ° Î À%¶ ®  ²+Á1É °"·u±3À5³;ÖÚ°ß àN½rã"Í ß àN½l¾ Í ÊUà@änÇH° ·@°n¹ ±6±)³bË Â °+¸Á1²r®c² ¹ ÀaÀ È Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (55) rå æ¢ç6è éuè ê ë ìtíTî_ï è ð¢ñØï î_ò£î_ò ëê ë+è"ê ó%ëlôöõlè ç ï%ë\îCæ ÷3î_ò ë è\î_ò ë ì ç ïaì@ç\ø+ùÐõîtí"ð ç6ë õ}ó5ï;úÚëfõTø+ì_ì@è"ø+ð û"ïað\ü õ{è\ý/î_ò ëhõTø ï îØê ó%è îí ó5õlè õTø ü+ü ë õî{îcò í îªï îñí+õíeê>ó%è\îè\ýî_ò ëí ê+ê ë óaóbí ð6îcþ]ÿ ò ë í ê+ê ë óaóbí ð6îò\í>û^ê+ì@ è ë+û^í"ðí"ì@ë íè ýò ë ì ê ó è\îUè ð î_ò ë}å í õ)ï5õ è ý}õrí ó%ë û+ë ë+ û þ L é P ô í ð ûï îñ è ø>ó%û õTø6ýCýï%ç6ë î@è ë õîuí å óaïbõTòÐî_ò\íTî í"ðí"ì@ë íè ý ê ó è\îJñ í õ:è ý ^ õ Jþ>æ\í ì@û õ:í õ û ë õlç\ìï;åTë+û ï;ð=è ì@û ë ì:û íTî@ë+ û J þ T þ ?í"ð ûyý_ì@è ù î_ò\í î êTè"ï;ðrî~è\ ý ï%ë ñ&÷Jî_ò ë`í"ê ê ë"ó5óbí"ðrîò í û}û"ï5õlç\ò í"ìtü ë+û{î_ò ë}è ð+ø\õ åTë\ý@è ì@ë`îcòTë»ÿ ìïbí ó è ø ìC î î_ò ë?ì@ë õTêTè ð û+ë"ð6îuõvð è þ ¦í"ð ! û ç6è"ø ó%û ð è\î û"ï5õTê ì@ è ë î_ò ï5õ ýuí>ç î þ "ó î_ò è ø ü"ò ÷ î_ò ë ì@ë õTê è ðTû+ë ð6îuõ#û ï5õTê+ørîtë^í"åTè ø6î î_ò ë ë ïbõîtë"ð ç6ënè\ýù1ø+ð>ï%ç ï;ê í ó ð ø+ù1å ë"ìuõ è ì í õ6õ)ï%ü"ð+ù ë"ð6î è\ý ù1ø+ð>ï%ç ï;ê í ópð ø+ù1å ë"ìuõ ÷ òTè ñ #ë ë ìc÷Uî_ò ë=ì@ë õTêTè ð û+ë"ð6îuõvð è îØè ð>ó æªïaðî_ò ë"ïaì è ñ#ðfõ)ï î@ë ê>óbí"$ ð &þ %' L é ( ô û+ë õlç\ìï;å ë õ^îcòTë õTø ï î#ê+ì@è"ê ë ìCîCæXú6ð è ñ#ð år æ )~èJ*þ " é vå ø6îí ó5õlèvõTø\ü ü ë õî/ï;ðî_ò ë ï;,ì +ë ð ë ìtí ó è ñHë ì è ý " îCî@è ì_ðTë\. æ -
/ í ì_0 ú "21í"ðTûví+ü"ì@ë ë ù ë ðrîî@èvõlë"óa ó - / í"ì_4 ú 351 î_ò ë`ð+ø+ù1å ë"ì~è ý õTø ï î/ê+ì@è"ê ë ìCîCæí 6 õ /3ø+ð ï ç ï;ê\í óZð+ø+ù1åTë ìuõ1è ì )~èJ7þ " é J þ 8 ð:î_ò ëè ð ëõ)ï û+ëJ÷ ì@ë õTêTè ð û+ë"ð6îuõÐò\í>û3îtí"úÚë ð3í"ð è":å 9_ë ç î_ï è ðnî_ò\í îð ë"ï îcòTë ìî_ò ëªê óbí ï;ð6îð è"ì #ë ï%û+ë"ð ç6ëvû ë ê ï ç îõ î_ò < ë ;ò\í õTìtíwð+ø ù1å ë ì&è ý#îcòTë õTø ï îê+ì@è êTë ìCîCæ ÷ð è"ì ï îñí õ ù1ørîuíTî@ë+û ï;ð îcòTë ð\í ù ë è ý îcòTë í"ê+êTë"óaó%í"ð6î å+ørî Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (56) =?>A@CB D EGF HJI KLB =?D MON<EQP#I RSI*=JT#KLHJU ILH7EV= F*DW= K XYKLB D U H#K#E IO=ZE F*[ DA>\=JP EQP#I]@CBYEGF#EV>^KLH_K `aEbPJIcT RSKLT#I RdEdMe> H EQP#I >ARfH F @gILN HJKLR*U >W=?D K UOhiIjEbPJICX#D\F*>A@kK ` EQP#IlF*T T#I*DAD\F*HYEbm n ILH#XYILNoEQP#Ip`V> H#U >AH hO=qRSI#EbB RQH#I Ur[7M$EQP#ItsuRV>^F*D&vaKLB RdEwKLH >\=Y=JB#IxH#K m.yzF RSI{= I EcF =?>^U ILN|FO=}EbPJI~F*T T#I*DAD\F*HYEcP F = =JBJXYXYI I U I UESKcI*=ZEGF [ DW>W=JP.EQP F#EEQP#Ic=JB > ED\F HJUp@gIOFO=JB RV> H h i = m M F RSUO=6U IO= X RV> [#I U > H=?> ESIT D\F*H! Om2 ] ::#N FO= TiD^K E ,KLm HJK E KLHiD M0EGF*DADW>^I*=> EQP0EQP#I|=?> ESI4F#E =JT#K#Eu[ BYE'> E FODW= K=ZEGF H#UO= T RK #I U.EQP F#EoT RSI*= I HYEVD M> E>W=YH#K#He[YM,K m N X P F RdM F>AI EGF H4vK*D^KLH7MON ,I DAP >m*suP#IT D^K#EK ` EQP#I F*T T#I*DAD\F*HYE>\=YH#KJ H_[YM¡U >A@gILHi=?> KLH¡K `,y ¢J£ ¤ £ £ _¢ £ £ misuP#I suRV>^F*D*vaKLB RdEP F =¡H#K E XYKLHJX#D B#U I U EQP#I.>\=Y=JB#IHJK m y RV>\h P7EVD MON F =¡EQP#Ic=JB > EoXYKLBiD^U!H#K E[JI!H#KLH b=JBi> ESI UcB HJU ILR¥¦BiD^I!yK ` § RSU I Rq¨&©d© v vfN!FO= >A@C@gK F [iD^I T RSKLT#I RdEªM X?F H [#I > U ILH7EQ> `Q> I U¡[YMgK EQPJILR«T#K*=Y=?>A[ D^Ig¬F#Mi=#m #m> @CBiD EGF H#I KLBi=?D MONEbPJI®RSI*=JT#K H#U I HYE =kH#K m6¯F*H#U P FJ#I F*D\= KzRGF*>W= I U°F H±F*DADW>^I U°>W=Y=JBJI°EQP FJE> H®EQP#I±F*[i= ILHJXYI²K ` =JT#I X#> `V>^X TiD^IOFkK `6TJK*=Y= I*=Y=?> KLH³K `´=JBi> E6T RSKLT#I RdEªMON=JB > Ew`SKLR T#KO=Y= I*=Y=?>^KLH$>\=!H#K#E´@jF*>AHYEGF*> H#F [ D I«µ¬P#KJ > `gKLH#Iq>W= H#K EC> H Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (57) ¶#·O¸Y¸ ¹*¸Y¸?º^·L»z· ¼¾½Q¿#¹ ¶ À·L¶#¹LÀd½dÁO½Q¿#¹ » ¿#·Jà Ä?Å*» ¿#¹ Æ#¹ Ç º\¸J¶#·*¸Y¸ ¹*¸Y¸ ¹ Ç Å » Ç ¿#·#ÃȸJÉ#Ä ¿e¶#¹ À ¸ ·L»ÊjÅJÁ ÄY·LÊg¹_½S·|½Q¿#¹ Ë · É Àd½}¼S·LÀÀS¹ Ì ¶#·*¸Y¸ ¹O¸Y¸?º^·L»· ¼,½Q¿#¹c¶ ÀS·L¶#¹ Àd½ªÁOÍÎ Ç Í Ë ·LÉ » ¸ ¹ Ï ¼S·LÀ ½Q¿#¹ Å ¶ ¶#¹ ÏAÏ^Å »Y½³ÀS¹#¼G¹ À ¸Ð½Q¿#¹ ¶ Ï^¹ Å Ç ºA» ÑO¸ÒÅO¸Ðì¹ ÏWÏ_ÅO¸ Ç · Ä É Êg¹L»Y½ ¸ ½b¿#Å#½4½Q¿ ÀS·LÉ#Ñ ¿#·LÉ7½º »È½b¿J¹®½bÀVº^Å*ÏCº ½¾¿#ÅO¸ÓÆ#¹ ¹L» ÊjÅ*ºA»Y½GÅ*º »J¹ Ç ½Q¿ Å#½¯½Q¿#¹ ¶#·*¸Y¸ ¹*¸Y¸?º ·L» ÃÅ ¸ Ç ¹*ÏAº Ô#¹ ÀS¹ Ç Æ7Á Ô#¹L» Ç ·LÀ ¸¾ÕoÖ׸#ÍfÕwº ½d½ ÅOÏW¸ ·L» ¸ Î#Å » Ç$ØÚÙ º » Å*»#ÄY¹<Û ÔY½bͬÎ7½ Ç Íu½S· ½Q¿#¹lÅ ¶ ¶#¹ ÏWÏ\Å »Y½SÜ\¸ ¿ É ¸JÆ Å » Ç´Ý ¿ ÀVºJÞ· Ä ¿ Å*ÏJß,ÅO¸#Í à ½fÑOÏ\Å »JÄY¹ Âu¸7Å*Ï^¹ Ç ¹ ¹ Ç$á â Í¦Û ã]Ì ä:Ö å ¶ Å Ñi¹cå]¸ ¹ ÄY·L» Ç ÏWº »#¹ ÀS¹ ¼VÏ^¹ Ä ½V¸.½Q¿#¹ ÀS¹ ÄY¹ º ¶7½· ¼g¶ ¿YÁi¸?º Ä?Å*Ï,Ô ÅiÄ?Å »Y½j¶#·O¸Y¸ ¹*¸Y¸?º^·L»¯Æ7Á ½Q¿#¹ÒÅ ¶ ¶#¹*ÏAÏ\Å*»Y½SÜ\¸È¿ Éi¸JÆ Å*» ÇzÝ ¿ ÀVºÞ,· Ä ¿#Å*Ï¡ß2Å ¸ ¼QÀS·LÊ ½b¿J¹ Ô#¹L» Ç ·LÀ ¸ Å*» Ç ½Q¿#¹ ·LÀVº\ÑOº » Å*Ï®¶ Ï\ÅOº »Y½~ÅOÏAÏ^¹ Ñ ¹*¸ Ä ÀVºAÊ0º » ÅOÏ ½QÀS¹*¸J¶ Å ¸Y¸ ÆYÁ ½Q¿#¹ ÀS¹O¸J¶#·L» Ç ¹L»Y½ ¸ º »Y½S· ½Q¿#¹ ¸JÉ º ½±Ï^Å » Ç Í æ ½Q¿#¹LÀçú\¸ ¹ Â*½Q¿#¹¶ Ï ¹OÅ·#¼ ½Q¿#¹ÀS¹O¸J¶#·L» Ç ¹L»Y½ ¸6ºW¸4»#· ½ ½S¹L»#Å Æ Ï ¹  ÅO¸ Û ã]Ì ä ìÅO¸ Ä ÀS·*¸Y¸ ¹ â Å Ê0ºA»#¹ Ç ·L» ½b¿J¹ ¶J· º »7½±· ¼ ¶#·O¸Y¸ ¹*¸Y¸?º^·L»°Å » Ç ¸J¿#¹ Ç ¹ ¶#·*¸ ¹ Ç{è ͪÍdÍdÍçÊÁÚ¿ É ¸JÆ Å » Ç ¿ Å Ç ½GÅ é¹L»È½Q¿#¹²¶J·*¸Y¸ ¹*¸Y¸?º ·L»ê· ¼6½Q¿#¹~¶ Ï · ½.º » Ç º\¸J¶ ÉY½S¹²ºA»²ÊÁ ¶ ÀS¹O¸ ¹L»#ÄY¹ ÍdÍdÍdÍë×Í²ì¿ Éi¸#ÂÚ½b¿J¹LÀS¹ ºW¸ »J· ì¹*º\Ñ ¿7½ º » ½Q¿#¹ ÄY·L»7½G¹ »Y½Vº^·L» ¸· ¼i½Q¿#¹|ÀS¹*¸J¶J·L» Ç ¹ »Y½ ¸g»J· Í äÅ » Ç å0½Q¿ Å#½iú ½Q¿#·LÉ7½ ½Q¿#¹¡¶ Ï ¹OÅ0· ¼ ½Q¿#¹¡¶#·*¸Y¸ ¹O¸Y¸?º^·L» Â7½Q¿#¹´¸JÉiº ½ ìÅO¸&¼VºAÏ^¹ Ç Í Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (58) í î ïGî ð ïGî ñ òió6ôjõ íuõ öÐî*÷#øeùoõ ú ûuüQò#ýð ïSúLþ ÿJø*ó´ú û¦î ñ ñ#ýOî õ î ïSý ÿkïSý*óJñJý ülú ûlübïSýOóJñ îOóYó ÿYüSú üQò#ý}óJþ ü \î ÿJø püQò#ý ïSý*óJñ Lÿ#ø ý ÿYü ó Oõ üQò#ý ñ ^ý ó°ü ýLÿ! Aÿ²übòJý " #$ ÿ $ óJþ ü% ÿJø_üQò#ý& $' '#ý$ ( *ÿYü) Aÿ|übòJý¾óZü* JüGý gýLÿYü) û¦ò#ý"
+ übÿJý*óYó ý*ó, $\ó-
.# ü ÿ/ 0 JüGý ø1 þYü*üQò#ý0ü0 Sý*ó ' OóYó2 ÿYü3 wübòJý óJþ ü4'5 ü6 }übòJý7 SýOó ' Lÿ#ø ýLÿYü ó#õ8 + übò9 {ÿ 0 #ü ÿÈüQò/ #ü 2 #üdüSý" : Oó. ; üdüGý ÿ|ü3 üQò#ý=<> ? Yýû0 3 " êü @ gýü3 ü @ gý6 þ7ü øLþJýÓü3 9 Aÿ/A0 ü ÿB <übòJý" lõDC) E 2 ,þ5 ü ópû ^ý øF Guò#ý Sý*ó ' Lÿ#ø ý ÿYü óxò/ E#ý #ý ýLÿ 2 $ AÿYü $ ÿ5 ÿ/# üQò/ Jü!üQò#ý $ Sý þ ' ÿ/#üQò#ýpóJþ ü '5 ü; ÿüQò#ý$ @ H I $'/ üJ #ûK ÿJý" þYü üQò#ý/ _ò/ øÿ ü:
LÿYü0 3 /E#ý düGý øL " : ò $ ýLÿ/#iý ø|üQò#ý|üSý*óZü @ , ÿ û0üQò#ýM ' '#ý ÿYü3N\ó& + übÿJý*óYó ý*ó& O üQòP Sý # $ Søtü3 kü0 Sý*ó '/ OóYó ÿ7ü wüQò#ýQ' üR IGuò#ý Sý û3 " Sý õJüQò#ý1 SýOó ' LÿJø ýLÿYü ó-N/'5^ý Cø ýOójÿ ü óJþióZü $ Aÿ]üQò/ Jü&üQò#ýpóJþ ü û3 " +' *óYó ýOóYóI Lÿ4 H Oó_û ?^ý ø4 + übò LþYü ò/ E ÿ/#S' *óYó ý*óYóI ÿ, û übòJý´óJþ üF( ÿJø, + üQòüQò#ý8 $' '#ý ?( ÿ7üR TVU XW ÿ.E ý M ûY ÿ $ Yü I *ø \ó- þióYóI ÿS LÿlüQò#ýø ý / #üSý øL WóYóJþJý*ó û üQò#ýZ'/ $ dü ^ý*ó. ÿJøZ O ¡û0 Aÿ#ø Aÿ/#Oó Sý " Sø ý ø Aÿ[<\ $ # $' òió ] _^Oõ T-` (a1 ÿJø T T õ/ /E#ý õ?üQò#ý. ' '#ý$ ( *ÿYü Oówÿ #ü"
Lÿ jüQò#ý " D'Jý üSýLÿYüK'Jý" ó-
Lÿ|ü3
û ^ýüQò#ý4
" #$ ÿ $ óJþ üH þYüóJò#ýò/ ø
Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (59) b$c(d-e[c e f/g5dVhRdji b k l m5i3eon m c poi0q prd g m iRs$iRq p"t3p/n3e"t3p"s i0q p1n m k l m@k u d t3p/i0g t0k p lwvVxyi0q p{z t m b$c}|~e"g tXi+e"km?d d g pk e"}b v e"g i)i0q p c e f/g5dVhRdji b k l$m5i3e{2b$m@kVi*b m@k8i0q p{ t3p$d-p"kVi}d g m is>b t3pZt3p/ p"t*d-p l b k ld-p/i\b dIm l pF q e c l1i0q pb p$c c(b$k iYq/b5lrc e f/g5dVh dji b k l$mIi3e n m c pDb k l 2b$m k i b$m@k iRq [email protected] g m i z}q pz}t m b$c |e"g tXi;l m?d m(d d-p l6iRq p d g m i;b k lb$c?d-e&l p f m l p l i0q pm?d d g p$dLk e" V b k l b u b m@k5djii0q p{b p c c b k iRs>;q m?c p t3p b d-e"k m k/u dSu$m p ke"k1n0m k l m k/u dSe"km?d d g p$dQk eF sF>s - s q e Hp/ p"t0si0q pZn m k l m@k u dyt3p/i0g t0k p l v xi0q p z}t m(b$c:|e"g tXiKq/b d v p p"k&d-p iHb dIm l p vVx4i0q m?dg l u ,p k i+v xZn m@k l m k/u d[e"k4d g f/q m?d d g p$dQk eF s>s - Y(iq b dSb$c?d-ev p p"kQf e"k f c@g l p l[i0q/b i i0q p&d g m iH c e/iOm?dZm l p k i m n m(b v5c pv x b x4e/nKm i*dZd g t t3e"g k l$m@k/u d b k l4v xm i*dQ tp$d-p"k ieF h - ¡ F s f/q b tXx/b4m@¢£p/i b k|e c e"kVx s p ¤p c q m¥)z}q p"t3p n e t3pFs%iRq p¦n m@k l m k/u de/n+i0q m?drg l u ,p"kVis u$m p"kre krm?d d g p dLk e" s>s - l p$d-p"tX p dLt3p dji e t b i m e"kQe n i0q p.d g m i 5c e/i i e2i0q p8b p$c c(b$k iR § kLd-f/t0g i m@k xZe nt3p f e"t3l"s:m i)q/b dob$c?d-ev p p kQn3e"g k l[i0q/b i i0q p t3p$d e"k l p k ik eF m(d9b¨c m f p k f p p m k©b¨d q e" ªe/nZiRq p t3p$d e"k l p k i%k eF s"iRq p&t3p$d e"k l p"kVi)k eF}Lm(dbLi p k/b k ie/n Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (60) «0¬ Q®3$¯ ° ±"² ³ ² «:² ±F´µD¶@²D·1¯ ¬ ±"°· ² ³S«R¬ Q®3$¯ ° ±"² ³ "²V«Y² ±"´ ¸ ¶(¯o·L«3"²/·$² «~¶@²·4¯ ¬ ±"°[¹±"´ºy± »«R¬ 4®3 ¯ ° ±"² ³ "² «~² ±F´µ · ² ³w«0¬ P®3 ¯ ° ±"² ³ "² «.² ±"´º½¼ ¾ ·$¶@¿¯·w«3"²/·$² «2± » À¬/· Á« ¶ à · ² ³ ¶@®;· ² ³=«0¬ ÅÄÆ Æ · ®_ÇH·$¾~È%¬/·$®0¿¯ ¬/·$¾ ·"´~É}¬ Ê·$®3=«0¬ ¯V· ¿,˯ ¬ ± °5¯6Ç;¬5¶ ¼/¬Ì¬/· ¯ÎÍ "²M®3 ° ±"®X«3 ³ Í ÊÅ«R¬ ÐÏ ± ¼I· ¾ Ñ ± ¿D¿ ¶?¯ ¯I¶ ± ² "®¶@²[¬ ¶?¯o®3"° ± ®X«KÒ Ó ´\ÔFÕ{Ö×µÙØÚ º · ² ³6Ò Ó ´YÔFÕ{Ö µÙØÚ"Û Ü%/Ó ¶(¯j«0¶ ²/Æű ²«0¬ Ý¿2·$¶@²Ô\· «0°/·$®2ÞO· ²àß8á± ·5³FÜOÈ ¾@¬5¶¥Ü ·$¾(¯-±®3/» ¾ ¼â« ³=¶@²Q«0¬ · ° ° $¾ ¾(·$² «3ã(¯r¯I¶ «3&° ¾ · ²=Ò Ó ´ÔFÕ{Ö×µÙØÙµ ´ Õ&¬ "²4«0¬ ®3$¯ ° ±"² ³ "²V« ¯{² ±F´Hµ · ² ³Úά/· ä 6«R®3 ¯ °/· ¯ ¯- ³ ¶@²V« ±[«R¬ &· ° ° ¾?¾(· ²V« ã ¯[° ¾ ±/«)±/»%Ú5å å=¯-æ"´Ê/· ®3³$¯ Ü}¯ ç Í5¯- æ"ç "²V« ° ®*¯-±"²5¯+³ "® ¶ ä ¶@²/Æo° ±$¯ ¯- ¯ ¯I¶ ±"²±"®""²àß0±/Ê ¶ ²/ÆS¯ ç ¼/¬ ° ±"®X« ¶ ±"²/¯ÙØ ° ®3± ° "®X«XÊ Ü~¼I· ² ² ± «+¯j« · ² ³¶@²·ÅÍ /«X«3"®° ± ¯I¶ « ¶ ±"²y«0¬/· ²4»R®3± ¿ Ç;¬ ±"¿½«0¬ /ÊD³ ® ¶ ä ³¯ ç ¼/¬1® ¶ Æ ¬ «*¯,±"®Y° ±$¯ ¯-$¯ ¯I¶ ±"²$è «0¬ /Ê8ÇO¶ ¾ ¾ ³ ¯-"®Xä «0¬ S¯V· ¿,2«0®3 · «R¿, ² « æ ç/·$¾£«3±;Ç+¬ ±"¿Å«R¬ /ʳ ® ¶ ä ¯ ç ¼/¬¾ ¶ ¼ "² ¼ 6±"®,® ¶(Æ ¬V«*¯ ´%À: ¼ ±"² ³ ¾ Ê Ü«0¬ 6É}® ¶(·$¾ Ñ ±"ç ®X« · ¾?¯-± ¼ ±"²V«*· ¶@²5¯Lé ·$¿2· Í/·$² ³ ¶Ò Ó ´)ÈYÕ{Ö×µàØêµ4®3 »0¾ ¼â« ¶@²/Æ4«0¬ 6ÄYÇH· ®3³ ¹±"´Oµ-ëVØ8ì ¸ Öì ì Ü)· ¯Z«0¬ =± Ç;² ®+± »,¾ · ² ³Î¶?¯4Þ ±/ä "®0² ¿, ² «R´ í ç «;«R¬ ®3$¯ ° ± ² ³ ² «*¯=¼I·$² ² ± «2³ "® ¶ ä P· ²VÊMÍ "² »0¶ «»R®3± ¿ «0¬ ¶?¯é · ¿2·$Í/· ² ³$¶¥Ü¯I¶@² ¼ ® ¶(Æ$¬ «*¯Z±/»«0¬ · ° ° $¾ ¾(·$² «)· ² ³=«0¬ ®3$¯ ° ±"² ³ ² «*¯y· ®3ÎÍ ¶@² Æ· ³Âßç ³ ¶ ¼I· «3 ³=· ² ³6«0¬ w· ° ° ¾ ¾ · ² « ¬/·5³.¯ ç ¼ ¼ ³ ³2«3± ° ®3±/ä ¬ "®î® ¶(Æ$¬ «*¯ æ ç/·,«0¬ .¯ ç ¶ «î¾ · ² ³F´ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (61) ï}ð ñ"ò3ñ ó ô ò3ñFõöRð ñ ó0÷ ø ù ÷ ø/ú ûÝô/óQöRð ñ ï ò ÷ ü$ý2þ~ô"ÿ òXöLú$÷ ñ ø ô"ø ÷?û û ÿ ñ$û,ø ô õ ü ø ù Qü ò3ñ û-ñ/ö"ü ûI÷ ù ñFõ ö0ð ñ.ü ñ$ý ý(ü$ø ö\÷(û ø ô ö%ô"ø5ý [ñ"øVö ÷ ö ý ñ ùyó3ô"òò3ñ$ûjö3ô"ò ü ö ÷ ô"øZô/óö0ð ñý(ü ø ù ,ñ ü û ÿ ò ÷@ø/ú û /ü$ò3ù$û 0÷ @ñ ! "$# ÿ öQü$ý(û-ô ò3ñ$ý ÷ ñ óQô/ó ÷@ø&%ÿ ø 'âö0÷ ô"ø ÷@ø ö0ð ñ 2ü$ø ø ñ òªù ñ$û '/ò ÷(# ñ ù ÷@ø ö0ð ñ ø ñ) ö /ü$ò ü ú ò ü ð* + , ï}ð ÿ5û õ>öRð ñ&ü ñ ý?ý(ü øVö- ûü ñ ü$ýY÷(ûrü ý ý ô .Hñ ù"õ/.;ð ÷?ý ñû-ñ öJö ÷ ø/ú ü ûI÷ ù ñ ö0ð ñ ï}ò ÷ ü$ýoþô"ÿ òXö0 (ûPó ÷@ø ù ÷ ø/ú û ú$÷ ñ ø ÷@ø1% ÿ ù ú ,ñ ø ö32 ù ñ '/ò3ñ ñrù ü ö3ñ ù4 5 3 * 5 rô"ø÷?û û ÿ ñ û ø ô5 õ6 >õ, 27 8 Fõ9 "õ ü ø ù:' ô"ø/û-ñ "ÿ ñ"ø ö ý {ô øLöRð ñ÷(û û ÿ ñø ô ; + ,<Yö0ð ñ=÷?û û ÿ ñ$û ø ô5 , õ= >õ 2> 8 Fõ? ü$ø ù@ A Qü ò3ñù ñ ' ÷ ù ñ ùZ÷@øDó*ü ô"ÿ òô/óöRð ñ ü ñ ý ý ü ø ö ü ø ùDü ú ü$÷ ø5ûjö öRð ñ ò3ñ$û ô"ø ù ñ"øVö û) þ~ô ø5û-ñ "ÿ ñ"ø ö ý õ\öRð ñü ñ ü$ýY÷?ûrù ñ '/ò3ñ ñ ù ÷@øró*ü ô"ÿ òô/ó%öRð ñ ü ñ ý ý ü ø ö}ü ø ù[ü ú ü ÷@ø5ûjö:ö0ð ñ&ò3ñ$û ô ø ù ñ ø ö*û õ*.;ð5÷ ý ñ[ù ÷@ò3ñ 'âö ÷@ø/ú ö0ð ñPò3ñ$û ô"ø ù ñ ø ö*û&ö3ôPò3ñ ûjö ô ò3ñöRð ñ¦û ÿ ÷ öB ò3ô ñ"òXöC 1# ñ ü ò ÷ ø/ú ý ô/öEDô > "õ+ø ô). F ø ô).;øü û$GIHJ KFõIGL'/ð ü òC /üMD÷3F£ñ/ö ü ø þ~ô$ý ô"ø õ Dñ).ONñ ý ð ÷PHQK "õ ,ñ ü û ÿ ò ÷@ø úR û L /ü ò3ù$û$ 0÷ @ñ * A S S R " ,ô"ò3ñT /ü òXö ÷U'/ÿ5ý(ü ò ý õ}ù ñ$û '/ò ÷(# ñ ù ÷ ø6ûI÷ ö3ñV ý ü ø Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (62) W X*Y[Z \^]J_7`7_$acb(dfecg)hRi jQbPk6b(d=l6m9n o b e0prqIl ste0h5j u jvb3d=k6b(d=k:b e b(dwe0i ecg)h@i5jQbUk6b3d)l6mSn g=l
x)hfh b ecg)h5j uwy{z>l y|i)s~} bn l6dweQmUh `rj0h5 i)=l6m i=s~b3x o)k
d)h }$n+ecjco)8eco j0h:b3d|x)i6nwn h*nwnAbUi5d4i=s9ecg)h^j0h6n x)h 8ecb )h j0h6n x i5d)} h dwevn i5j6i=ecg)h5jzbn h Y 9g)h l x x)h l6m4bnl6mPn i } h =j0h h } q4zg b(m h j0h6n+ecj-l6b(d b3d=keg h j0h6n x i5d)} h dwevnscj0i5 Al o=nAb3d=k:l6dwy@sco jCecg)h5j[wi dn+ecjco)8eQbUi5d@i5j x=l6jCecb(d=k1zb ecgecg)hx)i*nwn h6nwnAbUi d i5jx=l jCeEecg)h5j0h i)si5jsj0i =j0h*l ecb(d=k l d y =g)l j-k h i))h5j[ecg)hn l6b }x mUi)eY9g)h:} b(j0h 8eQbUi d s0i5j9j0h5 i)=l6mwi5j}6bn l d ecm hn+ecjco)8eco j0h4bnu)h6b3d=k k6b )h5d*q6l*ne0i u jQb(d=kecg)hi5jvbPk6b(d=l6mx)i6nAb ecb i5di=secg)h x mUi)eYi)z h=)h5jqb ebn zb eg i5owex j0h o)} bUwh i=s¡ecg)h¢jQbUk gwevn£i=s¡eg h¥¤>i=)h jcd h5dwe3` ¤>i=)h5jcd h5dwe/u i } b h6n§¦5o=leg h b3j,jQbPk g evni=s
i)z d h5jvn g b3xEb(d ecg)h m(bUk gwe i)s ¨)l6l u=l6d)} bIW X*Yª©?\^]J_&`«_ q9¬?z>l j0}i5Y_ ® `°¯=±*]¯ ¯6Y 9g)hOwi6n+evn²l6j0h l6m(m i)z h } b3d³svl )i5o j i=secg)h l x x h m(mUl dwe ecg j0i5o)k
g)i5o eY;©h =j0h h´n g)h h=eu)h}5j-l zd:l wwi j0} b3d)k6m y*Yµ9g)h 9jQbPl6m*¶~i o jCeLj0h wi j0}¡u h¡n h5dwe9u)l =·l6m i5d=k zb ecgecg)h¸wi5x yi)s ecg bn¹o)}*k h dweY º6b(m hBbn wi5dnAbUk
d)h }e0i j0h wi5j0} j0i i Y » ¼S¼6½ ¾/¼6¿ À Á4Ât¼BÃÄ6À5¼EŽ¾ÆcÇ ÈÉ0ÊËÌ9ÍÎ?Ì9Ì Ï¸ÐÉ-Ê9ÑÒ?Ó ½¹¼EÔSÕ)Ö×Ô Õ=ÖÙØ Ô Ô6Ú » Ë,Î=ÛJËÌ?Ü/ÒLÉ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (63) Ý6Þ*ß(àSßÙÝ á á6Þ â9ãä å)ä5æ*çJè éIê5ë ìí î6ï ð0ê5ñ ò ó ó)î6ï(ïPò6ìwôõ éIê5ë ìí î6ï ð0ê5ñSñ0î6í ó)ê ì)ö î5ì ôQí ì)ê5õ5÷ ø)ùò ì ö ú*õ ûµê5ì)îð0ê5ñ6ê=ôcü)î ñví)õ ý~ü=ò ì ó)ò)ô,þò6ÿ ð0ê5ñSñ0î6í ó ê5ì)ö î5ìwô ÿ3ìó)î ñví ê5ì*õ ê ö ò *ø ôcü)î ñ0î î5ñ0î î6ÿ ü ôê ï ö Aò*í î*í ò ì ö ö ÿ ðCð0î5ñ0î5ì ô Aò*í î6í î5ñ0îí =ü î ö5ëïUî ö ð0ê5ñ wê ó ñ0ê ÿí îê5ñô0ê î ó ï ê5ñ0î ô-ê wê ó ñ0ê ÿí î5øEôcü)î!ê5ñ0ö î ñ Aò ì ì)ê=ô î!ö ÿ 8ôvò ô-î ö wê ó ï î=ô0î ï *õ ~ì)ö î5ñ ôcü)î )ÿ3ñ =ë §í+ôvò6ì wî6í)ø ò ö Qê5ë ñcì ð0ê5ñ ! " # $!# $&% ' $)( * +-,/.10325476!282 9;:<,=.?>A@?B C 086 DE0F2HG @3, I J K I J K L I I!M N8OQP R P SUTWV X<Y Z []\ ^!_ ` Y a b c c ^!_d_ b![feQg X<Y Z []\ ^!_ ` Y a a ^!\hc Y [ i ^ [jek\l[ Y g mnb![ ipo g qr^!\hc Y [hi ^ [jes[ Y g tvu?w akxju?Z [ xy_ zHZ {Ab a|xd[}c ^ a)\ Y [Ug qr^!\hc Y [hi ^ [jek\l[ Y gj~b [hi}pb a ^}^ -c b a=e ^|g x i ^ \ ^ c b a bhe ^ Z i {^ [feQ ew ^ b!c c ^!_d_ b![fe \ b c c ^ b!_xy\b!_d_ Y ^ i|3lw xy_^\ ^ e=ekx[ bU\x i ^ eQwh^rakxb!_3X<Y Z a=e \ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (64) d d U;! } ¡hU ¢ f£¤ ¥ ¦ § ¨ £ ©|ª «¬© «¬ © © ©¯® yfh¡ U ® «°U±<²³±ª ¤µ´ ©|±A´ ±´h°¶¨ ·¥f® ¸ ¡ f£k¹ º»® §£¼ yfh¡ ¶h®|«F´½²³¾¿£¼ yfh¡ U¯ ® «<°U±À²³±1ª ¤p´ ©|±´j¨ ´h°§¨!¦ ¥ ¨ ® ¡ ¦® ·£¼ ¨ Á Á ¹y¹ ¨ j£ ¨ h ¨ ¨U]½£»£¼ ¦ !hÁ ® h j£k «  ® ] ¸ ¡ j£¹ ºU± £¼ è!Á Á ¨!¹ n ¥ ¦ ÄÅ ¨ ® ¡ ¦ ® §£¼ ¨ Á Áh ¹d¹¨ f£»¨ h ¨ ¨!d]½£Æ£¼ ¦ UhÁ ® h f£) ±ÈÇl¼ y¹ ¦ ¥É£d Ê£Q¼h˦ UhÁ ® f£)£ ®Ì¦ !½£ ® ¦ Ê£¼ h¡ £ Á ¦ ® Á ¦=£=º Í U¨ ¦kd ÎÁ ¹® £¶Ï?® « ©U ±Ð ® Ç Ñf ® ÇÒÓ¨ ÕÔ<ÖW´ × ±ØÔÙ¥ ¼ ¨ ¦=º ¨ ÏÑÚ £)¨!  ®!¹® jºU±5Ï? ÇÜÛ? ¹d¼ Ök× ±5¢ ¨Uh¡ ¦k © © ¸|« º ¨ ¦ ! Ý ¬«|«³°UªÞ ß Þ Þjà ª© Þ Þ á<¢® ¦ Á ¨ ¦=£k ¥ ¡ ¹ ¨ ¦k¹ ºU±U U ¥ ¦k Í dÈ £ ÐÁ ¹¨ â àU«rã|ä ÖW´µ¤µ´ Ý d£¼ ¯® ¦k U ¨U¹sh¡] £ áå±s¨ =£ ¦ Í ¦k ! £df£ ®;£¼ ® ¦k U ¨!¹h¼ ¨!Á Ì! £¼ ¦ Í ºæÇn¨ ºç® h¢A¨ f£k¹ j¤å¦ ¢® ¨U¹® ¢}Á ¡ ½£¦¡ ¥É£¡ ¦ Áh®!f !f ® ® 裼 ¦ !hÁh ¥É£k ¦ !hÁ ® h j£k® ¦!® £¼h ¦/ÇÒ |« é ¼ Ш Á Á ¨!¹|y¨!¹ ®¯ ¥ ¦ ±!Çl¼]d¹¯¦ !½£¦ ¨!d £Q¼h7¦ !hÁ ® f£)vQ¦ ® ¢ê¥¨!¡] Ш!fºë¡ ¦=£¼ ¦¿¥f® ]½£¦¡ ¥É£k® Ä® ¦ Á ¨ ¦=£k ÎÇÒ £Q¼Ì£¼ Á ®Uf !f® ì® ¦Á ¨ ¦=£Æ£¼ ¦ ® »® ¦§¦ ® ¢ ¥ ¦ U¨ £k ¯¨!fº ¥ ¼ ¨!¦ ® ¦8£¼ íj¨! Á ¹ ® £Q« é ¼ ¦ ¥É£k® Ð ® ¦ ¦ ¢® ¨U¹]® ¦À h¢A¨ f£k¹ н£¦¡ ¥É£¡ ¦ Ð Í ! ! U±!¨UÅ£ ® Í ¦k £Q¼hî® ¦) !d ¨!¹nÁ ®U £k® ® A£¼ ÊÁ]¹® £Q«Aï?®hÇ ¦Q± £y§ÇÒ £Q¼h® ¡f£ Contd....
Smt. Rajni Masand vs. Smt. Maya Devi RCA/19/06/2000 (65) ð ñ ò ó-ô õ ö÷fò»ø ùnúû ò ñköü ûfú)ýø ùÒúû ò»þnø ÿ ò ñ ò fú }þÅø ÿ ò ñ ò fú ø õ ö ò!ý ô ìúû ò öñ·ñkö ü!ûfú)ý ø ù·ø hò ñ)ýhû öð ö úû ò döü ûfúø ù õ ö ! #"%$ & ñ õ('?ø) * ,+, .-
/ 0- - 218û ò ÷føUý½úký ñ ò3 4 ø ò õ ö pù5 ÿ ø ô ñ|ø ù³úû ò6 ð ð ò 7 fú|úû ñ ø ô ü û ø ôjú8 2 ?ò ÷ ñ ò ò ýhû ò ò ú òõ ñ5 # 9:
÷f÷fø ñ õ!ö ü ; 18û ò<1rñkö= ?><ø ô ñ=ú}ñ ò ÷fø ñ õ ò ý ò@fú ÷ AB ø@ ü Åö úûÅúû ò}÷fø ðC;ø ù úû öyý5óôhõUü ò fú8 D ö òÃöyý÷fø@]ýöü ò õAú øñ&ò ÷fø ñ õñ ø ø E ' FHGJILK MON3P MOM)QSRTGJIVUXWOY Z K[P \ KLMO]^W_G `^a bc`^a bedf` ` g Contd....